WHAT IS THE NUMBER 1 HOLIDAY EYESHADOW PALETTE 2024? Let's RANK Them!

[@bushraaryan1841]

Hi Charlotte. A bit off topic but I wanted to thank you for the video you did about swimming. I too am still sad about a career path that didn’t work out for me and you really made me feel ok about not being ok…hope that makes sense 😊 Thank you 🩷

[@everydayjanuary3648]

The Icy nude is my top pick too! I absolutely love it. I returned the new Mario palette and got Icy Nude. Best decision.

[@Suseau]

I agree. That kick up is so annoying

[@angelahampson391]

The very best content there is out there totally professional and unbiased and trustworthy . Thank you a million times over ❤

[@kathleenquinlan4316]

I wholeheartedly agree with you, Charlotte! I wasn’t going to get Icy Nudes until I saw your review. I just love it! It’s my #1 too!

[@bevyoung2009]

The Visiart pallet is beautiful.

[@chemkink]

Yes. This video makes me want it to much.

[@vegasnine99]

I just bought the Lancome celestial palette on 30% off on their site today for Black Friday. I’m very excited to try it.

[@joellematar7828]

The color story of the viseart is STUNNING. I got a lot of palettes this year, but I love this one. I feel like I will buy it when it becomes available in France

[@FirstLadyD]

👑💕😯😀 I am pleasantly surprised, kind of shocked, but yay for Huda📖♥️🙏🕊️

[@KerstDo]

Bought the Bobbi Brown palette because of you (and because it was reduced to half the price ^^). She is stunning.

[@jenna-lynroman4127]

I bought the Viseart, but am anxiously awaiting its arrival. I also got the Hermes Minerales (which I think was holiday) and the Chanel.

[@sanjapetrevska4994]

Eyeliner Charlotte is stunning ❤

[@raeb84]

I added the Huda Icy Nude to my list. I picked up the Pretty Grunge this year, but seeing your review and a few others has convinced me.

[@jbbb7418]

Love this! Huda is my #1 as well… I also picked up Roxa, but like so many ND palettes, that are sort of one color or theme, I knew going in I would reach for it occasionally, and it would fit the purple need perfectly. I really love round up videos. They are so helpful when working within a budget, and with this economy I can not afford to make a wrong purchase step if at all possible.

[@karencarey7977]

Thinking of buying Huda Icy Nude palette for my 18 year old daughter for xmas - 20% off on Cult Beauty at the moment. It's a stunning palette.

[@SarinaMunro]

I think that’s a wonderful gift for your daughter!☺️♥️🙌🏼

[@mlpnorthsub8543]

Thank you so much for your, as always, incredible reviews, humor and honesty. I appreciate that you discuss the quality of the shadows, which may differ from your color story ranking. I will take a closer look at palettes 2-5. I wouldn't give Huda Kattan a penny, and therefore will skip over your #1. Thank you again. Looking forward to your next feature.

[@Suseau]

I think the Huda glitter was genius - puts sparkle on any shade you want without messing with it. It is astonishing how each and every sparkle goes from my finger to the eye and stays put.

[@TheNemesister]

That tacha set is lovely and of course the LE cleanser and bag kit 😍

[@mariasurikova702]

From all those palettes I´ve bought only one - and it´s actually the winner! Somehow I didn´t use it yet, so maybe this weekend I´ll pull the trigger. I´m quite surprised there´s no Dior or Chanel there. But I´m OK with it. Thank you for nice video!

[@gailschaefer-guajardo6731]

I was wrong I thought Viseart would be number one. Have ever tried Indy Brands like Fantasy Cosmetica, especially their Fall Harvest palette designed by Amanda Fitzgerald from Makeup Just for Fun in calibration with Fantasy Cosmetica.It's just a suggestion some of them are really pretty. I love Huda's Icy Nude palette. I am going to get my hands on it, they say on Black Friday Huda is having 80% off site wide. I deserve to do something nice for myself as I start radiation therapy tomorrow and my last day is 12/24/24. I loved this video, your look stunning today and your eye makeup is gorgeous, Icy Nude perhaps ....💖.

[@keepfitgirl8191]

I really love the colour story of Huda but I am put off by the idea of fallout! I have the Rose Quartz and get annoyed with the glittery bits underneath my eyes after applying. Btw Bobbi Brown do some rather lovely looking trios. There's one called Everyday Greys that I've got my eye on! Emma x

[@RoseOfMadina]

That's a common issue with glittery shades. Do you use an eyeprimer?

[@keepfitgirl8191]

@RoseOfMadina yes I do. It stays on my eyes ok but I just end up with the sparkles under my eyes & in my lashes as I'm applying it.

[@EllaLahnspiel]

Thank you for this great overview! Totally agree on your thoughts re the Viseart and am very intrigued by it now. Another palette that is pretty and twinkly but soft and we are able throughout the season rather than just for fireworks is the Suqqu holiday palette 101.

[@aggiaggi8306]

your eye makeup is stunning, please could you give us a tutorial?

[@AnneFry-n4m]

Luv the Icy Nude. Best pallet I have ❤

[@glambysophie1]

I´m loving the palette from Bobbi Brown, the packaging, colour story. Cyberweek is starting and I found it for 25% off and I bought it. ❤

[@julia_1421]

you made me want the PatmcGrath palette sooo bad😆😍😍 its really beautiful! and her metallics are just the prettiest on the market. I think the red packaging just throws people off, because when you look at the swatches on her site it looks much more neutral and pretty😍

[@DeliciaTrini]

I’m having a blast with the Luminous Legends! You can get both day time and evening looks!

[@susankleinman7849]

My palette of the year is the new viseart, and the Bobby brown!! Plus I got the Lancome Celestial Rose which has an amazing blue! Love your ranking 🙋‍♀️🇬🇧

[@gladysgarrity5721]

Hey Charlotte I couldn’t agree more with you it is absolutely beautiful mine is coming Saturday can’t wait ❤see you soon ❤

[@megdvs21]

What wonderful list 😀 I haven’t actually picked up any “ holiday release “ palettes this year but the ones I’ve enjoyed the look of and the looks created most were the viseart palette, the icy nude palette, and the ABH sugar palette

[@lavayuki]

My favourite is definitely the ND Roxa, followed by the Viseart and big pat mc Grath palette.

[@fatimag9108]

Hi Charlotte ! Thank you so much for this video At this point i believe we are telepathically linked in someway or another… i was thinking about all these palette releases and which would be best just yesterday! A while ago i wondered what holiday releases would make perfect gifts this year .. nonetheless that icy nude palette I’m enjoying your content for the personality you have & interests & of course humor i find myself enjoying every second thank you so much Please know your loved & appreciated so much

[@michifoong22]

Hi Charlotte! How would you compare Natasha’s INAN with Huda’s Icy?

[@ivanavaskova9458]

Hi Charlotte, I haven’t purchased yet but love Huda Beauty Icy Palette. Sending❤❤❤

[@jennifermajor5013]

I keep trying to not purchase the Icy Nude, but oh my she’s gorgeous ❤

[@SueGreene-st7qc]

Hi Charlotte, love this video. It was very fun. Hey make sure you check your Patrick top pallets very well because you may have heard that many people are finding a white mold on their eyeshadow pallets, especially on the very shimmery colors. It’s a certain formula they use that has a lot of moisture in it.

[@beeshopspink]

So many good ones this year, my faves are Chanel, Gucci, cles de peau and D&G palettes

[@Gnv-q2m]

I’ve purchased the BB Gleam Dream as my Christmas palette this year. I don’t have anything like it. I watched Lexi Jong’s video and your video and then had a full on makeover with the palette at a BB counter in-store before purchasing it. It’s tucked away to debut next month. I also like the Smokey Gleam palette and the eye trios but I keep a small curated collection of palettes and I can dupe these in my collection. The quality is great.

[@lovefilles]

The last eyeshadow palette I bought was the Lisa Eldridge Fawn, but it's not a Christmas palette. Currently, I'm not tempted by any of the latest releases. I already have some many palette that I absolutely love and I can t see right now how they could be surpassed. I feel like I've got plenty of options with all my Lisa E. and Tom Ford and ND alettes to last me a lifetime.

[@marybonome9279]

Great over view! Ty Charlotte! I'm not a shadow connoisseur 😅😅😅😅Something really has to reaally speak to me!! I purchased the Lancome Ltd Holiday which Lisa Eldridge collabed on! So beautiful! Color story and packaging- yes! MBM Ethereal-I know this is not everyone's cup of tea-but I love it! Finally - Viseart Sirensuse ..waiting for it! You definitely had a hand in my wallet!!!I love a cooler story- the ABH and Lawless are nice too but I prefer spending on Face products and skincare😂😂. Ty Charlotte!🎉🎉🎉

[@julieduran5769]

You're a genius! Yes, this is what I want to know! What's your favorite? How do they compare to each other? I was so excited to see this video!

[@thinkbig5438]

My color palette is soft winter. Xenon is my every day palette. 😅 I will try icy nude, but I‘m afraid it leans to neutral for me.

[@dvanhottie]

Wearing the Viseart today. It’s really pretty.

[@Mama-de-Tia]

Was quite shocked to see the Huda palette at no.1! Nice to know you can still surprise us 😂😊

[@Heyitskrystal]

Do you have the Bobbi Brown single shadow in moonstone? I think it’ll be your favorite single shadow ever please try it.

[@MsBNoodle]

Great idea there have been so many releases!

[@Suseau]

Huda Icy Nude does it all, but as complicated as Dior Celestial Purple looks, it might take over. Just got it today, still hesitated to use it, but on the eyes, it does something unexpectedly beautiful..

[@minniemadonmakeup]

Ooh can’t wait to see this list 💜 ps love your makeup ❄️.

[@evas4455]

I would love to know if astral solstice from the original divine rose palette is anything like the Patrick Ta in the Club shades. I have scoured KZbin trying to see if anyone does this comparison but nobody seems to have. I don’t suppose you could tell me if they are similar?

[@bevyoung2009]

Thank you gorgeous lady 😘

[@jillpotts7472]

great video

[@iissosmarts]

I had ZERO intention of buying the Patrick Ta duos. I was just happy, plooding along life, chuckling at the silliness of the so-called 'drama' over them, and then I saw your video on the gift guide for beauty lovers and your eyeshadow had me HOOKED!!!! I fell into a rabbit hole of trying to figure out what you were wearing on your eyes and just immediately purchased the Still at the Club Duo, having to pay an atrocious amount for shipping, but it's okay - at least my eyes will glisten during this holiday season whilst my bank account cries 🥲.

[@aggiaggi8306]

Charlotte, is there any chance to snag PMG Mothership at the BF sale?

[@BrendaBostonGirl]

Number 10: the Lancôme! Ah well, still great video!

[@bevyoung2009]

Hello beautiful Charlotte 😍

[@loribethbriscoe1357]

You have to try the new NARS palette!

[@abbyveronika1071]

1:09 and i say bobbi brown! ☺️

[@wb4n6]

You have to get the new lancome

[@CharlisDailyDiary]

💜💜💖

[@MarkHandley-c9f]

MY favorite is the Charlotte Tilbury Love Palette and second is Dior Soir de Bal.

[@ra.j7210]

I like Patrick ta stuff but this shadow duo even if there were ten million pearls in each I still wouldn’t b bothered because it has no impact !

[@EXOmakemeHorololo]

I'm confused why I can't see the PMG anywhere but on her website. I did buy past holiday palettes from other websites for sure 👀 it's nice to order from somewhere more reliable!

[@DeliciaTrini]

It’s on the Sephora site as well. I’m pretty sure it’s on the Ulta site

[@Елена-е2с2о]

Почему недоступны субтитры?

[@lavoixdevelours]

If Huda had put another duo chrome in there it would be perfect. Bling is awful.

[@niccar11]

Bling is such a waste of space in the palette. Could have been a blue shimmer? Icy something anyway.

[@taceyfowler8166]

Closed captioning be nice for me to hear you. 🤦🏽‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

[@virgniam4058]

I have to say I’m shocked by the winner! Not because it won, because everyone is loving it…. But your review of the Roxa palette seemed more glowing than your initial review of the Icy Nude! I actually bought the Roxa because of that! I’m still in the “return” window and now I don’t know… do I dare keep both🫣😬. I have INAN too … I was trying to downsize… 😓