Everything Wrong With Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows

[@gailcbull]

19 seconds in and you've already sinned 2 things that faithful adaptations from the source material: Watson narrating the stories and Watson writing and publishing books based on Holmes' cases. In the stories, Holmes often criticizes Watson's "florid, romantic" versions of what he thinks should be written as scientific studies on investigative techniques.

[@faridadianpuspitadewi2547]

agreed. Watson narrating the stories in the beginning of the movie is the same as the books where it was Watson who told all the Holmes' stories

[@Thalon2]

You know full well that background material does not count for sinning...

[@gailcbull]

@@Thalon2 If he can sin films based on his own rules, then I can sin his sinning videos based on my own rules. And as both a reader and a film fan, I say that sinning a film for a book-accurate adaptation choice is a sin. *ding*

[@bellaitclopru9958]

@@gailcbull I know I'm late to the conversation but that was a strong and well founded retort, I approve.

[@lorenzovitali9385]

@@gailcbull I agree with you

[@maxman1602]

Moriarty dies in the Holmes canon, in _The Final Problem,_ which was also his first appearance. He's just such a memorable villain, featured in so many adaptations and parodies, fans forget he was only in one story and died at the end.

[@crossfirehunter3652]

A book was made about Moriarty literary a few years ago in the same format as a classical Holmes book they even gave him an evil Watson(the colonel)

[@De-Nigma]

Who is also in one of the stories: The Empty House, where he brings Holmes back, the villain and part of the reason he's been in hiding pretending to be dead is the Colonel, who'd been watching them from the cliff, so he knew what had happened between Holmes and Moriarty.

[@Miyanoai14]

They also forget Irene Adler was also in only one story and honestly not as important as almost every adaptation makes her out to be. Though I actually liked her in these films so I'm annoyed they killed her off (at least Mary was pretty cool)

[@pinkies26k]

Miyanoai14 but she's mentioned many times in few other chapters. That's why she's memorable since Sherlock isn't fond of any other female except her. She's one of the many few that can outwit him. I dare say she's the only *female* that outwitted him

[@chrisrubenstahl2046]

Moriarty is alluded to in the last Holmes novel, The Valley of Fear (set chronologically before The Final Problem), as well as a few other stories. In most of those, Holmes either laments that there's no one of Moriarty's caliber still running around, or mocking the pretenders to his throne.

[@PinkiTadinki]

"Robert Downey Junior's Sherlock Holmes is basically Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow without the..." *Rum* , Jeremy. Without the rum.

[@SirParanoidAndroid]

PinkiTadinki his replacement for rhum is opium

[@topbreak38]

Generic Account number 2397012 and every other substance he can find. The breathing device was introduced because Sherlock was doing whippits.

[@keybord1005]

Are you saying the rum is gone?

[@filimongalogavros5301]

You are correct . . .

[@DeeFightingDreamer]

Without the jar of dirt.

[@clueless2001]

that "RDJ will be doing Iron Man for the rest of his life" comment only lasted a little over a year. *ding*

[@mint7442]

Vanguard539 hahhahahah I want to cry but I cannot help but laugh

[@ilikecurry2345]

That means yes more Holmes then, unless he cameos in Guardians of the Galaxy 3 in the soul world scene.

[@magicamadeye]

this guy would be great as cinema sins *reverse ding*

[@tmrevenge]

Once he runs out of money and marvel films start sucking even more. He will be back

[@a1001ku]

I'm the 420th like, bruh!!!

[@staffy888]

Ooh, I can't wait until he takes sins off for the badass slow mo cannon scene! -oh...

[@theveryworstluck1894]

cannon*

[@5CBR600RR]

TheVeryWorstLuck no he’s saying the film was recorded using a canon camera. 😏

[@alfredwang7607]

ikr

[@PRdeSO]

The part that was shot by Gavin Free?

[@staffy888]

@@PRdeSO Ye

[@alphaxtitania5597]

I actually really liked the final fist fight between Sherlock and Moriarty. The way Moriarty interjected into Sherlock's usual fight prediction, and then the two of them casually conversing on how the fight would play out was chilling.

[@samuelmurrill7438]

I don't care, I want a third one. These movies were great!

[@AlexM-up9tn]

Samuel Murrill third one? There’s only 1

[@JackCaz]

There's 2. A Game of Shadows (this vid) is the second one.

[@Ruffian_Xion]

A film being sinned does not reflect on its greatness (or otherwise). 'No film is without sin'

[@samuelmurrill7438]

Unconventional Jack I dont even think Jeremey realizes this is the second one lol

[@shanedenton214]

Samuel Murrill fuck you

[@Raider768]

"And coca leaves." "Throw in a little cocaine..." Dude. Where do you think cocaine comes from? What do you think they were implying?

[@MichaelDelvalle-nt4gp]

lol

[@max84678]

thats a sin right there XD everyone Sherlock reader knows Holmes is into coke XD

[@philip0320]

But cocaine comes from cocA leaves not coco

[@DonEBrooke32]

he was obviously thinking cocoa, (a cocoa bean tree has edible leaves does it not? O_o)

[@mikepastor.k6233]

Caffeine is cocaine's little red haired stepson

[@jweezyyy]

Rdj kills every role he takes on, he’s such a master at acting, he really knows how to define a character to set the standard, it’s impressive

[@lenakan8990]

When you said "kills" I thought you meant it in a negative way, phewww heh

[@denverarnold6210]

Dr. Dolittle

[@Nicksonian]

Here too, thought “kills” was meant to be negative. RDJ does kill every roll he’s in to the extent that the various roles should be put out of our misery. Ya, RDJ has had occasional flashes of talent, but as Sherlock Holmes, he plays an abysmal part in an abysmal production.

[@bonzopippinpaddleopsicopolis]

@@Nicksonian No

[@uriamudeltoro5075]

He shall forever and always be known as Sir Tony Stark (assuming at some point the character, at the least, IS/HAS BEEN KNIGHTED)

[@kalieffoster4607]

You know you love a movie, when none of the complaints mean anything to you. 😀😀🤣😂

[@bakerzane3055]

Agreed

[@leogronung3146]

Yeah, but this movie has so maaany mistakes. The „german speaking“ parts are completely wrong pronounced and the guns weren’t invented yet. Also Heilbronn never was a important city. There wasn’t even a weapon factory.

[@hydrangeas_lover]

​@@leogronung3146it's still a movie. They don't always get it right. Most of the continuity issues are sacrificed to elevate the movie. No movie is perfect my guy

[@ericsbuds]

I love the music at the peace summit. It starts all normal, but slowly goes off key as shit starts to hit the fan. Other movies have probably done that, but the way its pulled off here really works.

[@shanedenton214]

ericsbuds fuck you

[@lupecorrea3970]

Shane Denton no fuck you

[@rimurutempest4945]

Emma J. Quinn He’s too dumb to know how to do that.

[@orangetd88]

Agreed.

[@LadyOnikara]

100 sins off of Stephen Fry being Stephen Fry. He will show up in a movie naked and just smile about doing it. Don't ever change, dude!

[@zeusathena26]

I won't complain if he changes his clothes. We don't need to see his Fry. 😂🤣

[@horrorjunky4life50]

If only older women were allowed to get away with that as well...

[@zeusathena26]

@@horrorjunky4life50 I can't remember the title. But about 15 years ago Kathy Bates did a movie, where she get in a hot tub butt naked. She was middle aged at that time

[@opheliaismyname9180]

And Jude Law is in this one as well! Reunion for unhealthy as all hell (yes, I know they were real people, my point stands) couple Oscar and Bosie

[@avaatkisson9139]

I love how Jeremy is outraged at how good Holmes is at observing and predicting, or how much planning it would take for Moriarty to ensure that Holmes would fuck up and find the chess piece at the opera. But we all think the same things when we watch a CinemaSins video. Jeremy I'm sinning you for being one of the very people you complain about in this movie, because no one else would read the articles in a newspaper in a movie to discover if they're copy and pasted except for you and Sherlock

[@InVinoVeratas]

I don’t care, I love Sherlock Holmes.

[@someguy1576]

Bailey Green kzbin.info/www/bejne/p5-3i5WQrJZ9hrM This will defend Holmes in the first movie

[@606danco]

And watson everybody forget watson no shit sherlock nooo its watson now

[@seraphendipity]

So does cinema sins. Critique doesnt mean hate.

[@duillys]

THIS IS NOT SHERLOCK HOLMES! READ THE BOOKS!

[@imiguifurr]

@@seraphendipity this is not critique, dumbass... It's called whining... It is funny and gets views, but it should not be taken seriously or as an actual "critique"

[@botslayer27]

15:08 I think the point of some of the detail such as the breathing machine is to give the viewer the chance to remember details like Sherlock does. Which is why they also always show details like in the cake scene

[@karkatvantas9557]

Jeremy for fuck's sake, the assassin was there to kill Sim, not Holmes. Moriarty had no idea Holmes was there.

[@haydenlindquist7006]

"Not a good idea to kill off one of Sherlock's most popular villains." You just sinned Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

[@Uryel99]

And sinning Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is worth a hundred sins by itself.

[@jliller]

"You just sinned Sir Arthur Conan Doyle." Doyle fell for the Cottingley Fairies Hoax. He's got at least 1 sin right there. Also: Killing off a character because you're tired of writing him? +1 sin. Then retconing his death due to fan backlash? +5 sins. Thus probably inspiring countless comic book writers to do the same? +10 sins. If proven rather than suspected then +100 sins instead.

[@dman1456]

jliller how does it make sense to continue something you’re tired of if not for the people who keep you employed and love your work? Why would you keep writing a book you’re tired of writing? The biggest authors have now been using simple plot maps to churn out crap because they don’t care anymore about the story.

[@sgartner]

@Drake medinger Or simply turning their best series over to other authors and getting paid only for putting their name on the book in big capital letters.

[@jliller]

"Why would you keep writing a book you’re tired of writing?" Doyle could have simply stopped writing, despite the pleas from eager fans. That would have been fine. He didn't need to kill of Holmes. Killing off a main character for a good reason is fine, but killing them off because you're tired of writing them or just can't thing of anything interesting to with them is lame, especially because later you end up retconning their death when you've got new ideas for the character.

[@adamvialpando106]

9:50 Well there is a chance that the wouldn't have killed him. So they shot him to make sure he was dead and used the bomb to disguise the fact that he was targeted specifically. It's plainly explained in the movie.

[@LHRStormKeeper]

You forgot a key rule of Hollywood, though. There's no such thing as overkill.

[@Latinofire202]

It doesn't matter if it's explained. He'll still sin it. Does it all the time.

[@adamvialpando106]

Latinofire202 True. Heck if thw movie hadn't done ir he probably would have sinned it for not being thorough enough. He does that too.

[@someguy1576]

Adam Vialpando That’s a valid point

[@markotark]

12:13 "Oh no, not Marko! His sin was being too unimportant to this story." Amazing how one sentence can describe my whole life... Oh well.

[@barringtonjohnson2925]

"There are so many white dudes with beards in this movie all of them look alike" (in your voice) That's Racist.

[@topbreak38]

Barrington Johnson *ding*

[@NobleVI_343]

Nah, it's okay when it's wypipo

[@whyjay9959]

Turkeys were brought to the old world in the 16th century, and are commonly raised for food. They're not an exotic animal.

[@TheScholesie09]

Right, Norfolk in the UK is like, the turkey capital of the world.

[@angelofmalice0]

+1 sin

[@arkenthusiast]

I thought Ankara was the Turkey capital of the world

[@ComUnSas]

If turkeys are an out of time and place sin because they originated in America, then so is the tobacco in Holmes' pipe

[@Milamberinx]

@@ComUnSas yep, and the peanuts in the basket next to Rachel McAdams's stolen beans.

[@StephanieRoestel]

I'm kinda mad he didn't write a sin about Iron Man kissing Doctor Strange's girlfriend.

[@alexiz0013]

Lol

[@filimongalogavros5301]

So Sherlock Holmes is Iron Man without the superpowers . . .

[@WulfysGamingTidbits]

Two Sherlocks one Adler

[@asharkthatstubbeditstoe8843]

Sin a movie, that’s okay. Sin a TURKEY?!? You sir, have gone too far!

[@rafaelalodio5116]

If it was a goose or a chicken I would understand, but a turkey! What an a*hole.

[@nicktrains2234]

its outrageous!

[@dakoach4931]

he is sinning a turkey deal with it... his words not mine

[@stevenspiel]

He had to sin the turkey so the president could pardon it

[@ethanredding9977]

No turkey is without sin.

[@gunsnwheels9214]

Aw I hate you didn't remove a sin for ANY part. The first one is one of my favorites of all time. They're just so good. "They're intellectual equals so it ends in a fist fight." Yet it was stated that Moriarty was a prestigious boxer during college or something *ding*

[@travishimebaugh8381]

For the record: -Simza is cleverly portrayed as being vaguely-maybe-but-maybe-not supernatural; Holmes' observation and prediction talents are completely useless where she's concerned. She tries to help Holmes throughout his fight with the Cossack but he's utterly incapable of finding ways to take advantage of her "help" -The use of the machine gun on the train, as well as the bomb near the opera house, is perfectly accounted for: Moriarty uses fake anarchist attacks to hide his smaller crimes, to divert attention away from himself and exacerbate global tensions for his endgame. Much of his scheme is set up well in advance. -Watson-being-a-bumbling-idiot cliche is averted.

[@topic260]

Good Boxer, great swordsman and proficient at singlestick, despite his great age. - Valley of Fear

[@ConnorNotyerbidness]

AND theres the fact that the final encounter in the books with moriarty also came down to a fist fight.

[@lenakan8990]

"Ah, there's the Kembridge college boxer" or something XD

[@sarahmur7701]

either way you should see him in a crown.

[@katherinewren9906]

Gotta say, I'm disappointed, Jeremy. Hans Zimmer doesn't reuse his scores, other composers steal them. Pirates of the Caribbean was scored by Klaus Badelt. This is the second time you've made a joke like this and been wrong XD

[@bakerzane3055]

@Dr retardo He is jewish? Im living under a rock.

[@kl_kruemel]

Also Sherlock uses a C96 semi-automatic pistol which wasn't even produced before 1896 AND the german flag is the one of the Republic (1919-1933) and not the one of the Kaiserreich Why don't you see these (real) sins anymore?

[@DemBigOlEyes]

Because he's too busy pandering to the crowd who are simply here to see him diss a movie, regardless of whether it made sense.

[@jennyms1998]

all the bad plots and twodimensional characters have melted his brain

[@ComUnSas]

'Why don't you see these (real) sins anymore?' A reasonable question. I think he's getting bored.

[@MrR1ma]

They are really bad at firearms and weapons of war sins. Calling torpedoes missles for example

[@templar684]

Why put effort when you can make a simple video dissing everything on the nose and still get a lot of views.

[@TacComControl]

American Turkeys were already commonplace throughout Europe by the mid 1500s thanks to a man by the name of William Strickland, who was so beloved for his introduction of the turkey to Europe that his award of arms involved the blazon of a turkeyfowl.

[@blupunk01]

True they were commonplace, however... www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-humber-20672110 Strickland is said to have continued in the turkey trade and is reputed to have made so much money that he was able to build a stately home in Boynton, near Bridlington, East Yorkshire. The current owner of Boynton Hall is Richard Marriott, a descendant of Strickland. "Unfortunately, there is no real proof that he was the original man who brought the turkey into England," he said. "He is reputed to have sailed with one of the Cabots out of Bristol, but unfortunately we cannot make the facts fit the story. "I am sure there must be something there which links him more positively with the story of the turkey but it is very, very difficult to pin down a provable historical fact." Strickland seemed keen to promote the story, adopting the turkey as the family crest in 1550.

[@michaelcooper4245]

I was willing to forgive this movie for all of its sins because of the waterfall "battle" was a very nice nod to the source. BUT THAT WATERFALL MAKES NO SENSE. Thanks Cinema Sins.

[@Judiomon]

I

[@shanedenton214]

Michael Cooper fuck you

[@lupecorrea3970]

Shane Denton no fuck you

[@michaelcooper4245]

We are all fucked on this blessed day

[@ebilalo]

Shane Denton i like how i fined you replied on everyones comments. cool.

[@RellyDubb]

7:06 That isn't a box of grenades, it's a sack of grenades. I'm giving this video a sin Oh, how the tables have turned

[@JYMAHJAMES]

5:33 don't even lie, you'd ADD 100 sins if that happened

[@judeannethecandorchannel2153]

J^M^ (JAMA?) Probably Do you know where Julia Louis-Dreyfus surrendered by greenery comes from? I can't find. :(

[@captainjackknife5817]

Just a heads up, RDJ confirmed recently that Sherlock Holmes 3 is scheduled to begin shooting later this year. So, yet one more film to be sinned in the future.....

[@alphasierra.]

jay rambo Oh, come on.. Nobody wants that!

[@Seygem]

@Alpha Sierra and that's where you're wrong, kiddo

[@captainjackknife5817]

Alpha Sierra I would also be interested in another installment, these movies are like fun and awesomeness had a baby and hired humor as a babysitter.

[@KhanMann66]

Alpha Sierra You don't want it. I do.

[@simplebidnessman]

Alpha Sierra I do. I like these movies

[@JoshC701]

The close ups on the newspaper contain names of characters from the 'Blue Carbuncle' Conan Doyle story... that's impressive detail

[@TheJrbdog]

The one crime that Moriarty definitely didn't have anything to do with lol

[@IronCavalier]

“There are so many white dudes with beards in this movie, They all look alike.” That’s racist! Ding!

[@matohibiki]

You mean Beardist. Ding!

[@dman1456]

matohibiki you’re both ist-ist Ding!

[@DeeFightingDreamer]

Me: *sees the title* Me: "Okay, do not get angry because you love RDJ more than what is considered healthy. Just don't. It's okay for people to not like a movie. You're gonna be fine as long as the video doesn't comment on Rob."

[@christianvennemann9008]

14:10 "It's so overt, it's covert."

[@andjamwar]

Turkeys first arrived in the UK in the 1500s and were mass farmed very soon after. That Sin should be retracted.

[@eanaz79]

Jessica Knapman Mexico is in North America.

[@sgartner]

gind?

[@MercAran]

First, thank you for this one; after sinning the first one, I'd been waiting for you to tackle A Game of Shadows. Second, "Oh no, not Marko! His sin was being too unimportant to this story." That one made me bust a gut, so doubly thank you for that! You guys are the best

[@Uryel99]

There is actually nothing wrong in the fight scene and subsequent death of Moriarty, and Sherlock faking his own death, IF you know the source material. Truth is, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was a bit fed up with writting Sherlock Holmes' stories, so he killed him during a fight with Moriarty, where they both fell off a cliff. Later, du to the pression of the readers, he had to find a way to bring Sherlock back to write more stories. Nothing wrong either with the secret room. Sherlock has demonstrated many times that kind of observation skills in the books. Shit, even I demonstrated that kind of observation skills on a few occasions, it's not THAT amazing. However, the incorrect flag and time-displaced pistol were not sinned, the turkey was sinned despited it being commonly found in Europe for about 2 centuries before the story's time... Get your shit together, Cinemasins ! I know you're nitpicking assholes, but you used to nitpick about relevant things, while this is just lazy.

[@codelad1923]

I'll never fully enjoy a Sherlock TV show or movie. In the books you get details and logical thought processes. In the movies it's just said that they made some observation or deduction. In the books the real magic for me is the explnation and the fact that if I reread I realize I could've made the same deductions myself in some cases.

[@Miyanoai14]

Sadly most people find that boring so they have to remove it from cinema to keep it interesting for the masses. They added a ton of unnecessary action scenes in Murder on the Orient Express as well. I didn't mind it in these movies too much but I would have liked the addition of the explanations as well.

[@CasualNotice]

To be fair, Agatha Christie would have been fine with adding action to Orient Express. She hated writing Hercule Poirot, and considered him a pompous ass.

[@Kirill17]

The books and or sources other than the movie don't fucking matter

[@EmeraldEmsiron]

Yeah! We need more scenes that happen not to contain lapdances!

[@nyotaakito4979]

Although I love this movie I completely felt the sin with the twins and your confusion about them. I was equally confused when they mentioned them and acted like they were something the audience was supposed to recognize xD

[@gm2407]

Movie opens with RDJ playing a dude disguised as another Dude.

[@1Okoya1]

someone might have mentioned this before but.......you do realize that the eternal rivalry between Holmes and Moriarty boiled down to a fist fight on a cliff in the original text as well right?

[@TimTE01]

Yeah, but in his first appearance?

[@sub-zero6924]

thats how it worked in the original text as well. In his first appearance he and Holmes fought and fell off seemingly dying. (The author was trying to kill of Holmes and be done with the story, fan outrage brought him back.)

[@ComUnSas]

Yup, Moriarty appeared in just one of the original 60 short stories and novels. He was created as Holmes' ultimate foe to kill Holmes off, not a recurring character.

[@Aaron-zt5ee]

I'm glad someone brought that up. That scene was probably the most Sherlock Holmes moment of both films.

[@hungriestnunu7449]

Which Holmes also lost and basically had to do exactly what was done in the movie. Grab Moriarty and off they both go

[@brentage5000]

8:57 also, the cast of Glee, the Phantom of the Opera, and Thomas and Martha Wayne

[@DogNamedWatson]

Brent Dreher and any theatre kid ever

[@windsfiend]

The (presumed) death of Moriarty is supposed to be a reference of how he dies in the book. Aldoit s a good thing if they stop this franchise because Moriarty was supposed to be the last trial for Holmes as wanted by his author ... until his fans push doyle to write stories again. Yeah, fans could be huge d*ck even in 1903 :/

[@biohazard724]

windsfiend Sherlock Holmes was supposed to end at the Frieza saga

[@BlackDog97]

"The Turkey is being sinned, deal with it!" ... I laughed too hard

[@Jermungus115]

When yer one didn't show up for Sherlock's date I felt really sorry for him, you could definitely see that his heart was broken.

[@francisxes8471]

It was independent reading time today in class and I got this notification as I was reading the complete collection of Sherlock Holmes.

[@alexiz0013]

Haha, nice

[@宋庆礼]

That'S not fair

[@elithesia781]

No matter what, I will always love this movie.

[@blondbraid7986]

There's really no mystery solving worth mentioning in this movie, but I did like the action scenes and the main characters. My only gripe width it is that they killed off Irene Adler just to replace her with Noomi Rapace, who's character didn't do anything memorable and was only there to replace Irene Adler.

[@qwertyuiopzxcfgh]

"he's on a diet of caffeine, tobacco and coca leaves" "Throw in a little cocaine and..." You do know that cocaine is made from coca leaves right?

[@BulletTooth504]

They didn't think through their joke very well. The two movies didn't mention the word "cocaine", but it's pretty clear that Holmes is supposed to be using the stuff. Coca leaves in this film, something that is used for eye surgeries (cocaine hydrochloride) in the previous. Cinemasins should've of just said "Sounds like the Mickey Rourke meal plan."

[@matohibiki]

Coca leaves when cooked to be caramelized are eaten in south america to help ward off altitude sickness, and can make you quite hyper when too many are consumed. I mean, I wouldn't put it past Holmes to try making his own version of coke, but I believe the general idea in the film was that Holmes was scoffing down every kind of (non-drug, caffine notwithstanding) stimulant he could get his hands on.

[@JynessaSwann]

Yup, same thought here

[@MrDonitel]

Biggest Sin: The fisherman and the fish example. Sherlock put the fisherman and fish drawing in the notebook AFTER Moriarty made the analogy during the torture scene just so Sherlock could instantly travel back in time and make those drawings to be revealed in the ending scene. Genius! NOT!

[@theactualbajmahal833]

Actually though, the fishing references in the torture scene are there because of the Shubert piece playing on the phonograph and that was the same piece playing back in London, in Moriarty's study, when "the game" first began. Holmes made that little animation as a response to the London meeting, not the later torture.

[@MichaelDelvalle-nt4gp]

@@theactualbajmahal833 nice catch

[@gunsnwheels9214]

I need a third one. I enjoyed this representation more than Cumberbatches and that's saying a lot because Sherlock is awesome.

[@ronanmccutchon2364]

Well it’s happening!

[@bakerzane3055]

@@ronanmccutchon2364 wait actually?

[@ronanmccutchon2364]

@Miles Upshur I think so, coming out 2021

[@Klm49]

I loved them both equally and want any more of Cumberbund or Downey Jr as Holmes that the studios want to make!!

[@coralineparmentierworldpianist]

"19th Century Beatdown music"?!?Jeremy, what are you talking about ? The black dude is whistling Mozart's Little Night Music (1787) ...

[@arnonymus9859]

Thanx for knowing and mentioning that in the name of what´s left of Austria. 💋

[@mykodibear17]

The music isn't from the 19th century, but that's when this story takes place.

[@mons3020]

buuuuut Mozart's Little Night Music was inspired by the music he heard in the bars at night. So it could easily be an adaption of a beatdown tune, depending on the bar lol

[@shanedenton214]

Coraline Parmentier - Pianist for Peace fuck you

[@lupecorrea3970]

Shane Denton piss of shit

[@johnnorris3528]

Turkeys were brought to Europe by the Spanish in the 1500s, and were introduced in England not long after. They were a common sight on English farms long before the time this movie is set in. The turkey is not a sin.

[@uncomfortablecat]

It's been 2 years! Thank you Cinemasins. I was waiting for this one.

[@leviathan7751]

the movie is 7 years old....not sure what you mean by two

[@seijitheicedrake9487]

Leviathan 77 the last movie was sinned in 2016

[@kingsleysmith1104]

I know right I was looking for it when I watched the first movie I was so angry it hadn't been made

[@uncomfortablecat]

Leviathan 77 Sure. Cinemasins first made the first Sherlock Holmes movie 2 years ago.

[@InVinoVeratas]

Shouldn’t Benedict Cumberbatch want to wait for CinemaSins to do a video on Sherlock? You’re setting yourself up to fail!

[@elishaduggan997]

That moment when you realise that the 2 Sherlock Holmes (Downey Jr and Cumberbatch) were involved (or you can say in a relationship) with Irene Adler.

[@brigadier-tc8565]

I get the joke, but there are 3 Sherlock Holmes's currently Holmes-ing. Cumberbatch, Downey and Johnny Lee Miller, in the American show Elementary, which is actually pretty good

[@rpsyco]

And when the 2 Sherlock Holmes teamed up to fight Thanos to save the universe....without a single Sherlock Holmes reference...

[@NathanielKempson]

Actually i think there WAS a reference to it. Do you concour...I think.

[@li-limandragon9287]

I want a third one of these movies and I want Benedict Cumberbatch to play the villain.

[@metaphoricalparachute9130]

i love the sherlock holmes cinematic universe

[@ashrafbadreddine9470]

"To the Opera. that is a battle cry will rally only Frasier, his brother Niles..." this is the best commentary loool

[@Apankou]

One of the most stupid things about this film is the way they depict the travel route from Paris to Germany. As a German, I can tell you, to see mountains like this you would choose a route that's equivalent to going from LA to Santa Fe first in order to get to San Francisco, borrowing from a metaphor from your first Sherlock Holmes sins video.

[@EeveeRealSenpai]

Ultra Instinct Sherlock Holmes

[@orlando3185]

Eevee RealSenpai lmao

[@MDG-mykys]

lol, even though that's the opposite of instinct

[@mmraf1]

nah

[@mmraf1]

def Ultra Instinct, were just seeing it how Son Goku sees it against Jiren

[@mmraf1]

Jus cuz Whis said something doesnt mean this isnt what Goku is seeing. Dont think too hard about it 😂😂😂😂

[@EeveeRealSenpai]

For a second I thought it said Sherlock Gnomes

[@J4WBR34K4]

Eevee RealSenpai Sounds like an epic cross over with Sherlock and Gnomeo

[@mmraf1]

yeah there is a new movie called exactly that

[@J4WBR34K4]

Mark Rafla holy shit! i know what im watching tonight

[@MAGAMAN]

I was going to say "don't give them any more dumb ideas", then I remembered there is already a movie called that.

[@coltonallgire1135]

MAGA MAN If they want more dumb ideas, they should just watch the Trump presidency

[@CasualNotice]

I wasn't really paying attention when I watched this film, but, from the EWW, it seems like Noomi Rapace has exactly two scenes where she's useful, and the rest of the time she spends sitting close to RDJ and being pretty, like a parrot, or Rob Lowe.

[@rohitmurthy9514]

There were multiple places you could've taken sins off, you didn't even take one off!

[@Zach-Fetters]

I hope you found the strength to move on from this travesty

[@juuuune]

@@Zach-Fetters it has only been 10 months, give him 2 more and he should be ok

[@Burritoes]

It's actually called Sherlock Gnomes

[@asb81689]

italkcrab Uhh no...... It's Sherlock Gnomes. Don't you go out and watch movies?!?

[@shanedenton214]

ChickenTon Bwak fuck you

[@lupecorrea3970]

Shane Denton no fuck u

[@qiye3304]

ChickenTon Bwak no shit sherlock

[@insaknighty]

Shane Denton stop saying that to everyone.

[@Inerrant1]

I was waiting for the 'Enemy at the Gates' reference and was not disappointed.

[@vuppet5684]

What about Sherlock GNOMES?

[@颜健晖]

Vsauce Puppet *oh yea...*

[@颜健晖]

Vsauce Puppet what about *Shitty Norms* ?

[@Dubstone]

They did it 2 days ago

[@WolfArtist-zc9nf]

Dubstone that was gnomeo and Juliet lol

[@WolfArtist-zc9nf]

Vsauce Puppet he can't do it until it comes out on DVD

[@ZebbeCali]

Gotta give it to you, Jeremy; the last clip of Jude waking up at the wedding spliced with the friends clip is priceless.

[@Promthanius]

A Prestige reference! All is forgiven for that golden reference.

[@ikelos8190]

Hearing RDJ talking in a british accent is really uncomfortable

[@darkecofreak23]

Stephen Fry is ALWAYS a win!

[@JohnyG29]

darkecofreak23 God no.

[@stefano5776]

actually when holmes is hung with the hook the song is by Schubert and is called the trout

[@arjundahiya5485]

sherlock:* breathes* thats a sin, also hes breathing too fast might add a sin for that too

[@tylerpike1625]

"I expect the C.L.I.T. will come down hard." Died. I wager that far too few people picked up on that reference.

[@dudepool7530]

I AM THE C.L.I.T. COMMANDER!!!

[@tylersmith-xi4ct]

That movie was so damn funny lmao

[@jonnysupreme]

Captain America voice: I understood that reference

[@thehutch7728]

Don Song it stands for Coalition for the Liberation of Itinerant Tree-Dwellers

[@tuvyamaeir4684]

Still a better Sherlock than Elementary

[@DenniWintyr]

Admittedly, going over the falls in a fist fight with Moriarty is a direct lift from Doyle's original stories

[@Agk3los]

RDJ's Sherlock Holmes is basically Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow without all the eye make up, annoying mannerisms, and varying levels of acting like a kid who has never had alcohol trying to act drunk.

[@zafjaf]

Btw they announced a third film in this series

[@metaphoricalparachute9130]

ik im so excited

[@luckyinugirl1816]

I thought they weren't doing another because of the strain it puts on Robert Downey Jr.

[@beyzayildirim9608]

luckyinugirl they announced a third movie when A Game Of Shadows came out. It’s just that they weren’t able to shoot it yet because of RDJ’s busy schedule and because they had trouble figuring out a satisfying plot that would do the previous movies (and the cliffhanger) justice and not taint their Sherlock Holmes franchise. The third movie is set to release in December 2021 so they’ll probably already start the production this year. In that case RDJ will be 55/56 years old during the shooting, which is a somewhat old age but I don’t think it would exhaust him too much. After all he’s done a lot of his Iron Man/Sherlock Holmes stunts thus far and he’s regularly practiced Martial Arts for about 20 years now so it’s save to say he probably stayed fit enough to portray such a physical role despite his age.

[@markluni4234]

@@beyzayildirim9608 As long as Disney isn't involved, it should be ok.

[@asskicker5201]

ive been following you a long time Jeremy. i hope to one day see a movie, written, directed, and produced by you. you spot so many problems with scripts, sets, and everything. I can only assume if you made a movie it would be a perfect masterpiece with no errors in continuity, incorrect accents, no cliches, no fist fights, no Michael Bay explosions, etc. One day.

[@cynthiaclark5935]

Ass Kicker yeah... no

[@lurchadams2400]

@@cynthiaclark5935 sounds like a very boring movie that no one will talk about

[@dylan_stradley]

@15:22 Sherlock Holmes 3 is set to begin filming in late 2018

[@martinnaranjo3185]

Jeez Jeremy, you really don't like these movies I think they give the character a well deserved twist by exploring his mentioned physical feats that were actually hinted in the novels. After so many damn iterations of the character throughout the years this is a welcomed change. Plus, the cast's chemistry and the antagonist is freakin awesome.

[@wierdalien1]

Martin Naranjo Jeremy is now a cynical old bastard in need of readjustment

[@jossecoupe446]

Yup, this is one of my favourite films

[@Libellulaire]

It's irrelevant to the novels. The movies are pretty ridiculous... Sherlock is basically turned into a super human. And actually even if you take into account the novels, those movies are still pretty bad and ridiculous.

[@ComUnSas]

Most of the 'sins' were lame and unfunny. Maybe he's getting bored of this format?

[@wierdalien1]

Bubbling Waffle the novels show him to be a super man anyway. What this does better than the tv show is making sherlock actually care about watson.

[@DailyBrief]

I'll be sad if there's no Great Mouse Detective reference. *edit* *I'm sad*

[@OmniscientWarrior]

Maybe if they fought on a clock.

[@DailyBrief]

OmniscientWarrior Nope, should've played the song Raitgan does, "Goodbye So Soon", at 11:18

[@explosiveturtle266]

Answer to all your how did he do that sins/questions: He's Sherlock Holmes.

[@Catseye189]

"To the opera!" And kudos to having the two male leads dance together.

[@NoHandle44]

16:42 Would have been funnier if they used the clip from Mulan where Mushu says, "I LIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVE!"

[@michellecurry1664]

you all know he's getting set up to destroy Sherlock Gnomes

[@bladersmosh]

I thought it was going to be Murder on the Orient Express for this weeks mystery sins.

[@tmptjohn88]

Muppet Christmas carol had me dying 🤣🤣

[@ShawnsterVideos]

"AH! Stephen's fry!" , 8:01 DING!

[@jimbojankens9491]

I am the C.L.I.T. commander!

[@eetuhalmela9361]

i literally today thought when will they make this

[@Redflametrow]

That's almost as unbelievable as half of these deductions.

[@fabooshka]

Redflametrow still less coincidental than the plot though

[@Lgs260495]

me too

[@shanedenton214]

Black Hider fuck you

[@lupecorrea3970]

Shane Denton no fuck you

[@christianmaennchen42]

Everything wrong with the wolf of wall street

[@D.A.A.321]

2:46 „Mickey Rourke meal plan“ 😂

[@CeltycSparrow]

According to IMDB, there is a Sherlock Holmes 3 in the works. So there.

[@Kains_Gaming_Channel]

Everything wrong with PREDATOR!

[@TheJrbdog]

Hollywood preemptively makes a movie about Harvey Weinstein *ding*

[@sharilshahed6106]

TheJrbdog damn

[@lewis213b7]

Kain VS Predator yes

[@InVinoVeratas]

You mean, “Nothing wrong with Predator”, right?

[@laxeystu8096]

Yes please

Dude, you are ruining all of my favourite movies!! Never stop doing it.

[@benhaley1143]

RDJ's Sherlock Holmes is Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow, but without an Oscar Nom

[@GrimAnglo]

I adore the reference at 8:50 to The Talented Mr Ripley. So well thought out for a minor point.

[@stephaniereynolds6921]

Oh my God I love the C.L.I.T. Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back reference. You never cease to impress me Jeremy!

[@SamuelSturtridge]

I suggest you recount the sins of... The ORIGINAL Indiana Jones Trilogy!

[@zedstreams4765]

Zack Snydering in other movies is a sin. But when its Zack Snyder's Zack Snydering in Wonder Woman, its worth taking a sin off. I guess you gotta be biased, yo.

[@sharilshahed6106]

Zack Snyder didn't direct WW tho

[@Wh1stle_03]

Sharil Shahed I thought the first world war wasn't until 1914

[@hellowhoops]

Another sin taken off theres one in 2021

[@brennan7736]

16:14 Omg it was bugging me all night, its from Holy Grail when the French are debating whether to go out and take the trojan rabbit. It finally hit me here at work.

[@christianhaegler4817]

Sherluck? Aw come on guys, you could've done better with "Sheer Luck"! A digital Cookie for the one who gets this reference.