Charmed 3x22 Phoebe Dies, Prue Lives

[@barbarabaker1457]

That would have been an interesting direction as I always thought that Paige felt more like another Phoebe.

[@justinpullin98]

anastasia majoras Danielle Pullin

[@barbarabaker1457]

@@justinpullin98 I don't recognize those names can you clarify what this is about?

[@turtlelover8]

wow! you're so good at pieceing the episodes together and making them seem so real!

[@Senate300]

Just imagine how devastating it would've been for Prue, Piper & Cole if Phoebe died. Prue in her self loathing over the younger she failed to protect even though it wasn't her fault and Pipers would be inconsolable in her grief when the rage boils over. And Cole may as well be dead since he wouldn't be able to live with himself knowing the woman he loved died for him. Plus her sister won't be able to look at him anything other than hatred. Afterall, The Source did order Cole's imprisonment and Phoebe's assassination after Tempest reversed time at his request.

[@justinpullin98]

Danielle misty & anastasia it Justin

[@DavidTyler]

It would made sense if phoebe died and not Prue

[@Senate300]

@@DavidTyler Prue died because Shannon Doherty burned bridges with the Charmed powers that be.

[@cuteygirl949]

I have nothing against Paige but I think that the show was way better of before her entry

[@jdmalone95]

I can't remember if I commented on this before but I watched it again and had to say that it was awesome. I'm really loving that "Shining Allure - Relive the Charmed Story" effect at the end of your vids. Amazing. 5 stars.

[@cuteygirl949]

The show would have gone out better if prue died but they resurrected her and got her identity back plus added Paige as an extra because prue was the best sister

[@SlayersEulegy]

Great job. Really enjoyed it!

[@Haiqeem]

This is the way I pictured one of them ‘getting vanquished’ in the little fire screaming. Haha😂. You should do Prue next.

[@sapirush12]

pheobe is the best!!!! I prefer her to live

[@joffreyg7994]

Best decision = season 4 with shannen, holly, alyssa and Rose. Make just few scenes with shannen and Alyssa together. Like that, no drama and the show would have been so Amazing !

[@InnermostFear]

Once again an AMAZING video!:) I just love every single thing you do!

[@eddyhalliwell]

Nicely done!!

[@purpledarklighter]

Cool, very original and well done!

[@0ominnio0]

wow amazing work

[@EsmeraldaWyatt]

I would've loved it if this is how it had gone - especially if Paige never showed up. Shannen and Holly are such close friends...them battling evil with the help of Cole and Leo would've been so great! Especially if Phoebe could come back as a ghost and remain the Phoebs I love and not the PhoeME/Freebie she became - AND Wyatt was Phoebe Melinda like he should've been..

[@jan0009683]

great vid! i love it! :)

[@lostinozfan36]

that was sad when Phoebe died it makes more sense to kill of the eldest than the youngest.

[@JuanCarabajal]

wow, very well done!

[@disizzie]

You're sooo amaing a making vids, i wish none of them had died! That way it'd be the power of 4!

[@paigesylvester1758]

That NEVER Happend, Prue Died And Phoebe And Piper Found Their Half Sister Paige! Paige Was Never An Extra! Phoebe And Paige Are My Fav Out Of All Four Of The Sisters I Think It's Sad That Paige Never Met Prue :(

[@dylanj739]

So if Phoebe died, and Prue lived, that would mean Paige would have the power of premonition or would she still have telekinetic orbing?

[@ShinyAntics]

DylanJ7 that’s a very tricky question, since they never lay down a solid basis of how 4 sisters would share the three original powers, even the comic book messed it all up. Personally, I think it would be more of Paige’s whitelighter sending power, so perhaps closer to empathy or telepathy rather than premonitions. She would probably touch something/someone and sense a feeling or a thought or a memory, kind of like how the new fake Phoebe in the reboot does it.

[@NivM10]

I guess she would have the premonition. Not sure how they would combine her witch side and whitelighter sides power. It could also be separate. She can orb herself and can orb or teleport anything 1 place to another as her advance power being a hybrid and as a charmed one. Maybe she couldnt move those things when she orbed stuff (tele-orbing) but we'll never know.

[@mclaughlin72]

YESSSSS! Phoebe Dies. Yes - the universe is back on track. Phoebe should have died not Prue. Phoebe is the most irritating and usesless of the 'Charmed One's' She cared more about Cole than about staying and helping Prue and Piper defeat Shax.She is also the most selfish, self-absorbed person who dresses like a tramp in nearly every episode after S6.

[@LADejah12]

that is so true i like how you made that. i know how you didi i get because when pheobe went to the future she was burn

[@shelbecovington4161]

oh ok just to let everyone know I love phobe and she did care about her sister she just also love Cole but when Leo told her the news she wanted to save both their live at any chance they got

[@ShinyAntics]

Shelbe Covington what she should've done was orb with Leo to her sisters.. Vanquish Shax and cast a spell to stop all time until they figure everything out

[@grancampeon12]

@ShiningAllure i think it makes sense, if he stayed down there, the Source would trapped him and all the Charmed Ones would be dead

[@thewilduser1]

I miss you guys

[@KalokerinesDiakopes1]

Clever video, but Leo seems coward!

[@timmypop1]

whats it called the episode when phoebe dies because i dont see it in all hell brake loose

[@1001sehrazat]

More than once!

[@douuth]

awesome , but I like Phoebe more than Prue :)

[@msinvincible2000]

If only. Prue was much more interesting and powerful.

[@rebeccakavzer538]

My favorite actress died!!!! NO!!!!!!!! Why did you have to do that?? I love Phoebe, she is my favorite actress, no!!!!

[@M-M007]

If only!!!

[@coolcat98802]

It is better if Prue lived because between her Piper and Paige they would be a stronger Charmed ones and beside Phoebe annoys me because she didn't event show emotion when Prue dies she doesn't care about her sister only about herself.

[@DavidTyler]

It would made sense since The source wanted to kill her

[@hieihakusho5058]

I would love to do karate like Phoebe, I could see what Paige meant

[@Frackeette]

Wow...

[@rtozier2011]

As a person with a little sister, let me say how horrified I am that anyone could even contemplate this, let alone for such a trivial reason as dislike of Phoebe's character/actor. Losing Phoebe instead would have been even more devastating to Piper. How dare anyone fantasise about doing that to her.

[@ShinyAntics]

rtozier2011 Jesus Christ, no one’s fascinating about it. Both actresses were considering leaving.. this is just how it would’ve went down if Phoebe’s character was killed off. Heck, I’m still upset Prue’s character had to be killed off. It’s just a TV show, and this is just an alternative head canon. I even made a video where Piper was the one killed off, and many other videos where all four characters are still alive.

[@anat113]

very funny :-) buy i love phoebesooo....u know.. but no dobet that prue shoud never die!

[@Viktoriya556]

No, shannon doherty gave the movie people an ultimatum and they chose phoebe. Which was stupid, since phoebe isn't as good of an acctress as prue, she's so annoying.. It sucked afterwards. I stopped watching too. Wish Prue would've been alive.

[@Viktoriya556]

Lol she wanted to stay at first, but she didn't wanna work with Phoebe, they were fighting and having arguments all the time. And then they were like hmm noo trying to keep her at the show but they didnt wanna get rid of Phoebe, so she left.

[@MissDinaFBI]

yes!!!!!

[@ShinyAntics]

YES! All that crap to save Cole, and even that didn't work out at the end. She chose Cole over her sisters.

[@antonioluis5974]

Yes.

[@ElPaWri]

черт, мечта всей жизни.....

[@wcs494]

I like Prue better than Phoebe. Thats what the show should have done.

[@MultiJobart]

que mierda este debio ser el capitulo que tenia que slir bravo esa era la muerte todo seria distinto si hubiese muerto pohebe todavia tendriamos chamed para rato pero dejaron la mas sexy pero la del peor poder

[@alex45047]

Yeah, right... At first, Phoebe is dressed in white, than in pink?!?!?! I mean, duh......

[@darkasthesky]

i wish that they had killed Phoebe insted of Prue ...

[@alecmagnusmalec8543]

Fake

[@ShinyAntics]

Duh

[@delinquentazzi]

orrible.... W Phoebe