Makar Sankranti: The Greatest Festival on Earth - Koenraad Elst -

[@vvanamali6286]

The makara sankranti, which corresponds to the northern movement of the sun, is the uttarayana day and falls on Dec. 22nd. Because of the precession of the equinoxes, unless corrected, the sankaranti day will slip by 1 day in every 70 years. At this rate, if uncorrected, we'll end up celebrating uttarayana day when it is actually dakshinayana astronomically! Note that we are observing dhakshinayana on July 15 when we should, if we want to do it correctly, observe it on June 22nd. Correcting this error is important if we don't want to approach absurdity.

[@nancgeorge4537]

So when is the proper time in 2022

[@AnanthAathreyasa]

@@nancgeorge4537 i have the same question

[@kenny87ification]

One day the whole world will embrace Hinduism

[@treeoflife666]

As it was before so shall it be.

[@dharmayogaashram979]

That is a fundamentalist statement, at best, but extremely naive.

[@gayathrig5208]

My Pranam to you Sir. Very informative and educative.

[@4Sportsonly]

"let's go,fly a kite".... beautiful 🙏🕉️

[@RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA]

while flying the kite spread the essence of hinduism and its astronomical calendar and its glory to others to the greatest possible extent

[@ashishpatel350]

Make India dharmic again.

[@s.sarkar83]

absolutely 😆🙏🕉🚩🚩

[@dharmayogaashram979]

Here is a non Hindu who more strongly stands up for the Hindu/Yoga Dharma than many "Hindus".

[@abhisekhbanerjee9850]

Pranaam Koenraad ji..

[@samdidymus5476]

Koenrad Elst attempts to explain Makar Sankranti and the forces against the celebration of this and other Hindu festivals in this video made by CIS. Koenraad Elst has a welcome public face as a vocal supporter of Hindu causes, and this video too can be taken in that light. The casual listener will applaud Elst, but will remain unaware of the structural errors that he injects in this video. I welcome this video and the works by Dr. Elst, but my applause is conditional. Koenraad Elst is a Eurocentric scholar, and his thinking is obvious from his many past utterances - writings and videos. In this video, in the opening remarks, he attributes the Zodiac (rashis) to the Babylonians, followed by Egypto-Greek Hipparchus soon for Precession. A few minutes later, he claims that Babylonian astrology was followed in India. These claims have been roundly rejected by MANY Indic scholars, whose works are widely available and well-known for at least 20 years! Koenraad Elst takes inspiration from the late Eurocentric scholar David Pingree to make such outlandish claims, without acknowledging the Indic and Western scholars who have rejected those claims and shown otherwise. This was a letdown by Dr. Elst, but it does bring to focus what he is trying to propagate. Discerning readers should be careful to remove the Eurocentric claims and biases made by Koenraad Elst, in their reading of his works. It is good to be aware of what a scholar brings to the discourse. While Dr. Elst is entitled to his opinions, Indus University should be careful in putting such material out as learning material.

[@jigggro]

Sam Didymus thank you for this concise rebuttal. Please give some references of such arguments against what Elst is proposing. I am genuinely interested.

[@vishnuacharya6352]

Brilliant exposition!

[@rrsk88_farming]

Isn't it strange.. That people in India are secularizing.. And the West is embracing sanatan dharma💚🙏

[@kunalsen5880]

Yes , really very strange and disappointing 😞

[@dharmayogaashram979]

Really? No they are denying Hindu Dharma and taking up phony yoga.

[@saurabhthakur5041]

Great talk by one of the great Dharmic renaissance thinker

[@njzupdates]

It's shame that now im realizing to get the facts of these days.. Being a hindu And it's disgusting that despite belonging to brahman family i too dont know and no one even bothered to tell or talk me about these..

[@PirateCaptain666]

Absolutely important to correct the dates. If our Hindu tradition is ever evolving it must be a matter of pride to acknowledge errors and strive for accuracy.

[@arhanya8552]

aapko pranam..🙏

[@jesuscallingu7670]

How do you say u are outsider? No. U are a indian who known hindu civilization better than hindus.👍🏻🕉🚩

[@Tsun_Wu_Kong-Hanuman]

It replicates to play store too. Just a heads up.

[@mukesh7345]

Aap ko sadat naman

[@srinivasangokul300]

Great video. Very informative. Did not know there are stone henge type megaliths in Bharat. Was the humor intended?

[@keithhollett4337]

Vedic says Aryan is an elivated state of consciousness and has nothing to do with race. That is the origianl meaning of the term.

[@lolpol56]

Didn't understand,some graphics will help

[@rajendraprabhudesai3382]

Why do we need only foreign people to tell our own scientigic legacy. इस he doing it free of charge or apart of a strategy

[@jaiprem7413]

Rajendra Prabhudesai , while I respect the gentleman , I too have the same suspicion !!!

[@dharmayogaashram979]

So stand up for the Hindu/Yoga Dharma. What are you doing?

[@Tsun_Wu_Kong-Hanuman]

It's. Not. Like that. First remove all traces from. Google services. First step. It will copy itself to DRM then. Then you go to DRM annihilate it there. Then you update the. Google. Services. Not. Before. This.

[@vasudevakolar4091]

Mr Konrad dost or whatever what has flying kites and birds to do with the festival of makarsankranti your talk is entirely misleading you see any hindu yearly calender being continuously written for last millennium or more when you Europeans believed earth.is flat when your church killed those who said earth was round we hindus knew earth was along with other 6 planets revolving around sun pulled by his gravitational force in ancient times earth had a straight axis slowly the axis turned left by roughly 24 degrees called ayanamsa in in hindu astrology thus your 21 december entry of sun into Capricorn is much later in January according to hindu astrology when sun enters his northern course the when karana sankranti or entry into western cancer sign sun starts his southern course called 6 months uttarayan a 6 months dakshinayan a hindu almanacs have been there fir thousands of years based on drigganita surya samhitha even today hindu yearly almanacs give perfect timing of exact second to second eclipses of sun or moon and also exact time of eclipses on any day after 1000 years now getting back to western tropical or sayana zodiac mr koenrad or straight zodiac rod western astrology is based on earth being straight in axis but your own science has proved earth is bent from straight by rouggly24 degrees so your astrology fixing position of planets wrong by 24 degrees next western astrology predicts on the basis of sun signs vaguely but hindu astrology predicts yearly results predicts on the basis of birth moon sign and taking into consideration the birth ascendant sir leaving all these argument's my .moot point you are a christian your church doesn't believe in karma theory repeated burths you christians wait in your graves for judgement day but whereas hindu astrology is apart of basic hindu shastra a upaveda and hindus believe in karmic theory rebirth unless you believe in rebirth sir you can't advocate western or oriental astrology because the basis of a horoscope in astrology is the theory of rebirth and horoscope represents the positive and negative points earned in previous life so proved western astrology a sham kaminey ear ing profession adopted by western nuts

[@Tsun_Wu_Kong-Hanuman]

Otherwise. It will copy first to DRM then to. Google. Services. Vice versa. Isolate. It.

[@rajeshwardoraisubramania7138]

5 nuts

[@PARTHASARATHIJS]

boring lecture.

[@RAMAKRISHNACPNilAPRAMEYA]

maybe it's boring to listen. grasp the essence .