BTS' Communication Skills - Reaction & Analysis | Festa 2022

[@maxpbeaumont]

Appreciate you being here with me 💜 Click here for my uncut reaction & analysis (2.5 hours): www.patreon.com/maxbeaumont

[@erikoenglish1651]

I'm BTS ARMY for almost 8 years. I think many Baby ARMYs have wrong information. These information are all official. BTS members got shareholders and renegotiate their contract. Their contract expires date changed from 2026 to end of 2024. September 2020 Bighit IPO showed to public. After Suga had shoulder surgery, Bighit posted official statement on 11/3/20. This is Bighit official statement. Suga also felt that it was important for him to restore himself to good health to prepare for his mandatory military service as well as his post-service musical career. In 2020 many Silver ARMYs as me know Bighit and BTS members have plans for military service in 2021. But too many happened covid situation and Dynamite was mega hit etc. After dinner party video posted I communicated with K-Diamonds as Korean ARMYs. We had same idea that Jin is ready for go to mandatory military service. Honestly sad feeling but we have been ready for their military service since 2020. Sorry my English is not good. I'm Japanese. Just I want to give information to you. I love your channel's content. Thank you.

[@PyrateSilly]

The other elephant in the room that was not talked about is the military enlistment that they will have to do. With Jin being the oldest he will have to go in by December this year. Yoongi will be right behind him a few months after that. Their birthdays are just a few months apart. So I think in a way the solo albums is not only helping them grow as individuals but also keeping them doing what they love till they can all get back together after. That's just my take on it.

[@erikoenglish1651]

@@PyrateSilly 👍 BTS 💜 ARMYs 💜 Forever

[@susiebamon5373]

There is a new podcast of art basel with rm you should check it out

[@babyarmy6968]

I think it’s hard for Army to ever imagine their life without BTS because most of us if not all of us found these boys when we needed them. I was on bed rest with my third pregnancy and needed to stress less and get out of my own head more. That’s when I found these boys and their silliness and hope filled messages. Also their messages of not giving up and fighting back really unpowered me. I’m sure every Army has stories like that and I’m sure BTS is also aware of some Army’s stories as well. Because of how connected they are with their fans.

[@nt4075]

Honestly, they didnt have to personally say this, the company couldve just released a statement and so by them doing this, it takes so much respect, love and trust in ARMY to let us in and tell us these hard heavy things weighing them down. It shows how much we mean to them and it breaks my heart that they have to ask permission to rest. I hope everybody supports this move because as you can see, its nevery easy. This is why I will root for them, why I will always root for them. 😊

[@classical7]

Same! Apo Bangpo! 💜

[@corinnekae1736]

👏👏👏👏👏

[@khae_g]

You couldn't have said it any better. Apobangpo 💜

[@aissaagregado3309]

I totally agree with this! I am a baby ARMY. Anyway, as you said for them to ask their fans for permission to rest shows how much love and respect they have for ARMYs. I so love and respect them even more. One of the reasons I started loving BTS is not because of their great stage performances and amazing chreography, but because no matter how famous they are, they still remain so kind and humble. I will continue to support them no matter what from their solo albums, debuts or group performances. APOBANGPO!

[@tjpm]

Today I saw a video about ex K-pop idols and the presenter said the same as RM did. He said he couldn’t grasp what he was about anymore so he decided to take a break. That was so eye opening to me. And I felt so much for RM. I can’t even believe how Army’s were making a fuss about this, when these men obviously NEED this break.

[@fierte]

You are not wrong about Jin wanting to protect himself in this situation. A part of it is that he's obsessed with keeping the environment light and when things are really down, he feels compelled to lighten everyone up. But don't worry. Eventually you will hear about everything he felt, in a song. He feels comfortable giving raw honesty in music. I was extremely affected by Joon's speech as well. A lot of people assumed that Army was sad because they thought BTS was breaking up. But that's not the case. I'm sure you've heard this before. BTS - Army has an almost codependent parasocial relationship. So when we heard that the boys were exhausted and in pain.. and felt guilty about wanting a break, it broke our hearts and we were also unable to comfort them. That's why we were all sad.

[@maxpbeaumont]

Yes. I’ve heard that and I appreciate the comment. That makes total sense to me.

[@sallycapotosto6927]

That's exactly right. 💜💜

[@Yoonji9212]

I couldn't say that better 💜

[@onthatilemokoena5016]

I agree with you, I was crying because they said they were tired and waited for so long, to do what they wanted not that they might possible be disbanding.

[@sam693691]

@@humanbeing4928 This is what makes a lot of people cry, seeing them cry, and Joon breaking down that was the deal breaker. Got everyone crying a lot. I was on a live TikTok the host was crying when Jimin started, but when RM break down her flood works started she had to call her friend for emotional support. I was at work trying my best to hold back the tears, my hesrt was on the floor .

[@CISCOGAME]

I think I will never meet another group like BTS, there is no other group like them. They have always been sincere and sensitive towards their fans. They are unique, that makes them special and the best.

[@maxpbeaumont]

I’m totally with you on that

[@Reree-gz5bg]

🕺🕺🕺 This!!! To a T

[@harika_9399]

Honestly i feel like this can be said about most k-pop grps out there?

[@maryji4322]

@@harika_9399 I don’t think so, at least for the past 7 years, even though I also liked other groups but none of them are like BTS to me

[@harika_9399]

@@maryji4322 babe I think you missed the point! I was saying *’unique/special’* are basic remarks which can be said about most grps and *’best’* is a subjective one. I was agreeing on the “there’s no grp like bts” cuz I don’t think there’s any like Bigbang, 1D, Got7, OOO, Mamamoo etc etc too

[@heyoo.-.360]

Makes me really happy that jimin and rm have people like taehyung and yoongi in the group, because jimin and rm seem to be feeling very guilty and taehyung and yoongi im sure will keep reassuring them that us as fans truly just want what’s best for them all.

[@jg5615]

ARMYS are not going anywhere. We will support them in any & all endeavors.

[@shehaana7503]

This is so true. I've also realized that RM and Jimin tend to be extremely hard on themselves and that the others help to bring that back into balance. I guess this is why the seven of them are such a special blend and are so perfect together, because they complement each other so well.

[@skittleskim2570]

@@shehaana7503 yea. So true. Hearing Jimin and RM speak broke my heart. I hope they see that the real ARMYS would never want them to feel lazy because they need a break to focus on developing n finding themselves.

[@Garnishes]

I think you hit the nail on how some of the members emote and communicate: Yoongi -- his straightforward direct unembellished way of speaking, he doesn't give any fabricated motivational speak but is just real when he says things like "i have no advice to give to them because we have led such different lives" and that's what makes us trust him so much Seokjin -- he is so sincere for his love for ARMY but he doesn't let himself get deep into his emotions 100% because he always wants to be the one to keep things light-hearted and make others smile, notice that he peppers funny anecdotes throughout, especially after a particular member says something heavy. and as someone else said, he's more comfortable communicating it through music than speaking it out in front of the camera Hoseok -- the thing about hoseok is that he mostly keens an even-mode when it comes to emotional topics because like Jin, he likes to keep others happy. and as u said, he tends to let others shine and hear others' stories and digests his emotions internally. that said, because he tries to do that, it sometimes gets too much for him and overflows -- and because he's also very expressively emotionally, it comes out here and there...like how he would shed tears and cry in front of others (whereas Jin wouldn't let himself do that), and during the 2018 MAMA speech when he full-on cried to the point he couldn't speak properly Taehyung -- he is very in tuned with his emotions, and like u said he can pinpoint exactly where in his 'body' he feels discomfort and can articulate it, in that way he is very pure and childlike in expressing his emotions (out of all the members, we see him express his inner child the most and that's probably why people think he's the quirkiest, most imaginative and most unpredictable one in the group Jungkook --- our youngest who knows how to absorb and listen to what others say and summarises it concisely, sweet and simple. true that he really admires and looks up to his brothers around him, and i think he feels so grateful that he has his elder brothers to look to as an example, to be motivated by, to be influenced by. he's grown a lot and matured a lot into his own person and with his unique way of communicating too. Jimin -- the biggest empath, extremely sensitive to how others would feel, and everytime he speaks, he speaks through an emotive lens... it's true he doesn't speak so off the cuff when it comes to serious topics because he's very deliberate and intentional with every word he wants to convey to others, he's very thoughtful with his words Namjoon -- this rare moment of him breaking down is truly him letting his heart speak without his brain filtering....yes u're right most of the time he speaks with both his heart and his intellect -- and he analyses and ponders and contemplates a lot. but in that moment that he teared...it was such a precious moment of vulnerability...a different kind of vulnerability...we've not seen namjoon cry LIKE THAT... thats why as ARMY we all broke down crying too thanks Max for these reactions and analyses, for paying close attention to them as they communicate, and to also articulate how we as fans may feel -- it's true they weren't outright giving a simple statement at the start of the video...they were building it up and talking details about it, bit by bit, i think that's what made it a bit nerve-wrecking watching to ensure that we understood exactly what they were conveying. it was clear at the end, of course. but yes, ARMY feeling sad is because we felt their hardships, we feel what they feel when they said they were torn, we felt sad that they thought they would disappoint us because we would NEVER be disappointed in them, and then of course...namjoon's crying got us in tears. But at the end of the day, we're SO happy that they are able to do what they need to grow and get even stronger for BTS in the long run.

[@maxpbeaumont]

Fantastic summary! Thanks for putting this together and bringing more insight, clarity and depth to some of my thoughts. I really enjoyed reading through this.

[@AlexaHsu-oj5vk]

appreciate this!

[@gabrielagrigoras3448]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@Gramcracker72]

❤️🍀

[@Gramcracker72]

Blessings.

[@helenvane]

ever since yoongi's shoulder started healing after the surgery, and ever since their first concert after two years of not being able to perform, he's been so different. other things must have happened behind the scenes too. we're not completely sure what it is, but over the past 6-8 months, yoongi has become so much more passionate about life, about exploring his craft and learning new things. this break will only heal him and give him the space and time he needs even more. I'm so proud of him and I'm so excited to see everything he plans on sharing with us in the future.

[@miezieony4353]

he became more cheerful.. love his checkiness now.. he's more playful now...

[@senu.]

that injury was a heavy height on him for sure. I can't even imagine how painful it wold get during world tours and practice for hours. he's so strong, I could never ;;;;

[@shepardcommander5174]

His growth from 2013 and on is simply amazing! He gives me hope

[@tjpm]

IMO he feels more independent. And maybe has more power over his own career. Yoongi is a high introvert and he needs space to recharge. I think he has found that time. 💜

[@jenniferyee7936]

He also ended his Saturn return and came out with this awesome confidence in his now “adult” life.

[@ngitd]

it was hard watching the festa video the first time, but what hurt the most wasn't the fact that they are taking a break to rest. it's the fact that they feel so burned out. it hurts seeing people you love and admire so hurt and lost when it comes to their craft. im an artist as well and there is nothing scarier than not knowing what to say with your art. i hope they find peace and come back stronger than ever.

[@deb6252]

well said. Thanks

[@tjpm]

💯 💯 💯

[@eunoil160]

Out of all the members, Jin is the hardest to understand. Just when you think you know him, he does something you never thought of him. We only know what he wants us to know. And he has 6 different personalities when he's with each member. It's not that he doesn't think deep, he just doesn't let others to know what he thinks.

[@elainehardyman4694]

I was waiting for your reaction Max!! I'm so glad you see what we see in our boys and why it hit us so hard. They need this break. We aren't going anywhere.

[@maxpbeaumont]

Thanks for the message Elaine! And yup :)

[@moonchild9992]

The self awareness of these guys is absolutely amazing. They know their impact and the ripple effects it causes indirect and direct parties from their actions, but they also understand that to keep doing what they're doing for all benefiting parties, they need to step away to figure things out and experience life so that they can make more music to what's important to them and their ideologies. They have always strived to be real artists and musicians and all that is evident in their music. This will be a good break for EVERYONE to realise just how much BTS carried the industry.

[@maxpbeaumont]

Incredible amount of self awareness

[@k1nser]

As an army who's been here since 2013, I will always support them no matter what. Their music literally saved my life and it continues to encourage and give me strength when I have no motivation to keep going. Yes, they've always talked about wanting to release solo projects (just like the rap line have in the past) and have openly showed us snippets of them working on songs (tae is especially known for giving us spoilers for his songs). For me, rather than being sad they aren't promoting as a group, I'm excited for what they'll do as individuals. No matter what they choose, army will be there to support them. Also, I DEFINITELY cried a lot during this festa dinner bc it hurt to see them hurting so much. It hurts that they're afraid to disappoint us but I completely understand them. As someone who suffers from anxiety and depression, I constantly overthink even the smallest of things and being in their position with millions of people watching your every move, of course you'd be scared of making that announcement. Also, as an artist myself, burnout is not something easy to overcome, especially if you continue to work through it. The fact that they kept going for 2 years just to cheer us up during covid is very bittersweet bc I'm so thankful they care for us that much but at the same time it pains me that they had to push through all of that just for us. I truly hope they can take as much time as they need to grow as individuals and experience normal life. In all honesty, I'm more angry at the industry making bts feel like they can't take a break and that they'll disappoint army if they put themselves first. The biggest bs is that, after they have worked nonstop for 9 years (even more if you include years before their debut) bts are finally getting a well deserved break (which isn't even really a break bc the members will be promoting solo albums and are still working on projects), the chairman of the singers association publicly requested bts to reconsider the break bc of the financial impact it will have on the country like ??? It's just super frustrating bc korean media and companies constantly try to downplay bts' influence and accomplishments but as soon as bts want to rest for a bit, they're on their hands and knees begging for the group to come back bc they think that kpop will lose its global popularity For me, I don't really understand that seeing as I like many groups and will continue to support them just as I will continue to support the members of bts However, for someone to think they have the right to request bts to continue without a break when Namjoon literally talked about how the kpop industry doesn't let you have any time to mature as a person and want you to basically be a robot for them is absolutely ridiculous. These artists, "idols", are humans and deserve to be treated as such. Sorry this was longer than planned- basically I love the artists, hate the industry P.S. Apo Bangpo (아포방포) means army forever, bangtan forever

[@miezieony4353]

wow.. thanks for being with them since day 1....I really admire you for loving these guys as much as the rest of us here...Even though I've been an ARMY only in 2020.. I've been loving them since then.. I wish I had loved them earlier as I was not really into KPOP before... I was only into K-dramas.., I knew about them a long time ago when they came to perform in our country in 2017, and how I wish I had gone to watch them.. It was a sold-out concert, never before a group could filled a stadium of 60k capacity in one night.. We could even see the fireworks from far... I could never forgive myself to have missed the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to see them performing live...🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

[@jimins_missing_height777]

Why didn't you send Hobi a letter or a message back then?

[@senu.]

my exact same thoughts, I've been with them since November 2013 and I could not say it any better. they more than deserve this time to discover themselves as individuals and come back stronger and better as a music group when they feel the time is right. no pressure, i'm just going to enjoy chapter 2 and fall even harder for their talents and charms as soloists.

[@x.mono.x4011]

@@jimins_missing_height777 bruh 💀

[@Nicole-hc7rh]

They need this time to develop and grow and to experience life as they want to, whether that be as individuals, or together, or both. They’ve been running for 10 years. They deserve the rest. They’ve earned the rest. I hope people understand this is not a breakup of a band. These 7 men love each other as family, and ARMYs as such. They *will* be doing full group activities again when the time is right. I am so thankful for them. Thank you for this reaction. 💜

[@maxpbeaumont]

100% and my pleasure

[@imajinallthepurple]

@Louis Kingsta 10 since they all got together, Jimin joining last in 2012. They often use that as the bench mark. 😉

[@eileencritchley4630]

Thank you for saying this I completely agree with you.

[@ayoidek6571]

This festa has got to be my favorite

[@bollox21]

"Honest, human beings, with good intentions".. I knew i stanned the right group.. love this analysis 👏

[@maxpbeaumont]

Hell yeah! And thanks for the comment.

[@bollox21]

@@maxpbeaumont you're certainly insightful. I've subscribed x

[@chryztalll]

Yoongi finally has the mindset he wished he had back in In The Soop (his heart to heart with Jin). It now reflected in his speech here. Happiness, doing what you love and what makes you happy, not regretting anything, etc. Just wow.

[@kookbaring6953]

With Jin I think it’s because he doesn’t like getting emotional in front of the cameras. The members multiple times said they always talk to him about a lot things without the camera. Especially yoongi, he said him and Jin r a lot similar and talk a lot with each other . Jin himself said I don’t like showing emotional parts of me cuz I don’t want ppl to be sad because I’m sad so he shows he’s fun bright self to make ppl and happy and not worry. And since his the oldest I get it as an older sibling I understand. Hobi is also the same as Jin in that sense. Also joon crying got me soooo baddd😭😭

[@Anny-me9ny]

I admire that quality, although I would love to see him talk about subjects below the surface level. He clearly has intricate emotions. You can see it in his music

[@pi6lette]

I'm also the oldest in the family and had very similar thoughts as you. I always found Jin to be really relatable for the reasons you mentioned 💜

[@pi6lette]

As an oldest sibling, I may be projecting... but with Jin, I think a lot of his cautiousness with his words is about protecting others rather than himself. Also, people have mentioned before that Jin and Hobi are the most camera aware. When you know others are relying on you--be it the other members or the fans--you make sure you appear strong in front of them because you're their pillar. (Though with BTS, I think they're all able to lean on and support each other in different ways, which is part of what makes their bond so strong.) That's why you'll get a song like Abyss, where he'll say, "hey I wasn't feeling okay before, but I got help and feel better now, so you don't have to worry."

[@angelkbear5472]

Max, In your uncut reaction you wondered whether you have the right to comment on them due to your status as a new army. Your insight into their personalities as well as their communication and leadership skills is top notch. You notice things that I don’t or present your thinking and appreciation of the members in such an eloquent and thoughtful way. Please, don’t be shy about continuing to react to them and their music. 💜

[@deb6252]

I couldn't have complimented Max in a better way. Great job!

[@maxpbeaumont]

Incredibly nice of you to say :)

[@joycelee8944]

@@maxpbeaumont Just heard your reaction for the first time. You explained what what happening with them very clearly. Appreciate positive take on this.🙂👍

[@loribarnes6289]

I am also a newer Army like you Max, and I have quickly discovered that BTS and Army does not care one bit! They always say that BTS finds you when YOU need them. That could have been 10 years ago or 10 days ago. BTS and Army welcome you regardless. I have come to appreciate them as sensitive, beautiful human beings more than just artists. I have never invested emotionally in a group like this since I was a teen. I truly care about them and only want to see them happy. The success is only important if it is important to them. And I want to tell you, Max, that I truly enjoy your videos. You are insightful and thoughtful. You never belittle anyone's mannerisms or feelings. Thanks for adding to what I enjoy already!!

[@soniyabhusal8972]

I completely agree with your opinion on V. As the members themselves have said, Taehyung is very raw to the extent that sometimes he is overwhelmingly honest. He adores his younger self and is in touch with his childhood naivety. As someone who has been a fan of kpop for a long time now, I haven’t seen an idol as pure, honest, unfiltered as Tae. Wish him all the success for his solo endeavours ❤️

[@eyykaye]

When you said that Jin is not getting into touch so much of his deep emotions is actually very true but not in a sense of him not facing it but more like, he doesn't like showing it in front of the camera especially in front of ARMYs because he said that he only want to show his happy side in front of camera and he brings out his other emotions in his music. Often, his friends actually often says he's a quiet person off camera. This is what I actually like about Jin. He is a person I wish to be like who clearly knows his boundaries, still be himself yet also disciplined and knows the society.

[@anneprendergast7834]

I think we are so used to seeing RM in full control that seeing him break down was a shock and heartbreaking but at the same time, it’s a useful reminder that he too has struggles and deep and sometimes painful things to deal with. It humanised him and reminded me of how young he is and that our expectations must have been a real burden at times. I want to apologise to him and give him a hug at the same time. I think real Army understand that they didn’t make this decision lightly and that it is genuinely the best thing for them at this moment in time. I look forward to their spectacular solo activities and will wait for when the moment is right for them to return as a group.

[@GoodEggs]

I don't know anyone who didn't at last tear up when namjoon was emotional. Thank you for reacting, and I'm glad to hear your thoughts on this. I think it's easier for older people and fans (age, not years supporting them) just because of the perspective afforded it. A 2 year break is nothing to someone in their 30s or older, but for younger fans in their teens it might be harder to accept just because 2 years is still a lot.

[@maxpbeaumont]

Appreciate the comment. And I think you raise a really good point!

[@arixannaj]

I feel like I've been waiting on this forever lmaoo, I'm so happy

[@maxpbeaumont]

Enjoy enjoy enjoy

[@wongpauline22]

Same!!

[@sarahloooify]

As soon as I watched festa I was like "aw man, I gotta see Max react to this"

[@maxpbeaumont]

Love that - enjoy!

[@mary3723]

SAME! hahaha

[@sarahloooify]

@@maxpbeaumont I definitely did! Thank you for your videos 😊

[@miezieony4353]

I second your comment here.. I was skipping thru at other reactors, looking for Max's reactions..and finally it appears...so glad..

[@helenvane]

honestly, I think I speak for 90% of army when I say none of us were genuinely upset at the thought of an extended break. they've gone on long breaks before, and we've always found ways to strengthen the bond within the community and have fun. we host listening parties and millions of us all around the world listen to, talk about and dissect their music together because there's endless interpretations of their lyrics. that's how much thought they put into their work. we have fun and joke around and rewatch their old content together. we make study plans and work plans together, we learn languages together, we improve out mental health and physical health together. through many shared experiences and frustrations, army have grown into something more than just a fandom. so no, the thought of our boys going away for a bit wasn't what was upsetting. what was upsetting was how tired they were, and how hard they'd tried to keep it together for our sake. what was upsetting was watching them break down and knowing they'd felt this way for years now but hadn't been able to do anything about it because they had to keep running. seeing them hurt is what hurt us, not the news.

[@helenvane]

a couple days before this video dropped (and this would have been after their breaks had already began), they all came online together, for just 10 minutes. they sat around and joked together. we didn't understand it then, but in retrospect, it's obvious they were gently preparing army for the news. they were reassuring us that nothing had changed. personally, I hadn't seen them that happy and light-hearted for a long time before then. that tells me everything I need to know about how this break's treating them. they're happy, truly content. that's all we care about. that's all that matters.

[@juliegahimer6200]

I feel like they all keep each other grounded in different areas of their lives

[@ujalabatool752]

Max I really want to thank you for all of your sentiments in this video. I have been having a really hard time since this announcement, especially because I feel so guilty feeling sad for myself when it’s so clear they boys need AND deserve this break. Your video has given me a lot of comfort and a lot of hope. Just like Namjoon, you’re aware of your audience and I appreciate that you have treated this video with reverence, as it’s clearly such a sensitive topic. Like you said, they are a source of comfort to a lot of us and some of us feel a little lost in the wake of this announcement, but your video has helped me feel less lost and more hopeful for the future 💜

[@maxpbeaumont]

Thanks so much Ujala. I really appreciate you telling me all of this :) and the fact that you even mentioned my name in the same sentence as Namjoon… you know that made me smile 😊

[@nathalykim1263]

@@maxpbeaumont I agree with ujala, I like how you also respect us as armys, and know how difficult everything about this was to process most ppl just disregard our feelings, most of the time

[@ujalabatool752]

@@maxpbeaumont well as they say, your bias is the one you identify with the most and your bias wrecker is the one you wish you could be like haha. You definitely have a lot of the same qualities that we love in Joon which is why we all love your videos! Can’t wait to see what’s next 😊

[@deb6252]

Loved what you said. 100%

[@annamarieaguirre5214]

Same sentiments about Jimin. Among the 7, I am the most concerned for him since he has always had this strong attachment with the members. Not to say, the rest do not, but I think in comparison with the others - he would have a longer adjustment period (I think).

[@x.mono.x4011]

I agree

[@lightgreen8806]

Yes, but I am hopeful that this might prove good for both Jiminie and Jk, two members whom I always felt least secure about themselves away from group. I feel they dont see the amazing potential they have like we do and this change maybe hard but they would do well, right. On their own they would do well. And then they would realize they have worth outside the members circle too. I believe this is something they need. I only hope everything turns out positively. 💜

[@auroravg6039]

​@@lightgreen8806Чонгуку незачем беспокоится... Он очень талантлив

[@julyanam.g.7605]

It was such a shock especially because we weren't expecting anything like that, such honesty and realness in expressing their feelings. After seeing this Army was sad but no because of them taking a break rather it was discovering how hurt they are and all the pressure they feel, we wish we could hug them and tell them that is okay and that we would never be dissapponted but we can´t do that and that make us feel so impotent. Also even if they are in a break they are still active in social media and updating us about their lifes so it doesnt feel like they dissapeared. Thank you for your reaction, interesting as always

[@kirazalea5234]

"I think, at the end of the day, what people would want is for RM to do what's best for him" Exactly 💜

[@maryanne2002]

Thank you for the reaction. I remembered watching it & was like, hey, what's happening? I burst into tears when i saw our always stoic Suga teared up at RM's ments, cos Suga was the most unlikely and unexpected person for me, to cry publicly. So i was like, why is every member so tensed, down & sad? Fast fwd few months later..everything was revealed bit by bit..starting from the very next day, JK telling the WWW, ARMY, we are NOT breaking up! in Busan, Suga saying, ya, the news said we were breaking up, WE NEVER SAID THAT. And finally before Jin enlisted, we knew, how hurt they were by the haters, and how they had planned to enlist after their 2020 world tour, but the pandemic happened, tour got cancelled, and enlistment got postponed. Imagine enduring that hate till Dec2023, abt 4yrs, it would have taken a toll on anyone's mental health! I understand Jin's ABYSS even more now. And i understand why Suga is like, i hv nothing else to write about, cos he completed his D-DAY album and was just preparing for his concerts, and most important, he completed Amygdala by this Festa, and he told Jimin in ITS, this song is part of my treatment, to revisit the painful memories and control them. So that's why in the Festa, he's the most relaxed there, he knew that he had closed that chapter of his life, the pain that still haunts him 1 or 1½yrs, but it's much more manageable now as he shared in Suchwita. Why did he tear up in the Festa? Like any musician, Suga is a sensitive soul. Your leader RM suddenly burst into tears, you know what he's not saying, cos he couldn't share them yet, all the burdens were hard to bear. Fast fwd to today, i am just so glad they finally were and are able to tell us more why they cried that day. And we as ARMY will wait for 2025. Yes, BTS ARMY forever. Biggest hugs to BTS ARMY wherever you are! BORAHAE & always feeling blessed & grateful to be ARMY since 2019. Till we meet again may God continue to bless the 7 precious souls till they are reunited in 2025! 💜💜💜

[@annakolenkova7060]

About the tattoos: Jimin actually was the first to get (or at least to reveal) his tattoos. He has "Nevermind" written on his ribs, and he has some minor once - "young forever" above his elbows, "youth" behing his ear and 13 on his..wrist? And he recently got moon phases down his spine.

[@miezieony4353]

we can see Jin's tattoo too at the left side of his rib...check out his IG.. he's showing more of his WW Shoulder...and his hot body...

[@annakolenkova7060]

@@miezieony4353 this is not what I was talking about tho so your comment doesn't add anything to the conversation

[@miezieony4353]

@@annakolenkova7060.. sorry my bad. I understand that I shouldn't mention Jin's tatoo here as you are talking abt JImin's tatoos... anyways.. love all the 7 guys...

[@annakolenkova7060]

@@miezieony4353 it's just that the author asked if any of the guys had tattoos except for JK and I explained that Jimin, in fact, was the first (that we know of) in context of them discissung getting those friendship tattoos, so none of them had those "7" yet, that's why your comment didn't make any sense to me

[@lizsays3324]

They looked so happy and light, on their Yet to Come performances for the Music Shows. There are too many performers who burn out, turn to drugs, or break under the pressure. This is such a healthy way for them to say, we need a break, we need a change. My hope is that other artists can follow their lead.

[@SparklerMs]

You're absolutely right! This break will be the best way for them to heal and recover healthily. I just hope they can take the duration of time they need and not be pressured by the government or K-pop industry to return too soon.

[@Ronilisse]

It was so painful but so necessary to hear these words coming from their hearts. We are sad but glad that they’re pausing the group activities to Care for their well-being. BTS taught us to Love Ourselves, now they are taking actions to Love Themselves First. They need to be Happy! They’ve worked super hard for 9+ years and their Solo endeavors will be successful! I can’t wait for BTS Chapter 2.

[@Reree-gz5bg]

Me too! 👯😊

[@mary3723]

I'm watching this at 5 am! That's how urgent this was for me 😂 haha thank you sir!!!! Your channel is one of my favorites. As someone who's introverted, terrible at communication and public speaking, I really enjoy watching people express their feelings and thoughts or just simply communicate with one another. I watch a lot of interviews, shows and content like this, and you analyzing them was the cherry on top that I never knew I needed! Hahah so thank you~

[@mary3723]

@PianoSauce same, people who are good at communication and public speaking fascinate me!😭 I literally almost failed a class at college (public speaking) just because I couldn't give a presentation! But the professor was kind enough to give me half the mark just because I managed to stand in front of the class after postponing it for the whole semester 😂💔 I literally gathered all the courage I had and only managed to stand in front of them, and then started shaking, panicking and went back to my seat 😂💔💔 it was so embarrassing!! The class clapped for me though 😭 twice!!!!! When I went up and when I came back to my seat 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

[@mary3723]

@PianoSauce yeah.. that was one of the worst memories I have of college. And omg you just reminded me of my Oral Communication class!! That was a nightmare!

[@fatimaalkamoosi6578]

I really feel respected and grateful that they decided to tell us directly and be vulnerable to millions of people instead of going the easy way. It takes so much trust and love to do so specially when they knew a lot of people and media will twist their words. This video was hard to watch for army and not for the reason that they are doing solo activities or fear of disbandment, but that they have been feeling guilty and afraid of our reaction, I can't imagine the pressure they felt. We're really happy that they are getting their so much deserved rest

[@Always4Bangtan]

Grateful 💜. Grateful was the word. I cried a lot the morning this was released. And while I'm certainly grieving a bit for the close of this first chapter, my feelings that morning were just overwhelming gratitude. That they would share these things with us, that we can witness these moments as they come. They planned to do this SO long ago, and have been waiting all this time, and the weight of that became a bit crushing. For me what I felt from Namjoon was such a release, of guilt & struggle & honesty. It was a long-overdue weight from his shoulders, I think. And once again, he set an example for all of us. ARMY twitter in those first couple of days was my favorite it's ever been. People honestly self-examining, asking where we've contributed to pressure on the boys, asking how we can use this 'break' to do for ourselves the things we've been putting off, to embrace growth of our own. How can we not be invested in people like this? How can we not love people who give us back to ourselves, again and again? Thank you for the reaction, Max. It's always a pleasure. 💜

[@bangtanforever912]

I’ve been waiting for your reaction. This is the fourth time I’m watching this festa dinner and I can’t believe I still sobbed at Namjoon’s speech😭 I thought I was over it. Thank you Max, we really appreciate you and your love for our boys💜🫶🏽

[@tasheenatomlinson8439]

It’s been such a fun journey watching your videos as you learned more and more about each member. When I watched this festa the first time I knew you would notice how much JK has matured. And RM breaking down is just hard to watch because it reminds us of how human they actually are. They are tired and worn out and deserve all the rest they need, ARMY will be waiting and cheering them on 💜

[@LilMermaid28]

I think the hardest part for me was the guilt they feel (or RM) or like they will disappoint us. I never want anyone to feel like they can’t be happy or experience new things. I care about not just them as a group but individuals. Everyone deserves happiness whatever that looks like and sometimes that requires being selfish. I am happy for them.

[@WWH_JIN-KIB_HUENINGKAI]

3:23 you're right RM said it, Jin and Jhpoe are the ones who helped him to be grounded, I understand that Jin never shows his vulnerable side as a protection system,I think that in that sense he and Jhope are very similar

[@sovo-7]

Thank you for your reaction! it was yet again genuine, respectful and insightful. Ive had to unsubscribe from other reactors just from their Thumbnail and Video title because they immediately didn't understand the depth of this festa and respect it. You were the only reactor I watched for this FESTA because I had all confidence that you would understand the message BTS was giving. It was so clear that they weren't breaking up or even thinking about it and there is in fact so much to be excited about coming up. Thank you so much Max!! 💜

[@jimin4537]

jimin was actually the first in bts to get a tattoo back in 2018, he now has around 10 tattoos!

[@SakuraintheMoon]

I was waiting for this! I was shocked at the emotional responsibility they had to armys in releasing such a frank and honest conversation rather than simply tapering off the content bit by bit. Shows the respect and trust they have in us. As Namjoon said, this was content made for army, and they know that we would understand the desire to take a break. Yes, they deserve and need it. About Jin, I totally agree, you can see that he doesn't allow himself to go that deep into his emotions in front of the camera, but he does it in his songs. Everyone's honesty is admirable, and Namjoon allowing himself to just feel, oh, it's very special

[@deb6252]

your comments and thoughts are so insightful about each of our guys. The perspective you bring and express warmed my hurting heart so much. I'm 65 year old Army, forever. Could not be more proud of their individual characters. Thank you.

[@maxpbeaumont]

my pleasure thank you for the comment.

[@si04101987]

I haven't watch the Festa since it was released and again I'm crying. I can't help it... seeing them, specially Namjoon to be so sincere about his feelings and speaking from the heart, just makes me cry. I love the fact that they said it directly to ARMY and it was not through a message from their company. Thank you for your analysis!!

[@bauistik3982]

When i first watched this, i git teary eyed yes but it’s more of a surprised feeling or unexpected for me from BTS. But now watching this again, makes me cry. I started sobbing from the moment RM talk right after Jimin. It’s heartbreaking for me that they feel guilty for even thinking of taking a break and doing the things they’ve been thinking of doing as individual. Of being scared to disappoint us ARMYs for wanting to grow as a matured person. They deserve everything in the world! They deserve to be happy in whatever they do. They are free to decide for themselves. ARMYs should understand, support, love and accept what BTS desides to do coz it’s the least we could do for everything that they’ve given us for the last 9-10 years. BTS are the most sincere, genuine, respectful and greatful artists i have ever known. I’m a 44 year old BTS ARMY and a mother of 2 kids and i’ve never been this attached to other artists and have a very strong love and respect… only with BTS! All BTS members are honest, understanding, caring and respectful. V and Yoongi are the type to say what they want to say. Yes, Jungkook have great respect and love for his brothers. V adores, respect and gets along very well with his brothers. Jimin is the most attached to BTS as group in my opinion. While Jin, Suga, JHope and RM are the most amazing older brothers the younger members could ever have! No matter what happens, even if it takes forever… ARMYs will always be walking along with BTS just like how Suga said during the Love Yourself era. BTSxARMYs forever! I think and this is just my own opinion, all the pressure, negativities, disrespect, unnecessary hatred, attacks and disregard for their talent, sincerity and artistry have taken it’s toll on them. We all have to understand that BTS started at a very young age and have been dealing with the cruelty of the industry since day1, without stopping so it’s very understandable why they needed a break from all of those just to remain as the 7 amazing people we all love today! Most of us actually fell iber heals inlove with BTS because they could always be their genuine self with us with the teust that we will love, support and understand them no matter what… with all their beauty and flaws!

[@dangsarah1]

I recently discovered your channel and have watched so many of your reactions to BTS! Thank you for reacting to them with an open mind and for sharing the things you see in them, I’ve been watching them for a while and your insight has helped me to understand the members even better. Here’s to learning more about OUR favorite band together :)

[@maxpbeaumont]

Wooooo

[@Matildavux]

Thank you for a heartwarming and insightfull analysis. Cried again rewatching their dinner party. I did not find it possible to love and admire them moore than I already did, but I do after this genuine (and not scriptet) conversation between them. They really show us how to strive to live our lifes by loving our selves and respect other human beeings. I am in awe and wish them the best in every aspect of their life.

[@keciaandthepurpleheart2961]

Thank you Max! I have been avoiding all reactions to this dinner. It's been difficult to process my own feelings about it without adding other people's feelings to the mix. But the minute I saw your name pop-up I knew I had to watch your reaction ASAP. Just as I hoped, you have helped me take a step back and analyze it. I will 110% support these guys in whatever they choose to do and I'm proud of them for releasing this video. I have this strange feeling of pride and sadness all jumbled together. Thank you for your thoughtful analysis and comments it helped me make sense of my own feelings. Borahae.

[@haileyjohnson3861]

Thank you so much for the validation, saying that the pain is real. Outside people don't often understand that, how they truly have become a part of our lives that consistently bring us joy. But man, what a burden on them that must be sometimes. I am happy for them and have made peace with this rest, above all because I trust them. This Festa made me trust them more than ever before. They know what we think, how we're feeling, and we will be there in return for them, always.

[@vminsoulmates3413]

Actually jimin was the first member to get a tattoo even before jk .. he has multiple tattoos... Like moon phases down his spine... "Nevermind " written on his right ribs.."youth" behind his ear "13" on his wrist..."young and forever " written on either arms...now a 7 between his fingers

[@angelarothe1205]

I still cry every time I watch this. I’m a mom and I want them to take a break and enjoy life. We will get them back when it’s right for them. Love you always BTS.

[@imsokeiko]

I've been looking forward to this reaction from you. I appreciate your comprehensive take of their conversation. It's so heartbreaking to learn how they have been feeling, but so wonderful to see them happy and excited for their futures together and apart.

[@ninaaraneta2279]

Thank you for sharing your insights! I especially like your observations about Jin and Jimin - I've thought the same thing as well and its the first time I've heard someone articulate it concisely.

[@Phoenix.14]

Ahh I was waiting for this! Thank you so much, I love your page! Your analysis always helps me with my communication course at school and seeing the members in new ways. Love from Trinidad!! 🇹🇹

[@maxpbeaumont]

Thanks so much for your support! So glad my videos help - and good luck with your communication course 💜

[@margaretlalonde4365]

I have always felt that Jin was like the Mom, making sure they were all fed, up and moving, taking Jk to school in the early years and providing entertainment and positive vibes when the group needed it. RM is the dad of the group. He provides for them and protects them. Discipline them as needed and is their counsel. SUGA is like an aunt or uncle, providing backup to the parents as needed in taking care of the others and in their careers. Hobi is the big brother who's always there to play with the younger ones and to be a role model of what kind of adult behavior needs to be presented to the world.

[@asdthing962]

Came across your video and the way you described them is exactly why I fell in love with them. I cried when Festa dinner came out (purely out of selfishness of wanting to see them in concert again with their comeback), I cried for a few of days really whenever I saw videos of them goofing off, and watching this still made me teary eyed and emotional even tho I know they are still a group concentrating on their solo works (which I am excitedly anticipating). They absolutely deserve this break for as long as they need and to find themselves again.

[@antoineherrods9251]

It's naturally feel the burnout after such an intense work for years, but it requires a lot of braveness to accept it and do something before being destructed by these feelings. Its amazing how this young people can handle all these. They have a lots of internal resources, and thats a part of their greatness.

[@viksters]

"right now we might be stopping for a break and being lazy but that's for the future ahead of us" I loved when namjoon stated this. they have been working like machines for almost a decade now. I can only imagine how much time and experiences they feel like they've lost. let them experience life to find happiness and joy so when they're ready... they'll find their way back as a group to create new music for us. no matter what they do individually or as a group, I will always support them! pls max. I love that frame I'm the back of the car. it's so cute. I love your content. can't wait for more!

[@llisek]

25:38 actually Jimin was the first member to get a tatoo (nevermind on his ribs) few years ago

[@carolinaferronato1416]

Where are the millions on this video?! It was such a good reaction and you seem so genuine, I cried with you❤️

[@maxpbeaumont]

Thanks Carolina :)

[@sarah_7251]

Taking some time to think when they felt lost ,so that they can stay true to their music n themselves makes me love them even more. It shows how much of a true artist each one of them is.

[@flourishwithzel]

Thank you for reacting to this, i badly needed some reassurance (that how I understood it is the same as how others understood what they said) that they're not leaving us. As a 1 year old Army, I bawled my eyes out, how much more for those Armys who were there from the beginning. At least we know BTS is here to stay 💜

[@JK_Candy_Star]

They want to do solo stuffs along with their group stuffs That’s amazing .I am really happy for them. Wishing them the best for the future.

[@emmaleeanne_fg]

Thank you so much for this, Max. You validate everything that we’re all feeling, both explicitly and also through showing us how you’re moved as well.

[@PeyloBeauty]

I remember when I watched it I didn’t cry a river bc I was sad. I was just sooo relieved to see them open up more as a 2015 army. They were always kinda open but this proved how sincere they are and how humble they are. I was so happy to see them talk about themselves. To me this never screamed a break up but the opposite. I knew this will be such a healthy chapter. Since then hobi, namjoon, jimin and yoongi released their solos and they’re brilliant. I love it so much. Can’t wait for more. Jin is currently still in military and the members would visit him. Can’t wait for his return and album, I think the military will kind of change him. I can’t wait for 2025! When the whole gang is back and sit down and talk to each other and army about their experience and journey. I‘m so excited for them.

[@SusieQ1955]

It was hard to see hobi go in today, but they were all there, even Jin! I'm supporting everything they do - albums, singles, acting, fashion houses, and really happy for them. This festa was a mystery because they were working it all out still, and probably still are, but I know they'll be back, changed, strong, ready, and more talented than ever.. Meanwhile, I'm missing them, and wish them the best of luck.

[@3ama4life]

I remember being so excited for this Festa cos I just got into their music 2months prior and was ready for all the fun associated with Festa...... and then got this. My heart really broke, especially for Jimin's tears and RM's sobs. My heart broke at how guilty they felt and how uncertain their future seemed to them in that moment.

[@namptious]

Max, please know I’ve waited for this from the second I finished the festa video. I appreciate your thoughts so much!

[@maxpbeaumont]

:)

[@hannab7907]

This is just to answer some questions you posed during your video (thank you, btw - I truly love and appreciate all of your BTS reactions!) - Firstly, you asked whether ARMY knew that the boys were working on their own music, and yes, we did. I'm sure you know the rap line have all brought out their own mixtapes before and we kind of expected for the solo music of the other members to be released in that form as well. We heard them all talking about their own music many times before, we just weren't fully aware of the context that this would be happening in. - Secondly, you asked if Jungkook is the only member who already had tattoos, and no, he is not. Jimin actually has quite a few tattoos himself (even had them way before JK). And by now, all the members got their friendship tattoos done, too. We know Namjoon's is on the inside of his ankles, Jin's is on the left side of his waist, Hobi's is on the lower back of his calf, Jimin's on the inside of his ring finger, Tae's works as a nose for his mole elephant on his arm and Jk's is behind his ear. The only location that is unknown to us is Yoonig's tattoo. I also wanted to mention that even them going off into their solo careers before reuniting as BTS was mentioned before in another FESTA - they laid the whole concept of the 3 chapters (1st chapter together, 2nd chapter by themselves, and 3rd together again) out for us already. So, like others mentioned already, the only reason ARMY got so emotional over this video is because it clearly made all the members emotioinal and they entrusted us with some of their innermost feelings.

[@wanguwarui]

It's in his shoulder am not sure left or right

[@misasawada244]

They chose to share themselves with us, and I am thankful and the connection feels special. Watching this, I felt like maybe Jimin and Jin may take this turn the hardest, but then also imagined if they can each find their way through this without having to think about others’ happiness all the time, maybe they will end up contributing with their more distinct colors and powerful lines than they’re used to or comfortable, change the dynamics of the group and even impact the regular rapper-lyricists-producers, create more art that are deeply interesting and mature and unique as a result. I see the members doing solo things now, and I’m actually seeing how this way of having a news about one member one day and another member another day with the members bouncing off each other and overlapping with other artists is an efficient system. I realized how it must have been so taxing to do everything as 7 all the time, schedule-wise alone, and how this Chapter 2 thing may be the only way they can take a break, live their lives, feel their personal & individual feelings, and also disperse the insane media attention and public expectations to carve out a piece of sanity and any space at all. Also, the more I thought about this, the more I started to think so much was packed and communicated in their new songs for ARMY, and perhaps in their music their message is truest. These songs are what I come back to now, to understand. I trust Namjoon, his leadership and sincere intelligence, and I believe in Jungkook’s passion and his pure courage to always go forward and reach higher, and I have confidence in Suga’s understanding of the industry and steady hand. If there ever was magic in BTS, destiny in these 7 being on one ship, if they are to become a legend of their own thinking beyond the pedestal they’ve been placed, they can’t just walk the expected path and be satisfied but they have to be self-searching, experiment. take decisive measures and reach for the moon and real happiness. So, be it. Let them share the difficult process with their fans head on as directly as possible, and create something beyond the existing framework and boundaries. I also felt like maybe there are more that we don’t know and can’t see, and maybe they need the emergency exit now and it’s the smart choice. Let them take the exit before they’re reduced to something they can’t recognize. I hope they do whatever the heck they want. Go for it. There will be enough of us rooting for you, no matter what.

[@AngelaSealana]

Wow, thank you so much, Max. This was so meaningful to so many people, and your insights make it even moreso.

[@maxpbeaumont]

:) Thanks Angela -- I'm really glad you enjoyed it.

[@ruthieyancey8324]

I cried that whole day! But the things that have unfolded for each of them since that day has been incredible!

[@AMirroredPool]

I've been waiting for your reaction and analysis, Max. I'm glad it came a week later though, it gave us time to calm down and think and process. Thank you for this. I hope you still react to them in the future and give us more insight into their communication and in doing so help us to learn to communicate better as well.💜 APO-BANGPO! Army Forever, Bangtan Forever! 💜

[@laui236]

This is the first time I have seen this Festa Dinner after watching it for the first time last summer and the emotional rollercoaster hit me so hard. I have been crying my eyes out watching this. But i love how respectful you analyze these videos. Especially this one.

[@arixannaj]

Oh, about your question on if any of the other members have tattoos, both jimin and jungkook have tattoos, jimin has about 7 tattoos, a spine tattoo, one on his ribs, two behind his arms, one on his wrist, one behind his ear and the new friendship tattoo on the inside of one of his fingers. Jungkook is tatted from shoulder to fingertips on one arm and has his new friendship tattoo behind his ear. As for what came of the friendship tattoos they all got the number 7 but in different spots

[@arpitavk7062]

BTS have always been working on their solo music. Yoongi and RM have 2 mixtape each, Hobi have 1, Jungkook, V, Jimin and Jin all have solo songs. Jungkook have been working on his solo album for a few years, so is Tae. So, yes, we knew that. It's common for them.

[@sallycapotosto6927]

I just want to say a couple of things. First, remember Jin is staring at the inevitable military service time right in front of him. That is probably coloring his responses, not to mention limiting his ability to plan any solo career choices. He has a lot to think about right now. He'll be fine, though - I'm not worried about him or his future. Also, remember Namjoon was hitting the sauce pretty hard (they all were!) so that probably was a factor in him weeping and being so emotional. In my mind, that just makes what he says more endearing. Personally, I love watching/listening to his vlives when he's tipsy. He's just so cute! This was hard to watch. It was a necessary pain for them and for us. I appreciate Big Hit for allowing them to personally break the news to ARMY and I am really looking forward to Chapter Two. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@Rkive71]

Change is scary especially for someone like me who have anxiety and have been a BTS fan for almost 7 years now So this was a really hard one for me it took me a few days to stop crying even tho I was happy for them and happy they took the decision that was better for them but I still have to go back to hear their own words saying they will comeback as BTS every time my anxiety decides to give me a hard time

[@TamiTNT]

No matter how many times I watch this, the raw emotion they display makes me cry, every single time. I love that about them. The honest emotion.

[@101519e]

This made me realize how immense the pressure they've been under. And also made me realize their genuineness is why I have so much admiration and respect for them. Love to all of them.

[@rachiepants3408]

I know this is like a month late reply, but I just wanted to say thank you for seeing it from ARMY’s side and understanding why many of us were sad. Of course, I am so so happy that they are taking the necessary steps they need to be happier and experience their own lives outside of BTS, only to come back together with new stories to tell, stronger than ever. But when I first watched this, especially with some translations that were not entirely accurate, I felt my heart breaking and I felt scared that they would no longer be there for me every week. Even when I learned that it was just a break and that ARMY would be getting a lot of really cool solo content from them for awhile before they came back as a group, I still felt sad. The boys first found me in summer of 2020, when COVID and lockdowns were in full swing and nobody could do anything or go anywhere. They helped me through that summer and the subsequent time I spent in my first year of university online, feeling like I was isolated from all of my peers. They were my friends and comfort during that time, and they played that role for me as a cohesive group. I now understand the situation more but even then, I was heartbroken because they were so scared of disappointing us. How could I be disappointed in the 7 men who helped me in so many ways and made two years of hell in quarantine feel more like a fun (if super long) sleepover with friends? I’m so glad that they seem to be embracing their break completely now and I’m so so ecstatic for JHope’s success with his new album and I will support every one of their individual projects. Sorry for the long comment, but I’ve seen some reactors who have said that this is not a big deal and they can’t see why ARMY were so sad or concerned and that made me feel really bad, like I had overreacted. But you managed to empathize with how we might have seen this video and acknowledged our feelings about it without even knowing each of our stories that could explain why we were impacted in such a way. So thank you for engaging in BTS content and understanding why they have made such an impact on so many people’s lives. And thank you for understanding BTS’s point of view with this break and ARMY’s point of view for feeling a bit heartbroken and sad for a little while.💜

[@helenvane]

21:40 yes we did. they've always worked on solo music alongside working as bts. but before now, these solo works would be released as mixtapes and not albums. namjoon has two solo mixtapes. hoseok has one. yoongi has two. we knew both tae and jungkook were working on solo stuff because they've been talking about it for years.

[@adrianamontejano5193]

In a way it's terribly heartbreaking to see that they have been struggling with these types of feelings of guilt for essentially coming to the conclusion that they might need to focus on their own wellbeing. I think it's safe to say that millions of us have been attracted to them and have stayed with them for so long for their acceptance. They dont pretend that everything is always perfect and they have let everyone know that struggling, feeling inadecuate, anxious, depressed or other negative feelings does not characterize you in a negative light and does in no way define the rest of your life. They bring such great comfort to all because they acknowlege the struggles that make everyone unique and they are capable of talking about them and encourage without being condescending. Will we be sad that we might not see all of them together making music? Yes, but at the same time we will also be able to see each of them grow and showcase all of the feelings they have been hiding and express themselves in a way that is unique to each of them. We'll be able to see what they all contribute to the group and how the combination of all of their talents and personalities fit into the group that we all have come to love. And more importantly, they will have the much needed time that they need to discover themselves, a time that they have also gifted each of us during their career.

[@718pjm]

i liked your reaction a lot !! jimin was actually the first one to get tattoos out of everyone, he got the nevermind tattoo on his ribs… and he has never mentioned the meaning behind it (in case you see some people telling you the meaning behind any of their tattoos) the 7 tattoo they recently got is the exception since they directly spoke about it in this festa but nor jimin or jungkook have spoken about the meaning of their tattoos. also i think people were being a little overdramatic because the members themselves said there that they were not disbanding they are just taking a break from making music as a group, that’s literally it… i have been an army since 2015 ! so seeing them finally looking out for themselves and doing what they want makes me so happy because jimin has been wanting to do solo music since 2016, taehyung has been mentioning about his solo album for a couple of years now, yoongi we know he would want to do bigger things individually as a producer and songwriter as well as namjoon, hoseok has been wanting to try new things solo for quite a few time now and seokjin would have liked trying acting too but they couldn’t do those things because they have been busy as BTS. so they have been postponing those things for covid and for armys… because they didnt want to disappoint people but taking finally a group break to do all these things they have been wanting to do is what they deserve and they have all the rights to do !! i think being selfish and think for themselves for ONCE is correct and im just glad they’re doing it now

[@mims1992-y6c]

Thank you so much for acknowledging how difficult it was for us to watch that video and the real pain we all felt. Like so many have said already in the comments, the majority of us are committed to supporting BTS through every season, through whatever music they want to make, and through whatever they choose to do. What really got to us, was seeing how they were in so much pain. I cried for hours after watching this FESTA (and during it) and the pain I was feeling was in solidarity because I hated the thought that they had been hurt. While we get so much joy from them, it breaks my heart to know that at any point I may have received that joy at their expense and I don't want that. I know that they are givers rather than takers and that everything they gave to ARMY was from the heart - but they get exhausted too. And even the fact that they told us all of this in such an intimate setting as opposed to through a press release, just goes to show how much they do indeed love us. Yes of course, in addition to feeling their pain we also may feel sadness for ourselves because change is never easy and we are uncertain of the future. Most of us fell for all seven of them and seeing all seven together is what has driven that joy in us. And even knowing that they are not disbanding and will continue group activities in a limited fashion, it's still anxiety-inducing to think about a future of which we have no knowledge. And that's ok too. It's ok for all of us to process those emotions and those feelings even as we are happy for them and the healthy choice they are making. BTS walked us through this season so beautifully. They put together an incredible album for us in Proof, with carefully selected tracks telling their story up until this point. They released three new songs that are, essentially, love letters to ARMY and explain in detail their heart for this season, their love for each other and for us. And they made sure to let us know in the most honest way possible what is going on with them. Over dinner! Like the family that we are! I trust in BTS wholeheartedly and given all they've given to me, I am more than happy to wait as long as I have to until they are ready to return as seven. In the meantime, I'm getting so much joy knowing that they are getting the rest they need, they are getting to do the different types of activities that they've always wanted to do, and I just wish them so much happiness and joy. I will always be here to support them and I'm sure so many ARMY feel the same. Thanks again for a great reaction! 💜

[@Rose-lb9hd]

I have been a fan for a long time and have seen every single bts content and all the interviews out there and i can confirm you are 100% accurate about seokjin

[@mmmlaugh]

I love your observations about the members. After this live, Jungkook went home and did a 1 hour live comforting fans, sang songs, and even washed his dishes because a fan told him to. He is so real and caring. He knows their Army is emotionally invested in the band and he really respects Army's feelings.

[@pasemospagina8]

Thank you for your words, Max. I didn't expect watching this video would be so therapeutic for me, but it was comforting to hear you put into words all the feelings I have 💜

[@blingrid2873]

Thank you, Max, for this commentary . This feista is so emotional, raw, and loving . Kinda hard to watch, but your words are so healing. I truly appreciate your opinion 🫰🏼🇨🇦

[@beatrizorsi3610]

Dude, the MINUTE i watched bts festa 2022 i was already looking forward to see your analysis and, as expected, you didn’t disappoint at all! Thank youuuuu

[@joycelee8944]

Thank you Max. I have only been a fan for not even a year yet but I appreciate your reaction. this was upsetting when it happened but when you follow them and know what theyre doing you feel better. Theyre taking a much needed and deserved R & R and they are happier now just enjoying life. The first chapter is done but now their best is "yet to come"..Stay tuned.

[@chryztalll]

I waited for this I only went to YT every day for this video. Thank you for your effort!

[@s.susanmarandi9080]

As always, I really enjoyed your reaction to BTS! You always seem to be articulating my feelings. It's the very sincerity, humility, and relatability of BTS which has made them so dear to ARMY. I don't know if you're aware of this or not, but the president of the Korean music association publicly asked BTS to change their mind because she was afraid that their decision would impact other groups and Korean culture, etc., as well. Within a short time, things like "Leave BTS alone" and "BTS it's okay to rest" were trending. I found that very touching, and of course, a direct impact of the sincerity and unselfishness of BTS toward their fans.

[@chimeyoon60]

I watched this live and I cried my eyes out I've been their fan for 8 years they did alot of things for army it's time they take care of themselves

[@Curiosity1791]

💜💜I just watched this for the first time, and I want to thank you. Your honest and encouraging analysis gave me a lot to think about. It's so refreshing to see your reaction, because some other analyses of this festa really took advantage of the fans vulnerability for views. Thank you for being sincere, and sensitive to your listeners feelings.👍🤨🤨💜💜

[@alessandracapraro9659]

It's been really nice re-watching this with your commentary. And I cried at the end. Again. Because this whole dinner is a statement and they deliver it to us with so much sincerity and love involved. They shine so bright.