Celebrating the Prophet’s birth?

[@fulanalfulani8707]

It's the other way around habibi. If you are going to say that an act of worship is legislated then YOU have to bring the evidence for it.

[@trajictempr8574]

Exactly

[@Hadi.Hussein]

we aren’t making claims. You are claiming it’s bidah and haram, we consider it halal

[@muzzammilsuleiman7118]

@@Hadi.Husseindoesn’t work for ibadat bro, if I say smelling farts every Thursday is virtuous act to be done by Muslims, does it make sense when you say that is not part of the deen for me to ask you for proof that it’s haram or bidah

[@Faz110786]

What Shia says it’s legislated? We say it’s an expression of our love for the Prophet

[@Hadi.Hussein]

@@muzzammilsuleiman7118 we don’t say it’s a virtuous act we just do it because we love the prophet and want to do it, we don’t care about rewards. If you really love people you will celebrate their days of happiness and mourn their days of suffering out of love for them not because you expect rewards. Of course Allah Subhanahu wa ta’ala Is The Most Generous, and there is no doubt, but that is Gods Discretion.

[@Rhim96]

Mr Ganesh, why don't you bring us the evidence that you can celebrate Prophet birthday or ahlul bayt birthday from sahih Hadith? We don't do it because Prophet didn't order us to do it nor does ahlul bayt like Ali RA ever order us to do it or the sahaba of Rasulullah ever order us when Islam was perfect during their times, and they did tell us clearly not to innovates anything after them and bring into religion that was perfected by them, and they said those who do it, are in hell fire, so why should we have to celebrate and follow the sunnah of Kafirun when they are one who innovates this act for them?,

[@solsav]

Like you expect the prophet to say “yo where’s my cake?” In a Hadith or something?

[@Norah90774]

Islam isn’t meant to be complicated. It it mercy and ease. Do not forbid what Allah has not clearly forbidden.

[@husseinf2527]

​@@solsav 😂😂

[@Rhim96]

@@solsav no, I only expect you shia to do what he is order to follow if you truly love him and don't bring nothing else into religion by following what Kafirun doing, like a just like he's warned us not to do it if you're really true Muslims, and if you love to go hell fire willingly like a shiatin, keep on doing it,

[@Rhim96]

@@solsav no, I only expect you shia to do what he is order to follow if you truly love him and don't bring nothing else into religion by following what Kafirun doing, just like he warned us not to do it if you're really true Muslims,

[@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1]

Bismillah. Allah Subhaana Wa T'aala gave us two celebrations a year, Eid ul Fitr & Eid ul Adha. Khalaas

[@Norah90774]

Ok, then don’t celebrate when you have a new baby, or when your child graduates. Don’t invite friends and celebrate when Allah blesses you with a new house or a new wife. Why are you so stingy when it comes to the prophet??? You’d celebrate a new marriage but all hell breaks loose when a day is dedicated to our beloved prophet.

[@Norah90774]

Anyone who says that we’re not allowed to have a day dedicated to our beloved prophet I bet would have a huge wedding celebrating their own marriage, a graduation party, a bbq for a new house…but when it’s celebrating the birth of one of the most loved by Allah suddenly a line is drawn. Stop being stingy with joy.

[@geoafrikana]

This is ignorance at its peak. The mawlid you celebrate is supoosed to be an act of worship. You claim that you do it because you love the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم. The principle about acts of worship is they're forbidden except you find a proof for it. For example, a person can't pray subhi four rakaats because "there's no proof against it in the Qur'an". So also, you can't start an act of worship like mawlid without proof. The onus lies on you to provide proof for this. If you can't then repent and stop practicing it. As for the mats and rugs, they're mundane acts. Is there anyone whoever claimed that praying in such beautiful mosques brings one closer to Allah? So, they're not acts of worship. And the principle about mundane acts is they're permissible until a proof cancels them. Please repent and stop misleading people with your ignorance and stubbornness.

[@thatshiairaqi]

Celebrating the prophets birthday is found in our books of Hadith. If it’s not found in your then don’t celebrate it, but don’t mix your beliefs with ours.

[@SyahidanIbnMokhtar]

@@thatshiairaqi that's why we don't consider most of you shi'i as a muslim.

[@Rhim96]

​@@thatshiairaqiis that Hadith from the mouth of the Prophet S.A.W or ahlul bayt like Ali RA that order you shia to do it?, because Islam was perfected during their times, this act created by Kafirun, and why should we follow their sunnah?,

[@thatshiairaqi]

@@Rhim96 I didn’t quote a Hadith, I’m saying celebrating the birthday of the Prophet (sawa) is found in our Hadith, if it’s not found in yours than that’s your thing.

[@Rhim96]

@@thatshiairaqi and I said to you, is that Hadith from your book from the mouth of the Prophet S.A.W himself or Ali RA? If yes then qoute it here so I can follow it too, because Islam was perfected during their times, those who came after them and made their own words and rules has nothing to do with true Islamic teaching, is just a bid‘ah and those who do it, are in hell fire,

[@Mariam-lj8fz]

And the big question is , HOW did SAW celebrate his birthday and how did the sahabis celebrate it with him? Let's copy how he SAW did it... that's how we show our love for him instead of inventing our other ways.

[@liccleh4615]

He never celebrated it

[@Mariam-lj8fz]

@@liccleh4615 he fasted instead, right? So those who are really obsessed with our prophet's birthday are better off fasting on that day than doing other invented petty stuff.

[@maz7953]

If we brought the evidence they'd say it was untrustworthy or fabricated so whats the point. May Allah swt guide them and us.

[@chipe123o4]

For clarification, as Shia'a we don not celebrate the birth of the prophet as a "Eid", that is reserved to Al adha and Al Fitr and Day of the Ghadir and Friday especially. That said "Every day where Allah is not disobeyed is an Eid"

[@SyahidanIbnMokhtar]

The simple proof are "kulu bid'ah dalala". And not to imitate the Disbelievers. Jews are the ones im celebration of their birthday thus. Thus, a layman can answer the so called "imam" and shaykh. Let alone the Ulama'.

[@Preditor719]

Hadith please😊

[@SyahidanIbnMokhtar]

@@Preditor719 even if i do gave it to you, you won't accept it due to your sectarianistic nature (assuming you're a shi'a) or blind loyalty (assuming you're a sufi/strict madhabists)

[@Preditor719]

@@SyahidanIbnMokhtar assuming akhi i am open minded just give it

[@SyahidanIbnMokhtar]

@@Preditor719 for the former, there's many narrations, but the most best is Sunan An-nasa'i 1578, in phrase within the long narration, Rasulullah ﷺ said: "every newly invented matter is an innovation (bid'ah) and every innovation is misguidance, and every misguidance is in the fire." For the latter, there's too many from many references. But I'll give one short one. al abani 2691: Rasulullah ﷺ said: "Whoever imitates a people is one of them."

[@Rhim96]

​@@Preditor719why don't you bring us the evidence that you can celebrate Prophet birthday or ahlul bayt birthday from sahih Hadith? We don't do it because Prophet didn't order us to do it nor does ahlul bayt like Ali RA ever order us to do it or the sahaba of Rasulullah ever order us when Islam was perfect during their times, and they did tell us not to innovates anything after them, so why we have to celebrate and follow the sunnah of Kafirun when they are one who innovates this act for them?,

[@hamoudi_d]

🤣🤣 The classical "turn out around" strategy, but it's not working like that!

[@sadiqal-kaisy5497]

Shi3a are such innovators… They want to celebrate the prophet’s, the most beloved to Allah(SWT), birthday… Come to Saudi Arabia and learn the true sunnah of the prophet. Such as celebrating riyadh season festival with dancers and singers, celebrating halloween 👻 and celebrating new year’s eve.

[@user-jv7so4rk4z]

Likewise bring Ayaat or Hadith that says : No drinking permitted of Jim beam or Johnny Walker

[@ridmairsyam1708]

Misleading. This short does not giving link to full clip. Also not answering. And also there was never any proof that prophet's friend are celebrating prophet Muhammad's (PBUH) birthday. Thank you.

[@ajb570]

Little bit obsessed. Anyway you have a miserable religion, no birthdays, no music.

[@maz7953]

Lol man doesn't know that bidah means innovation in religion. He'd be shocked to know that we use electricity also!

[@joemama9375]

bro i am sorry but this is THE most childish thing ever, bidah is innovation in act of worship

[@okashgagaale3650]

May ALLAAH guide the shia

[@hamacris4424]

Then bring proof that allows the Prophet's(PBUH) birthday. Btw there's NONE.

[@thatshiairaqi]

From our books of Hadith or yours?

[@hamacris4424]

From the following below: 1. The Quran. 2. The Sunnah. 3. The Salaf. كل بدعة ضلالة، وكل ضلالة في النار.

[@thelion2087]

@@hamacris4424We don’t follow your so called made up salafi sect. Show us where in the Quran did Allah said….. may you all be salafi. Get educated. The Shia are only ones were mentioned by Allah in his book and by the prophet.

[@taskeenzahra4747]

When you don't love someone you behave like this it's not your fault you are arguing bcoz your inner enemity of Prophets ( s.a.w)and His family could get satisfied 🔥

[@Rhim96]

​@@taskeenzahra4747loving them does not mean to do what they never order us to do, loving them mean follow what exactly what they tell us to do, they warned us not to innovates anything what they didn't do or order us to do after them, and Prophet and his ahlul bayt Ali RA clearly tell us those who do it will be in hell fire, so why should we do something that created by Kafirun? We should follow sunnah of the Prophet or sunnah of Kafirun?,

[@mohamedhassan6174]

The Mawliid itself is not an act of worship, the things we do like the dikr, salatu nebi and telling seerah stories are worship acts.

[@writetohaji]

May ask you a question? During those times to travel from one point to another horses were used. May I ask you what you use? Before you put another person's belief in question, question yourself brother

[@kellsAC1]

Syed, both Shia and Sunni state that anything that is created as a practice and not performed my me is Bidda. What evidence do you have to suggest that this was practiced?

[@muzzammilsuleiman7118]

⁠doesn’t work for ibadat bro, if I say smelling farts every Thursday is virtuous act to be done by Muslims, does it make sense when you say that is not part of the deen for me to ask you for proof that it’s haram or bidah

[@thelion2087]

Sunnies make up their own analogies. Even their own books often goes against their made up narratives.

[@SyahidanIbnMokhtar]

Says the shi'a who can't prove the 12 imam

[@Rhim96]

Which of our ahlul sunnah sahih Hadith that goes against us?, as we know you Rafidah pick and choose Quran and sahih Hadith,.Which suited you, you accept it, which is goes against you shiatin Rafidah, you rejected it and says we shiatin don't accept this,

[@Svjood]

Imagine if I said there was no mention of vaping in the Qur’an and Hadith therefore, you should bring me a Hadith or Ayah from the Qur’an that specifically bans vaping or else I’m going to vape.

[@davidwang9427]

What talking about expensive carpets??? Prophet didn’t pray on any carpets that we have today, expensive or no expensive???? What’s your point? None right

[@ibrazard8067]

The sahaba which were the best people after the prophet Muhammad (PUH), didn't DO what makes you the right to do so? And that's the biggest prove that it's BIDA3

[@altruism123]

This is not a sunni shia question at all as many sunnis celebrate also. It is a diffeence if opionion among ALL scholars and not a haram halal issue

[@AirMuftiProductions]

analogy doesnt make sense, if its to make the speaking more easier to hear, and to make the house off allah look good? why is this issue? but a birthday? where is this concept derived from?

[@anazazeez0669]

Dear you are attacking to fundamental spiritual teachings of Islam. You cannot compare it with the wordly facilities Allah has given. You are really doing sin by confusing the people.

[@shayaanmiah4889]

Ffs my man found the most lame carpet excuse ever what a absolute joker 😅

[@m.faisaltahir2969]

Show we were using mike is permissible what are you talking about man

[@shahidrasul6210]

FYI- We are all Allah's vicegerents on earth! Question - can you produce a Hadith showing the Prophet Muhammad SAW celebrated birthdays?? I don't think so!!! Do you follow the prophet? Then do what he did and keep away from what he avoided!!! Crappy scholars behaving like criminal lawyers these days misguiding people!

[@iamsadiq024]

I've just realized that I can bring anything that's not specifically forbidden into Islam. What a lame explanation. Carpets, tiles, mics, are just like clothing in Islam. They have no relevance what so ever in our ibada.

[@streetgang4049]

The burden on proof is on you family, where does it say we can do this???

[@sheiksaleem3790]

😂😂😂 AllahamdulAllah i am sunni “ actually following hadees and sunna “ ! ! ! If anyone or anything its not practiced or said or done by prophet A.S its all innovation ! Innovation is good for world but not in deen Al Isalm !

[@alger16320]

Thé burden of proof is on you. You should produce your evidence. Also did the prophet sala Allahu alayhi wa Salam celebrated his birthday?

[@nazneenahm]

We Sunni Sufis of the Chisti order, that was founded by descendants of Hazrat Hussain (RA), do celebrate the birthday of the Prophet (SAW) as Eid e milad un Nabi. The Quran directs us to love and revere the Prophet (SAW). The descendants of the Prophet (SAW) were persecuted in Arab lands, so they fled to other places, like the Indian subcontinent and that persecution continues till today, by the Wahabis and the Salafis

[@haydayalltime6260]

Why not can we celebrate our Prophet's birthday? Till today muslims are remembering the Qurbani of Hazrat Ismail a.s and Allah command us to remember the running of Janab Hajra between safa and Marwa.. We can also remember our Prophet's birthday with acts which are halal like to wear new clothes, gatherings, poetry in praise of him etc

[@Rhim96]

Ya kadhaab, why can't you understand that, we did Qurban because Prophet order us to, janab hajra on safa and marwa because Allah order us to do it, but when did Rasulullah or ahlul bayt Like Ali RA or sahaba of Rasulullah S.A.W ever do birthday during their times or order us to do it when Islam was perfect during their times? This act created by Kafirun, why should we follow sunnah of Kafirun?,

[@thetruthnothingbutthetruth1]

Bismillah. Allah Subhaana Wa T'aala gave us two celebrations a year, Eid ul Fitr & Eid ul Adha. Khalaas.

[@haydayalltime6260]

@@Rhim96 they also didn't used mobiles..stop using technology made by kafiroon.. Do you have seminars in your colleges or universities or offices?? Surely if you gather to praise and to spread Prophet's personality on occasion of his birthday what's the problem..

[@haydayalltime6260]

@@Rhim96 Allah also praised our Prophet in holy Quran so we can.. Allah also remembers previous Prophets and their sacrifices..so we also can

[@Rhim96]

@@haydayalltime6260 yes Allah praise all the Prophets of Allah, we also praise the Prophets of Allah and speak about their story and what they sacrifice from what Allah tells us in holy Quran almost everyday, but did Allah tell us celebrate specifically on their birthday and do gathering and speak about them on their birthday?

[@saraadam3537]

Stop worshipping the prophet Worship Allah

[@kevinm3337]

🟥🟥🟥⭐⭐⭐⭐💫🌟🟩🟩🟩 innovation is Harram If Muhammad (pbuh tfp) never celebrated his birthday doing so is HARAM.

[@user-uv3nm7hx7c]

Haram. Its a innovation and sunnah of america not prophet pbuh 🙂🫡

[@alisson9185]

Celebrating the prophet's or ''somebody who is Allah's vice gerent on earth'' (whatever that means )'s birthday is okay BUT!! NO PRAYING ON RUGS OR USING LOUD MICROPHONES IN MOSQUES !!!😂😂😂الحمد لله على نعمة الاسلام

[@QueenQaffir]

Lol yet u can pray to him 5xs a day. What a joke

[@humanafied7303]

May Allah guide us all, May Allah protect us from the fitnas and the innovations of this Ummah, instead of celebrating the Prophets birthday, we can say اللهم صل وسلم وبارك على محمد, and by following his Sunnahs and leaving what he prevented for us. You don't have to say it or do iyon his birthday only but in your daily life Why blatantly lie on behalf of the Muslims when you know neither the Sahaba or prophet Muhammad صل الله عليه وسلم celebrated it and why don't you have evidence for it such as the Sahih Hadith?

[@eyadhani21]

Its a bunch of non sense But i will say though For once these shia people attempt to give dawah to more than just sunni people😂

[@abdullahitimta]

Budden of prove is on the innovator...

[@samadafzalie4195]

Cellebratimg is not easy to celebrate a poor quality not worth it. we have the best ones whom are granted on knowledge by Allah to celebrate sorry for those have nothing in reality

[@mcdawol]

There’s nothing wrong with celebrating peoples birthdays

[@NotTheUniverse]

Did prophet did it? Did he even celebrate his own? Bring the evidence. Don't use Shia Hadiths because they are not authentic.

[@mcdawol]

@@NotTheUniverse im using common sense, whats wrong with celebrating birthdays?

[@NotTheUniverse]

@@mcdawol You follow Sunnah don't you?

[@mcdawol]

@@NotTheUniverse no. I follow common sense. What sense is there in "celebrating birthdays is bad"?

[@NotTheUniverse]

@@mcdawol are you a Muslim? Let us confirm that first.

[@writetohaji]

Oh the mike lapel you are talking with is it not lavish too. Wow you are such an hipcrite. The clothing you are wearing was made with technology. Please also show evidence on what I have asked you.

[@Adam-yz3tv]

So dumb lol

[@asheikh964]

What a stupid example from the misguided