Carly Smithson - Total Eclipse Of The Heart - Top 10

-CHECK OUT CARLY SMITHSON OFFICIAL MYSPACE PAGE AT: www.myspace.com... -
Carly Smithson performs Bonny Tayler's 'Total Eclipse Of The Heart' on American Idol Top 10 night.
carly smithson brooke white david cook archuleta jason castro syesha mercado michael johns kristy lee cook music song songs tv show performance bonny taylor

[@cbotten106]

Carly's voice on the studio version of this song is pure magic. Seek it out.

[@markobanion5018]

She is STILL better than most of the contestants today.

[@mariedodd]

I still think Carly was one of the all time favorites over the past 10 seasons! She should have made it to number one! She is one of the best performers AI ever had! Hope her career is going well. What a great talent!!!!!!! Marie

[@justincferrell]

I agree!! She was amazing, man. America did her D I R T Y! I can’t remember, you remember how far she got? This wasn’t the episode of her elimination was it?

[@AllyR0402]

Miss Carly so much. Was disappointed when she didn't come out with her own album. We are the Fallen had a good CD but I would have liked a little more pop songs from her. Hope she is doing well.

[@MIX3DVI3WS]

We are the fallen stopped her solo album. Which sucked. They scrapped it as soon as she met Ben. I remember looking forward to it and then we are the fallen came out.

[@Neo2906]

man, what a briliant voice. can`t understand that...i think that was the perfect song for her voice. Love it !!!! Greetz Neo

[@mikeverderosa3601]

Rightful winner imo

[@nikaledesma]

yeah she's one of the great singers in american idol ALL seasons.

[@AnnieTigerChucky]

It was a disgrace when she was voted off at top 6 and michael johns was voted off at top 8. Honestly, when Jason Castro was in the bottom 3 in the top 6 elimination night and was the first one safe, I wanted to rip out his dreadlocks. Simon couldn't even stand him saying his singing was "atrocious." Top 5 should've been: Brook White (Top 5), Michael Johns (Top 4), Carly Smithson (Top 3), and the two Davids in the top 2 finale.

[@KpopTwice1]

Agreed!!!

[@jamal_eboni4]

Annie TigerChucky Syesha was amazing as well

[@MIX3DVI3WS]

Syesha should have been top 3 like she was. She was truly great. Should have been Smithson Archuleta and Syesha

[@michellemoh75]

Love this!!!

[@pikachupokemon1731]

Good stuff!!!!!!!!!

[@mistyeyedlass]

wow. i love carly!

[@pauldrumsonly]

best season ever

[@bummerboi2]

still a great singer xxxx

[@0503cat]

i love her curly hair,,haha so cute :D

[@gatarharo]

I LOVE HER!!!!!!!!

[@crislanenascimentolee4982]

linda, Brasil ❤

[@woolfallcrescent170]

we are the fallen rule!!!

[@falouchelo]

wow..i cant tell who sing it better...bonnie tyler or carly smithson"!!!!

[@hahs4]

she was really good at the beginning

[@anjas1903]

to be honest I like it better then original..

[@corsairusawc]

nice

[@camillerocks]

I love you! I love you! I love you! I love you!

[@mcmuffinerson]

I don't. If she had won she would have been a slave to American Idol's contract. They would have had total rights to her music and her image, having the right to change everything about how she appears, down to her hair color and the way she dresses. Now she's with WATF and is free to be the artist she wants. This was for the best.

[@CreativeTeamGMA7]

Her mom looks like Xena warrior princess

[@scm8487]

Very difficult to compete with Bonnie Tyler

[@viciouscanadianvixen]

@amykoto ...A LOT of people want to be like madonna and with good reason. it doesn't make them "fake" and it definitely isn't "shameful". madonna can't be duplicated, however, her achievements in the music industry can. i'm a HUGE madonna fan, however, vocally, she isn't spectacular-she just knows how to sell it and entertain to make people enjoy the music.

[@ventues9751]

This is a very hard song to sing Live. Bonnie Tyler can't even sing it live

[@LesleighHart]

wow this song really suits her and is rarely sung well as a cover

[@KenlovesJ]

She is very beautiful...i just can't find why people think she is such a great singer...this is video #3 that i have seen of her and she is not making a good impression...maybe she's one of the people that need songs to fit their voice. I wanna hear how she sounds with Fallen.

[@cbotten106]

Earth signs rule !

[@cheetahtje4]

She has a powerfull voice, chapeau

[@amazonbass]

She humiliated the choir.

[@mcmuffinerson]

Because people change their minds -_-

[@iamlindavilela]

Her highs are a lil weird, I think, but amazing performance!!!

[@dboyd7022001]

Randy and Simon weren't wrong but weren't 100% right. Overall, it wasn't a bad performance but wasn't American Idol winner material, either. I'm stoked for the revamp with Katy Perry as a judge (and Randy/Simon NOT!) They should seriously bring back Paula and throw in Carrie, Chris Daughtry, Kris Allen (because he's from Arkansas), Adam Lambert, Lauren Alaina, Scotty McCreery, Katherine McPhee, Pia Toscano (robbed of going further), Tim Urban (same as Pia), or Thia Megia (not a lot of Asian judges!) Hell, I would even take Kellie Pickler (as long as the audience didn't distract her with pickles!)

[@ShaulHaShablul]

amykoto how old are you? if you got to live enough years you probably know that if in your childhood you wanted to be for example a fireman there is NO chance you'll end up as one.

[@julianfarnfield-sykes1372]

The mic volume is too loud !

[@Xchantal87X]

she sings it perfect i ask myself what is she doing by idols she dont have to learn to sing:P

[@Slavic-King1917]

Not as good as Bonnie, BUT I give her props for trying

[@starofelo]

I'm gunna be honest- I really really dislike this song. If I ever hear it I change it fast, I just can't stand it. This version is the first version i've liked! I love it, love her :D Whyyy did she not win?

[@samsong24]

What? That note was totally in tune at the end. Randy needs his ears checked.

[@jl1008]

Bonnie Tyler*

[@jaycewheeled]

Madonna? Kylie Minogue? Come on, as far as voice is concerned they can't stand the comparison (with all the respect to Madonna and Kylie, two great artist). I would like to hear them performing this song...don't think they nailed it like Carly did.

[@DemonSlayer2121]

You always wanted to be a POP star? Be like Madona? Then why did you go all goth and do rock music...

[@jeremywhitworth7299]

When it comes to certain songs, you’re better off leaving them alone during a singing competition. Carrie Underwood pulled off Heart during her competition and it was great. She obviously had the talent to pull that off.

[@Gonkawonga]

Paula was on meds?

[@patrickruth153]

It bothers me she kinda looks like me as a baby

[@jackson4socks]

Randy needs his ears checked

[@nikaledesma]

she didn't really quite nailed the song. the song is to way high for her. but love her big voice.

[@ConcertgoerJ.R.]

I thought she did great, that last note was over sung however!

[@cbotten106]

Really? I'd say you've given her more than a fair shot...time to move on.

[@justschr]

She's shouting! OMG this version is awful!

[@miciray]

Oh how I wish that Carly won Idols!! She is truly amazing!! GO CARLY!!!!

[@MrTuxedoCat1]

I HAVE THE SAME BIRTHDAY AS HER