Case Study : I am an Expert, I don't need Investment Advice

Promo Code: WORLDCUP (Highest Ever Discount of 65% on Model Portfolios, Stock-O-Meter Plus & Fund-O-Meter)
Please visit investyadnya.in

[@tajji4u]

coffee Can wale manager ne to itna bhi nahi banaya hai, to fir manager ka selection bhi ek task hai

[@vineetjuneja3883]

Direct investor are just one bear market away from becoming the mutual fund investor :)

[@akshaynaik1719]

.. away from becoming FD investor.

[@vineetjuneja3883]

@@akshaynaik1719 😂

[@drarunaj]

My Father is a direct stock investor from 2006.. with a CAGR of 27%.

[@anandpatel4502]

@@drarunaj when market is all time high everyone with old investments becomes jhunjhunwala. Jan 2008 (all time highs during bank crisis) to april 2014 almost 6 years to reach its peak level of 2008 means old investors with holdings got no returns at all.

[@ramyasri6093]

Well said

[@SPR632]

He can invest 4 cr through mutual fund portfolio or fund manager guided stock portfolio. And he can test his knowledge or expertise through rest 1Cr capital.

[@prashantjambhale6733]

Sometimes too much advice is harmful

[@mahendrakumaroli2559]

While doing business we do select only one business and not worried about what others are doing or earning. In stock investing few business, as no direct control, 5-8 stocks are more than enough, whatever may be portfolio size. Business is all about taking positive calculative risk. One can't do business with mindset of an employee. What if the said investor is beating the benchmark or not, he is enjoying his journey while taking care of all his need. Points to remember 1) Whatever amount you have invested has nothing to do in direct stock investing what is your current value is all that what you have, if you are in loss and feel you have done a mistake book loss immediately and move to other stock, else wait patiently, with time you will be profitable. 2) If one just follow percentage distribution among large cap, midcap and small cap, you are looking for guaranteed/ safe return in an uncertain business environment. There is no sucess formula in direct stock investing it's all about taking calculative positive risks.

[@ParimalAde]

I agree, happiness & peace of mind is most important part of life 👍

[@dgr8oneme]

Statistically in India, on an average 50% mutual funds beat index fund every year. Primarily this might look like one can choose mutual fund have have a 50-50 chance of doing better than the benchmark.. BUT the key factor is that, that list of 50% mutual funds changes every year... Which means the mutual funds which CONSISTENTLY beat index fund OVER A NUMBER OF YEARS is very very small.. so if you do not like the probablity of finding those very few mutual funds, then investing in index fund insures that you don't underperform the bechmark. So INDEX FUND Investment over a long period of time is the best bet for most of the investors

[@maheshgaria3366]

Perfect and Golden advise

[@uttamdey1249]

True teacher..... Stock market ka mera ak sachcha Guru....

[@anandpatel4502]

7:40 even fund manager hardly can beat index funds in long run.

[@ParimalAde]

Then index fund is the answer

[@ShareAndLifeThought]

​@@ParimalAdeIndex fund is the answer because even fund manager has not beaten the index in longer horizon then why to choose fund manager?

[@pradeep2kedar]

Choose fund manager with the hopes of beating Index.

[@r_m_sureja77]

Sir u have always right advice ❤

[@georget44]

I am doing a detailed research, investing 50L through PMS, 50L in MF, and 50L own stock selection. After 2 years will come out with performance result.

[@ashub10194]

Totally agree with you sir.....if one wants to invest 5cr then.....I think 4.5 Cr should be through MF and remaining 0.5 cr one can invest on his own.....but if I am in the above case.....my 0.5 cr will be 60% in large cap......30% in mid cap and remaining 10% in small cap

[@pradeeppanwar62]

Kya baat kar rahe ho Sirjee, 11 to 12 stocks is not at all a concentrated portfolio. If I dont allocate atleast 7 to 8% minimum in a stock, my portfolio will never outperform index. It is a universal fact now. Also one more, your team and other youtubers make educational contents to educate your viewers, now this person you are talking about is an educated one.

[@sabytimes]

This is akin to going to a barber and asking do I need a haircut? 😃

[@clmex3125]

Beautiful video Mr ade. Ty so much

[@Raja-up6yv]

Sir, your question itself is confusing. You said his portfolio is about 10/12 stocks. Then you started comparing it with Funds. You talked about 'Skillset of Fund managers', Then you compared his stocks with Funds ! Is it an 'Apple to Apple comparison' ?

[@nabinchandradas2161]

I have slightly different opinion.I do have my own stocks portfolio and one thing I have notice concentrated portfolio are not always gave similar return what market gave.There are some phase when your portfolio underperform and also there are some periods when market are stagnant but your portfolio do fabulously well.Its very hard to judge a concentrated portfolio return in only one year horizon.

[@manishharne2985]

I think that's correct. Not enough to compare with 1 year result.

[@shubamdutta7599]

Quality stocks jaise hdfc, asian paints,bajaj finance ka portfolio tha to nehi chala hoga, bull market me gatiya shares chal Raha hai mazgaon,vi, cochin shipyard, BDL with no sustainability in earnings

[@_I_n_d_r_a_786]

Fund managers should give us guarantee that they will outperform index by atleast 2% for client and then whatever return are generated above that, that will be their fee over a period of five years..but bobody does that..😅

[@gouthampai5055]

Perfect Sir... thank you parimal Sir.we cannot beat the fund manager

[@Viru56]

Parimal sir- Really appreciate the topic you put across . Even I also completely agree that when any expert of that domain is available then we should go with his advise by paying his fees and should not put our money on stake to take chances and better one should focus on his core competency like focus on job or business whatever he does for his income that will help him more to increase his income and keep investing from same , Thank you !

[@lochan319]

I am also biggest cheerleader of saying “jiska kam usiko sajhe”. Superb video Parimal sir!!

[@AlternAmit]

That wisdom of fund manager you are talking about which he has learnt from years of "experience" has come from making a lot of mistakes. Those mistakes are someone else's money! Asking everyone to trust someone else with your money is easy, but doing it yourself isn't. A financial advisor will obviously recommend his services as best.

[@YashSharma-pj4qh]

what an excellent video ,thank you for this .

[@hrraghupathi]

Excellent advise for retail investors

[@arvindnagar6079]

Yes vedio is very very informative !! But the problem is that how to find out a trust worthy consultant especially when one Sr.Citizen) is not having even broad idea about this field. Your answer on this is solicited

[@seekertruth72]

trusting anyone is biggest issue everyday TOI stock investment frauds coming including muliti cr. people loosing many lakhs to cr hard earned , There is no control by cybercrime and police , people also get fooled in name of doubling investment in short time all the best

[@bighnarajmisra5903]

We can set up a simple portfolio consisting of 50% in an equity fund, like a Nifty 50 index fund, and 50% in a debt instrument, such as a 5-year G-Sec. This way, we don't need to pay for expert management or fees.

[@chandandas86]

It’s the best video till now from you guys ❤

[@NewUser75]

100% agree with you. Every finfluencer is selling stocks and because of bull run any ghisa pita stock has given some returns and these influencers are running communities with paid member suggesting random stocks. No Quant study, no research nothing. And they always keep be littleling the fund managers. Thank you thank you for saying this. I wish everyone sees this.

[@chiragpatel-vk2uq]

Truely very trusted you tube chanell. 🙏🙏🙏

[@nitin123ist]

Excellent discussions and vision given Parimal sir. its always better to outsource your portfolio to professionals. And at the least Mutual funds are available at such low cost.

[@praveenkadur7751]

Sir you are always stand with retailors its good.god bless you

[@arjungupta2687]

Beautiful case study sir

[@Nidhi.pranchal]

Please analysis dabur vs hul vs tata consumer.which 1 buy for portfolio as a FMCG sector

[@bhupalsb]

Beautiful content... as always ... All The Best.

[@ashishjain5564]

This case is combination of Human psychology, and also some finfluencers advise that by doing Stock Investing yourself you can learn many new things, as well as make you an interesting person. I agree the amount to spend on educating your self is huge. Professional Advise should be taken once Portfolio size become bigger.

[@praveenkadur7751]

Absolutly you are right sir i faced same problem and i took smallcase

[@AkashYT0406]

Sahi bola apne….my own stock performance is bad than mutual fund returns

[@pkvatsa]

Parimal Sir You are consistently telling since years that Stock Vs Mutual fund Let us analyse if you beat the fund manager do yourself or give to fund manger This case study only validate the thought process again and again that you keep suggesting Doing great job and keep doing Sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@akjay143]

Yes Sir l, I completely agree that consultants should perform their duties effectively. However, I have a question regarding the prevalent phenomenon where 70-80% of mutual funds fail to outperform benchmarks over 3-5 year periods. Given their expertise, consultants should consistently surpass benchmarks by a significant margin, not just by 1-2%. Why do consultants continue to invest in companies with negative returns, holding onto losing investments for the long term, instead of reassessing their strategy and reallocating resources to more profitable opportunities?

[@vaidikvichar6528]

You are right sir my mutual funds returns are 45% whereas my average portfolio returns are just 36% .. khud ko thoda zyada Shana samajne laga tha .. whereas now i have decided to invest more in mutual funds ..thank you for this video …

[@sumitmajumder884]

Very good Initiative 👍

[@shantanudeshpande6009]

Clients do this kind argument for tax advisory as well and once they received notice they request for help. Last week one referral client came to me with income tax notice for 22-23.. his income was 35lac, his employer deducted 8lac tax from his salary, he himself filled couple of revised returns and claimed all the exemptions and claim refund for all taxes (8lac). Now income tax sent notice to him saying "submit all the exemption proofs" now he came with "sir settlement karva do". I told him " Settlement vagara nahi hoti, pay 11lac now with all the interests and panelties.

[@anshashidharan8273]

In this case I disagree, respectfully. There is no way to know if the advisor / fund manager would have done any better. More than 50% of PMS and AIFs are giving below bench mark returns. Also, if a fund manager is unable to beat it in first year, we are told that we should give it time and it is a long term game etc etc. So, we should give this person enough time to see the results. Fund managers are as clueless as any one else beyond one year horizon. So, assuming most fund managers would have beaten his returns is a fallacy

[@ParimalAde]

Then Index Fund is the answer...

[@anshashidharan8273]

If index funds is the answer then there is no need for any funds managers. As they hope to beat the bench mark returns, he is also hoping to do better. There is no right or wrong in this. His approach is fine. He gets happiness in investing by himself. He will learn and do better next time. So, instead of advising to go to an advisor, please inform him about the do's and don'ts of self investing and risks.

[@rpm_hgate9570]

Sir what you are saying is right but i have mentioned already in some other video of yours that some people want to invest by their own they don't want exceptional returns they just want to check in long run if their choice was a correct one or not sir.. It's about the kick sometimes and i think people should try this more in sideways market cuz that is the time people actually bleed money cuz in bull market everyone is a hero in a bearish market also nowadays its recovering within a day cuz of retail participation but it is actually the consolidating market where your advice will be valued more... Any advices of yours on my this advice

[@manojkhanna5503]

Sir kya rate cut Kay band market deep correction legal?

[@Vivekgupta-cj6kh]

100% agree, यह बात मुझे मार्केट में दस साल बिताने के बाद समझ आई, मैंने paid service ली तो अब मैं nifty beat कर पा रहा हूं पहले मैं भी खुद को एक्सपर्ट समझता था, मेरे बेचने ks बाद शेयर ऊपर चला जाता था,खरीदने के बाद नीचे चला जाता है

[@pritamverlekar6897]

Correct 100%

[@dgr8oneme]

Index fund SIP se lete raho bhai... Kisiko pata nahi hota ke long term mein (10+ years) wo benchmark se better kar payenge ya nahi, chahe kitne bhi dinge haak le. In simple words if you buy the benchmark then you can't underperform the benchmark...

[@sanjaybaidya4743]

Sir need 1 video on any new provision on EPF?. There is 1 communication from my company on EPF contribition. As a salaried person its means a lot for our future retrial benefits

[@sarthak241989]

How to calculate stock cagr?

[@seekertruth72]

sir - what about trust - today everyday in TOI news comes of fraud in stock market doubling money - biggest issue is trust and safety of capital

[@sandeepjain5054]

IREDA

[@manishharne2985]

One more point to analyse own work 😂. Thanks!

[@jayeshkhara1425]

Parimal sir, Arjunji khud bhi gyani the lekun Jab yudh me gaye tab Sri Krishna , arjunji ke saarthi the aur saarthi ki advice se hi yudh jite the. Matlab advisor bahut jaruru hai

[@hiteshmakhija3778]

Sir, Need your advice. All kotak securities account are being converted to Neo platform which is not providing facility to invest in Direct MFs only Regular MFs facility is there. SEBI scores portal says file ODR. Already had lengthy discussion with KS compliance team where they have said it's management decision not to provide to improve their commission revenue. What can I do as an investor now ?

[@ParimalAde]

You can go with MFCentral

[@intellectualendeavors7194]

@@ParimalAde Corporates without skin in the game don't have incentive aligned in generating massive alpha. They just want to do better than most of the funds and play too safe. Ideally the fee structure should be such that investor should always get FD rate say 7% irrespective of market performance, then on any additional returns it can be divided like 30% of additional returns can be kept by fund managers or higher percentage if they want to keep fixed at 12%.

[@m.singha]

Sir, I completely agree you, But my question is last one year return of Yadnya Small & Midcap in SmallCases is around 8% and last 3 year CAGR is around 6%, then what is your perspective about this smallcases?

[@ParimalAde]

One should avoid. For Small & Mid Cap category, Mutual funds are much better. We have no hesitation in accepting that.

[@m.singha]

🙏​@@ParimalAde

[@himanshugandhi1689]

100 % true🙏

[@anupamparashar2248]

Parimal sir fund manager also dragging , in a pms there are apprximate 20% total retuns in 1.5 years

[@sagarodisha]

One thing You can Choose to Reply: in MF I am not getting dividend credited, but in stock I see real money Around 10k Credited every year on incremental Basis. I know this is illusion but that's make me to stay invested in direct stocks

[@kodakb1069]

Sorry but I don't agree to the major portion of the video. It's patience that helps u make money in the market & not constant monitoring of portfolio. . It took 10 ( 2007-2017)years for sensex to move from 20k to 30k & only 3 years for it to move from 40k to 80k. But an investor who has patiently done his SIP for the 10 years of underperformance is now reaping in the benefits. Also money deployed before 2014 is now giving u returns. Hence this fallacy of expert giving advice is BS. A simple investment in benchmark Nifty ETF can also take care of ur savings.

[@kamleshdeshmukh5135]

Mutual fund 15-20% rutern de deta hai

[@sidhubhakar1048]

BM sir is the best

[@saurabhkulkarni5076]

Okay, so if my portfolio is 1 cr, should I be looking for professional manger? If yes are there any good recommendations ?

[@ParimalAde]

Plz visit investyadnya.in

[@saurabhkulkarni5076]

@@ParimalAde I’ve subscribed to model portfolios last week (just before WORLDCUP promo 😌), but I’ll take allocation as per quanta funda & growth model portfolios right after next rebalance; is that the right approach? P.s. I’ve switched all my MFs as per model portfolio recommendations

[@supreetmahurkar183]

If diy just do index don't do stocks ye ek point add karna tha

[@hitzee6899]

With all due respect what's the guarantee that invest yadnya or consultant would do good. Franklin funds went down and they had one of the biggest analyst team at their disposal. We don't have a track record of yadnya during the bear phase of market. Saurabh mukherjea has been lagging in his returns. Why we HNI trust any of you rather than our own safe bets

[@ParimalAde]

Index fund is the answer then 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 If you are beating index funds with your stock selection then no need to change any strategy 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Mng002]

For concentrating portfolio mutual funds waste

[@sanjusamariya3422]

Sir, pls. Wear 4 star Indian jursey

[@monturegal]

In concentrated portfolio you don’t put your bet on 1 year return. You use 5-10 year returns to compare with the benchmark. Good Concentration beats index. Short term = 1year return calculation is for morons! A 1.5 cr loss to benchmark in one year might result in 15 cr profit to benchmark in next 5-10 years

[@ankitbhatia6736]

Hello Sir, How can I book a similar session to review my Stock Portfolio?

[@ParimalAde]

Plz visit investyadnya.in or else plz write an email to [e-mail]

[@jugalkishore9237]

🎉🎉

[@kamleshdeshmukh5135]

Sir aap kitne CAGR se return dilayenge model portfolio lenge to

[@ParimalAde]

No Idea Sir. We follow a process. Objective it to try and beat the benchmark and category average

[@logan4441]

​@@ParimalAde understood but your reply is extremely cut copy paste generic type like everyone You can tell us your own portfolio CAGR for reference

[@amanhooda3876]

Mutual fund lele bhai. Inke portfolio m mostly mote hathi type stock hi h.

[@dgr8oneme]

Index fund SIP se lete raho bhai... Kisiko pata nahi hota ke long term mein (10+ years) wo benchmark se better kar payenge ya nahi, chahe kitne bhi dinge haak le

[@manorakhee]

Most direct stocks portfolio fail to beat mutual funds.

[@gautamchoudhury8977]

❤❤❤

[@alluarjun7025]

Like milega parimal sir plzz❤

[@alluarjun7025]

Thanks 🙏

[@amitdutt77]

Is this a Real case scenario OR just an Hypothetical case study?

[@ParimalAde]

Real Case numbers changed

[@amitdutt77]

@@ParimalAde Thanks.

[@omprakashpandey3904]

Aap bahut achhe insaan ho sir, yeah dekhta hai aapke baat dekhai deta hai

[@palsantosh101]

Bhai tum direct bol do Humse hi lo

[@market_learner27]

Everything is cyclical He is beating Marcellus fund Tomorrow he will beat quant fund Assuming he does his homework right No one is unbeatable

[@-abidkhan]

I respectfully disagree... Learning fishing is the only way in the long term...

[@Onlynatures]

Profit book kar liya. 😂😂 shave ho gyi.. 😂😂😂😂

[@1976arya]

bhai ji 1.25cr and 1.5cr mein only 30L(6%) ka hi to underperformance hai. why are you discouraging the investors to take the command and learn from their underperformance

[@ParimalAde]

🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@BharatKumar-fn2lo]

watch the video again. Everything will be cleared.

[@thekrazy4tarun]

पूरे 3 साल सोचने के बाद अब मैंने आपके products लिए हैं . 16-17% का CAGR है पर लगता expert advice भी ज़रूरी है एक हद के बाद evolve होने के लिए . 😌

[@Genie890]

learly the investpr in th3 case study is mad ... 5 cr ki investment main 58% smallcap!!!😂😂😂

[@raslaankhan5146]

Buy BTC, sabko beat kar doge 😊

[@knowledgeofjujutsu1877]

Ohh so first develop financial knowledge, once you accumulated good sum of amount than Bhai tumhe jarurat nahi hai fund manage krne ki... Hum manage krne do... Fees pay Karo or ab hum karege manage... Hippocrates 😂