Cats that should TOTALLY go to the Dark Forest! | Warrior Cats Challenge #4

Mothpool song: • I Believe In You | WAR...
We all like to say that cats should go to the Dark Forest because we don't like them. Let's take that one step further and give reasons for completely innocent cats to be sent there!
Some of the cat art in this video was made by the lovely Missy Dakota!
You can support her on Patreon here: / missydakota
You can watch her on DeviantArt here: www.deviantart...

[@evabeilschmidt8884]

After Bluestar takes her kits to Riverclan, no Cat finds it suspicious that two Riverclan apprentices (Mistypaw, Stonepaw) look exactly like Bluestars thought dead kits and have the same names and possible age....

[@yuminkim888]

Eva Beilschmidt That’s what I was keep thinking about ! :) so I told my friend who’s a fan of Warriors. Just got a reply of : hey, shut up.

[@llamaislovellamaislife6354]

That's warriors logic for ya

[@ariboo13]

Exactly!

[@ferretfang5515]

graypool was also a blue gray cats so there

[@llamaislovellamaislife6354]

@@ferretfang5515 Yeah but they should think it's odd she suddenly had kits that were like 2 moons. They would know they aren't RiverClan just by that

[@suzannehardtke5103]

Tigerstar hates non clan cats *5 seconds later* Falls in love with a rogue cat *A few moons later* Acts like hawkfrost has always been in his clan and like he isn't half rogue Tigerstar is weird

[@kiui5022]

Tiger's father was a kittypet, too.

[@suzannehardtke5103]

@@kiui5022 ok

[@kweaver4855]

*Then falls in love with a kitty pet*

[@suzannehardtke5103]

@@kweaver4855 i thought sasha was a rogue (i haven't read the first book of tigerstar and sasha but i have read the second one)

[@kweaver4855]

She once *was* a kitty pet, before "running" away and becoming rogue.

[@konekokatt9986]

Here's something that makes NO sense in Warriors. The cats know every species of bird in human terms.. But they don't know what humans are called.

[@kavaler1471]

Same with the types of plants XD

[@Froggermini]

Konekokatt YEAH HOW DO THEY KNOW WHAT RABBITS OR MAGPIE ARE LIKE BOIIIIII

[@anderfoxie732]

Yeah Someone told me they don't know what Panthers are so they kicked me for using it (pantherpaw) BUT THEY KNOW WHAT LIONS AND TIGERS ARE

[@v1ograft]

Konekokatt and they know what lions, tigers, and leopards are?

[@darcieleboff5289]

Ooooofffff

[@streampath7728]

How long other cats being apprenticed lasts: A book or two SquirrelFlight’s: *A WHOLE SERIES*

[@cj.foxy.6383]

Swiftpaw was an apprentice for like... 4 books

[@thepurplepaw2231]

Only three books...

[@lesbianpigeon5958]

Oh poor baby waiting so long😔

[@robynsadlyisnttaken4692]

swiftpaw: i see another one of my kind

[@Kin_fe]

Chloe *you mean the thing that died* *yep he looks pretty dead I was watching the dogs kill him*

[@harriet3413]

The fact that Mousefur outlived two leaders each with NINE lives

[@willlockthedoor7176]

Except she died before firestar so you are wrong

[@jackhemenez6310]

crazy nuka she's a strong lady with a sour tounge I tasted it 😂

[@harriet3413]

@@willlockthedoor7176 well ok

[@coffee3984]

Didn't Sunstar only have 8 lives

[@harriet3413]

@@coffee3984 yeah but it was firestar and bluestar I was on about

[@gorephic8370]

When a she-cat looks at a tom, she magically gets pregnant.

[@liljatupsu]

Sometimes they don't even know who the dad is

[@goldandsilver4211]

Oof

[@jackhemenez6310]

GarnetGlimmer ya put a little mating moments ya get me ( as Bramblestar climbed squirrelflight she said IM READY!)

[@gorephic8370]

Jack Hemenez Lmao

[@jackyoshi4379]

So true tho

[@PixelPalettes]

The fact that Firestar abandoned his personality in The New Prophecy

[@laraglaum3116]

I KNOW RIGHT!!!!

[@hyperlinking]

True, I liked him until then.

[@francisthompson3772]

He had a personnality beyond generic chosen one?

[@offlineroses998]

Francis Thompson not really kind of? I mean, I’ve had other stuff where they have no personality or anything happens in their life. He like- I dunno. He doesn’t really. This is- don’t even respond.

[@crystal7965]

I feel he lost personality once he stopped being the main antagonist so we couldn't see the reason behind the way he acts

[@bread_queen8356]

Firestar: **Never officially joined Starclan because he either always came back or cats couldn't kill him** Falling branch: I'm going to do what's called a pro gamer move

[@serenitythesiren5031]

Firestar wasn't killed by a falling branch. He died from his wounds and the falling branch is just what made Dovewing snap out of her trance.

[@scarletkitty110]

You really took "never let em know you're next move" too far, didn't ya?

[@nonexistent8651]

Firestar really said: *"I always come back."*

[@kayleejones3570]

Shadowclan= Great in shadows Riverclan= Great in rivers Windclan= Great in the wind Thunderclan=... Great in thunder?

[@iclynnx]

ThunderClan is great in forests

[@kayleejones3570]

THUNDERclan

[@crystalitepower6533]

OvO

[@bryleeclements5709]

Lol

[@briella87]

Mr Dog lmao

[@druidshollow]

y'know what makes no sense? honeyfern dying to save briarkit, just for her to get paralyzed later anyways. cmon!!

[@purllow]

Oh hI

[@yesul1883]

@@skyhawke223 she doesnt complain '-' at least not after a time, and wouldn't you complain sometimes if you barely could go out of a room that you share with a grumpy person?

[@yesul1883]

@@skyhawke223 i've only seen a few times Briarlight complaining about her problems, at least a lot less than jayfeather xd

[@koi5535]

Yeah ikr like I was watching a fact video and It said that in the Last Hope when HollyLeaf dies saving IvyPool but if she didn’t win it said that IvyPool would’ve won!

[@melodytheskulldog9305]

puzzlii also berrynose had kits with poppyfrost honeyfern’s sister 🙀

[@user-xk1cl5bw3y]

Bluefur getting away with saying her kits were taken by badgers when there was no scent of one..

[@kiui5022]

Scent washes off quickly in snow.

[@dovewingseyesaregreen5664]

I thought she said it was a fox.

[@jetstar9608]

She said it was a fox in Bluestar's Prophecy, but in The Darkest Hour Smallear said that a badger had gotten to them.

[@decideonanamedamnit4261]

Actually no, she said they were stolen by a fox.

[@roitoxicmocha3286]

Wouldn’t the clan of found Mosskit’s body I don’t think Bluefur buried her

[@robinberardine6779]

3:42 “Well, a lot of warrior names don’t make sense.” *Shows TwigBranch*

[@SkyDaisyAnimations]

Robin Berardine i commented that too lol

[@thatcrowkiddraws]

#Twigbranchdeservedbetter

[@hasbeennot4077]

Blazefire from tigerhearts shadow

[@lunaremerald21]

The fact that the 6th arc is named broken code when EVERY ARC BREAKS THE WARRIOR CODE!!!

[@QuicksilverStudios0w0614]

Lunar WarriorPoke1 *seventh

[@scorpion5206]

what if the 5 leader make a new code for the new series thats why it called broken code because they destroyed it

[@crystalitepower6533]

OvO

[@promisedblood]

that literally no one noticing mistytar and stonefur having he same suffix AND looking identical to bluestars kits that went “missing-“

[@coluproductions4619]

ッfeathercat IKR, the fact that they were her kits was *so* obvious

[@LeoAnnastasia]

Mistytar ... DOES THE LAKE EVEN HAVE TAR- okay I'll go home

[@manuelvalencia2099]

Feather cat, that is true. Though I’m not trying to be offensive to Fireheart/star, he was only a kittypet (well, used to be) and yet most of the cats in ThunderClan and RiverClan had seen Mistyfoot and Stonefur countless times in the first series, like how did they not notice? Same blue colored pelt, and sky blue eyes. Fireheart/star DID see the identical pelts of Mistyfoot and Bluestar in the first series as well. Plus, wasn’t the slightest bit confusing that only Thrushpelt found out about Bluefur and Oakheart, where many cats could’ve just followed Bluefur and found her with a RiverClan tom?

[@aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa3160]

Uhh.... Mistykit is a veryyy commonnn....kit name...!

[@Lost_Eclipse]

if the TC noticed that they was (obviously) BlueStar's kits, they could think that RC warriors stealed them, and then happen a battle of TC thinking they kidnapped. It would be so interesting!

[@emxlysartproductions9581]

It doesn’t make sense that the Erin’s only made The Last Hope because they wanted to get rid of all the annoying characters, And to stop Ferncloud from having any more kits......

[@johnwalsh5889]

Emily Melchor But they got rid off Firestar, and he wasn’t annoying. Edit: also, in order to get rid of all the annoying cats, they would have had to kill Jayfeather..

[@kayleejones3570]

Except for Firestar. He's you brother. He's Jake's son. Your Jake's son. We are all Jake's son.

[@friend610]

@@kayleejones3570 very true

[@dprmars]

R.i.p Mousefur ;-;

[@zotial5937]

“A lot of warrior names don’t make sense” *Twigbranch*

[@AuntJeannie1]

Clawface and Maggottail come to mind too.

[@astrida1753]

Billystorm:)))))

[@mygeeetar]

*cough cough* harrykit

[@Alexi0s]

Bumblestripe

[@blazing_arsonist]

lol i saw it too-

[@kc9297]

Something that doesnt make sense: THUNDERCLAN 99.99999999% OF THE TIME ONLY HAVE A PROPHECY CAT IN THEIR CLAN! #Needmoreotherprophecyclancatsotherthanthunderclancats

[@VixyKitty]

Soooooo true

[@no-jj7bv]

A Forest fire will save our clan. *fact*

[@VixyKitty]

Lol

[@spideredcastle]

It’s true they get heaps of prophecies, but they don’t normally tell the other clans, so they might have prophecies that thunderclan doesn’t know about..? I might be wrong.

[@merlin1542]

That is a long hashtag

[@0rca_s]

Brightheart never gets an apprentice(excluding jayfeather) and greystripe doesn't get a new mentor. sad times. :( 1 like = 1 apprentice for brightheart and 1 mentor for graystripe. EDIT: Holy heck thanks for all the likes, i didn't expect many people to see this comment. XD EDIT 2: GREAT STARCLAN! POOR BRIGHTHEART AND GRAYSTRIPE, THEY HAVE SO MANY MENTORS AND APPRENTICES, WHAT HAVE YOU ALL DONE?! (but in all seriousness, thanks for liking my terrible comment. XD)

[@psychigoat3873]

Wait what if...WE MADE BRIGHTHEART GRAYSTRIPES APRENTICE :00000

[@sureytho7872]

Brightheart should go back in time and apprentice Greystripe

[@0rca_s]

Good idea @Loner the Lone Wolf

[@rosestarofroseclan8094]

K Brightheart now has 245 apprentices and Graybae has 245 mentors

[@damien5620]

Thrushpelt and bluestar never became hecking mates

[@Nana-pj2zv]

Here's what doesn't make sense: 1. Brackenfur hasn't died yet 2. Graystripe is still alive 3. Ambermoon and her littermates are never acknowledged. 4. Hollyleaf went back to ThunderClan only to be killed in the next book :(

[@pigeon3224]

Graystripe’s probably gonna die after the next book

[@booshyu4285]

IKR! Hollyleaf was my favourite character and when she came back I was so exited! And then she died! And I cried!

[@sarasqz]

brinny Graystripe is immortal

[@GusThePrankster]

What about... MISTYSTAR???

[@Nana-pj2zv]

@@GusThePrankster Lol I forgot about her...I wanna know how many lives she has left?

[@sillyspyder9876]

The fact that the warrior code and the medicine cat code have been broken so many times yet is still THERE!!!!

[@maylienarotski5092]

Snowkit had a sister. Named Mistlekit. She didn't die she just disappeared. She had whitechough then recovered then no mention of her since. Where is Mistlekit?

[@goldandsilver4211]

She might have dieded of the after effects of whitecough... *derps*

[@chrisspiegel2183]

Maybe she ran away abfter she recovered? or pretended to get better then died? OR MAYBE SHE JOINED SKYCLAN AND MECAME MISTLETOE?!?! Oh wow now I know what happened.

[@holyleaf1558]

She’s hiding in the basement of the nursery

[@ceciliaumlauf4850]

9rainbowtails sliatwobniar9 I'm surprised Mistle(hint hint) kit isn't strong.

[@anoushkashenoy692]

9rainbowtails sliatwobniar9 I think Mistlekit was from a different litter.

[@lavenderscare4995]

What dosen't make sense to me is that starclan said they didn't know what the fatee of the clans truly was after they were forced out of there old territory, BUT goosefeather was given prophecies about the lake territory anyway. It seems like starclan just likes drama...

[@decideonanamedamnit4261]

StarClan is basically just your standard group of popular kids in an LPS series.

[@iqstillrendering8889]

“What fatee Of the clans” Me: Fate. *mic drop*

[@uzurpatori_]

The fact that we haven’t gotten a Star-clan Super Edition.

[@skxptic1]

Right

[@jobinduke2176]

Alexandra Bendik WE NEED A STARCLAN SUPER EDITION FOR THE FOLLOWING STONEFUR FEATHERTAIL OAKHEART SILVERSTREAM AND MANY MORE

[@Raymundo6]

@@jobinduke2176 yeah!

[@clementine929]

This idea is genius!

[@ne0njuice782]

Aspenleaves The cat I agree stonefur is awesome and so is the other characters!

[@sugarcandyz3019]

The fact that Mapleshade gets exiled for mating with a cat in in a different clan but Leafpool does the same thing and doesn't get exiled. I still like Leafpool

[@darcieleboff5289]

Maple also did a murder to the cata who watched her kits drown.

[@elcar659]

Cats did it more in Leafpool's lifetime, so it wasn't unheard of like in Mapleshade's lifetime.

[@elcar659]

@@darcieleboff5289 That was after she was exiled.

[@blondeashfur3445]

Shaplemaid was born like 48923 moons ago. It was unheard of be mates with a cat in another clan in her time. I wouldn't be surprised if she was the first cat to ever break that rule

[@aesthetic_writer]

@@blondeashfur3445 Shaplemaid? I need to call her that more often.

[@flurfmaster2798]

it makes zero sense that there is a cat named twigBRANCH

[@flurfmaster2798]

+Tatiana Bezerra ikr? it shows how even if they are different, or live apart, they still love eachother.

[@Frostwing]

Omg I just commented that

[@lakefeatherss]

@Tatiana Bezerra Honestly, I think the shade suffix would've fitted Violetshine more, and shine would fit Twigbranch

[@Hadeshy]

Me, when the name of a cat is completely changed when translated with no apparent reason : That doesn't make any sense, the original one was so much better. Why? Me, looking at Twigbranch: Ok. Now I have high expectations on the translation. Please. Correct this. Make it better. Please.

[@furrygamergirl1467]

Yeah! Bramblestar basically gave her the name TwigTwig. I would have preferred Twigsong. It would have sounded prettier and even better!

[@madisontheriault4385]

Wanna know what doesn't sense? Speckletail's LAST kit, Snowkit, apparently 'had' to die. Like come on dude!! It was her LAST kit before becoming an elder!!!

[@tinycarrots]

But what about Mistlekit...

[@madisontheriault4385]

@@tinycarrots I don't know him.....

[@tinycarrots]

@@madisontheriault4385 she was Snowkit sister, and after he died she just....vanished

[@thereyvan]

Yeah. Draikinator’s AU with Mistlekit and Snowkit is amazing tho.

[@kayayenenay6112]

Thats because erin hunter thought snowkit would become more handsome than firestar bro.

[@Officialgovernmenthater]

why does sandstorm go from loathing (haha map reference) Firepaw to loving him? its because he's a smoking hot kittypet

[@chubbletea]

Oh God

[@dougwalker4313]

My god yes lol

[@that_foo_stoney]

I mean they don't describe him as handsome for nothing

[@lilliang6744]

“Don’t you just hate it when a random dead guy yells at you to go outside?” -Smudge

[@musicfan2077]

GreyStripe outliving FireStar. I mean how can one cat die 9 times over but the other one be just fine and Immortal partying in the Elders Den. Heck everyone who is the same age as GreyStripe is dead RavenPaw, Sandstrom, DustPelt, Firestar are all dead. #GreystripeIsUnkillableForTheSakeOfHaveingOneLastOrginalCat. Its just always driven me insane reading a new book and seeing he is still alive. (Just Kill GreyStripe by having a clan or another type of attack on the camp and they can say he went out defending the kits or something.) Edit: Great StarClan I have never gotten so many likes or replies thx guys

[@petunia8083]

Stack Of Paper I’m pretty sure that Alderheart wouldn’t try to kill himself... Or that the Erin’s would allow a main character to commit suicide.

[@layonstage]

He will never die! He to beautiful to die!

[@explosionsfxauuuuugh]

Also. Mistystar. Older then Graystripe, a _leader_ and according to the Warriors Wiki, _HASN'T LOST ANY OF HER LIVES?!?_

[@TheDragonForest]

Honestly I wouldn't be surprised if Mistystar lost a few lives to old age

[@axolotltrasharts3970]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO #GraystripeProtectionSquad

[@achildno3236]

Bluestars Prophecy logic: Sleeping with a cat makes you pregnant. (She slept with Oakheart and was pregos the next day)

[@catmeowing4329]

True logic: The Erins Didint Show It, But Bluestar and Oakheart Mated that night lol

[@achildno3236]

starly naveiro ik ik ,it's a "kids" book it was a joke xD

[@catmeowing4329]

@@achildno3236 xD

[@Witheredrobux]

Ehhh, the Erins left out the part where they mated and they forget about the Warrior code.

[@zane6rown]

Nah G Oakheart just an Animal 🤣

[@mayleemarierichardson896]

What doesn’t make sense about warriors 1.Rusty beat Longtail 2.Firepaw graduated high school at 2 moons 3.Scourge slipped up and Firestar killed him 4.Leafstar isn’t dead 5.Thistleclaw went to the dark forest 6.Snowfur chased tow SC cats WHILE being a queen 7.Dovewings eye color 8.Firestar didn’t rename Daisy 9.MISTYSTAR & GRAYSTRIPE ARE STILL ALIVE 10.Rosetail’ Name wasn’t put in allegiances 11.ShadowClan’s symbol looks like a lazy office worker.

[@bryleeclements5709]

What did graystripe do to you?

[@stompology2791]

Graystripe is like 12-13years old. They can live up to like 16years old if they don't die in battle. As for Mistystar, She's probably like 15years old and her time is coming soon, reason why Riverclan has been going crazy in the books lately.

[@mariaagustinaferrero2333]

what the. Mistystar is still alive??

[@thejmekold]

For number 5 it does make sense that Thistleclaw went to the dark forest, he was some messed up psycho path. And Firestar didn't rename daisy or Millie because they wanted to keep their kittypet names. But the rest I do agree with

[@z2791]

The Erins kept greystripe alive because the fans LOVED him

[@ollie8391]

Do you know what makes no sense? *_SpottedLeaf not being a leaf with spots._*

[@LemonsInBound]

omg, i didn't know what spottedleaf looked like at first, i thought she was a calico with a leaf on her head or something XD

[@bethanypollard6194]

Was jayfeather in a coma when he went back in time? Or did time stop completely? This never made sense to me .... ._______.

[@VioletS18]

I think he just disappeared from that existence. What I would like to have seen is someone have found him gone and they think he's dead but then he appears out of no where and the only cat to see him was lion blaze. Then he has to explain it to lion blaze and it's like a sibling secret

[@layonstage]

When he went back in time it felt like he'd been there for days but he actually was there for a few heartbeats meaning he didn't miss a day of his real time. It's pretty weird but that's what they confirmed

[@TheDragonForest]

He probably just returned a few to the to a few seconds after he left(sorry if he was like missing or something in the books I haven't read the older books in a while

[@alyssamacias2359]

One thing that doesnt make sense is Dovewing's eye color, the editors couldnt even decide what color they were and eventually just drew her with rainbow eyes

[@mapledrizzle8024]

SkyClan should have been named TreeClan, that's what doesn't make sense. Even the Clan's symbol proves that it should have been named TreeClan. If they were SkyClan, they would be flying cats (that would be cool, but then they would get sent to the Dark Forest for fly hacks)

[@GildedTopaz]

Yea, why is the symbol a tree? Can’t it be a cloud, or a sun?

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

@@mochily ...The clan's name were created long before anyone in the Erin Hunter team thought of dawn of the clans. The first time that we see the first leaders is in the prologue of Long Shadows(which was a really interesting piece of lore. The third arc was pretty good at giving us new and interesting lore in general).

[@lukavardell3506]

Brokentail became deputy to Raggedstar before having an apprentice. When Raggedstar and Yellowfang both had the dream about kits in battle, Raggedstar defended that he would never send kits into battle, or even break the code. He broke the code for Brokentail to become deputy. I'm so confused.

[@FishWithOneEye]

A problem is the fact that Cloudtail was there when Firestar lost his first life (and came back to life) YET HE STILL DIDN’T BELIEVE IN STARCLAN!

[@whereishoney]

excuse you HE FOUGHT IN THE DARK FOREST BATTLE AND STILL DIDN'T BELIEVE IN STARCLAN

[@FishWithOneEye]

MiloClooodie... I’m only up to Dawn... :(

[@whereishoney]

*gasp* um... well at least you know he doesn't die…? :D

[@diamondkid2229]

Cloudtail probably thinks Firestar never died in the first place.

[@bryleeclements5709]

Kaboom!💥🧠💥mindblown

[@Littlepup93]

How Tigerstar and Leopardstar managed to get so many bones to make High Bone Pile. Also how they got the bones clean enough to do that / weren't infested with maggots and parasites with all the rotting meat clinging to the bones if they weren't picked clean.

[@dizzy_kurimu]

Tigerstar eat all and get fat. By that he don't win with Scourge

[@arscheffel73]

There was a fire in the forest and all the trees grew back in a few days...

[@pasteldragons0788]

Trees are evil XD

[@arscheffel73]

Thats why trees are in de dank forest DANK FOREST

[@belliepuff]

4:45 I have a reason Brackenfur is interesting. He apprenticed/trained my favorite Warriors character, Hollyleaf

[@HollyleafIscool]

Yass slay

[@samanvipyboyina4674]

OMG U R A MIRACLE I NEVER NOTICED THAT

[@furrygamergirl1467]

Why is every Ginger cat have to be named after Firestar? Sparkpelt, Flametail, Lionblaze. All have something to do with Fire, do they not? Oh wait! I forgot about Leafstar’s kit, what was his name again? Firekit? Can someone please explain this?

[@dovewingseyesaregreen5664]

Her name is Firefern.

[@hollypaww4346]

Um Squirrelflight is ginger and she wasn't named by Firestar

[@furrygamergirl1467]

Yes I understand that, but almost every ginger cat is named after Firestar. Thank you for pointing it out though.

[@hollypaww4346]

@@furrygamergirl1467 yeah too many Firestar clones

[@jetstar9608]

What's even worse is all those brown tabby clones roaming the forest

[@jellobee8530]

*Spoilers Ahead.* I feel like Brackenfur is underrated, as he has lost so many of his kin as the series progressed. He lost many of his kits, including Molepaw, Honeyfern and Seedpaw, he lost his mate, Sorreltail, and his sister, Cinderpelt. I feel like he is not just a background character, but a very interesting character. He is the brother of Brightheart and Cinderpelt, two very unforgettable characters, and he is just kind of thrown to the side. He was a very good mate to Sorreltail, and a good father to Cinderheart, Poppyfrost, Honeybriar, Molepaw, Seedpaw, and Lilyheart. He is a very loyal and honest cat, and has been in the series for a long time without getting much attention. Since the first arc he has been here. He mentored 3 warriors who might or might not have affected the “Omen of the Stars” arc (Whitewing, Hollyleaf, and Sorrelstripe), and he even lost his first apprentice, Tawnypaw(pelt) after she left for ShadowClan.

[@novacloverrain5209]

I think it’s really sad that Brackenfur almost was made deputy but then Brableclaw becomes one

[@valkje9834]

JelloBee I totally agree! Brackenfur is one of my favourite characters and I’m still sad he didn’t get chosen as deputy and brambleclaw did

[@jellobee8530]

Marit van der Valk Im also sad he didn’t become deputy, but he atleast Firestar was considering making him deputy. 😅

[@speckledfire_]

Gosh, I love Brackenfur, and I agree. He is really underrated! Why do all the great characters have to be thrown to the side!

[@neptunesmoonss]

The fact that Fallen Leaves 'can't' escape the tunnels. Just go through the entrance, or if you can float, then just go through the hole in the main cave jeez

[@VioletS18]

I think there's like a barrier that s keeping him in

[@jossislookingjuicy1794]

I think in the book he said he was convinced that if he went anywhere else other than the tunnels, his mother would never find him. (Don’t quote me on this, I haven’t read PoT/OoTS for the last 5 years and/or this might’ve been some sort of fever dream lmao)

[@neptunesmoonss]

Stack Of Paper Well that makes sense but why exactly is he the only one Jaypaw can communicate with Is he the only one kept down there?

[@neptunesmoonss]

Savannah DelRio I'm on outcast So I don't have a clue

[@dogwolf1295]

He went with his mom and the other ancients at the end of 'the last hope'

[@procyon2911]

The fact that Smokepaw fell off a cliff in the New Prophecy and became a warrior at the lake like nothing happened and the fact that Copperpaw vanished after Sunrise. She didn't even get a warrior name...

[@Malanchuk_Diana]

the authors wrote that what smokepaw and smokefoot is different characters Smokepaw can't be a Smokefoot, because he is dark-gray, Smokefoot is black. Watch wiki first idiot

[@procyon2911]

@@Malanchuk_Diana I wrote this years ago why so heated 😭

[@truly5115]

A big problem is when you realise the whole Clan is related and that you can't escape the 'We're actually related' mates

[@NightTheKittenn]

The reason all cats are described as totishell when they have a tricolor pattern is because the books are written in England, where calico isn’t a term.

[@project_letters]

(I'm in england calico is a term we say it all the time)

[@crystalitepower6533]

OvO

[@someonewithachannel6232]

@@project_letters Yeah, most do use it, but it isn't apart of British English, it's American.

[@scoutpaws438]

i myself, call the ones with a black base color and small orange/white dapples a tortiseshell and a white base with orange/black/gray patches a calico im weird ik

[@project_letters]

@@someonewithachannel6232 yeah I got that but how they said it it was like it wasn't even heard of in britian

[@kyprinos]

I don’t understand why they got rid of Rusty and replaced him with Firepaw later on. It just doesn’t make sense to replace a main character that early!

[@milkmelatonin5882]

I know right!

[@damiankim5879]

Wth

[@youreoffensive2865]

Excuse me they did what now

[@nebufu]

yeah! rusty was one of my favourite characters- too bad he got replaced

[@Torengruil6932]

Replaced?? Isnt Rusty and Firepaw the exact same character?

[@robii0776]

something that makes me think cats can now teleport is that in Darkest Night in a Vision of Shadows, there is that part when they rescue Frecklewish. Bellaleaf suggests a plan tons of miles away from the clans, and in the next chapter, she is home and no one else from the patrol is.

[@pepsidraws788]

The biggest problem? The Tigerstar clones! There has been one in each clan but WindClan. WindClan needs a Tigerstar clone!

[@scorpion5206]

breese pelt

[@QuicksilverStudios0w0614]

Hawkheart

[@pepsidraws788]

Scorpion Breezepelt isn’t related to Tigerstar.

[@pepsidraws788]

Creamfire Studios 0w0 Hawkheart isn’t related to Tigerstar

[@scorpion5206]

yes but clones dont mean they have to be related that just means that they are alike witch they are. and he is evil but if you read crowfeathers trial he is the only one that because trusted back into his hime clans again so really you could call him a clone plus extras

[@imbored5095]

Everyone watching for Bluefurs kits with not smells of badgers or foxes...

[@yellowfootproductions8835]

How can jayfeather time travel. Doctor jay

[@bryleeclements5709]

Lol

[@kiripima3284]

He has powers

[@rosieburrito]

After he says some warrior cat names don’t make sense the text reads “Twigbranch”

[@glitterbreeze8867]

Well you asked for it, here it is: The Last Hope is a complete book of death and tried to kill everybody due to so many deaths. And literally, there is no hope. LITERALLY

[@Mythicalwaters]

yeah hopekit is nowhere to be seen in that book

[@jetstar9608]

The last hope was basically the greencough book. It killed off SO MANY minor characters

[@starcre9338]

BRACKENFUR SAVED A KIT!!!!

[@nagitoontheds9613]

YES

[@Chloebear-asmr1030]

He did a backflip on a hawk that is impressive!

[@bebopbang7268]

Joel Traver *slams table* EXACTLY AND THAT BACK FLIP WAS CR I SP

[@blueeyes28392]

PowerPixie123 and he saved Fireheart in the 3rd book forests of secrets when Cloudkit was being attacked by a bagder Fireheart almost got bitten by the badger but Brackenpaw got bit instead

[@ratchild2732]

PowerPixie123 YEAH! AND HE’S...- INTERESTING!

[@asteriathenightwing5907]

Cinderpelt being forced to become a medicine cat cuz of 1 hurt leg but then later briarligjt able to be a warrior even though she is paralyzed!

[@stargaruu8161]

hello fellow wof reader.

[@asteriathenightwing5907]

@@stargaruu8161 im also a huge warrior cats fan

[@jazzyfarrier952]

I didnt realize this until now! Briar light has worst injury out of both of them, but manages to stay a warrior.At least Cinder pelt can actually WALK.

[@sparksfly5877]

She was already technically a warrior when she got paralysed. She’d finished her assessment.

[@leahboston1708]

Rosetail died in the first book....

[@gyattaway]

Akira: a lot of warrior cat names don’t make sense **flashes Twigbranch’s name**

[@stompology2791]

Never knowing what Pinestar died of.

[@jobinduke2176]

Stompology AND HIS KITTYPET NAME!!

[@balls5823]

@Marjolein And Animalss I thought Pinestar was the father of Firestar, and that his name was Jake.

[@joandaniels9241]

@@balls5823 oof

[@doodlesthrower5026]

Unknown Apocalypse but then Tigerstar(claw) and Firestar would be brothers and worst enemies... Wait... My worst enemy is my sister... IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW

[@stompology2791]

@@balls5823 Nope. That was a fan theory. But ever since Legends of the Clans, Pinestar met Jake...So it's confirmed not to be true.

[@mysteryman2628]

The main character doesn't get beaten for 5 series, but dies from a tree

[@hollypaww4346]

Firestar died because of wounds

[@jetstar9608]

Why does everyone think that?! Firestar died of a tree! In the Ultimate Guide, it says he died of his wounds, but in the book, a tree fell on top of him. The Ultimate Guide isn't exactly a reputable source, there are many mistakes.

[@wishy894]

Jetstar What possibly could’ve happened is the tree just finished him off, the wounds made him weaker, or idkk JEJSKS He was on his last lifeee And the wounds ..idfk anymore lol

[@3daniku]

He lost his other lives. He died more than the other cats

[@depressedtheatrekid1709]

@@jetstar9608 in the books, it says the tree lands NEXT to him

[@adahahtrix706]

the next novella coming out "Spottedleaf's scent"

[@thisisadeadaccount8414]

The females need her perfume

[@NatureGirl-gn6ld]

Lol

[@thisisadeadaccount8414]

I need the perfume people create it

[@spongegod1462]

Akira: we need reasons to why cats need to suffer eternal hunger and isolation while slowly fading from existence... Basically all of akiras fans: nO wE dOnT

[@jumblejoys9148]

You know what’s wrong with warriors, the fact there was only like one thunderclan medicine cat that actually wanted the job

[@dogwolf1295]

Featherwhisker Cloudspots Leafpool Hollyleaf (as an apprentice, backed out later) Alderheart Spottedleaf (kinda, as she wasn't coerced into it or forced by an injury)

[@kiui5022]

Leafpool was pressured by Sandstorm to become med.

[@midnightfirefly8715]

Where does it say Leafpool was pressured by Sandstorm?

[@jumblejoys9148]

Alderheart became a med cat cus he sucked at being a warrior, And spottedleaf proved that she never wanted to become a med cat in Spottedleafs heart, and even leaf pool had to give up the job at one point

[@midnightfirefly8715]

And also Jayfeather was once a warrior apprentice but because he is blind he became a medicine cat and spottedleaf told him that's his destiny as a medicine instead of a warrior.

[@nickwiebelhaus7585]

I don’t understand why it took soooooo long for gray wing to love turtle tail and once he has the chance she dies to monster like WHY!

[@maxtothe1006]

The thing that doesn’t make sense in the series is why squirrelflight didn’t say “it was only to get ashfur away” her kits would still love her and think she’s their mom, why didn’t she do that??

[@zzzz-xd7ss]

Fun fact: Pineapple is a valid warrior name.

[@idrovepastyourhouse-9385]

So is Deadpool

[@alisafricano6635]

and Mountaindew

[@wispii2254]

And flipflop and weedsmoke,

[@farleapthequeen346]

And Bluetooth

[@angelinatishkina1640]

And Ravenclaw

[@rapidstrike87rapid71]

The warrior code is broken so much its hardly ever mentioned eanymore.

[@shadowmudkipz7360]

The thing wrong with the books is that heavystep died about 5 times before he went to starclan (obviously they didn't like him)

[@kyro_xx]

But they didn't want to get rid of him? G A S P

[@lilygrill913]

I never thought I would see you here 🐈

[@shadowmudkipz7360]

Lily Grill yello

[@shadowmudkipz7360]

EpicKitties12 no they didn't want him coming to starclan because he was so heavy and would fall through the sky

[@eeveez-exe]

The one thing in warriors that doesn’t make sense is hunting in Starclan I don’t get it. Do prey from the forest go to starclan? *Just to be killed AGAIN?*

[@theaceofhearts7249]

Well if that's the case.It's a cruel cruel world 🌎

[@Amanda-de7ph]

you know what? that bunny that blinded longtail should go to the dark forest.

[@angelinatishkina1640]

I'm late but The badger that killed Cinderpelt, Sharptooth, the monster that ran over Snowfur, the tree that injured Briarlight and killed Longtail, the greencough that killed many cats, the hawk that killed Snowkit, the WindClan warrior that killed Badgerfang, and the dogs that killed Swiftpaw should also go to the Dark Forest.

[@bonk1818]

What doesn’t make sense is the lack of memes in the warriors series. Seriously think about it. A bunch of young cats. Together. Alone. In total isolation. Theoretically there should be much more gay frogs because of this. I mean have you or anyone else ever even tried to count the amount of times a cat has caught a squirrel? Well I have. In order to buy more instagram subs tigerstar killed many squirrels and sat on a pile of their dead bodies. The pile contained no more than 14 squirrels which he had collected over his life time. I just don’t understand this and is a serious error that the Erin’s made when making the books we all know that moth flight is actually a fluorescent green colors

[@jetstar9608]

Are we all forgetting about Jayfeather X Stick? Or Thornclaw the patrol guy? Or the millions of brown tabby clones? Or Twigbranch is a good name?

[@awfgretgdfe3880]

Dovewings eyes definitely don't make sense

[@mariakillian8]

what doesnt make sense is hawkfrost going to the dark forest because of ashfur .hawkfrost did not take a life he died before firestar lost a life but ashfur was alive and he tried killing for other innocent cats and woosh he is in starclan.the end

[@jac9515]

Maria Killian For the record, Hawkfrost technically killed Hollyleaf, in the battle with the dark forest. Although, I don’t remember if he was already dead or not, because I’m not very caught up on the books. (I’m rereading them)

[@mariakillian8]

actually he did die i dont wanna spoil tho

[@lokimcwilliams2584]

What doesn’t make sense is that on the back of Darkest Hour, it says that bluestar gave fireheart a prophecy, even though he was firestar when he was given the prophecy, and also, why did Mistyfoot and Stonefur just realize that bluestar was their mother, even though they saw her like a million times before they went to RiverClan.

[@ratchild2732]

Lil’ Bon Buns because they saw her as kits, and they probably cant remember.

[@tylerjones7592]

Lil’ Bon Buns did you remember anything about your time as a baby

[@stangalanty4865]

Hollyleaf coming back at one point, the next book, she's gone to Starclan Edit: OMG this is the most likes I've gotten thanks!

[@splurg]

Heyyyyy castel cats That's all I have to say

[@stangalanty4865]

LupaLuna my real self is more beautiful just like everyone else + THANK UUUU

[@Cymopolia]

dovewing's eyes.....those eyes........I..I can't....I just.....*dies of not knowing what the color of Dovewing's eyes is*

[@stompology2791]

Can we just say she has turquoise eyes and leave it at that. And since cats don't know what a mixture of green and blue is, it's the opinion of the cat mentioning her eye color.

[@whereishoney]

_I know those _*_eyes,_*_ following me_ _Dark and familiar and deep as the sea…_

[@warriorcatsforever5301]

I know it acward like 4 different colors of eye But I know what it is the Arron’s didn’t agree on 1 color

[@Riverwish]

Something about the Warriors books that doesn't make sense would have to be The Darkest Hour because Firestar meets his-half brother, Scourge, and Firestar decides to kill him in battle. Wow, Scourge, you never knew Firestar was your half-brother.

[@kyro_xx]

Exactly. Wouldn't Scourge reconise Firestar because he looks like his father?

[@Riverwish]

EpicKitties12 oh yeah! Why didn't I think of that?

[@YourLocalReaper]

4:10 "Wait, which check bones are we talking about?" Dirty mind, Dirty mind, D-D-Dirty mind

[@iheartmomosoo]

My opinion on warriors in ThunderClan: Fireheart (star) is interesting Graystripe is fat (and sometimes lazy) Bluestar is muscular and pretty (but with bruises) Cinderpelt is hyper but kind Spottedleaf died too young I loved Lionheart but my friends say he's weak Tigerclaw (star) is big and bulky and and probably has a scratch on his nose Brightpaw (heart) is pretty (even tho she has half of her head missing) Brackenfur is just normal I guess Cloudpaw (tail) is also hyper like Cinderpelt and never listens to clan mates (like when he was a kit and apprentice)

[@RipVanWinkle-gg3ym]

Graystripe fans triggered

[@megaaaaaaan1622]

The books do claim that he eats alot.

[@chadls921]

@@megaaaaaaan1622 😂

[@foxedouts]

My cat's name is Graystripe

[@pupper9264]

What did you just say bout my boi? 👁-👁

[@iceld.]

the biggest problem in warriors is onestar. 'uh k so i don't like mudclaw he stole my fidget spinner so you can lead bye have fun oh yeah also don't fight thunderclan for me k firestar is the son of my boyfriend so' 'okay daddy i will' 9 books later 'cmon kids this guy who broke shadowclan up y;know him sol yeah that guy said that thunderclan said hello to whitetail so we're gonna fight them'

[@Sobber.]

That they made Scourge and Firestar kin but never let them find out!!!!!!!!! Ughhhh!!!! If they did find find out... Then, HUGE PLOT TWIST EVER!! Plus, Jake has lotz of m8s. Edit: Wot? 20 likes? The most i have got was 3 Oof.

[@dogwolf1295]

Imagine. Firestar: So glad Scourge is dead! We can finally get peace! Random Bloodclan cat : Oh, yeah... he's your half brother. Firestar: ....uh... **Blue screen of death**... Firestar.exe has stopped working.

[@jetstar9608]

Jake is EVERYONES father

[@djamilalahiani6489]

Jake mated with nutmeg who gave birth to firestar. Jake ALSO mated with QUINCE who gave birth to scourge. I dont get how people do not know this.ITS IN THE ULTIMATE GUIDE FOR STARCLAN'S SAKE!!!!

[@yeetusdeletus9457]

He’s a player, duh

[@3daniku]

@@yeetusdeletus9457 nawh, a lot of cats get other mates.

[@kuwabarastarr]

4:55 idk, I enjoyed Tallstar’s, Crookedstar and Yellowfang’s. I also didn’t mind reading Bluestar’s SE either.

[@nugget8967]

fidget wing. I think Tallstar’s and Crookedstar’s were good, but I also liked Mothflight’s (although I hear she is annoying in Squirrelflight’s book)

[@judgefulljasper3177]

I liked all of those ones too

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

@@nugget8967 Wait what? How does Mothflight meet Squirrelflight?

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

Crookedstar's promise is awesome yeah, Tallstar's one is decent, but Yellowfang's...It gets good once Brokenstar takes over, let's say it like that.

[@kuwabarastarr]

@@legrandliseurtri7495 Tallstars was my first non manga warriors book, so I'm biased haha. I also really liked reading about the buildup of his rage since he had nobody to really talk to.

[@Crows_And_Bugies_Art]

Just Egg being a cat.

[@evanchristy6815]

Sasha should go to the dark forest for giving river clan 2 sassy feisty cats

[@ratchild2732]

Bombastic Films iKr

[@CandiiShillai]

Mistystar should be a cyber hacker

[@amandahamm3546]

squirflight and leafpool have some kind of specail power and are the first "Specail" cats to not have a 6 book long theory

[@Lost_Eclipse]

yes. specail. not never totally special. And SquirFlight, not never ever never SquirrelFlight

[@Lost_Eclipse]

@CatLoverAna well, i say SquirrelFlight.

[@Lost_Eclipse]

@CatLoverAna i didnt write it wrong. The dude there write squirflight, and then it can be called SquirrelFlight or Squirrelflight. dont matter what letter is bigger, what matter is write right.

[@Lost_Eclipse]

@CatLoverAna and what i wrote doesnt matter too. if you say that, in first place, why did you come there and "correct" me, if doesnt matter what i wrote? if doesnt matter what the dude up there wrote, doesnt matter what i wrote so.

[@Lost_Eclipse]

@CatLoverAna but if doesnt matter too, why did you corrected *me?* you up there said it, or well, you was correcting me, but its what i understand that you said that what the dude up there wrote doesnt matter or something like that. if i sounded rude sorry too, and its okay! but you did really sounded rude, when i was just making an joke and not correcting them. try to not sound rude when correcting others, and sorry if i sounded too. (and im brazilian and my english is a trash- thats why i wrote so bad in the other comment)

[@pinstripesgirlfriend]

Every cat with the suffix "snow" shall suffer a horrible death! Examples: Snowfur, Snowkit, Snowtuft(probably)

[@astronic9979]

SnowFluf- I mean bush.

[@tytanner4539]

You said suffix. The cats you named did not ha e the suffix snow. They had the prefix snow.

[@nellie0_0]

and Snowbush I think

[@funalli-inactive-3640]

Prefix

[@funalli-inactive-3640]

Oh i did not realize someone else said that sorry.

[@explosionsfxauuuuugh]

It doesn't make sense that the Warriors books _NEVER GET A CHAPTER ABOUT THE OTHER CLANS LIFE WITHOUT THUNDERCLAN BEFORE VISION OF SHADOWS WITHOUT COUNTING THE SUPER EDITIONS, STARCLAN, DARK FOREST, THE DAWN OF THE CLANS AND THOSE OTHER THINGS. TECHNICALLY DAWN OF THE CLANS ISN'T EVEN A CLAN YET SO IT REALLY DOESN'T COUNT._

[@catfoy8888]

Didn't we get a point of view from flametail

[@novacloverrain5209]

cat foy, and Stormfur

[@explosionsfxauuuuugh]

I forgot Stormfur and Flametail existed.

[@scorpion5206]

well, in omen of the stars there are a couple of chapter in flametails pov before he dies

[@frostfeather1310]

What doesn’t make sense in Warriors is that names like pearnose, owlnose, and twig branch exist. But luckily I have a solution, just change the name to squidward the cat, nostril hole, and tree.

[@Wereboypiko]

4:46 Akira: remember the time he..uh.. Me: Remember the time he respected Jaypaw (feather) and let him go to the moonpool despite his blindness.

[@not-charley]

Every family tree has at least a relationship where a cat becomes mates with their cousin/uncle/other relative I mean- just look at WarriorsUnlimited’s ruining ships series.

[@not-charley]

ah ok(I respect that)

[@bryleeclements5709]

Graystripe's illegal.. NUUUUUUU😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@KM73139]

@Ofelia Gurdian i ship it too

[@scooterscones]

something that doesnt make sense in warriors is that they call humans twolegs when birds have two legs....

[@kellygross5606]

Yeah but "kittypet". What on earth is "kittypet"?

[@x3eevee]

The biggest problem in warriors is the name Tigerstar. How do they know what tigers are?

[@nectarinn3]

Even worse, they also know about lions and leopards. Seriusly, how? Unless there was a zoo escape and some of the big cats met with the clans, i don't buy it.

[@cursedblessing]

Actually, it’s been metioned in the first series that their descendants (all the tigers and leopards and etc) ruled the land before all of them. Saying that would probably mean they already know all their cat defendants

[@wolfieolfie]

They used to have multiple clans that had Tigers, Lions, Leopards, ect.

[@mysryuza]

Novani Neoq And a Lion, Leopard, and a star and a sun, etc.

[@mysryuza]

Sans The Eevee Except that they were mentioned as tales and legends.

[@riverpaw3234]

Maybe some of the editing/writing team should go to the dark forest for writing Spottedleaf's Heart.

[@Pastelitten]

Something that doesn't make sense? That jayfeather broke his stick!! WHAT ABOUT JAYFEATHER X STICK?!

[@skyd3735]

Heavy step died 3 times.........I think Something that doesn’t make sense is Twigbranch Do I need to say anymore? Twigbranch

[@briella87]

Also the fact that there could be a cat called breezebreeze.... (Swiftbreeze and breezepelt)

[@mariaagustinaferrero2333]

@@briella87 Well a lot of same suffix,same preffix names are possible Leafleaf,Moonmoon,Clawclaw(clawface exists),etc

[@alisafricano6635]

@@briella87 Starstar

[@booshyu4285]

Guys if Scrouge was still Tiny and became leader Tinystar! Or Littlestar 😂

[@houwlingwoolf]

4 time*

[@knightthemage2474]

Where do the cats go to learn stuff? Like one moon kits can't talk and the next they can speak fluently. What's up with that?

[@skyshale]

4:45 *Cough* Saved Marshkit from a hawk *cough*

[@sodo_mizer]

I find it absolutely STUPID that they made SpottedLeaf fall in love with THISTLECLAW! *AS A APPRENTICE!!!!*

[@jackhemenez6310]

Manisha Wal an apprentice mfriend

[@dogwolf1295]

It's not the age gap (i mean, look at dustpelt and fernpaw) but the fact that the Erins handled the child grooming so badly and made it seem like the only thing he did wrong was training in the DF.

[@sodo_mizer]

Jack Hemenez srry im dutch im not the best at english..

[@decideonanamedamnit4261]

An apprentice

[@rickygee1233]

ThistleClaw minipulated her into loving him.

[@dan_get_off_the_van]

I wanna throw Rock into the dark forest for banning Jayfeather's relationship with Halfmoon! How dare you Rock!

[@tylerjones7592]

Kiwi_ Juuzou Jayfeather is a medicine cat he can’t have a mate

[@judgefulljasper3177]

Yes I very much agree

[@arcticsden9510]

What doesn’t make sense is that Dovewing simply cannot compute that she’s not special anymore. Or any other main series character who got shoved aside for the next series, and still kept jumping in and trying to be in the spotlight again. *cough* Firestar *cough *

[@dio44492]

You know what makes no sense? How Spottedleaf, the one hot cat, didn’t get to go to the beach prom with Brambleclaw Squirrelpaw Tawnypelt Feathertail Stormfur, and baby little Crowpaw, she should’ve gone instead of Crowpaw because Crowpaw’s diapers didn’t get changed in 7000 years.

[@cloudysystem3942]

Spottedleaf dead yo And they still need a WindClan cat not 3 ThunderClan