Ranking Every Season - MNAF Tier List

[@tryagain3975]

The thing I don’t like about origins was that the whole time Dan was basically just getting chased and there wasn’t really anything else but that but it was still pretty good.

[@Tw1sted9356]

DESK HIDING

[@jagdpanther6910]

Ronaldo was blind

[@doyouwannab7469]

I remember when the first season of mnaf was released haha i was only in 5th grade, and now Im a freshman in high school. Time flies, huh? anyways, keep up the great work dan!!

[@EvanGamer]

Exactly the same here

[@corvanj8766]

Same, but I saw these before I went to middle school

[@doyouwannab7469]

@@corvanj8766 yeah, me too! I started watching a month or two after the first episode came out

[@mcchicken3928]

Same!!!!

[@kryten1016]

Im from the uk so i have no idea what 5th grade and freshmen are XD

[@Ink-Line-Games]

*Dan talks about wanting a game based on Senary Saloon* Me, a fnaf fangame dev: "Is that inspiration I smell?"

[@caketaro]

That sounds fun. What engine do you use?

[@Ink-Line-Games]

@@caketaro Usually I use clickteam fusion, but I think that if I made a Senary Saloon game I would use either unity or unreal engine 4, so that I can have animatronics that move around the map.

[@caketaro]

@@Ink-Line-Games that is cool, Clickteam is pretty good for a fnaf game. I feel unreal or unity would make it a better experience although. Due to examples like tipping Bonnie, walking to the cell, and even walking around (maybe there is an objective mode where free roaming is necessary like after a night maybe to go to the salvage shed)

[@TherealKeop]

Did you ever make it?

[@Ink-Line-Games]

@@TherealKeop No, I made all the animatronic models but the game itself was shelved.

[@kosairain69]

For me, I like that Ant doesn't have a point of view when he came back because it kinda adds to the mystery! Its all like "Somethings up but I cant quite tell" and it adds more mystery in my option. Senary Saloon Is one of my favorites too because of how creative it is and how different it is! For me, Origins and Starlight Factory kinda blended together in a way. Don't get me wrong, Its pretty good! But kinda meshed together , it was like "Run, hide, bit of story and repeat". At least for me! Thanks for visiting my ted talk and have a great day!

[@erice5115]

Yes but I would like to see his point of view mabe after cavemans is done

[@KillaCoopyt]

The emerald skirt from MNAF is so nastalgic

[@scottbishop5247]

Truly, I’m interested with how the story has gone and the storytelling Dan puts into these. I want to see what he could do with a Security Breach inspired story.

[@zinkheroofyoutube8004]

We see a reference to security breach at the end of saloon. A news article says that the animatronics are being moved to a mall

[@rileyk13]

Been watching sense the first season came out!!!! And season one is for sure the best because it set the frame for everything and I’m so happy I found you when I did and I just am so happy :) Edit: I forgot the starlight season even excised 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@freddyfazbearspizzaria1351]

Hello! We at the Freddy Fazbear's Pizzaria management team wish for you to stop commenting!

[@Caninwalk]

@@freddyfazbearspizzaria1351 hello here at the we don't give damn we would really appreciate it if YOU stopped commenting!

[@StoppedEmu]

@@freddyfazbearspizzaria1351 Hello! as a… uhhh… just stfu

[@breadmold3545]

While everyone is theorizing about the lore of MNAF, I'm in the background theorizing about what shaders were used

[@Oasis775]

sildurs vibrant shaders

[@breadmold3545]

@@Oasis775 I actually found out a short while after posting this it was the BSL Shaders

[@Oasis775]

@@breadmold3545 oh I thought it was sildurs they look the same

[@breadmold3545]

@@Oasis775 yea I asked caveman during one of his streams which one it was and he said BSL

[@colthoffard6589]

Actually my favorite fnaf movie has to be the first one Fnaf movie that he made cuz you know the first is always the good one

[@loftgaming5031]

The first on is my personal fav to but I have to admit sensory saloon and the fnaf factory are the best

[@goomba-dp3fb]

I personally liked the second one best

[@elevator-_-6083]

@@goomba-dp3fb same

[@eva_hammoud]

Each season has something special about it. Its pretty hard for me to choose. Fun park is one that I usually re-watch, because of all the craziness and things happening. And because its the one that (spoiler) Ant supposedly "died" in, it always gets me emotional. (yes I get emotional over minecraft roleplays DONT JUDGE ME) But honestly I've currently been really enjoying Senary Saloon, especially the 6th night, with the big twist where (another spoiler) "Ant" calls Ranaldo father. But honestly i cant choose. Each one of them is equally amazing.

[@WisdomCap]

Senary Saloon has the same nostalgic energy as MNAF 2 had. That’s a very hard energy to recreate and it looks so good

[@Roodle_18]

16:53 - When I heard Dan said that he and someone else try to make the MNAF Senary Saloon an actual game and tell Scott to put it in his Fanverse Initiative I was like “YES, YES PLEASE!! I would love that so much”

[@boohoo7304]

16:45 plot twist you say oh ok 5 hours later: still theorizing what the plot twist could be

[@ShinyRowletGuy]

The rest of the world watching Texas: your weakness and snow? The rest of the world: your kidding right?

[@notarthur313]

Bruh

[@caketaro]

It took me by surprise. I was freezing and my house is so tiny we all huddled onto the same bed until on the final night I managed to sleep on a chair

[@caketaro]

TLDR: We aint used to snow often the only times I remember it happening I was 6-7 (2009-2010), 14 (2017), and now 17 and like 7 months (2021)

[@ShinyRowletGuy]

@@caketaro I live were the Florida men room in the wild do you think I'm used to a slight cold breeze? January and February is hell but in reverse, cold. Anyway hope you understand that I'm joking.

[@earthyboi1895]

thank you cave! over the years you've made something spectacular and I've been with ever since the start, seeing your troubles and all that you went through makes me happy that I've watched you for 5+ years when my friend showed me your channel!

[@boohoo7304]

"Your amazing" -everyone

[@Dazeddaydreamyart]

Cave. Can I just say, I love all of your mnaf. You were one of the people that inspired me to really watch fnaf and get into theories and other things. You have always been one of my favorite mc roleplay you tubers, still are. You always will be. The progress throughout mnaf I find so impressive, and I’ve always wanted to do some kind mnaf roleplay when I’m older and have a team of friends who would be up for it. Just, Cave I love you and your videos. Please stay safe in this hard time and I really hope issues irl work out for you. I hope you’re doing okay, thank you for all the progress, roleplay, and content you’ve given to the people of the community.

[@furythewolf6544]

I feel like he made the William Afton story cause he was like lets name purple guy ranoldo

[@furythewolf6544]

I have never had this many likes on one of my comments before

[@Shadowpuppets]

No

[@Shadowpuppets]

He named it reynoldo because purple guy didn’t have a name until after dan created the first mnaf

[@furythewolf6544]

That could be it I'm I was just saying

[@GamerBen8]

My tier list is the same as yours but the thing about Senary Saloon is just it hurts to see Ant so mean instead of the best friend he used to be.

[@Caro-Universe]

Couldn’t agree more

[@FlexingToday]

I haven’t watched these in years

[@codllama87]

Dude same

[@Reedog_]

Same

[@fettbricks0258]

Still nostalgic for MNAF 2, that will always hold a place in my heart. But I absolutely LOVED 6, it was amazing. It made me excited for the next season, and potential games (maybe?). Great job and I can’t wait to see the next season!

[@KoolHolyKnight]

Dan, my boy. Excellent work😁 and congrats for surviving without power. I've experienced a 4 day outage 3 or 4 years ago but your videos kept me consuming your videos even to this day. Thank you so much for being you😊

[@appleman2474]

i still sometimes rewatch these episodes

[@maninthevoid]

90% of a mnaf video Cavemanfilms:RANDOMLY SCREAMING AT EITHER A ANIMATRONIC,ANT,OR SOMETHING AT A RANDOM OBJECT.

[@cerebraltr6798]

Literally just finished rewatching the whole series 2 weeks ago, can’t wait for episode 7 of Senary Saloon, keep up the great work Dan

[@puffin1806]

ant holding an animatronic at gun point will always be the funniest thing to me

[@nohandsdrawing1992]

Can't wait for night 7. Awesome series caveman I always love binge watching it.

[@TwoTailedGamerYT]

@CavemanFilms I loved these series SO MUCH that i also find myself rewatching the series many times over. Hope there’s another season after Salonary Saloon, love the vids bro

[@justpassingby298]

Just remembered this existed, might rewatch everything from the beginning. pog

[@nyx-nat]

caveman just has gone insane throughout the week

[@dm1lls919]

I'm happy your ok Dan. 🎮

[@vortex1403]

Hey caveman I doubt you are gonna read this but this series is my favorite series I have every watched and you are my favorite KZbinr I watched every single episode at least twice and I want to thank you for that! I will be in that live when night 7 comes out P.S can you do a non canon or canon season of you and ant going back to OG season 1 MNAF I would love that and everyone would too think

[@howdyhowdyhowdie]

Very nice video, MNAF 1 and Fun Park were the best ones for me, Even though MNAF 1 would be considered low quality now, but back then it was really impressive and I loved it. Fun Park was my favorite, though. I wonder if he'll be releasing the stuff for Senary Saloon? I think most people who are map-makers or just like to build stuff in MC would love to get the stuff for this.

[@TooMuchDogman]

I plan on drawing the Senary Saloon characters and will post on insta so wish me luck with them! and ill make sure to give all the credit to you caveman's film for that series is truly a master piece

[@AkitoVR]

I think my ranking is the exact same as yours, I do want to see some kind of Security Puppet concept again from Starlight though. Security Breach is a big mall so good luck if you do that with different floors, and I really don’t unserstand why people keep asking for character returns like Ant after they see him die in season 3, but great hes back now.

[@TheGreenManiac10]

Im gonna put all of these in a playlist and watch all of them when night 7 comes out

[@eclipseballad]

The thing about 2, origins, Starlight Revival, and Scenary Saloon make sense lore wise. End of two is where origins starts up. I count the park as a filler season. End of origins is where Dan/caveman ends up in the hospital in a medically induced coma. Starlight Revival is inside of Caveman's subconscious fighting against the remnant he was injected with by William. The end of S.R. where Dan is running from the amalgam animatronic he unknowingly created and escapes the factory is where Scenery Saloon begins. Edit: Dan, even though Starlight Revival was a pain in the ass to make; but *if* Scenary Saloon was made without Starlight Revival the story wouldn't make a lot of sense. You unknowingly started a story and it's almost finished with night 7 of Scenary Saloon.

[@notbob7305]

How is Fun House filler???

[@JillInTheBox]

Me, knowing how bad Texas weather has been for the past week and a half: PREACH, CAVE. PREACH.

[@potatospringtrap]

I didn't even know there was more MNAF untill yesterday so today I binged the whole thing today

[@rweezy3604]

One thing I always questioned is “Why does Michael try to kill Dan in Night 4, then try to help him in Night 6?” I’m guessing it was something to do with the production. Edit: Or may have been because Dan wanted to squeeze in some extra lore from the new games, like he said

[@MGPVPFire]

It wasn’t him,

[@snowy6337]

caveman thank you for your entertainment thought this pandemic it has been a thrill to watch these mine nights at Freddy's series since the very beginning and i hope to see the closing episode to mine nights at Freddy's to be the best, last, fun episode to this series.

[@hudsonirwin8755]

I’m going to binge watch the entire series now

[@shaneomac8289]

Well, it’s good to see you again at least 😂 Be prepared to get constant donations during that fancy little watch party we’re gonna have.

[@Chasevdp]

Ya the best video yet, I have been watching for 6 years now, since I got an account on KZbin. Keep up the good work

[@rhsavage3495]

The factory was my favorite there’s just something about it that makes it so good and also when is episode seven coming out

[@EvanGamer]

He says it right in the beginning of the video

[@Semij1YT]

Ive been re watching the whole series bc i have wait for somany years for this

[@Ticcy12]

18:12. Dude just destroyed the pals lmao

[@gigablast0228]

Your content inspired me to create my own stories, so I just wanna say thank you and I hope you continue to do films for youtube :D

[@DouglasTheBlackEngineNo.10]

I can’t believe this omg I remember all these seasons from episode 1 5:42 5:43 Ohh it’s so great LOL 16:05 that’s dope

[@burntyogurt6167]

Indeed “TExaS Is CrAaZy”

[@SpiritOfSpite]

I agree with this list, the big 3d models were very clunky and Saloon's definitely a return to form.

[@BodeyG245]

I just read the description and HELL YEAH I'd watch it if u did a SCP tier list i think it would be great :)

[@caiti4lifeetuts981]

I like how your always getting chased around I think that it makes it seem really hilarious!

[@rainbowcake8650]

Yay our favorite security guard is back

[@JokieJesterE]

Man i'm so glad that my power never went out, it was just a beautiful once in a lifetime snow day for us since it never snows here

[@captainpaco6364]

so glad to see you uploading again

[@MemesSwitched]

Tbh I’ve lived in Texas my whole life and just kinda went “huh” and then sat in the cold for a week lol

[@Affinity_Official]

Hey dude just so you know i have been watching ur content since the first fnaf vid and i kept watching since thanks for your great rp content!

[@SparkyDragon]

I split everything into two ranks: S tier and not S tier. S tier: MNAF 1, Factory, and Senary Saloon Not S tier: MNAF 3, 4, and 5 This is my thinking because of the reason why I loved MNAF 1 so much. MNAF 1 was Dan and Ant working together, and it was them discovering secrets in a location that wasn't too big or small. Factory and SS follow the same plan. I didn't really like the other three because they were just way too big. Finding secrets in a small place that we got to know well over a few episodes brought excitement and awe, but in the 3 seasons with massive locations, finding a secret room wasn't interesting because little to no time was spent getting comfy in or hyping up that area. I'm really glad that Senary Saloon is going back to the original co-op mystery formula instead of the gargantuan chases with no respite or enchanting mysteries.

[@N0TH3R3.]

"The freaking weathers bi-polar" why did that crack me up because I'm manic all the time and I never know if I'm gonna be in a high or a low and the weather reflects that somehow XD

[@chaosglitch3109]

I watched it more recently as I just found out this all existed. I literally binged it all. Personally I loved it all, but my favorite was Starlight Revival. It was honestly a really nice story. I hate the very end but it was awesome.

[@Pichardgang]

My tier list: S: MNAF Fun Park, MNAF 1, MNAF Senary Saloon, MNAF Factory A: MNAF Origin B: MNAF Starlight Revival

[@mekoshort6316]

Also cave man i love your fanf series i watched every epsiode atleast 6 times

[@nostalgia5031]

Oh yeah, what happened on episode 4 season 3

[@gamersav7856]

@@nostalgia5031 you talking about when any died

[@gamersav7856]

@@nostalgia5031 least fav part of the season

[@tri-greenplayz5056]

MNAF 1:A tier MNAF 2:I wish I could give it somthing above S tier fun park:A tier origins:somthing beteewn A and B starlight:C tier saloon:WAAYYYY ABOVE *A* TIER Note:thank you cavemanflims for making this master piece

[@Sticwick]

I think we can all agree that the series is at it's best when Dan and Ant can bounce off each other's dialogue

[@Creeper0224]

Huge Fan of MNAF 1 and 2, I watched most of 3 but kinda dwindled out from it, and then Origins came out, I tried to watch it, wasn't too interested so I kinda just left the MNAF scene. But through the years I've rewatched episodes of MNAF 1 2 and 3 for nostalgia, I love the Factory and the Pizzeria, so simple but so compelling, even sometimes the jumps still get me xD. But anyways, now that I see you rank this Saloon one to be as good as 2, I think it's worth a watch!

[@Zo1dus]

I basically found your channel through these videos. I remember when season 2 was anounced and i was so gyped for it.

[@anormalguy3238]

I'm happy ur Internet is back can't wait for vids

[@indofreddy4748]

you still haven't made a playlist for origins we have to look for the videos our selves!

[@Cyphire_Rage]

Ep. 6 was crazy. Did not expect the end

[@brandonwagner5819]

This was a really go series I watched the 11 hour video that combines every episode for like a week (I was camping when I started watching it)

[@samcarson5892]

I honestly thought you ended Senary Saloon on a cliffhanger but no there’s gonna be a ep 7?, also I really liked Starlight MNAF

[@player2004-n9q]

I feel like either ant was Ronaldo or he didn’t exist in the first place, one of those will be the twist, I hope those are it at least, but I just can’t- wait.... what if it all was a COMA?!

[@jacksonvill33]

They’ve hinted at that they’ve been friends since they were little but they don’t remember it

[@Smile-db2ou]

Ronaldo and ant are two different ppl so no ant was never Ronaldo but he was Baby in MNAF scenery Saloon but baby impersonated him

[@rowan1413]

oof starlight revival was my favourite... something about it was really cool, and it was the most varied season, and imo the scariest. the starlight puppet is really cool. after that i think the fun park, im just nostalgic about that one, the park was too big though i agree, that one scared me but its mostly nostalgia making me like it as much as i do oop i think factory next, that one was iconic but the nights could be a bit monotonous (except the last few, those were amazing, and the day time parts were good too) then origins, that was a bit of a mess in parts, however definitely had its scary moments. the ending was good, however the last episode felt, very low stakes :/ then the original mnaf. it was okay, a fun classic then senary saloon. i wish i could put it higher, the ending was amazing, and the salvage was good. but the nights got soo monotonous, and the arguing between caveman and ant quickly just became... repetitive, annoying, and stressful... the ending was great and the season had its scary moments, but... it was too monotonous, i had to watch it at 1.5x speed in the last two episodes, swapping it back for the salvage and cut scenes :/

[@rowan1413]

damn i scrolled down far, im like the only person that really loves starlight revival and didnt like saloon, oop

[@zacanator0766]

My friend and I are working on a massive fnaf fan game that consist of 60 sets of nights aka stories and starlight revival is one of them it’s also one of the best seasons in my opinion, if it wasn’t a season of MNAF it would have been a much better story and I guess I like the animatronics (vinnie and vixie are part of the game btw) for now at least

[@thatrandomredengine9430]

Unpopular opinion, Starlight revival is S-tier. It’s a big departure, especially from the other seasons. Though I kinda like that much more. I love that this season tells its own story and doesn’t try to connect to the others. I wish that was more this actual fnaf series. I’m tired of the same story being told in fnaf, it need to end and just start a brand new story with brand new characters. Plus the lighting and set design is top notch, just like the others ^^

[@ShyL3V1]

I watch this every time I go to bed like I watch all of them before I go to bed.

[@vividerrabbit5124]

My favorite is the factory because it was a good sequel to season 1. Season 1 is a gem, i love that one too. I watched every single season but i have to say my least favorite was the origin, it just was very confusing to me

[@-_Dark-.-Cresent_-]

tbh i watched all of them within this week i love all of them it makes my day watching them

[@bubaduck8601]

My favorite is FNAF 3 The Fun Park because of how Ronaldo got Ant and of all the suspense and how it is connected to Senary Saloon.

[@doyouwannab7469]

I would definitely put mnaf factory and senary saloon, mnaf 1 in high a, origins at B, mnaf 3 in D, And starlight in F

[@tbone280]

I'm glad he back in action and making the scenery saloon ;)

[@coltengott1057]

Texas weather is like comedy in the future. It's RANDOMELY GENERATED

[@loganentertainment1814]

Interesting on how Caveman is ranking his own series. XD

[@spongebobfan9246]

LOGAN YOUR COOL! Also I've been watching mnaf since season two!

[@meatycheerios199]

Watched like the first two seasons years ago when they first came out. Forgot this series existed. Went on a nostalgia trip a week ago and found the old videos, found out its still somehow on going. Binged all of it 👌👌 The first one may be bad but itll always be my favorite because of that

[@boneslol7497]

the nostalgia from the first 2 seasons are best days of my life

[@theorginalreddragon]

i can't believe it's been 6 years since the first episode of mnaf

[@goldencyanrod64]

If someone actually makes a senary saloon fangame, I wonder if all of the animatronics will have voice acting

[@agentboi4794]

My cousin also lives in Texas. I'm feeling for you bro. Also MNAF 1 is am automatic S-Teir.

[@rainbowplayz4928]

CavemanFilms wooo Thank god your ok and back, I was worried about you and stay safe CavemanFilms Stay safe

[@Kcv2]

The factory will always have a special place in my heart 💜

[@danepoole2625]

If you think Texas weather is crazy, come to Michigan it's scary up here

[@imnotanerd8253]

Next season should be like you revisiting the fnaf 1 map but it had an upgrade but then you get trapped in there for five or more nights until the police break you out

[@ethanplushyt4000]

16:06 The Continuity Is A Bit Messed Up With The MNaF 3 Poster Of The Animatronic Dan & Ant

[@Aloneblone738]

Hey caveman I just found this video and I’ve been watching all of your mnaf since the first 1 now I tried to watch the last 4 mnaf seasons but I couldn’t for some reason I just couldn’t pull myself to watch the last 4 I watch the first 2 mnaf 1 and 2, those where by far my favorite ones I watched both of those still to this day and I’ve been watching mnaf since you released the first one.

[@anisarahamut2858]

Mnaf 3 was my favorite season they say the map was to big but I disagree in my opinion it was scariest season the map being so big made it feel like something could jump out at any moment this season made me jump more then any other season when I watch it for the first time and the hallway chases were perfection =D

[@the_honey_bagel199]

Dude re-watching this made me want to draw Bar-Hop Bonnie. Favorite character out of all of MNAF, ngl.

[@NerdCentralReal]

Waiting for MNAF is like waiting for Wandavision EXITING

[@carnivoree]

Never knew you were in Texas- Tomorrow my Dad is going to Texas, for a game or something, I don't know- And is it bad i haven't finished every MNAF, Except 1,2, and I think 3-

[@Hamzter1234]

DO IT unless you have something important to do its so good

[@carnivoree]

@@Hamzter1234 Alr :')

[@cobra3094]

You killed me twice in the Site-21 tour stream and I'm patiently waiting for my revenge. I do believe people should be able to wait for Mnaf content.