The Circulation of Commodities through Money | Chapter 3

[@ChapterbyChapter]

Support the channel and get the book through our (affiliate) link: amzn.to/3bdHSiB

[@kra3525]

I thought the background audio was terrible and too loud. But as I kept watching and I focused on the young gentledude's voice I began to calm down and focus on the spoken words. Huge flex when he was reading in German and switched back to English. Somehow the whole video worked out pretty well. Thanks for an awesome video gentledude.

[@Filmsfromthebear]

These are very intuitive videos! Thanks a ton for taking the time to put them out

[@4umata]

this is nice but pls filter abit more the background music, it sounds way too upfront and interrupting I feel

[@virtusoroca7724]

There's a point wich sounds quite strange to me. That some marxists reject Marx theory of value. Very unlikelly. This statement was linked in the video to the fact that things that dont have value, could have price. I dont see how the first statement connects to the other. Specially considering that the case for price-with-no-value issue is explicitly tackled by Marx in the last chapters of Das Kapital, book 3. He calls this an irrational value-form, and identifies that price in this case is determined not by socially necesary labor-time to produce it (afterall the thing in question is not product of labor) but by future gain (the obvious case is price of land, being determined by land revenue). Maybe youre presenting chapters before reading the hole book. I highly recommend reading it all first. I could give you guys some help if you like. Let me know. Great vídeo anyway. Thanks for the effort.

[@stogerat]

There are analytical marxists or some other schools of marxist thought that reject the LTV but come to a lot of the same conclusions regardless while valuing marx's materialist theory of history or other aspects of his philosophy/sociology/economics.

[@im2randomghgh]

He also significantly overstates modern dismissal of the labour theory of value. It doesn't seem to be a complete account, because of irrational prices and unrefined resources. The same is true of marginalism though, which short circuits when supply and demand are in equilibrium.

[@sholomantian]

Why this style of music in the background?

[@seedee3d]

cancer

[@B_e_e_k_a_y]

@@seedee3d lmao

[@pampachakraborty8309]

@@seedee3d bro people with adhd may find this nice

[@arturogonzalez6232]

“Hoarding of money indicates a stagnation in the circulation of commodities” ufff very applicable stuff there

[@marcusmeindel2103]

Wow, really precise! And well played jokes! I love the last second after the quotations :) Thanks for doing this and greetings from Graz!

[@SaifRizwan]

Great stuff, but the background music's a little distracting.

[@ChapterbyChapter]

We've been getting that a lot lately and I agree, do you think we should turn it down a bit or do videos completely without background music? -R

[@johan_r59]

@@ChapterbyChapter I'd say completely get rid of it.

[@pampachakraborty8309]

@@ChapterbyChapter people with adhd may find it helpful

[@SJPYT]

Why the annoying background music?

[@costbart]

yeah the minecraft music threw me off 35 sec in.

[@wy7128]

which episode is the concept of socially necessary labor time?

[@louisparry-mills9132]

Hey, great video. You mention that some later marxists reject the labour theory of value, do you know who the most prominent examples of this are?

[@socialistquickfix]

great video, background music is fine why the hate

[@amyhernandez4407]

Why is the music so sad?

[@padraigtomas3617]

Why any music? I want to hear what is being said. Regardless of the nature of the music, it is a distraction.

[@TopLobster11]

Because USSR failed😂

[@triggeredliberal7236]

Read the Critique of the Gotha Program, which is quite an insight to his knowledge of what a Communist Society would look like, the end of it being very famous or infamous really, I think at the start of his Critique, the misconception that Marx thought Labor was the source of value isn't exactly true, Nature is as another source as Labor for Value for him and he used that knowledge to critique the program and Lassalle , it was true for many of the others before him though who believed in it

[@chadmarx7718]

Value and use-value are different things. Also when marx uses the word "wealth", he means use-values. He even says in chapter 1 of capital that wealth may increase while value goes down

[@alancarlosms]

Excellent content, however I can't concentrate because of the background music.

[@Zach98506]

Thanks

[@nbvw3]

Judging by your accent in the German passage, you should have said "Dinge, de wos an und fia sich kaane Woan net sand..." (Servus von einem Wiener)

[@ChapterbyChapter]

Servus zruck! Gfreit mi, dass se Wiener des ah anschaun!

[@RobobTheGreat]

Upvote/like this comment if you were expecting the red-haired woman from the first 2 videos to be narrating this one as well.

[@JohnRunaway.Official]

I really appreciate this series, but I can't focus because the background music & the waving of hands is constantly distracting me 😂

[@schaeffer1994]

That is a lot of gesticulation

[@cesaralvarez2453]

Bring back the girl shes nice.

[@paddycowhey3406]

I love the vids but I like the girl more bc she's cute

[@ws-ob4wy]

The background music is annoying.

[@tofolcano9639]

3:47 Completely uncalled for side note... Especially after you talked about labor theory of value with no problems on chapter 1 and 2. Of course economists disagree with the labor theory of value, they haven't worked a single day in their lives! Lmao

[@jayrickyvillarante4202]

Please remove the background music!

[@ChapterbyChapter]

haha unfortunately i don't have the video without music anymore

[@ChapterbyChapter]

but for new videos i'll keep that in mind!

[@jayrickyvillarante4202]

@@ChapterbyChapter Thank you!! Your videos are great except the background music. :)

[@tylertownsend4074]

The music on this video is so distracting 😢

[@Luke-pk3rb]

Good video but the background music was godawful it was so hard to concentrate on what he was saying cuz I felt like sleeping to that slow soft classical music

[@the1onlynoob]

Ah yes, private power of private persons, Otherwise written in short as ‘pp of pps’

[@TopLobster11]

Him: If you are here because of Marx’s revolutionary ideas and are getting frustrated with Math, bear with me. Me, a Capitalist, who’s here for the Philosophy and also to win debate against my Commie friend: Yesn’t

[@pampachakraborty8309]

Respect

[@FLLMALL]

If you really want to debate with them, I'd recommend actually reading the book. At the end, however, you might actually become a commie yourself so...

[@authenticallysuperficial9874]

Conceding that the LTV is obviously wrong then saying "be nice to poor little Marxy, he doesn't know any better" is hillarious 😂

[@authenticallysuperficial9874]

Entertaining a person's delusions is not a legitimate expression of kindness

[@authenticallysuperficial9874]

And at any rate Marx is dead.

[@NomeUtenteNonDisp]

Dude! You gesticulate, like, A LOT. And I say that as an Italian. That's very distracting.