Caruso/Lanza/Pavarotti - O sole mio

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

Mario Lanza was great in his films.

[@cattycassals]

Mario lanza is from my home town. I feel he had the best voice

[@tonygrimaldi3534]

Lanza was the best

[@michaelmika2995]

Beautiful 😢❤😊

[@marymelody8223]

When Mario Lanza held me in his arms and sang to me lovingly....... I was less than one year old, cast as his baby daughter Gloria, in the film, The Great Caruso

[@SonySony-tm6wd]

Мдельдмонака

[@domenicomarcucci8002]

Divino

[@blancagumucio840]

Wow! What a fortunate girl!

[@ireneputnam1065]

You were touched by greatness!

[@cornelio5777]

Touched by an Angel...

[@frankmartinez2655]

The American King Tenor..."O sole mio!!!"

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

I have always loved this song and it is lovely to see a photograph of the worlds greatest tenor who ever lived. That is my opinion. EC himself.

[@ИннаБорисовна-ю5у]

Трудно дать комунибудь предпочтение. Все три певца гениально талантливы. Каждый поёт со своим, только ему присущи темпераментное. ❤❤❤

[@mariateresagorosito4539]

Que hermosura es la más hermosa canción ...un derroche de talento .sería injusto elegir....son exelente los tres...!! maravillosos ❤

[@hernandourdaneta5097]

Lanza, Pavarotti y Caruso, en ése orden. Un privilegio escuchar éstas magníficas voces.

[@michaelmika2995]

Brings tears 😢 to my old eyes..

[@ЕвгенийСергеев-я5ю]

Прослушка одну мелодию заслуженно с каким отрывом по красоте голоса отдаю предпочтение любимому Марио Ланца жаль что ушел от нас так рано

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

When I was a child. I also listened to the man who was known as count John McCormack.

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

I was sad Pavarotti passed away. A great loss to the world of music.

[@michelafragala6425]

Bravo bravissimo che bella canzone Napoli 👍👍👍💫💫💥💥💥💫

[@np9979]

Моя мама пела,мой папа играл на фортепиано все неаполитанские песни.так прошло моё детство в СССР 70х.

[@JamesAnderson-pt1ds]

Lanza,,,,,all day long.

[@carlosandressanchezgiraldo1070]

Tan magistral y encantadoras voces ,que hasta los pájaros callaban para disfrutar ,estas celestiales interpretaciones, inmortales ,vida eterna para estos grades,que privilegio poder disfrutarlos.

[@DA-to1ej]

Lanza!

[@np100]

When I was a small child, my father used to sing this song and many of Caruso's to me. I never thought I would find them again. THANK YOU!

[@jorgetrujilloalbornoz6213]

No sabia de este gran tenor mario lanza , pero que voz tan potente y sublime extraordinario los 3

[@joeblack8915]

Lanza owns it by a mile.

[@rosadandrea6531]

Me encanta O sole mío. piu bella!!

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

I have always enjoyed listening to the three tenors mentioned. There was another tenor whom I liked as a child. John McCormack.

[@ЮрийБакиев-н7и]

АЛИЛЛУЙЯ ! БРАВО ! КЛАСС ! МАСТЕРА ВСЕ : ЭНРИКО КАРУЗО , МАРИО ЛАНЦА И ПАВАРОТТИ ! СУПЕР ГОЛОСА ! КРУТЫЕ МАСТЕРА ПЕНИЯ ! ТВОРЧЕСКИЕ БОГИ ! СПАСИБО ! ....../ ОНИ МНЕ ДУШУ ВЫВОРАЧИВАЮТ ! /🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊🌹🕊

[@frankmartinez2655]

El Rey Enrico Caruso viva siempre...

[@franciscohernandez2638]

Grandes tenores caruso grandioso lanza grande Pavarotti

[@johnboszko2032]

A beautiful song sung by professional, simply wonderful

[@lsmart]

I cannot fathom how anyone could pick another tenor as the greatest ever. Besides the deafening power of his voice, the ability of his high notes to grow in power (which no other singer could do), and the sheer richness of his voice from top to bottom, it is his singing that REALLY has no equal. This is just one of dozens of arias and songs for which the Caruso performance is the best, simply because literally every syllable is perfectly phrased, sung with the perfect tempo and emotion, and yet musically perfect as well. Unlike the Corellis and Martinellis who sacrificed musical perfection for emotional impact, and the Bjorlings and Schipas, who sacrificed emotional fervor to get musical perfection, Caruso managed to get perfection in both. And I say all this despite being a Luciano fanatic.

[@jorgegb6]

Por siempre..... Mario Lanza !!!!

[@leonelseabra7032]

Uma das mais belas cançonetas italianas,cantada e Bem,por alguns dos MELHORES que ja apareceram no mundo.

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

I agree. I thought I would never be able to hear their voices again. So it is a big thank you to YOU TUBE for giving us this opportunity to do so. I am sure everyone who like this type of music will agree with me.

[@foruro]

lastima que hemos perdido tan bellas voces aunque otros vienen pero nadie ocupa el puesto de ninguno de ellos son unicos menos mal que podemos por medio de ustedes disfrutar de tan bellas voces que son regalos para nuestros oidos y sentimientos muchas gracias al que aportó este recuerdo a youtube una vez más gracias

[@JoseSilva-xd7se]

É uma benção e um previlégio termos estas peças ao nosso alcance.

[@renatafriedenberg4292]

What a performance, beautiful voices!!!

[@ВалентинаПаршина-ф5д]

Марио Ланца отдаю предпочтение... понимаю, что не судят о Голосе с носителей звукозаписывающих устройств... Голос Марио и его пение - объёмны, драматичны, глубоки...без завлекательных "трелей"... для меня это важно... ♥️♥️♥️👏👏👏🌹🌹🌼

[@thirty6min]

It is amazing how the recording technology have advanced. The eardrums were gradually less assaulted from Caruso to Lanza to Pavarottti. This is a great post to compare the three, thanks.

[@chamitoguajiro3709]

Caruso incomparable , creo que sus fanáticos veían en Lanza a Caruso , eso se llama Añoranza.

[@medmond6]

To hear a legendary singer from another age (Caruso) is amazing especially in the quality of the transcription. BTW they were all great.

[@inescacharron9832]

Esto es demasiado, poder comparar las tres voces en una canción tan bella

[@cato5553]

No se puede comparar ..con la tecnologia de studio ... Uno grabacion primitiva ..la voz de Caruso aplaca a la fieras ... La segunda con orquesta y la tercera ... CARUSO con estas tecnologia serua lo que es LEYENDA..

[@lawrencemcgranaghan6190]

Absolutely fantastic.

[@pijushdutta2641]

In 60yrs i have heard many great voices but he ia great singer cannot compared wih other siñgers worldwide he is special

[@roybernardo9946]

Why even choose all three are truly amazing.

[@j.chaves530]

VOZES QUE JAMAIS MORRERÃO.

[@NeroBurnR]

Марио Ланца Лучший!

[@franciscohernandez2638]

Tres genios de la música de todos los tiempos fabulosa interpretación

[@lucasvelasco4866]

La verdad.. M. Lanza tiene.1 caudal impresionante...Y hasta parece que grita!!! (Admiro grandemente su talento pues x el supe quien.era Caruso) Enrico cantaba...SIN.DESPEINARSE y era 1 gran interprete

[@jd-gw4gr]

i forgot how great the great lanza was, thank you for the reminder, but how can one distinguish between the other great singers: caruso, pavarotti? how! like splitting hairs.

[@atlatahuac]

just deee-light-ful! thanx so much. Of late, with all these you tube recordings and ability to listen to cleaned up greats of primitive recordings era, these 'invidious' comparisons have been a guilty pleasure.

[@manonlapert3452]

A 7 ans avec nos parents à la campagne un bonheur

[@Άννα-ο1η]

Несравненный Карузо! Ему нет равных!

[@azyuwish99]

My father heard both Caruso and Lanza and his preference was actually Lanza. To me Lanza sounds here as if he has endless power and could draw on it forever, like a window of sound pouring through him.

[@lisaborsella5412]

Sounds like you know music. So do I, and you are so right! I am going through a rough time in my life and this sure helps

[@cjosborne9430]

Lanza had no discipline and his voice remained untrained. Yes, he was blessed with a fabulous voice, and he could apply a lot of "gusto" (the few times he sang) but was such a diva snot that no one could stand him.

[@roxalysmendez7941]

Extasiado al escuchar a estos grandes, mis respetos Tom !Saludos!

[@apolinar2011]

Tres Soles de la musica clasica

[@susanabaeza6679]

Música lirica

[@Medietos]

Divinelyu sublime! Thank you very much.

[@susanabaeza6679]

Me quedo con la interpretación de Mario Lanza es magistral. Luego con Luciano Pavarotti que fue en vivo y fue hermosa, y por último con Enrico Caruso linda interpretación pero como la grabación es antigua no se escucha bien.

[@roxalysmendez7941]

Mis respetos para el gran Caruso ,Pavarotti, pero la voz que verdaderamente sobresale por su impecable y pasional interpretacion es la del gran Lanza

[@violinalang5292]

#1 Caruso

[@josemariperezy.826]

Si se escucha bien..son distintas sus voces...el mejor Fernando de Lucia aunque la canta medio tono bajo..distintos ..ni mejor ni peor...señores entendidos..el extravagante..Mario lanza

[@lt6245]

My ears tell me that Mario Lanza sounds the best

[@r.j.delahoya7679]

Caruso!

[@juracydiassantos3193]

Três gênio, mais fico com Caruso, fico apensar se Caruso existe nos dias de hoje.

[@tomfroekjaer]

Glad you liked it. Another video with comparisons can be found here on KZbin under this heading: Bjoerling, Schmidt, Gigli - O Sole Mio

[@eduardobarreto4]

Mario Lanza por la milla clasica:fuerza,emoción y tecnica.Caruso nunca me ha gustado su forma de cantar empujando la voz yPavarotti la canta muy livianamente,como para salir del paso.

[@sugarbist]

Caruso sings this song with the best interpretation and the least exaggeration

[@ursmue1937]

You have to cry with the wolves. Lanza sings emotionally, simply beautiful, against M.L. Caruso is a bit colourless here. But your expert opinion in God's ear.

[@danieltadey]

Exacto, y hay que entender que la grabación de Caruso tiene cien años, y a pesar de las limitaciones técnicas, sigue siendo brillante!

[@cjosborne9430]

You are correct. Caruso's voice was trained and retained its magic. Lanza was "too important" to stick around for any training. He wanted to belt, get a check, and then have a belt. A prima donna with zero discipline.

[@sugarbist]

@@cjosborne9430 In actuality , Lanza did train with Enrico Rosati for about 15 months. Rosati was initially enthused by Lanza and said, for 34 years since Gigli, I have been waiting for a voice like this. There have been many other positives written about Lanza's voice. However, Rosati also claimed that Lanza was not disciplined, showing up late for lessons, claiming that a young lady kept him up all night, showing up hungover at times and refusing to learn solfeggi. Rosati became frustrated with Lanza's behavior. In a way I feel fortunate that we had Lanza's great voice, but also a little cheated because he never truly had an operatic career. Even in this O Sole Mio, the recording sounds enhanced and if you listen closely, Lanza sings ''Manario'' Sole` instead of Manato Sole and doubles the consonant in sole as solle at about 4.00. The double consonant is not a big thing, but for me the ''Manario Sole'' is annoying. Still a great voice. In My Opinion, If Lanza had the discipline of a Corelli, Gigli, Volpi or Del Monaco, he might have become a great operatic tenor. Enjoy

[@xxx-ji9ot]

Insuperables. Los tres grandes tenores. Que melancolia me embarga cuando oigo a estos grandes cantores italianos.

[@hildahernandezmanrique4755]

Hermosa canción

[@charlschabort7612]

caruso i love best most emotion

[@danielveliz8109]

Caruso por siempre 💕

[@tomfroekjaer]

Yeah, you 've seen through me :-) No, they are all great in their own way. The digitally remastered Caruso version was a mistake, of course, and the Pavarotti version doesn't really do justice to him. I had to pick the shortest version I could find due to KZbin limitations.

[@operaguy1]

Study the lyric. It is ravishing. He is overcome with joy when he "sees his sun rise in her eyes." If you have ever seen that exact thing blossom in the eyes of the one you love, you will understand.

[@danielformica-yourvocalteacher]

lots of comments.. remember different times in each singers career there really is no judging.. also live versus studio come on people..

[@hartmutlorentzen9659]

Da gibt es nichts zu diskutieren: Caruso singt ohne Schnörkel und ohne opernhaftes Gehabe. Kurz : er ist der Beste!

[@tomfroekjaer]

@ShawDAMAN Two years later I respond :-) Yes, absolutely, Lanza was definately the best choice as to portraying Caruso. Sorry about the delay !

[@ShawDAMAN]

Very nice. I'm going with Lanza. Most naturally beautiful voice of the 3 in my opinion. That passage from 6:10-6:21 gives me goosebumps. Caruso great of course. Congrats on picking, perhaps, the 3 greatest singers of this song ever :)

[@guillermototivilo811]

Lanza Is the greatest

[@LadyDoc]

I agree. Lanza’s voice was the most lovely sound of all the tenors of the second half of the 20th century.

[@Mooorhe]

Yeah, I've come around and I'm happy that I have :P. I still don't listen to him as much as I would if the recording quality was better.

[@r.j.delahoya7679]

1 caruso, 2. lanza. 3. pavarotti

[@nov1731]

Caruso is the one who DOESN'T scream - making it into an art song Even with the limitations of the recordings of the time, he sings it like he loves it.

[@roxalysmendez7941]

Fred Romagnolo es problema es que Caruso no podía gritar tan alto como Lanza y escucharse tan bien.

[@chessiepique9532]

+Fred Romagnolo Totally with you, man. Recording quality, range ... who cares?

[@roxalysmendez7941]

+Chessie Pique !To me!!

[@chessiepique9532]

roxalys mendez To each their own, and I respect your opinion. If I had a range of more than an octave, maybe I'd take more interest. :)

[@roxalysmendez7941]

an octave? What about you, Mario Lanza or me?

[@tomfroekjaer]

I agree with all you said - including your comment on the remastered Caruso version :-) Just had it handy...

[@sammydefauw6756]

Enrico caruso,+overleden en mario lanza heeft het grzongen on film ok defauw raymond 🎉

[@allachikarina1826]

Величайшие Теноры Bravissimo.

[@tomfroekjaer]

@dghulati: no, the Pavarotti recording is absolutely no good; sorry about that.... The Caruso recording, in fact, isn't either (remastering ruins the nuances).

[@glendagaskin151]

Thanks. We appreciate your efforts. No comparison. Pavarotti will never be equaled. His power is unbelievable. What a God we serve to be the Creator. The power to give us gifts.

[@dorothywhite8645]

Mario Lanza's voice is rich. Pavarotti sings beautifully but with the same voice. Lanza's changes with the music. They are all great, but to me Mario is the best

[@sugarbist]

Dear Dorothy, I think Lanza's version is overblown and the recording is enhanced and schmaltzy. There also is no word in Italian or dialect as MANARIO

[@helenesandford9870]

Are the words o my sun shine

[@roxalysmendez7941]

this is not ... that is the other, that this or the other is better, so any of these versions are the best of these huge artists.this is not ... that is the other, that this or the other is better, so any of these versions are the best of these huge artists.

[@oldschoolw3]

Gran interpretacion,buenas de nuevo roxalys me gustaria darte mi whasap para pasarte nuevas grabaciones para que veas los progresos y todo eso :P

[@oldschoolw3]

No se si te acordaras de mi,hace bastantes meses te pase una grabacvion mia de nessum dorma que me dijiste que era baritono y que tenia que hacer ejercicios y todo eso.

[@roxalysmendez7941]

Unai Seoane por supuesto que recuerdo a vos, mi estimado Unai , con gusto espero vuestras grabaciones y os daré nuestra humilde opinión !Saludos!

[@oldschoolw3]

valee gracias :P mi numero de whasap es este 665701711 cuando eso hablame y te mando las grabaciones no grabe video !Saludos!

[@tomfroekjaer]

We accord fully, then :-) Concerning Caruso I for some reason was never bother by the poor recording quality. Unfortunately we'll never really be able to experience the full impact of his voice. But according to eye/hear witnesses most of the nuances have been lost in the recordings.

[@nataliyaberezovsksys2372]

I think Mario Lanza is the best of them

[@Cocus62]

Please, hear the other rendition(O sole mio) of Mario Lanza upload for bestsoundbox ........

[@vercingetorixkingofgalia7196]

Caruso.

[@ЮрийБакиев-д7ж]

💞🍒💞🍒💞🍒💞🍒💞🍒💞

[@roxalysmendez7941]

Inmenso Lanza.........

[@cjosborne9430]

Lanza was RAW and untrained. But, he is loud. If loud is best, then Lanza wins. Caruso's voice is from heaven!

[@Ricardo-jz1kf]

Se puede escuchar algo mejor , que a estos tres grandes tenores? Me atrevo a decir que imposible.

[@ShawDAMAN]

Incidentally, Lanza was always humble when compared to Caruso- around the time of his first movie he said "I wish they (the critics) wouldn't compare me to Caruso. I've got a long way to go before I even rate a mention in the same breath as Caruso." He echoed the same thoughts many other times. Show me another tenor, though, who was better equipped in voice and appearance to portray Caruso in a tribute film.

[@cjosborne9430]

Mario Lanza had a powerful voice. But, it was so untrained, and he was so undisciplined, that it becomes annoying over time. ML (fake name) fought with everyone, never took good advice, and was a general pain in the posterior. IF he had the discipline to train, and learn, and practice, he might have become great over time. He was SO popular and SO successful that he "ran away" from Hollywood and relocated in Rome, Italy (where his parents were never from, his mother was from Abruzzo, and his father was from Molise) so even his "pouts" didn't make sense).

[@valeriedavidson2785]

@@cjosborne9430 He was the best. There will never be another.

[@ursmue1937]

@@cjosborne9430, Lanza untrained ? 😂 Look Pappano on Lanza 😅

[@Mooorhe]

Interestingly, I think it was thinking and analyzing Caruso's recordings that made me take so long to realise that Caruso's voice was so good. The poor recording quality got on my nerves when I analyzed, I think just letting the voice take you to heaven without paying too much attention to it. I think it's a wonderful thing when a singer can you make you sit back and enjoy rather than pay attention to every detail; it's part of why I love Pavarotti and Caruso so much.

[@valeriedavidson2785]

I think Mario was the greatest. I was a teenager when he was famous and his voice took me to heaven. I never could understand why people thought Pavarotti was special. He did nothing for me.

[@mardav33]

Hearing all the comparisons, it sounds to me that Mario's voice is a little deeper and stronger than the others, maybe because of the quality of the recordings. Mario Lanza will always be my favorite. He had more feeling in his music.

[@cjosborne9430]

Lanza was also untrained and undisciplined, so he "made up for it in raw emotion." If he had the discipline to not fight with every human being on earth, he would have gone far. But, he was a skunk and that counts for something. Caruso was real and it shows in his strong voice. Lanza was loud. There is a difference between strong and loud.

[@erzsebetszajko28]

Régen halott szépségek

[@ИринаМалафеева-ы6ш]

Ланца более искренен и убедительней!!!

[@robertd7790]

Mario Lanza #1 Caruso #2. Pavoratti #3

[@guedouarandree9285]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ursmue1937]

Ja, beim langsam laufen 😊

[@aldolanini3815]

Caruso caruso caruso