Building The Perfect 5 Pen Fountain Pen Collection

[@RobertJonesWightpaint]

I love that there are people who care about these things still - email and ballpoints are very useful, but if you want style, you need a fountain pen, good writing paper, and to top it all off - a pocket watch. Granted, you can't write with a pocket watch, but somehow these things just seem to go together: pieces that have been made with thought and care.

[@keithmclean3627]

Agree, but as a watchmaker, any watch is a joy to see these days, a smartwatch is not a watch! It's a little phone!

[@007emilbond]

As a guy in his twenties, I would say any mechanical watch. I love fountain pens and try to have one with me at any opportunity, but pocket watches tend to be more impractical due to my lifestyle. I rarely wear a waistcoat and my pockets tend to be full of stuff that could damage the watch. That is why I always wear an automatic wristwatch. However, I wish a time of my life will come when I am able to wear a pocket watch daily, you know, when I don’t have to be running like crazy all the time, lol.

[@ckildegaard]

I'm a student, and recently decided to try a fountain pen. I got a Platinum Preppy with a medium nib size, and absolutely love it. The better writing experience makes me want to actually do things on paper again which -- it turns out -- is a more effective (and even somewhat pleasurable!) way for me to think through homework assignments. :)

[@Michelt007]

You are so right that fountain pens grant style to its user! I feel upset and disappointed when I see a head of state not using a fountain pen to sign official document, for example, a president of the USA using a sharpie! So sad!

[@bradcruise6291]

Totally agree, I do wear a smart watch but also carry a pocket watch and vintage compass everyday

[@ladyamalthea85]

I'm brand new to fountain pens, I wrote my first journal entry with my dad's old Lamy Al-Star this morning. I'm already desperate to buy more. Where I live, there's nowhere to go test pens so reviews are essential to understand what a pen is like.

[@serdarturgut]

this is typical and probably one of the best - time-tested ways of beginning to FP hobby, most of us entered this hobby exactly the way you did. my frank and friendly advice: do not pay more than usd 10 for any pens, wish you the best

[@ladyamalthea85]

@@serdarturgut I live in Australia, everything is more expensive here 10USD wouldn't get me much

[@mlkrborn]

Good sample

[@JMaxwell1000]

I've never written with a Lamy, but I'm glad that you, too, have discovered the joy of fountain pens. They make all the difference in the world in writing tasks. No more need to pressure down into the paper, so you can just let the words flow out of your fingertips :)

[@MsObsidianReloaded]

Try visiting pen shows. They have them around the world annually in different major cities. If you can afford traveling internationally, please do. Also, consider looking up some local fountain pen enthusiasts groups in your area. You'd be surprised what you may find. Try starting a local pen enthusiasts group. So many people you will meet and you can learn more about the hobby and test different pens. ❤

[@jimbojet8728]

Yes, I’ve been using the Lamy 2000 since, whenever, for many years now. It’s a true workhorse. Writes so beautifully, easy to be writing with all day long. Whenever it’s picked up , it writes! It’s never dried up on me, it’s just so ridiculously reliable. I love it! I don’t have a pocket pen , but there’s one on my shopping list now. Thanks for the vid.

[@angelus_solus]

I already have the one pen I'll ever need; a fine point Lamy Safari.

[@CristianPerciun]

I bought a Pelikan 140 thanks to this video, and it has become my favorite fountain pen, even though I've also got a Montblanc 146. It's just, the vintage has this kind of magic to it, the history, the quality, and even the colors that new ones don't necessarily have. The flex is certainly a magnificent feature! Anyway, looking forward to buy the Lamy 2000, since you've praised it so much! 😊 Thank you, again!

[@blaberus1]

It's also my favourite.

[@geckygeck8999]

Pilot custom 823 for edc. Pilot custom 845 or custom urushi for a showpiece Pilot custom 912 with FA: flex, enjoying inks Pilot elite: Pocket pen

[@SrirachaSandvvitch]

My pens would be: 1. Favorite pen-Lamy 2000 2. Quick note taker-Pilot VP 3. Pocket pen-Pilot e95s 4. Fancy pen-Pilot Custom 823 5. Large ink capacity-Twsbi Vac 700r Thanks for this video. It's nice to read all the comments and see what others prefer.

[@sporkconsumer9051]

same, have 1,2,and 3, im finaly gonna get the 823 soon

[@himanshumishra5661]

😊

[@northstarjakobs]

I adore my 823, the Lamy 200 and the e95 are on my wish list for sure

[@alphadog9331]

As a medical student, I have found the Majohn A1 to be very practical. I can write quickly when I need to and I am not too concerned if it gets swiped or lost in the hospital

[@Doodlebud]

What pen you thinking of getting when you graduate?

[@akshayjadhav9602]

Same over here i use the Majohn A1 for my daily use i am a high school student and this pen is very handy

[@DBCuzitis]

@@DoodlebudMy nephew is set to graduate soon from Queen’s Engineering and I wish Ensso still had a titanium Italia pen available. Sadly they are a small shop and only have what they are currently making. I have the pocket Piuma in titanium with the titanium nib - always carry it in my pocket.

[@bagheera3008]

How do you make sure it doesnt dry out? I just bought one and it hard starts or doesnt write intermittently :(

[@alphadog9331]

@@bagheera3008 There isn’t a ton you can do outside frequent cleaning between ink refills or every week or 2. That will usually resolve any hard stopping

[@emmanuelgutierrez6306]

I actually like you making a mistake. It makes it real. ❤❤ awesome videos.

[@osgoodbad]

I'm less of a collector and more of a curator, so even though I've owned dozens of fountain pens over the last seven years, I only tend to keep about five pens at any given time and sell the others off to make room for more. My current collection: Pilot Vanishing Point / matte black / medium stub italic (my quickdraw/note taking pen) Pilot Custom 823 Clear/FA (my everyday expressive pen) Edison Pearl Moonbow Acrylic Draw Filler - Broad Stub (my other expressive pen) Diplomat Aero Orange / Fine Stub (my work pen) Sailor Pro Gear Jade Green / Fine (my versatile pen, in the process of being replaced by a Lamy 2000 in EF) Typically my pens need to write differently enough from my other pens to justify their place in my collection. Every single pen is a magnificent and reliable writer, which is the by far the biggest requirement for my pens. If they cannot write every single time, I have no use for them. I'm in the same pickle as you regarding your Lamy 2000: mine writes flawlessly out of the box, but as more of a generous fine than an XF. Do I gamble and make it the XXF that I intended to get it ground as, or do I keep it the way it is and accept that sometimes life throws you a curveball? Or get a custom grind. Your XF stub looks very appealing. Concessions: I have a vintage Parker Vacumatic with a flexy nib that I adore, but it arrived with a bit of a mold problem. I'm working on getting it resolved, and that might either upend things or cause my number to rise. The Parker Vacumatic is the most beautiful pen every made, though your Pelikan has the same color scheme. Gripes: I think "Everyday Carry" and "Pocket Pen" have too much overlap. If I everyday carry my pen, I don't care if it's a pocket pen. I clip my pens to my collar or between my buttons and have done so without issue for years. I'm far more concerned about wear from my seatbelt than I ever could be about leaking. Consider adding a category for "custom pens" and getting a pen made for you that's exactly what you're looking for. Edison did a sublime job and I would work with them again, but there are many companies that will work with you to make something completely to your liking. Thanks for your great videos.

[@SusanneMBarrett]

I don't have an extensive or expensive collection, but I adore the Kaweco Lilliput in brass; it's the dearest little pocket pen. I have small hands and rheumatoid arthritis, and I don't have to press down much, and the pen feels substantive despite its teensy size. I wanted to get it in copper, but I just couldn't go the extra thirty dollars. My favorite pen is likely my Pilot Metropolitan Retro Gray 1.1 mm stub; I've had many more expensive pens, but I adore the stub nib and its affordability. I would love to be able to grind my nibs to be cursive italic, but that's definitely outside my ability and skill set!

[@mellow-jello]

Looking at function for my only 5: 1) Quick note taking - Pilot VP 2) Everyday writer - Lamy Vista 3) EDC x cold clime - Parker Jotter FP 4) Business settings - Lamy Studio 5) Travel - Platinum Plaisir

[@gnoppix]

Following the categories you layed down, these are what I have... 1. Hongdian N7 2. Platinum Plaisir 3. Ahab Noodler's Flex 4. Parker 100 5. Majohn A1 Thanks for sharing.

[@amydebuitleir]

Personally, I need a category for an "experiment" pen: inexpensive and easy to modify/maintain/repair/modify and find replacement parts. Something you're not afraid to try a shimmer ink in, or to try tuning the nib yourself. Probably one of my TWSBI ecos.

[@houghwhite411]

For me it's pilot kakuno in clear

[@nineten-eu4ig]

Twsbi eco is great I think it is my main writing pen now

[@terenehidia]

I turn 55 in 2024 and my birthday present to myself will be creating a 5 pen collection. Now I am a newbie. I started a couple years ago and bought a Pilot Metropolitan pen which I disliked. So I became skeptical on fountain pens and penfluencers (sp?) in general. But my love of writing and anything to do with books, pens, pencils and paper led me back to fountain pens. So starting back slowly for Christmas I got a Lamy Lx in marron for my book journal. I love it and it makes me want to write. So the 💡 went off in my 🧠 - ohhhhhhh this is why 🥰. And my 5 count doesn’t include the Lamy so I am already cheating a bit but it seems that what yinz fountain pen enthusiasts do anyway. Thanks for sharing these informative and fun videos.

[@Doodlebud]

When I hear the term penfluencer I cringe LOL 😆 With my channel I just hope to shed some light on pens I come across to help people with any purchases they are looking into. I also like sharing what I've learned when it comes to fixing pens/nibs. It's a very old technology which needs tuning from time to time. But when you have a pen that's tuned just the way you like it, it's the best writing experience there is 🤤

[@infin1ty850]

I really need to get a Lamy 2000 fountain pen. I only have the rollerball, which I absolutely love.

[@themisterchristie]

If I had to choose from my current collection I'd be hard pressed, I'll try but there might be some I don't actually own: 1) Everyday Carry - Platinum Prefounte - writes first time every time with the great sealing cap 2) Pocket Pen - Gravitas Pocket Pen in Ultem, for the durability, styling, and ink capacity (first pen on this list I don't own). If I had to go with from my collection, the only pocket pen is the Pilot Petit1, which seals great. 3) Vintage Pen - Have to go with the over engineered Sheaffer Snorkel for the cool factor. From my collection would be the Eclipse Vis-O-Ray once I restore it, the only nice vintage one I have. 4) Grail Pen - I'll go with the Visconti Homo Sapiens with the lava resin. I don't have any that nice in my collection. 5) Travel Pen - I would go with the Majohn A1 also, for the clicky convenience. From my collection would be the Jinhao 80, writes every time as long as it doesn't sit unused for over 24 hours, and is cheap.

[@evanbasnaw]

EDC/Pocket - Safari - I just throw it in a pocket and forget about it. It never fails me. Vintage - 1944 Shaeffer Vac-filler - I just love the nib and I only have 4 vintage pens to choose from. Mine is modified to be an eyedropper. Flex - Pilot Falcon. - There's nothing in my collection that compares to this. Luxury - Lamy 2000 F - Though this one could probably fit most of the categories here Travel - Platinum Plasir - It's rugged, affordable, and reliable. Plus you can carry cartridges to fill it if you're away.

[@daintiestquarters3411]

Never heard someone speak with so much passion about pens. I love your channel. I collect watches, but I am thinking of adding some pens to my collection.

[@Doodlebud]

So many fun pens out there!

[@MrIrrationalSmith]

This convinced me to get a Majohn A1. I've been wanting a cheaper vanishing point alternative, and the A1 in orange is gorgeous.

[@ina_lina]

--EDC: Retro 51 Harriet Tubman . I don't actually carry it every day, but Retro 51s are my current favorite writers, so I had to put one on the list. The only fountain pen I carry every day is a Pilot Petit 1 that fits in the small zipper pouch I use for a wallet. --Pocket: Traveler's Brass . --Vintage: The Sheaffer Targa Regency Stripe my dad bought for me when we were in Paris together a million years ago. --Luxury: I don't have a real luxury pen. If I were rich, I'd buy a Visconti Il Magnifico Verzino Green Marble. As it is, my most expensive pen (even though I got it at a great sale price) is my Pilot Falcon that I use for drawing (and kinda counts as a flex nib). --Travel: Well... If I'm traveling, I'm making art, so I'll have several fountain pens in my kit, ranging from preppys, kakunos, and lamys to the aforementioned retro 51s and falcon. --Fun bonus pen: Either my Taccia Spotlight Forest Eye with a music nib because it's pretty, or the TWSBI 580 RBT that serves as my dedicated DeAtramentis Document white pen. Thank you for all your fountain pen knowledge you share.

[@JosephDickson]

My list: EDC - Kaweco Sport EF Sketch - Pilot Prera F In the backpack - Pilot Prera M At the desk - TWSBI Go, Eco, & 580.

[@dianedemasi]

Oooh, the vintage Elite. So beautiful! My current collection is a total of eight pens: Platinum Preppy, Jinghao 450, two Pilot Metros, Kaweco Perkeo, Pilot Explorer, TWSBI Eco, and a Cross Townsend (I think - I know it's a Cross, but I can't find an identical one, but the design is very Townsend-like). If the lid on my Pilot Explorer, would stay put, I'd list that as my travel pen. I really enjoy the writing experience with that pen. As for the other categories, I think they'd be filled by default, LOL. I've been using fountain pens for ten years and I'm finally getting to the point where I may attempt to fix a few things to bring a little more joy. The Kaweco is scratchy and the TWSBI cuts out mid-writing. The lids on the Explorer and the Preppy don't stay on. And the grip section on the Cross untwists as I write. Despite the little nuances, I really can't complain, I love writing with all of them. Merry Christmas and thank you for the videos!

[@Doodlebud]

Merry Christmas to you too 🎄

[@pbnjezly404]

Hey, some pens I can afford, lol

[@quailypoes]

I'd probably go with... 1. Jinhao x159 2. Jinhao 159 3. Sheaffer No-Nonsense 4. Sheaffer "School Pen" 5. Dip pen

[@peterpuleo2904]

Great acetic choices.

[@evanescentwave181]

Just got a Gravitas Titanium in the Tisnix color. Really like the color. So far like the pen. However, when you spin it it doesn't roll over to the flat spot very often. I wonder if the lighter weight is the cause. I don't care though and I like the roll stop feature by itself. Thanks you all your helpful insight and info.

[@squeelit]

Love the choices you made, and the honesty in why you chose them. At first, I was surprised by the choice of cost vs seal strength for travel. But after remembering how many items have been lost during adventures, it makes sense. I don't tend to pack anything else that couldn't be replaced readily, so bringing an heirloom pen makes no sense either. Again, I love seeing your collections and finding new pens to add to my wish list. Newest addition being the vintage Pilot Elite. Wow! That Elite is just exquisite... Something about it reminds me of the antique cigarette case my grandfather used, or the details within the dash of classic cars, or even old radio dials. It will likely be next year's birthday present to myself, if possible.

[@Doodlebud]

That vintage elite is seriously sexy! Here's my review if you haven't seen it yet: kzbin.info/www/bejne/l5bJoY2mrpqZqJo

[@jdblack9703]

Pelican 140 is a nice pen. I’m using a Sheaffer Imperial today with BuGu Box Emerald ink. I think the ink makes a difference in the writing experience. I enjoy you videos.

[@Jezee213]

I got the Majohn A1 for xmas and I'm in love with it. I had a vintage VP and it's just as good, I'm using some Iroshizuku Kon-Peki and it really pairs well with the A1.

[@xlerb2286]

I'm not familiar with many of the pens out there but I like your choices. My favorites would still be my Lamy 2000 and maybe an odd choice but one of the cheaper Sheaffer Targa pens. Those were the two favorite pens I used in school and for me I've never seen any I like better.

[@johnrus7661]

I just got one Waterman pen for the 20+ years. Been wonderful, now I need to get my wife a fountain pen. Probably a Waterman, since she works as a MA in a doctors office. A pen is an indispensable everyday tool for her and has a massive collection of them. But no fountain pens. And that's gonna change here soon.

[@gregorypease213]

Great concept, and a lot of fun. I don't yet have a pocket fountain pen, but the rest were pretty easy for me. 1. EDC - Pelikan. They always write, they never leak, and they're easy to maintain. 2. Pocket Pen - TBD. I've had a Space Pen bullet in my pocket for decades, but a FP would be a nice add. 3. Vintage/Flex - Pelikan, either my 140 or my 400nn. (Though a 1920s Waterman is a very close runner-up.) 4. Luxury - My Pelikan 1000 F nib. I've had a few MB 149s, but the M1000 has been more dependable, more reliable. Runner up, my MB Agatha Christie 5. Travel - Finally, a break in the pattern. My Parker Duofold Centennial because it's dead reliable, never leaks, and uses cartridges, which are convenient when on long trips. My Pelikans don't leak, either, but carrying bottles of ink is a bit of a deal breaker for me.

[@Doodlebud]

An M1000 is on my list. Need to at least try one out one day

[@gregorypease213]

@@Doodlebud They've got all that that "big pen appeal." They write wet, tend to be at least a couple sizes broader than you'd expect them to be (my F is between what a normal M and B would be), are substantial and heavy, but there's just something about them. You've got me thinking about a Lamy 2000 again. And, that Gravitas! I just need to pick the one I want...

[@addertooth1]

I have always enjoyed the artful flair of flex nibs. In this narrow niche my top two are any Watermen with a flexy Red or Pink keyhole nib pen. Examples would be a number 7, or a copper/silver-ray Ink Vue pen. The Ink Vue for those who did not like the rubber ink bladder. Another top runner was the adjustable firm to flex nib in the "jewelry store" Coronet, with the block of precious metal as the slider, instead of the stamped metal slider. All of the examples I have will leave a 2mm+ line without railroading. They make writing with a great deal of expression. They also fit the vintage slot he has in his 5 pen collection. Waterman also made some excellent "pocket pens", which some had outstanding flex nibs as well. One of my favorites is a Waterman 552 in solid gold with an amazing flexy number 2 nib. The Lady Patricia is also a strong runner.

[@breadyegg]

I was lucky enough for find a Pelikan M120 'F' at a flea market on holiday in Lisbon. Smoothed the nib out a bit and now it's the pen I always have inked. It's so pleasing to use. Oh, and it cost me twelve euros.

[@kevinu.k.7042]

Great stuff! I bought a Montblanc 146 once and sent it straight back. For me the Pelikan M805 was just so much better made and wrote better too. The MB had wobbly threads on the cap too. My grail pen is an Onoto. Natural acrylic, hand made and an exceptionally good writer. I wish I had bought one years earlier. We all have our different choices though.

[@alfiochieffallo3524]

Great video! Just purchased my first Lamy Safari online. Can't wait for it to arrive. Thanks for this informative video.

[@kokeshi1340]

Me too, just yesterday !

[@fepatton]

I cover many of those categories with my vintage Parker 51 in burgundy with gold-filled cap. Love how it writes, feels, and looks. I prefer understated pens, and I almost always grab it in favor of any of the others in my collection. Cheers!

[@KendallW]

Always fun to ask those hard questions, and talk categories. I would probably throw in a few other factors to consider, like variety of look and color, as well as what inks work best for each one and how they match up with the inks I couldn't live without.

[@varadharajannadarajah]

1)Montegrappa Extra Custom with extrafine nib 2)Namiki Emperor with fine medium nib 3)Montblanc 149 (Platinum trim) with fine nib 4)Pilot custom 823 with medium nib 5)TWSBI VAC 700R The first two, I’ll keep at home only. Rest for work.

[@SouveekBose]

I think I would add demonstrator as a category. Probably club it with one of the other categories such as mini or edc

[@mikequinlan9585]

This is the second KZbin video I watched today that confirms why people are willing to pick a Montblanc over other pens. It’s not complicated, it boils down to how they feel when you write with it. The feel and performance trumps all the other features. For anyone on the fence I strongly recommend buying the pen used from a reputable dealer. It cost about the same as a with a good pen in the $250.00 range but it will give you better performance.

[@snowf6307]

My top pen is not very popular--it's a Lamy Accent that has a lacquered piano black finish with a Briarwood section grip. The nib is 14k gold and was worked on by Mike Masuyama (Lamy nibs are unfortunately not consistent in my opinion). I personally think it's Lamy's best pen, even over the 2k. The Accent has it all for me: smart design, great balance, very comfortable grip, modern nib with a soft feel, and the lovely one-third twist cap which is kind of rare on fountain pens. I have to reiterate that it's such a good looking pen: the combination of wood and metal reminds me of an expensive violin bow.

[@soxandbears]

Clipped to notebook - Lamy 2000 Long writer - Pilot 823 Gusher / Ink fun - Opus 88 w/Franklin-Christoph Broad Look at me - Sailor King of Pen Thanks babe - pretty birthday pen

[@slo_carry]

I was thinking about it during your video and I would replace the vintage category with sentimental since I've sold every vintage pens I've had. Daily Carry: The Good Blue R615. Pocket Pen: ēnsso Pocket Piuma Titanium (I don't usually use pocket pens, so this will probably get replaced by the Full Size Titanium Piuma in February) Sentimental: Conklin Duragraph Royal that my wife picked up for me at Pelikan Hub. Luxury Pen: My Namiki Yukari Chinkin Cherry Blossom pen. I absolutely love everything about the pen and still can't believe I own one. Travel Pen: Pilot Vanishing Point LS. Usually need quiet when traveling. Bonus Pen: I honestly can't decide between Nakaya Long Writer, Visconti Homo Sapiens Magma, or my Newton Pens Townsend. I think it would be an in the moment decision.

[@syedafahd]

Why waiting for February to buy full sized Ensso? They have 20% off right now.

[@slo_carry]

@@syedafahd I'm waiting because they don't have the full size in Titanium right now. It won't be ready until February or later.

[@jarnMod]

I agree on the Majohn A1, for the exactly same reason. Pilot Vanishing Point is my desk pen, one I can grab and work and in the moment of brain constipation, just click it and it doesn't dry. Majohn A1 is as good, but you can bang it and don't cry over the cost. Vanishing point is the one I love, but you don't send Gundam out every time when you can send GMs.

[@DebSilhan_FocusedontheMagic]

Wow, that vintage Elite is so nice. Thanks for sharing.

[@daithi1966]

My EDC/pocket pen is a Pilot 95S. My journal pen is Pilot 835. My pen for art is a TWSBI Mini Vac with an aftermarket flex nib. These are the pens I use all the time. My other two pens would be a premium vintage (Waterman 512) and premium modern (Pilot 845 Urushi in vermilion).

[@williammodlin2621]

Great video. I agree pretty much across the board with your choices. The Lamy is by far my favorite pen and you can write forever with it; it’s just so comfortable in the hand. I don’t have a big grail pen, but I’d probably go for the MB 149 if I had one. Interestingly, I was taking notes with my Majohn A1 (matte black) during this video. I’ve got 2 Pilot vanishing points and they don’t offer any better writing experience, so I just use the A1 as a daily writer. Thanks for the thought and care you put into this topic.

[@jamesaritchie1]

Differences. One of the things I hate most about the 2000 is that I think it's one of the most uncomfortable pens I've ever used.

[@offline._archive]

My list would be Lamy 2000, Pilot custom 823, Pilot 913 FA (for sketching), Sailor Pro Gear, Platinum 3776 century UEF. My Pelikan 605 is on the way so let’s see if my list will change then.

[@niftybottle]

My Five: EDC/pocket - Kaweco Sport AL in fine - I'd worry about my L2K if I carried it around. This one is small, reasonably durable (being metal) and the fine nib is better for cheap paper than my usual medium Smooth Writer - Lamy 2000 - my thoughts in making my own categories were mostly "what writing experiences do I not want to do without". I got a used Lamy 2000 to see what the hype was about, and immediately fell in love. Lamy gold nibs hit my "smooth" sweet spot - it's possible for nibs to be too smooth for me (Pilots, Waterman pens). Until I got my first Lamy gold nib (Dialog CC), I didn't realize I could like smooth pens. The 2000 IMO improves on that pen with a wonderful texture and monstrous ink capacity. Feedbacky Writer - a Sailor - Sailor nibs tend to be pretty consistent, and I love that pencil feel. I'm getting my first with 21k gold this Christmas (a Realo) and I'll see how that compares to the 14ks. I mildly prefer the Pro Gear type body. Apart from that the Sailors are fairly interchangable, just pick a style. I'll also be seeing how I do with the bigger pen body with my Christmas present. Fun Writer- Pilot Vanishing Point Broad ground into CSI by Kirk Speer - as mentioned earlier, Pilot nibs aren't for me in general, but the grind and tune made this super fun to write with, and it's my primary Italic. And of course the addicting click, which is why I went to the effort of getting a nib ground for it to make it usable for me. Knock-around - TWSBI 580 M with Tomahawk slits by Kirk Speer - this is my pen to put shimmer inks and such into. I wanted a pen that at least started off cheap and was easy to disassemble for thorough cleaning. TWSBI makes the bust sub-$100 modern pens for me, and the 580 ALR is my favorite of those; I love the grip texture/ribbing. The Tomahawk slits add softness and make the pen nicer to write with. Secret Sixth: Flex nib - Wahl-Eversharp Semi-Flex or Fountain Pen Revolution Ultra-Flex - this one is hard, both choosing between these two and leaving out of the main five. I love flex! But it doesn't quite itch as much scratch as the above for me. I don't have any wet noodle and I'm not sure I want any: vintage semi-flex is enough for me, and too much more flex makes it hard for me to keep it under control. The choice here is between a bit more quality IMO on the nib and the ease of non-vintage use. Gun to my head right now I'd pick the FPR for convenience and ease of cleaning, but I think my choice would go back and forth 30 times a day. Honorable Mention: Ink Swatching - Kakimori Dip Nib with holder - technically not a fountain pen, nyah nyah. Worth a mention, I thought, as I test a lot of inks and cleaning takes much less time with a dip pen. Not sure what I'd do without squeaking it by on a technicality - was previously using a TWSBI Swipe for testing (and a slightly murdered Eco before, which had trouble taking all the cleaning involved), but that isn't really a pen I'd miss writing with terribly, and I'd worry about the slits on the 580 if I used/cleaned it that often.

[@Merlin012001]

My EDC is a Lamy Safari with a cursive nib, my pocket pen is the E95S, there are no vintage pens in my collection, the luxury pen for me would be a toss up between the E95S and my Conklin Endura in gunmetal and Abalone. and for travel I have to go with my new Jinhao X159s. My wild card would be the Platinum makie Mt Fuji and blossoms brush pen.

[@susanfoley8360]

I agree about the Montblanc 149. No matter where I go I keep coming back to it.

[@Doodlebud]

I just put mine back in rotation again and am always so glad whenever I take it out to write. Its just perfect, especially with that nib grind which suits my writing just so

[@addertooth1]

I view the Montblanc 149 as the additional factor of "office jewelry". It is instantly recognizable among high end pen users, even those who only know a little about fountain pens. When I used to visit tip tier law offices, it was in the pocket of virtually all of the Senior Partner pockets. They took as much pride in their pen, as they did their Cufflinks and their other high-end office jewelry. I always found the body of the 149 a bit big for extended writing, but it was perfect for signing a contract.

[@cdgarcia]

I always wonder if the MB 149 with all its copy cats if it’s still the pen to get. I appreciate your 5 categories it gives me a guide a look to what I’m missing in my collection-Pocket pen, luxury (it’s subjective but I still don’t have an upper end pen), vintage My travel pen would be a Tactile Mover ball point or Retro 51 roller ball. I don’t want to mess around with ink on the road unless I’m driving. EDC would be any pen of the week right now it’s a pen from Relic Pen

[@julianfisher8190]

Lovely video...and realistic! I even have a couple of your choice both of which I have so much affection for (Lamy & Pelikan, for the record). I do like my Kaweco Sport Brass for the mini category, but I may well have to hunt out a 149 and a Majohn (such variety!). Thanks for such an imaginative choice...

[@CumulusWishes]

I don't think I've been around the pen scene long enough to decide what goes into what category. I've tried quite a few pens (mostly majohn) but so far the only ones I really like are the a1 though at some point I do plan on replacing the nib with a vanishing point nib but 80 bucks is hard to part with. Though if I ever get a chance to try any of these pens u will not pass it up. Another great video and def keep my eye out for some of these pens when I get a chance

[@somekid3893]

I think you might be missing two categories -- though you might think of them as flex alternatives. My opinion on line variability is there's basically three axes one can choose, which is exemplified by the four major methods of making nibs which can create variable line thicknesses: there's the flex choice of using added force on the nib; there's the fude/zoom option of pen attack angle -- that is, holding the pen at a shallow angle versus vertical versus reverse; and there's the third option mostly employed by the Pilot Parallel of rotating the pen between your fingers without necessarily changing the angle at which you're holding the pen to change your thickness. That said, I think really what that does to your category system is makes it a 7 (8 for a freebie) pen system by adding two extra categories in the two additional methods of varying line thicknesses. And, considering seven is the number of completion, I think that means you made a pretty good system here :)

[@viclucyzia]

I own beside a few the Waterman Allure Graduate. Write very smoothly, cheap, nice looking and great for everyday writing. Give it a try.

[@daleharvey3278]

I have 2 favorites 1: my favorite pen is a parker51 b nib...I ve been using a Sheaffer snorkel fill which I'm using daily.

[@peterhess2610]

Hey doodlebud. I just found a Parker fountain pen that’s been floating around various dark corners of my house for years. The etching on the barrel shows it was made in England. I remember years ago in a futile effort to get it to write I may have bent the nib too much to the point it may not be making contact with the the feeder that it’s supposed to sit on. To give you an idea how old it is I found the card that the refills are attached to. There’s a little sticker that shows it sold for $1.10 for six cartridges at staples. That’s all I have on it. Any thoughts will be greatly appreciated.

[@houghwhite411]

Edc/workhorse: Pilot VP Experiment pen: pilot Kakuno Bring everywhere throw everywhere pen: Lamy safari I'll bring safari to the end of the world, the pen just begs to be in that role

[@joseparada4430]

A Jinhao 80 is the best fountain pen for me. As eyedropper Moonman C-1. I like Pilot nibs too. No more no less. Regards.

[@kjp76]

I bought a Lamy 2000 with the F nib out of curiosity. I agree with all your delights. In my opinion, it is the nicest workhorse. However, it is too heavy and slick for my fingers. But I regret selling it. In addition, I bought an F nib. Maybe one of the children will get that pen someday? In my everyday life, I need five ink colors: • Blue in Platinum #3776 Century Oshino with a slightly tuned F nib. • Turquoise using Sailor Pro Gear Slim with a slightly tuned F nib. ‣ Pilot Prera with an F nib for black, green, and red. All of them are wet enough that I can write with them quickly and with smoothly. None of them scratch like what I heard in the video above. At the same time, they are precise enough to write clearly and unambiguously even in the Hobonichi grid. Their transparency makes it easier for me to see how much ink is left in the pen and whether it is not drying up. Maybe one day I'll get a Nakaya Cigar Portable Heki-Tamenuri with a soft F nib?

[@gcvrsa]

Five that I *need*? As opposed to merely *want*? Easy. Five TWSBI ECOs. 1. EF daily writer, filled with Mrs. Stewart's Concentrated Liquid Bluing 2. 1.1 mm stub italic for signatures and cheque writing, filled with Mrs. Stewart's 3. B filled with highlighter ink, for highlighting, of course These top three are the pens I actually use every day. 4. & 5. two Ms filled with black ink and red ink, for playing Index Card RPG and other roleplaying games. I don't need any others, but I do like to have two other EFs filled with seasonal inks. I absolutely refuse to use cartridge pens. Piston or eyedropper fill only.

[@VinylWave11]

My choice in pens is as follows: Sailor Pro-gear Black mat with black nib medium point Sailor Naginata 1911 special nib medium Omas Emotica in blue with titanium fine nib TWSBI clear pen body with medium nib Retro 1951 Tornado ballpoint Retro 1951 matching pencil I have these in my EsterBrook Co Pen case that converts to a desktop pen cup. I have been using fountain pens almost exclusively for about 15 years. It would have to be something extraordinary for me to buy another high end fountain pen. I am not a collector; but, I love the feel of writing with fountain pens. I know there are a lot of pens on the market. However, I took my time purchasing my pens and only bought ones that I loved. I still love all of the pens I listed. The only thing I would want is something that works and feels like writing with a soft brush that my Sailor Naginata 1911 special nib.

[@donbrownist]

Wonderful choices. And. Great video as usual. Thanks so much.

[@sumitsarkar2783]

Really sir, despite being an artist and ardent pen lover I really envy your so selected collection.....❤ Love your pens 😮😊

[@homeboi4159]

I only want to keep two pens, they’re both Pilot Elite 95s’s.

[@sanjay130176]

For me 1. Pilot PO nib pen 2. TWSBI Eco Fine nib 3. Lamy 2k medium nib 4.Pelican M400/600/800 medium nib 5. Sailor zoom

[@comprehendeth92]

My regular use pens. Visconti Crystal Dream, Vanishing Point, Koweco Sport/Lilliput, TWSBI diamond, Visconti Homo Sapiens Bronze Age with stub nib. I keep the last one for special writing. The others are daily use. Journaling, note writing, etc. Each has a use. I have plenty of other pens that I love, but these are my keepers.

[@crouserm]

I accept your challenge! EDC, Pocket, Vintage/(Flex), Luxury/Grail, Travel, Bonus. May I not be held to these choices! EDC: ensso Italia Copper, with a titanium nib -- flex, and I might be able to break windows with it. Lots more to say. Pocket: Scrikss 419 -- piston fill; remarkable line variation, unobtrusive (usually, a liability for my personality, but, still). Vintage/Flex: at the moment, Oxford-Wahl ca. 1939, with a nib someone ground to cursive -- also, great pocket pen. Luxury/Grail: painful! choice! -- Pelikan m805 Stresemann which I fitted with their m800 two=tone F nib -- the pain was what I left behind. Travel/Replaceable: Asvine P20, medium steel nib: wonderful writer, did not make a mess inflight, be mad if I lost it, but could replace it readily, not likely to run out of ink if full when I leave home. Bonus: Visconti Midnight Voyager (1990s): gift from a friend; magnificent nib -- not willing to part with it. Hope to God to be able to ship the rest of my collection to my son who likes pens!

[@BizarreBear]

EDC: Pilot 823 or Lamy 2000 Pocket pen: Kaweco Sport Brass (I haven’t tried any other pocket pens) Vintage: Pilot MYU Luxury: Montblanc Solitaire Blue Hour LeGrand Travel/Beater: Platinum Procyon

[@Doodlebud]

How do you like the Myu? I've been looking at them forever!

[@BizarreBear]

@@Doodlebud So I don’t actually own the Myu, but I’ve tried my friend’s one. It’s a really fun pen. I think for most people the E95 will do, but the metal body is just so nice. I don’t recall what nib size my friend’s Myu was, but it was very stiff, but still a very good writer imo. I’d love to see you review one!

[@lisedionne4649]

Thank you for the classification ... It is fair ...I like the rigorous intellectual analysis ... and ... I like the conclusion of this analysis ... I am a Mont Blanc's fan 😉

[@brianlooksaround6125]

I have to agree with you about that Pelikan 140. I have the same pen and it is a sheer delight to use. A gem of a writer.

[@donhall-aquitania1025]

I only use fountain pens for journaling so my four pens are full sized with #6 nibs except for my Lamy 2000. My other journalers are Montblanc 146, Pilot Silvern, and Diplomat Excellence A2. My last pen will be a Pelikan m1000 for it’s crazy nib.

[@45sandlps]

I appreciated your categories, made it simpler for me, but I think it worth considering nib sizes too. If your Everyday has a companion journal then no problem, your Vintage is likely to be used at home, same with the Heirloom, but If you don't know what paper quality will be available, then the Travel and Pocket Pen may need to be Fine. The ink is another consideration and that's a Rabbit hole Alice, with drying time, waterproofness, and absorbency to consider. B.T.W., I chose my Heirloom by having the one I bought the House and signed the contracts with (Medium Nib and permanent ink). Who would buy a $350k house with a $3 Biro? Great video and subject!

[@hannahroedder936]

Have! EDC: TWSBI Eco (4) Narwhal Nautilus (2), Pocket/Travel: Kaweco Sport (2), Vintage/Flex: Omas Ogiva/MoMA (6) Parker Duofold Sr. "flatop" (2) Modern/Premium: Aurora Internazionale, Conway Stewart Churchill (3), Pelikan M800 (2) Happy!

[@rrreid27]

Excellent video! Thanks for sharing it! My 5 from my collection: Lamy 2000 with an M nib (EDC) Pilot Custom Black Stripe M nib (Vintage) Namiki Emperor M nib (Luxury) Pilot Elite F nib (Pocket Pen) Similar to yours, but with the inlaid nib, like the Custom Black Stripe Pilot Fermo F nib (Travel Pen)

[@antonioraffa123]

You made that look easy. Thank you!

[@sajjadhusain4146]

Always a great topic to ponder and discuss. If pressed, and if I’m completely honest I’d unhesitatingly choose 5 different Aurora pens in my 5-only mini pen collection. But for variety’s sake I’d pick the following: Aurora 88 Sailor KoP Sheaffer PFM (IV or V) Visconti Divina Elegance Pilot Custom 845 edit: to be sure, I actually own the five pens I named. 🙂

[@ichirofakename]

KoP or go home.

[@sajjadhusain4146]

@@ichirofakename …True! I own three. Each one is indispensable to me. Alas, you’re still holding out getting one. The price is a perennial stumbling block, I know.

[@ichirofakename]

@@sajjadhusain4146 Keep up the pressure, I'm sure to break down sooner or later.

[@sajjadhusain4146]

@@ichirofakename ..I plead mea culpa…I realize that I have, several times already, tempted and goaded you to just go for it and finally land a KoP you desire and deserve.

[@ironmic9244]

@@sajjadhusain4146 I'm interested in the KoP just for the nib, but the price for a C/C. That hurts, because it's a big pen. And, I like my mediums and broader, so I'll need a broad. Any reason for why the Major Japanese pen makers go with a C/C? Even the Custom Urushi is a C/C. I'm not comfortable with eyedroppers so that eliminates a couple of good Japanese pens, but I love all the different types of nibs you get with Sailor and especially Pilot.

[@TXDude]

Waterman Gentleman, fine point.

[@bngr_bngr]

I would pick my Montblanc 149 and the Waterman fountain pen. I have a couple of others but I’m not crazy about them. I would add a Twisbi vacuum pen or a Stipula fountain pens. My every day writing instruments are rollerballs and mechanical pencils. I do have Montblanc pen that was my mother’s, so that would be my fifth choice.

[@Neel-y4f]

My pens would be: 1. Favorite pen-Pilot custom 843 2. Quick note taker-Lamy Safari 3. Pocket pen-Kaweco Al sport 4. Fancy pen-Mont blanc 149 5. Large ink capacity-Twsbi Eco

[@mikej.8885]

EDC Pilot 823 (smoke). Travel Pen Vanishing Point (Matte Black) {823 is great for plane travel}. Pocket Pen Kaweco Sport (Dark Green). Vintage Pen (you don't need a flex pen) Montblanc 144. Luxury Pen Vanishing Point Raden Galaxy. 6th Category Kokuno or Safari to get non-fountain pen people into fountain pens use it everywhere so people can see...

[@Doodlebud]

Ooooooo a raden finish, makes for a gorgeous pen

[@mikej.8885]

@@Doodlebud my big splurge lol

[@Glassjaw003]

Everyday Carry: Conid Bulkfiller - 14k gold nib Pocket Carry: Conid Bulkfiller 14k gold nib Flex Pen: Conid Bulkfiller Titanium nib Vintage Pen: Waterman Hundred Year Grail Pen: Conid Bulkfiller CAISO 18k nib Travel Pen: Conid Bulkfiller 14k

[@genaishivatov1737]

Pens that really impressed me - Pilot Cocoon, Kaweco Sport, Sailor Procolor 500, Pelikan M205, Pilot Custom 74.

[@hnaoto2]

Hmm..my Nakayama cigar, vanishing point, homo sapiens, pineider avatar, and twsbi vac700. Always grab those no matter how many pens I buy lol.

[@WolfiePeters]

Parker 51 Vac and Wing Sung 601 Vac - those are the pens that I need. Yes, I have others that I like and enjoy, but the P 51 and WS 601 are the ones I couldn't give up.

[@mikehoare6093]

got a pelikan 140 from my grandad, but I don´t write with it. glad you mentioned this classic piece !

[@sailcat9]

Great video! I guess if I were to pare down my conglomeration of pens to just five, I would choose the Lamy 2000 (F), Diplomat Excellence A+ in the Wave finish (M), Platinum President (B), Pilot Custom 823 Amber (M), and the Pilot e95s (F). If I get a sixth choice, how about the Faber Castell e-Motion matte black (M) as a kick around pen?

[@taariqmayet9547]

Awesome Selection!!!. I would replace the Lamy 2000 with a Kaweco Sport, the Pelikan 140 swap with Pilot Falcon, and for travel not fountain pen but B3 Aviator, just for it versatility. its 2 pens (Choice of black, blue, red) and a pencil in one body. but Meisterstuck and Gravitas definitely Stays!!! I actually EDC a Kaweco Demo with eye dropper conversion and polished Fine nib, Writes beautifully. I also EDC a Pilot Metropolitan sometimes.

[@taariqmayet9547]

I Forgot to add, i only need a Gravitas and Meisterstuck to complete my 5 Pen collection, i do have other pens as well like Twisbi's and Caran d'ache, but i don't really like them to much, Twisbi only because the plastic is not so good. It cracks and breaks easily. They write awesome though. My favorite writer is the falcon with EF 14k nib.

[@manifunk1]

Lamy 2000 Pilot Capless Twsbi Diamond 580 Watermans Pen Expert Mont Blanc 146

[@TweakMDS]

Before I even watch this and have you influence me: Daily writer: Lamy 2000 with a medium cursive italic grind. Bring anywhere: TWSBI 580 AL-R prussian blue 1.1 stub. Favorite aesthetic: Leonardo Mosaico Baobab. Best writing feel: Pelikan M805 Stresemann broad. Tank (+ lower ink capacity to swap quickly): Diplomat Aero Flame.

[@robertmaxey5406]

I would go for a third Parker 51. I would fill it with green ink.

[@Anton_the_Vampire]

Thinking about my modest collection, I think my 5 (which don't totally fit the categories) are; Italix Parson's Essential Parker 45 CT gold nib Noodler's Konrad (flex) Parker Sonnet gold nib Italix Chaplain's Tankard

[@ToastSoon4808]

I like all the pens you suggest however prefer medium to broad nibs. My greatest dissapointment was the Mont Blanc - one keeps drying up so,its a issue uncapping and eventually gets to write, the other - the mechancics for turning out the nib just packed up - the third one my boerboel pup destroyed and the pencil ( my most favourite) the logo head kept turning loose and get lost. Annoying is to take the pen in fot repairs, pay the same amount, juusyt to return with the same problem later.

[@13noman1]

Another thought provoking home run! Let's see -- based on pens I have in hand, I'd go with the following: Pocket: ensso XS in titanium: faceted, light, tough, great nib! EDC: (hardest category): Franklin Christoph Model 20 (slip cap, well tuned nib, easily slips in shirt pocket) Vintage/flex: gonna cheat here and go with my Pelikan M800, tweaked by Mike Masuyama as flex fine cursive italic Luxury/grail: Santini Italia (another tough call) Travel: Opus 88 Fantasia! Fantastic, eye dropper fill, shut off valve. This was the easiest call of the 5 categories!

[@Doodlebud]

Yeah a Santini is a pretty amazing pen

[@guy1642]

How about beginning pens? I just bought my first, a Pilot Metropolitan with a medium nib. For my second pen I’m considering a Lamy Safari with 1.1 mm stub nib. What are your suggestions for starter pens, and specifically your suggestions for nibs, tip shape, flexibility, etc.? Thank you!

[@Doodlebud]

I could do something like that

[@AndrewThibeault]

Love that pen case, too.

[@Javi_C]

Very difficult selecting only 5! Nice picks Doodlebud!

[@MultiRandman]

I think it's significant that the best nib (for flexibility) and personality is with the vintage Pelikan. Vintage pens are still way more desirable and in terms of styling, materials, and workmanship are head and shoulders above new pens. Many of the contemporary manufacturers of fountain pens are copying the classic vintage pens. Just buy the original if you value quality and the quality of a hand ground nib. Each pen has it's own personality.

[@timh7246]

In the opening you show some nice 5-pen fabric holders. I have always liked the ones where there is fabric between the pens to protect them from scratching each other. Brand please? I'm having trouble finding them on line. Thank you!

[@Doodlebud]

Here's the review kzbin.info/www/bejne/jofFaYmYr7Gkjqc

[@jmcclusky2640]

Try the Gravitas Titanium Pocket Pen with the Stainless section. You'll love it. The balance is perfect! His Delrin pocket pen with a titanium section is also really nice if you prefer a lighter pen.

[@Doodlebud]

Love Gravitas pens!