Chad - Who would you pick in real life, Brooke or Peyton

[@melodievercier8693]

I guess he is not better than Lucas. Both cheated on their girlfriend !

[@napoleonlovecraft439]

Melodie Vercier At least Lucas wasn’t married.

[@indowestasianmusic1375]

Lucas is better actually. He atleast didn't cheat on his wife.

[@kgrimes842]

Cheated on the same person too! Chad on Sophia and Lucas on Brooke!

[@moulaye7534]

@@indowestasianmusic1375 not that we know off

[@azaka3720]

@@Josh-ph4te he cheated on brooke. a cheater is a cheater, luv

[@allylouise6980]

Of course its "Peyton".. He married Brooke and cheated sooo hes gotta say that.

[@irabonta1874]

marriage happened before d show so they broke up still filming

[@juanandresblanco2790]

You’re totally confusing fiction with reality They asked him who would he CHAD would pick in real life. Not his character which btw was always meant to end up with Peyton

[@HermanFalckHow]

@@irabonta1874 No. They got married and divorced while on the show.

[@Jonathan-c6t7g]

@@irabonta1874marriage happened during the show lol

[@elaynethayanne8978]

Can't believe somebody actually asked him this question.

[@amarzya445]

I think both girls are too good for him. BAMM I said it

[@toobad9295]

aww he's wearing his lucas hoodie from OTH memories :'(

[@natashaortiz8547]

This is how I see it Leyton's relationship was an emotional/deep connection and physical attraction/intimacy while Brucas's relationship was physical attraction/intimacy and she would teach him how to have fun.

[@zoeelder1496]

Fair play to whoever asked him this question, there's an obvious fucking reason why he couldn't give a straight answer. I know that Sophia was acting a character, but she is similar to Brooke in a lot of ways and she has even said this herself in interviews and from the way he acted it's clear he knew if he said Brooke that people were going to go off on one.

[@kendallrabideau1352]

deep down he wanted to say Brooke

[@poppinc8145]

He should have just said that IRL he was married to Sophia Bush and so Brooke was the more likely one.

[@MusicAholic_Official]

@@kendallrabideau1352 man 20 years you justh can't make it. Chad ALWAYS said Leyton were meant to be from the start. Enough with this divorce stuff... the story of the show was about Lucas and Peyton

[@swagymicswagger]

They knew what they were doing when they asked that question 😂

[@summertime7651]

It's a fair question because it's about their characters not the actresses. Furthermore, Chad is an asshole for cheating on Sophia.

[@joshhunt4146]

Rheya Ruiz it makes him a bit of a nob tho... he should have been a man and broke up with her first if he wasn’t happy in the relationship. Also who in their fucking right mind would cheat on Sophia Bush...

[@austinbarr6356]

@@joshhunt4146right? she's one of the most beautiful women in the world tbh

[@hopeaiden6639]

Technically He did pick in real life tho he was married to Sophia bush aka Brooke!😊

[@Somethingpeerless]

Hope Aiden well he cheated on her so that's a kinda rude question I think...

[@KaterinaPetrovaPierc]

Brooke and Sophia is two different people, so not really :)

[@okokwo5161]

he cheated on her in real life too. with paris hilton

[@gizmokat8321]

That was a rumor... I have put the pieces together, Paris Hilton did cheat on Nick Carter while filming House of Wax but it wasn't with Chad, she just told Aaron (Carter) that it was Chad because he was the bigger name at the time (there is a video out there of the guy she did hook up with, whom I'm not naming because I am pretty sure all his fans already know, with her voice). Chad was on set almost all of the time and Paris was only there for like two weeks and only in a few scenes so she had a lot of down time, the same two weeks he was setting up his proposal and proposing to Sophia... which was documented for German MTV... so he literally did not have time to cheat... They didn't work out because they were young and not ready for marriage, they weren't right for each other, only they were in love but it was more like a puppy love. Reality is what broke them up. I can't believe all these year later that people still believe this... Sophia has even said it was because they were young and dumb.

[@Sweetpagal_]

GizmoKat 83 but then how come Sophia tweeted back that time about her fuckboy partner and how come she was happy when Paris hilton went jail

[@evamurzagulova3881]

im just still over here all alone stanning brucas

[@iLovePaulWesley1864]

S A L V A T O R E You are not all alone, I am in the same boat you are in buddy.

[@lanaz1568]

Eva Murzagulova Don’t worry there is plenty people like us who root for Brucas!

[@onenighthope9851]

NO HERE I AM

[@billiedhadda4511]

Brucas all the way. Didn’t like Peyton and Lucas at all!

[@azaka3720]

Me 2

[@jasmina4583]

if he was still with Sophia he def would've picked brooke

[@fatoumatawaggeh9856]

exactly. thank you.

[@nolita_fairytale]

if he was still with sophia the show would have kept brooke and lucas together

[@jasmina4583]

@@nolita_fairytale yh that’s what I’m saying

[@wwnnn16]

Mark, (the creator and writer) said Luke and Peyton was always end game. And that he didn’t want them to get boring is why they kept breaking up. And I truly get that, like Chad just said🤷🏾‍♀️

[@juanandresblanco2790]

@@nolita_fairytale no, even Sophia said her divorce with Chad didn’t affect anything Even in S3 when they were married in real life Leyton was developing again like in the school shooting or in the last 2 episodes of the season

[@Book_Dragon2562]

Look at all the Brucas/Sophia fans trying to spin Chad’s response. The question was about the *characters* not the actresses, and the fandom was gonna go nuts no matter which way he leaned. Stop making excuses and just accept that Brucas was a beautiful distraction and never meant to be endgame. When the creator himself says “it was always Lucas and Peyton,” that’s game over folks! The fat lady has sung and she’s singing Leyton’s song.

[@KenzieLillian]

TheCjma88 well that’s not completely true as hilarie burton (Peyton) said in an interview that she was told brucas (Brooke and Lucas) and Jeyton (jake and Peyton) were the endgames

[@unnatius]

@@KenzieLillian yeah but you don't give so many beautiful moments for 2 ppl if they're not endgame. (Lucas cares for Peyton, Peyton cares for him back) Brooke and Lucas only have sex scenes and insecure talks. So NO.

[@miabella790]

Beauty in a Breakdown I’m a brucas fan but i like leyton too, and honestly i agree with you. leyton was endgame, but darn it i wish the writers wouldn’t have gotten me soo invested with all the “i’m the guy for you b.d” moments.

[@Nazaba09]

KenzieLillian that was probably what the network wanted but they also wanted naley endgame and mark wanted to divorce them after Haley left to go on tour. Mark negotiated and said if you get naley I get leyton.

[@vbrandy7088]

@@KenzieLillian Hilarie Burton wasn't a writter or in charge of the show. Mark Schwan was the one in charge and he clearly said "it was always lucas and peyton" .. Just by watching the pilot yoouu can tell Leyton was gonna be endgame

[@jennifergardner9510]

This is hilarious. He had an interesting answer.

[@aly8950]

And people wonder why Sophia and Chad barely do conventions especially together lmao

[@irabonta1874]

she divorced his cheating ass

[@Kratos-GodOfWar]

It's a wonder that Chad and Sophia were able to work together for three years after their divorce. I don't know of many ex-couples that could do that, Fleetwood Mac fell apart because a couple broke up, and it was no good.

[@dipankarjoshi3828]

Leyton was set on stone from day 1. Brooke wasn't even in first ep. So get out with married and all

[@thewildbruce5612]

Lucas and Peyton were ALWAYS meant to be end game, no matter what those sour Brooke fans say!!!

[@rosemarylucas2]

Of course he would say that he cheated on Sophia/Brooke so obviously he would say Lucas was meant to end up with Peyton

[@bela11triz]

@Rheya Ruiz no,it's not

[@ameliebzh56]

Cuz lucas was meant to end up with peyton.

[@rosemarylucas2]

@@ameliebzh56 nah lies

[@ameliebzh56]

@@rosemarylucas2 i never lie about one tree hill.

[@kieramcgregor]

Or maybe he chose Peyton because he wanted to chose Peyton 🤷🏼‍♀️👏🏻💜

[@lilyb4486]

No matter what happened between him and sophia in real life, I think Leyton developed more as a couple and had some of the best scenes in the show. I personally didn’t see Brucas ever being endgame.

[@thewildbruce5612]

Me too! Leyton all the way!!!

[@jimesmorgun809]

nahh brucas was supposed to be endgame

[@wrghty]

​@@jimesmorgun809No, they weren't. The creator said even if Chad/Sophia didn't break up, Brucas would've as Leyton were meant to be end game from the beginning. Even Sophia said this at some point. Burton said she thought it would be cool if Peyton ended up with Jake but she knew from the beginning her character was going to finish with Lucas. So, i don't know where you're getting your info ha

[@majda456]

I see lots of people talking about his private life & how they think it influenced his choice here , cz they think Leyton was endgame only cz of his issues with Sophia , i personally didn't even know what had happened behind the scenes between him & Sophia when i watched the show & still it made perfect sense to me that Luke ended up with Peyton , i just felt from the very first moment they talked to eachother thay they were meant for eachother , the chemistry was insane , they were so similar & they had the same interests cz they were both artists & so they got along easily & understood eachother very well , that's why whenever one of them was going through something they would always run to eachother & talked it out whether they were lovers or bestfriends , they got eachother like crazy ! He never had that bond with Brooke , their relationship was more romantic than anything else , but with Peyton it was a strong friendship + romantic feelings which is the perfect combination for an epic love story , Leyton was meant to be since the very first moment , i felt it with all my heart & i'm so happy they got their happy ending ❤

[@llimone3338]

I agree with y’all that Leyton was meant to be but their story line in the end was so bad. Lucas went from "i love u Lindsay" to "i hate you peyton" to "i love you peyton" in like a second

[@maddsluiz1296]

I think it had to be forced because the actors were leaving

[@nikig2382]

It didn’t happen that quickly at all. I don’t like to defend the writing on this show, but it’s clear early on in season 5 that he did not get over Peyton and other characters repeatedly try to tell him that. Also, Lucas never actually hated her.

[@michaelanecchi268]

whether or not he was originally supposed to end up with peyton (which to me, from what i watched of it, it certainly looked that way), their storyline worked so well. for me personally, everything pointed to Leyton being endgame & they were my favourite ship on the show.

[@thewildbruce5612]

Lucas and Peyton (Leyton) were always supposed to be endgame. Mark just wanted to spice up the show a little bit, with the whole Brucas fiasko.

[@thewildbruce5612]

By the way. Leyton were my favorite ship as well. I saw that Chad and Hilarie had more chemistry even in real life, than Chad and Sophia ever had!

[@natashaortiz8547]

@@thewildbruce5612 The reason Chad and Hilarie have chemistry in real life is because he did a Season 5 episode of Dawson's Creek where she made an appearance where she had a scene with him in an episode and that is how they met and he said that when he met Hilarie that she told him that he wasn't cool and he had a thing for her but she didn't feel the same way so she turned him down super quick and that is when he saw a fire in her and that is when he decided that she was going to be his friend and before One Tree Hill premiered in the fall him and Hilarie co-hosted Pepsi Smash in 2003 and Sophia was only supposed to be a guest star for comedy purposes which is why she had to audition three times but then people fell in love with her character so then they decided to add her as a main character.

[@thewildbruce5612]

@@natashaortiz8547 I know Chad and Hilarie made an episode together on Dawson's Creek and I've seen that episode. But I didn't know the rest of the information you wrote, so thanks for that. 😊👍🏻

[@natashaortiz8547]

@@thewildbruce5612 Your Welcome and Hilarie said that the producers were trying out different chemistry by putting them with other people but that the producers couldn't deny her and Chad's chemistry because she said that they have always had a chemistry that is either love/hate or really love each other.

[@Kiu2672]

And that's not the real life but a show. People shouldn't care about the private life of Chad and Sophia!!!

[@luwamalem9537]

Good save Chad, good save! 😂

[@SydneyKong]

"those decisions are above my pay grade" AHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAH. well technically didn't he already have brooke in real life sooo

[@sweetriad9606]

Thanks you!!!!! made my day happy, Chad's is so funny. I love him 😍

[@smith7206]

This was one of the best parts of their Q & As. Thanks for posting, so happy I get to keep reliving this past weekend!

[@Mwhiteshelley]

+Terry Smith I also created some comic book style frames of this Q&A question. You can see it on my facebook page. :-)

[@smith7206]

+Joanna Foster I seen them haha. I loved it. I saw it on the Eyecon group page

[@katia9445]

Wait, this really happend just 10 months ago?

[@kathleendavis454]

Katia Eriksen yesssssss

[@Aliza_27]

Oh my god. Thank you for that Chad. My Leyton heart is so happy.

[@Book_Dragon2562]

Here’s the thing, Chad chose Sophia (not Brooke) and then he cheated on her. He and Hilario are terrific friends and their characters were soulmates. People really need to learn how to separate reel from real. Even if Chad and Sophia had stayed together (which is highly unlikely since both have said and done things that made it clear that marriage was doomed from the start and not really what either party wanted) Lucas and Peyton were always going to end up together because the Creator/Writer has confirmed it was always meant to be Lucas and Peyton. Brooke wasn’t even a character when that endgame was written.

[@Kratos-GodOfWar]

True, Brooke literally didn't exist in the pilot, and truth be told, I wouldn't be surprised if Brooke's sudden existence in the second episode was like Buffy The Vampire Slayer where she suddenly has a sister in Season Five, only nobody explains it lol. And because that Leyton scene with the tow truck and the Comet is written before Brooke existed/Tara was renamed to Brooke/Sophia was cast, and gives off legit "there's fireworks on ungodly levels going off here" vibes, I stand by Leyton, but I think Brooke is better off without Lucas in that way.

[@poppinc8145]

@@Kratos-GodOfWar There's a huge difference between joining a show in Season 5 and joining a show in the second episode of Season 1 like Sophia did. Pilots often have fewer (or sometimes more) cast members than the overall show because it's a proof-of-concept to the network.

[@thewildbruce5612]

@kendallrabideau1352 Nope!!!!!! Deep down he has ALWAYS wanted to say PEYTON, even when he was still with Brooke!!!!!!

[@majda456]

Well there u go ! This is for the ppl who keep saying that the storyline changed cz of Chad & Sophia's divorce , he just said that it was decided from the time lucas told peyton she had nice legs aka season 1 that Leyton was endgame So ppl now can chill & shut up about it 😊

[@summertime7651]

He said it was decided for HIM, Chad, not the writers or directors. He thought it was meant to be at that moment. Lucas was supposed to end up with Brooke (the writers/directors decided). peopleschoice.com/2016/08/25/one-tree-hill-star-hilarie-burton-reveals-lucas-was-originally-supposed-to-end-up-with-brooke-interview/ www.hollywoodnewsdaily.com/2016/one-tree-hill-shocker-lucas-was-supposed-to-end-up-with-brooke-peyton-with-jake/10394

[@Sweets0727]

SummerTime the creator of the show states that he created a whole around Lucas and Peyton. So every other storyline was for dramatic effect (I.e Brucas and Jeyton). It was to show that no matter what may come between two destined lovers they will always find their way back to each other.

[@kendallwriter23]

it did. hilarie even said so in an interview.

[@majda456]

SummerTime I read the article , but if u pay a good attention , Hilarie said that the creators of the show were trying diffrent pairs & seeing which pair has the best chemistry & when they said that Luke & Brooke were gonna end up together it wasn't a definite decision , they were still testing them & she said that when they saw that the chemistry between Luke & Peyton was indeniable it was no question that that was the endgame , so nothing was really sure from the start they had to try diffrent pairs & see what clicked , & at the end of it was Leyton that felt like the real deal !

[@Kiu2672]

@@summertime7651 At the time, it was not the writers/directors who decided but the channel. Sophia was a P.O.S for the producers... nothing more! Peyton/Hilarie was the first female character of the show, Brooke/Sophia a minor character!

[@smoakqueenfam]

The reason why he was having such a difficult time was because he was married to Sophia in real life 😂 so if he picked Brooke everyone would be freaking out about that, but if he picked Peyton it would have been the easy answer since that’s how it was in the show. Killed me how torn he was tho 😂

[@Nazaba09]

That’s not why. Brucas Shippers were terrifying so he didn’t want to Upset them.

[@reinemfz2961]

@@Nazaba09 false.. brucas fans knew he was gonna say peyton he was torn because he knew brucas was supposed to be endgame & had better chemistry, but wasn’t because of what he did in real life.

[@Nazaba09]

@@reinemfz2961 no they were not. Leyton were always endgame.

[@reinemfz2961]

@@Nazaba09 false but ok

[@juanandresblanco2790]

@@reinemfz2961 Brucas was never supposed to be endgame. Stop lying EVERYONE including Chad, the creator, Sophia, Hillary, Joy said it was the plan from the beginning. You should look up their podcast so you can get your facts straight before lying. And LMAO Lucas cheated on Brooke twice and she was always so insecure about Peyton… you really thought that was endgame????

[@JaredThaBoi]

I’d definitely pick Peyton 😍💗🙌🏽

[@reneehaa9684]

I totally agree with him each relationship lucas had made since in the moment and so did each relationship Peyton had especially Jake(if only that happened lol) but them being end game makes since from the frist ep. And things coming around full circle.

[@nkatarina]

stop making up stupid excuses as to why he didn't choose brooke. Sophia and Brooke don't have any connection. Brooke is not Sophia Sophia is just portraying Brooke and she's a character, i know brucas fans are mad that Leyton was the end game but stop disrespecting their choice and it was clear from the pilot that it was gonna be an end game, i respect your opinions but stop bashing other people opinions. I respectfully disagree with you.

[@patrickfabsich2692]

It was clear Lucas and Peyton end up together. But his Break with Sophia in Real speeded it i think. I love the Show but it was so the let be Lucas again with Brooke and he brooke her Heart again. Okay s3 /4 was not his fault Peytons also she kissed him because she thinks she dies. I like them as Pair but Lucas and Peyton was allways a Endgame the Pilot make it clear Haley and Natham was the Surprise. Its clear he would take Peyton he was marrried with Sophis Bush! But Please dont tell it Hilary Burtons Husband!:)))

[@jkuhlinsp2ce232]

Did anyone forgot that he was married to sophia

[@ruthvogels]

I so love how he dropped the mic😅😅😂😂😂

[@Nazaba09]

I can’t believe so many years later people are STILL shipping Brooke and Lucas. WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU? He was awful to her and cheated on her multiple times. And then he cheated on Lindsey. Peyton was the ONLY PERSON he was never awful to.

[@reinemfz2961]

“i hate you” to peyton wasn’t awful? he was a douche to legit everybody he was ever with.. brooke and lucas were supposed to be endgame.. that’s why people ship them because they only changed the show around when they got divorced in real life.

[@aissatabalde4444]

@@reinemfz2961 the first scene was him and peyton. His love has always been for peyton. Lucas think too much! and sometimes by dint of thinking too much he chooses reason instead of the heart. because he is afraid of his own feelings. Brooke let him forget about life

[@reinemfz2961]

@@aissatabalde4444 you’re comment slowly stopped making sense..

[@aissatabalde4444]

@@reinemfz2961 sorry i'm french. I don't know how write my point correctly

[@Nazaba09]

@@reinemfz2961 incorrect. Brooke wasn’t even in the pilot. Leyton was always supposed to be endgame. Nathan and Haley were supposed to get a divorce but the network didn’t allow it so mark negotiated that if he gave them Nathan and Haley, he got Lucas and Peyton.

[@MH-yl5fq]

Honestly brucas was kinda annoying to me because most of their relationship was just them trying to trust each other. Brooke felt insecure about Peyton and Lucas felt insecure about Chris. Literally the whole beginning part of the relationship was Lucas saying that “he’s the guy for her” and her telling him that they should be friends with benefits. And as soon as she sees him with Rachel she goes and sleeps with Chris. Idk they just seemed really messy to me and they literally had nothing in common. Even while they were together there were always these little moments where Lucas would comfort Peyton when Ellie died or the scenes in the library when Peyton got shot which to me had way more chemistry than Brucas scenes ever had. That’s why Leyton is endgame.

[@zoeelder1496]

Think i just read a comment saying that Chad regretted what he done, from what I have seen of him it didn't look like it and i have never heard of him actually saying that he regretted it. Maybe he has so apologies if i'm wrong..... but then again even if he has said it doesn't make what he done any less hurtful for Soph

[@lilyb4486]

They kept the details of their relationship very private, which makes it hard to judge him or her about how they reacted to it based on him being or acting happy and funny. People usually don’t show up to large public events looking depressed or talking about their breakups so we don’t really know if he regretted what he allegedly did!

[@Kratos-GodOfWar]

@@lilyb4486 well, Sophia ain't talkin' about it either and is clearly sick of hearin' it, as seen in her Michael Rosenbaum interview. I think we should let it rest. They was cute as Lucas and Brooke, and as Chad and Sophia, but that's done now. Sophia Bush (Brooke) has a new podcast with Hilarie Burton Morgan (Peyton) and Bethany Joy Lenz (Haley), called Drama Queens. It's pretty cool, they re-watch the show, episode-by-episode, once a week, as was done in 2003, and they're almost done with Season One of One Tree Hill. They've had Lee Norris (Mouth), Antwon Tanner (Skills), Barbara Alyn Woods (Deb), Paul Johansson (Dan), and Moira Kelly (Karen) already on the show. I believe there are not only plans to get the rest of the cast, like Craig Sheffer (Keith), Barry Corbin (Whitey), James Lafferty (Nathan) and maybe even Chad Michael Murray (Lucas), in addition to all those who appear after Season One, and some of the aforementioned people above. Let's just be real here: IF Chad appears at all, assuming he appears, I imagine that Sophia will miss that episode. If he doesn't appear, we all know why, and it's not exclusively because he has better shit to do. That said, let's also assume Sophia doesn't miss the episode: she ain't gonna say shit to Chad, and there will be no mention of the relationship between them. So, as they has let that die, so should we. Sorry... -A Brucas/Chophia fan

[@japrillers2824]

OMG with these people why cant they just give him a frigging break and just admit that peyton and lucas were much better match in the show! And it was never confirmed that he cheated and even if he had its like anciant history, he was just a kid, people make mistakes! And dont get why people just cant get it in their heads that what happens in the show is just a show and the writers writes the show and not always mix it up with real lifes, they really should get over it. Just poor guy I think he has gotten already enough crap about past mistakes, sophia and fans really should just get over it.

[@nikig2382]

Agreed! But I’m pretty sure Nick Carter confirmed it back in the day.

[@autumnosborne9624]

he should’ve said haley and left it at that😂

[@Kratos-GodOfWar]

Imagine lol

[@Sweets0727]

Yassss Chad dude awesome answer... my Leyton heart 💕 is on cloud 9 rite now.

[@linneajohansson3017]

Haha Yeah But he was together with Sophia ( Brooke ) So clearly Brooke Not Peyton ;) He just said that cause he messed up the relationship

[@Kiu2672]

@@linneajohansson3017 No because he really likes Hilarie. They still have a beautiful friendship.

[@Ambereigh]

@@linneajohansson3017 yeah and he real life cheated on her cause he didn’t really love her so...

[@kgrimes842]

Question was who would he pick yet his answer was still about Lucas picking. He couldn't pick because he's happily married with someone who's not like either of them

[@KenzieLillian]

Katherine Grimes was the question who he would pick to date in real life tho or who would he want to end up together on the show if he was in charge of that

[@Lptla]

are you kidding me?! Of course it was Peyton. It was destiny

[@TianaT4]

Actually Hilary Burton herself confirmed it was Brooke who was supposed to end up with Luke but since Chad was a dickhead and couldn't keep it in his pants, he complicated and ruined the whole OTH story, it would have been just weird if they ended up together.. But at the end, Brooke was way way more awesome than Luke and he didn't deserve her ,unlike Julian. So Peyton and Lucas were same level of lame, they deserved each other for all i care :D

[@Lptla]

lmao do you have the link of her interview? Hilarie has always supported Leyton, but even if she didn't she wasn't a writer of the show so her opinion didn't really matter. Mark himself said that Lucas and Peyton were meant to be from the beginning, that's why it was possible to make all the parallels between them bc it was all planned. Chad was an asshole, yes, I agree but the actors kept having scenes with each other, they had a lot of scenes in S5 and they also kissed once (season 5 episode 5 flashback), so it was still possible making brucas endgame but Mark couldn't bc leyton was the ship he had in mind from the start. I've never liked Brooke...never...so I respect your opinion of Peyton, even if I disagree obviously!

[@samlavin1391]

@@TianaT4 She said she got told that BL/JP were endgame at some point, but never said that the Chophia divorce changed that. Plus with everything that has come out about Mark, there's no way in the world he would have changed directions in order to make things easier for Sophia.

[@reinemfz2961]

@@samlavin1391 Sophia literally said they only wanted to put her in bras for her wardrobe so she came to set with a turtleneck to prove a point & they changed her wardrobe.. if she came to set & said she didn’t want to play a love interest with her CHEATING husband they most definitely would change it around. they changed it around in the already in season 2 & 3 because brucas had more chemistry, so..

[@samlavin1391]

@@reinemfz2961 Sophia has also said that Mark and the producers didn’t give a fuck about her and Chad’s feelings and were flat out running TV ads about their situation.

[@jiazubair4427]

Chad is so perfect 😍

[@JenniTheMusician]

Can we talk about how Chad called Stephen Chase? Weird.

[@mezagarner4427]

Chad is so funny!!!

[@3thugs80]

is that chase from oth

[@MaybeItsNimra]

yeah

[@gianvittoriomarti9393]

People stil accusing Chad for have cheated on Sophia 20 YEARS AGO, while now he has a family with 3 kids is crazy! Get a life 😭😭😭😭

[@GlodieLingomo]

Cuz he felt bad about cheating on her, so he had to move on very fast. 😂 stop defending a cheater, what he did was wrong and broke Sophia’s heart 💔 he have to acknowledge that

[@gianvittoriomarti9393]

@@GlodieLingomo Girl! 20 YEARS HAS PASSED, now he has a wife and 3 kids! If you don't understand this simple logic that's your problem! I'm not defending him, he made a mistake but you all are incapable to move on!

[@GlodieLingomo]

@@gianvittoriomarti9393 Well I hope he learned a lesson.

[@pavelsilviu9825]

I have an important question: why couldn't their love story be real?lucas -peyton?

[@vanessamendessouzamendes8308]

FAMOSO. LUCAS SCOTT 💕😍😍

[@ninishcjute7970]

Lucas and brooke would have ended up together had it not been for Chad cheating on her. They had so much chemistry that they fell for each other in real life. Ultimately I think they put Lucas with Peyton because it was too hard for Sophia and would make the whole story come full circle.

[@toobad9295]

no, litteraly from the first episode of one tree hill it was obvious that peyton and lucas would end up together with the fact that he had this long crush on her also they had an instant connection

[@ninishcjute7970]

Zora Blabla No actually that's not true, they started out with them as their start point but soon realized that their dynamics didn't work, they were just boring. Jake was perfect for Peyton he balanced her. And with Brooke and Lucas they were perfect in season 3 she was all energy and he was the calm one. The same with Hayley and Nathan they complement each other. Lucas and Peyton were the same person and that's why they had to break them up or make drama with either Peyton or Lucas when they were together to make it interesting. And what about the plot, "I'm the guy for you Brooke Davies" at that time they had made their mind that they would end up together. But in the end of the third season they realized how hard it was for Sophia and took another root. Lucas and Brooke were perfect.

[@toobad9295]

and that's why mark said otherwise? that it was always peyton and lucas, he said it? plus I'm not talking about who looks better as a couple I'm talking about lucas and peyton's CONNECTION

[@ninishcjute7970]

Zora Blabla When was I talking about who looked better, I was talking about the connection. There was none, in the first season they had a little but that was because Peyton was another person she was bitchy but then she changed as a character which didn't complement Lucas at all and they realized that Lucas and Brooke worked together. And yea of course Mark can't say the real reason, they even had some hope for them in the beginning of season 4 but there was no return at that point. And again if they wanted them to get back together they wouldn't take the Brooke and Lucas relationship as seriously as they did with him saying that she was the one for him. Lucas and Peyton were cute in the first season but that was it otherwise there was no connection at all. Hayley and Lucas would have worked better, Peyton and Lucas had become such good friends and it was like they were siblings so it just felt weird when they got together in season 4.

[@toobad9295]

okay and what about his long crush on peyton huh? or the books that he wrote about her? and the prediction he made with haley where he says that peyton sawyer will become peyton scott? and peyton's sketches of him? you keep talking about that one sentence he said to brooke? but that's all they had and since you're saying that what about lucas saying 'I want it all with you' it's even cuter

[@Justin.Dayoc85]

Yea he married her and you see how far that got. Little over a year and after all this this she still has nothing nice to say about him.

[@Sweets0727]

Ikr. It's funny cause Sophia acting as if just because he cheated on her the world was supposed to end-- girl bye. The man moved on with a wife and two kids. But I mean even thou, Chad never bash her or had nothing negative to say about her. She's so petty to me. Brucas/Chopia just didn't work - it happens.

[@Sweets0727]

Layla S ^^first of all, I never said I'm ok with cheaters. I simply said that Sophia acted as if she has absolutely nothing good to say about Chad. But I'm sure that was not the case before he cheated. I don't know how their relationship was but I doubt it was all bad js. And FYI: Sophia did indeed bashed Chad publicly - she called him her "f**kboy partner" on twitter. Guess the jokes on her since she went ahead and marry the dude smh.

[@alexforesta8068]

Why would Sophia have anything nice to say about him though? She has only publically commented about him maybe 3 times and honest why wouldn't she? Chad not only cheated on her, they got divorced and not even a year later he was engaged to an extra he met on set who was sophia's friend. Chad has no reason to publicly bash her she never did anything to him.

[@Sweets0727]

ALEXANDRA FORESTA Okay, don't hate me for saying this but - I'm pretty sure it was Sophia who stated - her mum told her "if you don't have something nice to say about a person then don't say anything at all". Did he cheated on her : yes . Did he regret doing it: yes Should we condemn him for it: probably not. The fact of the matter is we are all human beings and yes we make mistakes, but in doing so we learn from it, we grow from it and move forward. I'm not saying I support him cheating but I'm saying people tend to do stupid things when your young and naive. Now, in regards to him dating/engagement to Kenzie, that was foul (even thou I doubt Sophia and Kenzie was besties) but please don't pretend as if Sophia didn't date not one but two of Chad's friend ( i.e James and Austin respectively). Everyone to me deserves a second chance to redeem themselves imo. Did you hear of Chad cheating on any of other partners?-idk but I didn't so far.

[@alexforesta8068]

I agree that the comment she made was a little petty absolutely, but at the same time she did have reason to be upset, she was majorly betrayed by him, but its not as if she goes out of her way to talk about him. As far as her dating 2 of chads friends, James and chad apparently started having a lot of tension with each other before he started dating sophia and Austin came on the show because he was already with sophia him and chad were never friends by the time austin came on the show sophia and him were already together. I wont dispute sophia saying that wasnt great but there are other interviews where she does speak about her marriage positively as a learning experience.

[@parisveronica4202]

My Leyton heart is happy.

[@alicesalvatore5623]

Sorry but the only reason why he would pick Peyton would be bcz him and Brooke where married and he cheated on her in real life. And in the actual ending of the show Lucas and Brooke where supposed to end up together but since he cheated on her they both said they couldn't work that way so they changed it and he ended up with peyton

[@bianca-ht9tz]

i so agree with u...

[@Justbooksmusiccatsandapen]

Alice Elledge actually Mark has stated several times that it was always Peyton and Lucas. also Chad is playing the character of Lucas on the show he was asked who HE would pick. Sophia is a real-life individual Brooke is not she's a character big difference. Chad and Sophia couldn't make it work it doesn't mean their characters couldn't. besides if they couldn't be professional and work it out they wouldn't have lasted as long as they did working together on the show. Myself I've always been Peyton and Lucas. fan. Also Hillary and Chad have a close relationship offset.

[@katerinastydia8081]

What you are saying isnt real,when Sophia was asked about that she told the pres that everything that was going on in her personal life didnt affect her work and that they both acted as professionals Although the relationship betweem brooke and lucas wasnt supposed to last for so long it did only because they where together irl and the wanted to shoot more scenes together

[@alexforesta8068]

Its not true though that there divorce did not impact it one way or the other. Yes mark always said that leyton was endgame and that's what he wanted from day 1 but sophia wasn't in the pilot nobody knew the chemistry that chophia had and that shifted the direction of the show. Mark said publically numerous times that he was always mindful of chophias person relationship and couldn't force them to be romantic together after they divorced in such a bitter way, the truth of the matter is that at that time more fans did like brucas. Chophias chemistry is much stronger than hilarie and chads and even leyton fans know that. I'm not saying for sure brucas would have been endgame if they did not divorce but they wouldn't have been counted out as end game and they certainly wouldn't have continued writing the show acting like brucas never even existed.

[@moeshak9944]

If your fan you know not to ask that question. Apt of bad blood between chad and Brooke and you can’t just say they were young

[@mahatisathish4802]

Lmao I can't with their role play-

[@nataschamartins7]

Brucas >>>>>>>>>>> Leyton

[@jailasantiago8380]

Ohhhhhhhh I like Brooke and Lucas better together

[@zahraheidari191]

How in hell they did ask such a question😕 it's kind of inappropriate due to his past with Sophia bush

[@shawol275]

If lucas got his peyton in the end, why couldnt chad find his peyton In soph?

[@Kratos-GodOfWar]

Cause like Lucas, Chad was a dum-dum when it came to not fucking up relationships

[@sorohsmith6908]

What was Chad doing when he was lying down?

[@limaa8782]

Soroh Smith therapy

[@sorohsmith6908]

therapy for what

[@desdes777]

@@sorohsmith6908 it was a joke

[@onlyallegra]

No one acts the way Chad does. His body language, microexpressions, pauses, and even the way he articulates things makes you fall in love with any character he plays. I may even watch those movies still and like them. But real.. life .. Chad.., I will never fully support. Sophia all the way. Chad is an idiot. Used to think he pulled a Heath Ledger to try and become the cheater character he played. But, value wise, dude I don't respect him for doing that to Sophia. I will always love her first. Not sorry.

[@zoeyx9821]

He only ever called Brooke pretty girl though

[@Nazaba09]

Actually not true.

[@zoeyx9821]

When did he call someone else pretty girl?

[@ameliebzh56]

@@zoeyx9821 Lucas called Peyton pretty girl in 6x11. You're welcome :)

[@vbrandy7088]

look like someone didn't watch the show lol. Lucas called Peyton pretty girl as well and he also called her beautiful numerous times.

[@reinemfz2961]

@@ameliebzh56 and it was disgusting

[@loverlover6490]

Brucas all the way. Whether the show’s storyline was changed because of their real life breakup we don’t know but it’s common sense that It played a part in it.

[@Nazaba09]

It wasn’t. Mark wanted leyton but brucas was the fan favorite so they made them be together but Naley was ALSO fan favorite and mark wanted them to divorce after Haley came back from tour and the network said no so he said fine, if you get naley, I get leyton.

[@RChatterjee_15]

Okayy, I think people need to understand that Brooke and Sophia are NOT the same person ..Sophia is a real person.... Brooke is a character written by people .... this question is about Brooke...not Sophia...no one would dare bring Sophia in such questions considering what he did to her.. Sophia does not deserve to be dragged in these conversations.

[@jessicaaraujo7590]

ALGUEM TRADUZZZZZZZZZ?

[@mercuryman5800]

Is the question about the real life actresses or if the characters were actually real???

[@theauntyb2505]

Well he wouldn’t say Sophia cause that’s his ex

[@kendallrabideau1352]

deep down he wanted to say Brooke

[@Rachel.321]

Could any body please write what did he actually say?

[@layansasa7775]

Each relationship taught a lesson but in the end Lucas & Peyton were always meant to be... it was fate from the beginning

[@dianehermans]

wat you think hy was gone say when his current wife was ther hy cheating with her to on Nicky hy was wat maried divorce engement 3 time and every time was hy cheating

[@sarahdelgado1826]

the answer is peyton cause Chad cheated on Sophia, otherwise Brooke and Lucas would be endgame on the show, and that breaks my heart cause brooke and luke had so much more chemistry

[@dustybear7712]

Who. Ever you. Guys are. You. Need. To stop. Your. Custing on. Hear. Watch. Your mouth. You. Would. Be. Better. Of to. Stay. Off hear. You. Guys. Need. To. Grow up.

[@keishathe3rd]

Lucas had so much more game then Chad. Chad is a corny guy .

[@irabonta1874]

sophia divorced him after cheating on her

[@snb_angels]

And then she went on to date her other co-stars on that show. I like Sophia but all that was weird.

[@thewildbruce5612]

@@snb_angels Yeah. And now Sophia's married to a rich guy, just like her character Brooke told Peyton in season 1. 🤣

[@lydiatimmons6413]

I don't care about what people think I always gonna brucas🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@dandelion1469]

i think it would have been funny if instead of saying brooke or peyton he said haley