Can The Government Grant a Legal Guarantee to the Minimum Support Price for Farmers? | UPSC GS3

[@StudyIQEducationLtd]

Use the code ‘ANKITLIVE’ to get Our Courses at a Maximum discount! Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3HQFpcJ For any queries please whatsapp on bit.ly/wame8952084937 UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation P2I 2025 February Batch : bit.ly/3HQFpcJ Batch Starting on 16th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3HQFpcJ UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February Hindi Batch 2 बैच 17 फरवरी 2024 से शुरू हो रहा है | बैच का समय शाम 6:00 बजे Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3IhXOQd UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February English Batch Batch Starting on 26th February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/47XLChH UPSC IAS Long Term P2I Foundation LIVE 2026 Batch 2 Batch Starting on 21st February 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3OGqnKH UPSC IAS Live SIP+ 2024 February Batch 2 Batch Starting on 16th February'2024 | Class Timing - 11:00 AM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/42zYYQh UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 6 Batch Started on 16th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/46nl6h4 UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw (PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature) Set of 18 - General Studies books Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/416mF1T

[@knightray7616]

That's why crop diversification is important.

[@hitakshiyadav1763]

To enhance nutritional food security and to protect soil fertility

[@GeneralFranky-b1o]

Thats what previous farm laws were . Under the previous farm laws the farmers were given more power to sell their produce to buyers who provides a better price. But they protested against it

[@TheD0D0_001]

असली मुद्दा सिर्फ विरोध करना है|

[@XauUsd.46]

India me 100rupees me log protest krne keliye ready hote 🤣

[@xoxoxoxoxooxo]

Tractor k nashe 😂

[@simransucharita5434]

​@@XauUsd.46 not only 100rs bro.. 1 bottle will make them do these things Punjabi hai to 2 bottle.. upar se Canada ka dollars not rupees 😂

[@zaar94631]

Tractor me diesel dalne ke liye, langar ke liye, tent ke liye inke pas bahut paise hain....

[@deepakpeaky]

Farm Laws were necessary. Because of some Andolanjeevi Kissan all the Real farmers of India are suffering.

[@niksaraf3055]

farmers have to decide

[@Rishabhh78]

farmers anpadh hain mostly aur behkawe mein aa jate hain, unhe sirf short term gain or loss dikhta hai, har koi apne niyam khud nahi banata, sarkar hoti isi liye hai @@niksaraf3055

[@tarunsaini9939]

​@@niksaraf3055govt ka kaam kya raha fir jab farmers hi decide krenge to

[@tarunsaini9939]

​@@niksaraf3055green revolution bhi aya kyuki govt ne policies implement ki thi na ki farmers ne decide kiya tha

[@Atish523]

They are not kisan, they are khalistani

[@sandipbiswas8550]

They should demand better infrastructure, cold storage chain facility, e-logistic, R&D for new seeds and fartilizers instead of free electricity or guaranteed MSP.....

[@RajuKoirala-np3qe]

This is only a way. Support farmers with R&D & produce more yield.

[@sandipbiswas8550]

@@RajuKoirala-np3qe But the sad reality is that our farmers stuck in MSP like a gramophone............ They aren't interested to discover new ways and increase their income..... They must demand for R&D , but sorry to say they only protest for politics.....

[@eternalshiv]

​@@sandipbiswas8550what is R&D ?

[@akhilsharma9271]

It is the responsibility of policymakers to provide them all kind of support , as our farmers are not that educated and aware at least govt should come forward on the table for dialogue and not act like monarchy

[@sandipbiswas8550]

@@akhilsharma9271 Did you know that every year Govt. Spend 2.5 lakh cr. Only in MSP....... How much agricultural Infrastructural development will be done by this..... Its true that our farmers are not educated but the people behind them are very educated...... Are you ever thinking that Why only Punjab and Haryana lead this protest..... Why not West Bengal or Bihar.....??? Bcz their situation is totally different.......

[@dibyendugoswami-l7r]

The processes mentioned in the video are one way or the other destructive for either party. If govt starts paying those prices out of pocket, then the national treasury will be affected, if the msp is strictly implemented, then we will have to pay nearly twice or thrice the price. This problem is never going to solve until the farmers make some cooperative like AMUL.

[@anik5579]

But rahul doesnt understand na😪

[@knowledge-21234]

Rahul understand very well he will do whatever soros will say​@@anik5579

[@chandrankarsukhwal888]

​@@knownfacts-pn6pu govt nhi banks write off karte hai corporate loans which are already at high interest rates 12%+ considering risks associated with failures none of the PSU banks are reporting loses. With high interest they can recover any potential losses on other loans which are NPA.

[@pipipupu5104]

​@@chandrankarsukhwal888 toh kyu write off karte hain itna loans yeh bhi batao na

[@aagneyaryan7786]

There can be many many alternatives possible if govt. Seriously starts working seriously instead of doing petty politics

[@pratiksingha251]

Fir log mehangai mehangai chillayenge... Akhir kre to kre kya... Sarkar to MSP lga degi fir rona to aam admi ko hi pdega 🤔🤔🤔

[@sandeeprout3324]

Mujhe thoda details me bata bhai actually baat hai kya msp se kisan ko kese fayda aur aam admi ko ghata kaise aur 2022 wala protest kya tha

[@tenacious_will]

A/C farmer withdrawn from WTO and Har kisan ko huge number me pension de. Agar WTO se hatgya to Exports karne me dikkat hogi aur WTO ke hote fixed MSP nhi la sakte nhi to WTO membership reject kar dega. And Itne logo farmers ke liye itna huge pension freebies ko hurt karega.

[@sandeeprout3324]

@@tenacious_will matlab kuch nahi kar sakte wto se rista toda toh export me problem par farmer khus aur farmer ki na suno toh woh protest karte hain kya kare

[@Rishika2004-y3q]

Even farmers will be harmed by this. They will get MSP for only those crops they will sell in the market but what about other crops which they consume? They will also become costly. They will get increased prices for 1-2 crops but they will have to bear the burden of high prices on every crop. It will be in no one's benefit

[@motiweson]

Kisan aam admi nhi hai?

[@prashantkv4]

Need to give Financial education to farmers so they can diversify their income streams and not depend only on conventional farming. Only Agriculture cannot give them high income. They need to do additional things along with it.

[@ArjunSingh-hb9ff]

Yes farmers needs to be well educated 😊

[@Hinduevents]

Acha hai AC mein bethke Gyan Dena. Mere Bhai jaise jameen rahegi waise hi kheti karni padti hai jo fasal hai woh jameen aur karibi market ke upar depend karta hai

[@anuragbanerjee2879]

Start processing food ... make it high value

[@nitishgautam4270]

@@Hinduevents to saari fasalo pr kyu mang rahe hai un pr hi lagao ji us region main max ugaati jaye

[@Rjvenu9911]

Most of them are already doing it. They have 2-3 other sources of income that's how they are surviving

[@Longhouse3321]

Cover the story of sandeshkhali in WB

[@Shubhamy1180]

He has already covered it

[@akashtiwari1292]

Matter jis din hota hai usi din Ankit sir cover krte hai 😂

[@theniravpanchal]

I stand with Govt and Farmers of All other states. These Punjabi farmers are owned by Unions they would do anything that unions say.

[@hbt253]

Kisano ko subsidy di jati hai, sanman nidhi bhi di jati hai, laon bhi maf kiye jate hai. Dhandha hum bhi karte hai aur hume koi support ya subsidy nahi, loan hum bhi lete hai kabhi humare loan maf nahi karta koi. Hum bhi sari chije including petrol, diesel market price pe hi buy karte hai. Krishi bhi business hai usme profit ki guarantee koi nahi de sakta. Kitne kisan IT bharte hai? Unke to pashupalan se leke aur bhi business, rojgari hoti hai. Humare tax ke paise free bees ke liye nahi!!

[@GrandDad_001]

​@@ATULBARKHEabe sarkar ke paas itna fund nhi h ki India ki sari crops kharid le. Sara pesa inko de Diya to fir highways, transport, schools etc. ke liye mat rona.

[@hbt253]

@@ATULBARKHE har khet ki fasal ek jaisi hoti hai? Kuchh bhi ugake MSP loge? Open market ki demand karo. Direct selling ki bat karo. Quality ke hisab se paise milenge. Kisi dhandhe me profit ki guarantee nahi hoti, MSP wali bat hi wahitat hai.

[@divyanshpatel9904]

​@@ATULBARKHEHa to tu jaake market me jab chawal kharidna to msp me kharidna ok 😂😂😂😂phir mat bolna mehngayi hai

[@hbt253]

@@GrandDad_001 bhai ye notanki hai. Kheti ke liye jo diya ja sakta hai wo dete hi hai. Aj ke kisan keval kheti pe nirbhar nahi wo swayam ya koi aur dusri income karta hi hai. Kitne kisan IT bharte hai ? IT na bharna pade is liye nakli kisan ban rahe hai paise wale bhi. Humare tax ke paise free bees me bantna sahi nahi. Pata hai road jam karke transport band karke kitna nukshan hota hai dusro ko.

[@shifujiyt9724]

​@@ATULBARKHE Bro the thing is MSP dena bhe issue nei he. But MSP ke naam pr tum ye expectations rakho ke koi nei to sarkar to karid he legi MSP price pe to ye bhe to galat he. N we all know how MSP will be manipulated by the force of andolan n protests

[@sktechz4071]

Radhe radhe ankit sirji 🙏

[@DilipKumar-tl9ut]

Radhe krishna ❤

[@DhirendraSingh-w4i]

Aandolan Desh ke liye sahi hai or galat bhi (if intension are wrong) I hope gov. Will resolve the problem.

[@shorts_editzz210]

We know that 90% people of Punjab and Haryana are not workers they are only landlords the people from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh go to Haryana and Punjab for agriculture so basically they are original. And we can see a link that when the elections are near they started for protest but what are they doing rest of the year.

[@shortstories433]

jab dange elections k time pr hote hn to protest bhi election k time pr hone chahiye

[@tom-sy3ol]

Msp is true issue

[@shortstories433]

@@NarkoPrani nahi dange vahi krvata h jo dharam ki rajneeti krta h

[@mukul9221]

Allah mkc ​@@shortstories433

[@shantivskranti6634]

Dange dharm pe hi nahi baki issues pe bhi hote hai (example -meitei/kuki ethnic conflict)

[@rohitdosti]

Demands by the farmers : (a) Monthly pension of 10k. (b) Govt to fully cover crop insurance costs. (c) India to withdraw from WTO, so that farmers can seek more subsidies. (d) Increase in import duties on food, forcing us to exclusively buy from our beloved farmers. (e) Inclusion of agriculture in MNREGA, entitling farmers to Rs 700 per day for 200 days a year for working in their own fields.

[@ashutoshpatel5030]

21000 monthly literally itna ko padh likh ke bhi nahi kamata 😂

[@sugandha6827]

Why are they even working and doing farming if they aren’t able to earn and everything Govt. And people of India bas to do. We all should shift to Self agriculture.

[@vijayvijaynsnbdbdbhxb]

Thank God Thailand trip ka ticket nahi manga

[@Justforfun55678]

Farmer ke liye respect khtm

[@Gurvinder4041]

Fool’s option (e) is for farmers so they can get labour because it is very to get labour to work on farms.

[@Fgygsh]

free culture

[@nm5269]

High income farmers should be Taxed

[@sahildeepsingh206]

TRUE BRO..... NOT ONLY THE LANDLESS LABOURERS SHOULD BE GIVEN THE TAX BENEFITS NOT THE WEALTHY LANDOWENRS

[@smitpatel9202]

High income dairy farmers should be taxed

[@cglaspirant813]

In punjab and hariyana FARMER does not want implantation of farmer law but in RAJASTHAN madhyapradesh middle up and many states want implementation of farmer law

[@nikhilverma2647]

Water, electricity, machine fuel sbme subsidy. Tax Dena nhi. Harr 2-3 saale loan waiver. Phirbhi or muft ki cheeze chaiye inhe. Import hi krao, sasta padega 😂 Land size or income of farmer k hisab se benefits and subsidy Dena chaiye. Ye to crorepati bane h big land farmers, or danga krte h. Or msp vale grains harr state se proportionally Lena chaiye, Punjab vale pagla gye h. And proportional aquisition k saath requirements pehle btana chaiye, itna lenge iss state se. Or itne ton TK hi msp milegi.

[@midphoenix]

Bhak wo pension bhi demand krr rhe hai

[@nikhilverma2647]

@@midphoenixhadh h, itna pehle se free me mil to rha h. Tax Dena nhi h pr pension chaiye. Waah !

[@dhh608]

​@@nikhilverma2647ye kuch bai hai bus dikat punjab k kissan ko he hai vo ese samjte hai ki bus kisaan vo he hai hakikat me kisan nai hai sare khalistani hai

[@shavy9300]

Govt should make a proper data of farmer and make categories finacial basis Strong economically farmer Small and marginaised farmer

[@mathsolutions8438]

This is not farmer protest. They are anti indian elements

[@vvk594]

Exactly Khalistan sponsored one.

[@logarhlandu2538]

acha

[@gamingwithlegendaryguys2519]

🤡

[@mrshahidk07]

The correct answer is Jowar. Jowar is the main food crop in semi-arid areas of central and southern India. Maharashtra alone produces more than half of the total jowar production of the country. It is both Kharif and Rabi crops in Southern India.

[@viraj9565]

Free ka paani bizli no tax subsidised fertilizer all facilities given to them now they are doing gundagardi

[@niksaraf3055]

r u talking about adoni or farmer

[@sagarshetty3175]

adani gets free water ? for what ? 😆 uneducated @@niksaraf3055

[@ritik5356]

@@niksaraf3055 chup kr bhediye

[@ajaysinghgusain8386]

ye apne papa adani or Ambani ke bare main bol raha hai

[@Kapil-pg9kd]

Har jagah adani Ambani hi karoge salo ​@@ajaysinghgusain8386

[@rajivmishra1309]

Increase the quality of the product and sell it outside the country!

[@Farming_lifestyle_official]

we support Indian farmers 🌾🌾🚜🚜 farmers protest in Delhi 🇮🇳 100+ farmers injured by police bullets 🤕🤕

[@Shiva-me1vz]

Maharashtra vidarbha Cotton kharacha 8000 per quintal.... Bhav mil rha hai 6000 per quintal...2000 rs loss per quintal 😢😢😢

[@प्रेम-ब8न]

जिनको लगता है कि ये केवल किसान है तो उन्हें बता दें कि किसान और भी राज्यो में रहते हैं केवल पंजाब में नहीं रहते हैं😂

[@goutamkumarporey9677]

Ekdam sahi baat hai...

[@hardjaat8620]

Kri h k kde kheti tene ... Jyada gyan na pele .. Phle kheti kr k dekh 2 saal phir boliye

[@divyanshpatel9904]

​​@@hardjaat8620tere se jada kheti ki hai smaja 😂?jaada Gyan mat de ..😂😂

[@manishnimbar]

*भारत के किसान है वो खालिस्तानी पंजाबी हरियाणवी नही वो भारतीय किसान है*

[@newchapteroflife78]

Wait dheere dheere sare bharat se videos aayegi Up haryana sb jagh hai but news m nhi dikhaya ja rha

[@rohiniahlawat1035]

I am from uttar pradesh ......................here I have seen that protest is from large farmers of haryana and punjab and not from small farmers small farmers are not protesting .........and if leader says they just repeat

[@shuvendudebnath5565]

Achha, 1 small farmar kitna kama lete hai pure sall farming karke?

[@NikhilSharma-tp9ut]

MSP dene se inflation 6% above chla jayega....koi beech ka rasta nikalna pdega

[@nitienvats8257]

Inflation is above 6% already, but hidden by faulty calculations done by government. They have employed all clever tactics to juggle the statistics

[@Abhinav_Karniwal]

@@nitienvats8257 so you want to increase it more?

[@Visionm41]

This is very dangerous for a country, suppose army also start backmailing government for some reasons

[@Abhishek-k1b2s]

They can not do so as constitution prohibits them

[@ajaychaudhary1786]

President is supreme commander, so they can't.

[@sunitization]

They will not. Or may be if government further reduce army service to 1 year further after agniveer.

[@rockers5720]

Third way can't be possible , because claim can never be passed in govt

[@shifujiyt9724]

Why punjab farmers think ke sirf wahi farming kr te he puree india me 😅.

[@beantsingh6724]

Mostly punjab meh farming hi hoti h anpad .

[@HarshSingh-1034]

​@@beantsingh6724 Wo pu re desh mein hoti hai

[@manishnimbar]

*भारत के किसान है वो खालिस्तानी पंजाबी हरियाणवी नही वो भारतीय किसान है*

[@pramilakanojia1678]

Bhai yaha tere comments ke reply dekh Kar hi hassi aa rahi hai sab punjab me hi hai baaki bharat ke log azaadi nahi chahte the aur mazdoori Kar Rahe the.logic died today 😂😂

[@theniravpanchal]

​@@beantsingh6724Pure desh me hoti hai Anpad-pro

[@ajaybabankauthale7597]

Problem is same states farmer protested against farm bills and not fighting for some provisions which were there in farm bill.

[@garry1672]

For diversification Farmers Demanding Minimum Support Price, if any factory Producer or Shopkeeper Can Demand Maximum Retail Price (MRP) then why Farmers Can't ? Farmers purchase everything on MRP but never sell their Corps on MSP according to their Choice.

[@zaar94631]

MSP is already there.....

[@rakeshmeshram7346]

Unbiased point of view is important from your side

[@Hey1234Hey]

Gov and farmers must come to an understanding common ground that should ultimately result in more efficiency and better tech in India's farm sector with emphasis on more support to farmers rather than mega private companies. Just look at US's Monsanto, US farmers are powerless and have to bend to the private companies screwing them over.

[@sandip870]

They earn fairly handsome amount dude...

[@sumedhsingh731]

​@@sandip870 Any data source for your claim? Most farmers arent rich

[@sandip870]

@@sumedhsingh731 bcz it is the middle man in India who profits...here is the same... middle man on the streets...why do you think food prices is so high but farmers are not rich

[@zaar94631]

These are Punjab and Haryana farmers only who earn very handsome money.....They employ all workers from up and Bihar at very cheap.....

[@rickycool6083]

They all literally have private planes crores worth of machinery. @@sumedhsingh731

[@Pradeep_Ranjan]

No country can buy whole production at MSP Everyone know this and this is why they are demanding it. So that this issue will roll and roll and roll. This is not for farmers it is just for politics.

[@vedictheartoffocus1697]

Lagta hai election aane wala h

[@ravikumarsahu6381]

तभी तो अंतरिम बजट आया है... आशाओं वाला ।

[@GrandDad_001]

​@@ravikumarsahu6381umeed h asha bni rhegi 😂

[@gajendrakumar1907]

Msp pe guarantee kanoon milega but aapko milne wali sari subsidy chhodna padega

[@craxlocus]

Non reasonable non plausible demand hai ...... election motivated demand hai Chaos create karne ke liye

[@sunitization]

Msp ka promise kosne koya tha?

[@rajnikantsinghrajnikantsin4725]

These are political worker

[@Zindagi_Live_100]

India, France, Germany, Italy, Belgium, Spain etc देश में एक ही time पर Farmers protest हो रही है India के farmer बहुत कम demand करते हैं वही France के farmers 140 demandअपने government के सामने रखी है और 140 करोड़ आबादी वाला देश के किसान कुछ नहीं मांग कर पाते है। 🙏🙏

[@nousername1587]

Sab kuchh to pehle se hi de rakha h kisan ko

[@KingKhan-tq4xf]

We stand with farmers...

[@hitesh9396]

Thankyou for explaining it in an easy manner

[@jagdishchand3994]

Remove rice, jeere, or gaho from msp

[@Donatellohamilto1063]

Whenever the farmers go to sell after harvest their crops are never sold in MSP at all every time the price is below MSP and the people running mills are benefiting from it

[@rahulnagarkar8237]

मैने तो अभी खेती करना हि बंद कर दिया हैं/जब बहोत सारे किसान खेती बंद करेगे तब मोदी साहब बाहर से सस्ता मगवाकर सबको देगे/

[@nitienvats8257]

​@@rahulnagarkar8237हरित क्रांति सरकार की जरूरत थी क्योंकि उस समय अनाज काम होता था, और किसानों को मूल्य अच्छा मिलता था, फिर उन्नत किस्में आई और खेतो की पैदावार तो बढ़ी लेकिन साथ में हर साल खर्चे भी बढ़ते चले गए, और मिट्टी खराब होती चली गई । अब फिर वही होगा, किसान खेती करना काम करेगा तो पैदावार कम होगी, और किसानो को अपने आप अच्छा भाव मिलने लगेगा, फिर सरकार की मुसीबत बढ़ेगी साथ में आम जनता की भी क्योंकि सरकार को डॉलर खर्च करके अनाज आयात करना पड़ेगा । और अगर ऐसा हुआ तो स्थिती बहुत खराब हो जायेगी, क्योंकि आज हम डॉलर कमाते है, खाद्य पदार्थ बेचकर फिर हमको खुद डॉलर खर्च कर खाद्य पदार्थ खरीदने पड़ेंगे । इसलिए अगर किसानों की समस्याओं को उचित तरीके से सुलझा लिया जाता है तो सरकार को देश का पैसा ही देश में खर्च करना पड़ेगा । और इससे विदेशी मुद्रा भंडार पर असर नहीं पड़ेगा ।

[@devaroraa]

that's for what farm laws were...to stop the dominance of middlemen

[@Pdh-vz6kh]

​@@devaroraa APMC mandies are abolished in bihar earlier, check their financial condition now.... They are only labours to the other states, instead of paper knowledge try to get some praticality....🙏

[@ChandranPrema123]

​@@Pdh-vz6khif imports from Outside is cheap then you know who is playing the game

[@NaveenKumar-gq8uk]

MSP for sugar cane is 340 per quintal not 2000 per quintal. 6:40

[@PrabhjotSahi]

One of the better videos on the channel

[@AnuragMauryalive]

Jo log bol rhe h kisano ki mang ko man liya jaye to ye wahi log h jo kuchh din phle charo trf hahakar mchaye ghoom rhe the ki tamatar 200 rs kg h itni mhngai hai aam insaan kya khaye 😂😂

[@Vikaschauhan_]

Its Shame. Farmer situation is bad, production of crop is all time High. and some people saying it's poltics. Come village then see ground realities how difficult is to produce crop in this situation when golbal warming is happening and environmental disturbance. Everybody's want to eat vegetables, Atta, daal but nobody want to give fair price to farmers. Thats why people are runing to metro cities bcz they can't do farming bcz it's tough and expensive

[@ajaychaudhary1786]

Nailed it❤.......true and straight

[@xavierchicha6010]

Fortuner pe farmers ko loan without intrest diya jaaye, diesel 50 rupees kiya jaaye kisano k liye, canada me 3 bhk ki 1 flat de aur life time visa saath me..jay kisaan

[@jagvindersinghraizada5057]

Bhai😂

[@AkshayPatil-f6b]

पहले पंजाब डुबा दिया अब हिंदुस्थान की बारी.......टॅक्स तो देते नही उडाव हमारा टॅक्स पेपर का पैसा .....

[@samindherreddy]

I being a farmer is against this Dramabazi😤 we want msp but not bankruptcy of my nation, yes we face lot of issues but this is a propaganda clearly

[@sandip870]

Not only that they want to cancel all free trade agreements and withdrawal from WTO... clearly a political march

[@ayushmankar4100]

Firm laws ke khilaf kyun they tum loog ? Bhai !

[@samindherreddy]

@@ayushmankar4100 I am not against those laws infact I want them for my profits

[@deepakkumarpati1146]

Agriculture me waise bhi 0 tax hai...which is good for small and marginal farmers...but ye andolan karne wale mercedes pakar k ghumte hain...aur agri income ka tax b nai denge......inorganic agitation....foreign funded...... Other real farmers across India should oppose these so called farmer (read arhatias).....they are ruining the name of real farmers

[@nitienvats8257]

Ankit bhai Bharat Ratn Sammanit MS Swaminathan ne apni report mein bahut achche se samjhaya hai ki kaose MSP farmers ko di jaani chahiye, ab sarkar dena nahi chahti kyuki ussse usey kuch hasil nahi hone wala, agar corporates ko paisa baanta jaata hai to wo money round hokar political parties ko hi milta hai, funding ke taur par, kisano ko dekar kya milega kuch nahi. Ab kisano se to vasuli nahi kar sakti na koi party chande ki. In short it is all possible to apply MSP, you should have a vision of proper implementation, and a continous monitoring and feedback mechanism of how to keep MSP in control by controlling the various paramaetrs effecting the MSP as per Swaminathan report.

[@ajaychaudhary1786]

Exactly

[@yashkatiyar8286]

Why government is not ready for export of farmers crop,,, but in our country export of crops done only in papers ,, EXPORT ENDS BEFORE START but we can't see this in other sectors,,, government is thinking about inflation flew in country only by export of farmers crop,,we can see other sectors like private company manufacturing vehicle, electronic gadgets,,,packed food items,,, private school fee etc ,(we can't think petrol and diesel price because its also in private sector if we can reduce 1-2 rupees from here and help farmers from but not,,, EVERY PROBLEM HAVE SOLUTION IF WE WANT TO SOLVE IT

[@anubhavtiwari3909]

These so called farmers shd be dealt with strict action...thy have taken everything for granted....Thy r posing national threat...🤬🤬🤬

[@mpgvlogs555]

2.5 cr ki gari leke 10000 ki MSP mangte hai

[@vedjoshi443]

Framers should pay income tax, Commodity market should be kept open for imports to reduce price, NO free electricity, no subsidy, no samman nidhi, no msp, no apmc and declared farming as industry and allow them to sell at their rate

[@nitienvats8257]

Try to understand the farming before putting your views.

[@nitienvats8257]

Farming is the only noble profession people are doing, because food can not be produced in factories, and with out food we can not survive.

[@vari217]

​@nitienvats8257 try to understand one thing. No one is doing farming for nobel work. Everyone does it for profit.

[@Pdh-vz6kh]

Than u should prepare yourself to buy aata 100rs/ kg

[@nitienvats8257]

@NarkoPrani Do you go to doctor and ask medical services for free. In fact when ill/diseased people beg in front of him to save the life of your near and dear ones. And corporate hospital doctors, can force you to sell your all belongings, and will not guarantee to save them. So how can you expect farmer who is not even able to sell its produce above its initial cost to give free to you. He is working hard so that his family and other's family should not out of starvation. Do not be a liability in society, do some work and earn your food.

[@SS40519]

Sir thank you for these details. I learn many things about MSP

[@subhajit.-.]

अगर सरकार ने किसानों को न्यूनतम समर्थन मूल्य दिया, तो किसानों की आय में वृद्धि होगी, लेकिन उसके बाजार में हर एक सब्जी की कीमत ज्यादा होगी, फिर महंगाई जरूर होगी। हर एक सेक्टर में सब अपने हिसाब से मूल्य निर्धारित किया जाता है, लेकिन किसानों को कोई नुकसान नहीं होता है। सरकार वी बहार एक्सपोर्ट पर रोक लगा रखा है।

[@annyamishra]

I thought there is only one solution of this problem is the govt. should impose one fixed price like mrp for APMC traders or govt. both...then only it is benificial for farmers.

[@4wheelingadv]

How can the govt waive off some lakh crores of loans of the corporates but can't ensure msp saying it'll strain the treasury? Has govt discussed about this with any farmer representative? What's the update about Swaminathan commission report suggestion? I can't understand why can't govt break the syndicates, why is it so difficult that makes them so powerful more than any authority?

[@nigamjogadia356]

Big Corporate companies can decide their goods price so they can be profitable but Farmers can't....that is the sad reality..but one thing that farmers have to help themselves...no govt can help them....they should make one organization that have silos to store produces so can they can sell only when they get the price right.......

[@SRmasti.]

सर मेरा ऐसा मानना है कि सरकार चाहे कुछ भी ना कर सके परंतु उसकी एक कार्य अवश्य करना चाहिए कि किसान कोई भी वस्तु जिस प्राइस में बेचता है वह रिटेल प्राइस में किसान के बेच हुए दम की डेढ़ गुना से अधिक नहीं हो सकती इससे किसानों को कुछ फायदा हो सकेगा

[@akhilgaur0]

Very informative sir.❤

[@MrPromisegoel]

Pls give full info that if govt will have to purchase all crops after msp then govt sell the crops also to further buyers. It may be in loss or profit And if farmers get some extra amount in their pockets, they will go in market and market will boom also

[@AmritLal-oh7gg]

All private employees, factory workers, building banane wale majdoor delhi chalo!!! Demand - max work, 3 days+ 5 hours working with minimum salary 1 lakh!! Workers should also get salary!!

[@ankushmukherjee3219]

HGahahahah😂

[@himanshusingh-ks8ww]

Han 4cr ki G wagen lekr msp maangta huwa gareeb kisaan Punjab ka

[@Rickystanicky2902]

😂😂sahi baat hai

[@ajaychaudhary1786]

Yeah....they fight for small farmers Like Modiji fight for Adani

[@paul9629]

for what they are fighting can u tell me....? ​@@ajaychaudhary1786

[@dharam1718]

10% of farmers hijacked what the other 90% of farmers agreed and wanted in the last changes introduced for farmers. Currently, farmers are paid 2% of GDP as subsidies compared to defense forces, getting 1.7% of health getting 2%of GDP. Previously, opposition parliamentary members had clearly declared that the platform has been set for disruption of government . Current farmers protests are said by many is supported by foreign players to disrupt development of Bharat A farmers able to modify their tractors valued approximately 10 lakh or thereabouts is not poor, driving a Mercedes car and houses in other states A closer look at the financials and links to trace their sources of funding

[@Rjvenu9911]

Bhai food ke bina soldiers kab Tak bhookhe lagenge. Agar khane ko roti nahi hogi to education ko khaoge kya?

[@dharam1718]

@@Rjvenu9911 are farmers giving it for free?

[@Rjvenu9911]

@@dharam1718 they are giving at a huge loss to retailers. That is why they are committing suicide. If they give it free to you will you be happy?

[@rakeshmeshram7346]

Please stand with the farmer

[@vishalsrivastava9257]

Protest....!!! Lgta h Election ane wale h 😂

[@sunitization]

Msp koi random amount thode hi hoga. Uska formula hoga , kitni laagat aayi aur kitna profit lena hai. Agar business apna profit set kar sakte hai to kisaan kyu nhi?

[@_kumu_ku]

In Punjab, all harvesting seasons are over now. So in the free time let's protest. Maximum Selling Price will be announced by govt due to

[@ajaychaudhary1786]

for Farmers there is no free time. From books u just get to know about sowing and harvesting, what about the taking care of these crops. Farming is 24*7 job .....do some farming and u will know

[@sairoadways4365]

how msp is decided is not shown in the video. can't govt decide MSP close to MRP

[@footballthrills5386]

A2 + fl ( c2)

[@pradeepattri2253]

4th option भी है मेरे भाई। product exchange will be revolutionary!

[@ashwanijangra9187]

मेरी फ़सल , मेरा ब्योरा(my crop , my details)

[@manishsharma8497]

Major crop of central and southern part of India is: Jowar

[@amansharma-gj3fp]

सर मेने थोड़ी बहुत आईएएस की तैयारी की है और उसका नतीजा ये है की आज भी वो चीजे स्टडी किए बिना नीद नही आती उस के हिसाब से बोलूं की अभी मैं किसान हु और पेस्टीसाइड की शॉप चलता हु mp मै भवंतर हुई थी लेकिन वो बुरी तरह से कला बजरी की सीकर हुई थी इसी लिए शिवराज सरकार ने किसानों को सहारा देने के लिए बीमा का सहारा लिया😂 और लगातार बीमा देते रहे 😂

[@ranadeeeproy]

This farmers' protest seems funded by enemies. Why does this protest always only come from only two states, Punjab and Hariana. Other state farmers never participated

[@Krish1111-m1f]

MSP dedo naye Tax lagado Sari subsidy khatam kardo . Kah do MSP lelo. Dekhte hain kya doglapan hai.

[@skgentlemancadet4725]

4:24 kya sir kisan ye bol rahe ki koi bhi agr kharide to msp pe kharide naki government hi msp pe kharide

[@manishkhatri5003]

Political active ne farmers..vehle

[@mohitsachdeva8142]

asking for demands before elections doesn't make them less important

[@nishant115me]

But it does make the intention of demands questionable

[@gamingwithlegendaryguys2519]

​@@nishant115meintention of ram mandir inaugration before completion was questionable too.

[@nishant115me]

@@gamingwithlegendaryguys2519 to karo question kisne mana kiya h sadak thodi block kari kisi ne uske liye

[@gamingwithlegendaryguys2519]

@@nishant115me sadak protester ne block kiya hai ya police ne.🤡

[@nishant115me]

@@gamingwithlegendaryguys2519 protestors ki vajah se police ne

[@__iavinash]

Nice video ❤

[@GamerzGamazm-bo2uw]

इनके ट्रेक्टर को कब्जे में लिया जाए, शामिल सभी किसान नेताओं की प्रोपर्टीज और शामिल हुए सभी अमीर किसानों कि प्रोपर्टीज और बैंक में रखी रकम को सील कर के, देश को होने वाले सभी नुकसान की भरपाई की जाएं। नहीं तो ये इसी प्रकार देश के लोगों को परेशान करते रहेंगे।

[@shashwatgupta1745]

The solution lies only in exhortation of manufacturing sector by Govt. More unskilled, semi skilled jobs will be created to absorb the disguised workforce from agriculture to mfg sector which will enhance their income.

[@shubhamjain5282]

Due to same foreign investors always have fear to invest in India … people who are getting subsidy doing protest and people paying taxes getting nothing

[@vipintyagi3384]

Udhogpati price apney hisab se jitna chah bda de koi control nhi kyuki sarkar udhogpati se chalti hai kisano se nhi

[@Gurpreet.jheeta]

Better way would be kisan selling crops directly to manufacturers like they sell milk directly to amul and verka, win win situation

[@Rjvenu9911]

Crop is in quintals, it's not in few kgs. It's not practical.

[@Krish1111-m1f]

India me sabse Ameer kisan Punjab , Haryana aur Western UP me hain. Aur woh extensive water croping karte hain. Baki states ke kisan not so profit me hain. Is wajah se ye dalali Wale kisan paresan hain. Ye already paise Wale hain. Ye nhi chahte ki dusre kisan bhi profit len.

[@theseeker_]

Best analysis ❤

[@Cloud_ninee]

Yha 60 bigha zamin hai fir bhi aaj tak road par jake danga nahi karne ka ghamand hai😌

[@anandbhosle8312]

Government should implement Madhyapradesh Model PDP

[@anmolkoul1280]

Mast session 🤝

[@prashanttikas]

kash mere pass khet hota, mai bhi msp, loan maaf, 6k yearly, aur jo khet me ugta uska paisa bhi banata bina tax bhare,.....kya kare naseeb hi bekar hai, na to khet hai na to job, ab msp ke naam pe jyada paise dekhe anaaj bhi kharido kya kare

[@anyatalkss]

Not possible

[@Donatellohamilto1063]

Buy directly from farmers remove mill system will help in upgrading farmers effectiveness in storage and selling and high quality of farming.

[@ayushmankar4100]

Aur mill mein kaam karne wale loogon ka kya hoga phir ?

[@World_ofsanatani]

If msp will be given then it will badly affect the development work in the country bcz major chunk of government funds were absorbed in giving msp to all farmers of this country for all crops this will definetely ruin the country's growth 💯

[@RajeshreeSawant-n1u]

Hum samaz sakte hai ki elections karib aate hi aandolan kar ke hum govt per pressure bana sakte hai apni valid demands ke liye . But yeh real farmer agitation hai hi nahi .