Can We Find The Best Vegan Sour Cream? | Vegan Sour Cream Taste Test

Another vegan taste test!!! This time we are testing vegan sour cream brands. Six total brands -- can we decide on a winner?
Let us know in the comments if you agree with us and which taste test we should do next.
★Read More for Price, Store Locator, Ingredients, etc★
🌱 makeitdairyfree.com/vegan-sour-cream-taste-test/
❌ Allergens: Info given on each if Top 8 Free
2:30 Follow Your Heart Sour Cream
4:45 Forager's Sour Cream
7:08 Good Karma Sour Cream
9:35 Kite Hill Sour Cream
12:57 Tofutti Sour Cream
14:52 Wayfare Sour Cream
19:19 Best Vegan Sour Cream Winner
✔️Did you make one of these? Share a photo on IG and use #MakeItDairyFree​ to be featured!
🖤 Hey…have a good day, okay? We appreciate you🌈
Thanks so much for watching. We’d love if you could click the “Thumbs Up!” Button, leave a comment below and Subscribe to our channel!
Subscribe to our channel → kzbin.info​
Make It Dairy Free Website → makeitdairyfree.com​
Weekly Newsletter → view.flodesk.com/pages/5fea4d...​
Instagram → makeitdairy...​
Facebook → makeitdairyfree​
Twitter → makeitdairyfree​
Pinterest → pinterest.com/makeitdairyfree​
Contact us → [e-mail]
Private Facebook Community → groups/amazi...​
#VeganSourCream #VeganReview #VeganTasteTest
★Products That We Used For This Recipe★
*Affiliate Links for products help us make these videos. Thank you for your support.
Our Photography/Videography Equipment → www.amazon.com/shop/makeitdai...​

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Do you have a favorite?

[@debbietampasheher3682]

I haven't bought many sour creams. I bought the forager recently. It was okay. I usually make the Mcdougal sour cream in my blender as needed. I add a little lactic acid to the Mcdougal recipe. We just rarely use it 😆 But I do love it

[@debbietampasheher3682]

But...I have had the tofutti and it was also okay 😆

[@joycewilson8513]

To me, once I mix it into the Taco, I really can't discern the taste because the Taco seasonings take over

[@dianew7058]

Kite Hill is the best..the only sour cream I will use. Yes dairy sour cream has tang.

[@NC-gm2lb]

Violife and Miyokos...I like the Forager one too but you have to stir it

[@She_is_P]

This channel is helps me when I’m grocery shopping. I am currently transitioning to vegan. New Subbie here.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

So happy you find it helpful!

[@torrancereed9441]

Im just transitioning my self a month in

[@user-ky4us2bz5z]

Been vegan for over 6 years and I’ve never had any of the sour creams on the market! Thanks for this!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

You're welcome!

[@abundancewithajah4768]

I’m so happy y’all decided to do this for us

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Our pleasure!

[@kayg426]

I am currently trying to go completely dairy free and found your channel it has helped me a lot.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

So glad to hear that

[@allis2849]

Can’t wait to watch!! Love how calming you guys are to watch, always makes my day!💕

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Awww thank you!

[@ItsLindaMichelle]

Y’all are a blessing from above. I needed a good laugh today, thank you.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

So glad we could give you a laugh

[@sharon4094]

You guys are hysterical!

[@Truthfavorblessed]

Kite Hill is my favorite! I’ve used the cream cheese in mashed potatoes, their ricotta cheese in lasagna, etc, with VioLife shredded cheese...😋

[@MakeItDairyFree]

love their ricotta, not so much the cream cheese lol

[@Mmmelisssa]

LIVE for your taste tests. 🙌🏽💖 I’ve only used Tofutti!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

So glad you enjoy them

[@reachtrita]

You two are so sweet and kind!

[@glonnief]

You guys always crush the vids👍🏾. I enjoy most of Follow your Heart products. The cheeses, mayo and sour cream.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

awww thank you!

[@tiffanypatterson5430]

Definitely subscribed! Since watching your videos I have successfully been vegan for a week. You two give me life!

[@smallbiztaxlady]

I needed this! Saves me the trouble of having to taste test.

[@lindsaytoussaint]

I was gonna use the time stamps but y’all are so entertaining lol.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

hahaha, thank you, but also they are listed in the description box if you need to come back and see a specific one

[@ACamiul]

When you decide on price, it's important to divide by ounces so you are comparing on a per ounce basis. I haven't had many of these, so thanks for trying for us and giving solid reviews!

[@vv1323]

Vegan frozen pizzas next please 🙏🏻 Or ice creams! Or maybe something different like protein bars?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

pizza is definitely on our list. We have to wait for freezer space HAHAHA

[@melschevelle]

Daiya frozen pizzas ARE AMAZING

[@danabrown6341]

Adorable as always, thank you!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you! 😊

[@maxinef6654]

Thanks for the review. I’m going to try the Follow Your Heart since I also like their mayo.

[@IkambaDeVictoire]

I love yall! I need to go vegan for my health, and you guys are SUCH A HELP! Thanm you for all that you do and share! Blessings to you and your family. 🙏🏿🌻

[@miacarter8097]

Thank you for this video! I love Sour cream! I'm so happy there are vegan options for this.

[@Julie-jl2kk]

im so glad u took my potato suggestion!! eeh!!>_

[@MakeItDairyFree]

It was great

[@ambernimmo5948]

Love you two ❤ thanks for the vid My favorite is kite hill lol

[@vincentt.7501]

Good channel! informative and good chemistry!!!!!

[@Mmmelisssa]

Vegan mayos next please! 🤞🏽

[@MakeItDairyFree]

on the list!

[@KitCat71819]

Yes please!!!

[@chefdeena]

@@MakeItDairyFree warning: if you say anything bad about the Hellman's vegan Mayo we boxing 🥊🥊 🧐just kidding love you guys!!🤣🤣🤣🥰🥰

[@torigillispie9823]

The only vegan mayo that I love is called Veganise....it taste just like Best Foods real stuff.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

@@chefdeena HAHAHAH

[@neophoenix999able]

As a vegan for longer than you guys have been alive, Tofutti Sour Cream is the best.

[@amandarenken4044]

I love your channel and so glad I found you! I am newly vegan and always looking for ideas and your content has been so helpful. I have three kids and would love to see a video on what your kids eat/kids lunchbox ideas. Love you guys!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you are here! Hopefully soon!

[@taylorbush8713]

I tried Kite Hill last night and was blown away. Tastes just like sour cream and didn't get any of that citrusey flavor you guys were talking about. Maybe they changed the formula.

[@MissStasi77]

I have tried 2 of these b4 ...thanks for this video yall are hilarious

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you!!

[@jenniferlavender4391]

I love follow your heart sour cream! Can't wait to see your other ones. I don't love tofutti but in a pinch masked with all the taco fillings it'll do

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Seems like we agree ;)

[@itzmjay9175]

I’m a fairly new vegan so I’m so glad I found you guys channel🙌🏾

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We're happy you are here!

[@debbietampasheher3682]

They are fun!

[@Asachara]

@@MakeItDairyFree run from veganism. support ur local farm with pasture raised animals. humans cannot sustain themselves on veganism. its delusional, horrible for your health, for the air, soil and its a very materialistic/consumer mindset. these people are searching for something that can be naturally made from healthy cows. it contain natural bacteria, vitamin a, b12, b6, calcium, vitamin d, saturated fat... all with one ingredient. while they consume plant and seed sludge with 5+ ingredients in plastic. a local dairy farm u can reuse glass jars... u will be healthy, ur wallet and the planet will be healthy as well.

[@Asachara]

rotational grazing.

[@DuchessofBoosh]

“You smell like feet and I like you” LMFAO this one was fun, I feel like you guys were enjoying it more 😂😂😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

LOL thanks

[@leelalo6625]

I laughed so much watching this. Thanks for leaving the funnies in.

[@eventstephen]

Tofutti is legit, and I see it in a lot of stores. Been enjoying it for a long time. Great video, guys! Thanks!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@raeraesma]

I love your taste tests. Our favorite is Follow Your Heart, but I usually make my own with cashews.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Love that!

[@kateswelstad7281]

Super helpful thank you! You’re right it is so hard to find wayfaire or fyh sour cream but now I will put forth the extra effort. Tofutti is my go to but it’s definitely not perfect.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you find and like one of them

[@beauschneider6848]

Y'alls videos have been very helpful. Sour cream is probably the main thing I miss being vegan. I will have to check out the follow your heart brand. I tried kite hill and forager and yuk!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

let us know if you do

[@lyndseymichele]

Follow your heart is my go to. I also LOVE their dressings. The creamy garlic and their honey mustard 👌👌👌💯💯💯

[@gidget8717]

I like the Tofutti to mix with a jar of salsa. It makes an excellent dressing for any tex-mex dish. The really thick texture of the Tofutti is ideal for this.

[@thaimexx]

So glad y’all made this video! I’m new w dairy free products and bought Forager. I thought it was disgusting!! I wouldn’t even think about buying another brand, but after watching this..: I am open to trying a new one ❤️

[@MakeItDairyFree]

oh man! I hope you find one you like

[@a_ya_la]

ROLF, I only like to cook with sour cream as in cakes, so I was curious about this and thank you because I definitely needed the insight! Making a note follow your heart!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you found it helpful

[@TheBionicGoat]

I just tried the forager sour cream for the first time the other day and when i opened it, i was APPALLED. It just looked so unappetizing. I stirred it and it got better, but it just wasn't good. So i mixed it with buffalo sauce and buffalo seasoning cause i could not eat it by itself. It made a decent creamy buffalo sauce.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Oh no but great idea to not waste it

[@zeamer11]

If you live where there is a Kroger, Simple Truth Plant Based Sour Cream is the best!! I was struggling to find something that tastes like real sour cream, and this one did it. I am NOT a fan of cashew cream, so that wasn’t an option for me. I would be curious to try Follow Your Heart Sour Cream if I can find it

[@MakeItDairyFree]

No Kroger :/

[@barbaraparland]

I like the 30min ish videos. Feels like an honest review/reaction. Never feels like there's filler. I like the texture shots. I think it would be interesting to see if you like any of them as an ingredient in a recipe, especially if you didn't like it straight up. PS- I am knitting if you're curious🧶🤣

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We want to see photos on IG!

[@amandanjax90]

Oo I will have to try the follow your heart one! They are my favorite cheese for the most part. You both are hilarious! 😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you so much

[@aLife2Dai4]

Toffuti is MY GO TO! Tastes just like creme fresh!!!!!!!🔥🔥🔥🔥 i even use it on bagels like cream cheese but i use the sour cream bc it’s creamier. Love it!

[@angelacollins2616]

You guys are awesome! I never tried the follow your heart, I will try now. My go to is the tofutti. You guys should taste test dips kite hill ranch dip is good.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

great idea

[@2075vj]

I like Forgers yogurt. Thanks for sharing 🙏🏾

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks for watching!

[@derail6969]

oh so glad you did this. As I REALLY want to make good changes and stay clear of dairy that's killing my belly

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you find some recipes you love!

[@imsosan74]

Thank you for this I haven’t found any good sour cream So known I will taste the follow your heart!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you like it

[@MissJK_]

As a non vegan Kite Hill is incredibly authentic tasting. It legitimately taste like dairy sour cream. No comparison.

[@barbarawilliams7723]

My brand is #2 I can’t wait to try Follow your heart 😋

[@tyne76]

Love the shorter length of this video!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We're trying to find a good balance LOL

[@NC-gm2lb]

Are you guys stirring them before the taste test? It makes a difference because they can settle.

[@miacarter8097]

Got an instant subscriber here

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks so much

[@kennethmaese4622]

Great videos, subscribed.

[@KfolksMs]

Haven’t had any vegan sour cream but now I know what to try!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you enjoy

[@tamcon72]

Sour cream _is_ yogurt-adjacent . . . And Larish'a blouse is so lovely and a sitting duck for upspits : ) Sour cream, like yogurt, is another product I abandoned upon becoming vegan, but I'm a Slavic person--we put sour cream on everything--so that one has been hard to give up. I appreciate you guys so much for daring to do another dairy analogue taste test. TFP!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you so much.

[@moisesmartinez6721]

I really like your guys content and the way you review products. Please keep up the amazing work. Question, have you ever done a review on vegan mayonnaise? If so can you share the link with me, as I can not find one. Thank you in advance!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We haven't, but it's on our very soon to do list!

[@moisesmartinez6721]

@@MakeItDairyFree Awesome!

[@deedee2874]

Love the critiques and thoughtfulness you both put into your responses, but Andrew's tongue clacking the bad ones is a hoot 😂 By the way have you done vegan mince meat taste test when it is fried with onions, garlic and salt, just like a traditional mince would start out before the tomatoes were added

[@ninajoyner7113]

Haven’t tried but one and I always make it my own. That’s Tofutti. Will look for the other ones.

[@celestlake183]

I actually love the forager brand sour cream, it tastes a little like French onion dip

[@kyow6412]

Forager is our household fav, and their new cheeses are bomb!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Nice!

[@kyow6412]

@@MakeItDairyFree loving your content!! I can’t believe it took me so long to stumble on your videos. You have officially changed the non dairy yogurt of choice in my house and we have been vegan for 6 years!!! Lol

[@nburris1127]

Follow your heart is really good!

[@JoysBeautyJawns]

I totally agree with y’all on the Foragers! I don’t mind their yogurt with fruit and nuts and a little granola but the sour cream was an immediate no for me! I really didn’t care for the consistency or flavor! Y’all led me right tho with the Daiya new recipe for shredded cheese!!! Love love love your channel!! You have a beautiful family 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you so much!

[@angieowens9319]

I laughed the whole time! Follow your heart has never failed me on any of their products. Oh I made your banana bread this morning! Delish!🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾

[@MakeItDairyFree]

So happy you liked it!

[@louwannawilson8035]

As you said in your cream cheese taste test - I am old school. I enjoy Tofutti. But as Oui is my fave yogurt, too. I am inspired to "branch out" and try some new brands.

[@drivers805]

Kite Hill Sour Cream is AMAZING… has slight tartness like real sour cream! I wish it cost less or gave more in the package.

[@DC-ef8op]

Love these videos. I need a good sour cream desperately

[@MakeItDairyFree]

hope you find one!

[@cimesq]

I found the best vegan yogurt after following your taste test.. So I will definitely try your top pick on sour creams as I’ve only had the Tofutti.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you like it!

[@harleymclaughlin8631]

This is very helpful! I am not vegan but, my daughter has a bad milk allergy so finding alternatives is fantastic

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad it's helpful

[@paulaleach6058]

I’ve only tried the Tofutti, Kite Hill, & Good Karma. As a vegan of over 25 years, I’ve had the Tofutti many, many times. It was the only player in the game forever. While not flavored exactly like dairy sour cream, I was always fine with it & still buy it occasionally. I’ve had the Kite Hill several times more recently, & I do like it. I love the KH cream cheese. I tried the Good Karma once & hated it. I’d like to try Follow Your Heart, as I love their Vegenaise.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

25 years is amazing!!!

[@katiarici3622]

I will try to look for the Follow Your Heart sour cream. I’m extremely surprised you didn’t like Forager! My family who is not vegan totally liked Forager. They stopped buying real sour cream. Forager sour cream is often out of stock for us. Perhaps I bought a different version than you guys.

[@MrMinion437]

Can you please do a video on vegan parmesan cheese. I really need some for my pizzaaaaaaaaa, also thanks for all the great content :)

[@brianweber4616]

I just tried a newer one that's not on here, Violife sour cream. It's fair. I remember preferring Kroger's Simple Truth sour cream, which, as you said in a previous comment, appears to be WayFare repackaged... ingredients are almost identical and the box is even the same shape. (BTW, some of the Simple Truth frozen meat substitutes appear to be repackaged Gardein, or at least manufactured by Gardein.) I'll have to try the Follow Your Heart next.

[@izayuh3828]

Luckily Way far is at the store across the street for me. I really enjoy it as well 🙏🏾✨

[@theshannankay]

The first time I had follow your heart, 4 years into being vegan, I got a runny/liquidity container, so I guess consistency/stability was an issue with the product, either way it was disgusting and I didn't retry it until a year ago and it was so good and thick. My fave sour cream. Tofutti was my go to for years even though it's a better cream cheese than sour cream imo.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Oh no, glad you tried again though

[@katiehemstreet8939]

I buy Tofutti, but I've tried both Forager and Good Karma and I like them. I honestly by Tofutti because it's in a smaller tub and we don't eat enough sour cream to go through that big ol' tub before it spoils. I'd bee excited to try Follow Your Heart.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Totally understand not wanting to waste

[@JonnyLWarren1]

I Iove Forager as well, maybe from now on I shouldn't watch food review videos because I can see it's possible the people judging may not like what you would like, and then you go through life never trying it but if you did it would have been your favorite

[@HoppySabbathHomestead]

I have had the good karma one and it does have a yogurty smell and taste but I will grow on you! Lol I have to try the follow your heart one!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Let us know what you think if you do!

[@victoriablanc761]

no no we don't need them shorter.. we want to know what you think, packaging and all. these are very helpful thx for doing these.

[@kimhubbs1104]

If you have an ingles you can find the follow your heart or good karma. Im gonna give the follow your heart another try. It's been a while since I gave it a try.

[@SenoritaConejita]

Wait! Wayfare had THE BEST sour cream and then the recipe changed, it was more like yogurt consistency...but the ones you guys tried looks like the old one! I gotta give it a try again. Thanks for the video!

[@foreverx_xlost]

If you stir the Forager really well, it has a very smooth consistency. Much more appealing lol

[@AsaliGrayce]

Tofutti Sour Cream is really good! I use it in vegan mac and cheese, instead of making a "cheese" sauce out of nuts and veggies. I just use veg stock, pasta, Tofutti sour cream and vegan cheeses. It's wayyyy gooey'er than most super runny vegan mac....Annnnd I love using it to make Vegan Tzatziki sauce for gyro's.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you enjoy

[@sheraleeronan2326]

I have purchased Wayfare for some while best out there.. Only concern is it tends to go mouldy fast and does not keep for long

[@MsSassyMT]

I've been steering clear of vegan sour cream. I had high hopes for the Kite Hill though because I've had their chive cream cheese and liked it. After seeing this review, I hope I can find the Follow Your Heart brand to try.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We don't like the original KH cream cheese, but never tried the chive, so you may like this one

[@LeahElisheva]

I love the follow your heart brand for shredded cheese , too I haven’t had sour cream since I became vegan so this is good to know! I used to love baked potatoes with sour cream ::) No reason in the world not to be vegan! ✌️ ❤️

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you like!

[@kieselguhrvonepp9737]

WayFare sour cream is available at Kroger under the name “Simple Truth Plant Based Dairy Free Sour Cream Alternative”. Same stuff. Tasty

[@margarett_b]

If you were to do this taste test where I live you would only have one to try out ;P I am happy sour cream is not an ingredient I used to use often before going vegan because it would be real hard now! . Having said that, I am happy you found sth you really enjoy! Keeping my fingers crossed you will somehow use up you didn't like too ;P Anyways, sending you lots of love! Stay safe and have a great rest of the week!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We have a few ideas for these ;) Have a great week!

[@gracecheatham9839]

I’m from LA and its my first time Hearing about Wayfair 😁 but follow your heart is my favorite and I get it at stater brothers 🥰

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Awesome!

[@tarabooartarmy3654]

I’ve been trying to find the Follow Your Heart sour cream EVERYWHERE. Did they stop making it? Anyone know? None of the stores near me carry it, even the ones who carry their other products, and all the sites that reference it online say “Out of Stock” 😢

[@TheRitchExperience]

I just tried tofutti with the vegan walnut tacos anddddd I’m not mad at it. I can only seem to find tofutti where I’m located but I’m pleased

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Awesome

[@dianechandler]

I love Kite Hill the best!

[@jomams1040]

Where's the blog post that you guys talking about is that on the actual website or Instagram or is that a whole separate thing thanks

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Website. If you open the description box to this video, it's linked in there

[@astramcnamara]

I bought the forager sour cream yesterday, just tried it, and then googled if it is supposed to taste sweet, and found this video😂 does taste like coconut yogurt

[@oksana7301]

Not sure if Presidents Choice products are available to you but here in Ontario Canada I just bought that brand sour cream alternative, plant based and it’s very similar to sour cream.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

They aren't. Glad you enjoy it!

[@jomams1040]

Is the follow your heart made with soy that's my only big problem as I don't do soy at all?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

No soy

[@michellebeckham6402]

I’ve always used the Tofutti brand. I had avoided the FYH brand (even though I love their cheeses) just because it was a bigger container and had a shorter shelf life. After years I finally gave in and bought it. I was so impressed and thought it was spot on. I went through many containers. Then to my dismay (gasp) they changed formula by making it soy free. After that I just didn’t like it anymore. I was so sad. I even emailed them about it. I wish they had the original version as well. I’ve seen reviews of a a Simple Truth brand that a lot of people like.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

oh man, so sorry to hear that.

[@alysoncocking1236]

That was a fun video. Around my area in the UK, I haven't seen any vegan sour creams.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

oh wow, not even one!?

[@alysoncocking1236]

@@MakeItDairyFree Nope, I've not seen one.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

@@alysoncocking1236 darn

[@peacefeline1107]

I was so excited when I found Good Karma sour cream! Then I tasted it, yuck! 🤢 I am happy to see this taste test and this makes me want to try the Follow Your Heart brand. I have not seen the Wayfair brand in my area. Thanks for this 💚

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hope you like the FYH