[CLEAN MR Removed] aespa - Supernova | Mnet Mcountdown 240516 MR제거

Mnet Mcountdown CLEAN MR제거 240516 aespa Supernova
'최초 공개' aespa - Supernova #엠카운트다운 EP.843 | Mnet 240516 방송
Link: • '최초 공개' aespa - Supern...
~ This stage may not be 100% live but please still enjoy! thanks for all the support!
#MRREMOVED #AESPA #SUPERNOVA #KARINA #WINTER #GISELLE #NINGNING #MNET #MCOUNTDOWN
Support/Request here! ( ･ω･)ﾉ: www.buymeacoff...

[@VIVAMRRemoved]

~ Hey everyone ( ･ω･)ﾉ, just fyi its possible this stage is not 100% live (which is common with first stage) but what do you think?! please enjoy and i hope you are enjoying aespa's comeback and their beautiful vocals - such icons! 💖

[@Fulla.]

How??

[@SalamSalam-gp2wp]

Im sure it's live

[@gsuznhdndn7996]

It's live just admit it

[@thisis38942]

You can hear their breathing bruh. Prerecorded versions don’t contain the breathes because they are edited out

[@shibal-ju4xv]

it’s live wdym

[@radhikanaik1751]

Karina is 100% singing live as per her bubble update

[@anastasyavie6236]

oh, that's good to hear, even in this recording, you can hear that it's live

[@airairairairairair]

You can even hear her breath, so yeah

[@rickay4549]

What was her bubble update?

[@radhikanaik1751]

@@rickay4549 She said that for Supernova's Mnet we are gonna sing live but Minjeong will not because of her health issues. Hope mys will support us and try to sing the hard fanchant 💙 I hope you all will enjoy the performance 💋 ~ Translated by me

[@rickay4549]

@@radhikanaik1751 thank you so much!

[@user-oi5du4ep4h]

Imagine being so good that people think your very evident live singing is lip sync😭😭

[@enamiasaace]

Yeah , they think SM and YG groups lipsync 😂

[@S___123]

Pre recordings are made to sound realistic they were very obviously lip syncing in this stage

[@aespa9725]

@@S___123 bffr karina said they were live singing in bubble. yall are always like this in every aespa stage, lets just accept the fact that aespa are good at live singing...

[@annabethyeung8512]

@@aespa9725where?? I can’t find her bubble posts anywhere 😢

[@S___123]

@@aespa9725 so? I never said they never sung live at all I said they were lip syncing which is true.. sounding robotic even during the faster paced parts isn’t physically possible

[@hrr5761]

후렴부르는 아이돌이 귀한세대라니... 이게 맞나싶다

[@whyyoulikehim]

요즘은 뭐만 하면 후렴에 사람이 못 낼 소리를 넣으니까요

[@ruv_you]

이렇게 잘하는데 어떻게 밟을거야 하이브ㅜㅜ 나원참 ㅜㅜㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-vb1zf2vn7o]

그러게요

[@user-jk6yr3jo3p]

밟으실 수수수수퍼노바

[@cheesecheer8073]

​@@user-jk6yr3jo3pㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@iiieeieei390]

aaaa~시혁 bang~

[@user-ff4uf5sg6g]

아니 근데 여긴 진짜 네명 다 라이브 잘함ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 메보롤 닝닝윈터 당연 잘하고 리보급 카리나가 진짜 탄탄하게 잘하고 래퍼인 지젤도 자기파트 잘함

[@user-vb1zf2vn7o]

카리나 참고로 보컬도 잘합니다

[@제로즈-0320]

리보급인 카리나가 노래 잘부르는데 불구하고 래퍼여서 서브보컬인게 신기함 ㅋㅋ

[@user-ff4uf5sg6g]

@@제로즈-0320 오피셜 포지션이 없어서 그럼ㅋㅋ 서브보컬이라고 한적 없고 카리나만 소개때 춤 노래 랩 다 하는 멤버라고 함

[@제로즈-0320]

@@user-ff4uf5sg6g 그렇긴함 근데 다른 멤이 노래를 잘불러서 거의다 서브보컬이라고 함 근데 난 에스파중에서 가장 라이브열심히 한다고 생각해서.. 요즘엔 포지션 없는게 트렌드?더라 다 잘해야되서? 다른 멤이 잘해서 뇌피셜로 다들 리보아님서보로 생각함

[@user-ff4uf5sg6g]

@@제로즈-0320 ㅇㅇ.. 근데 갠적으로 윈터닝닝이 메보라 카리나는 리보가 맞다고 봄 지젤이 서브보컬이고

[@user-kw1sp7sk2b]

마이크에 호흡 부딪히는 소리 다 나는데 그럼 라이브지 ㅋㅋㅋ 그냥 무대 볼 때부터 알았음

[@user-yf1tl2tq6o]

ㄹㅇ 라이브 다 티남

[@sm-bo4of]

ㄹㅇ 솔직히 블맘 데뷔무대부터 보면 라이븐데 너무 잘불러서 팬들만 캐치하는게 너무 아쉬움....

[@user-yw1zr6gi1h]

카리나가 엠넷에서 한 건 라이브라 말 함

[@sm-bo4of]

@@fnsjsowpo8c8c4dhwjw 일부러 립싱크 할때는 AR음향을 키우고 마이크 소리를 줄이기 때문에 거의 안들린다고 봐도 무방합니다.

[@sm-bo4of]

@@fnsjsowpo8c8c4dhwjw 그리고 라이브 ar녹음 하는건 녹음실에서 하는거라 숨소리 안들어가요

[@lol-wr5qd]

대박! 보통 후렴구는 잘 안 부르던데 에스파는 다 부르네

[@agnssnadint]

Yess bc this is aespa❤

[@user-jw4jc7vu2p]

조만간 앵콜 라이브 보여주면 백퍼 증명된다 ㅋㅋ 또 엄청 비교되겠네 ㅋㅋㅋ 개꿀잼 앵콜 라이브가 더 기대되는거 처음~

[@uusidvkakk]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@곽나연-h9n]

죄송한데 찐따같으세요

[@honeystarxx]

투표 해주라 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 다음주 슈퍼노바 1위 가즈아

[@anastasyavie6236]

This is actually sounds so live, not just because the breathing but the volume fluctuation, the audience also sounds very apparent with their voice, also I hear mispronunciation too, like it probably has backtrack but they also sing live all on top of that

[@bimaptr]

yeah you will listen what exactly you hear today in their next promotion since they used pre record

[@anagabriella4830]

@@bimaptr Karina looks like really live, but the rest of them are obviously lypsinc (and i do not blame them for this!!) Hope they sing this song live bc ins't hard tought... Except for Winter bc she's sick sooo... SM let her rest pls

[@vivalavida9980]

@@anagabriella4830 I think all of them sang live.

[@Elric-zz2sb]

@@anagabriella4830no, their mics moved a lot so i highly doubt that it’s live and it’s normal as it’s their first stage plus it’s irrelevant since they are good singers. if it is live then they all sang.

[@lucillealbay1572]

All of them sing live 100% because of their range it's easy for them to sing this live...hellerk they are from SM not hybe...🤨 so funny how people asking if this is live...they are really amaze how aespa is really stable while singing live ..that's the fact...

[@LaYunoM02]

They singing live..you can hear their breathing

[@4321ball]

Yeah but it’s prerecord live without choreography I guessed

[@rayseroy7407]

@@4321ballit’s prerecord but mic was on

[@KrulciferEdenfelt]

@@4321ball this is not precrecorded. Prerecorded would sound way more cleaner than this.

[@lizotta457]

@@KrulciferEdenfelt so many moments here are so clear

[@moonrabbit6079]

How can yall tell the difference? 😮

[@toddlf0310]

에스파도 에스파지만 마이들도 실력 미쳤네....

[@MrSkinniSoul]

녹화전에 팬매가 집합시켜서 연습시킴ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-br1cw3mr8u]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@Do_Mindfulness]

ㅋㅋㅋㄱ 개웃기네 ​@@MrSkinniSoul

[@wonbinsarangheyo]

@@MrSkinniSoul왜이렇게 귀엽짘ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@Seonah_dokjil320]

​@@MrSkinniSoul 어ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋ

[@The_second_cat]

이제와서 보니 지금까지 에스파 라이브 억까하던 무리들이 누군지 알겠다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 짜란다잘한다❤ 팬질할때 젤 좋은게 뿌듯헐때ㅋㅋ

[@justmeowit-s2c]

아 그 염소키우시는 푸짐한분😂😂😂

[@unknownanonymous_]

it’s live, this song isn’t even hard to sing compared to aespa’s standard title tracks 😂ningning is singing completely in a different range than the studio version (higher note during the bridge, lower for the adlibs during the end) and giselle was breathy during the “explosion” part, karina even from the start and it’s evident during the “aaaah body bang”

[@HanQ28]

It may just be pre-recording. Also Ningning's adlibs at the end are not lower. They're the same as the studio recording.

[@nis4b.]

@@HanQ28 1:34 Ningnings mispronunciation didn’t sound live to you? Or Winters part right after? Their MV removed often gets many comments like these, because people are doubting if it’s live or not. And not because it’s bad, but because it sounds way too good for what they’re used to hearing from most artists outside of SM.

[@unknownanonymous_]

@@HanQ28 you need to let it go lol. ningning’s adlibs were lower and also way louder than the OA parts that the others were singing, it doesnt blend in as well as the studio version. it really isnt that hard to convince yourself that aespa sang this live when this is their easiest laid-back vocal title track ever. that’s also why they kept changing the tunes and pronunciation since it’s more talk-singing rather than vocally challenging

[@crystalcastle660]

Ningning adilbs are the same range as the original wtf are you on? People lie and still get hundreds of likes 💀

[@nusantaramedika9489]

u want to tell haters? you cannot coz haters its like ROCK hard to tell they

[@user-fg7ek6jb9k]

2:01 댄브 구간 팬들 떼창 열심히하는 거 너무 귀엽다

[@kairimon4669]

Because it's part of the fan chant. Aespa is making Mys debut with them XD

[@user-os8hb7hp7o]

노래실력도 좋은데 건너뛰는거 없이 완곡까지...

[@gitulahpokonya]

THEYRE SING LIVE! STOP DENIAL THE FACT. the comment section is so annoyinggg as f

[@SalamSalam-gp2wp]

Yes it's live

[@rickay4549]

aespa is so good people cannot believe their live vocals are real.

[@happyleggo9904]

If anything it's a compliment bc they sound so good it's hard for some people to believe. There's also the recording video as further proof.

[@yuliatirahmah9462]

Frrr

[@Yunessa02]

Yeah even during the studio record their vocals is so great

[@보갱츄]

녹음된거라하기엔 춤추는 동작 소리랑 숨소리나서 ,,

[@user-bt6vi2ns6n]

닝닝 너무 잘한다

[@nicolostories]

This is LIVE but with backtrack. They're so stable by the way. But if you still don't want to admit it, let's just give them a win to hear their encore.

[@alwaYsisss]

High possibility of being live. Song is too easy for aespa. Ningning’s highnote doesn’t even feel like highnote as it’s just normal range for them.

[@likhon_akon98]

Everything is easy for Aespa.

[@DML897]

This is only a pre-release single too. The title track I'm sure is gonna have major vocals

[@Elric-zz2sb]

@@DML897just to clear up any possible confusion, supernova is still a title track. armageddon is a double title track album.

[@dhkrzh]

@@DML897supernova also their tittle track

[@andisulis]

​@@DML897 They have two title tracks, Supernova & Armageddon

[@jihyekim1374]

4명 다 지리네 ㄷㄷ 이번 곡은 특히 닝닝이가 찢은듯

[@agnssnadint]

All member

[@urmyfavkindofnight]

​@@agnssnadint they literally said that tho? why do yall cant stand nn praises🥴

[@agnssnadint]

@@urmyfavkindofnight I just said again so what?

[@agnssnadint]

@@urmyfavkindofnight I just said again so what?

[@ooo-ik3mu]

이렇게 어떤 그룹은 또 밟혔습니다

[@냥냥-r9r]

에스파 밟으실수수수수퍼노바

[@y_geonn]

에스파밟으실수수수수퍼노밞

[@noname-pd5nh]

카리나 저음은 ㄹㅇ 음원이랑 개똑같은데

[@user-zu4ru9xb4p]

에스파 원래 라이브 잘했음 이걸 보고도 실력 얘기 하면 ㄹㅇ 얼탱….

[@user-vv3cj1xy8t]

이만큼 안정적인걸 본적이 없으니까 맨날 라이브아니다아니다 어휴 ㅅㅂ

[@gsuznhdndn7996]

This is really amazing ....People find it very difficult to distinguish whether this is live or not but this is not strange for a group like aespa They're from SM so This is very normal for people to doubt their voices whether this is live or not ..... because for a very long time we have not found a group like this The imaginative stability of the vocal with the powerful dance That's insane

[@verennanda8104]

👍

[@mamamememoo]

Super Junior, Girls Generation, Shinee who are Aespa’s senior label mates are ALL good at singing, dancing & hosting. Aespa follows in their footsteps in these aspects.

[@deefd6760]

닝닝 윈터가 진짜 찐이라고 아이돌계의 신이시라고

[@user-ci7qi5ue3b]

지젤 진짜 없어선 안될 음색임

[@user-kq1cy3se7t]

ㄹㅇ 쫀뜩쫀득 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@skyllline24]

ㅇㅈ

[@kimlove_123]

진짜로 지젤 음색 보물이야

[@user-vl8iz5ny1s]

ㅇㅈ 스파이시때 느낌

[@냠념-j1n]

그 feels right 어쩌구 하는 거기 진짜 쫜-득함

[@youngju-fe5pt]

에스파 진짜 다 예쁘고 실력좋은듯

[@Hyehwa818]

하이브빠들이 이 영상을 보면 부들부들대는거 아님?ㅋㅋ 난 윈터팬이지만 에스파 응원한다

[@Psychic-01tube]

하이브빠로 묶지 마셈 개내중에서도 뉴진스같이 하이브 소속 그룹은 응원해도 하이브 싫어하는 애들 있을듯.

[@곽나연-h9n]

하이브 돌 좋아하는애들 다 하이브 싫어하고 에스파같은 실력좋은 그룹들도 다 좋아함

[@I_m_BBee]

에스파 밟으실 수수수수퍼노바

[@djjkhsnejje]

이거는 진짜! 라이브 네요 움직일때 소리 다르자나요

[@CAPYBARAHYRAX]

수수수수파노바

[@goldencitivil]

드라마도 라이브로 했는데 무슨 라이브가 아니라는둥 난리야 ㅎㅎㅎ 이 곡은 박자가 어렵지 에스파한테는 쉬운곡이야

[@TatianaNikolayeva-wq7on]

카리나 바디뱅 이후 저음 너무 안정적이예요😊

[@뚜찌빠찌-z1o]

카리나 목소리 진짜 좋다ㅜㅜ

[@aespapago]

이게 라이브라니.... 나 에스파 평생 좋아할 듯

[@jkuiop7]

omg the vocals are the best i can listen to this only all day

[@mamamememoo]

It’s LIVE. The breathing is a good clue and there are some slight differences btw the recording and the live performance. And if you still wonder if they can sing coz their vocals sound so good, you can watch the video where they are recording the song. Aespa is SM and their performers are arguably some of the best at singing in the Kpop industry.

[@amg0735]

어디는 너무 못해서 가수가 라이브 한게 맞냐고 난리고 여기는 너무 잘해서 이게 진짜 라이브 한게 맞냐고 난리네 똑같이 라이브 의심인데 분위기가 전혀 다르네

[@aqsah14]

You can hear other air sounds being picked up by the mic aside from their breathing so it’s deffo partially live at least

[@user-we6it2jj9l]

애들 그냥 앉아서 부르는 거 같은 편안함이네…. 역시 스엠은 라이브 맛집

[@user-we6it2jj9l]

에스파 진짜 음정 정확한 거 봐….. 하 음원보다 좋다….

[@지유-u2p]

스엠돌들은 못 까는 이유. 라이브 도파민 싹 돌잖아 ㅋ ❤

[@user-np3lg3my2v]

아ㅏㅏ바디뱅은 mr제거로 들어도 개쩌네

[@ggnumber15one85]

Tapi tak sejelek kamu

[@user-bp8eh9ps6n]

진짜잘함 이런게가수지!!! 진짜실력외모최고❤

[@Karinanumber1]

Omgggg I love aespaaaaaaaa and Get well soon winter😢😢

[@ambarmp]

que le paso a winter

[@Lolo77573]

@@ambarmpshe has recently undergone a lung surgery

[@chanrachel7071]

@@ambarmp There was a little fire accident at mcountdown today when aespa was performing. Winter apparently inhaled some smoke and was unwell (she underwent lung surgery last month). Hope SM will give her enough time to rest and recover 😢

[@ro_di_]

ㅅㅂ 믿을수 없다ㅜ이게 라이브라니 그냥 평생 복종할게요 ㅜ

[@user-mx9in3ml3g]

복종한다는게 개웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 저도 평생 복종할께요

[@SalamSalam-gp2wp]

I'm show you 0:01 part karina live 0:06 part ningning live 1:10 part giselle live 2:24 they singing all live chorus

[@annatroncoso7085]

either SM is getting REAL GOOD at the pre-records coz the breathing is too on point and you can hear variations in volume... or AESPA STABLE QUEENS HELLO????

[@sowhat1674]

I think only winter that is not singing because of post surgery.

[@vergil8833]

@@sowhat1674 I don't think it affects her singing, but she would get tired alot faster than normal.

[@gsuznhdndn7996]

even with their breathing you can't admit that they're singing love 💀 ? But that's normal for aespa Queens

[@sowhat1674]

@@vergil8833 didn't she just had lung rupture? Im pretty sure that gotta affect your singing and dancing at the same time.

[@sowhat1674]

@@vergil8833 didn't she just had lung rupture? Im pretty sure that gotta affect your singing and dancing at the same time.

[@user-sr2qm7sv1h]

닝닝사랑해

[@핸들이고장난팔톤트럭]

여러분. 원래 첫방은 사녹이든 뭐든 하지만... 우리 이미 에스파의 실력을 알잖아요. 나중에 더 많은 영상 나올거예요. 수수수수퍼노바!

[@MeltsInYourMOUTHhNotInYourHAND]

Thats why the tone register is low if you compare this song with their previous one. Because they want to perform LIVE with confidence. Guys AESPA doing this because of backlash now we are seeing them PERFORMING and you cannot accept it 🤪 AESPA ❤

[@sn1325]

목소리가 비는 곳이 없다 개좋아 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@riuezz915]

1:02 HELLOO? why is karina's voice sound like taeyon at this part 😭

[@elizabethparedes6161]

Omg 😮

[@Gloria_Aria]

라이브는 지젤이 의외로 잘함.

[@hayanhanam]

보컬실력 좋은거랑 별개로 댄스라이브는 좀 힘들어한다고 생각했는데 이번 노래가 드라마나 스파이시 이런것보다 상대적으로 쉬워서 그런지 댄스라이브도 기깔나게 하네 ㄷㄷ

[@Kamchoo]

100% 라이브맞음 마이크 지직 숨소리 다나는데ㅋㅋㅋ

[@abcdef-kf3my]

Wow that’s so stable not gonna lie🔥🔥🔥

[@selenophilerain1880]

The breath they take when singing really proves that they are singing live.

[@Supernova11-t3g]

Woaaahhh seperti yg di harapkan,iniloh AESPA 🔥🎉😎 Keren Woi stabil dari awal hingga akhir 😆

[@crabotato]

stable queens👑😌

[@Lucaseeeee]

Giselle live so good🔥

[@BobGolob]

Awesome live performance! AESPA always delivers! Well done, girls!

[@verennanda8104]

Jika masih ada yang bilang lipsync, aku rasa kalian sungguh harus periksa kesehatan telinga 😅 . Ini sangat jelas mereka bernyanyi live , bahkan sebelum MR removed suara asli dan backtrack nya terlihat sangat jelas berbeda . Apakah kalian lupa saat winter tranding karna dia bernyanyi dengan sangat gampang , bahkan di nada tinggi . Jadi jangan menyangkal kebenaran hanya karena kalian tidak suka aespa . Karena itu terlihat sangat bodoh 😂

[@agnssnadint]

Orang yg sudah membenci aespa akan tetap tutup telinga haha,, sebenarnya mereka iri

[@icha5344]

Susah kalo emg dia dari awalnya denial pasti ga terima kalo aespa live

[@azikra9765]

Ini Pre-record kan

[@loveyou4695]

Karina bilang di bubble 100% live, lagian kalo pre record pasti lebih bening ​@@azikra9765

[@verennanda8104]

@@azikra9765 untuk penampilan nya memang pre-record bukan siaran langsung . Tapi untuk nyanyiannya mereka nyanyi live dan ada backtracknya , jdi bukan lipsync

[@냥덕]

와 다 부르네ㄷㄷ대박

[@rachelchibi07]

Listen to them. Even dancing while singing live there's not a weak link. So proud

[@mypearlb5208]

Both Ningning's low and higher tone sound so good omg, so pleasing to the ears!

[@uusidvkakk]

라이브가 맛있어요

[@five8193]

Get well soon uri Winter

[@user-lp9ko6tf9l]

에스파는 무대때 무조건 마이들 소리질러~ 한마디씩 넣어줘야 할듯 이게 라이브 아니라는 애들은 귀에 뭐 박힌거임?

[@user-wf5kc6hi7m]

역시 갓스파 🤘🏻

[@broa3225]

이거 누가봐도 라이브로부르던데

[@fannyjihantika445]

Ning ning OMG

[@beccawu967]

fans are so used to bad singers that they think this is pre-recorded or something. just pls use your brains and know that sm artists will never disappoint when it comes to vocals

[@bepishes]

le sserafim moment (and yes im gonna drag them here)

[@beccawu967]

@@bepishes period as u should

[@user-ot6wn1lk4q]

Guys this is an easy song for aespa vocal ability. You can hear the breath and tone variations.

[@jisoolove7499]

just beautiful. There are other videos where they are clearly only using a backtrack or prerecord but this is so clearly live and it’s lovely to see

[@6uess]

일단 노래가 에스파 노래 중에선 비교적 쉬운 편이라 잘 부를 수밖에 없지 않나? 이거보다 어려운 노래도 잘부르던뎅 일단 난 뒤에 힘빠져서 헥헥대는거 때메 라이브라고 생각함! 강 에스파가 음방에서 1등하고 앵콜 라이브로 인증해주면 좋겠당

[@youngju-fe5pt]

곡이 난해해서 다른곡 보다 힘들어보여요..ㅠ.ㅠ

[@애옹맑]

@@youngju-fe5pt고음도 없어서 비교적 쉬운 건 맞음. 박자라던가 오히려 낮은 음이라 안정적이긴 힘든 것도 맞구...

[@hyun03]

그냥 실력이 좋았는 데 점점 더 좋아지고 있는 느낌임

[@내이름-h6n]

카리나 저음 너무 매력적이다❤❤

[@estelvio1538]

이악물고 라이브하네 ㅋㅋ.. 마이크 숨소리 계속나

[@glowupwithselina]

They are so stabil😍

[@양말양-m8y]

얘넨 진짜 넷 다 잘하네

[@xorary]

슈노는 그냥 가뿐하게 하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@boss_babyi]

I'm always so proud to be a my, cause my girls never disappoint me, their talents, music, visuals, mvs, performances, chemistries, live vocal 💗💗

[@시루떡시루-f5t]

진짜 안정적이네

[@SassybunnieYW]

Their stamina is insane

[@boss_babyi]

It is funny how people think they are lip sycing when they are singing live because they sound so good just like the studio ver

[@afreeen.m]

LIVE SINGING BY GODSPA ACEPA such crisp and clear vocals I'm getting chills

[@didiwai]

can't believe that winter with deep voice and IT'S LIVE !!!!!! loudest scream for the girlssss🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@user-dy3dr6ug6k]

Semua grup kpop seharusnya bisa seperti mereka, bernyanyi live adalah salah satu cara menikmati musik kpop

[@Cfghjs]

닝닝도 올라운더 아이돌인데 사람들이 많이 모르는듯

[@reinasuci1280]

Aespa queen

[@clarisinschallah5106]

In love with karina deep voice and stability

[@HanQ28]

To those to say Ningning's adlibs are lower than the studio recording, NO they're not. They're exactly the same keys. Stop trying to discredit Ningning. She can sing as high as G5 and Ab5 in Drama. The highest notes ever reached by 4th gen girlgroups. You think she can't handle the C5 and D5 notes in this song? She can sing the whole song in her sleep.

[@T1andO411]

에스파 너무 잘한다👍👍 마이들도 피처링 확실하게 잘해주네요 최고👍👍

[@nenengsarini5814]

Just because your idols sound like dying when singing live, doesn't mean others too. Yeah maybe you should keep listening to your idols' horrible voice instead of coming here and leave any bad comments.

[@Dlduddid332]

ㄹㅇ 춤핑계도 할필요없이 ㅈㄴ잘하네 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-vy3bb8mo2q]

ㄹㅇ 뉴진스 댓글보고 개 역했다...

[@xxxxxxxxx66667]

비주얼 퍼포 라이브 올라운더 미쳣다 와

[@SalamSalam-gp2wp]

They are singing live the breath singing some part they leave it not important karina voice and giselle part live yall don't understand they can do it easy