Buku Bahasa Inggris SD TEREKSPOS!

omg guys ini Buku parah Habis, kamu bisa lihat sEndiri deh. i hope you GUYS will all be carreful when buy English book for the kid.
Seriously though... this is a real problem. Buku pelajaran bahasa Inggris di Indonesia ga semuanya jelek gini tapi saya yakin banyak lagi buku diluar sana yg salah2 di setiap halaman. They shouldn't be allowed to print them. Klo ga mampu sekolah mahal mendingan belajar bahasa Inggris di KZbin deh kayaknya.
Want to learn how to become a youtuber yourself? Get my COMPLETE KZbin COURSE online at Udemy. www.udemy.com/...
/ sacha_stevenson
/ sachastevenson

[@verren1420]

Oh Lord. Saya guru les paruh waktu bahasa Inggris di Bali. Buku yang dibahas Sacha itu kebetulan juga yang dipakai murid saya yang kelas 6 SD. Saya rasanya mau nangis tiap ngajar dia pake buku itu soalnya grammarnya banyak yang salah T-T help. Apalagi yang preposition itu (SEMUANYA PAKE -IN) nangis. Cetakan semester 2 ini lebih buruk dibanding yang semester lalu. Saya harap buku LKS seperti ini diperbaiki ke depannya karna terkadang ada beberapa guru di sekolah yang mengabaikan kesalahan-kesalahan kecil ini.

[@wallywaldo88]

kenapa masih dipake bu?

[@ceria_ceri]

@@wallywaldo88 dia hanya guru les. Sedangkan di sekolah, latihan atau pr dari LKS tersebut

[@cahidijoyoraharjo7833]

@@wallywaldo88 Guru les diperintahkan untuk menggunakan buku yang sudah disediakan. Mereka tidak diperkenankan untuk menggunakan buku pilihan mereka sendiri. Kecuali kalau les privat.

[@kopisusu2000]

Turut berduka cita, Bu. Saya juga guru les Inggris. Dillema-nya adalah, kalau murid kita ajarkan yang benar, lalu di sekolah diadakan ulangan bahasa Inggris, lalu jawaban murid (yang sudah benar) dianggap salah, bagaimana coba? EN: My condolences, maam. I am an English tutor too. The problem is, if we teach our students the correct things, then when they have an English quiz, they tend to answer the correct things, right? What if the teacher at their schools mark their answers as incorrect (because the answer key says so)?

[@fionadewi9266]

Saya juga pernah jadi guru les paruh waktu kak, di Salatiga. Dan semua itu juga saya temukan di buku-buku murid-murid saya mulai dari yg masih SD kelas 2 sampai LKS SMP kelas 3 semuanya seperti itu. Dan bukan cuma di Salatiga, adik-adik sepupu saya yg di Blitar (domisili asli saya di Blitar, tapi saya kuliah dan menjadi guru les paruh waktu di Salatiga) itu juga sama saja. Bahkan ada yg judul bab dan isi materinya jauh tidak nyambung sama sekali. Terlebih lagi banyak siswa yg saya coba instruksikan untuk membaca teks yg ada di dalam buku mereka sendiri, tapi setelahnya itu mereka tidak tahu "apa yg dibicarakan di dalam teks tersebut?"

[@icebear4325]

Goverment: "CINTAILAH PRODUK PRODUK INDONESIA!!" Meanwhile, produk Indonesia be like:

[@latifafauziahafrizon3678]

Sad fact

[@raccoonguy21]

How can we love our products but they just wouldn't care bout it

[@crispycactus-es6xp]

Lol

[@user-bo1ej5im9t]

So your country product are better than us?

[@feliceclefie8450]

Agree.... Sedih sekali

[@enobening]

REFUND! REFUND! REFUND! oh wait, it's 20 years late.

[@lyq232]

Wah, ada bang Eno di sini, mantap

[@gshhsbshznjsksjsk3927]

6

[@martingarry5359]

Widiiiii kurator mim mampir

[@masubet5360]

Bjirt

[@FavouredWoods]

Damn even our lord and master comment on this vid. *This is a serious problem*

[@michaelsetiawan2746]

Plot twist: The LKS is testing the students whether or not they could find and correct the "errors" in the book.

[@hhwi.e_o]

Guru saya dulu pas smp emang sengaja anjir buat cari yg salahnya 😂

[@jakartagamer6188]

e si geblek mana ada yang tahu, kita mah cuman ngikutin aja -_-

[@laladeelaladoo7121]

Error analysis over 9000

[@zedreamreaver4327]

That's what I've been doing for the last 10 years in every English class I've ever been in :v

[@sonnysatriaabdullah1455]

Indonesian's education law : books and teachers always right.

[@regitasonia]

What's even worse is when the teachers aren't even that fluent in English and teaches you with broken English and wrong grammar. And when u tried to correct them, they won't accept it because they're 'the teacher'. I went to an international School in elementary years and moved to a local public school in 5th grade. Man, the English teacher was horrible. I don't even know how she could be a teacher, it's really sad knowing there are lots of teacher like her.

[@hkmrsrg1367]

The same experience I had yesterday and the months before when I had to debate fellow English teachers on the use of 'in, on, and at' and explain that it's not "How do you think?" but "What do you think?" when asking for opinions and on other stuffs.

[@YEP753]

i feel ya😂🙃

[@inday5785]

Yeah, my teacher told my whole class, how to pronounce *Through* is Trh-uf

[@IdaeChop]

3 words. Was and Were.

[@susetyoherlambang9171]

Same, like wth? My English teacher thought that the fastest transportation is a train, it's actually a plane. Also he thought that people who sails a ship is called instructor instead of sailor, it's triggering me.

[@anditarigan85]

Sacha makasih banyak sudah membedah secara sadis buku pelajaran itu, hahaha. Kebetulan aku juga bekerja sebagai penulis buku pelajaran di salah satu penerbit (tapi bukan yang nerbitin buku yang kamu bedah, hehe). Kebanyakan penerbit buku pelajaran harus "kejar tayang" dan kami harus lembur untuk membuat buku sebanyak-banyaknya dalam waktu singkat. Makanya buku yang hancur seperti itu bisa lumrah ditemuin di kebanyakan buku pelajaran. But like you said, as education book writer we must not make mistake. Satu kesalahan kecil bisa jadi "dosa turunan" karena kesalahan itu terkesan benar. Jadi ga ada alasan bagi kami untuk mencari alasan. Mudah2an teman-teman penulis buku pendidikan di Indonesia bisa ngeliat ini dan tetap menulis sebaik mungkin terlepas dari tuntutan pekerjaan yang ada. 👍

[@amaninindonesia]

Mantap bang Andi 👍🏻

[@ardikaputu]

Tp buku LKS bahasa inggris di tahun 1999 - 2000an awal sptnya nggak gini-gini amat deh 😀. Mngkin karena waktu itu LKS cenderung hanya dikeluarkan oleh segelintir penerbit nasional mainstream jadinya kualitasnya lebih baik, gak spt skrg, LKS diterbitkan penerbit lokal yg bejibun, jadinya ya begitu deh.

[@kekikukak_1893]

Semangat bang kerjanya... kami juga semangat kok cari duit buat beliin anak.. Tiap 3bulan ganti Lks buku sampe wajib bayar nggk ada ngutang2 sama pihak sekolah satu haripun...

[@jadigini6808]

Susah emg skrg di indonesia, hidup serba sulit. Apapa2 kepepet dan tekanan yg hebat. Akhirnya semua orientasinya cuma kuntatitas. Mafia fkkk

[@nicosunic5466]

@@ardikaputu jaman dulu juga gitu koq, gw inget SMP tahun 2000an ada guru yang anti pakai LKS karena kualitasnya rendah menurut beliau. Dan bbrp kali kasus buku pelajaran yg isinya kontroversial (porno, radikal, dsb) itu dari LKS ya, apa memang faktor penerbit yg cuma "lokal" kah?

[@adirenaldy]

We need to warn Mr. Nadiem Makarim to recall the book or the whole nation will learn the wrong book.

[@ikhsanramadhan564]

bahasa inggris resminya gak diajarkan di sd

[@bababoeythehorsemen8462]

But it just a dream :V

[@fandifirmanda2671]

@@ikhsanramadhan564 lalu?

[@ikhsanramadhan564]

@@fandifirmanda2671 jadi pak nadiem gak ada urusan merecall buku itu, karena kementrian gak nyediain kurikulumnya. Yang bisa merecall ya sekolah yg sok sokan mau ngadain bahasa inggris

[@tiaraprameswari8499]

@@ikhsanramadhan564 yg bisa dibilang sok2an itu bukan sekolahnya pak, tapi penulis dan penerbitnya. Apa salahnya sekolah mau ngajarin bahasa inggris ke muridnya? Justru bahasa inggris lebih bagus diajarkan sejak dini. Cuma sekolah gak tau buku mana yg bagus utk jadi referensi. Bahkan pada buku yg diterbitkan penerbit yg udah ternama kaya er****ga pun masih sering ditemukan kesalahan tanda baca dan grammar.

[@erikcodimaspamungkas5908]

S.S. M.Hum means the writer has a master's degree in either literature or linguistics. Imagine that.

[@Sunnyy_ah]

I can't 😭😭

[@dariowerbowy9976]

Ericko Dimas maybe that SS stands for Super Suck 😂

[@TulipsLibelle]

Hum. Stands for humiliation 🤭🤭

[@safakha2]

@@dariowerbowy9976 😂😂

[@qartodesua7853]

Well i feel annoyed for that, it is just so disgusting for me, this could be the reason why million of indonesian hate english or they speak or write incorrectly all the time.

[@GeorginoEstevez]

Thank God i learned english "Mostly" from classic disney cartoon right before i went to elementary school 🙆

[@freizakun]

Lmao same

[@LetsSewIt]

Good thing I was a hardcore video game geek since I was 4

[@nanda-rw3qm]

Dhia Anjaini sameee

[@justinjavera645]

Indeed..

[@cheaire]

I learned English mostly from the internet-

[@ewiltasantosa418]

"What season is this? It is..." Sacha: It is Epic SD Student: *write that down*

[@glenlucifer2500]

SD Student : i got 100 Me : WHAAT....

[@serenskw5254]

@@glenlucifer2500 "thanos "impossible" meme template"

[@glenlucifer2500]

@@serenskw5254 Oh yea, that's will be good. xD

[@priscameleniasari7911]

maaf kak seharusnya yg bener gmn ya ? aku sembari belajar juga

[@glenlucifer2500]

@@priscameleniasari7911 "What season is this? It is..." Sacha: it is Epic Artinya "Apa musim ini(Musim apakah ini)? ini adalah" Sacha: ini adalah Hebat sekali(Epik) Hanya ada 2 musim di negara yang berada di garis khatulistiwa yaitu: musim kemarau(dry) dan musim penghujan(rainy) Sedangkan negara yang berada di luar garis khatulistiwa ada 4 musim yaitu: musim semi(spring), musim panas(summer), musim gugur(autumn), musim dingin(winter)

[@pernfadhilah]

i attack the book and the book attack me back i'm choked

[@hendrawankodri7782]

ahahahaha

[@rahmanugrahaini]

Segitu ngeselinnya yah 😆

[@cahidijoyoraharjo7833]

Diserang sama tinta, kaya gurita aja, ya? LOL

[@Vonfafa3]

I’m choking?

[@dtjchentube]

.. the book attacks me back (pake "s")

[@rismadeco]

"They wear their shoes, we wear the socks" Berarti mereka pake sepatu mereka, tapi ga pake kaos kakinya. Kita yang pake kaos kaki mereka Ini terngakak 😂😂

[@hlr1513]

Ngakakkk

[@alexong8653]

Nice point 👍

[@AkhyarMaulanaPangeranWeb]

ya tambah lagi kaos kaki nya separang doang, terus dipakai bareng - bareng yang itu - itu terus, wkawkawk

[@adamardhana4839]

Good point 😅

[@steveclarkkentchuliuxiang6807]

iya. the bisa diterjemahin nya. jd lengkapnya, mereka pakai sepatu, kita pakai kaos kakinya. ceritanya mungkin lg sharing paket hadiah sepatu kali

[@damdam9942]

Entah ya gw merasa lebih gampang paham belajar bhs inggris sm sacha dr pd pas gw sekolah atau pas les dulu. Yg ngerasa sama mana acungin tangan.... 🤭

[@kekikukak_1893]

karena kita sekolah abis buat ngafalin rumus dari SD sampe SMA

[@aditroitz]

@Alfero TV akwkwkwk bener

[@dwiariismurini7544]

Aku, sih, sama aja antara Sacha, sekolah, dan les. Tapi, ya ampun, setidaknya sekolahku pake program luar negeri.

[@levintine777]

My english teacher told me that “we go to the 2nd floor with ladder”. I told him it supposed to be “stair”… he grounded me. What are we, electricians??

[@tiptoe386]

Bruh. *LADDER*

[@mrluthfians01]

Well, that's sumthing

[@rxineyy.movedchannels2566]

y e s

[@flyer_452official9]

Dayum. What is wrong with your teacher?

[@altostarphase9412]

wkwkwwk, naik tangga lipat buat ke lantai 2.

[@cynicallyclash]

halo, anak SMP kls 1 disini pantesan firasat gw gk sesuai sama buku paket, terkadang grammarnya gk "proper", terus skill spelling gurunya agak gk masuk akal gitu kita butuh guru bahasa inggris yang kompeten

[@Alkierari]

Kalau gw dah ada firasat soal itu dari SD kelas 6 kalau gak salah, dan sekarang di SMA makin parah. Karena gurunya nilai b. Inggris gw turun. Kapan ya dapet guru b. Inggris yang baik?

[@sakuranine1802]

Indonesia butuh banyak guru seperti Sacha STEVENSON yang kritis seperti ini ....👍👍👍👍

[@sasalim9024]

Setujuuuuuu

[@rahmatdicky8458]

Cocoknya mbak sascha ngajar guru2 nya biar lebih teliti lagi🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@fadlihermawan9123]

Hmm... berpikir kritis rasanya masih sulit diterima di negara ini. Anehnya, nyinyir malah dipersilakan 😅.

[@muhd7144]

That's on the grammar. Wait till you hear the pronunciation...

[@rismadeco]

The pronunciation is just like the writing. Oxpord.

[@muhd7144]

@@rismadeco LOL 😂

[@auzipratama2714]

It's almost terrible XD

[@komangputrardelrey]

Hahaha 😂

[@cahidijoyoraharjo7833]

@@rismadeco 😂😂😂 Parah pisan!

[@maulinanada9432]

8:51 "gapapa salah dikit yg penting bisa bahass inggris" Bener sekali. Kebanyakan org indo suka menyepelekan hal2 kecil ky gini, kalo sumber belajarnya aja salah, bakal menyesatkan anak2, dn klo mrk ngga dibenerin dr kecil, akan susah di'ubah'pas udh gede.. Ini mah buku asal buat aja kali ya. Masa koma dan titik aja ngga bisa bedain?! Dan yg buat dan ngedit juga udah sarjana, bakan M. Hum?!

[@sagung1620]

Gua ngobrol sama bule pake bahasa Inggris walaupun salah pengucapanya tpi mereka tetep respect dan bilang bahasa Inggris km lumayan bagus.Kalau sama orang indo langsung di bilang ga usah sok Inggris loe. Terus di ketawain gitu

[@MRizqialfianfaidl2409]

Mereka memang respect banget , dan kadang dari mereka membenarkan apa yang kita bicara kan , ini masalah kosa kata kalau salah nulis terus udah jadi bentuk buku kasihan yang mengkonsumsi dong

[@sagung1620]

@@MRizqialfianfaidl2409 pengalaman selama di sekolah gua sama sekali ga paham apa yg guru bahasa Inggris ajarin .Belajarnya pake rumus ,verb dll haduh pusing gua dan pelajaran itu sama sekali g nyambung.Tpi skrng gua bisa bahasa Inggris karena ada temen bule sama suka nonton film bahasa Inggris belajar cara ngobrol

[@MRizqialfianfaidl2409]

@@sagung1620 semakin banyak ngomong semakin banyak kosa kata , gw dlu juga ngga ngerti tapi setelah gw belajar dan lulus dari sastra Inggris sudah agak ngerti , mungkin metode nya aja yang kurang jadi siswa kurang faham , kalau ngomong kan ngga butuh , kalau nulis ngga ngerti kacau

[@carinaayu2028]

Betul bgt... trs guru klo kita kasih tau.., pak bu ini salah.. malah kita d omelin.. 😅😅 Salah dikit klo tertulis itu fatal pdhl.. soalnya klo nanti test semacam toefl atau marlin.., pertanyaan justru di hal2 yg remeh itu (misal penggunaan preposisi) Klo conversation ama bule mah asal lawan bicara kita paham...

[@fahrizald4348]

Saya pernah benerin hal yang salah di buku-buku yang disediakan di sekolah,tapi para pengajar mengubah pola pikir saya,yang dimana jika itu dijadikan pedoman maka itu yang benar. Bagaimana saya tau itu bener/kurang tepat? Saya kursus diluar sekolah,dan tidak hanya di satu tempat. Artinya 2 tempat berkata bahwa A itu A, sedangkan di sekolah A itu B. Dan saya mulai mencari tau sendiri,memastikan mana yang benar di Internet. Ya,A adalah A. Maaf menggunakan permisalan dalam curahan saya,saya ga terlalu inget soal & jawaban tsb,tapi ingat bagaimana kejadiannya.

[@Universalistic]

me: mom can we buy an english book? mom: we have english book at home. english book at home:

[@aditovich]

pantesan bhs.inggris gw bego... pake buku yg salah dr kecil

[@uzuhany7412]

Wkwkwk 🤣

[@JaszLcookie]

No wonder my grammar sucks..

[@aditovich]

사주리 selow aja... relax...

[@aditovich]

사주리 blamingnya dmn?

[@aditovich]

사주리 oh gt... trus kl bilang “diberi buku bener juga gak jamin bhs inggrismu bagus. Jangan alasan” itu blaming bukan?

[@safitrianns7640]

"Terus anak nya udah gede masuk seleb english dia" APA CUMA AKU YG NGAKAK PAS KALIMAT INI 🤣

[@berrysanjaya9169]

wkwk sama gue juga 😅😅😅

[@m.fathurrizkya.w6484]

Barkum ?

[@glenlucifer2500]

Dragon Health : 1% Remaining

[@nickywu9476]

8:41 "It's like criminal, it's criminal." Sasha udh tdk bsa tahan emosi ny, so do I. Mereka lebih pilih byr jutaan rupiah ke editor yg udh sarjana drpd byr cuma 200K ke bule remaja yg lagi surfing di pantai. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@yahsasepta7089]

For them, money is everything bro.

[@nickywu9476]

@@yahsasepta7089 true

[@darrylstephandra6790]

"Christians can meet the doctor at a hospital" i found that somewhat disturbing

[@klauserji]

The best, THE BEST, source to learn english in indonesia are: -youtube videos -movies -games -reddit

[@dindapriska]

For me it's all of the above, but switch reddit (as I don't use it) with books, such as English novels, comics, Oxford Dictionary, and Oxford Grammar.

[@dentist8444]

Reddit is blocked smh

[@dindapriska]

@@dentist8444 VPN can bypass that block.

[@dentist8444]

@@dindapriskaTOR browser also, but some of vpn arent free and had virus yet :/

[@klauserji]

Just use 1.1.1.1, it's an open dns. Hard to explain but it takes less toll compared to vpn (basically it's faster).

[@ima7333]

Now you can feel my frustration trying to teach my son. Then my son has to fight his teacher with google as support on the correct prepositions.

[@n00bie96]

haha I always do this to my teachers, a quick google search can easily prove that they're wrong. The worst part is that 70% of the time, my teachers do not accept corrections because you know, "I'm a teacher so I must be right"

[@ima7333]

n00bie go protest your teacher. If he/she thinks he/she is right, then have your parent protest it.

[@regitasonia]

Omg same 😭 I have to deal with it since elementary school. Gosh, the teachers were horrible. The worst part is they don't want to be corrected.

[@sunduwhy6001]

*Me in front of my book : "am i even trusting you now ?"*

[@rubyanggitha2530]

UGHHH.. this had been a problem since FOREVER!!! I had a problem with LKS textbooks when I came back from the US to Indonesia in middle school. When I told the teacher that I didn't understand what the question meant (the grammar was SOOO awful), he humiliated me in front of the class saying "anak baru dari Amerika nggak ngerti bahasa Inggris" and encouraged my classmates to laugh at me. It honestly tore my self-esteem back then. :(

[@emanueltheodorus1056]

Wow, that must've been horrible! Can't blame ya when english sucks in that school.

[@stephencrownsamosir]

That would be a toxic teacher

[@wartono.]

Buku sekolah dasarnya aja sudah salah, padahal jd dasar pemahaman yg sangat penting, emang seharusnya yg ngajar di SD atau bikin buku2 SD itu professor atau ahlinya masing-masing.,

[@KBProduction]

🤦🏻‍♂️ thanks sacha. We should find those kampret editors of the book.

[@ssszwu]

Sumpah ya gw sendiri ngerasain dari SD SMP gw murid favorit nya guru bahasa inggris krn semua soal di LKS aku isiin semua dari awal buku dibagiin, dan ketika belajar buat TOEFL ternyata banyak banget hal terutama preposition yg salah make nya, dan itu susah banget buat nginget yang bener karena yang salah uda keinget uda nempel ddalem otak dari kecil😭 makasih bangett uda bikin konten ini, jangan dianggap dia merendahkan ato apa, tapi sascha disini ngajak kita semua buat belajar dan belajar dari kesalahan2 yang uda terlanjur tertanam di otak.. Semoga penulis buku pendidikan bisa lebih teliti lagi

[@Maximillian1019]

WHAT THE HELL… Baru pertama kali gue liat konten se-KREATIF ini buku LKS SD aja dibabat abis 😂😂😂😂 Keren banget, ya Tuhan…

[@iiiririeehd5747]

Here ‘s the thing with books like this. They translate every word to the english meaning without putting a grammar on it. Jadi author nya itu cuma translate kata kata nya ke bahasa inggrish. Tapi masalah nya, kadang kalo cuma digituin, grammarnya gk bener..

[@gusdzikrillah9229]

Inilah bukti Tematik membuat anak-anak kita semakin bodoh. Ketika nanti mahasiswa dan lulus S1 harus diwajibkan TOEFL 450an dan saya berhasil mencapai 580an kemudian digugat benerapa dosen, mereka bilang saya curang, yang Notabene padahal saya 2th berhasil menyelesaikan 2 Diploma Degrees di U.S. Saya langsung bilang "What the fakin' hell y'all out of mind?" Dan mereka hanya melihat saya dengan heran tanpa mengerti bahwa saya 'curse' mereka... Bagaimana nasib anakku kelak jika masih kaya gini, Bapakmu berhasil mencapai TOEFL 460an ketika lulus SMA, apakah kamu kelak hanya bisa TOEFL 330an ketika kamu lulus SMA, yg score itu didapatkan Bapakmu ketika lulus SMP... Bubarkan TEMATIK

[@n_aniki]

"What the fakin hell y'all out of mind?" *You've become the very thing you swore to destroy*

[@gusdzikrillah9229]

@@n_aniki Hahaha, oh...kay, it's make sense dude. But, when I curse like that, I'm so annoyed with what their did...

[@n_aniki]

@@gusdzikrillah9229 Sorry for being a grammar nazi, but "it make sense" and "I'm so annoyed with what they did"

[@n_aniki]

@@gusdzikrillah9229 Also, I feel like you didn't really get my joke do you?

[@orewalblack1125]

@@n_aniki I get it

[@Mal_O_Ware]

*Short Story Time:* Guru B. Inggris gw nyalahin gw karena nulis 'you guys', bilang itu salah karena dia "gak pernah ngedenger/ngeliat orang lain gunainnya".

[@nambelas]

Padahal terjemahannya pasti sering denger kan: "Lu Orang". lol

[@kemalmusthafa779]

ya ampun, tapi maaf-maaf saja, guru anda lawak sekali.

[@eosadler9999]

Sadly, many people in Indonesia nowadays think that when they know something (even just a little), they master the whole subject. And then, do such thing to convince other people that they're kings of the clouds. Cause it is storm and they need to wear the socks. For safety. 😅🤦

[@wahyudijrachman62]

I hate the ending 😂😂😂

[@s0ul216]

That's called Dunning-Kruger syndrome, and yes it's commonly happened widely around the globe.

[@Nevir202]

As a native English speaker... Extra painful... 😱 Sad to say, I’ve seen the official English tests from the Indonesian government, and some of it is so bad, there is no “correct” answer, and I would have to guess.

[@n00bie96]

I got 84 on my national english exam (middle school) and scored a 623 TOEFL that same year. I could've gone to the best public school in my town if the creators of the test actually spoke english :))

[@Nevir202]

n00bie I believe you. I couldn’t believe what a mess it was. 🤦‍♂️

[@itscashew5535]

*Sees something about indonesia* *Goes to the comment section* Indonesian: "It's free Real Estate"

[@Airylite]

She lives in indo

[@itscashew5535]

@@Airylite r/whoooosh

[@Airylite]

Cringe

[@hectoristoomuch]

cringe

[@p3el_]

Okay but... Why

[@hyorimhw]

Even Junior High School Student's book have the same mistake. The grammar is just pissing me off. As of today, i've done 2 try outs and there are alot of mistakes. This books, Test, Try Outs, and "Lembar Soal" is really pissing me off. First of all, the answer should've been this but it turns out to be the other wayy, and the grammar jeezzz I meant these books didn't even teach us proper English. Indonesian government, Please fix this problem as this may affect all students across indonesia. make it proper english not "indonesian english"(not talking about the accent).

[@rezax2857]

hey man, i'm a junior high school student. and yeah, the grmmar is so messed up. like... literally!

[@n_aniki]

You think that's bad? Wait till High School to see more grammar errors in your book

[@hyorimhw]

@@n_aniki well, ****.

[@StarBattle08]

@@hyorimhw these books* & mungkin as of today*

[@sakatakintoki6276]

Wkwkwk, same dude. Me and my classmates are from an international school so we pretty much know grammar. And like when we're doing the try outs and practice questions, we're just laughing our ass out whenever the sentences sound so stupid 😂😂😂.

[@zedreamreaver4327]

As someone who speaks English since childhood and lives in Indonesia, I cannot agree more. The number of times I've been in an argument with my English teachers is just unaccounted for. Nice of you to point that out. 😂

[@ditasari1172]

Pantesan pas SD bingung bgt sama bahasa inggris apa tenses, ternyata ini sebabnya

[@maxsaboofpiu]

"Salah sedikit gapapa" 140 is a small number for Indonesia's standard for the number of mistakes allowed, yeah.

[@AbiRizky]

Back in highschool I had this English teacher who wouldn't even care that she made mistakes, let alone listening to her students correcting those mistakes. She must've learned English from one of those books.

[@shirleys.1436]

Sacha, this video is funny and also refreshing. I was educated in Indonesia and Australia. I cannot agree more! I realised how bad the English I learnt from my Indonesian school when I moved to the Australian school. Let us hope Nadiem Makarim watch this🤔🤓

[@diyahayuanggraeni558]

Finally it's just only the elementary school sis? How about in junior high school and high school sis Sacha Stevenson kadang merasa sedih karena Indonesia kurang critical thinking on their mind sis

[@ceritaibubahagia6573]

Omg pertama! Itu penulisnya nggak ada yg lulusan sastra Inggris gitu? Semoga ini bukan buku resmi yg jadi buku wajib di sekolah2.

[@rizqifirdausi6439]

Padahal di mention kalo penulisnya S. S., M. Hum. Yg artinya dia s2 sastra ingris

[@bilimeyer4146]

@@rizqifirdausi6439 S1 mas. Kcuali mas nulisnya "master (dan) sastra Inggris".

[@dewihasanah9754]

Bukan...lks biasanya penerbit dan penggunanya lokalan...

[@elisabetnugraheni]

Untung penulisnya nama orang .. Coba klo penulisnya "TIM MGMP Kabupaten ...." udah pasti tuh buku dipake buat seluruh sekolah negri se kabupaten.. Klo tulisannya penulis cuma nama orang gitu ma yg pake paling cuma skolah swasta yg minat beli itu buku..

[@ceritaibubahagia6573]

Oh M.Hum itu sastra Inggris ya? Haha.. maap, gatau saya. Kirain magister hukum atau apa gitu 😆

[@Griff10poldi]

7:17 Even their Indonesian level is horrible too... "Di sini" without space

[@rizalboond674]

Penulisan preposisi ini ditulis terpisah, contoh: di rumah, ke kantor, dan dari Surabaya. Kesalahan yang paling umum adalah penulisan kata seperti "dimana", "disana", "disini", "ditempat", dibawah", "diatas", "ditengah", "kemana", "kesana", "kesini", "keatas", "kebawah" yang seharusnya ditulis "di mana", "di sana", "di sini", "di tempat", di bawah", "di atas", "di tengah", "ke mana", "ke sana", "ke sini", "ke atas", "ke bawah". Source: id.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preposisi Klo menurut wikipedia sdh benar, tapi ntar saya coba cari2 sumber lain

[@enydgambit6046]

Rizal Boond : ya...sy cuma ingatnya kalo "menyatakan tempat", maka ditulis terpisah...pokoknya gitu dah... 😂

[@rizalboond674]

@@enydgambit6046 iya tapi menurut saya kata sana, sini, bawah, atas. kan bisa menjadi kata ganti tempat. Saya jga masih belajar makanya ini cari referensi sumber lain selain wikipedia

[@enydgambit6046]

Rizal Boond : sip sip...sy jg jd baca² lagi ni ttg penulisan yg bener 😁 soalny udh lama pelajaran dulu wktu SD taon 90an 😂

[@achmadsyafaat7018]

@@rizalboond674 bener ini saya juga suka lupa atau engga ngeh kalo salah, emang harus liat kalimat juga sepertinya

[@handokolie1292]

Keren sasha. That’s why i send my children to international school instead.

[@ariwijaya85]

Cina kan.. Biasalah tu😆😆.. Klo pribumi hantar ke sekolah biasa aja

[@Loxer150]

That’s why they need to change and update the book and curriculum because not everyone can afford to go to an international school.

[@MDzaki-uk2ll]

@@ariwijaya85 1. Rasis 2. Semua berhak untuk mendapatkan pendidikan yang setara dan inovatif 3. Sistem edukasi Indonesia masih tertinggal jauh dengan negara-negara barat 4. Baca kritikan pedas Lowy Institute terhadap Sistem Pendidikan Indonesia

[@amirulmahfud9947]

@@ariwijaya85 apa si lu kenape bawa bawa ras, suka suka die lah kalo mao bawa anaknye ke sekolah internasional. Bukan lo ini yang bayar

[@dragonboimmdvideos]

if only i have enough money 😭

[@marshellanovitasari3429]

aku seorang mahasiswa guru, dan jujur aku sedih banget liat buku2 kaya gini beredar. Bener banget kata Sacha, murid boleh salah dikit-dikit tapi penulis, editor, dan guru HARUS MENUNTUN MURID PADA KEBENARAN. Sacha, perbanyak lagi ya konten pendidikan :)

[@juliantotriwijaya9208]

1:38 wow just entering "daftar pustaka" and we can already see the mistakes, this is a Great Start guys :)

[@RyanIKJ]

"This bokk it's was tottaly a joke!" - M.Hum. (Magister Humor)

[@softboy7797]

Apasi Maksudnya it's was? Wkwk Terus bokk apaan dah?

[@wardatulrh5615]

@@softboy7797 sama, dia juga lagi nge Joke kok 😁😁😁😁

[@kurniawan3686]

*book *totally

[@irakrisna]

@@softboy7797 dia ngejoke juga bro .... 😅🤣

[@user-on8vk5gb6x]

@@kurniawan3686 r/woooosh r/youngpeopleonyoutube

[@kopisusu2000]

7:17 The writer is not competent in Bahasa Indonesia too, apparently. There is no such Indonesian word as "disini" nor "disana". To be fair, it is common that most Indonesians confuse "di" as a prefix and as a preposition. However, we are talking about a book about 2nd language here. For kids too! If the writer is not competent in the 1st language, what do you expect? I agree with Sacha's conclusion. I am a frustrated English teacher too, BTW.

[@ayusaleha4452]

Walaupun Indonesia banyak masalah, Sacha tetap cinta & suka tinggal disini... 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@canniereddie]

I remember my teacher used to pronounce "goose" as "ghost" and the whole class just believes.

[@canniereddie]

@FoxBoy yeah-

[@iannoypeople4916]

@@canniereddie yo wtf that is real? Unbelievable for me lol

[@canniereddie]

@@iannoypeople4916 It's real, man.

[@itsarin2166]

"Because I can play snow man" ehh... mate, what are you tryin' to say?

[@weebslime]

spinning them pen

[@dindapriska]

Profesional editors to the writer and the related 'editor' of the book: "When will you learn? When will you LEARN?! *THAT YOUR ACTIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES!!"*

[@AB-qc5jc]

Yea I'm Indonesia and sitting in junior high school The books that we are learning don't have correct word and the teachers are just not good at teaching Jadi kebanyakan murid kalau guru ngajar ngajarnya yang salah

[@nurprimamasido]

I sometimes teach my students about those mistakes in their so called "LKS" book... We found really funny and my students couldn't stop laughing after understanding the meaning of what is written in the book ... Here's one sentence written in the book that is hard for me to forget : Anton and his wives ........... watch a movie in the cinema. (I believe you know what I mean)

[@firdanjulian8277]

Nurprima Masido hebat ya, bisa pada akur istri2 nya

[@user-ui6ie8el6o]

polygamy lol

[@SetsunaFSeiei-ny8im]

Jawabanya anton+bini2nya do wactch ya?? Mereka Emang nonton kan?

[@JustFifaThings]

Hahahah

[@malcolm.victoriano]

What if Anton has 4 wives? 😂

[@dokterspeaking9355]

Savage! Thanks for doing it, actually masih banyak buku2 yg engga qualified utk dipakai, dg isi yg ridiculous. Krn bener banget, kalo sejak awal belaajr yg salah, praktek yg salah, nanti sempurna di hal yg salah.

[@randomscroller9347]

Dari dulu emang selalu nemuin kejanggalan-kejanggalan dalam buku LKS yang dipake sekolah, bahkan sampe LKS SMA. Tapi sebagai murid saya ga bisa terlalu maksa ngoreksi jawaban-jawaban buku ataupun pendapat guru-guru bahasa inggris. Contoh: saya inget dulu dalam teks ada frasa "it turns out that she.." dan guru saya mengartikannya sebagai "dia berbalik keluar". Saya langsung koreksi, "pak , itu artinya 'ternyata'". Tapi si bpk ttp bersikeras kalo artinya "berbalik keluar".

[@aryosheva8204]

Kebiasaan org indonesia tuh ngartiin perkata, sampe lupa kalo ada yang namanya frasa

[@kkoesoemo]

Tematik : Hello Cambridge : I'm here to end this BOOK's career LOL

[@nicholasreyza3968]

They attac They protecc But most importantntly They want their money bacc

[@amnhrsy]

Lmao so true

[@jellyboygaming4429]

LOL

[@dragonboimmdvideos]

are they thicc tho

[@tiptoe386]

importantly*

[@nicholasreyza3968]

moemoe toe it’s a typo

[@-zuzur0ll712]

Honestly, If youtube didn't introduce me to PewDiePie, I would've been the creator of that book.

[@gavinattalahadiyan325]

lmao why

[@awpimawpimawpaajd4176]

Pewdiepie itu swedish dia juga ga perfect inggrisnya jgn dijadikan acuan dasar bocah

[@HaniSantosa]

OMG "that song" should be your opening and ending song from now on. I couldn't stop laughing.

[@TiroDaenuwySJ-ru2te]

OMG! Thanks so much Sacha for doing this! I have been teaching English for 3 years for grade school and high schools in Central Java and the English is freakin atrocious in most school books. I can't believe people make money out of this ****! Please expose more! It's not about the mistakes, but how paper is wasted on mistakes that are reprinted and taught to generations of Indonesians :-(

[@wisjourney2870]

I’m glad that I have opportunity to work with American for four years. I learn a lot how to communicate well in English ✌️

[@alexsujatmiko931]

Have an opportunity kurang "an" woi duh

[@wisjourney2870]

Alex Sujatmiko ask sacha ada yang salah !!!

[@kasogikosoni6750]

You were glad that you had an opportunity to work with an American for four years, so you could learn how to communicate in English properly.

[@amowangtingtong]

its also sad when i see my friend’s 5 years old daughter that just moved to Indo from Singapore (she speaks fluent english anyway) did her English homework from her kindergarten school here in Indo. She was struggling to do the homework because the right answer for the ordinal number of 3 is “3rd” and there were no choice for the “rd” in the collumn😭😭😭

[@fkhrhdzf]

and there's a lot of people who still pronounce "fiveteen/fivety", not "fifteen/fifty"

[@sdm000]

The expression on her face just explained everything wrong about the book. 😂 #2020gantibuku

[@m.ridhowahyudi8006]

Buat yg blg guru nya acuh dan tidak mempermsalahkan keslahan ini jangnlah berpikir buruk dulu. Mungkin bagi guru yg mengaja bhsa inggris di sekolah dasar memang tidak memperhatikan keselahn tersebut karena mungkin pengetahuannya tidak samapai disitu. Dikarenakan ltar belakang pendididikan nya bukan dari jurusan bahasa inggris. Jadi kemapuan bhasa inggrisnya sangat lah pas pasan dikarenakan latar blkg pendidikan itu tadi. Karna pada umunya para guru SD latar pendidkan nya dari jurusan pendidikan guru sekolah dasar.

[@joejambul3039]

I cried listening to the song- English teacher from Malaysia

[@AbsaAbrach]

Nyesel aku dulu waktu sekolah pas pelajaran bhs. Inggris bolos. *Untuk adik2 yg masih sekolah giat belajar ya.*

[@capricorngirl7331]

sama dong, aku baru belajar b inggris pas mau tamat SMA wkwk

[@AbsaAbrach]

@@capricorngirl7331 😅 iya kak 🤭

[@aryosheva8204]

Kyknya mendingan lu bolos pas pelajaran bahasa inggris buat main game yg make bahasa inggris dah wkwk

[@mutiarapasha8630]

"belajar sampe kuliah biar pinter kaya orang-orang kuliah lainnya" Penulis buku:

[@alexong8653]

It may be well-received if the title becomes "Finding Common Mistakes... ", where students can instead circle the qualified questions' errors out rather than answering it.

[@waterunderthebridge2291]

Semoga bapak Mendikbud nonton video ini. Pantaslah kalo pendidikan bahasa Inggris kita ketinggalan, dari SD aja udah diajarin yang salah. Keterusan sampai dewasa taunya yang salah terus. Saya jadi merasa insecure sendiri, jangan-jangan selama ini bahasa Inggris saya salah di mata orang-orang yang bahasa ibunya bahasa Inggris :( Anyway, good video, Ms. Sacha :)))

[@gunungmerapiapi1933]

The low number of dislikes really shows how much support you have. We love you, Sacha 💕💕

[@Trippii]

I'm at student right now, currently sitting at grade 8, there's so many errors/mistake in my English book, if i ever tried to correct the grammar errors to my teacher or my friend they always says "This is a book made by professionals, you can't compete with them". Like c'mon, so i just follow how the book shows me lmao

[@rxineyy.movedchannels2566]

why you're? it's you*

[@chrisradja8690]

Ini maksudnya dia.. dia mau nunjukin bahwa dia lah korban hidup 😂😂

[@callmemaximillian7772]

Love the sarcasm, on point, 10/10, would watch again

[@bradleyokonma]

My teacher probably used this book cause her English is pretty bad, probably also the reason I have troubles with preposition, grammar and wording.

[@cylestyy]

yojimbo is that a jojo pfp?

[@bradleyokonma]

@@cylestyy maybe

[@rezza2507]

Terima kasih banyak Sacha Stevenson sudah mengoreksi LKS Bahasa Inggris SD/Mi. Semoga video" berikutnya bisa LKS B.Inggris SMP/MTs, SMA/MA/SMK

[@aureavita8653]

Im still in school and also interested in linguistics, so the fact that even the most basic information for english lessons are incorrect, shows that we have a long way to go from Ki Hajar Dewantara

[@mrsgrey2037]

Hye sacha, i'm one of your subscriber from Malaysia🇲🇾 I love your videos, it such a great and accessible explanation from you, i've learned a lot from your vlogs which eventually improving so much in my english. Would you probably make a video about Malaysian artist too? if you don't mind. I wanna know your point of view bout them, how fluent they are. I'll give you few names as your reference (Maya karin, Neelofa, Yuna, Faizal tahir and Yasmin hani). Hoping that you will considering my request. Sorry for my bad english writing, still learning. Looking forward to your next video. Have a great day ahead ❤ Much love from Malaysia 😘

[@faizyusuf2470]

She's a foreign living in indonesian, idk if she ever known some malaysian artist

[@mrsgrey2037]

@@faizyusuf2470 yes dear i know that. That's why i've already put a few names there to be her references..

[@hexaananda9909]

Agree! Stereo type orang Indonesia terhadap orang malaysia "oh orang malaysia bahasa Inggrisnya emang bagus" (terjadi juga untuk orang india) saya juga penasaran apakah mereka tidak melakukan kesalahan dalam daily conversation mereka? Saya jadi teringat kata "fighting" yang dimaksudkan untuk "semangat" tapi ternyata salah penggunaan dan pernah dibahas oleh sacha (atau mr.D saya lupa maaf😂). Kalo gak salah dalam English malaysia juga ada salah penggunaan kata, tapi saya lupa apa. Saya subscribe channel mereka seperti Lobak merah, World of buzz, says, dll

[@mrsgrey2037]

@@hexaananda9909 as far as i know the word 'fighting" is from korean-english word, it is actually hwaiting or paiting, correct me if i'm wrong. But still i agree with you, there's a lot of mistakes that we still do in english, especially me 😂...

[@rismadeco]

I hope English books for students aren't like that in Malaysia 😂

[@nurminidesyani6190]

Tell me about it. My nephew uses kurikulum 2006 English Book, I was literally outraged! The editor is S1 but I don't think the person understands English well!

[@IN4RICH4NKakyoin]

the students who owned this book should return it to the publisher of the book.

[@xfauzi]

Makasih udah berani share beginian, setidaknya dengan video kritik seperti ini, bisa membuat pendidikan di Indonesia semakin baik lagi.

[@AnnisaFatiha]

Saya adalah korban saat SMP juga d sekolah saya d wajibkan membeli buku LKS BAHASA INGGRIS, dan masalah penempatan IN, AT dan penggunaan THE saya pernah menjawab soal yg saya merasa sangat benar tapi di kaaih salah oleh guru saya karena tidak sesuai dengan kunci jawqban yg ada d buku LKS itu, sungguh menyedihkan saya harap pemerintah bisa melihat video ini dan lebih konsen untuk pendi bhaasa Inggris

[@cheaire]

I will literally lose my non-existent brain cells if I have this book-

[@cloudstrife3799]

9:20 Mindblowing... Maklum Sacha, banyak yang lulus sarjana hasil nyogok atau bayar orang buat bikinin skripsi.

[@sweettoxicity4980]

Lmao i would answer it with a correct grammar and my teacher would be mad at me because i didnt write it down the same as the options.

[@rezza2507]

Gelar akademik di buku LKS Bahasa Inggris itu : SS = Sarjana Sastra (Bachelor of Literature) M.Hum. = Magister Humaniora

[@mkthecat5133]

Videos like this make me realise how grateful I am to learn English from a proper course at an early age. I know that not everyone can afford a proper tutor to teach English to younger people (especially since most English courses in Indonesia is expensive as hell). But seeing the cheaper alternative in the form of that cursed book is why the majority of Indonesian students struggled with English.

[@fresh5261]

Instead of groceries, many local teacher taught them daily needs. This is what happened since I was in primary and still continue right now.

[@alberthartono5295]

Barangkali dikira sama dengan kata-kata , "give us today our daily bread.." Lalu, main tabrak saja...😂

[@JonhEdward]

kayak nya itu gara" di translate langsung dari bahasa indo ke inggris : daily = harian lalu needs = kebutuhan jdi mungkin arti nya menurutmereka mungkin kebutuhan harian tpi sayang nya bahasa inggris gak bisa gtu

[@hannekehartkoorn5987]

And the Indonesian is a literal translation of the Dutch 'dagelijks benodigdheden'.

[@kurniawan3686]

intinya kalo kata2 itu dah terngiang2 , kita bingung ini verb nya pas ga sih , terus apakah ini sudah berlalu , masa lampau , baru berjalan kah , ga heran sih sekolah internasional ya mahal sama sekolah negeri

[@GalluZ]

All Indonesian English books are basically legalized r/fellowkids.

[@pokefan69420]

Can confirm.

[@agbag8185]

Reddit bros

[@amandachairunnisa2165]

"Jangan-jangan ini sebabnya dari kecil diracuni..." 😂😂😂😂

[@cahidijoyoraharjo7833]

Tapi kayanya guru bahasa Inggris yang bener sih ga akan pake buku kacau begitu deh.

[@ninasakinah9882]

Saya suka video ini. Saya akan share. Terimakasih banyak bu Stevenson. Jangan takut bila nanti kamu dikecam karena kamu telah memberitahukan yang benar. Demi pendidikan di Indonesia yang lebih baik. Sekali lagi terimakasih

[@newrisingdamned7604]

even tho its bad they teach this on english class. This actually can be something of indonesian's singlish. buy the daily needs is a direct translation of Membeli kebutuhan sehari hari, so as well as the many other mistakes.

[@theycallmeCHICO]

Sachaaa udh bikin tour rumah yg ini belom siiiih. Bikin dong sachaaaa

[@aken_yudoyo]

up

[@indonesiaaustralia2032]

Let’s ask The Ministry of education of Indonesia, why this is happening?

[@kadekagusambara2212]

He's not on any social media. I'm eager to share this to him.

[@softbleep2020]

Me: mom can i learn english? Mom: we can learn english at home English at home:

[@nurulchannel3731]

lelucon dengan referensi video ini a : where are you ? b : in the way a : ok.. wait, what??? get it gak euy ?

[@melnovt5042]

Contentnya bagus banget Sacha. Ada value nya. Bikin yang banyak ya yang kayak gini. Yang diajarkan di sekolah sama yang casual / native emang beda banget...