Caller gets PUMMELED on Mosaic authorship, slavery, god's justice, and more.

[@alexissmith5589]

Justin is the epitome of "the best cure for Christianity is reading the Bible."

[@petermuninyi718]

Sadly not, they read it and only see what they've been taught to see (exegesis) I've been there and getting out wasn't as straightforward as one may imagine. The process of disillusionment is very painful but ultimately refreshing

[@hibbo1351]

I've correctly prophesied the non-return of Jesus for 45 years straight without fail.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Hail Hibbo 🙌

[@hibbo1351]

@Deconstruction_Zone :) no donations necessary. Nor will I threaten you with eternal damnation.

[@hibbo1351]

@Deconstruction_Zone maybe one day you can touch on Exodus 4:24-26. So many questions..... Why did God want Moses dead? What did the foreskin do to calm Yahweh down? Did her son hold a grudge? Did Isaac hold a grudge? (Off topic)

[@Yossarian.]

I've been doing it for 54 years. Get of my band wagon you false prophet!

[@Kellie08]

I’ve been doing it 9 years longer than you.

[@adamhunter5766]

Cognitive dissonance is a helluva drug

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

😆😆😆

[@_Siloam_]

Jesus Christ is the true cure to depression 😊❤ Romans 10:9-10 “If you declare with your mouth, “Jesus is Lord,” and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For it is with your heart that you believe and are justified, and it is with your mouth that you profess your faith and are saved.” 😊👍

[@adamhunter5766]

@@_Siloam_ Your Jesus is a failed prophet Deuteronomy 18:22 [22] If a prophet speaks in the name of the Lord but the thing does not take place or prove true, it is a word that the Lord has not spoken. The prophet has spoken it presumptuously; do not be frightened by it.

[@adamhunter5766]

@_Siloam_ in case you don't know I'm talking about Matthew 24:34-35 NRSV [34] Truly I tell you, this generation will not pass away until all these things have taken place. [35] Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will not pass away.

[@_Siloam_]

@@adamhunter5766 Matthew 24:1-8” Jesus left the temple and was walking away when his disciples came up to him to call his attention to its buildings. 2 “Do you see all these things?” he asked. “Truly I tell you, not one stone here will be left on another; every one will be thrown down.” 3 As Jesus was sitting on the Mount of Olives, the disciples came to him privately. “Tell us,” they said, “when will this happen, and what will be the sign of your coming and of the end of the age?” 4 Jesus answered: “Watch out that no one deceives you. 5 For many will come in my name, claiming, ‘I am the Messiah,’ and will deceive many. 6 You will hear of wars and rumors of wars, but see to it that you are not alarmed. Such things must happen, but the end is still to come. 7 Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom. There will be famines and earthquakes in various places. 8 All these are the beginning of birth pains. These things have happened (such as the destruction of the Second Jewish Temple), World War 1, and World War 2, and rumors of World War 3. Jesus loves you my friend; come to Him and you will see true light! 😄 Why do you continue living in hate? 😔

[@markhaunert5029]

I've seen 1000s of atheist/ religious debates. You are truly impressive Justin. Thank you from a new sub for sure.

[@Only-c6f]

Jesus is foretold in prophecies and seen Rising again. Vast majority of top atheist and agnostic scholars affirm that the Apostles and many others did see Him physically risen after 3 days. The only excuse you can give like them are impractical hypothesis like a mass mutual hallucination which is a joke, or some other bugged out hypothesis. So yeah everyone's Bowing. Get ready.

[@Yossarian.]

​@Only-c6f Where do you get the notion that anyone can confirm that anyone else at that time saw the risen jesus?

[@Yossarian.]

​@@Only-c6f As far as I know it was only Paul who claimed to have physically seen jesus. Is that not the case.

[@markhaunert5029]

@Yossarian. I know right. Just look at the nonsense being read today that's totally false yet we're supposed to believe things from illiterate, uneducated, gullible people from ancient times.

@@Yossarian. Paul didn't claim to physically see Jesus. He claims he had a vision.

[@mikerobbins298]

I watched one video.... instant subscriber! You're a MACHINE, Justin!! Brilliant work!! Keep it up!

[@Kellie08]

A better question would be “Would you trust a surgeon whose education was 99% false”.

[@INSOLIASTUDIOS]

I find your disdain for ignorance refreshing

[@BossRedRanger]

The Autobiography of Malcom X was written by ALEX HALEY! What an idiot.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

God is not sending his best

[@jennifer60515]

@@Deconstruction_Zone😂😂😂

[@xxlionroarxxxxxxxx4438]

The dude is a Christian and that’s what they do is LIE !!

[@skimmingstone3energyrecords]

Our ancestors have a lot to answer for... Putting all this nonsense in people's minds.

[@davidarbogast37]

I wouldn't say that our ancestors need to answer for this as it seems only logical that primitive people would create primitive beliefs. The people that do have to answer though are those who actively promote it as true and then do everything within their power to impose it upon others as if it were true.

[@biashacker]

This caller is a very good example of why "The Handmaidens Tale," could be a real possibility in America.

[@rockymountainhomestead]

Man, you leftists just cannot help yourselves from drawing fanciful conclusions that are so ridiculous, only you believe them. You are no less hypocritical than the Christian right you hate so much

[@paulatiredofthisshit]

Especially now

[@frankhh24]

I can’t overstate the impact of these conversations. Systematically debunking every argument Christians present plants seeds for those listening that will (hopefully) help them deconstruct and deconvert in the future. It also provides a sense of confirmation and affirmation for those who are deconstructing, as well as for atheists. Extraordinary, transformative, faith-shifting-phenomenal. Please never, ever stop! 😂

[@PhilJones-j7x]

U do know urpathetic correct no wonder ur bald

[@mrJohnDesiderio]

Cooked to perfection . Nice sear , good smoke ring, slight pink in the center. Gordon Ramsay would be proud.

[@johnflesner8086]

Cheeky without being inpertinent.🤭

[@ruirodtube]

My first reading was “God Ramsey would be proud” 😂

[@chelseawales1090]

1:13:30 NOT PAYING THEM is one of the defining characteristics of slavery, David.

[@adreanqq7276]

Found this channel after your appearance on the line and I am very impressed by the conversations being had here.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Thank you friend!

[@vodking]

@@Deconstruction_Zone Wait, you were on the line? I need to see that, but more importantly, they need to get you on board full time!

[@Kellie08]

@@Deconstruction_ZoneWHAT? When were you on The Line? I need to find out how I missed that.

[@davehughson]

That was amazing. The things Christians say. Unbelievable.

[@Professor_Pink]

"Do you think that Moses said that 'Moses is the most humble man on earth'?" ".....[awkward pause].....yes." "You think the most humble man on earth brags about being the most humble man on earth?" ahhahhaa

[@pansepot1490]

humblebrag 😅

[@bobby9192]

I love imagining Moses in a MAGA hat saying “Everyone knows I’m the most humble man on earth, no one’s more humble than me, everyone knows it”

[@WhoThisMonkey]

​@@bobby9192 The US makes up 4.25% of the global population, please don't keep making it about your backwards political system. The rest of us are tired of it.

[@jennifer60515]

@@bobby9192 You know, he actually said that. The traitor, I mean. He said he was very humble. I can’t remember how he worded it, but it was hilarious.

[@AudunWangen]

​@@bobby9192The memes are limitless when you read the bible and actually understand what it says. I laughed so hard I almost fell off the sofa 😂

[@hyprlab]

"Without lies, Christianity dies." Best quote of the video!

[@JoyRBradford]

OMG! This guy is trying to justify a woman getting stoned to death for MAYBE not being a virgin! WTF is wrong with him?

[@amawordie7801]

Yep Unbelievable

[@Deris87]

Admittedly I've still got 20 minutes to go, so let's hope the caller doesn’t make liar out of me, but I do want to give him credit for one thing. Unlike 90% of theist callers, he didn't get hostile and start making personal attacks. He continued making bad, perhaps even knowingly dishonest arguments to assuage his cognitive dissonance, but he never lashed out. While that should be a low bar to clear, it's sadly not among believers and apologists. He took his lumps for over an hour with stoicism and basic decency, so honestly kudos to him for that.

[@somepublic]

They are always equally confident and unprepared.

[@johns1625]

And pubescent and congested

[@Kellie08]

It’s mind boggling. It’s like they are always the first Christian to ever call an atheist show. How do they not listen to the caller before them and how do they think they will not get the same biblical spanking? I will never understand this.

[@INSOLIASTUDIOS]

Wow fantastic job. Glad I found your channel:)

[@johannesbrahms9528]

The loudest part about this are the long-ass silences.

[@biscuitapocalypse5883]

"okay next!" I confidently proclaimed just before the bouncer's other fist shattered my nose.

[@chethanburre6016]

I know right?! The sheer arrogance while being owned.

[@tylertucker2608]

This was AWESOME ❤️!!

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Thank you friend!!

[@AnotherHomeChef]

I like the guy’s laugh every time he’s caught. They call that a “tell” in poker.

[@SaintD382]

Justin has been an eye-opener to me in so many ways, but one of my favorite gifts from Justin is the revelation that the New Testament writers were, in many cases, actually _lying._ Somehow I never made this connection before -- I guess I just thought they were deluded, or mistaken...and in some cases, maybe that's what was happening. But in other cases they were absolutely telling bald-faced lies, and they knew it. Understanding this fact has transformed my view of the New Testament writers.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Thank you watching friend. I still recall when I made this discovery. I was dismayed that so many people were willing to accept such poor exegetical work.

@@Deconstruction_Zone the miracles are a hint that the story might not be factual

[@melantheoszimurri9981]

Check out the book holy fable

[@janetfedeles3964]

God can do anything He wants is how I have come to realize rhat Christians interpret the Bible.

[@uncleanunicorn4571]

This is what christianity does. Mental gymnastics to escape contradiction and defend the indefensible.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Yup. It's their only defence

[@uncleanunicorn4571]

@@Deconstruction_Zone after you enslave the guest and his Virgin daughters, teach them critical thinking.

[@Kellie08]

If mental gymnastics was an Olympic sport all Christians would have gold medals.

[@Not_An_EV]

​@@Kellie08​​Nah, they'd have platinum because regular winners get gold, and as always, they'd want to be more special and unique than everyone else. 🤣🤣

[@tomahadel]

I'm sorry killing animals for food is murder

[@MacLaw3084]

Defending clearly unjust execution is madness.

[@cubsbaseball9]

The dishonesty of these people is stunning;

[@thinkcritically655]

The autobiography of Malcolm X was written by Alex Haley but is still written in the first person. The caller is a confused indoctrinated individual who has lost the ability to think.

[@Enkarashaddam]

Most of the time these pathetic rebuttals are constructed by one or a few mentally degenerate reprobates like Plantinga, Hovind and Comfort and disseminated widely. Plantinga is the worst to me because of his smug abuse of modal logic hiding behind a thin veneer of academia. These "intellectuals" neither understand nor read much of anything, much less Malcolm X. At most they know it was written by someone else so therefore it couldn't be first person. That's usually why all apologetics sound the same and why so many apologists don't understand the arguments they are making because they heard it from a source of a source.

[@chefpetey]

This caller has just enough knowledge to be dangerous 😊

[@williambeckett6336]

This caller revealed he's a monster for shrugging and saying "that's gods law" for executing innocent women. His level of excuse making is horrid and has no bottom.

[@rockymountainhomestead]

Same with every Christian who is faithful to the imaginary yahweh

[@donnyh3497]

Ouch! That was brutal. How could reasonably intelligent people actually believe that christianity garbage?

[@antediluvianatheist5262]

They don't. Those that have these beliefs are either ignorant, not reasonably intelligent, or carefully do not examine these beliefs.

[@Kellie08]

There is nothing reasonable, intelligent, logical or moral about believing in the Abrahamic religions.

[@andersandersen6295]

They are brainwashed and deeply invested in god, it takes a lot to admit how mistaken you are and leave it behind, most will rather lie and jump through endless hoops.

[@kidd32888]

Indoctrination

[@thetruest7497]

Painful

[@Kellie08]

I needed a morphine drip.

[@thetruest7497]

@Kellie08 those who have prolonged discussions with these people have the patience of a Saint.

[@shawnbradley3874]

That pay their slaves!!??? If they pay them, they're not slaves!!

[@Itsme-dn7cp]

I love that the caller can laugh numerous times good job breakin it down Justin!

[@lawrencemurray568]

I am very happy the algorithm served your channel up. Nice work and I'm subscribed. 👍

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Thank you friend 🫶

[@timandmonica]

He who has ears, let him hear. Your caller can hear, but he won't listen.

[@Kellie08]

He’s listening. That’s why he refuses to answer questions.

[@LordOfWisdom59]

I'm not an atheist, I'm a Norse Pagan, but I wanted to thank you regardless for the work you do dismantling christian dogma. We might not believe in the same things, I may believe in many gods while you believe in none, but christian dogma is just as much a threat to you as it is to me. Thank you for all you do.

[@michaelhenry1763]

Very cool. I enjoy reading Norse mythology.

[@exoplanet11]

Hail Sleipnir!

[@jaxnaturals]

The third problem with the sheet is that the woman is now forced to live with someone who doesn't want her. Surely, she was beaten mercilessly. Just horrible and disgusting

[@Pr0t0typeSky]

Imagine getting corrected for 45 minutes, and the person whose been correcting you tells you the bible says earth is flat. You with your whole chest say "It doesnt say that the Earth is flat, in Job it says that the Earth is a sphere"... As if person whose been correcting you accidently brought up the topic not knowing the arguments.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Yea, it's odd to me that they think I'm going to bring up talking points that I haven't researched 😂

[@porkyboy4226]

​@@Deconstruction_Zonewhy not? They clearly do!😂

[@Satans_lil_helper]

Searching for truth and morality in the Bible is like digging for a kernel of corn in a pile of 💩.

an imaginary kernel

[@michaelmccaffrey2731]

I'm only 18 minutes in and I'm amazed that this guy has as much knowledge as he does, and still didn't discover that the bible is a complete disaster

[@edwinortizestay398]

It's so painful listening to this caller.

[@user-pt1cz4ot1e]

“It’s the Lions and Texans…..nobody’s getting injured.” 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 I’m anti-theist, but part of me wants to root for this savage here. 😂 Edit: oof….😮‍💨 Justifying the execution of innocent women, huh? These fools will go along with ANYTHING!

[@chethanburre6016]

Did he just say that the British treated Indian slaves well?

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

I doubt the slaves would agree....

[@Professor_Pink]

"Alright, next?" So you were wrong about the preceding topic? Is that a tacit admission? Edit: Lmfao! And then, on the next point, he has no response once more and says "Next?" Oh, I love seeing people (theist or atheist alike) crushed by facts and rational analysis and the pure power of logic.

[@_Siloam_]

James 4:8 “Draw near to God and He will draw near to you. Cleanse your hands, you sinners; and purify your hearts, you double-minded.” Repent of your sins to God, my friend! ❤😊

[@Mxxx-ii9bu]

@_Siloam_ "Gott ist tot." Friedrich Nietzsche

[@Professor_Pink]

@@_Siloam_ I'll do that tonight if you just offer reasons for believing it is true today

[@OldWalkingCrow]

Gotta appreciate the symmetry of christian circular logic: God is real because bible, and bible is true because bible. It must be very comforting, so long as you don't think about it.

[@garygood6804]

Circular would be God is true because bible, Bible is true because of god.

[@Only-c6f]

Jesus is foretold in prophecies and seen Rising again. Vast majority of top atheist and agnostic scholars affirm that the Apostles and many others did see Him physically risen after 3 days. The only excuse you can give like them are impractical hypothesis like a mass mutual hallucination which is a joke, or some other bugged out hypothesis. So yeah everyone's Bowing. Get ready.

[@Yossarian.]

​@@Only-c6f No they don't.

The Bible is only "comforting" if you don't know what's in it.

[@Yossarian.]

It's also comforting if you can ignore the bad and embrace the good.

[@aidenmartin6674]

The caller repeatedly shows he has an inflexible mind where the Bible is concerned. He has his interpretation and making him understand a new interpretation is so difficult because he’s not listening. Like all theists his mind is closed shut. I’m really impressed with the biblical knowledge shown by the host.

[@rockymountainhomestead]

Justin, like all atheists I've ever encountered, are great at picking apart such low hanging fruit of disapproving the Bible. Yet when it comes to CAGW, immunization statistics and science, trans science, and similar topics... they operate EXACTLY the same way

[@NullHypatheist]

Need to update the age check to: "Are you at least 18? And would you choose to own slaves if you could?"

[@spankduncan1114]

It's odd how a book some believe is written by an all knowing being can get so many facts wrong. Cognitive dissonance is a beautiful thing to use for maintaining one's faith in believing impossible things.

[@javierordonez2445]

I will have to say I love this channel so much

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

🫶🫶

[@JasonHenderson]

50:21 "if the Bible said Jonah swallowed a whale I would still believe" this guy probably

[@Itsme-dn7cp]

Great discussion

[@GeoffreyElliott-sw3dv]

Great show guys!

[@darkmattersproject2951]

This is ridiculous. I thought he was going to come after you when he kept asking for your name. As an African American man these evangelicals are very scary. This is why I am a Buddhist

[@tomyossarian7681]

I am terrified. There are people like David all over the world. How many? How soon?

[@paulw9873]

So burning for eternity is not horrific - wow. This person says a lot of the same stuff as Mr Batman.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

A good creator would never create hell in the first place

[@Not_An_EV]

​@@Deconstruction_ZoneI mean people read the bible and somehow came to the conclusion that God is good so clearly logical and critical thinking isn't a skill they possess.

[@csadler]

1:12:47 I almost vomit when these people defend slavery and the beating to near death of their slaves. What immoral people they are.

[@Buttaman2218]

Dude is a dishonest hypocrite

[@necahi9764]

My new favorite channel.

[@scottbroadfoot3530]

Hopefully America will catch up with the civilised countries in the world and improve education to move away from these silly old religions.

[@EastSide-qc5oy]

I don’t have a lot of hope for that. Maybe a few years ago. Not so much anymore.

[@jennifer60515]

No, we are going back in time and it is actually getting worse right now. Christian nationalism is taking over and we will soon be a theocratic country. I don’t know how to prevent it, that seems to be the path we’re on.

[@ichsehsanders]

TheoCRAZY Incoming

[@anthonycraig274]

Just on the first 10 minutes I subscribed. I don’t even subscribe to the first 10 videos I like. I do love to see someone break down the fact in a systematic, logical way. Let’s see how the rest goes.

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Thank you!!

[@bodricthered]

I love the mental imagine of moses writing the narration for his own funeral and all the hideous, immoral stuff that happened after it, as though he's just there jotting it all down in a little tent, whistling away as he goes through the details of the mistakes hes6 going to make and all.... just what? Bonkers.

[@Taintedwings4444]

The question 'Is slavery ever okay?'. The only acceptable answer is: no.

[@jenniferbell6832]

Really enjoying this channel!

[@mickthebandit]

I have read the bible cover to cover (ok I skipped a bit, here and there) and I have no desire to waste months of my life reading it again. Justin, you are a hero ❤

[@atheist-thatsall]

Whew. I've heard countless people defend slavery, but they usually stop there. First time I've heard anyone be ok with being owned by someone else. But my two take aways from this are "that's adorable" and "yapping". I will be saying both of those. A lot.

[@project_nihilist]

Good stuff

[@New-z1x]

What a disgusting guest defending slavery wtf

[@pudderhon]

I like that this guy, the caller, actually had a sense of humor and could laugh at things

[@janicelemasters7614]

Your knowledge of the Bible is very impressive!

[@garygood6804]

Amazing how you learn when you read something. Wanna learn about the magical abortion potion in the bible?

[@HereForTheAdventure]

I’d like you to look into flat earth the way you’ve looked into Christianity. This isn’t a joke. You’re extremely intelligent and I would be curious what you’d find if you’d be willing to look into flat earth. Not from a Christian perspective (most Christians I know don’t believe in a flat earth.) Thank you for your willingness to be transparent and also examine everything in pursuit of truth.

[@Kellie08]

Why anyone would worship the creator of evil is beyond me.

[@patrickparker4576]

I lost it when you said "do you like sand?" 🤣 (then I subscribed, natch...)

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

😂😂 that was cold but I couldn't stop myself.

[@Jo-JoandTaffy]

You have to watch til the end where he confidently states, "I would own slaves."

[@kidslovesatan34]

Eww

[@smol-one]

Honestly... that's nothing compared to him saying he'd willingly be a slave.

[@rhondah1587]

Oh heck, Spiderman comics is at least 1% true. Does the caller believe in Spiderman?

[@Deconstruction_Zone]

Praise his mighty webs

[@dwaynehinton9729]

no one has to speak to the fact that dolly parton or benedict cumberbatch exist. if a god exists, it would need no one to argue for its existence.

[@shanehaddix8021]

I seen him the other day on axp and decided to check it out and he is now one of my favorite athiests. He absolutely crushes these callers

[@Nontheistatheist]

Nothing like secular bible reading. ❤❤❤

[@1tahliajaye]

They just regurgitate what they've been told. They don't actually look it up themselves.

[@chocofro3]

"Have you considered 'no'?" is so damn hilarious lol

[@nollattacykel]

Poor soul, I feel so sorry for him. Indoctrination is a powerful and dangerous drug.

[@MegaLoucon]

Sorry to disappoint the callers gods brother, but I am actually the most humble man there ever was or will be.

[@niblick616]

No. I am Spartacus.

[@litenedderkopp]

Was not expecting the surprise twist in this one.

[@scamchan]

"the tipping point" That would be GOD needing a book FULL STOP!!

[@JasonHenderson]

@@scamchan " what does God need with a starship"

[@scamchan]

@@JasonHenderson For his friends. Since GOD himself is everywhere.

[@JasonHenderson]

@@scamchan if he's all powerful he could teleport his friends wherever he wanted them to go. Or he could create infinite numbers of them to be everywhere all the time like he is. Or he could annihilate one version of a person and then create them instantly somewhere else with all their memories.

[@JoyRBradford]

I have been binge watching now and your knowledge of the Bible is impressive! You smoke these guys! 🚬

[@Ninthofnine1969]

Caller says it says what he wants... even though, or until it doesn't even say that!!! Even worse, nah that bits figurative metaphor even, after all, god moves in mysterious ways blah blah blah

[@BobLobLaw4545]

You got a sub my man! Love, love, love your content! Keep em coming

[@kevin933]

I really appreciate how you don't let these people get away with anything. You keep reeling them back to their dishonest bullshit claims when they quickly try to say stuff and move on as if it were fact, and their brains break.

[@SHOZOHIRONO480]

I believe Julius Caesar wrote in the third person for his war commentaries, not that it really matters

[@Enkarashaddam]

The ending of this literally blew my mind, like exploded my frontal cortex clear from my skull how shockingly evil this guy (the caller) is

[@rukusthelamiaslayer9510]

Ouch 😮

[@defenestratefalsehoods]

the Torah (1st 5 books) was written over 600 years after the Exodus story would have taken place. There is no evidence for any of the exodus story or Moses.

[@mikeowens2329]

As a young christian we were taught to throw out the "out of context" when we were shown faults in the bible.

[@raypalmerino7862]

If he was a woman he'd have a different Outlook. I guarantee it.

[@Jyotinanda108]

I'm neither Christian or atheist but if I was a Christian I'd be seriously questioning my faith after listening to these conversations

[@jonathanjrgensen6774]

50:10 "do you like sand?" Is diabolical

[@HypatiaK]

I would like to know WHY he wants to believe, not what, or if, he believes. Something is driving him to reject the most telling arguments against his belief.

[@Kellie08]

He wants to believe because his entire existence depends on it. He sounds like he’s probably between the age of 70-80. Imagine living for even 60 years and finding out everything you have ever believed was a lie. Imagine how devastated you’d be if you gave 10% of your entire income away for 50 years and you did that because you were lied to. They are also terrified of God. That’s another reason. They are afraid of going to hell which most of them believe is burning for all eternity.