[CHUANG 2020] EP01 Part II | Girls in Bench Team Launch a Challenge,And Who Can Stand Out?

[@mihanni2214]

"Why am I here? Because I couldn't get jobs." Please I love her 😭😂

[@taegucci8100]

That's what we call honesty😂 if she really is here to get a job why does she have to think about a reason that please the audience ?

[@niranrakwaan9401]

T A E G U C C I 🤣🤣🤣

[@kimboih7631]

what time? I don’t remember this...

[@junjieliu4571]

1.35

[@candyxu4616]

Kim Boih 1:43:54

[@sophieyue8654]

I think Tao is right. Honestly, everyone could be afraid of failure, but there is no need to cry before you give it a shot.

[@estherviplubin9077]

Sophie Yue he’s 100% right! How can you be a performer if your too scared to compete? What’s the point of coming on the show? Everyone has their weakness but they still proudly stood up to perform regardless of the feedback. That’s how you grow as an artist.

[@lovexo9]

exactly this is not a pity show

[@lovemetillidie689]

@Silurian Wonders Nope. He is right. Honestly I would've gotten mad too. The girls chose to come here but they were timid, they should have some confidence, if not, then what was the use of coming to a show were you HAVE to at least perform one stage. Regarding about the male mentors, these shows look for qualified mentors and mentors that are available, since the show's system became stricter, I'm glad they chose males and not females. Since some females could go easy on them. Don't call him a bully if you don't understand how Chinese show systems work, because you definitely don't seem to.

[@lrose1310]

Isn't that what Curley said? Not Tao?

[@prettygirl1625]

Silurian Wonders do you know the definition of the word bully??? Clearly not A bully is a person who habitually seeks to harm or intimidate those whom they perceive as vulnerable so how is he one of them??? Plus I didn't hear him say anything really disrespectful to the girls , he said: "Do you know why I'm annoyed?? Is because why are already here so raise your hand, the stage is cruel , why are you here ,to be the most timid, if you can't do it then leave (after all there are girls who would give everything to be in their place ) so please tell me what was wrong in what he said And you said that women aren't slave (which has nothing to do with what was being discussed) and that they are beautiful artistic spirits that should be nurtured but actually they aren't giving themselves an opportunity to be appreciated

[@p01104]

For those that think Tao's comments are a bit harsh, I think you have to understand that these group of judges went through so many years of training in Korea under SM. They are the one who knows that crying ain't going to get you anywhere. If you are familiar with this show, you'll know that in the previous season, one particular girl debuted and she literally can't sing or dance.

[@iluvMCRsupercool]

If you don't mind me asking who that girl is? i'm curious to see how she debuted!

[@dt8101]

@@iluvMCRsupercool Yang Chao Yue. She debuted only because she is cute...she cannot sing/dance at all and is totally a joke, dragging down the entire team... she is very famous now, but in a bad way...times have changed. Chinese audience are very tired of people like Yang Chao Yue in showbiz. i am guessing this year's show will be very different in terms of which 7 can eventually debut. a lot more emphasis on hardcore vocal and dance skills.

[@ThemedNumber02]

D T DANG! You dragged that girl in the mud!!

[@liviamartins1805]

@@dt8101 Any of these groups still active? Were they successful in chinese market?

[@valliandria7348]

@@liviamartins1805 Yes still active...and for ....the success: go see Rocket Girls 101

[@iamoon3078]

Curley Gao is really talented. The best singer for me

[@belle5423]

Same

[@tamiresalves946]

same x3

[@binitathebe2487]

Same man i think it was unfair

[@farzeenfaruque489]

Is it of 2020? Or of previous years?

[@tiffanyglitterizada]

@@farzeenfaruque489 it is from this month! Competition stills happening!

[@piperisacutie05]

Came here after watching “youth with you” I’m obsessed with these shows. Curley Gao is such a talented singer, I’m obsessed

[@mxm1337]

Too many obsessions not good 😂

[@scoundrelsy670]

i think YWY better~~~~~~CHUANG just soso~~

[@Sucaloid321]

Agreed! Curley Gao gave my shivers!!

[@aria0218_]

Same here, YWY got too much drama

[@blinkherehylt2316]

ItsJessicaBlake yess support her

[@YasMine-li5ym]

Curley should be in the final girlgroup she is so talented

[@hyunjim6678]

Yas Mine she deserves to be a SOLOIST. She is way too good to be in this show.

[@amy-ho8sd]

She is

[@Amiiiinachamii]

yes their group is soo talent

[@chengjoanna2010]

She is in the final girl group

[@_jay__22]

70% of the comments : about curley gao's group 20% of the comments : how cute Nene is 10% of the comments : how unfair the choosing system is

[@annalimpiadolimpiado5023]

Bias

[@estrella7861]

I think the system is not that unfair tho. Everyone has super power

[@piss-v4l]

Cyndi Pe it isn’t fair but honestly this first ep doesn’t mean anything lol

[@estrella7861]

@@piss-v4l Ah,agree

[@3lla358]

_ alice. I don't see much about Curley gao

[@afrinalim1827]

Where are the “The Untamed” fans rooting for Chen Zhouxuan!? Not only her acting is good but her voice just takes my breath away!! I can hear it all day long on repeat! She is so amazing!

[@xyc350]

it's aight

[@starry8226]

Here !! I'm here coz of ChenZhouXuan ❤️

[@itachischiffer4056]

@@starry8226 same

[@michellebeltran4115]

Same! I’m rooting for her

[@sakinazehra7533]

Here I am

[@soupfairy_1]

I am not even going to lie this Chinese version is better than the Korean one the way they battle each other, I am in love 😘

[@zzz-er9qd]

wtf Chinese version is just for fun Korean version is more serious

[@feansoriano2895]

worldwide handsome how do you know that? It’s obviously serious how can you not see that? Atleast this show spent more money on the sets that would make viewers hyped and excited, I’m honestly in love with the atmosphere of this show

[@alondrareyes2402]

worldwide handsome Chinese at least don’t rig the trainees votes like Korea’s did making x1 disband

[@koala2587]

@@alondrareyes2402 lamao the Chinese version absolutely does rig the vote ,and this is heavily criticised by Chinese audiences.

[@许浩川]

喜欢就对了

[@todayiglowup4286]

ok im gonna say it now these trainees are on a whole other level than the korean survival show trainees. these are probably the best of the best in china, honestly they could all debut already. if you look at their singing and dancing, its already super advanced compared to produce 101 trainees

[@lunay4723]

Pearlie Grace they are soo much talented. No offense to produce 101. But these girls can both sing, rap and dance at the same time and im like 🤭🤭🤭. Like some Korean trainees train for years but they still lip sync. Like I’m not against it but once in a while I wanna hear their raw voices🤷🏽‍♀️

[@mianbaobei]

Pearlie Grace you should watch youth with you 2 as well!! the girls there are really on fire!!

[@lunay4723]

Jeni Toh I do watch them too. I really like baby monster and xin liu ❤️

[@ggerdagg]

I agree, but not with first season, first korean season had a lot of talent, but not everyone go to the group because of corruption, for example leader-songwriter in g-idle is from first season

[@sofialee74]

They're so talented, that's right but not all of them know how to work as a team, there are several who are shy or scared and didn't show their true talent. On the other hand, there are girls that stand out much more or try to do it to the task of their own team.

[@miiwaah]

All the girls are so talented in their own ways. But I do agree with Tao on why he got angry, why join the show if you are too timid? It's not a place to pity a person to stardom. If you want to fight for your dream, stand up and try your best. Not winning a spot doesn't mean that you're not good enough, it just means that you need to practice harder and improve yourself. I think for sure this show needs someone like Tao to input strictness into the trainees. It's to help them gain their lack confidence. Tao has a very soft heart, he is a strict person only because he cares and want the girls to believe in themselves. Just two episodes in and I can see so many talented girls. Looking forward to this show.

[@linpuype9783]

for real tho it's not good to have this mindset that others are superior to you and what if, I wouldn't want to give up if I would've come so far

[@lovemetillidie689]

@Silurian Wonders Wdym you agree and literally put Tao was being disrespectful right after that? The op is talking how Tao is strict because he cares. Don't go around talking nonsense if you don't understand them

[@thatasiangirl0_039]

@Silurian Wonders Are you stupid or what, did you understand nothing out of her comment?

[@chilln9859]

Excellent comment! Thank you!

[@dontread9967]

@Silurian Wonders why did you reply in all comments like this? May be you hate Tao that's why you don't like his shouting 😑you even said he bullied them 🙄

[@alistairrupert3201]

when the lolita girl fell down on the stair but she still wants to keep her character is so funny haha 1:02:41

[@emmanabi1283]

😂

[@anneh.2982]

Call me a child but my favourite performance is Dong Ba La. It was so cool and they had such a great stage presence, they nailed it !

[@marielasotelo6884]

Las mejores

[@knightcool7769]

YESSSSS!! I loved it

[@arfarandawa4780]

Same

[@rima2956]

Me too it was amazing

[@maryoryibarravelasco58]

It was the best for me too!

[@lovemetillidie689]

People are getting mad at Tao because he "shouted" at the girls. You have to understand, he is doing this because he knows crying can get you nowhere. And he is an ex-member of EXO from SM Entertainment. The company is known for their strict standards. He knows so he cares. And no one learns if you're too sweet with them, he has to get mad here and there. There are many other strict mentors. Lisa, Cheetah, Yixing and others. Don't get mad at Tao for not understanding him

[@menukalaghu2991]

Yup👏💞

[@piss-v4l]

박오로라 um literally no one is mad ngl, like almost everyone is supporting the intentions of his actions, I’m Chinese and even Chinese are very supportive, I saw 0 hate comments unless u count the ones like “I think he’s a little bit scary but I do know why he’s doing it”

[@kenodawg7151]

Lisa was strict, but she never raised her voice to point of yelling. A mentor is someone who is to be a trusted advisor/trainer. The other mentors were just as frustrated at this point, but they did not have to yell to get their point across.

[@skyshin39]

It's a comedy to take Chinese people who failed in Korea and teach them.Tao betrayed exo and ran away. Is there no artist in China other than idols who have been active in Korea? lol

[@taegucci8100]

I agree , plus , his compliments weight a lot since he has very high standards

[@ducksummoner980]

lolita girl has my whole heart she's so cute

[@asktoseducemiss434]

hua chiyo (the chinese-japanese soloist) 100% deserved to win. she has insane talent and charisma. sis was ROBBED

[@leslie226]

@@asktoseducemiss434 ikr !!

[@taegucci8100]

Ikr , I LOVE HOW SHE DIDN'T LOOSE HER HER CHARISMA WHEN SHE FELL

[@Yes-bl7mp]

Nene has my heart and the lolita girl is so cute 😭 i love her personality; it's so amusing watching her talk when she's teasing or being funny. Even her comments are amusing.

[@do_kyungsoo9369]

I think curley gao and her members deserved that priority seat..it's so obvious right they have a great vocal..i don't say yaohoi don't have a great vocal..hurmm,I'm so dissatisfied with this system,poor them

[@do_kyungsoo9369]

@Potty Mouth what do you mean like kpop song?

[@animeSara2]

I would let both of them in the top seats, because even if Yao had taken the seat, there was another free, right??

[@gaga832]

Ikr And they did not only sing but they danced while singing. With the other team Tao choosed someone else because the dancing wasn't good enough but with this group they choose someone who didn't dance at all. I just don't understand. Like I was okay with every other groups till the last one😭I didn't expect that

[@do_kyungsoo9369]

@@gaga832 yeah,like they said for the other groups before,they want to choose girl group not soloist but hurmm,i dont what to say anymore..huhuhu

[@do_kyungsoo9369]

@@animeSara2 yeah,actually i thought about this too....in preview for next episode,it's seem like they will give that seat to another group who don't perform yet

[@pta96]

I have to say Zhong FeiFei is absolutely stunning, wow

[@huanghadiya8361]

Curley Gao is the best. I cannot put my eyes on other girls once you are here.

[@2047gc9]

huang hadiya cool 牙啦

[@ditto_op12]

Typical fan girl

[@moofynaa6075]

I think so. I like Curley Gao the best! Her voice is so different from others singer in this show.. but she didn’t pass it I feel so sorry for her

[@tamiresalves946]

@@ditto_op12 I see your jealousy

[@am5ters504]

IZ*ONE i think the fact that she has fangirls like this kind of already proves how good she is

[@互相伤害吧]

101的时候， 很多有实力的女孩因为没镜头， 导致还没来得及被人看到就无声无息地淘汰了。 比如林君怡是101初选A组， 她当时就是几乎完全没镜头导致没人记得她， 直到她被淘汰了才有人发现她竟然是A组的却一轮游了。 看看这次她多拼多豁得出去， 就知道她当初多不甘心。 这次这个赛事安排给所有女孩一个公平的表现自己的机会， 只要敢上， 就有机会得到镜头， 这样还不抓住的话， 就真的是自己不够努力了。 尤其是像张艺凡这样的女孩， 她芭蕾跳得好， 可芭蕾是不适合女团舞的。 初舞台之后就都是团战了， 她其实是非常需要靠初舞台的个人PK环节来展示自己的。 哪怕输了， 至少能让人记住学员里有她这样一个气质绝佳的芭蕾少女。 结果她就这样放弃了， 真是太可惜了。 说真的看得出黄子韬和宋茜最后都急了， 拼命让还没举手的女孩赶紧站起来。 尤其是黄子韬， 他是101的发起人， 他比其他教练都知道没镜头对这些女孩们意味着什么， 所以他也是最激动的一个， 他是真的为不敢举手的女孩急了。 如果不是真心为这些女孩着想， 他根本不用这样大动肝火。 说到底， 这些女孩哪个出道跟他有什么关系呢？ 他这么焦急还不是想让每一个女孩都能不留遗憾嘛。

[@刘佳敏-v2w]

说的太好了，我就喜欢这种有实力的比拼，而不是只会炒作的，而且真是对黄子韬路转粉

[@祉诺陈]

还有扶贫朱天天🧐

[@ierwenzhong1700]

A组扶贫林君怡

[@sirogong7823]

黄子韬又中二，又有点脾气，挺有个性的。他创1的时候就发怒过。

[@chungfankwan3472]

對阿，101一堆強的又沒鏡頭，而且那些爛得要死還出道真的莫名其妙，這還最強女團，你要打造最強的起碼給實力比較好的多點鏡頭阿。

[@exo-lmidzy5072]

girls don't be upset with TAO, he is a wonderful person and he doesn't say this without reason that he wants you to trust only yourself, he has suffered a lot in the past I really was Stan him since his demarcation and I know how much he suffered so please give him love and listen to advice and also for luhan And Victoria and another teachera and sorry for my bad English

[@apink9039]

Yeah

[@dayanaoliveira2806]

Yeah, babe

[@ThemedNumber02]

Apink your English is good

[@lu_lu0328]

He really is good, he just knows how harsh the industry is so he’s harsh

[@exo-lmidzy5072]

@@ThemedNumber02 thank you

[@tatz_han7550]

I think I will Stan Nene...she makes me smile unconsciously....

[@cairiakapampangan1320]

Same here ❤ Something special of her .

[@lovelyghoulz1323]

That whole group makes me so happy 🥺

[@phonpisey8303]

same hare

[@bluesol609]

that’s what tao is doing lmao

[@ditto_op12]

She is so cute. Also, she acts on 2gether the serie.

[@sun14lits72]

It's kinda unfair to Victoria how her comments are only for the VIP to see. she gives great feedback but people can't see it, and think she doesn't give any.

[@PandaOnHoliday]

damn that sucks

[@minimissmai]

I want to see her comments especially since she personally came from a girl group herself.

[@xo_diimplesz5005]

Yeah I was wondering why she has no screen time. Like I wanted to hear her comments

[@ellanote2260]

Why for VIP only wtf

[@Kayvid002]

Sun14Lits Preach!!!

[@maryji4322]

Just so people know: Curley Gao also produces/writes songs, and she plays the piano. So yeah :)

[@neginnasiri3198]

This is why I always liked Luhan, he acts so mature without outbursts like Tao and he voted the 3 girls (rational decision instead of emotional imo) he is really kind and mature.

[@JustJnn0526]

sameee. and if he has criticism, he'll give it in a nice way rather than "you're just not good. we want the best here" like when he had to tell gao zhi that she was out of tune.

[@SalwaDin]

@@JustJnn0526 exactly , I feel like TAO is more strict cuz of what he experienced and yes I am referring to exo and idk know much but like apparently luhan was more popular and I bet he was treated better bcuz of it. Rather Tao it was different, I mean I am just assuming thing so I don't rlly know. Plus luhan is older

[@sophieyue8654]

Yao is a good singer, but I'm more impressed by Gao and her group. (┯_┯)

[@miiwaah]

My honest opinion is this show needs someone like tao. Not everyone can understand how to improve with nice critic all the time. Sometimes harshness is needed, which I think it is needed to wake the girls up and to be more competitive. Mentors are there to guide them to improve and different people need different type of mentors.

[@amyvo8830]

Salwa Din Tao is doesn’t has good experience in judging and he doesn’t has a good taste just my opinion. Luhan has more experience and knowledge better than Tao...

[@lly8935]

Am I the only one who realise huang zi tao's face and the girl's face beside him are the same in the thumbnail? 😂

[@Melody-zp9vx]

- l.liyii - 😂😂Love their eye smiles

[@piperisacutie05]

Hahah I just noticed

[@RiddhiL-]

🤣🤣🤣🤣same

[@wenqianzhu9709]

no, you are not the only personhhhhh

[@israaderrij9867]

Vivian Crony yes on wetv app

[@tsukki4958]

Isn't anyone going to talk about the girl who solo-ed against the group, she killed it

[@PurpleSilva]

Bold！

[@taegucci8100]

Yes , if she debutes I'm definitely gonna be her fan ... I already am lol

[@michelleyang2629]

She’s incredible

[@pamslinda8930]

omgg bestie do you had the time stanp??

[@LyndaTomTang]

Previous comment says 1.14.41

[@하트택]

Liu Xiening!!!!!! Now that gugudan’s pretty much done, I hope you find success and happiness through this show. It’s so satisfying as a longtime fan to see you finally spread your wings and show the world your talents!

[@Ali-ge5dw]

Gugudan disbanded seriously

[@하트택]

Abdikarim Ahmed not officially. but they’re inactive and will probably continue to be inactive for a while.

[@al3xskng854]

I doubt they’re done, she probably is just there to promote their group or something

[@Tine.T]

Now " I'm a super WOman" is stuck in my head. She's so cool!

[@PurpleHaze4me]

that was so kind of curley to give yao hui the opportunity to shine on stage. just look at curley feeling the song and getting lost in it. she wasn't concerned about winning or losing the battle at that particular moment..

[@blurberrycreative1996]

Tao is in the right. Better worded: "you can't just forfeit when you haven't even fought yet". And I love how Victoria inspired the girls after his statement and they all stood up with confidence.

[@GrayLifeZone]

I understand Tao. He had every right to be this mad. Tao had to go to another country because an opportunity like this show wasn't even available back then. He learned another language, stayed in a very strict system of training for years, and even when he debuted he had to fight for a spotlight. These girls got an opportunity over thousands of other girls who auditioned and got rejected. they have the opportunity to showcase their talents without losing anything but instead, they are sitting on those seats as some elite group who are already at the top. They aren't even trying when many others in the same room as them were fighting head to head. If you can't even appreciate the blessing you have, then you don't deserve such a blessing.

[@LyndaTomTang]

It wasnt a blessing tho, it was the opportunity, the chance to show ur talent/skill... Because they weren't competing all against each other. It was the top ones getting to choose after who steps up to be chosen. It wasn't always like style competing like against like.

[@irissszhou]

WHY is no one commenting about Tao's long lost sister? I'M SCARED RN

[@dramalooverhi4452]

Iris Zhou FR

[@liviamartins1805]

Im shocked and no one is talking about it

[@yaparn1012]

????

[@pebbles3506]

Can sm pls explain what this is abt?!?

[@maria23977]

@@pebbles3506 their is a trainer that looks like Tao😂

[@yaya54579]

Why is no one talking about tao who looked to luhan at the end when hua chiyo sang the song from kris wu!!!?? my poor exo-l heart is crying Q_Q

[@brigittewastaken8200]

i was so confused about that, that was cute.

[@julianaracines8488]

Right?? The highlight of the episode haha

[@erlsb0pdg99]

😢😢😢😢

[@armyxblinkforever7614]

@Want Dinner Tao is the one with the Light Brown skin and Luhan then one who Looks super Young and Handsome and cute both of them are Mentors and Former members of exo

[@leena5531]

hua chiyo (the chinese-japanese soloist) 100% deserved to win. she has insane talent and charisma. sis was ROBBED

[@celecha]

Ikrrrr!

[@Supernatural3878]

The girl who went solo and took on a team of 6 girls was so unbelievably amazing 1:14:41 her dance performance wasn't nearly as good as her singing but still so impressive

[@LyndaTomTang]

Think she just got tired n bored of waiting really

[@李雪-t8l]

​@TomLynda Tang most of them actually

[@JustJnn0526]

damn when tao yelled at them for crying oof. then the other judges were like "yikes we gotta make his words sound nicer"

[@lovexo9]

lol, ikr but i do agree with how tao handle the situation, they need to get a reality check. This is not a pity show, how can you give up when u didnt even give/show your all. They got nothing to loss

[@michellesmirnova4471]

Lover엑 소_ Agreed, Tao is being harsh because this industry won’t go easy on these girls. If they want to win they have to give it their all, and for him to get mad that the girls aren’t working as hard as they should then expect to win this show is perfectly reasonable.

[@lovexo9]

@@michellesmirnova4471 yes exactly, they have the chances to debut, like only a few steps, yet they arent even gonna/want to try. Plus chances of debut is higher if they manage to make themselves shine/stood out to the public. its also easier since they dont need to learn new language like tao/luhan/victoria

[@ceceh583]

Michelle Smirnova he does NOT need to be that harsh at all. They were lacking confidence in themselves which is why they cried, yelling at them for doing so is not the right move. Look at JYP’s nizi project, girl’s cried but he told them what they needed to hear constructively instead of an outburst. You can be annoyed and still be mature about a situation. I do not want to hear about Tao being in SM either Bc luhan was in the exact same group and does not act out in that way.

[@michellesmirnova4471]

Shimmer It’s called showing them what the world is truly like. Yeah it’s not nice, but he had all the right in the world to do that. Do you think the industry will be all “awww it’s okay you can cry”? No. He’s being honest, the industry will be even MORE harsh than him. If he’s gonna treat them nicely then that’s even more rude, because he’s not preparing them for the real world when he knows that he should. It’s fully valid for him to get mad that the girls come there and cry instead of working on their confidence and proving to him that they are capable. You won’t get anywhere unless you work harder than anyone, he’s just ensuring they do.

[@healloveandpeace800]

I am a big fan of Curley Gao希林娜依高 and I think Yao Hui 姚慧 is also talented and courageous! I think there is no need to hate Yao Hui 姚慧 for winning the spot over Curley because the spot itself doesn’t really matter much for this show! Even Curley herself enjoyed Yao Hui 姚慧‘s performance:) In fact, this is just some conflicts created by the show to make sure people talk about the contestants~ which will help promote popularity for both of them and which is a great thing! It is all about click rate 流量 nowadays and we should be kind to these talented girls!

[@mek5386]

On weibo it already became a hot topic. A lot of people debating this issue ahaha So ur right

[@mxm1337]

At the end of the day it's not really about who is more talented But who will win the public vote...

[@ngkristal2895]

Yeah I think everyone hv a different taste when Yao hui singing actually made my heart feel touched!!

[@ngkristal2895]

And Curley gao’s group is also insane

[@MarsIntelligence]

Curley Gao is currently a student in Berklee Music School majoring in singing! Super Cool.

[@tamiresalves946]

Hua Chiyo sings so well and with much stability, she's also very ambitious and has a lot of charisma, she can completely shine in her own way, she could be easily successful as soloist

[@rooze_e]

Am I the only one who wanted Luhan to display mic movement while singing when the mentors asked him too!!!! God I just love this man so much

[@claramonroe9759]

I didn't like that Curley Gao and her group doesn't won the battle. That broke my heart. I'm kinda sad and disappointed 😭

[@dreamsomnia9813]

what annoys me even more is the fact that after they put the soloist in the top 7 there was still that empty seat that Sally from gugudan was sitting in. Why didn't they put the 3 girls up there?

[@claramonroe9759]

@@dreamsomnia9813 x10000

[@bangchu3579]

Me too

[@2047gc9]

Clara Monroe ugly teeth

[@dreamsomnia9813]

@@2047gc9 that's kind of a fucked up thing to say about someone.

[@izshotme]

i find the competition fair actually... they asked to see how the girls perform as a group, so they're not comparing skills, they're looking at their chemistry as a group + how they look on stage anyways the ranking will change eventually so there's no reason to be mad about it

[@rutenunes5313]

Tao scares me when he is mad. But he was right

[@wowohaha8747]

Rute Nunes He is easily got mad as 1st season

[@iamcarinawong]

Cause the students were at fault too

[@donelynespiritu7215]

but the way he judge the last 2 competitors... was unfair.. it was a 👎 for me... luhan still stood for the 3 till the end of decision making of mentors ... which is.. 😍😍😍.. he can really see a true talent...

[@midos2200]

Tao got excited easily. And got mad easily too. Hahaha

[@rutenunes5313]

@@midos2200 true ahahaha

[@tinazheng8789]

Curley, Feifei and roubing should've stayed. Yao hui is good and it's nice that she's a singer songwriter but this is trying to form a girl group. We don't even know if she can dance (since she didn't dance I'm guessing she can't) . If she ends up not being able to dance she's just gonna end up being pushed down anyway so why put her up there when the chances of her getting pushed down are very high

[@goldenbliss4259]

yao hui can easily portray her emotions when she is singing and her voice is really one of a kind, it's so soothing and beautiful. I don't want to say that curley, feifei and roubing don't have a good voice, no, because they a rly strong contestants when it comes to singing, but Yao hui is rly standing out, she is rly unique and just like Tao said, in a group you also need an original songwriter, and she is just fitting for this role, regarding to her dance skills...well she is in produce camp to learn, practice and get better at things she is lacking in. Which means she can take this opportunity to improve her dancing.

[@donelynespiritu7215]

@@goldenbliss4259 the voice is not 1 of a kind as a singer.. she sounds like the other trainees.. hear it closely.. but if you compare the voice of curley... that is a flexible voice.. she can sing all types of song not just acoustic... may I add.. they are trying to produce a group not solo artist... why wont she try in the voice china, or any competions where she can showcase her talent as composer/ singer

[@gracezhao4984]

Honestly, does anyone remember Yang Chaoyue? From Produce 101? Before you guys talk about Yao Hui, lets think of ChaoYue. Her talents were being adorable and crying. Practically nothing else (this is when she was on the show, she may have improved after training with Rocket Girls 101). She still managed to place 3rd (I'm not trying to be rude, she herself admitted that she wasn't good and thought she didn't deserve this). at least Yao Hui can sing. It doesn't matter if she gets pushed down or not, if she works hard to learn how to dance, she'll stay if not she'll get pushed down. That's just how life works. This is only one of the first episodes, there is nothing to worry about. I believe in XiLinNaYi's group, that they'll be able to go back up, that this is only the beginning (literally...it's only the beginning).

[@祉诺陈]

Grace /o.o\ Zhao I don't even think they are comparable honestly because Yao Hui is actually v talented. Btw if you think a contestant got chosen because pf crying than that's kind of the mentors' fault lol

[@goldenbliss4259]

@@donelynespiritu7215 i listened to the other contestants sing and tbh Yao Hui doesn't sound like them, she has her own style and can really show what she's got. You may say that she sounds the same just because she has a soft and soothing voice, many of the other girls have tried to sing soothing, but not many have been able to pull off what she did. Yao Hui expresses herself very beautifully and she also has a lot of singing skills. Yes Curley is an amazing singer, who has a very powerful voice and I have nothing to complain about her, but it doesn't mean that Yao Hui isn't an amazing singer either. She probably hasn't hit those high notes like Curley, but it doesn't mean that she can't, you heard her sing only 2 songs and already assume things you may not know about her, I am looking forward to her future performances too, because I really believe she has more to show us. And if she won't then she will just get pushed down in the ranking, because this is what the show is about, you either show what you have in store or you'll lose your chance. But until then lets just see what happens :))) And yes they are trying to produce a girlgroup, that's right... But that doesn't mean Yao Hui wouldn't be qualified for that position... For the time being she lacks im dancing, but that's exactly why she is here in this show to get trained and improver the things she is lacking in... She can definitely become better. ^^

[@ae-haniz3562]

Somehow Tao judgements is only to his own opinion and not being fair to the other judges. Luhan and Victoria were being very patient and mature. They took their time to see every little of the girls performance. No hate for the judges btw .

[@hywSANA]

nah nah the edits here really throw a lotta shades on him

[@02melissa20]

I think Tao is speaking from experience when he says crying wont help you achieve your dreams, but he shouldn’t have gotten angry about it and thrown a fit.

[@karentriminio3146]

Quick reminder that Tao debuted in EXO under SM's Company as a foreigner. SM is known for their exhaustive and perfectionist training method which means to even debut with EXO 8 years ago he had to compete with other trainees. I am not saying what he says is the rule but you should also take this into consideration because he came from harsh, competitive environment

[@pragyanigurung7069]

I think as tao has passed through many hard paths. He is trying to help them because he knows how hard it is ,he wants them to be strong and confident so even they don’t win they will be able to face their upcoming😁

[@peachpanda88]

They cut off a lot of Tao's great advice part. He gave lots of good advice even proper vocal care but Tencent cut it off. So annoying. They got what they wanted though w/ Tao scolding the trainees as it got this show #1 trending with 4million+ people talking about it on Weibo.

[@陳先生-i2m]

被華承妍圈粉了，寶藏女孩啊，長得好看又有實力又謙虛，愛了愛了❤️還有劉些寧，是一個好有魅力的女孩。

[@gisellemora5027]

Performances that i liked 10:14 Hu Yanan, Chen Xinye, Zhong Xin, Chen Yujin 27:44 Jiang Zhenyu ♡, Yuan Jiayi, Li Chengxi, Tu Zhiying, Sun Luly 38:37 Tu Zhiying 58:50 Ma Sihui ♡, Zhang Qing, Li Jiajue 1:05:09 Chen Zhuoxuan's ♡ group, i didn't particularly like this stage but i like her so I'm putting the timestamp. She does the high note. 1:21:28 Liu Xuening's group (sally from gugudan) 1:38:28 Li Zimeng, Miao Jingou, Wang Lina, Sun Ruyun 1:48:43 Lin Jiahui ♡, Tan Sihui, Li Yulu, Wu Miaoyin 1:54:25 Curley Gao ♡, Chen Roubing, FeiFei 2:04:36 2:09:47 Yao Hui ♡ 8:24 Lin Jiahui is funny i like her. I think I'm gonna vote for her for that clip alone sjsjs

[@teeeereeeeezaaaaa]

I think Yao Hui needs more recognition so here is a thing: one of the most difficult things to do when you're making a song it's translating your emotions to the lyrics and melody. She made the mentors emotional during her performance and she sounds so pure and sincere. Besides, even tho she learned to do music a little time ago she is still so good. I just think she is truly gifted and born to make music. Maybe she will not win this show or something, but she deserved all the recognition from the judges for her performance. All my love and support for her.

[@LyndaTomTang]

My fave so far xXx

[@kyu759]

Sally and Nene are my favorite trainees. Hope they debut!

[@МадинаНасырова-д4н]

Тоже зашел сюда, чтобы найти русскоязычный комментарий? : З

[@alya_1440]

@Tennie Kim да

[@mitsuryro1945]

ты ванга?

[@failed_v_again7236]

Угу

[@simqxk3486]

Прив

[@Kate-sv8pt]

That Lolita girl is the most CUTE thing I've ever seen

[@iluvactresses1]

I think my favorite performance was from Jiang Zhenyu's team wearing blue. The girl who played the zither was so cool and everything was really well synchronized and beautiful. They danced so so well!

[@LyndaTomTang]

Eh, one made a mistake n they didn't sing and dance together

[@asuman4921]

Kanun çalan kız Yuan Jia Yi

[@ttmt98]

对姚慧没有恶意，只能说对导师们的评价感到失望，也相信很大部分是导演组的操作。参加女团选拔不就是要唱要跳吗？之前要求华承妍唱跳，她也都做到了，但是还是被打败，现在到姚慧这里就没这个要求？了解她一路走来不容易，但是有哪位学员不是靠自己的努力走到这里的？她们都很不简单，节目组有必要耍这种感情牌吗？觉得她一个人有十分钟的镜头就很不对劲，导师们对她的评价（除了鹿晗以外）也不是很专业，不理智。如果真的要公平PK的话，也应该让希林表演自己的原创作品，相信一点也不会输给姚慧。真的无语... 我昨晚看到血压飙高，看来综艺节目真的对我的身体不好 :-)（多加一句：本人觉得五毒也应该唱歌，单单以舞蹈表演胜出也不公平。）

[@haiyueli725]

赞同，感觉对华承妍不公平，唱的也是原创，跳舞也还可以。

[@MrCooonut]

习惯就好，但骂还是要骂的。腾讯和爱奇艺确实都很狗！哪个选秀不是拿剧本的，最后没成团的混的更好也不少，有能力的还是可以被人看到的。

[@greenoot]

很大可能是有剧本，这个事情都上热搜了，希琳娜依收获了不少粉丝。

[@mayo_2552]

同感

[@melodylin6392]

如果要挑一个创作型的，之前那一个单人的 实力更强 会唱会跳

[@youmakemydawn7398]

Do you know why I'm annoyed? This stage isn't for you to express your emotions or cry. The stage is cruel. If you can do it, do it. If you can't, leave. - Huang Zi Tao he's not being harsh at all. he's just caring about them and wants them to have the best future they can have. their problems won't be solved if they keep crying.

[@nyanthar9821]

The girls are talented. But i think the mentors ' judgements are not quite fair and they like to think about unecessary things and cant give precise decision. I do personally love all mentors. But their judgments are something off.

[@vurelamic]

May Mon the Mentors aren’t fair at all. The first 3 girls in the part 1 were so good and danced wayyyy better than the Russian girl but the mentors just complimented the Russian girl for her basic dance moves that didn’t even give no one any goosebumps. Some how I also think the mentors aren’t fair at all

[@stevexiong6092]

@@vurelamic the mentors all suck and are clearly paid by the companies that back certain favorites. Tao is a talentless hack who only comments on people's appearance. Lay is so much better as a judge of talent.

[@Kayvid002]

steve xiong lmao because they don’t do as you want they suck and are paid by some companies? Who have more money than Tencent who hired them? Like seriously and would they risk their fame and careers for that little money? I’m not sure if you know they are all successful and rich? That’s why it’s a big deal to get these ex SM artists gathering for a show. Hence cnetz basically say Tencent has too much money and really is serious about this girl group. And if it’s script it’d be Tencent script. Because they would have contract w the girls companies to make a gg. But this is definitely due to the editing issue. If Tencent included the mentors comments on each trainees you would know why they picked who they picked. Like Victoria made sure about basic skill and no mistakes is made on stage. She actually voted for both the Foreign girl group and the solo to stay. If anyone who know what girl group is and how to be successful as one and have the most empathy with the girls. It should be her. After all she was the only ChiNese leader of a kpop GIRL group, from SM at that. Luhan’s comments are pretty professional too

[@jessicaaa123]

Most of their more meaningful comments are in the vip episodes

[@yiraidyabigail8984]

@@Kayvid002 This!

[@candykrush4796]

Wow so many talented trainees here.. Li Xie Ning group.. their killing part was really cool (the way they flip their hair and advance). The blue team's performance with the chinese instrument also felt very refreshing. The Lolita's group was cute and eye catching. What more.. there are trainees who could compose and sing their own songs.. This show really overflows with talent.

[@katrinaeloize]

i love how unassuming the girls act, saying humble things like "i'm not ready" "they're so good," and then they perform soooo well haha. it seems almost as if every single trainee has ground to hold.

[@Angelina-ou6nu]

Liu Xiening (sally) killed it!

[@loy-wh8sl]

I came to see and support Zhong FeiFei, please go vote for her.

[@Ali-ge5dw]

I hope she is treated well

[@wendawls.3463]

she's so talented and also SOOO gorgeous i hope she can get into the final group

[@wendyho9441]

How to vote them?

[@puppyprincess2822]

I came for her but fell in love with the other people as well.

[@feifeithings2442]

Wendy Ho you can vote through the wetv app

[@nyodager6916]

*mentors: we appreciate own produced songs more than other things* Hua Chengyan sing a translated chinese-japanese song, dance and sing her own composed song but doesn´t win Me: ARE U KIDDING ME?? HuaHua I love u and Wang Ke loves u too haha :)

[@刘佳敏-v2w]

我看有评论说没青你好，我觉得明明比青你好多了，有实力的特别多，我就喜欢有实力的比拼，而不是靠炒作和表情拿第一的。

[@Dongdong-xg3rm]

I pick that Chinese-Japanese mixed girl.

[@ks5061]

??? who is dat

[@genoveffabersaglieri7131]

k s it’s the girl with the dark green outfit, Huachengyan (华承妍). She also did a duet some time ago with Kris Wu

[@theunderestimated1467]

Genoveffa Bersaglieri time stamp?

[@FernandaVega-mc7cv]

1:09:28

[@andreamarin9854]

Same, i’ve got her song stuck in my head 😍😍

[@iSAFAEable]

Curley gao is just wayyy out of everyone's league, i really hope Chinese viewers feel the same way about her, if they don't have her in the final group they might as well just stop the show ngl

[@mihanni2214]

Well shes currently #1 rank so I think it's safe to say she's well liked

[@iSAFAEable]

krabbiekassie omg yesss i knew Cviewers have taste i’m just glad they didn’t disappoint, i‘ll stay hopeful🥺

[@candirita]

@@iSAFAEable Also because was already known from the Chinese version on the voice (even though they changed the name). She made it quite far and was many people's favourite competitor.

[@its.onedream]

Im chinese viewer and she is AMAZING!!! you can also watch her on sing china 2016 or 2017 i forgot

[@its.onedream]

@@candirita yesssssssssssss i watched it before i came to this show her mentor was my fav

[@stanlei8328]

毛毛和鹿晗的情商比较高，让人感觉很舒服

[@闲听]

沙漠之雕简直魔性，哈哈哈，开心果组合，姚慧好像佟丽娅啊~

[@hobihobi9316]

Yeah the soloist did well, but she Lowkey won bc she cried, like I’m sorry but Curley’s group did AMAZING, I’m still mad they lost

[@doodleydooo945]

Your comment is rude.

[@peachyyygelo0031]

I agree. I felt like they pitied her. Blame it on editing or whatever but the difference in how they treated the solo girl that went before her makes me sort of mad. They didnt give her the chance bc she was a soloist competing against a group of six but then decided to give the solo girl who went second a chance because they were getting emotional. The mentors didnt consider the fact that she was also a soloist, they felt like they just needed to put a soloist up there.

[@peachyyygelo0031]

@@teeeereeeeezaaaaa based off of the comments that the mentors made about hua chiyo. They chose the group over her bc she was a soloist. The performance that she put on was, in my opinion better than the groups. The girl that danced after hua chiyo's superwoman performance was not as eye catching. It wasn't anything new. All she did was roll her body, not put on a performance.

[@tsuaa5431]

@@doodleydooo945 But it's true. 😑

[@leejiajing965]

To be neutral: For those contestants doing well, keep going and maintain the spot. As for contestants doing poorly and not in top tier, it's okay, keep fighting and don't give up. It is only the very first episode, and they still have a long way to go. Most importantly, they must put in the efforts and cherish the stage without any regrets. Remember, the final episode ranking will be the one decides if you can make it into the group. I believe that as long they continue working hard and improving themselves, they will get more attention from people like us. Keep fighting everyone! ***To add on, People may don't like the outcome of the battle results, but they should not hate the contestants. It is not like they know they will win like that.

[@donelynespiritu7215]

it was not really the contestant's fault.. but misjudgments of some mentors...and turned out to be unfair..

[@ngawharau6834]

2:13:22 I don’t understand bc they were good at dancing and powerful vocals and this is a gg show, they were actually amazing, whereas the girl who won was only good at singing and lyrics which is good but I don’t think it gg material, I’m not hating, I love her voice it’s soothing but in terms of gg material she’s just not there but she can go solo with singing, also the girl at 1:14:37 singing her song superwoman, that’s gg material

[@Esqm]

In terms of singing she is better. In terms of idol, the other group fits. Who knows? She was able to express feelings in her singing which is hard to do unless you’ve been through things.

[@sunnyleeuwon7215]

I guess that it is because Curley won her place through vocals, and since the girls vocals were better, or that the other members of Curley’s group didn’t have strong vocals, that the other girl won.

[@tissan1998]

Tao said it because he wants to give a place to a song producer/composer a place in the group. He said the other three didn't lack either. I mean it still just the first episode.

[@ngkristal2895]

Idk if Chinese is ur first language or not. But for me her song rly touched my heart very deeply. But I also like another team and every one hv a different taste

[@Chrestomanci94]

the judges said they want a mix of talent up in the chairs rn - those who are all-rounders, those good at dancing, good at singing, and those with a lyricist solo quality

[@chengsilvia8215]

Many people picked Curley and said YaoHui doesn't deserve the seat. Don't you think it is too over? Curley sings well of course, but what she did is performing a song while YaoHui is telling her story. To be honest, YaoHui's performance touched me more. Curley is imitating but Yao is the new creater. Maybe you guys are not Chinese and cannot understand the real meaning of lyrics in Yao's song. But she really deserves the seat.

[@vanilla498]

Cheng Silvia word

[@drdenty]

Agreed. YaoHui’s performance brought me to tears because of how the emotion shows in her voice.

[@Sucaloid321]

I don't agree with their system. If they're going to have two groups go against each other, the groups should perform similar pieces. If a group is singing and dancing, the other group should be singing and dancing. In my opinion, it's not a fair evaluation. Hopefully the whole show isn't like this...

[@아멜리에니글레]

Sorry but I like more this system, people get offended easily nowaday

[@hyunhun5156]

i agree 100% with you. the amount of frustration i had while watching this-and i’m only an hour in.

[@JustJnn0526]

that's how the other idol survival show (that's nearing its end) had their first audition (in case you wanted to know).

[@ooooo000ooooo]

아멜리에 니글 레 Who said anything about “offended”? It’s just critique and a matter of preference

[@coolwong213]

why qcyn2 is better

[@MDY_8]

华承严的super woman beat做的真棒👍🏻

[@nemesis7539]

am i the only one who doesn't understand why five poisons won when they haven't even showcased their vocals????

[@animeSara2]

Because they did better than the other one. The first sang and danced, but the singing was too bad even the mentor said so if we eliminate the singing from the group they only have the dance as well as the second group, and as a group dance the second was more coordinated, more synchronized and the did well in group but the others only have explosion what is good, but you can see that the dance is a bit chaotic. So I think that is why they chose the second group. if gao zi team can really sing I hope they can show and to learn how to coordinate in dance and to sing while dancing and improve a lot, because I think they have charisma

[@nemesis7539]

@@animeSara2 yes but this isn't a dance competition it's about being capable of singing and dancing... no one can tell us than the second group was bad at that too, or am I wrong ?

[@animeSara2]

@@nemesis7539 actually, to be an idol is more than dance and sing. Is based on attracting fans. If the show give you an opportunity to show your abilities and the other team do better, don't worry, it will be another opportunity. But the thrut is the first group were not capable of signing while dancing and that left a bad impression if you try but not do it right, also, they want to be in a girl group but they even can organise a dance with their group? As the mentor said the first group dance was chaotic more like the dance battles from the begging. So, first group give us sing and do it wrong, also they give us dance and the second team do way better. The decision is clear, if the second team can't sing they possible will be dragged down, but in the battle the performance of both teams were very different and that is what matters in an idol the performance you give to the public

[@jennylieu123]

@@animeSara2 I dont believe this is true, even with that fantastic dance performance.. it is only fair if they sing as well. It just seems off cause the whole performance of the second group feels like you're watching SHEN YUN instead of an idol show if you know what I mean. Also, if they only did dancing..then they shouldve given the first group another chance as well its annoying and just seems unfair ://

[@5555sfr]

it's cause they were competing for the dancer spot, singing was a bonus, and the other group did badly

[@CELESTEXINGPING]

黄子韬：长得像我不是一件坏事。 🤣

[@irischen3146]

XingPing Chen 疑惑可以有，但你不需自卑 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣太可爱了！

[@jacky7035]

黃子韬这样说也是因为他是他自己。

[@jacky7035]

总不能说自己很丑啊！

[@siniz7391]

看到希林娜依 高被battle下来真的觉得不可思议，她们三人团体真的很强。姚慧也很好但是这不是一个女团选秀嘛。。女团是要又唱又跳阿。如果非要一个原创，之前唱super women的不好吗，人家还跳了舞诶。感觉好可惜23333（以上仅个人意见，不同意别回复我丫 谢谢）

[@ccll5992]

sini z 就是搞得十分不公平！

[@吳瑾軒]

这并不是最终结果，接下来的考验还有很多，话说回来这也许是节目想要的效果，就是要你我拿来讨论

[@wushiyipao]

才第二集，后面还长，总会发光的

[@rorschachgotnicemask9449]

1:54:32 草！！！怪不得牛叔换片头了，原来是被女团买了！！！

[@uureever]

就是为了造成反转效果！curly gao根本就是下去一小会儿再回来的

[@-staninfinite-623]

I feel like yao hui isnt getting appreciated much in the comment section so heres a comments abt how much I love her voice and shes so cute omg and idkw but when Victoria talked abt her past it made me tear up bc it must've been hard for her and it made me so emotional bc ik idk I feel like her music and everything was so sincere and it just broke me down and I just like love her now and all yall hating on her for getting the top seat ur favs will have another chance so let her have this moment ok luvs

[@baronessbeta5895]

yeah, while curley is my one pick yao hui was so sweet and she can definitely sing. It's not her fault she got picked so people should leave her alone and get mad at the judges instead if they disagree with the result

[@Monique_Wong]

真的是，唱歌最強的被拉了下來，舞蹈最強的也被拉下來

[@fatimaisabelsumbaine7242]

Liu Xiening (Sally) my girl!! You are amazing!! Fighting

[@thepurpleberry34]

I was shocked when read comments before that Curley's team lost but now watching the whole battle, I can understand the mentors decision. Yaohui's lyrics, from a mothertongue's perspective.. it actually brought me to tears. Her song was simple but the lyrics are raw and like Victoria said, along with her story it really leaves an impression. I feel like Yaohui and Curley can prob go head to head in solo vocals but Yaohui's performance here was more impactful than the cover of "me too".

[@rickashley4118]

I agree

[@yim_e]

they didnt even see yaohui’s dance skills before making a decision, which was purely emotional. curley’s team was more experienced. and if the mentors were judging based on songwriting, why didn’t hua chengyan win? she had a natural charisma, great song writing ability as well as being a decent dancer. in the next few eps, yaohui fails the theme song dance challenge. no surprise there, the mentors never saw her dance

[@THORINO_STUDIO]

I just noticed cause I've been a fan for so long, especially for SM groups, they've always looked at things as a whole and see if the group shine together and not individually. Tao really emphasizes teamwork :)

[@nettasmally5464]

I haven't laughed so much in a long long time, my fav performance is dong bala, lol

[@ngawharau6834]

Eugenette Small same so catchy and fun

[@nettasmally5464]

@@ngawharau6834 🤓

[@dreamsomnia9813]

One of my faves. I also lile th2 performance by UG!

[@nettasmally5464]

@@dreamsomnia9813 I know it's a little sad they didn't at least make it to the second step at least🤔 hopefully they can reach at least there before the next set of performances 😯

[@selen6189]

The fact that Curley is Uyghur made me like her even more

[@dramaein1943]

We're here for Zhong FEIFEI. FIGHTIN' 🙌

[@Sabrinaocviana]

YES!

[@mundomagnífico2.0]

Yes! 🙌🙌🙌

[@jessicakonobi]

periodtttt

[@ko-ln1kk]

yesss

[@nyasha7721]

So far im here for: Junyi, Curley Gao, Curley Zhong(feifei) and nene. Let's see who from this bench assessment can catch my eye. Alright the only other one whos caught my interest is the lolita girl, Wang lina and hua choiyi.

[@kongwee1978]

@@ly-sona Out going personality, like Esther Yu.

[@nyasha7721]

@@ly-sona She really is lol I like her alot

[@nyasha7721]

@@kongwee1978 EXACTLY THAT! OMG HEY YOU WATCH YOUTHWITHYOU AS WELL YAY HEY! HAHA

[@el6063]

Btw the Lolita girls name is XIe Anran

[@nyasha7721]

@@el6063 Thank you!

[@zhennotzen]

Who ever is doing the translation is doing a REALLY good job

[@racmanelias5974]

Its. OK my baby curley. Gao will get back again I'm sure because your so talented

[@raqellzz]

When they said they would perform ‘power’, i thought it was exo POWER...

[@elparfen9225]

Same

[@sean68777]

Do you know three EX EXO will reunion?

[@Midna.K]

Same omg

[@shweta3054]

Same

[@shuttin7417]

Same I was OMG

[@ariannafahur3000]

For the last girls the 3 they wear so good bro like howww do I have to cry to be in the top Im sorry but is not fair

[@serena8932]

I feel like they should evaluate each trainee individually instead as a group, because some trainees in the groups who got a high grade definitely aren’t there yet but they got the high grade because of the group performance. I feel like individual evaluations are better for the trainees too so they can know where they are at and improve from there.

[@weiranhuang3939]

cuz they prepared as groups and its only the first stage. Later they will be trained and evaluated separately.

[@puntej4548]

I agree with you

[@serena8932]

黄蔚然 对呀可是其他选秀节目都是individual evaluation不管他们是不是一个团表演。觉得这样更公平一些，像刘谢宁被降级了虽然她个人实力足够到上面。觉得一开始就这样会更好对选手们都是好事。

[@lalasuperbearrrrrrrr]

Agreed!!! I feel the Chinese version wants to do some so-called innovation to distinguish from all the Korean versions in the past.. but there’s a reason why the original Korean produce 101 gained so much popularity and success... so they should have sticked to the original evaluation system.

[@Jessica-yd3ld]

totally agreed.

[@jojowho4084]

I was shocked when yao hui won instead of Curley Gao(Xi lin na yi Gao)'s group. Creating your own songs is cool, but her songs are just like any plain slow Chinese songs. I heard many songs sounding similar to hers and there is just no uniqueness. I like yao hui's voice and it's very soothing, but it's very emotional as other people say. This is a competition to have a spot in a girl group. Yao hui doesn't dance which is a requirement girl groups need. If this is other produce shows like youth with you or korean produce shows, she will definitely be asked to show a dance performance. But if she doesn't know how to dance well, she will definitely be moved to a lower class. Curley Gao's group have vocals and dance. They reach the requirements of being cabable of being in a girl group. This is not a singing competition and not a competition to showcase your own songs. This is why I prefer watching youth with you and korean produce shows because they have a clear idea of what girl groups need. The mentors have clear roles. This show is a bit messy and i don't get why they got rid of the alphabet ranks. Many of the trainees are talented and yao hui is also very talented.

[@hanlu1590]

if SM thought so it would have lost two main EXO vocalists. Chen and Baek had no dance skills but SM debuted on EXO and today they are complete artists and are part of kpop history.

[@eileen9024]

@@hanlu1590 i mean they chen and baekhyun can train but these girls who can't dance will literally suffer throughout the whole program because every single performance requires them to dance and sometimes they even have to learn it within 3-5 days

[@eileen9024]

agreed! The mentors keep talking about the importance of being able to work well in a girl group but their last judgement was totally contradicting what they said and its true that they'll remove the ABCDF rank? if its true, this is a stupid idea to judge who gets to stand at the highest stage in the theme performance lol

[@katherineg3111]

I think maybe that's because the thought of mentors. Da and Mao is famous for composing and writing songs in china, then Tao said there should be a spot for composer. then that's three( Da, Mao, Tao) over two( Luhan, Song Qian), so Yao Hui win. Da is a flying mentor, so don't worry this situation.

[@jojowho4084]

@@eileen9024 I was confused with how they are ranking the skills of the trainees this season. This isn't a group battle; this is a battle to win a spot in the new girl group. Can't the mentors judge the girls individually like they always did? If one girl shine more than the others they should receive a high rank. If the other members of the group didn't do so well, they should receive a low rank.

[@SkyNami]

Some of you are really coming for the mentors just because you don't agree with their picks and stuff and I understand I don't always agree with what they say or the picks they make but at the end of the day they're mentors for a reason. I mean not only are all the mentors extremely talented but they've all experienced a bunch of hardship and an opinion from a viewer who probably doesn't know a thing about singing or dancing or being in an idol group compared to people who are professionals and have experience like who opinion seems more right? yall getting mad at tao for being harsh but a lot of the things he says are the truth like tao knows hardship yet yall mad at him because he's harsh like honestly, this show needs someone like him because nine times out of ten thanks to his bluntness those girls are getting a good wake up call and do better and become confident. Don't be coming for the mentors just because you don't agree with them yall just seem salty at this point.

[@lovexo9]

yess, i like how tao handle the situation these girls need to get reality check. crying aint gonna bring you anywhere, afterall this is not a pity show.

[@mayathebee1219]

Exactly ! Preach

[@yousraammachi9087]

BLESS. I find it hilarious when 15 years olds who have never even went to a gym and spend all their time in their rooms on their phones criticize the mentoring of people who have an experience of many years in their own field.

[@abp1400]

Hua Chengyan (aka Chiyo) to me is the most impressive solo artist. She seems very well rounded.

[@scarlettdrama4994]

I’m literally cheering for the vocalist. I fell in love with them lol. Definitely will be cheering for them especially Nene

[@rosewaiters5925]

I love how hyped Tao is after watching every performance

[@elenaguo1094]

首先如果教练们能看见姚慧的那些经历 那么没有理由他们不知道希林娜依也有原创作品，还是伯克利学生 硬要说原创，我个人更喜欢华承妍，‘I'm a super women’ 。 凭什么华承妍会因为比不过一整个团队而失败，但是姚慧连舞都没跳就能赢了。 至于她的原创作品我只能说是好听的，但是我没有眼前一亮的感觉。 旋律什么的都太套路，就好像歌的起承转合你能猜到，下一秒是该低音了，该高音了。 好听但并不惊艳，这种旋律的歌说实话。挺多的。 最后检讨一下我自己，我并不太能听出她歌里想要表达的情绪，大概是因为我母胎solo19年，抱歉了。 还有姜贞羽真的好有气质啊，胡玛尔那支舞好好看啊，沙漠之雕那段真的笑的我肚子疼， 另外我真的好喜欢国风唱腔，这次创造营有实力的妹妹真的好多啊。 以上所有谨代表个人观点。

[@erichuang6348]

她跟高比的是vocal

[@kg_girl]

说了这么多 我同意你最后一句话 只代表你个人观点

[@牛牛当自强]

关键是姚的声线也好听，现场学员也都说她唱功很强，不仅仅是因为原创

[@유명천작]

凭什么要按着你的想法选呢？

[@erichuang6348]

@@유명천작 你没看到最后一句话吗？

[@siewmuimui]

a 4 hour episode debut, my back is hurting now lol anyhow i am so feeling those 3 girls at the end, vocal talent is amazing. looking forward to the ballerina! totally remember her from another show.

[@pazichi]

This discourse of her insecurity hit me so hard in my heart, I let it out my tears, and they left my eyes, my feelings are in the floor, because I- I feel the same thing, I crying now. Yes, I want to do my dreams, but I'm a shy girl.

[@tthe1620]

艾特毛毛，为啥《我要变好看》令你感动， 是因为你有一首《如果有一天我变得很有钱》！ 😂😂！！

[@melzay...514]

Sometimes, you need a loud voice to help wake up and I believe that's what Tao played a role in. If you are someone on the show, then no matter what the circumstances, you must try your best to stand out so that viewers can remember you. Doesn't matter if you are scared or shy, if you want to be someone on stage, you have to go up and face the fears.

[@yengliberoconnor8181]

"You can be confused. But you don't have to be sad." Lmfaooo this made my day.

[@ggg9814]

姚慧真天然美聲，完全是'不求造作，只做創作'，唱歌自然真誠真心感動人心，比那些只懂沒感情沒感覺的所謂歌藝超級很多；如此原創聲色藝美女，絕對是別樹一格，比那些驕扭造作的大熱門，簡直是天与地的分別，SOLO真的很適合她，若有實力公司培養必有佳績。