Can you create your own new Qur'an recitation?

[@islamicclarity7062]

So anyone can create their own Qur'an recitation or version today? Would it be canonical? How did they decide which ones were canonical?

[@chrisazure1624]

The local person with the most power at the time decided what was authentic. Islam is a religion based on authority by might.

[@roshlew6994]

And they have the audacity to claim there is no human involvement in Quran.. Arabs created Quran from plagiarized and corrupted scriptural stories and folklore of apocryphal Christian sects and Jews of seventh century Arabia..

[@madebija]

😂😂😂😱 "A little bit of Warsh, A little of bit of Kalun, with a just a tiny but of Hars and voila..."I have created a new qiraat called...the Islamabad edition. Quote from Dr. J.Smith

[@jxcess3891]

The donkey called farida is a charlatan. The differences in the qiraats are not merely recital. For example, the sura 37.12 has a difference in meaning in some of the ko-oorans. The hafs version is different in meaning from the khalaf version. www.nquran.com/ar/ayacompare/?sora=37&aya=12 Hafs says "you (muhummud) wonder", while khalaf version says "I (allah) wonder". Which is the correct quran? The famous librarian, al-Nadim, in the year 375 A.H./987 A.D. records that Abdullah ibn Mas'ud's version of the Qur'an had 110-112 suras while Ubayy ibn Ka'b's collection had 116, that these collections had a different ordering of the suras and that there were variants in the verses. See, Al-Nadim, The Fihrist of al-Nadim - A Tenth Century survey of Muslim Culture, New York: Columbia University Press, pp. pp. 58-61 and 79. And these different versions of the Qur'an were used by the early Islamic scholars. For example, when Al-Tabari (d. 310 AH/923 AD) quotes the Qur'an in his writings, he not only quotes from Uthman's version but also from Abdullah ibn Mas'ud's version. See, The History of Al-Tabari, SUNY, vol. I, p. 353, vol. II, pp. 68, 108, 109, vol. III, p. 174. Arthur Jeffery (Materials for the History of the Text of the Qur'an) surveyed these Islamic scholars and identified 15 primary different collections of the Qur'an with a whole range of variants. In the 1980's many ancient Qur'ans were discovered in San`a'. Some of these have the sura order that was credited to Abdullah ibn Masud and others. (Gerd-R Puin, Observations on the Early Qur'an Manuscripts in San`a'. In "The Qur'an as Text", ed. Stefan Wild, Leiden: Brill, 1996. pp. 110-111)

[@FRED-gx2qk]

@@roshlew6994 its done and dusted why cant they give up talking bollox

[@setfreebythetruth-knowtrut3791]

This is miracle of recitation! :)

[@oliverbenis]

Did Farid just make the Standard Narrative hole deeper? Paging YQ.

[@saotome6502]

Exactly

[@chrisazure1624]

They keep ripping more holes in the cloth when they try to patch one area.

[@pembasmijinguahira]

The standard narrative has more holes 🤣

[@chrisazure1624]

@@georgepeh All of a sudden, I have a hankerin' to go to Baskin Robbins - 31 flavors and then you can mix them. Rocky Road mixed with Chocolate Mint, yumm.

[@jxcess3891]

It's called the miracle of reinterpretion and it's sub-miracle, the miracle of re-canonization.

[@darwn977]

I’m working on Qira’at Darwin as we speak.

[@Heafyshiu]

Farid drilling new holes😂😂😂😂😂👍

[@QuranicIslam]

😆

[@ronhabster8778]

They are the ultimate spin masters 🤣

[@JackSmith-qi2sl]

Subhanallah perfectly preserved 😍

[@chrisazure1624]

Do they realize how senseless this is?

[@karenthompson1337]

Unbelievably stupid. My gosh. Don’t they hear themselves? 🤪

[@spadadelsignore]

So basically you can make your own qira'at like a Subway sandwich, but can't use the Reading of Muhammad's own best reciter (Ubay)...let that sink in.

[@TheTorbar]

it was too unpopular to use. they are still used too btw but not in prayer etc

[@aladinndrake110]

Thanks Islamic Clarity bringing to sharp focus, how Grateful Muslims really aught to be to God - for undertaking to preserve the holy Koran. Your clip brings into focus the miracle that it truly is that you go to whichever country in the world- China, Japan, Mongolia, Tibet, India, Mideast, Iran, South Africa, Europe n the America’s Muslims have the same holy Koran. Amazingly beautiful and inspiring to all Muslims. What a Mercy Granted to man!

[@frankly.speaking]

7 Arhufs (dialects) x 30plus Qiraats (variant readings)= *ONE HOLEY QURAN*

[@farhanf3732]

HAHAHA thats funny how anti-Muslim try to justify the corruption of their books by attacking qiraat

[@frankly.speaking]

@@farhanf3732 funny how muslims including deedat, Zakir n other imminent muslim scholars claimed that not a word, letter, dot or meaning was changed in the quran for 1400 hundred years until their filthy lies were exposed..... Till today majority of muslims had no knowledge of what aruf or qiraats were, let alone non-muslims... until holes were discovered 😂 Check the below link... kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3_SZ5eOmJecY5I

[@TheTorbar]

yup. no human "inventing" needed. just taking what was already there. and where did 30+ qirat comefrom name me 21

[@frankly.speaking]

@@TheTorbar here are few variant qurans by name Naafi' Al-Madani Ibn Katheer Al-Makki Abu Amr Al-Basri Ibn Aamir Ash-Shami Asim al-Kufi Hamzah Al-Kufi Al-Kisaa'i Khalaf Al-Bazzar Abu Ja'far Al-Madanee Yaqub ibn Al-Basri

[@frankly.speaking]

@@TheTorbar but where are the *"seven Arhufs (dialects)"* today which was given to mohammed supposedly by jibril? Why aren't you asking me about it's list too?

[@frankjaeger9068]

perfectly preserved

[@ahmadar1278]

What about combining all 10 recitiations in One surah? So a bit here and a bit there.

[@christwitness847]

Excellent.

[@sambeguely1132]

a new reshiteation?

[@Islamiccalling]

I'm sorry where did he say you can create your own recitation?! At second 0:27 he said not really today, because the chain has to go back to the prophet. You really are grasping at straws with your sheep audience aren't you?!

[@retrictumrectus1010]

From what I understood, Farid wanted to say that you cannot make up your own original recitation but you can combine the bits and pieces of approved recitations. If this is music, he is basically saying that making new original music is not allowed and only existing music shall be sang, but mash-ups are allowable. But mash-ups basically butcher both recitations, a deviant recitation. It is basically a separate recitation.

[@aladinndrake110]

Has any of the modern sheiks, imams or Islamic scholars lectured about this? I mean bona Fide Muslims? Obviously 🙄 to get an Islamic perspective one cannot go to Abu Jahl? Thank God that the Holy Koran is preserved. 😊❤️

[@theastronomer5800]

Allah in heaven probably can't keep up making new "eternal" tables with the different recitations of the Quran.

[@edwinooo11226]

I keep shaking my head

[@elmundir]

the funny thing is no one of the first centuries have said that 7 qiraat = 7 ahruf he s' just ignorant

[@TheTorbar]

you take the ahruf to make qiraat

[@christwitness847]

I notice that Mansur's mouth is getting twisted, like a mouth of an impenitent liar.

[@zulqarnainabdullah5891]

Yes, why not ? I also dont see a problem.

[@zulqarnainabdullah5891]

@mysotiras5 No, Quran was ascemded in 7 different mode of recitation a.k.a akhruf. In al-Fatihah we can recite maliki yaumiddin (king of the day of Judgement) or maaliki yaumiddin (Owner of the Day of Judgement). both are accepted and approved by Rasulullah. And there are many more in the Quran. Muslims should know this.

[@theastronomer5800]

@@zulqarnainabdullah5891 Quite a few of these recitations actually carry a meaning that goes way beyond your (well known) example. Also, the rasm varies between some. Ancient manuscripts have many serious variants also.

[@notionSlave]

Doesn't mean it's a legitimate one....zoinks.

[@shakazulu8254]

What's a mess absurdité in highest level When the faith obliteted tour thought how sad use your brain not to fit with your faith created alternative reality but to search the truth only then you could free your mind from the bundaries of islam

[@aladinndrake110]

😊

[@WarriorWomann]

Dig dig dig .... 🕳

[@Bei-Abedan]

He really hasn't got a clue on what he is talking about lol

[@Endtime-dh9lk]

Ofcourse you can combine nonsense with nonsense without altering it being nonsense. 😁

[@farhanf3732]

HAHHAA good try. But, Farid say you can combine Hafs and Warsh since both are canonical thats not controversy to the Muslim. This video shows how desperate anti-Muslim to stop Islam Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala said: هُوَ الَّذِىٓ أَرْسَلَ رَسُولَهُۥ بِالْهُدٰى وَدِينِ الْحَقِّ لِيُظْهِرَهُۥ عَلَى الدِّينِ كُلِّهِۦ  ۚ وَكَفٰى بِاللَّهِ شَهِيدًا "It is He who sent His Messenger with guidance and the religion of truth to manifest it over all religion. And sufficient is Allah as Witness." (Qur'an surah Al-Fath 48: Verse 28)

[@farhanf3732]

@mysotiras5 There are seven mutawattir recitation to read the Qur'an. Muslim agree on this, if you cant understand at least dont lie. Furthermore, since Hafs,Warsh, and other five are both connected to the Prophet Muhammad shallallaahu 'alaihi wasallam so Muslim can combine those qiraat thats not controversy among the Muslim. The problem with someone like you is think that different qiraat is like corruption of the Bible, thats just make Muslim (even a layman) laugh at you Regarding 'change meaning' oo come on thats not change it corroborate and all of them go back to Prophet Muhammad shallallaahu 'alaihi wasallam For example Walahum 'adzaabun aliimun bimaa kaanuu yakdzibuun (Hafs) (for them the great punishment because they lie) Walahum 'adzaabun aliimun bimaa kaanuu yukadzdzibuun (Warsh) (for them great punishment because the accuse other to lie) Conclusion: great punishment is given to them not only they used to lie but also they accuse other to lie

[@islamicclarity7062]

@@farhanf3732 I would check out this video. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fX2ViZZqe8dsf5o

[@farhanf3732]

@@islamicclarity7062 Of course, even i know there are recitations which are not authentic thats why we have isnaad and choose/combine the seven connected recitation. Some Muslim on that tweet may thought Abu Safiyah doubt the preservation of Qur'an which is not the case at all

[@islamicclarity7062]

@@farhanf3732 No, that's not what the video is saying. The scholar is questioning Farid's reading that says all the readings are mutwatirah.

[@farhanf3732]

@@islamicclarity7062 Sorry man, i dont see where particullary Farid say all readings are mutawattir, In this video he says - Someone can combine mutawattir recitation In twitter he says - Ibn Jazari say thats mutawattir but Marijn and Abu Safiyah disagree Both not imply that all readings are mutawattir

[@lastprophet8338]

The more they talk the more holes they create in the Qurans