Cat Valentine vs. Carly Shay 👯‍♀️ Who’s Sam's Bestie? | NickRewind

[@ari5333]

I love Cat but Sam's bestie is definitely Carly

[@ConnorMiller417]

“I only have one best friend. A cool, fun, meat-loving, best friend.” “Yeah, mama does love meat!” Sam is Carly’s one and only best friend!

[@Ameliathehorselover2]

And cat of course!

[@Mayaplaystocaboca]

@@Ameliathehorselover2 nooo

[@Alex_mmk]

@@Mayaplaystocabocayesss she can have two besties!

[@seanpierre2420]

I think Carly is sam’s real best friend because they hung out for a really long time

[@jesseandries1227]

Carly knows a lot about Sam. They are without a doubt best friends. 💕

[@MarcoCastillo-n5w]

I Pick Both Cat Valentine & Carly Shay

[@XavierEstrada-cc9bn]

My opinion Sam can have two best friends not just one.

[@EdwardSanchezProductions]

Carly of course

[@dilmanboskani2223]

NO SHE HAS TWO BESTIES

[@dilmanboskani2223]

SO DONT JUST COPY PEOPLE

[@Yuzen3D]

@@dilmanboskani2223first carly and sam met first and they know each other SO MUCH

[@Moomyman3000]

She can have 2 best friends

[@Alex_mmk]

@@Moomyman3000exactly

[@IsaiahHarrigan]

We all know who is Sam’s best friend! 😊 (It have to be Carly because in my opinion Carly and Sam were best friends since they were 8 years old and they still best friends not to mention they best friends in real life too!) 😃

[@osarius7001]

Barack Obama

[@jasminmable345]

Ok Carly in sam’s best friend and cat is sam’s roommate it means that cat and Carly are friends too I think

[@IsaiahHarrigan]

@@jasminmable345 Yeah

[@kaliharoane3685]

Best friends Bobby Zimmerman kaliha Roane Jackson Jackie hye and estate planning BFFs forever thank you you're such friends BFF Forever always. Bobby Zimmerman kaliha Roane Jackson Jackie turns friends Nice rewind Jude too much turns friends loved beat loved yes seice just a Donna Kelly'll and black pictures Carmen Electra kaliha system that the same friends

[@kaliharoane3685]

Even give Carmen pictures pivot kaliha Roane Jackson Jackie hye bobby Zimmerman him boys guy Everything show. Friends beat Bobby Zimmerman kaliha Roane Jackson Jackie hye and black pictures ll We. All. Know that you too much turns friends loved beat friends Bobby Zimmerman kaliha Roane you too much turns friends loved. Kiss. The first mommies and black fight against tucsus home now mom Carmen pictures pivot kaliha Roane Jackson Jackie hye and black pictures Carmen Electra kaliha Roane

[@Onyx765]

Definitely Carly without a doubt! But I also did love the odd but sweet friendship with Cat as well!

[@awkwardfreakinperson7936]

I really wanted carly and cat to meet

[@karylleamor6565]

Carly is sam's best friend ever sense childhood, and in the future the actors are still best friends.

[@nintendians]

both carly and cat are sam's bestie.

[@kawaiitwinsworld3730]

I think Carly is Sam’s best friend. They have been friends for years and Cat has been friends with Sam for not as long as Carly

[@Kirus_]

Trur

[@Guest-2]

I think both. Both of their friendship is so strong!!!!! Even tho Sam and cat got into some fights they still got back to friends!!

[@rubyclark6632]

RuSlsoszaLAKSOSOZSOOWWK01L1❤😁❤❤❤😬❤😬❤❤🤗❤🤗🤗🤗🤗🌈🤗😈🤗😍😍🤗🤗😍🤗😍🤗😍🤗😍🤗😇😈🤗😈🤗😈🤗😈🤗😍🤗🤗❤❤🤗❤🤗❤🤗❤🤗❤🤗❤🤗🤗❤🤗❤🤗🤗❤🤗❤🤗😈🤗🤗😈🤗🌈🌈

[@I_am_cupcake_lord]

I agree

[@guadalupearaiza4460]

well last time carly won

[@Alex_mmk]

@@guadalupearaiza4460bruh she has two besties

[@anthony9031]

Carly and Sam have known each other their whole lives Cat and Sam had really just met and was still getting to know each other as they lived together

[@NeddyMontz]

0:30 - 0:38 I remember laughing at this part 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 especially with Lewbert’s scream

[@azzz7279]

imagine Carly & Cat meeting though

[@gab_3829]

they did on the crossover episode i think

[@mark120a]

@@gab_3829 Cat never really interacted with any of the cast except for Gibby

[@ivywt]

@@gab_3829 they barely interacted

[@gab_3829]

@@ivywt ah mb, havent seen the episode in ages

[@ivywt]

@@gab_3829 its ok

[@thecatslayer3.1]

1:52 Cat: “CALL 991” 😂

[@jourlenchery792]

Carly is the most best friend that Sam has.

[@marissaflores418]

3:49 Sam starts to grab Poober from Ellie, but Cat intervenes

[@Laveganamacley2210]

Wario plays the role of Carly as Garlic and Rosalina plays the role of Sam or Rosam. In Nickelodeon series iGarlic or iCarly.

[@Laveganamacley2210]

And Rosalina plays the role of Sam as Rosam and Wario plays the role of Cat as Catario in Nickelodeon series Rosam and Catario or Sam and Cat.

[@SuperNASCARrocks]

Carly is Sam’s bestie because they did everything together. They were inseparable from the very beginning.

[@famillebikitik125]

Did you guys know that in Jennette and Ariana are born the same day in real life?

[@ivywt]

nice

[@Alex_mmk]

Yep just one year apart

[@juztjess8806]

Carly knows Sam better

[@navya3913]

You don't even need to compare when the universe knows that Carly is Sam's bestie

[@Alex_mmk]

She have two besties cat and carly

[@MrTCTV3]

7:56 Carly: I don't have two best friends. I just have one. One awesome, cool, meat loving best friend Sam: Mama does love the meat!

[@jrs.ogjr.01081]

I think Carly because Sam was nicer to her

[@Alex_mmk]

Huh

[@robertruhiu559]

Carly is the true bestie for Sam they’ve been friends since the beginning thus creating the very own popular web-show ICarly.

[@shelbycovington4831]

Team Carly

[@Laveganamacley2210]

Sam and cat sounds like Rosam and catario.

[@isaacogunmuko3947]

Sam and Cat: Cat was Carly's replacement New iCarly: Harper is Sam's replacement

[@javaughnwright4673]

Exactly

[@I_am_cupcake_lord]

That’s why I didn’t want to watch the new iCarly

[@BunnyBerry-z4q]

@@I_am_cupcake_lord thank you I don’t get why Carly got a new bestie they could have stayed besties but Sam doesn’t have to be on screen

[@Alex_mmk]

@@BunnyBerry-z4qCarly got a new bestie because jennette sam character quit acting so they replaced Sam with harper

[@awesomegirl5190]

Carly is Sam best friend

[@Laveganamacley2210]

Wario is Garlic and Rosalina is Sam ''Rosam''.

[@Shyletmebeurgf]

I feel so bad for sam actor she didnt need that

[@evelyn-qc9ll]

What happened

[@Alex_mmk]

@@evelyn-qc9llI think she/he was talking about her experiences on Nickelodeon I THINK

[@gabrielmigueis6280]

I love Carly and Sam's friendship since forever

[@Laveganamacley2210]

Rosalina is Sam ''Rosam'' and Wario is Cat ''Catario''

[@e.099]

IMO, Sam has been great friends with Carly & always had her as the #1 bestfriend, but I also think that it's possible that she's also close to Cat, although I see that Sam is BFFs with Cat but not as close as Carly & I don't really think that Sam is capable of replacing Carly with ANYONE at all

[@Laveganamacley2210]

iGarlic and Rosam and Catario. iCarly and Sam and Cat.

[@reutbudany5695]

Everyone knows carly but cat also a cute bestie

[@kumalalakumalalakumalasave5078]

I think both can be sam's besties

[@Alex_mmk]

Exactly

[@rp2595]

Carly. No more questions.

[@melanierosario21]

The bibble scene still makes me laugh😂❤️

[@nathaly6396]

Carly has been with Sam since they were 8

[@chrispinion]

They could easily had Gibby and Cat do a sitcom 😂😂😂😂😂

[@liltmarshall8717]

It's both. Cat is Sam's best friend as she moved on a bit with her life and Harper is Carly's best friend from a new chapter in her life

[@javaughnwright4673]

Exactly

[@Mindungie0]

Ofcourse true

[@thefighter5182]

It's not both. Because Carly and Sam have always been best friends when they were 8 years old and grew up together. Because Cat just happens to be Sam's roommate and living together and just trying to get to know each other.

[@liltmarshall8717]

@@thefighter5182 it is both. And it's not about how long you've known someone

[@thefighter5182]

Then it's not about how long you haven't known someone. Like for example Sam and Cat.

[@pianotalent6437]

The ending is……AMAZING 🤩

[@Beautifulgirly-p9d]

We all know Carly is Sam's best friend.

[@Laveganamacley2210]

Carly sounds like garlic to me.

[@clavisolemgbe4124]

Carly is a great friend to Sam 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰❤❤❤

[@juanhinojosa7727]

No Brainer. Carly Shay all the way everyday.

[@eniolaadekoya2100]

cat should have won the loyalty one cause she risked her life

[@IconicallyCat]

Sam's bff is Carly and Cat's bff is Jade srry if u wrote comments similar before me

[@ivywt]

true

[@thefighter5182]

Jade's bff is Sam. Because they're a lot alike by being the best savage characters ever and that's why.

[@IconicallyCat]

@@thefighter5182 ye but Carly and Sam knew each other longer and do more things together. Jade and Sam may be friends but not bff

[@thefighter5182]

Then Jade and Sam are more relatable to each other. Because people are scared of Jade and also people are afraid of Sam because of how physical she is. Which means they're bff material.

[@rubysoto5600]

1:25 AHHHHHHHHH 😊

[@RuwaizahAli]

Carly ofc❤❤❤❤

[@not_tiara]

Sam's bestie is Carly and Cats bestie is Jade

[@katie_lynn777]

Cat could be her second best friend or jade

[@LittleMissCraftie]

Obviously Carly. Let me ask you this, how long has Sam and Carly knew each other? Since they were eight. Since they were little How long has Sam and Cat knew each other, for 1 whole season. Sam and Carly are the best of friends.

[@davaadorjiinkhulann14122]

Carly of couse

[@jenniferperry1904]

I Say Cat Valentine is Sam's best friend it's like a Crossover between icarly and Victorious together Sam and Cat All the way

[@marissaflores418]

3:51 Oh, no!

[@Livmylifelivi]

Carly is her best friend and Cat is her lover

[@BunnyBerry-z4q]

Can you do one on Sam and Harper next?

[@Raidenshogun9234]

I love Sam and cat but I think Carly is a better friend just in my opinion I just feel like I see Sam smile the most when it's Carly and not that much with cat like I love cat like she been protecting Sam it's just that I think that Sam really misses Carly

[@rockychan9037]

bro if you just watched both showed you'd know its carly

[@Jfkf-f8q]

Yea I finished both shows and I know it's Carly.

[@ivywt]

yep it’s carly

[@BigFredBreezy]

Carly Wins Yessss That's What I Called Great Sam's Bestie👏🏽👏🏽

[@rebeccadennen7063]

Blue dog soda looks like kool-aid

[@sionsarker5642]

Carly is 1st cats second🤣

[@paullefort4502]

Cat purr purr meow meow

[@rrre99]

carly is sam’s old friend, since they were 8. but her relationship with cat it’s SOMETHING 🥹

[@LBF522]

Sam has a history with Carly.

[@beastleezardi_yt]

the winner's Carly with the score of 7/6

[@BatoolZahidi-w4u]

This is so interesting😄👑💎🔷💌

[@jenniferperry1904]

It's hard to choose who Sam's best friend is That's Between Carly and Cat if I picked Sam's best friend I would have to say Cat Valentine

[@pie1485]

We all love cat but we know that carly is sam's bestfriend but she loves cat too. 🥰

[@ericasmith7989]

Cut.😡🤬

[@starwarsguy9803]

Sam literally said to Carly in the first episode “Which is why you are my best friend!”

[@Mightyangel-p8m]

I think icarly best friends sam so winning 💪

[@officialgamerjackzgamer]

Carly Shayyy

[@AoyamaReal]

I mean Carly and Sam knew each other since they were kids, sooooo

[@Ssenikrum]

Carly belongs with sam and cat belongs with jade cuz carly can control sam and cat can control jade

[@chrysy7861]

After reading her book. We all know the answer..

[@CaesarSalad19]

So the poll that said Carly at 87% didn’t convince you?

[@seanpierre2420]

What poll

[@ivywt]

@@seanpierre2420 nickrewind’s poll

[@Hergirly-g4v]

2:08 Carly

[@dilmanboskani2223]

Team carly 👇👇👇

[@nigelmutembei8225]

NICE 👌

[@CatherineRasenyalo]

I love Cat valentines and Sam pokit

[@Noreya4life]

Without a doubt Carly

[@CarlosGonazelezGomezEricaGomez]

Really Cool

[@icy_st4r]

Sams true bestie: Carly Cats true bestie: Jade

[@BLACKWIDOW44444]

Carly Shy her friend

[@ESTHIYAH09]

Ig why not 3 of them be best friend tori jade trina too

[@Jay_Chk]

carly

[@MasterAdam-bx3io]

Carly

[@margaretkendell2209]

Carly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@kahenaarnoux8201]

Carly is Sam’s best friend cause she known her longer

[@rubyclark6632]

RuAlakzS,SAKAKAKKAKKZSKSSKSWKK11💩🌈💩💚💩💚💩💩💚💩💚💩💚💚💩💚💩💚💩🧡🧡💚🧡🧡🧡🧡💚💚🧡🌎😜😉😉💀💀😜😜🧡💀💀🧡💀🧡🧡💀🧡😜💀🧡😜😜🧡😜🧡😜🧡😜👿😜👿😜😜👿👿😊😈

[@Theyluvsheeg]

Carly grew up with Sam and knows more about her. She wins for me, also I wish she made an entrance in sam and cat

[@sawyer.miraculous]

Have a wonderful day

[@DogWater-s7g]

Bro what was that

[@joshuatewolde1837]

& I DON’T Have ‘2 Best Friends! I Just Have ‘1’ - ‘1 AWESOME, COOL MEAT-LOVIN’ BEST FRIEND’.” - Carly Shay, 2007-2012, 2021 Paramount Plus Revival Present - Just leave it all to Carly Shay Miranda Cosgrove for becoming one of the EPITOMES Of BFF in Nickelodeon History! 👏 👏👏

[@Mindungie0]

Carly is sams best friend so is cat but carly and sam are closer so ill go for both

[@manehernandez9907]

Empate carly y cat son sus mejores amigas ya que ambas la quieren y la conocen mejor que nadie

[@jaynia8055]

Carly picked Sam.

[@thefighter5182]

They picked each other.

[@richarddaoud578]

Carly And Cat

[@richarddaoud578]

Carly