Billlie has very heavy lore, they have short films for every album that explain a bit of their storyline. You were actually able to pick up on some of it from the lyrics! Billlie Love is a character in their lore who went missing, she was friends with the rest of the girls and it is heavily implied that they are responsible for her disappearance. They definitely have a creepy/unsettling vibe and it’s super unique
@Brickerbrack9 ай бұрын
Or at least that they may have been able to _prevent_ her disappearance, but didn't and then lied about it...
@dhubu_dhubu9 ай бұрын
I've been meaning to get into them, now your explanation got me hooked, thanks!
@BillliesHouse5 ай бұрын
If anyone wants to go and look more into billlie and their lore I have it all organised on this channel as playlists
@neodxlso9 ай бұрын
BILLLIE??? OMG I NEVER THOUGHT ID SEE THE DAYY BELIEVE’VE (billlie fandom) WE WON. THANK YOU CAITLIN🤍🤍🤍
@neodxlso9 ай бұрын
they creepiness you kept mentioning is because their lore! long story short the 7 of them were friends with this girl named “billlie” but one day she disappeared so they’re on a mission to figure out what happened but none of them were there when she disappeared so we don’t know who’s point of view is actually correct
@danaslitlist19 ай бұрын
Okay Pretty Little Liars energy LOL i didn't know they had this lore as a casual listener so this is so cool!!
@ArdenAdams21259 ай бұрын
GingaMingaYO is one of my most played songs on Spotify, along with their bside Flip A Coin. They’re a really cool group!
@BlueMooMoo969 ай бұрын
Flip A Coin is a masterpiece 👌
@evepalace9 ай бұрын
Thank you for reacting to Billlie, I'm glad you liked them! Their bsides are amazing, definitely worth checking out. Also the music at 25:42 is part of their own OST, they have 2 gorgeous albums with soundtrack music that I really recommend listening to in your own time
@fromiizone9 ай бұрын
The only title track left is "Ring Ma Bell" along with their christmas single "Snowy Night". Billlie bsides are freakin insane!! They have put out some of the best bsides I have heard so far in all of their albums. Their general sound is kinda red velvet/f(x)-ish.
@exoneusvtan81739 ай бұрын
I can always count on you for a random group marathon out of nowhere.
@caitlinbensonn9 ай бұрын
HAHA 💕
@larissafleming54019 ай бұрын
To me, Ring X Ring is one of the best debuts in kpop! I love that song so so so much!
@RSkies9 ай бұрын
Billie, to me, is Red Velvet's little sister in terms of being creepy cute, fun concepts and serving VOCALS. I really hope 2024 is great to the girls, they deserve so much success!
@CarlosSM22109 ай бұрын
Indeed they are, I'm not saying is the reason, but I can see some of that SM spice in them since Mystic Story is a subsidiary of SM and both have been making projects together with their artists, and do share some producers.
@laur79106 ай бұрын
yess! theyre very similar to RV
@animalgirl379 ай бұрын
GingaMingaYo is soooo iconic for them. They gained a ton of fans in that era thanks to Tsuki’s viral fancam (she is the 4/5th gen facial expressions queen). I really hope you can react to their second comeback ‘RING ma Bell’ 😊 also their whole discography is super rich in harmonies and melodies like they are such a unique group with a strong identity. They also have the most complex lore I’ve ever hear of and I still don’t know what’s going on there..but they really commit to it which is fun!!
@toledo_campos9 ай бұрын
Billlie is SO solid musically. Every release has no skips, like for real, not because I liked them. They remind people to Red Velvet (and I get that because quality B-sides mixed with fun Kpop concepts) but I think they go beyond, because of the lore and the commitment to having a coherent vision. Billlie isn't a group that changes in every comeback, but also they managed to keep things interesting, intriguing and weird, being fun in the process. Thank you for doing this marathon, and hope you can grab their content in the future, specially for you to catch the lore and that creepiness, but this is already amazing and love your way of reacting to this group and their antics. You open-mindedness shows clearly. Love to y'all.
@trampysdani93779 ай бұрын
omg yess I've been hoping you'll get to them. You should DEFINITELY get into their b-sides when you have the time. Most of their b-sides are genuine masterpieces. I'd def recommend starting with the billage of perception albums, chapter 1 and 3 are incredible. Thank you so much for the surprise lol
@yukiotsutsumi9 ай бұрын
YES! nevertheless and enchanted night are like top 5 music in general this year
@trampysdani93779 ай бұрын
@@yukiotsutsumi yesss omg
@diordino9 ай бұрын
EXACLY!! i love billlie and they're one of my favourite 4th gen groups because of their discography. Personally, my favourite bsides are Believe and Brave~ A song for Matilda
@E.Bashmak9 ай бұрын
Personally 2nd is my favourite in terms of b-sides. So I would reccomend all 3 chapters.
@yassir47809 ай бұрын
@@yukiotsutsumidefinitely! These two are SO GOOD!!
@erikah8439 ай бұрын
Since fans never mention this- Mystic is known as the artist label aka non idol performers. Billie is essentially backed by in-house musicians/artists and producers. I just think it's a cool fact because it's the reason they were able to bless us with a full on rock song with live instruments.
@kalindabittner9 ай бұрын
Ring x Ring being their DEBUT SONG is CRAZY, it's really different but it sets up their larger sound really well. You can see the growth in their production, but you're right they've always kept a creepy undertone with experimental/chromatic elements, and I find it gives every genre and concept that they cover a lot of depth. And you're right about these songs being hard to sing, but they do it flawlessly; their live vocals are top tier. And I love their rap line, their dances are so cool, it's all so good!? I was reminded rewatching these videos with you just how much I love Billlie and their whole concept 🥲❤ really glad you liked it! There's one more title track you haven't seen, and then some sick b-sides that you might like checking out, but yeah we know you're super busy so whatever/whenever! Thanks for checking them out!!!
@valentine78729 ай бұрын
i absolutely LOVE how Billlie is more sm than sm itself 😀 Mystic Story is under sm and it shows in every Billlie music choices. i hope you heard it too thank you for that reaction stan Billlie everyone
@leahn90159 ай бұрын
im so glad you checked out billlie! They’re super underrated and going through a lot right now with 2 members on hiatus so I really hope more people can get into them during this difficult period
@tninotmaru8 ай бұрын
YES!!! BILLLIE MY LOVE!💜💙 they are such a talented group with an AMAZING sound, I don't think I'll ever get bored with what they come up with. Delicious music, paired with incredible vocals, plus everything going on with the MV's (the props??? The makeup and outfits??? THE LOCATIONS? LIGHTING??? THE VIDEO EDITING??????!!! HELLO???) and the way The Lore is being handled. They are such a unique group.
@steffengoelitz9 ай бұрын
Billlie gets a thumbs up! 👍 I'm here for part 2 with more of thier MVs (Patbingsu, Ring My Bell, Snowy Night & BYOB).
@odgykins9 ай бұрын
Pardon my French but NO FXXXXXX WAY!!!!!!!!!! Caitlin I got CHILLS when I saw you uploaded this. Billlie are my ult girl group and you are my ult reactor haha! I LOVE YOU SM FOR THIS!!! Okay imma watch the video now! Lol
@caitlinbensonn9 ай бұрын
STOP YOU’RE SO SWEET! 😭 - hope you enjoyed! 💕
@mybilllie3 ай бұрын
girl you need to continue reacting to billlie once you’re able to. the B in Billlie stands for b-side so TRUST when i say they’re amazing! not to mention, they have music videos for ring ma bell, snowy night, patbingsu, byob and butterfly effect and i think you’ll love them just as much! truly so good and the girls are so very sweet, funny and talented!!
@joysbestie259 ай бұрын
Thank you for watching Billlie!!! They are truly one of a kind group. They are usually 7 but two (Moon Sua and Suhyeon) are taking breaks for their own personal reasons. They really are an amazing group with an incredible discography and even more incredible girls. Their personalities all shine so bright. Each member has a very long history going from pre debut to now. It really means a lot to see more people finding out about them. Theyre the best!
@RoseAllDayyy9 ай бұрын
BILLLIE! Their songs are fantastic and their lore is creepy/mysterious (it seems that their friend Billlie went missing when they were younger, and they are trying to find her.. except they can’t remember much and could be involved..). There is a lot of symbolism in their MVs and lyrics (some of which you picked up on!). The piano intro for GingaMingaYo is the melody from their B side “a sign”. I feel like Billlie are spiritually the little sisters of Red Velvet… vocals are top tier, songs are diverse, MVs are quirky and creepy.
@innerdances9 ай бұрын
hihi so giving a lil backstory here about the member changes!! they originally debut with 6 members with the song ring x ring, then sheon was added in the gingamingayo era (which is why gingamingayo has 7 members) lastly, in the dang era 2 of the original members (moon sua and suhyun) went on hiatus due to mental and health reasons respectively. hence why there only are 5 members in the last comeback. (byob & dang)
@gloriamanggalagita52379 ай бұрын
sheon was added just a week after billlie debut with ring x ring.. sheon officially show up in snowy night MV (winter song, before gingamingayo era) :)
@innerdances9 ай бұрын
@@gloriamanggalagita5237 thanks for the clarification 💞💞
@michaelar21889 ай бұрын
I know people hate comparing groups for some reason, but I’m gonna say this. I get mad red velvet vibes from them, and this is coming from a die hard revluv. They’ve got vocals, the vocal layering, the slight creepiness, the switch up of concepts. I say the same thing about nmixx too. Those two 4th gen ggs really have that “weird” vibe I love as a revluv
@sameerakhan74559 ай бұрын
No I DEFINITELY agree. Like, it makes sense that their music has SME vibes as the company is a subsidiary of SME but the red velvet vibes are incredibly strong so I agree with all your reasons. The lore, the creepiness and especially the vocals. Idk but Haram's voice ESPECIALLY feels SM like if that makes sense and she's quickly becoming one of my favourite vocalists.
@adiamadino99879 ай бұрын
Yes definitely cos billlie is their daughter 😁
@jime6089 ай бұрын
Comparing a group to rv is compliment and billlie is the best example
@jesclle9 ай бұрын
billlie are such a treasure
@vepm9 ай бұрын
If i could marry a song, i would like to marry Everybody's got a $ecret from Billlie. You SHOULD check out their B-side. Funfact: Mystic Story is a subsidiary from SM ent. so basically ÆSPA and Billlie are sister, also Red velvet. Not to mention that almost all of Billlie's song has this Red Velvet's eerie, weird atsmosphere.
@_Eunoia_9 ай бұрын
Billlie's albums are SO good, like they're one of the few groups with unskippable b-sides. I really recommend checking out their other songs! :) Also they released a single "Snowy Night" (it has a cute Christmas/winter themed MV) in winter 2021 and it's SO GOOD, I really recommend giving it a watch! It has some slow jazz vibes, and the harmonies are beautiful. And their summer single "Patbingsu" is an absolute BOP. 💜
@loren14509 ай бұрын
oh you NEED to check out their bsides, they're insane
@victoriab989 ай бұрын
ringxring is my favorite billlie title track! i love how experimental it is
@HPDDJ9 ай бұрын
Ohhhh the b-sides are so good, I would love to see you check them out! Some other MV's you could check out: Snowy Night Patbingsu Ring MA Bell BYOB
@chillzbanana33529 ай бұрын
YASS WE STAN BILLLIE AND CAITLIN!!!
@de68a9 ай бұрын
Many thanks for this Billlie Marathon !! Pog!! Such a wonderful group - true kpop hardworkers with all the right songs, lore, concepts, visuals and company behind them. They deserve so much more success and recognition. Tsuki (aka Taru from Magicour) is one of the most visual idols with such a cute happy character - and is friends with NingNing!! (Btw, Tsuki is absolutely stunning in real life!!) All thoughts with MoonSua and Suhyeon - hope they return soon!!
@gabrielacastillo81259 ай бұрын
I had missed the notification for this one 😭 I really love Billlie, have been their fan almost since debut and they never disappoint me, they are so talented and hardworking, I am so happy you did this reaction 🥺💙 Thank you
@lotuspie9 ай бұрын
Oh my god my fav yt reactor is listening to my ULTS??? thank you so much Caitlin 😭😭😭🫶🫶🫶
@natashajade83399 ай бұрын
oh my god i am so happy you reacted to billlie they are my favourite girl group, i am so happy you liked them.
@pabloacostarios11999 ай бұрын
YAAAAAAAS I LOVE BILLLIE AND I LOVE YOU ❤
@benji11709 ай бұрын
Thank you so muchh for reacting to them! If you want to check out more of their stuff, theres another title track called “RING ma Bell” which is one of my favorite song from them! Theres also “BYOB” which is a cute relax song that i really enjoy! Billlie are known to have some of THE BEST B-SIDES OUT THEREEEE. I’d recommend their b-side “flipp!ng a coin” which has a performance mv, theres also “enchanted night” with dance performance!! Keep up the good work im literally OBSSESSED with your vidssss❤❤❤
@samy_from_Neverland9 ай бұрын
i. dude fell in love with them EUNOIA IS SOTY
@earthcitty9 ай бұрын
Oh my GOSH!!! A Billlie reaction!?!?! Caitlin, THANK YOU! Billlie is one of my secondary groups behind Red Velvet.
@prstnluvr9 ай бұрын
I SCREAMED WHEN I SAW THIS
@tylerfrogman9 ай бұрын
WAS NOTTT EXPECTING THIS ONE BUT IM EXCITED
@ShortNeckedAlpaca9 ай бұрын
what a nice surprise! Billlie is such a unique group. I dont' stan them (just bc I haven't give myself the time to check out more of their stuff) but their music and concepts are so cool and have so much variety! RingxRing is one of the coolest kpop songs I've ever heard, my jaw was on the floor the first time I listened to it and I still get chills every time it comes on. Also, totally understand if you didn't catch it because the songs were overwhelming lol but they're from Mystic Story company, so that means that they're Lucy's label mates!
@Ookirarin98oO9 ай бұрын
Caitlin I need you to look into their lore and b-sides RingxRing is about the lost of billie love and the starting point of everything is really interesting
@mool34749 ай бұрын
i was so obsessed with gingamingayo, i love billlie's style!!! glad you reacted to them :)
@narrativebynay9 ай бұрын
omg i never thought you'd react to billlie!!! as huge fans of both red velvet and billlie, i genuinely believe their discography is the closest to red velvet's out of all the 4th gen girl groups today. hope you continue your billlie journey! looking forward to it
@Misss_Em9 ай бұрын
Billlie is my top girl group ever just after them honestly the bsides are just as good
@swanderfool9 ай бұрын
aah thank you for reacting to Billlie! Hope you could catch up with the rest MVs and maybe check out on their storyline films as well! theyre indeed (creepily) attractive!!
@hopeworldian18999 ай бұрын
Billlie very quickly shot up to my top three girl groups when i discovered them. RING X RING and Gingamingayo are two of my favorite kpop songs like... ever. Their sound is soooo unique! I'm glad you like them!
@kiwisensei20319 ай бұрын
You should have watched Ring Ma bell, it just so rock code and it sounds more like their b-sides
@bbewps9 ай бұрын
I hope you'll listen to “Snowy Night” this Christmas.😊
@overloadfl9 ай бұрын
You actually missed one more of their title track called "RING Ma Bell" you should check it out! their bsides are also amazing!
@akoyaahime9 ай бұрын
omg thank you so much for reacting to BILLLIE! They are AMAZINGGGG! RINGXRING is my fav kpop song ever ngl. A lot of ppl don't like it that much, which i understand since the sound is very unique and kinda overwhelming if you are not used to that kind of sound, but it has a lot of jpop elements that for me were very familiar but mixed with kpop elements aswell so it tingled all the right spots in my brain haha also, elements from japanese math rock in the instrumental??? HEAVENNNNNN. And creepy nostalgia on top of that??? hell yeah. I support them ever since! Hope they get the recognition they deserve soon enough :) they have some of the best live vocals out there aswell and are INCREDIBLE performers!
@livi-hj1gw9 ай бұрын
For your information so you know, they debuted with 6 members and they added suyeon in gingamingayo and they are 7, but this year 2 members went hiatus for health problems (Moon sua and Suhyeon) and they have released some songs as 5 members
@leocookie99089 ай бұрын
I NEEDED THIS SO BAD BRO
@sha25969 ай бұрын
Your order of listening threw you off which was funny. I lold when you said they were easy listening, I was like, wait until she hears RMB, RxR, and Gingamingayo. Billlie is an awesome little gem. So glad you gave them a listen, but girls can DANCE! You should see their dance covers, and Bsides, I have all their albums and they are all amazing!❤
@sundewwalker94109 ай бұрын
I've been hoping to see you react to Billlie for forever! Thank you QUEEN!
@ateezs88839 ай бұрын
GingaMingaYo is so addicting ❤
@ND-kh5yw9 ай бұрын
Love you picking up on the creepiness even from their least creepy mvs! Their concept strong Love your reactions dude thanks for the bit of happiness
@yoqueen93669 ай бұрын
Their albums are all incredible, the bsides are some of the best in kpop
@wemakeskzstay03259 ай бұрын
OMG BILLLIE MY LOVESSSSS
@aisyahsofea1929 ай бұрын
you need to watch the iconic tsuki "gingamingayo" fancam
@jrgonzalez839 ай бұрын
Was going to recommend this also, it blew up and went crazy viral
@audrepoison5669 ай бұрын
YASS THEY'RE TECHNICALLY SM!
@AverageB-side9 ай бұрын
Yeeeeeeessssss! Billlie deserves nothing but love! I am so so so glad to see anyone check them out but especially for you to check them out. Edited to add: yes they are a little creepy but in the best way. The Billlie lore is deep and so good.
@kitsune_jean9 ай бұрын
thank you very much for reacting to billie, I love this group 😭💙
@fonchee9 ай бұрын
as a huge stay, i'm also a fan of this group because they're one of the groups that has really good sidetracks, i recommend you to try listening to these songs, i bet you like them as i do - flipping a coin - the rumor - a sign anonymous - nevertheless especially a whole album of Chapter 2 (i don't quite like the title song of this album but sidetracks are all sooo good
@tarumisuu9 ай бұрын
i LOVE your reactions so much , as for what happened in the end of eunoia mv you need to watch the trailer released before every song they have a story and each song is connected to it its so good
@minhanhhh2559 ай бұрын
omg billlie!! i'm so happy you're reacting to them thank you so much! their discography is so good, the title tracks are always different and unexpected, and the bsides are garanteed to be incredible in every album
@TheMusicBoxMashups9 ай бұрын
Please listen to their b-sides. I don't even stan them but I've been a casual listener since their debut. Recommendations: flipping a coin, everybody's got a secret, brave (a song for matilda), nevertheless, enchanted night, a sign (anonymous), overlap, my B = birth of emotion
@kookumi51399 ай бұрын
OMG YAYYYYYYYY BILLLIE
@astrotuffin9 ай бұрын
I literally just started diving into (and having on repeat) Billlie last week! SO glad to see this marathon reaction to them from my reactor!
@bbyong39 ай бұрын
billlie is actually my ult gg so I’m so so so happy you reacted to them and enjoyed the songs 😭😭 their whole discography is so amazing and i listen to all of it whenever i can, which is pretty rare for me when it comes to other groups. thank u so much for the video caitlin!!! and since we’re in the holiday season, I’d rlly recommend listening to everybody’s got a secret and snowy night on your own time if you’d like to!! both are christmasy songs w very different vibes lol
@callmeak219 ай бұрын
YES YES YES YES
@bbewps9 ай бұрын
I would like to recommend another song, Ring ma bell. This song is very good.🥰🥰
@s272899 ай бұрын
tbh I think you would like their bsides a lot! eunoia the second video you reacted too has a small film called white night which goes along with it :) lso the lore is like heavy in the bsides too which is super cool and just some small things they're seven members, hocus pocus has 5 of them, and doesn't technically follow the lore, since two members are on hiatus right now, and ring x ring is actually their debut song!, and they introduced their seventh member in gingamingayo, and their company is actually a subsidiary of sm and they're all really talented girls I hope you'll get to check out more of their stuff
@Vernonye9 ай бұрын
Never thought I’d see Billlie on your channel! Thank you so much for checking them!
@jinamzbykt73229 ай бұрын
Thanks for reaction billlie. 🥰💙💜
@maliablossom73409 ай бұрын
Omg I never would have guessed you would react to billlie but I’m so glad you did. Their production is immaculate and they are so versatile. Literally none of their songs are like the other. They are probably in my top favorite fourth gen gg. Ring my Bell is my favorite title track but if you love their title tracks their b songs are top tier
@aespicysone9 ай бұрын
EUNOIA is my fav track from them
@yiren_zz9 ай бұрын
OMG YES IM SO HAPPY WHATTTTT, i hope she will react to patbingsu,ring ma bell,byob and snowy night
@ivanbraidi7 ай бұрын
Billlie are just too good. You definitely have to check Enchanted Nights and Flipping a Coin. You won't regret it. ;)
@hrc48859 ай бұрын
When it comes to billlie u gotta check out the b-sides it's REALLLY GOOD
@BlueMooMoo969 ай бұрын
Thank you for reacting to Billlie. They're such an underrated group in my opinion. My favorite songs are Flip a coin and Ring Ma Bell. Btw, one of the rappers is Moonsua. Her brother was Moonbin from Astro. He was her idol ❤
@Temo20249 ай бұрын
OMGGG YESS I LOVE BILLLIE ❤
@AznIntegra5214 ай бұрын
I’m a Billlie pre debut stan but they have a complicated lore and its deep. Also i mean no disrespect to other girl groups in the 4th gen era but Billlie is THE best dancing girl group out of the 4th gen era. I say this coz they trained by 1 million dance studios, they can do very hard ridge choreography with ease. Basically boy group style choreography and still not b tired. Also billlie has 2 main rappers, 2 main vocalist, and 2 main dancers. To put it simply, Billlie thats refer to in their lore is a girl that the 7 girls made friends with and is basically the 8th member to their group so to speak. One day billlie disappeared without a trace and somehow the girls are responsible for it which is y u see police sirens at the end of eunoia. There is more to this lore that we really cant comprehend but thats the basic version of it
@pluvio41419 ай бұрын
Loved this video! So happy you checked out one of my favorite groups!!! Hope you’ll do a part two🫶🏻♥️
@hyejinn6719 ай бұрын
Omggg love it... Thank you ❤
@Ookirarin98oO9 ай бұрын
OMG YOU'RE REACTING TO MY GIRLS IM SO HAPPY
@MarioFragile9 ай бұрын
i love billlie so much
@puffyping9 ай бұрын
this reminded me how iconic gingamingayo is, omg
@benji11709 ай бұрын
YESSSS OMGG MY FAVORITE KZbinR REACTING TO MY FAVORITE GROUPPPPP YES❤❤❤❤❤
@headofema9 ай бұрын
omg yay!!! billlie appreciation
@blueraspberry70069 ай бұрын
Yess Billlie!!! If you ever react to them again you should really react to snowy night! Its fitting since its very christmas.
@laur3nbee9 ай бұрын
if you were to check out more, i'd recommend ring ma bell (the only title track missing from this video), snowy night & patbingsu (special single album releases, one christmas vibes and one summer vibes) and flipping a coin (my favourite bside - from their debut album and it has a performance video!)
@dayjimong9 ай бұрын
i really love ringxring and gingamingayo so much. top song for me along byob and ring ma bell
@Vanellustrades9 ай бұрын
LETS GOOO Billlie time!!!
@bee97409 ай бұрын
OMG I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONEEEE
@iluvstatz8 ай бұрын
Hey Caitlin, i think you should do a Billlie guide. But it’s your choice if you want.
@101fayee9 ай бұрын
check out their lore even on your own time or for a vid (when u have time ofc) it’s amazing
@phiiesh9 ай бұрын
I DID A DOUBLE TAKE I LOVE BILLLIE GIRLS
@Gabb29129 ай бұрын
OMG??! I started to listen to their whole discography literally yesterday😭😭 I'm so shocked