Best Commanders to Swap [pick these commanders FIRST] Rise of Kingdoms Tier List

[@Chisgule]

IMPORTANT: some of the methods to save tickets were PATCHED OUT, please be careful of the ACTUAL TICKET COST when the event shows up! You could hear my skepticism about the 1111 conversion cost... please be sure to check the actual cost in game before using tickets!! KEEP IN MIND: Ragnar Prime is from an event but we don't know how to get more of him at this time. Liu Che is reliably found in the wheel. This is a part of the reason Ragnar Prime is #2 on the list. ALSO - you could argue that Hera is a better swap than lapulapu for city defense, depending if you care more about swarm or rally.

[@Champions-gnt]

@@Chisgule ok

[@labroskii1685]

Liu che is also in the sovereign keys, same with gorgo

[@Death_kxng]

At 26:30 about the tickets and tricks Lilith have already changed and fixed the situation i think. It was a bug if am correct.

[@Noobghost604]

can you make a video going in depth about what is the best way to spend your gems/tickets when this events comes out? I am a f2p so I will need a video. Pls and thank you

[@TheSanctume]

Ragnar Prime is summon-able in Legendary Tavern now. Re: Wallace is single target. IF next Inf is aoe-Smite, Wallace is in the chopping block. Going to wait what the next MGE cav commander will be that comes out with Arthur

[@xMoonMoonMoon]

I’m just happy for the one guy who accidentally maxed Leonidas instead of Beli Prime. This event is for him

[@Mila-gx1dg]

😂😂 100%

[@cmlcml415]

Lmao he can finally get rid of the "decent infantry commander" 😂

[@ibrahimguel90]

Huo again being disrespected. He's in the best cavalry march in the game, Huo/Arthur. Also Huo won't be gone anytime soon, he'll at least be here for 1 and a half year, because he's better than Nevsky. In addition I think Wallace is overrated and overhyped. People don't realise that he's basically Beli prime but just with smite dmg, and when the next inf comes out in 3-4 months he'll be replaced and every inf main will cry because he didn't last very long.

[@KND.7482]

Haha You are a clown You are crazy 😂😂😂

[@ibrahimguel90]

@KND.7482 nope I'm not. Only reason Wallace was considered good in the first place is because he's smite dmg. He's the only other smite full open field commander with Liu Che. But most likely next inf cycle will be smite again, benching him because people are going to run Ragnar/Scipio and Liu/new inf

[@Merkz_66]

@@KND.7482​​⁠why are you insulting someone for having an opinion? Plus he’s not wrong. Omniarch done early testing and based on that Huo/Arthur is now the best open field march in the game

[@Jefestephens]

@@KND.7482what a goofball. Who is a better primary than Huo?? People just hate single target. Lol there is no better march than Huo Joan in ruins. It will be huo Arthur or Arthur/? When we get the other commander for combo.

[@kchris5326]

@@Merkz_66probably because he never said it was an opinion. He stated it as fact. Also, Omniarch did testing for 1v1 on a simulator that may or may not be accurate. I still think Joan/Arthur will be better in actual field fighting where 1v1 doesn’t happen ofter.

[@kitykityliklik5599]

According to Mr. siege, the best single range march is Gajah/Cordoba.

[@Johnnyboy893]

Agreed. But chis point is siege isn’t his top priority so if you are going to invest in them, invest in the newest. They may not be the best single march right now but may be the building blocks for the next gen of seige

[@NYmikeman]

Mr Seige says best march is Gaja / Cordoba

[@kitykityliklik5599]

@@NYmikeman that’s what I meant haha

[@Mila-gx1dg]

Ngl some range marches are super appealing. Those reports are insane! Altar reports especially blew my mind

[@99Coupe]

I have expertise gajah/cordoba 0 regrets

[@nehcd711]

If you buy writer of history bundles, I think the best value is 5111 swap to expertise which will cost 36 tickets (15 USD) and save you from spending an additional 35 USD. It will cost you 50 gold heads if you have a 1111 commander which equates to 25 USD in writer of history bundles. Total of 10 USD savings.

[@Champions-gnt]

Yes thank you I was hoping you'll make a video about this😊

[@tenbear5]

Definitely making a siege march but with Arthur on the horizon it’s a no brainer

[@nicoalvarez4357]

In my situation, I run scipi/lc and zl/hermann, huo is now mi top priority with Arthur, plus I have set and armaments, and 1400 free heads

[@hizanga]

I dont think skill damage going anywhere. The developers are just introducing different systems to create choices. They proved this with ragnar prime. The next archer may be healing. But I bet you they put more meta skill damage archers in game. And it's a great idea. Rather then just continually going power creep, the developers are just giving us options to use.

[@hizanga]

Combo doesn't really pop off until you get your gear to level 5. Butterfly effect will be crazy with that. Skill damage with huo will probably be better until then.

[@FroobyPebbles]

My only issue with archers, is we all thought infantry was full smite and then we got Ragnar Prime. Is he a random one off? Or will infantry be both smite and/or skill in the future. We might see the same for archers with skill and healing/true damage

[@endermantheend7625]

This is the vid I was waiting for 🎉

[@pwon]

Great video. Crazy to see how the recent commander releases and their new mechanisms completely shifted the dynamics - just a year ago, i wouldve never guessed zhuge's future would be in question so soon. Also, surprised to see ragnar prime prioritized over philip - may just have to reconsider my choices. One final note - i dont think there's any special synergy between sargon and combo. Sargon deals direct dmg per basic atk for 5s, which can occur at most once per turn. Reading between the lines, it just seems like combo attack is an extension of basic attack that can stack - i dont even think it generates rage or affect instant proc skills dependent on dealing basic atk. I think this misconception comes from the obscure wording of liu che's previous expertise description.

[@joru8056]

Was literally thinking about it just now 😅thx

[@RickBjork]

You're a sicko w/ that echelon set. Well done Chisgule!!!

[@cristianflores2981]

29:06 yeah it’s not adding up at all cuz it completely contradicts what it says in the dev q&a mails

[@Mr.Smiles606]

As a low spender would it make sense to swap a max YSG for ZL since I only plan to have one archer march? (my gold key commanders are all 5511-5551 range)

[@GarfieldTuesday]

I'm in the same situation I hope some expert answers😅

[@ken_chiro_6913]

same question since I only have YSg expertised and Some gold key at 5551

[@biktorbiktor7824]

(me too) i only have ysg expertised (and alex)... but i have 5551 sala/el cid that i can use to swap other comms.. and get arthur maxed and liu che 5551

[@nuckleupbtch]

YSG is old I say it’s okay honestly

[@BCamacho8]

ZL is the better overall commander by a mile, BUT YSG comes into play specifically when you play an artifact KvK and pair Huo with YSG. If you're aiming for an Archer march, though, I would aim for ZL over YSG. *edit* this is a very generic response and honestly depending on your account, I would advise against swapping into an Archer commander if you don't already have a footprint in Archer Commanders. You may benefit from have a meta infantry and meta Cav march if you already have the gear for those troop types. Just depends on what armor you have made already for each march type.

[@tangoblast2497]

U think its still best to swap gold key commanders even if you dont hsve enough to re max them instantly? Or do something like ramsees or harald

[@Themellow-i2i]

Absolutely

[@Mila-gx1dg]

Thank u for this. I started thinking about kvks where u could use other comms skills and started 2nd guessing everything 😂

[@strat3g1cal41]

Also I would not swap into anything siege until we have someone that has tested it and see how it works or if you have the resources to test it for others to determine the meta

[@realjohnlove]

17:41 hypothetically, the next Archer might be a poison-stack Mighty Heal

[@kamran202035]

HI Chisgule, Why you suggest we should keep YSG? I want to swap him for HermanP (or maybe Philip) to pair him with Zhug, meta commanders aside I only have Martel and YSG expertised and will swap Martel for Arthur. What do you think?

[@iamAdrian_Gaming]

We swapping Chisgule 💯💯

[@andrewwong2377]

Gold key Ragnar with relics is extremely good for rallying cities with attlia, just put it out there.

[@aliwahab1982]

Is ysg a safe swap for arthur ? And who is the best commander to swap to for zl parir philip , shajar or herman ? Any help or ideas would be useful.

[@Alcibiades92]

Philip is the best placeholder for any kind of march. for some marches, he is even ultra good, and if you are a whale, a must.

[@pmarshall1988]

As of right now who is the best garrison pairing for Gorgo and when are new garrison commanders expected.

[@AzzamAbuJbara]

20:32 thank you, you are first content creator used logic not emotion to judge shajar and herman🔥

[@dungletien6240]

hello I play 1 archer march and have zhuge + yi, should I swap yi with herman or shajar?

[@AzzamAbuJbara]

@ do you mean ysg?

[@AzzamAbuJbara]

Any way if you mean ysg , I would swap out another commander but if you don’t have another choice yea replace him with shajar

[@Manuel-oj5xc]

So don’t trade ysg for Arthur? I don’t open field with him since I don’t have a pair and the only march I’m running first season of soc is scipi/lc

[@Mr_Zaib087]

I don't have any spare expertise attained commander. I have El cid 5531 and cao cao,5541 what should I swap for Arthur?

[@realjohnlove]

Cao has use, El Cid is gonna be my swapper

[@Vermonster19]

Archers have the best rally, best garrison, and dominating openfield aoe. "wow, RIP archers"... why... what part about Choe/Dido and Ashuribanipals being everywhere makes anybody think archers are lagging behind?

[@philip9707]

In the field they are really underperforming

[@Vermonster19]

@@xMoonMoonMoon Except for rallies for the past several years? Oh and Choe is a top garrison? Like what are you even talking about. Top kingdoms and top players all have Hermann as a must have commander still. Arthur reviving cav from the brink and archer will get more true damage probably super pushed on their rotation. Oh and archer who already had the best civ in the game just got a new civ too. Crazy to be pretending archers don't just sit on top of the rally meta

[@Vermonster19]

@@xMoonMoonMoon Nah you're just clueless and probably never rallies or garrisoned in your life. Before Ashur it was Henry and before Henry it was Nebu. Archers have always run the rally meta and you clearly have multiple viable field marches you apparently are just bad because all the top players in the game have been raving about how good Ashur/Phillip or Phillip/Ashur is. Archers get 35% health from Phillip the best stats of any troop type. You just like to complain and apparently are very bad at the game to be an archer main and not realize most archer mains are running 3 good field marches without issues.

[@Vermonster19]

@@xMoonMoonMoon Responded to nothing I said, and cool so I probably have more KP than you and you have to name-drop a kingdom instead of responding to actual meta history. Archers have the only MGE commander that is seeing meta field use and you're complaining about having one meta march ignoring the fact that Ashur is all over the field. Respond to the points instead of attempting to name drop.

[@realjohnlove]

Ppl swarming them

[@Defense89]

thx for video im so hype about arthur and butterfly!!!! For siege i'd say swap for cordoba as he is always in the top pairing possible, and best one is gajah cordoba.

[@Batmandle]

13:12 Gonzalo is top tier in engineering why wouldn't you take him

[@JeffMsgc]

Some prefer dancing(hit and run) than standing(towering), and some do both

[@denycandrayt8109]

Thanks very much sir to made this video

[@jlambert443]

I will swap CC and Ysg for Arthur and Phillip. I will use my gold heads to finish huo instead.

[@Zungentruppen]

It should go live at reset tonight

[@soccernedim]

GOAT! needed this!!

[@Tibi2k22]

Hello.I have a question:If u swap the commanders for example Frederick(5-5-5-1) to Arthur(1-1-1-1) after u swap it will remained permanent after the event is done?

[@GOG21407]

Can a free to play swap for Arthur? Commander swap event doesn’t have a timer like most event.

[@ghost-4201]

What's the best garrison pair at the moment?

[@raeesshah257]

Could anyone please guide me if I should replace my Scipio Prime with Ranger prime to pair with Lui Che is it worth it, like is Scipio and Lui che still the best infantry march despite the introduction of ranger p?

[@Daurgothoth1]

Ragnar P and Scipio Liu Che and wallace are the best infantry marches

[@davidw.5185]

I'm adding a full experticed third engineering march. I can also run 2-3 field marches for the murderball, but if you want to mix things up and you can pour in the investment, Seige is very fun.

[@kchris5326]

I am getting Gajah and Arthur. Upgrade cav march and add a second siege march

[@MrHukd]

Swapping to john is a very bad idea. Myself and every other siege player that have invested in him will tell you gonzo is miles better. John just doesnt slap like we expected him to

[@MrSiegeOfficial]

It’s funny seeing the other ranged commanders like Babur in on to swap lol, he absolutely slaps, anyone with him maxed will know that though

[@NewYorkCardCollectors]

After testing, I guess Huo/Arthur is the best cav march. I currently run Liu Che/Alex, Guan Scipio, Zhuge/Herman, and Nevsky/Joan. Do I swap FOR Arthur and huo, or Arthur and Ragnar? Or another d different mix?

[@mountainstudionocopyrightm1901]

I have Huo, WW, Liu, the new Ragna, Scipio Prime,. Liu and Scipio's skills are maxed, but if I max Ragna and WW, I will have two strong infantry marches, or I can max Huo and Arthur. What should I do? Ragna, huo, Arthur, ww is 1111

[@mountainstudionocopyrightm1901]

Help me

[@nicdiamond9989]

Depends on your equipment. I’d say HUO and Arthur are one of the best if not the best march in the game rn. Without a doubt you should be swapping for Arthur

[@ПитрХван]

Hi, I currently have Nevsky, Zhuge/German Prime, Liu Che can you tell me what four commanders to pump to them?

[@SpanioloJony]

Thank you for this video. Perfect Timing, however with the not Swap i lost my plan. Need your support. I am main inv. Working now on cav Equipment. Have following Commander pairing: 1. Liu Che and Alex (both expert) 2. Nevski (expert) and Joan 5515 3. Zughe (expert) and Hermann 5511. 4. Scipio (5511) and Mehmet (5511). What would you recommend me? I have other Commander to swap with max 5521. Arthur is priority for me but dont know if only swap to 5521 or e.g. with Joan or Nevski as trade to nearly expert him, depending who fits better in pairing. Second swap could be first siege commander. Thanks upfront.

[@docholmes1172]

I swapped for Liu/Philip. In the middle of a kvk rn and the march is slapping. Even with mostly epic gear and pretty crappy armaments

[@korion1569]

I think i would change the new sieges for Gajah And Gonzalo if you want the best of the best, they give you the most balance and great ressults, but if you like more the new commanders it's okay, they're great too, i personally preffer John and Stephen cause i love John's design

[@extr3m0]

1 starred commander is 1000, 4 starred is 1111, stars arent reducing the cost, unlocking this last 3 skill through them does

[@Yaradan]

Perfect timing

[@calber59]

I have max prime scip, Che, Ragnar, Arthur, Joan, Nevsky. What would be the best other swap? I was between Wallace, Philip, and huo. Can Phillip run with Arthur and be best for his versatility

[@kevinramos5188]

The mge commander will have combo too I just wish these can last and wait for other commanders

[@SystemcIify]

Rangnar Prime paired with what commander? and First or secound commander?

[@MJVP6983]

I gambled on Arthur + Phillip. I think they rrally have good synergy with the rage reduction and damage increase buffs. If it doesnt work I can always put Arthur behind Nevsky and Phillip behind LC. Gave up my YSG since I only had him at 5525 and I never got to expertise him. 😂

[@eess9803]

Are the extra heads from the gold key commanders are going to be swap as well

[@christophkeller1232]

Why Not swap Guan? If i run ragnar p with Scipio, i dont need him

[@jira368]

Hey im f2p Player. My best march actually is liu with alex. Should i swap alex with ww? I dont know

[@mackchelios]

Why is Mulan put in the cannot swap? She is a gold key commander. After looking at it she can be swapped as per the event that came out.

[@dr_sami21]

Saladin is one of the only commanders which have an insane healing reduction and everyone disrespect him... I can't understand that. 😢

[@NSBeverything]

Arthur or Ragnar prime who should be swapped if only one is possible?

[@kraftbloop3664]

Currently have Zl/boudica P. Should I swap for hermann P? Looking at Ragnar P and Arthur for swaps

[@TheRevoltant]

No Philippe 2 boudica is better than zl herman

[@Dude-ct1wo]

DO NOT LET BRO COOK 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[@Bon_Clay_Edits]

Who is better, Heracles or Lapu Lapu?

[@JohnSmith-nm6dc]

hi can you do the video about new archer commander

[@shizzaren6826]

I'm in a pretty new kd, only like 50d old. Since we know we get 2 swaps after KVK 2 for 2 SoC commanders, I was wondering, for commander swap, swap CC (since i get him from daily bundles and such till CM come, already 5235) for a meta commander at end of season 2, invest in YSG get him exp, but probably not swap him. That means I can swap a 2nd commander, you reckon I should use gh to go as far as I can on CM? Thut? Or possibly exp ysg then exp alex but swap YSG+CC and keep alex for liu che? Or something entirely else? This is from spender perspective.

[@Devils_Lasagna]

When i only have Alex as an inf commander, should i go for Liu Che or Ragnar?

[@rianpriambodo9548]

Liuche

[@Chisgule]

Hmm hard to say. Both amazing. If you’re going to spend gems on wheel, you could swap to ragnar prime and spin for liu

[@Bratexxxx]

Why not swap out YSG,if I already have 1 meta archer march,and I am not planning on investing in Archers?

[@qiaoerye]

so, how does it work? the levels and skills will all be swapped? like a maxed/expertised Khan swap with Arthur, then Arthur will be maxed/expertised?

[@TJMiton]

lol, mate you can definitely swap out guan.

[@nicdiamond9989]

Wait so should we be using wedge for Nevsky Arthur

[@redbluegreen1062]

Ya of course nevsky is skill damage commander

[@nicdiamond9989]

@ what about this combo attack ? Is it not for cavalry ?

[@redbluegreen1062]

@@nicdiamond9989 the combo is only for when he is primary

[@WillofD18]

no way you really debated the current best archer march isnt worth a swap lol

[@SultanSultan-jk1uh]

What means cannot be swapped? It means they are really good ?

[@nikolaperunovic4744]

can we save tickets for some another time when swaps comes again ?

[@Chisgule]

No, to my knowledge it will never return

[@라스베가스러키맘]

"advanced" players - those who spent 6 figures on the game

[@MomentofSilenceBand]

Best video in channel history!

[@ChristofferChrintz]

I have liu che and Alex expertised. Should i go for Scipio Prime or Ragna? - i have heard that scipi liu che is really good...

[@Chisgule]

Ragnar IMO. Scipio is ofc amazing with liu, but he's so old. Ragnar damage factor is INSANE and you can't get ragnar anywhere right now since his initial drop in game.

[@Redkillabish]

Iv seen ragnar prime appear in sovereign keys list

[@icecube4030]

chisgule you do know we cannot swap to Ragnar right? hes not an option. well atleast for kds in end of kvk 2

[@kchris5326]

As for siege, Gajah/Cordoba are the best. The new commanders are just ok. Stephen better than John. John would probably be the lowest priority legendary siege commander currently in the game.

[@CavScoutCookies]

How many swaps do you get total?

[@dread3921]

Omniarch said about Sargon first, just saying And Ramses is not a GC Commander Solid advice on Jadwiga! Thank you 🙏

[@RanzoMoney]

Is Ash x Boudica or Boudica x Ash the better pairing? Thanks

[@stefanodg6155]

Boudica will be trash soon dont do it. im an archer main im no an hater XD

[@RanzoMoney]

I have two solid archer sets , but trying to figure out what to do with my archers Zhuge Hermann Boudica YSG, who should I replace Boudica with?

[@rianpriambodo9548]

​@@RanzoMoney zhuge/herman and ashur/ysg. Swap boudica to ashur.

[@RanzoMoney]

@@rianpriambodo9548thanks man

[@xMoonMoonMoon]

@@RanzoMoneyswap Boudica, she’s a piece of trash

[@jasonjones8849]

I'm slowly learning to do the opposite of what Chisgle says nowadays

[@Idkidkidktoby]

Who’s the best commander in the game

[@ebube2001]

Great video so much value in few mins all in exchange for liking the video. GG

[@cyntai6690]

richard to be ok to swap is hilarius 🤣

[@realjohnlove]

9:55 Mulan can be swapped. And thats the one I was waiting on you to rate ironically lol

[@stardriver75]

Why can i only swap commanders from season 3

[@SVGrokZ]

Why is Shajar the future chis? is Hermann not as good as Shajar?

[@Cyrus84]

How is joan under WW? She does like 2x the damage and it’s aoe!

[@BCamacho8]

One is cav and one is infantry. Doesn't matter... they fill different roles for completely different categories and we can speculate WW should have more worth in the future compared to Joan who is older than WW by a good margin. Not saying WW is better or worse than Joan, just saying that having one above ther other doesn't matter as much because they play different roles.

[@fatpedro5588]

Surely Minamota can't be swapped out as you can't buy his sculptures again?

[@bbsitoyt147]

Need help am archery main i have ZL/HERMAN,,,,BOUDICA/YSG SHOULD I SWAP BOUDICA FOR SHAJAR..OR SHOULD I SWAP HUO/ARTHUR FOR MY FIRST CAV MARCH

[@nicdiamond9989]

Should I swap gorgo or Sargon. I’m not a garrison , only field. After all the math, I can only pair one of them with skippy P, so Scip with Sargon or Scip with Gorgo ?

[@shao5889]

Sargon is terrible. Do not use, i made the mistake of maxing as well. Today was the happiest day of my life, i finally got rid of him. Get ragnar or LC

[@nicdiamond9989]

@ I have LC , I’m doing new cav , think I’ll do Sargon for Huo

[@PainPills]

does the swap event start today at reset?

[@ulisisal]

Swap Ww to Ragnar and stay with LC/Alex and Ragnar/ scipio ? Make sense ??

[@chrisxtrm]

dont you have other more useless commanders to swap out?

[@Hydrobladegiyuu]

thats exactly what i plan to do too, especially since inf are coming out soon which should replace alex from LC pairing

[@limbercuevas9051]

is it smart to bench and swap guan for ragnar i also run liu with alex

[@Don0t_laugh_021]

I tired 3rd option mix one but when i try 1111 and level 40 4 Stare then ot showing 120 ticketa why?? Can anyone explain me please

[@dungletien6240]

hello I play 1 archer march and have zhuge + yi, should I swap yi with herman or shajar?

[@rianpriambodo9548]

Herman

[@Idkidkidktoby]

Is there a certain way to get ragnard

[@Louis-ts1iw]

I currently have ZL YSG, who should I swap to pair with ZL to replace ysg?

[@ChristIsKing8888]

Herman

[@Louis-ts1iw]

@ that was my plan. Chis made me think

[@shaddy8652]

You also said smite will be the only way for infantry and then there is Ragnar prime ... Lilith really works in a weird way

[@Chisgule]

Maybe the next inf commander will have a skill damage option like Arthur