REACTING TO YOUR UNPOPULAR OPINIONS! I Was NOT Prepared!

[@janicedevereux2839]

My issue with Pat McGrath is her mothership pallets. They are expensive and yet when you have everyone she’s put out and none of them have a match ivory throughout the collection … not one light, Matte shade… Yet, dark burgundy, and Reds are throughout every mothership Pallet therefore such a waste of pan space, and money …

[@kathie4669]

I'm here for the mini blushes 😊 I'd feel so much better about buying new shades if they didn't take so long to finish.

[@chrissymoss514]

Yes please, half sizes in everything (size DOES matter and I want a small one 🤪). Just looking at the Haus Labs blushers puts me off and why on earth do we need plate size highlighters????? Great vid 👍👍👍 Love ya, 💜🌸💜🌸💜

[@R.L.Maverick]

I have an unpopular opinion…😀. I don’t do the Insta so do you think maybe you could post this inquiry on YT also so your loyal followers here can weigh in? Thanks for the video it was great hearing everyone’s take on this especially yours Charlotte!

[@R.L.Maverick]

You couldn’t have described it better between ND v PML eyeshadows. That said, I didn’t get the hype with PML until I bought the midnight sun palette. Then…I bought 9 other motherships at Christmas. Yes, I did. I am LOVING them!!!! Lol.

[@EmilyRose970]

Tubing mascaras are great because a good tubing mascara won't smudge, smear or transfer at all. It can get to the end of the day and your eye area looks exactly the same, sans any panda effect. They also come off very easily, in soft pieces (tubes) when warm water is applied, so good for people with sensitive eyes or fragile eyelashes.

[@chrystar1]

Yes! I have asian hooded eyes that become pandas with ALL non-tubing mascaras- even waterproof.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@kaina2001]

@@CharlotteHoldcroft Caliray come hell or high water is amazing!!! I have literally tried soo many and it lasts all day, does not smudge at all and I am pre menopause so i can sweat up a storm and nothing that resembles a dewy glow! lol and when I take my shower, no need to use anything makeup remover because it just slides off!! That stuff is something I have never experienced before!! The name suits it for sure

[@2009socalgal]

I agree! My favorite tubing mascara is still Thrive Cosmetics because of how easy it comes off. 2nd favorite would be Caliray (doesn’t wash off as easily as Thrive does).

[@kaina2001]

@@2009socalgal I’ve been seeing pop up everywhere! Going to have to try! People keep talking about the tower 28 one too

[@reganszczepanowska8272]

Minis!!!YES YES YES! Would totally be on board with 1/2 size foundations!,

[@emmalcm]

I love this sort of video from you! Also love that my husband now knows who it is when I'm listening to a video of yours, not by name but refers to you as 'that funny lady' 😂 makeup humour is clearly not wasted on him haha x

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤣🤣🤣

[@tammiemartinez6485]

I'm with Samantha. I don't like YT shorts either. Both are a waste of my time...

[@TheKiwibirder]

My two favorite Charlotte moments of late: the text to your boss about a "labial tear," and imagining you getting really angry at the wind. 😂🤣😂

[@mariahc9038]

I don’t think Pat McGrath would take so much heat for putting out more simple colors stories if she didn’t still charge artisan prices for them 🤷🏼‍♀️.

[@loytoco]

However, people are super fine re-buying the same colours over and over by Natasha Denona or Tom Ford. That was the point made by the person who commented. Same goes for price.

[@girlwhomustnotbenamed4139]

I think it's because she started out with interesting and versatile colour stories in her Motherships but has slowly transformed into all her palettes looking essentially the same. I'm personally not a fan of ND but with her mini and midi palettes her brand is a lot more affordable altogether, which takes a lot of the edge off, plus her eyeshadow colour stories are still mostly different and interesting.

[@loytoco]

@@girlwhomustnotbenamed4139 ND repeats the same colour stories over and over. Plus, the quality is not even close to PML. I find ND shadows quality extremely poor.

[@exomake_mehorololo]

​@@loytocoND is not even closely as repetitive as PMG. There's no argument here. We all have eyes to see it.

[@loytoco]

@@exomake_mehorololo that's just your opinion. ND releases palettes where half the colours are all the same. ND is not even close in quality to Pat McGrath, and yet people talk as if it is. If you like it good.

[@EvelienHV85]

I always felt CT got away with a lot, like their one face palette, while Hourglass was given so much shit about it. In regards to flawless skin: I think a good corrector will do more than a full coverage foundation. Especially if you’re older, I think a flawless skin will be easier reached with less of a heavy product.

[@eleniminas7742]

NOT AN UNPOPULAR OPINION:IN every video i can't get over how gorgeous your eyes look.Not just the eyeshadow but your eyes and your lashes OMG ♥︎ GOD bless you my beautiful, love u always all the way from Greece 🇬🇷 ♥︎♥︎♥︎ xo xo

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Awww thank you!

[@rikkirobinson4429]

Same

[@nadiadncr]

Συμφωνώ 😊

[@eleniminas7742]

@@nadiadncr γειά σου κούκλα μου γλυκιά ♥︎♥︎

[@nadiadncr]

@@eleniminas7742 γεια σου όμορφη 🧿🧿🧿

[@bzdwatson]

TOTALLY AGREE about wishing all makeup came in smaller sizes! That is one reason I love Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk foundation: it comes in a mini 18 mLsize or a full bottle. I ONLY buy the mini - since I use two shades (winter and summer) and don't wear foundation every day, it is hard for me to use up a full size bottle! And the mini is great for travel. I don't like large packaging in general, but also, who needs that much product?! Highlighters have gotten ridiculous!

[@ineswitherspoon873]

Don’t hate me but I’ve realised that Lisa Eldridge products generally are not for me. I had almost all the lipsticks (not just matte ones), lipglosses, liquid eyeshadow and went ahead and bought two of the eye palettes when she released them recently too but just can’t get on with any of it. In fact I just recently decluttered most of the lippies and think the eyeshadow might be going the same way 🙈

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

That's allowed! More for me...😉

[@msanyae8454]

I agree on the eyeshadow - they blend away to nothing-ness. The foundation is also no good. I like the lipsticks but they're nothing groundbreaking (except that red one is great 😍).

[@divadream]

I love your Instagram!! How long of a shelf life are her liquid eyeshadows supposed to have?

[@ineswitherspoon873]

@@divadream oh thank you 😊 I have no idea on shelf life, it’s not something I particularly pay attention to to be honest, I go by how it looks, smells and performs, if one of those is off then I’ll think about letting it go, otherwise I keep using it 🙂

[@Gemma1558]

I have one of her lipsticks and lip pencils and I was not impressed-too dry

[@cmyers6755]

I used to work on counter and we had a moisturiser for oily skin that lots of customers used to tell me they hated the smell (sweaty feet apparently) and why did the company make it smell like that - it was fragrance free! You just can’t win sometimes 🤷🏻‍♀️😆

[@jillpotts7472]

charlotte tilbury pillow talk lipstick and lip liner kit was my very first charlotte tillbury product. the liner wasvery difficult to get it to lay down pigment. and the lipstick lasts an hr at best!

[@mavrick6499]

Unpopular opinions: - Sperm eyebrows are so odd and strange. This is where people do a rounded head at the inside beginning of their eyebrow and then this thin tail drawn in after. - Putting bronzer, blush and highlighter basically on the same spot on your cheek. It looks ridiculous (IMO). - Crimped hair or mermaid waves. Maybe one supermodel looks okay with them in an editorial shoot. Everyone else looks like they slept with their hair in bobby pins or stuck their finger in a light socket and didn't wait long enough. (Enjoyed the video Charlotte!)

[@parksbpknit]

Yes, more mini's please!!! I also especially love mini nail polish too.

[@kristinelewis5373]

My unpopular opinion is that Pat McGrath collections are sometimes lazy, cash grabs or underwhelming. Not always, but I can’t forgive her for slapping stickers on top of overstock Midnight Sun palettes and saying “here’s my Star Wars collection.” Literally colourpop had more interesting Star Wars collabs (mandalorian palette, Star Wars and Darth Vader palettes)

[@valentinaufimzeff3527]

I am not understanding the hype about Lisa Eldridge’s lip products either. Have purchased some and it’s nothing special at all, just an average lip liner and gloss and lipstick. Definitely not a stand out products… but just good

[@jwb0310]

I agree. I like the glosses but in all honesty I think the nyx butter glosses are comparable and can get them for around £6. As for the lipsticks, the shades don't look anything like the online swatches and I'm yet to find a colour that suits me.

[@Desertmermaid52]

I think tubing mascaras are not supposed to transfer under the eyes as regular mascara would. I do have a transfer problem with my mature skin and hooded eyes but I don’t see a big difference with the tubing one- it’s a bit better when I use a tubing mascara but not a huge difference. ❤

[@joolsdunn1800]

I agree with the opinion on Le Labo. After hearing Santal 33 everywhere, I ordered a sample set. All of them were distinctly average and I actually disliked Santal 33. Baccarat Rouge 540 hype on the other hand - mmmmm! I love it!

[@jessicazhong9083]

I love using a hydrating primer on my dry skin. Even with skincare, my face isn't a good canvas for makeup because most foundations suck out the moisture from my skin. Primer acts like a barrier between skin and product, so I also believe in using both skincare and primer for skin prep. Nice video!!

[@sabrinapretty]

Chanel Ultra le Teint is the foundation I always grab when I want to look my best! It's amazing for glam makeup

[@jodismith8]

I adore ultra le teint best wedding foundation ever and I’ve tried them all 😂❤❤

[@MakeupVixen]

I learned from working at Mac that 85% of your foundations are equal to the same as concealers. In my kit I don’t even buy foundations, just a bunch of concealers. So that’s your half size foundation trick. Buy one corrector or brightened, one skin tone concealer and maybe a dark concealer for contour or bronzing. Done. A bunch of foundations are not needed. Enjoy your videos.

[@ingevanhulst1528]

I wanted to try a tubing mascara, ( I agree it is hard to know because it is not written on the tube) I had a feeling they were also more available in the USA and the uk than in Europe. But I finally got one ( the Victoria Beckham beauty mascara is a tubing formula). And guess what? I ❤️ it! ( it gives not that full on drama, but it gives length and separation and a good amount of definition. And it is really easy to remove, so nice with my sensitive eyes)

[@eligefashion]

I agree about the skin care being better than primer, I have intensely oily skin and since I've being using good skincare and routine I don't use any primer, only setting spray. My makeup lasts all day and applies beautifully. BUT I am interested in trying a primer one of these days again to see if changes anything. I feel for myself personally less products on my face equals to longer wear with my makeup. Setting spray is ALWAYS a must under my makeup.

[@dazereigh]

Le Labo The Noir 29 is my absolute favourite. I had a sample and had a gentleman ask me what I was wearing, said it smelled amazing. I went and bought everything in the range, no one had ever said that to me before.

[@sandytayler8518]

I agree I’ve got 12 Lisa Eldridge lipsticks. 3 of my Matt’s broke within 3 uses and I use them with just a tip showing so it makes me cross!!!! She needs to fix this. I love her shiny ones but I won’t buy any more Matt’s it’s just a waste of money when they break

[@emiliebova]

I don’t know how to use up my makeup! I am getting scared when I die, my children will need to toss all my powders and lipsticks and cream foundations in a bag and wonder what the heck I was thinking.

[@AllisonMoon-SheWandersFeral]

Perhaps you could assemble a list of what you have & book a FaceT8me consult with your favourite YT beauty MUA to help you out? What about #CheriVoyage? She does consult sessions

[@eleniminas7742]

😂 haha 😂

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

🤣🤣🤣

[@evelynrosado9711]

😂 😅

[@ConstanzeC]

Do a No-buy-year. Or two ...

[@unwindknitting]

I got to the end can’t remember everything I was going to comment on (I’m old)… but I will say I think WA reformulated her eye pods and the new ones that came in the holiday set are amazing. So much easier to use than the originals. I tend to use a tubing mascara on my bottom lashes because I have issues with transfer. I used to use the Mac Gigi black lash and now use Victoria Beckham. They don’t build as much as traditional mascara, but … no transfer. And easy removal.

[@eleonoradamone]

Hi Charlotte!! First of all, thanks for addressing my question (I'm freezingelf on IG). I agree with you, if you want to cover every imperfection, you probably need full coverage products, but I guess I could have expanded a but more about whan I meant. The thing about "flawless skin finish" that bothers me the most is people on social media going on an on about how flawless their skin looks just because they have applied at least 3 layers of full coverage foundation and patted on powder foundation to set it all. Of course theirs skin has no flaws! LOL But in real life, in person, their skin appearance is another story for another day.

[@TheMiikka34]

My dopamine hit doesn't come from solely luxury or solely drugstore products. I get happy and excited when I find something amazing like the perfect red lippie. I don't care where I get it, I just want it lol

[@drjcd66]

Hi, Charlotte! I love your "unpopular opinions" as well as your other content ☺️ I have to thank you for talking about the MAC Stack mascara in your videos. I finally tried it and LOVE it! Have a great week! XO from the States.

[@shelleymalone4427]

Here’s an unpopular opinion - the new Charlotte Tilbury blush pink pop is not pink. On my fair skin, it looks orange. I had to return mine 😢 Charlotte, I love your videos. You always make me smile.

[@sueanderson9860]

💯. Exactly the same for me!

[@vegasnine99]

Love this series. The new Chanel No 1 foundation fragrance is AMAZING.....I don't know if they make a perfume, but I need it

[@mlanden111]

I love some fragrances in products, but if it's something that directly touches skin it either needs to be subtle or there needs to be an unscented option, too. My skin can handle anything (i loved the peach scented line from TF) but i know others can't.

[@jenniferwilcox8773]

Thanks for using my unpopular opinion! I'm in Canada and currently watching old seasons of Love Island. I'm loving it like you!

[@kaliopinikitas5821]

You have the most incredible lashes, Charlotte! Love your videos and your sense of humour. I always look forward to your videos and really appreciate your take on all things makeup. Thank you for being you!

[@rnelson13]

I initially got WA eye pod in Tabac in a Cult Beauty advent and its not like any other texture I’ve come across (putty like). It’s gives a subtle light wash of colour (perhaps this the issue), I find once it’s been on your eyelid for a bit and warms up via your skin temp, it’s very pretty. I agree, it is awkward to get out of the pot with fingers and you do have to dig your brush in a fair bit. Can’t explain, I just weirdly really like them (I’ve also got Le Nuit set) … mind you I prefer a tinted moisturiser to foundation, so they may be better suited to those who are minimalist when it comes to everyday with a no makeup, makeup look 👍🏽😊

[@betsybabf748]

Every brand and every person will take criticism because some people just live to hate or bash someone or something. I love the staying power of matte lipsticks, but with a gloss over them. My lips get bigger from GlamGlow plumper. I put it on just to 'inflame' my lips while doing my eyes, then wipe off to use lip color I want for the day and notice a big difference.

[@holliberry2614]

Lisa Eldridge really does have the best lip products....mainly because the shades are so appropriate. I LOVE her Velvet lip sticks...but they are too drying for my lips...so the fix? Mac Lip Prep....and THANK GOODNESS , matching liner and then the lipstick. And BONUS, i add the matching Lip Gloss. She is a genius for making a whole 'kit' with matching liner, gloss and Velvet lipstick. They also stain so well...... that you can just pat some in..put a light gloss over it...and make it as light or dark as you want. Lisa Eldridge, Victoria Beckham Beauty and Chanel... my holy grails!!

[@marielle7505]

I was very surprised and sad to notice that I don't like Lisa Eldridge lipstick either. I have two, in two different formulas. The matte one is very dry and the color is shockingly different from what I expected from ordering online. It looked nothing like what I ordered, yet it was what I ordered. Way darker and way more cooltoned and it doesn't suit me at all. The other one is fine, nothing to write home about. I also have a lipliner, but that is in the same horrible color as the matte lipstick. That's three products, expensive ones too, and I hate two, and one is just fine. So no more Lisa Eldridge for me any time soon.

[@nicolabray2732]

Charlotte, actual pissin myself at the pet/children response🙌🏻😛🤣🤣 Honestly, you cheer me right up even though I’m not a big commentor, please know you are one hilarious, fantastic woman🙌🏻🥰💞 xx

[@karenphipps7532]

Mel influence is still being felt ❤ I found your channel through the makeup mystery box exchange you did!

[@lisapierce525]

Love these unpopular opinions videos! Your eyeballs are sparkling like a mischevious child! That’s a compliment if you don’t know it! And you look stunning! ❤

[@jillpotts7472]

my makeup artist friend said i can't wear shimmer eyeshadow, only matte z im 53 and takecare of myself ...i was bummed . she 1said. my eye lids are too wrinkled ☹️

[@nathalielamothe6899]

You should wear what makes you feel happy. Who cares if it’s not perfect? I say: « Simply have fun! »

[@Elizabeth-tm7xr]

I too am tired of the "Pillow Talk" label. It's named too much in too many products. The name is to me, now, mundane. Try the Chanel foundation please and thank you! Thank you Charlotte!

[@danaconnor8255]

You need to try Chanel Ultra Le Teint...

[@leahmiranda8359]

The Guerlain Meteorites has a fragrance that reminds me of the April Violets perfume by Yardley of London that I was LOVING in my early adult years! I wish I could still find it! I love these videos! Your sense of humor slays me.....every time! 😂

[@twoleftfeet9626]

I have found the BEST primer (apart from the new Dior Glow one) Urban Decay all nighter setting spray applied as a primer. Makes foundation sit fantastically

[@reneeallred5082]

I also hate CT cream bronzer but love the Chanel

[@lynnewoods7925]

I have thoroughly enjoyed this episode, not laughed this much in ages 🤣

[@yoshih.8910]

I have a few palettes from Path and I really miss there some light matt transitions shades. 😏

[@leighriley4176]

Me too i was just looking to buy a single shadow for that purpose but i dont kno who to buy from

[@yoshih.8910]

@@leighriley4176u can try Sephora matte, scented candle or chou a la creme, if you prefer cool tone.

[@evelynrosado9711]

ND shadows are more wearable for day to day than PMG.

[@evelynrosado9711]

For me the Dior foundations works really well in my mature face skin.

[@phyllidaacworth5212]

I do sometimes find high street makeup exciting. I have discovered a new range of MUA eyeshadows that is incredibly cheap but has the most beautiful metallic shimmers. Their five pan palettes are very reminiscent of Natasha Denona minis.

[@tammyroy9042]

Your videos are always fun but these are especially fun! I have a LOT of makeup and was trying to think what unpopular opinions I might have - the only one I can think of off the top of my head. The Tower 28 mascara……EVERYONE raves about it in the beauty community so…..I bought it and it does nothing for my lashes. It’s nice, it performed well, it was ok but there is no wow factor for me and I feel like I’m the only person on the planet who doesn’t love it and this is a safe space for me to say that out loud lol 😂 Smiles from across the pond🇨🇦

[@katies4521]

It’s so interesting how many unpopular opinions people have, but that’s great because I love these videos. Also, you explained the difference between Pat McGrath and Natasha Denona palettes for me also

[@janicecroissiert9116]

The Chanel Le Teint foundation was too drying on my normal/dry skin. Glad it was a sample.

[@eimearinez]

I love CT minis esp for holidays

[@barbbandurski3679]

Love your videos. Watching from across the pond and feeling frustrated because of so many advertisements

[@denpearce9162]

Tubing mascara doesn’t come off with eye makeup remover or cleansing balms. You remove it with warm water & gently rubbing you’re lashes. I’m no expert but love trying new products. I have a Beauty Pie new tubing mascara arriving this week which I’m looking forward to trying. Thxx & love you’re vlogs xxx

[@cindyp5132]

Now I might never see Charlotte's dog?! I've waited years for a sneak peek, I've heard him, I think he's big... But I'm sad now cause I love a pet in any video!! 😁🤣

[@ClaireRogers]

I love Lisa and I just picked up Sorcery Lip Gloss, absolutely love it but my hair did stick to my mouth when I wore it and it's windy! I knew it would but for some reason I expected this lip gloss to be different! When you don't like some type of products, it doesn't matter which brand they're from.

[@sarahc-b]

I have two of the WA eye pods (Tabac and Champagne) and they're gorgeous. I think maybe people don't like them because they're not super impactful? They're a lovely wash of subtle color that can be built up, and the formula is really, really good. I'm more into "in your face" colors, but use these a lot when I'm either going for something more neutral or want subtle shimmer. They're pretty on-brand for the whole line.

[@lionesslux6816]

Some lipsticks or glosses without scent tast like soap and I really cannot handle that. So at least in lip products it is a big yes for perfume. The rest of my makeup I like having non-perfumed.

[@symphorosa2526]

I also find it hard to love Lisa Eldridge lip products…the colours are either too blue based ( why so many rose/pinks..?) too bright or too nude/ brown for me…I’m still waiting for a muted terracottaish red…sadly even Cinnabar lipstick is not warm enough and too bright

[@shattered00]

Have you tried Le Labo's The Matcha 26? It's a relatively new scent, I tried it on at an airport counter when I was traveling, could not stop smelling my arm for 3 days.

[@coding7196]

I am sympathetic with those who hate some fragrances. Ilia's Wanderlust smells of toffee and it annoys me now.

[@worthigirl2946]

Totally agree with you love! I want to look dripping wet, all the time, as if I live in the rainforest and it's always raining!🤣🤣❤️

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Yes!!

[@mlcarv]

The Westman Atelier eyeshadows are good until they dry out a few months later. I won’t rebuy any even though I love the blush, highlighter and contour sticks and love the brand’s esthetic in general.

[@loytoco]

I agree on the Pat McGrath comment. She gets a lot of hate also for prices. The same people that complain for the price of a mothership are fine with the prices of Tom Ford or Chanel quads, who also release the same colour story over and over. I do not like Lisa Eldridge products on anyone. Whenever I see influencers wearing them I always think they look like they are wearing drugstore products. Considering her ties to L'Oreal, that's probably even accurate. I also find that good skincare works best for me than primer.

[@lindsayhoffman2688]

I think the price complaint is because PM has sales like 10 times a year. I bought something at 35% off over Xmas and a week later, it was 40% off 😂. Chanel and Tom Ford never do sales, so people accept it is what it is. But with PM discounting things all the time, it no longer makes sense to pay full price or buy anything at launch as full price now feels like a cash grab if you know it will be so much less in a few months.

[@loytoco]

@@lindsayhoffman2688 To me, Chanel and Tom Ford are much more money grabs than PML. Sales are an opportunity, not something to be offended by. Nobody forces people to buy things at launch. Lisa Eldridge does the old "sold out" strategy all the time, and people are still there playing. There is just this thing of needing to hate on something if somebody else does. It's like the whole Hourglass/Chanel comparison. Everybody is fuming because Hourglass needs more shades, but nobody is mad at Chanel. People just love hate trends, imo.

[@lindsayhoffman2688]

@@loytoco I’m not mad at any brand 😂. They can charge what they like and people can choose to pay or not. I’m just saying for me personally and probably a lot of other people, PM’s constant sales (seriously, I think she has more than any other brand, there is one right now after having had two different ones just this past December) means I will no longer pay full price for any of her products because I’m happy to wait. And when you know you can get it close to half off several times a year, the full price seems even higher by comparison. I do buy Tom Ford and Chanel from time to time. For me, it’s worth it, as I love what I have but I am also very selective….like I wouldn’t buy eyeliners, mascaras etc… that I can easily get elsewhere for much less but will instead choose something special that I know I will adore and use regularly, like the TF Nude Dip quad.). All makeup brands are kind of a cash grab really, with the markups and margins being so incredibly high. I just think PM gets the “hate” for her prices as you say moreso than other brands because she positioned herself as a luxury brand but the constant sales and discounts has tarnished that reputation a bit. (Not to mention recent launches where she put Star Wars stickers over older, unsold stock….it just doesn’t look great.). Chanel and Tom Ford type brands are always consistent in pricing and aesthetic so it’s harder to complain about something that’s been the same forever. You either love them and are a customer or you have no interest and pass them by but I don’t think there is any expectation/disappointment or feeling of connection to the brand the way people seem to with PM.

[@lindsayhoffman2688]

@@loytoco Fully agree that people love hate (and love) trends. Hourglass and Tarte got crucified for lack of shade range but nobody said anything about Dior, Chanel etc… who are much worse in that respect. Fenty was christened the leader paving the way for inclusive shade ranges when MAC has been doing that since the 90’s.

[@jillpotts7472]

love glossy lipstick and scented makeup

[@dkladiann]

I agree with you that you never know what a tubing mascara is, but I find if it never comes off my eyes without a lot of work it seems to be a tubing mascara

[@jbridges9574]

I don’t like CT Pillow talk lipsticks. I think my lip tone is too purple- the lipsticks all look like dirt on me. I also don’t think the formula is worth the money.

[@aleseonlife]

Only 2m in and I def agree about PML. People hate on that brand so much. I don’t buy everything, but I also don’t feel compelled to get upset when there’s a repeat release I don’t want. 🤷🏾‍♀️ And yea… I also find ND a little boring… but I always like the looks I create with her palettes… boring, but looks so good 😬

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

💞💞

[@jodismith8]

Definitely get a ultra le teint sample that would be fab to see ❤😊 it was my wedding foundation it lasts so well all day without touch ups and I don’t find it too matte (I don’t like matte foundations I like glow- it isn’t very glowy but definitely luminous) ❤ Love your videos xx

[@annemarietimmerman7213]

Loved the video, so interesting, thanks so much dear Charlotte, and looking amazing as always!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩 Being 52, having more sensitive eyes now, i gave away almost all my PMG/ND/SG palettes. But now, Pat has a liquid shadow that does NOT fly into my eyes and i just love it!!!! Why hating Pillow Talk....i was a bit Pillow Talk tired, but understood the last years more and more that it's a brand in a brand indeed. What i would love to see from CT, is doing such a good 2.0 version with the Original Pillow Talk quad. She CAN do it, i hope she does!!! What is flawless? So personal. When i smash Suqqu quad 117 on my eyes (have sort of hazel/khaki eyes), i don't have to think, i blend here and there, and it's maybe not flawless, but elegant colours and shine, love their formula so much!!! What is flawless foundation, yes depends on the skintype, for me a bit dry and sensitive. I think i use my Cle de Peau matte foundation in the glass bottle the most, sometimes mixed with the more radiant/natural one from them. Also love others like all Chantecaille foundations. But because of certain fragrance or lavender oil (TF) i cannot handle, lots of them i have to let go.The pet question, i respect everybody, really! But love to see pets!!! Thanks Charlotte, have a wonderful day!!!😘😘😘😘😘😘

[@Trotro2023]

I love the Dior dream skin cushion foundation. One of my faves, but very expensive.

[@mindie1594]

I find the Huda concealer very dry! but love the coverage. I use it on the inner of my eye and then a more creamy concealer for the rest. I find the two balance out and it works a treat!

[@twoleftfeet9626]

Try the Dior forever skin correct. Better coverage than huda and less drying

[@mindie1594]

@@twoleftfeet9626 I recently bought it. I like it, but I find myself going back to my combination.

[@rachelo6727]

Viseart has mini eyeshadow palettes 😉

[@shadow_wolf2177]

You’re the first one I’ve seen wear Fire Rose on here. So sad that I missed out on that palette. Stunning eye look.

[@janicecroissiert9116]

I love the Dior Super Potent Serum foundation. Great, for dry/normal skin. The best foundation I have tried from Dior.

[@prof.m.19]

Chanel Ultra le Teint is a great foundation indeed.. I am all for mini makeup as well. It is quite annoying. I stopped buying makeup a few years ago just because I have so much already and they take forever to finish. Plus, every makeup line now is making everything bigger and bigger. I don't need an eyeshow paletter of 12 colors only to see another 12 color palette launched the following season. It is nice that we now can get mini mascaras of our favorite brands - travel size. Perfect! But what about the rest! Mini eyeshadows? Mini lipsticks? where are they? And stop making those foundation glass bottles so heavy. I don't want to pay for the bottle, I want to pay for the product. Enough already! There. I ranted. 😁😁😊😊

[@jodismith8]

It’s amazing isn’t it- was my wedding day foundation ❤

[@katemakeuplooks]

Got a Gucci Westman eyeshadow in a Cult Beauty advent calendar and it is indeed rubbish. I think it’s supposed to be an eyeshadow topper but I rubbed and rubbed with my finger and hardly any came out. They are also tiny and very expensive.

[@mimimoon6082]

Thanks for sharing your unpopular opinion Charlotte! this was fun to watch but I'm still trying to process question at 16:29.

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

Same!😅

[@redouteshabby2024]

I understand the Pillow Talk dislike when every launch had the same shades-if the original didn't work for you (every palette looked terra cotta on me) then none of them worked. But today you are correct, its just a sub brand of the brand. Westman Atelier eyeshadows...WELL, they are extremely small for the price and some work and some don't. Some don't last 5 minutes and some are lovely. But its a heavy investment to find out!

[@claudsnyc]

That was a fabulous unpopular opinion video! Really enjoyed it. Just goes to show that we all love different things and have different experiences with products. Thank you Charlotte 🥰😘

[@CharlotteHoldcroft]

So true!

[@lovefilles]

where shall we write you for unpopular opinions outside Instagram?

[@ladyveracity]

I’ve never bought Nars Orgasm anything, or CT Pillowtalk anything. Nothing against them, I just have yet to see something in those ranges that really speak to me. One day I will, and THAT is why they keep producing in those lines.

[@ioanaanghel2975]

Have you tried Dior Prestige foundation? I love it, I’m surprised not many people mention it.

[@michellemuntau]

Haha OMG. I did not think that you would answer my unpopular opintion 😂 I think it depends a lot what SPF you use (mine works as a gripping primer) and what skin you have. If you are oily primer is 👌

[@michellemuntau]

Love you channel ❤

[@Eileen3007]

I have never tried the Chanel Ultra Le Teint either Charlotte, however, I have heard good reports about it. I would be interested to see you review this perhaps you could get samples! Xx

[@twoleftfeet9626]

It is matte, but very nice. I have it

[@jodismith8]

I love it and I don’t like matte foundations it doesn’t look too matte on my skin just very natural but perfecting 😊

[@peninalipkin2974]

I dont own any of Lisa Eldriges lipsticks because I heard a while ago that they were snapping and breaking. is that still happening? I tried her new lipgloss the Dancing Rose and it is the best lipgloss i have ever used so smooth and like a real skincare product not at all sticky i may even need to buy more thats crazy coming from me

[@arzumgulsar6951]

Westman Atelier are very lush and velvety. Apart from the shade Tabak, the others are ‘subtle’ shades. Maybe that’s the criticism.

[@kerriann81]

I agree with the comment about ND versus PM eyeshadow. I loved ND but now that I have 2 motherships I can’t go back. I still like my glam palette but I’m doubtful I’ll purchase any more ND.

[@kerriann81]

And I feel like it’s easy to make PM shadows everyday friendly. Especially Divine rose 1. That’s my office go to!

[@jwb0310]

Funny as I am the opposite. I would reach for Natasha denona over pat mcgrath 9 times out of 10. I much prefer the ND formula and I just can't get on with the PMG special shades.

[@laritalovesmakeup]

Charlotte I’m so happy your not going to shorts here on You Tube. So many are and I just don’t like it. I feel if I wanted shorts I would go to tic toc. Il like you I only go there sometime for funny pet Videos. Oh! I absolutely love my pets. Xo. ❤

[@v.conforti653]

That blush looks lovely on you!!

[@AllisonMoon-SheWandersFeral]

I finally saw Natasha Denona in Barcelona. I don’t know why anyone would buy hers, when they could get Catrice 5 palettes that seem identical