CHE#45 | Bangla Podcast | Garga Chatterjee | Politics and the Bengali language

No video

CHE#45 | Bangla Podcast | Garga Chatterjee | Politics and the Bengali language

Рет қаралды 10,484

Күн бұрын

Is it inevitable that Bangla as a language will eventually be colonized by the Hindi-Hindu-Hindusthan consensus, which is currently ruling the roost in New Delhi? Garga Chatterjee is at his combative best here as he dissects this possibility and declaims the historical antecedents of the present moment.
Hosted by Srinjoy Ganguly and Soumik Ghosh.
RSS Feed: shorturl.at/btwMQ
Spotify: shorturl.at/dDHZ6
Amazon Music: shorturl.at/oAKXZ
#CHE #thecoffeehouseexperience #GargaChatterjee #Politics #Bangla #bengalilanguage #banglapokkho ‪@banglapokkho‬ #SoumikGhosh #SrinjoyGanguly #banglabhasha #bengali #bengal
---------------------
KZbin: / @thecoffeehouseexperience
Facebook: / coffeehouseexp
RSS Feed: rss.com/podcas...
Spotify: spoti.fi/3P75RSN
Amazon Music: amzn.to/3Z9dsVn

Пікірлер: 141

@anjanpyne4704 5 ай бұрын

এত সরল আর প্রাঞ্জল করে বাংলা ও বাঙালির আসল দুরাবস্থার জায়গাটা বোঝানোর জন্য ধন্যবাদ। প্রত্যেক বাঙালিকে দলগত ও ব্যাক্তিগত পরিসরে জাতির অর্থনৈতিক ও আত্মিক প্রগতির জন্য চেষ্টা করে যেতে হবে। জয় বাংলা ❤

@user-ge2kh1sy5f 5 ай бұрын

গর্গ বাবু এই ব্যাখ্যা একদম সঠিক মূল্যায়ন, রাজনৈতিক সামাজিক এবং অর্থনৈিকভাবে। এই আলোচনাটা বাংলার শিক্ষিত সমাজের বোঝা উচিত।

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

Khub bhalo charcha

@sumitbhattacharyya2058 5 ай бұрын

আমি জন্মথেকেই এই বাংলায় কথা বলি, সংস্কৃততেই উল্লেখ আছে "জননী জন্মভূমিশ্চ স্বর্গদপি গরিয়সী " সেখানে রাষ্ট্রীয় ভাষাবলে কিছুই থাকতে পারে না, কারণ ভাষার আবার অনেক উপভাষা বর্তমান,তবে মনে রাখুন সবাই একই,বাংলা বাংলাই বাঙালি বাঙালিই ❤😊

@sulagnasamanta3541 5 ай бұрын

Tai Kolkata lok ra bangali chay bangal basi asol bangali khujtay asun Burdwan Birbhum Bankura Purulia Murshidabad Malda Dui medinipur Jhargram Ar amra Kolkata ka akdom pochondo kori na sab o par er mal e vorti

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541 apni koren na seta apnar problem amra chai amra chayi jela ar bangali ra kolkata te looby hok

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541 Kolkata ke neejer moton koraar jonno, aapna ra kichu Koren o nee.

@gauravdey4163 4 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541 opar epar abar akhando bharot eta abar ki

@sulagnasamanta3541 4 ай бұрын

@@gauravdey4163 opar er khader khaoa mal ra bujbay na Oder jala amra vitay mati charay asay chi Tora o tai kar Ata amra buji

@SuVo1221 5 ай бұрын

ভালো ভাবে ব্যাখ্যা করেছেন ।।

@swarnadipchatterjee 5 ай бұрын

চমৎকার। জয় বাংলা!

@jhantudutta7475 5 ай бұрын

Eita bangla desh noy.Ei kotha ta bangla desher slogan.tmc ;ar ei faltu lok gulo import koreche.

@sulagnasamanta3541 5 ай бұрын

Ki jala ata India Bangladesh na

@sg04f 5 ай бұрын

জয় বাংলা!!! @@sulagnasamanta3541

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541 joy bangla najrul er kobita te ache are bhai bharot er rastra pari bole che

@kaustavchakraborty1406 5 ай бұрын

অনেকদিন পর কফি হাউসের এপিসোড পেয়ে ভাল লাগল। সাংবাদিক সুমন চ্যাটার্জি র সাথে একটা podcast করার অনূর্ধ্ব রইলো।

@blueman710 5 ай бұрын

ei video ta ami chiro jibon rekhe debo

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Don't absorb and retain negativity. Bengalees are known for that and is the reason they never grow. They look for miracles as the wonders from Bengal has stopped coming. So, first come first, egolessness, followed by work hard, cooperation, inculcating virtues & knowledge, developing perception, practising celibacy (the only culture of Human being as setbacks like Sandeshkhali pop up anytime), and service to mankind.

@blueman710 5 ай бұрын

@@bkashim apnar somossa ki? ke apni je apnar kotha sunte hobe?

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

@@blueman710 Very clear. Wisdom & common sense if not inherited in birth, has to be cultivated from past experience. Please remember, Calcutta was known as one of the "Most Modern & Developed City" and "City of Palaces" when British ruled & left. This city was hawkeyed by Jinnah, who thought Bangalees were low breed. Nehru on the other hand, did not want to include whole of Bengal, so was least interested. It was Shyama da, due to his efforts & patriotism, separated the Hindu Bengal, and included in India. Bangalees, did not honour him as a Creator of Hindu Bengal, hence by nature they are ungrateful- this is first. Secondly, Jinnah knew very well the unaware nature of Bengalis and unsupported & hanging existence, ordered "Direct Action Day" when Soharawardy was ruling Bangal. The riots were disastorous for Hindu Bangalis, and perhaps would have gone extinct, if an army of Sikhs, Biharis and Gorkhas had not come to their rescue- so this visual does not mention this. Then the Noakhali and partition killings in 1947. The Bangali muslims chose Punjabi muslims as their Sahebs or masters after the britishers, thus giving liscence to sqeeze them economically, deprive them of higher position, and rape their ladies. Genocide in 1971 is the stamp of evil acts of Pakistanis. Again Indian army came to their rescue, which comprised of Sikhs, Gorkhas and those from Hindu- Hindu belt. Due to devastating genocide, Bangalees came to India as refugees for the second time. West Bengal bore the brunt, but rest of India also took this load, although they were settled in outskirts, low habitat areas and even in jungles, but at least given a place to live in. After so many years, when compared with Punjabis & Sindhis, I find a huge difference in standard of living. Sindhis don't even have a state of their own in India, which please note. In case a Punjabi's business fails or has gone bankrupt in Hindi India, he says, would go back to his state, where "Mother Punjab" will at least feed them. Bangalees are low in self-esteem in this regard. Bengal were the ones in real sense, who opposed the dynastical rule, due to their independent nature, but they could not sustain it due to dwindling economical resources. Communism & Naxalism, pushed away the those who put Industries and gave jobs. Naxalism in particular, destroyed the indegenous Business class (I didn't knew this-so thanks for the info), which speaks of their non-visionary and foolish nature. Still there is no "Son of Soil", which can address the poverty & joblessness in Bengal. On the other hand, those from Hindi belt, come outside to work and develop, which speaks of their vision, wisdom, common sense and sef-esteem, rather than begging as Bangalis. Ask you hero, who has posted this vedeo, to make another vedeo, on the truth which I have written,ay be visualised. Save that, which can inspire a change in you.

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

@@bkashim yes up bihar are very much growing

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

Up bihar is growing in number but not in quality. Why do they leave own states to come to bengal? Is there anything in up bihar?

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

If meros gujjus are that hard working then their own states would be golden. In that case they would not leave their own states to come all the way to bengal to run grocery shop or cloth shop.

@banglaobangalii 5 ай бұрын

জয় বাংলা ❤

@sulagnasamanta3541 5 ай бұрын

Vai ata Bangladesh er slogan

@banglaobangalii 5 ай бұрын

বাংলা ভাষাটা বাংলাদেশের জাতীয় ভাষা। বাংলায় কথা বলিস না তাহলে।

@rajivreview7201 5 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541arey gadhi... Jai bangla protyek bangalir slogan..... Jodi bangali tobey jai bangla e bolte hobey..... Aar Jodi tumi hindi bashi tobey jai bihar bolo😅.... Jai bangla

@rajivreview7201 5 ай бұрын

@@sulagnasamanta3541arey gadhi... Jai bangla protyek bangalir slogan..... Jodi bangali tobey jai bangla e bolte hobey..... Aar Jodi tumi hindi bashi tobey jai bihar bolo😅.... Jai bangla

@sulagnasamanta3541 5 ай бұрын

@@banglaobangalii ami bolbo amar kaj e joy bangla ki hm Monay hochay 75 bochor e sabai bangla bhasa vulay gachay Akhon Bolo karok koi prokar Samas dhorbo Amra bangla vasa samman kori Amar matri vasha Sata niya Ora amra kori na

@masudalam4901 5 ай бұрын

Malda theke garga da jindabad 🐯joy bangla ❤❤❤

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Slowly you may insert the use of Urdu

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

Days are not very far when Urdu will be removed.

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

@@user-um7wp4pz3c wish you all the best. But to make it a time bound execution, Bengali Hindus needs to be educated first, instill confidence, imbibe knowledge of our origins, and tell them why language of soul & soil is the only way for growth, survival and retaining lost glorious culture.

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

You are using too much words only emotionally. Do you think meros and gujjus have come to bengal in such large number because their own states are highly developed? They are thronging here because their own states are devastated, there is nothing. They come here in search of livelihood. And coming here they run grocery shop or cloth shop or fruit stall. But who requires these services?

@sreyanshuchaterjee3962 Ай бұрын

@@user-um7wp4pz3c This is a categorical flaw in your assumption. The land of Bengal which includes illegal region that terms itself Bangladesh, was the most fertile region of "south asia" as the muricans term it. The ancient economical system was agriculture based. There were majestic trading/shipping hubs in this region. Such records have been supressed for reasons best known to British and Nawabs, who had their divine right to rule over this land. We need to go back to when Bangla even became a language, and we see ourselves in an era where Islamic empire of Bengal was at its peak and the rulers often took loans from rajasthan-sindhi origin business houses, Their existence over here predates Bangla. Now, coming to the part , why are they are in huge numbers and could accumulate such business network here? Well its a complex topic, but we can start with the trading hubs estbalished during british rule. The biggest beneficiary were local bengali landlords, muslim small rulers and taluk managers. The Sindhi-Gujju-Maru had only one way to progress here, trade and they traded as a tightly knit group. Still now, they maintain that. Bengalis have been ideological, squabbing lot. Bengali hindus have never understood the fact that Bangladesh terms Bangla as its own as Bangla as we know as a language developed during Islamic rule of the region. Pre-Islamic Bengal didnt speak Bengali as we know it,.

@ayushmondal8514 5 ай бұрын

JOY BANGLA ❤ JOY BANGALI

@swapanhore2476 Ай бұрын

গর্গবাবু জিন্দাবাদ। বাংলাপক্ষ জিন্দাবাদ। বাংলাপক্ষের সংগঠনের সকল সদস্যদের জন্য আমি গর্বিত, ও এই বিষয়ে বলবো বাঙ্গালীদের জন্য সুরক্ষার জন্য বাংলাপক্ষের হয়ে জীবন বলিদান দেওয়ার সময় এসেছে। জয় বাংলা।

@sg04f 5 ай бұрын

1:04:37 গর্গ দা এখানে কি বলতে গেছিলেন "আমার একবার মনে আছে মোদী..." বলে?

@mousumibiswas3021 4 ай бұрын

এর থেকে বাঁচার কি আর কোন উপায় আছে ? বাঙলার হারানো জমিকে বাঙলার সঙ্গে যুক্ত করা বা বাঙলাতে বাঙলা ভাষাকে প্রাধান্য দেওয়া । এটা করতে পারতো জ্যোতি বসু। কিন্তু উনি তো কিছুই করেন নি।

@mitadas8339 2 ай бұрын

আমাদের পরবর্তী প্রো জন্মের জন্য ভয় হয় কি হবে ওদের সজাগ হওয়ার দরকার জয়বাংলা।

@anjanpyne4704 5 ай бұрын

1:14:03 ভজহরি মাহাতোর লেখা টুসু গান "শুন বিহারী ভাই তুরা রাখতে লারবি ডাং দেখাই"। kzbin.info/www/bejne/anObfIOGfbWirK8si=3unJJ9Cg3CGpmoVQ

@aritrabhattacharyya8797 4 ай бұрын

Bengal is a nation, India is a civilisation. Bharatavarsha literally means Bharata continent.

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Still exists, in case a bengalee wants a job in kolkata, he needs to oil a marwari...

@totanghorai7747 12 күн бұрын

বাংলা ভাষার শব্দ ভান্ডার এত খারাপ ও নয় যে এত বিদেশি শব্দ ব্যবহার করতে হবে। বাংলা পৃথিবীর মিষ্টতম ভাষা এটা মনে রেখে বাংলা ভাষার অনুষ্ঠান করতে অনুরোধ

@rajivreview7201 5 ай бұрын

Bangla abong bangali ke shudu amader garga da bachatey parbey..... Jai bangla

@baghazukhov152 Ай бұрын

জয় বাংলা । জয় বাংলা । জয় বাংলা ।

@BadAss_691 5 ай бұрын

সংবিধানের ৩৫১ নম্বর অনুচ্ছেদের বিরুদ্ধে লড়তে হবে।

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Jyoti Basu claimed that he was approached by BJP, which later on declined by Lal Krishna Adwani, that, Jyoti Basu is mentally disturbed.

@tonmoysarkar7814 28 күн бұрын

47 এ দেশ ভাগ কিসের ভিত্তিতে হয়েছে !!

@kshetranathdey1552 2 ай бұрын

Promisory note-এর মধ্যে যতগুলি ভাষা আছে,সেগুলি সব ই রাষ্ট্র ভাষা।ইংরেজি ও হিন্দি যোগাযোগ রক্ষাকারী ভাষা মাত্র।

@vinayaklohani9632 Ай бұрын

Dhulekar wa Maharashtrian Brahmin from Dhule, a district in northern Maharashtra and not as he says was from UP.

@praloybratarakshit8685 4 ай бұрын

United provinces of oudh and agra

@parthapratimdeb7637 Ай бұрын

We need 86 percent reservation like other states

@ashoksengupta8173 Ай бұрын

গর্গ চট্টোপাধ্যায় তোমাদের origin কোথা থেকে?? উপাধ্যায় কোন রাজ্যের ?? তোমরা এদের বংশধর। দেশবিভাগের সময় বাংলাকে বিভাজনের জন্য কে দায়ী??

@tonmoysarkar7814 28 күн бұрын

উনাকে বলতে বলুন 47 এ দেশ ভাগ কিসের ভিত্তিতে হয়েছিল ?

@uttammaitra9919 Ай бұрын

Confusing. VICE-VERSA.

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Muslims from west, turks and mughals and the british thought people of bengal are low breed, and hence they distanced themselves making relationships and never took them in Army

@nillchowdhury806 5 ай бұрын

Oi jonnoi to swadeshi movemente bangalir lath kheye calcutta theke delhite rajdhani niye geche. Ar kapurush muslimder to bash diye to shyama prasad west bengalke ber kore niye ashe Pakistan theke.

@user-bz7nl7et8e Ай бұрын

Ader kotha sune bangali aj dan khoiratite

@indranilbari4477 Ай бұрын

Sobjaigai GUJRATI cholbe na!!!

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

These people declare that they support establishment of bengali language in every field of work but they do not do anything for the improvement of the language. If the language is incapable for work in different fields of activities like engineering and medicine then people will be disenchanted with the language and they will join some other linguistic groups. And bengali language and nation will be lost. So first of all it is required to improve the language.

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

And bengalis will only write poetry recite poetry join in drama and sing song but will not join production and distribution, though they consume everything.

@nityagopalnanda2006 Ай бұрын

ইংরেজী বলা কেন ???

@drrmdebnath8356 3 ай бұрын

These chattor jis tortured common Hindus,,they forced them to be converted..ruled bengal during british..patitioned India..they ruled west bengal for last 77 years upto now..why then this is the situation..explain..harharmahadev

@baghazukhov152 Ай бұрын

chop sala behari coolie

@adarshakar009 5 ай бұрын

Garga da kon college er professor? R educational qualification ki?

@BadAss_691 5 ай бұрын

Professor of ISI , Kolkata PhD -Harvard , Post Doc-MIT, MBBS-Medical College Kolkata

@adarshakar009 4 ай бұрын

@@BadAss_691 shotti nki? Shune toa bengali superstar ankush er aieee top kora mone pore galo...

@BadAss_691 4 ай бұрын

@@adarshakar009 O sat purush poreo Garga Da r nokher joggo hote parbe na.

@joybanik2581 28 күн бұрын

Gargar chatterjee profile ta dekhe ashte...tahole r kotha bolte na

@user-um7wp4pz3c 5 ай бұрын

But you people are not doing anything for development of the bengali language.

@ashishkushwaha2262 4 ай бұрын

Dada aami non bengali aamder ki hobe....

@white_skinned_bitch 2 ай бұрын

State chhere chole ja

@ashishkushwaha2262 2 ай бұрын

Jabo na....100 year piriye giyechhe aikhane ...

@apexengineering6607 2 ай бұрын

Kichui habe na, tabe bangalike dominate kora cholbe na.

@death-jy1ph Ай бұрын

@@ashishkushwaha2262 apni bangla bojhen jokhn durgapuja koren nijeke bangali bolen jokhn takhn apni bangali. Eta podobir bepr noy.

@ashishkushwaha2262 Ай бұрын

Asansol te footh path dokhol achhe..... 25 lak 30 lakh takar dokn kine ..vender Der triple Dhaka pode giye chhe.... dokan cholchhe na bikri kore palate hochhe....

@krishna1525 4 ай бұрын

Garga is the B team of tmc..

@user-ry8ew2ee6r 5 ай бұрын

৬:০০ রেফারেন্স কই , কখন আমিতজি এরম বললেন?? কবে?? আর অমিত সাহা বাঙালিদের নয়, অবৈধ ভাবে ভারতে ঘাঁটি গেড়ে থাকা বাংলাদেশের নাগরিকদের বলেছিলেন!

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

Uni ki janen kato bangla deshi tale shob uttar bharater lok pakistan er

@user-ry8ew2ee6r 5 ай бұрын

@@gauravdey4163 আমার প্রশ্নের উত্তর পেলাম না....

@apexengineering6607 2 ай бұрын

Bangladesh theke asa jodi bangali Hindu Bangali hai, amra tader pokkhe, karon deshbhager jonno Tara aste baddho hoeche.

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Hindi is the national language. In case there is any problem anywhere in India, it's this language connection from where one gets support. For Bengalis, it is well established, that refuge seeking Bengalis came at least twice when they were in deep trouble. Bengalis, should never compare with south, as south had the wisdom and common sense long way back, how to protect their self esteem and language. Bengalis don't know how to grow, and hence they look towards others for their survival, especially to economically strong Hindi speaking people.

@DipakBose-bq1vv 5 ай бұрын

Hindi is not the national language but only one of the official language along with English.

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

@@DipakBose-bq1vv however you place it, according to yours suitability. But keep in mind it will be difficult to secure one's mother tongue, if it is not economically good & strong. Further it should be well entrenched with strategy and good workforce. Bangla language got a shake in Bangladesh 🇧🇩, when West Pakistanis sensed their dominance both economically and militarily. Bangladesh somehow managed to secure their language after the worst genocide in the history of mankind, but giving unaccountable lives and self-respect, and with the help of Indian army. French could secure their language from the English, after fighting tooth and nail. South Indians secure their language, as they stood strong on their ground, from the North Indians spread.

@gauravdey4163 5 ай бұрын

@@bkashim hindi chapate ele hindi chotke debo pindi

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Dada, maach-bhaat cholbe naa.

@nillchowdhury806 5 ай бұрын

Suorer mangsho cholbe.

@hiransarkar1236 3 ай бұрын

Hmm, only cow urine and dung cholbe .Apparently that also helps to cure diseases :)

@bkashim 3 ай бұрын

@@hiransarkar1236 hopefully this revert does not come out of satire (byango). For info, the people who respect cow, and base their life on it, are well focused and are positive. You cannot stay focused for a long time, based on nonveg eating, and that's what happening in West Bengal or Bengali community as whole. Bengalis are loosing everywhere.

@death-jy1ph Ай бұрын

@@bkashim jat rajput veg eaters were working in british army, search recent honour killing, castism, female foeticide data, they are on top.

@bkashim Ай бұрын

@@death-jy1ph whatever, but they remained secure and under armour of wisdom & purity. Quite Intelligently, they have written the sacred books and winning war against evils in their favour. Both Krishna & Ram were born in their occupied lands, where all from the world come to visit. In 1947, India became independent, with a starc difference, while rest of India was celebrating, Bengalis, the Maach-bhaat wallas, were cut down to peices. So Bengalis, are more sacrificial goats than anything else. The Eastern part of maach-bhaat wallas, chose Punjabi Muslims to be their Masters after the British left, rather than choosing independence, earned from highest numbers of sacrifices. Even after being independent for 75 years, it lags behind rest of India by at least 30 years, although it started on very high note, when British left. The Rich Bengal is now known as poor Bengal. After giving countless freedom fighters sacrificing lives and initiating modern strategy of freedom which was conclusive, they are now taunted as Bangladeshis for speaking Bengali!!!. The Rajputs and Jats, killed female foeticide, only to save them from Muslim invaders, if they loose. East Bengalis could not protect their ladies from Punjabi Muslims, shame!!!

@udayshankarsen5343 5 ай бұрын

Gargar baktobbye aami ekmot noi ..accha ei vodrolok ti ke? Ei vodroloker prokrito shikkhay aamar sandeho aache .

@parthapratimdas597 5 ай бұрын

Btw tor joggota ki?

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

Agreed. Seems to further divide Bengal.

@studyneet-cu7qb 5 ай бұрын

mbbs from

@studyneet-cu7qb 5 ай бұрын

mbbs from medical college kolkata. wbjee rank 2 . phd from havard .post doc mit .

@bkashim 5 ай бұрын

@@studyneet-cu7qb a great profession, as God himself, the saviour of mankind, peace & Happiness, often quotes doctors as his refection in this age of hell, in case he is true. He could have saved few lives, but he took the footpath of awakening Bengal, which is so much required. If it is in right earnest, then he must have noticed and picked the qualities & virtues of others, instead of criticising them. Why the hell on earth, the people of most fertile land in earth, has most blunt headed people, must be churned. Greater Bengal was least attacked by muslim invaders, but conversion to Muslim religion has been most. Bengal was the cradle of English empire, who exploited and squeezed them the most. Bengal has been receiving the Highest quality of education from the English but most ignorant. In case of Muslim dominated riots, its these hindi speaking, Hindu people come to their rescue which he should not forget. So first, serve egolessly to educate, develop common sense & wisdom in Bengalees without hatred, then the objective of divinity and ruling their own shall be realised.