Captain America vs Captain America: Who Will Win? (Steve Rogers, Sam Wilson)

There’s a new Captain America in the MCU, and he has a really awesome suit to go with his new role. Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) will be donning the shield that Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) used for the entire Infinity Saga, and Sam definitely knows how to use it. He fits the identity as Captain America, but is he as strong as his predecessor? Could Sam Wilson’s Captain America beat Steve Rogers’ Captain America in a fight? This is currently being debated in Captain America: Cold War Marvel Comics storyline, but let’s settle this together right here, right now!
Subscribe:youtube.com/@CBR?sub_confirmation=1
Chapters:
0:00 Captain America VS Captain America
0:29 Steve Rogers’ Powers, Strengths, and Weaknesses
5:24 Sam Wilson’s Powers, Strengths, and Weaknesses
11:15 The Fight and the Outcome
Our Social Media:
/ cbr
/ comicbookresources
/ cbrgeeks
/ comic-book-resources
Our Website
www.cbr.com
Written by: Alex Atiyeh
Narrated by: Alex Atiyeh
Edited by: MA
For copyright matters please contact us at: [e-mail]

[@cbr]

Who do you think would win?

[@seanpatrickcain2]

Steve Rogers

[@angryb0325]

Steve Rogers for sure

[@popyilladayebga2570]

Is that a question

[@angryb0325]

@@popyilladayebga2570 Quesas

[@HeatherNickless-vt8zr]

It would be great if there was a (Captain America) Red Falcon vs Rhodes war machine (Iron Patriot).

[@CryptidZeker415]

Steve wins this fight if your talking about the MCU. As much as I love Sam, his track record does not support him to win against Steve. Steve defeated crossbones and a dozen hydra agents all at once without his shield. Sam was losing to just crossbones alone. Even when Sam got his wings, shield and tech as captain America, he was stalemated by batroc. Steve has a confirmed win against batroc. Sam and Bucky were subdued by spiderman, while Steve was able to subdue spiderman on his own. Steve wins this fight

[@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155]

Steve beat the crap out of a 15 yo boy. Sam & Bucky were trying to subdue him, Captain America slammed a metal shield into his face. Captain America tried to kill a 15 yo boy & you feel he is better than two men who tried not to hurt, again, a 15 yo boy?

[@heyman4088]

@@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155that has nothing to do with what they said nigga that 15 yo boy should’ve known better then to fight a literal war hero 💀

[@BLACKSTA361]

​@@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155wow this generation is soft

[@trexadvent4726]

Would it make sense if this video was made after we all saw Captain America 4 New World Order so that we can see how Sam Wilson is going to be like as the new Captain America?

[@tonycumberbatch7651]

Sure we can wait but Sam, won't do it alone he'll have Torres as the new Falcon.

[@chrislecount4801]

I think Steve Rogers would win: 1. He has the superhero serum. 2. He has more experience (having defeated/assisted in defeating Red Skull, Loki, The Winter Soldier, and Thanos.

[@malik6091]

Haven’t watched the video yet but I mean… one guy has the super soldier serum… the other one doesn’t

[@BLACKSTA361]

The other one has aerial advantage tbo

[@RomaroBrandon]

It's Steve Rogers until Sam Wilson can lift Mjolnir

[@yadielenielbellecolon982]

Thank For The Great Video 🥰😍

[@shyquezthomas9174]

Easily Steve Rogers cause Sam has always been his side kick

[@jonathanmendez310]

Sam didn't even wanna take the freaking serum. He ain't doing nothing

[@ShastaHawk]

Going with the comics, the original would win and it would be a very easy fight. Going with the movies, Steve would still win but with some difficulty. Steve has fought gun wielding opponents many times, even without his shield, so the guns won't even be a issue. And concerning the shield, it's a tool and not a crutch, so he's just as good a fighter without it as he is with it. Sam's only advantage is flight but once again, Steve has beaten flying heroes on multiple occasions.

[@budgiecat2885]

Steve would have difficulty? Sam needed Bucky to take down John Walker and John had JUST gotten accostumed to the serum and was unstable. And Sam and Bucky barely took him down. Steve would wipe the floor with Sam like it was nothing

[@IAmVortex-edits]

@@budgiecat2885yes but with his new vibraniam suit it could be more difficult I’m not saying sam wins case he definitely doesn’t but I think it could be a closer fight with how Sam could use his technology.

[@budgiecat2885]

@@IAmVortex-edits It seems Sam ditches the new suit in the next movie lol (Just another excuse to sell new merch; no one really ever keeps the same outfit in the MCU sans Vision. So even when it makes no sense (like why does Kamala Khan have a new suit in The Marvels when it takes place immediately at the post credit scene of her final episode?) like Sam ditching his new Vibranium suit, they do it for the new merch. But nah it wouldnt be a close fight lol Sam's suit isnt like T'Challa's or Homecoming Spidey tech suit. He still has no super soldier powers. All he has is flight. In the comics, Steve took a bullet to the head and LIVED

[@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155]

Just a thought/theory that as Wakanda has a Super Soldier Serum & Nanotechnology, could they have given it to Sam Wilson via his new suit?

[@HeatherNickless-vt8zr]

It could be possible but remember that it was reckless of Sam to pass off the Captain America identity to some showboat warrior but the people giving the wrong Cap. America the serum was even more reckless.

[@HeatherNickless-vt8zr]

We know well enough of Sam's type of character that there was no way he would even think of touching the stuff.

[@HeatherNickless-vt8zr]

In fact; Fake Cap. was even quicker to accept the power of the super soldier serum than Steve Rogers was.

[@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155]

@@HeatherNickless-vt8zr Correct & agreed, which is exactly why he is perfect to get the Super Soldier Serum. And, remember that Wakanda is basically a dictatorship run by the best warrior & I would not put it past then to dose Sam with it against his will.

[@HeatherNickless-vt8zr]

​@@trippsmythoftheaurigancoal8155 ; Wakanda is not a Dictatorship; Killmonger only made it a Dictatorship when he thought he killed T'challa the first; he never listened to reason; he was hotter in the head than Namor had been and by comparison; Namor only sought out vengeance for his people's wellbeing; but Killmonger wanted war to justify his vendetta to those who wronged him as well as wage a third world war.

[@shanebigfella7884]

I had my captain america shirt on this morning before this dropped. YOU KNOW MY ANSWER

[@tylermakray2279]

Ummm....Sam doesn't have any abilities, cap is a super soldier, idk how this is a question 😂

[@Potato_Sama]

Flying isn't an ability?

[@tylermakray2279]

@@Potato_Sama no because he needs a suit to fly, he doesn't actually have that ability

[@Potato_Sama]

@@tylermakray2279 Steve needed steroids to be good he didn’t naturally have that ability either

[@tylermakray2279]

@@Potato_Sama no it was a super soldier serum, not just steroids, it makes him super strong, super fast, it increased his intelligence which is why he can throw his shield and use geometry to make it always come back to him, also enhanced all senses , and a low level healing factor, read a comic

[@tylermakray2279]

@@Potato_Sama also sam was beaten single handedly by antman in the first antman movie when they has to steal that thing from the avengers compound

[@theeyeopener4141]

Steve....because he can fight all day, and Sam can't cause he has other things to do than to fight all day...Lmaooo

[@Cj_Cadillac3477]

I appreciate the honest breakdown and giving my boi falcon a fighting chance.

[@budgiecat2885]

even though it makes no sense

[@grownmannn2]

Ayyye!!! I remember when Sam made all those birds poop on Steve in the comics hilarious

[@BODYGUARDAXI1GOD007]

Nice it saw❤

[@NightSurgeon09]

And the winner is...Isaiah Bradley! Come on, guy kicked Winter Soldier's ass back in Vietnam. Steve only broke even with Bucky in their second encounter. And sam captured buckey on his own. (Don't hate me, I love Steve too).

[@davidburris120]

I think Steve’s got this on but correct me if I’m wrong within the comic doesn’t Sam eventually get the super soldier serum? If that’s the case, I wonder if he’ll get it in his upcoming movie and if that would give him the edge over Steve. Your argument about Steve’s weakness when the enemy is a friendly v. Sam’s drive is valid, but I think Steve would be a similar weakness to Sam. He looks up to and admires Steve like no other.

[@CryptidZeker415]

Neither sam or Bucky got the super soldier serum in the comics. Sam's only power is that he can communicate with birds

[@tillymccarthy6739]

sam fell short multiple times to people like spiderman, antman and lets be honest steve would win in a fight. Meanwhile steve fell short to a purple giant who had infinity stones

[@CoolMan1_SonicAndOtherStuff]

Steve Rogers was the original, and the one Sam is still trying to live up to. So it's obviously Steve. Although Sam is also a great fighter.

[@tillymccarthy6739]

steve would win no question

[@SirsasthNigam.]

Steve's lack of ranged attack was unexpected

[@sultanahad]

My favorite is Steve Roger in The MCU and he will win

[@user-oe6fg4yh9h]

What if you would have done it like they did not know each other it would have been a different story and if you count the fact that Steve is not only worthy of Mjolnir he is worthy of Stormbreaker and Jane Fosters version of Mjolnir and the shield from Black panther in Infinity war so Steve would had an advantage against Sam

[@paulr5391]

That can be said about Captain America Verse Batman. In my opinion. Yes, I am a Batman fan.

[@cp37373]

Steve wins easily. Obviously.

[@krissybates7356]

Well, I think about Steve Rogers and Sam. They are different. Steve is average. And I know he never want to hurt anyone, but that was how do I brainwash Steve. And he forgot his normal life when he was skinny kid he was chosen one. Sam is. Says a normal guy.

[@kain772]

Remember! That's America's ass. Steve Roger's all day 😂

[@tanaka7341]

Batman and batman

[@johnchanchanqiyang1369]

Steve Rogers is the best

[@jasonwashington8697]

Without the serum Sam would win easy.

[@akinwaleakingboye3976]

Cap because mjliounir is long range attack

[@BLACKSTA361]

Isiah bradley or John Walker beat both

[@Larv6464]

The answer is obviously captain America 😂

[@jasonrohan7471]

Steve Roger's is my choice. Hey, I'm old fashioned.

[@budgiecat2885]

Thats not old fasion thats just logical. Sam has no chance. He needed Bucky to defeat John Walker and they barely did it. How the hell could he beat Steve who is better than John. This video shouldnt even exist.

[@navodayanethmal6752]

Steve Rogers with mjolnir No chance

[@Fitnessgam3r]

I say Steve rogers will win just cuz he is more skillful in battle also he now have Thor’s hammer like u say he doesn’t have ranger power now he have electricity 😊

[@Ballisticplays_]

Steve easily wins

[@CaptainAmerict]

Captain america wins

[@The_Infamous_Boogyman]

Rogers beat iron man even when scanning his fight oattern and had lasers and shit. Falcon cant touch that tech. It's Rogers

[@sharonjiles3889]

Steve Rogers win .

[@heyman4088]

Another horrible take, Steve Rogers would destroy Sam Wilson with or without a shield he’s overall better in every way, a better fighter and has WAY more feats of him defeating stronger foes and has more experience and is a smarter fighter in the battle field this shows the lack of research y’all do 💀

[@TevronPlays]

They stalemated in an arm wrestle in the comics. Steve has the edge in h2h and Sam has the edge in skill, cuz of the tech he can work with. It's hard to decide man. If this is on MCU terms. Steve washes Sam.

[@TevronPlays]

kzbin.infobksIuL6z6vw?feature=shared

[@htownboss6422]

Sam wins in the sky he is super op

[@waterlessgeothermal]

steve rogers fought ultron steve would blow sam out of the water.

[@htownboss6422]

@@waterlessgeothermal he wouldn't hit him

[@Jamie_Winsh]

Tbf Sam could definitely hold his own and does have a chance to win but i think ultimately Steve would come out on top

[@cp37373]

Lmfao

[@budgiecat2885]

Did you not see Falcon & the Winter Soldier? It took Sam AND Bucky to take John Walker down. And John was unstable. Steve would punt kick Sam

[@tonycumberbatch7651]

Sam wins. His aerial ability, his use of weaponry and, his Wakanda technology just give him the edge. Also, Sam knows how to use the Caps shield. That said, Captain America will always be Steve Roger as, he just Awesome. Just give him a Wakanda made suit and Mjölnir and Cap wins. Sam has no defence against the lightning, he just gets fried. P.S. Cap uses computer technology and is a master of combat strategy in the comics and "He Can Do It All Day".

[@cp37373]

Sam gets smoked quite easily obviously.

[@TheDarkknight711]

You mean Captain America vs Falcon

[@ajjemal4355]

I think captain America will win lol

[@thehpexplorers5767]

First

[@E4T3MUP55]

"I'm 99.99% sure Sam would win." Outro: "I think Sam would win but to be honest, I'm not 100% on my current answer."

[@abdiasisabdi2104]

When it comes to raw strength, there are a handful of humans stronger than Steve Rogers. Sure, Sam Wilson trained in the United States Airforce and can hold his own on a fight. But he was overpowered in a one on one duel against Rumlow.

[@ShastaHawk]

There's many more than a handful, dude. Steve's max lift is at 1000 pounds, and that's with his legs, and there's at least hundreds more MUCH stronger than that. With that said, Steve has beaten characters much stronger than him with speed and leverage.

[@blairadams8892]

This has to be a joke! Seriously you think Sam Wilson’s capt would beat Steve Rodgers capt.! Steve went against thanos with damn mjolnir, fought and bested iron man, punching and breaking Ultron robots, and your saying Sam would win!? I’m baffled at this video. 😂