i think vava and yuqi were over confident and off tune, and a bit rude interrupting han hong and the judges so i can see why han hong was annoyed.. BUT i feel like if they were not happy w the performance, why did they all raise their card? this gives the girls the false hope that they made it to the next round, like no wonder they were crying like crazy at the end of the ep. i also think that han hong should have delivered the news to the girls, and not those two random judges who probably didnt know what to say, what can they say?? i think IQIYI did it on purpose for the views but it is just shady.. like why are yalll trying to act like mnet now
@shylee87103 жыл бұрын
yess, its like they trying to create drama for views like Mnet
@queenning283 жыл бұрын
I actually agree with Han Hong's critiques. Her attitude is a bit harsh, but from my observation, she always sounds pretty "tough" even in normal conversations. It's probably just her personality. And she was born in Tibet (I think she’s half-Tibetan). She's had a tough upbringing. Let's not expect her to be as soft and gentle as our average idol singers nowadays. Overall, I think she's right in saying that pitch correctness cannot be sacrificed in any type of competition, for any reason whatsoever. If Yuqi and Vava were at their own concerts, maybe occasionally they could "loose up" a bit, because they would be surrounded by their fans who were mostly there to see them, instead of judging their singing. But here they're in a competition against many other good singers. It wouldn't be fair for the judges to ignore their pitch issues. I'm glad that at the end they promised to keep practising and improving. They both need to solidify the foundations (including pitch) if they want to advance their careers as serious singers and live performers.
@luvluv65443 жыл бұрын
I actually happy that she tell them their mistake straightforward, but they seems to be playful that's why she had to make it harsh so they know that she is serious, if compared to korean judges they even gave more harsh comments if you don't do well.
@hii20603 жыл бұрын
@@luvluv6544 yea I actually think tht Han Hong is a really good teacher
@queenning283 жыл бұрын
@@luvluv6544 Oh god the Kpop judges would be soooo mad at Yuqi’s team for acting playful on stage while receiving negative comments. It’s good that China doesn’t have strict senior-junior status difference, so the big seniors like Han Hong are pretty lenient with young idols. They don’t expect a super high level of respectfulness to begin with. Even in this video, she still laughed at Yuqi’s small joke at the end. She’s not really offended by her. I agree with you that she is extra harsh here because she wants the girls to take her words to their hearts.
@vanLovely3 жыл бұрын
i kind of miss that cause english subs was messy when i was watching... but i don´t feel they deserve to be rated as the worst performance from the assigment
@choodijane44383 жыл бұрын
@Getaway Minnie no, I think op meant Han Hong being born in Tibet; Yuqi is from Beijing
I know Yuqi's very busy but I really hope she has some vocal training while doing this show from a professional. Her voice cracks have been very frequent and I hope she can learn the right techniques which suits her vocal range. I want her to grow stronger for herself and Idle
@jonathanfranciscosanchezma72613 жыл бұрын
She was a lot better when he was with i-dle, her lady Gaga cover ITS so good... Do you think she isn't singing well because she Is tired? Because she didn't sing in a lot of Time?
@johaseulsaranghae67583 жыл бұрын
i believe that they should’ve gotten a reality check regarding their vocals, but their overall performance should not have placed last. even yamy and shan yichun knew that they didn’t do well, so i don’t think that it’s fair
I think it is expected for teacher han to give them a reality check, as no matter what, they are in fact in a competition, i really like yuqi alot so i must say her actions after her competition today did not leave me a good impression, it is good to have confidence, but i must say today performance is a big shortcoming for me, i feel that it could have been improved in many ways. Not disappointed, but really could have been way way better!! I have total trust in yuqi that she really can be the giant she want to be, hope she shows it well
@Jingelx3 жыл бұрын
I think they just misread the situation and the judges tone. They probably wanted to keep it lighthearted as it is a variety show after all. I don’t think they meant for it to be anyway disrespectful or arrogant.
@jeenalama46833 жыл бұрын
@@Jingelx this isnt a fun variety show .. its a competition ... of course its a type of variety show but not the ones where you have fun .. here tou get judged and ranked and critised sometimes and you get eliminated too
@Jingelx3 жыл бұрын
@@jeenalama4683 yes it would be if they were rookies or trainees. Most of them already have an established fan base. They have an image. Yuqi is always cheerful and bubbly. Probably wanted to be herself. Chill.
@jeenalama46833 жыл бұрын
@@Jingelx whether popular or npt you need to respect the stage and treat every single perfprmance the same
I've been a neverland for a long time and I feel like YUQI will know her mistake. She seems to goof around on the outside but she is actually taking her mistake seriously in the inside. Remember how she cried during the lion stage? Im not siding her but I believe she will do well in the next stage
@lyw53453 жыл бұрын
I can feel that Han Hong has their best interests at heart. She *knows* that they can do better in singing and deliver a better stage performance, which is why she's "chiding" them. Jiayou Yuqi & Vava!
I agree with han..although I'm a huge idle fan..plus I'm a singer although never professionally trained..when v sing ..v come to k if v hv gone off tune..d voice crack n its really embarrassing when v do it..yuqi was really overhyped this episode n full of over confidence..confidence is d key but overconfidence can throw u down ..nd d judge was extremely serious this time..u could say she did not like d performance..nd yuqi n her partner were very lenient abt it...their attitude would hv caused them to be given a black card..I feel if they would hv quietly agreed on wat d judge said..they would hv been performing on d big stage..But anyways..all the best yuqi..!!!
I think that she is a little disrespectful when the teacher was speaking but it's still understandable bcuz i can feel that she just wanted to have fun with the stage and she was hype from her performance Moreover she's still young. At the end aren't everything went back to normal tho, the teacher was laughing while chit chatting with her at the end and she didn't fight back, and i don think it's a great issue about her accused "attitude problem".
@curryrice68373 жыл бұрын
there’s problem with their mic but they also were off-key. their tune was not right it was right for han hong to be strict with them or they will never know their problem
@joyce30033 жыл бұрын
I'm really not a fan of this title. The constructive criticism was valid based off the performance, if judges can't be honest about singers being off tune then the idols won't see a reason to continue pushing themselves, Yuqi will continue to improve I believe in her
5:54 😂 Two naughty kids fooling around and the teacher had to teach them a lesson 好像頑皮的小學生被老師教訓一樣
@stopit1403 жыл бұрын
I could smell the bad news for yuqi literally at the beginning of the episode because they kept putting in scenes of her talking about her confidence in getting to the big stage. Yuqi is like one of my top favorite idols but honestly I was a bit disappointed with her last performance. The editing of the last episode also gave her a bad image and I feel like the show just wanted drama as yuqi is probably one of the more popular members due to her appearance in running man China. Overall disappointed with both yuqi and the show. She literally got first in the last episode and now she’s last? Like what???🤨😒
I only watch this show because of Yuqi. As a Nevie I'm already biased towards her. It's okay to make mistakes, but I just hope she doesn't think that this performance was good because then she will never improve. After watching a couple of Yuqi's performances, I can clearly see why Miyeon and Minnie are the main vocalists in the group. I love Yuqi's vocal color but she needs more vocal lessons. Her rapping actually sounds better than I expected though; I like her rhythm.
@pangkouxiong12443 жыл бұрын
I don't believe as a nevie it's fair to judge based on just these performances. You can think it, but putting that negative shite on the net behind a screen is sad.
@frankaustriablas61863 жыл бұрын
I think Yuqi is acting as bubbly as she can but in the inside I know she's so broken and crying.
@yvy.8303 жыл бұрын
fr her face literally fell so many times then she was like :D as they continued talking
@cherryip498 Жыл бұрын
韓老師是非常嚴謹的人,可也是最溫柔的人,願意認真指點又提攜後輩的人,真的不多見了。
@czarinadeleon21283 жыл бұрын
That thing vava did with the chair didnt really look as cool as what they did during their practice..
@Co0kieICExBlend3 жыл бұрын
Yes i agree with Han Hong ~ even though i came here for Yuqi, its really out of tune
@skrskrskrlll3 жыл бұрын
As for Yuqi, she likes to goof around and makes joke here and there. I am glad that the teachers told them what was wrong and disciplined Yuqi. I mean she's still in her early 20 and still learning. People makes mistake too and I am quite sure that she's been alerted by the teacher to be serious during test when the teacher told her to stand straight and listen carefully. The teachers have high expectation from her. I am quite sure they just want the best for her.
@ms.random62033 жыл бұрын
YuQi is still very young. She can learn a lot. So its no problem
赞!!!!!! Awesome!!!!!!!!! What a epic Song!!!! Let's go Yuqi!!!!!
@freyamaxwell57863 жыл бұрын
This episode basically show us that attitude is more important than teamwork and it showed us how to give people hopes up and then downing them in last minute. Yuqi is really a honest person, soyeon said that yuqi always show her mood expression. for a sec, I can see her face turned to serious and focus to listen when hanhong scolding them as like she know she makes a mistake and in danger position, but in the next second hanhong said she will still rise the card and makes her assume that the mistake was forgivable and hanhong will still let them to pass. The other mentor was not helping to, he said that off tune is big problem but still rise the card. So she just honest with her feels, that's why she still don't get the hanhong really warn and judgement when they give her a safe sign not a completely harsh judge. Why can't they just tell her that they not like yuqi and vava performance and give her warning so they can understand that their mistake is not fine ? So they can understand and prepare themself, you all can see that they really didn't expect the result will be so bad. Ini mah lebih susah dari kode keras "mentor baik2 saja" dan kata terserah.
@ym2ii3 жыл бұрын
i really like yuqi but i don’t think her behaviour when han hong was talking about their performance was correct , idk if it’s evil editing but it looked like yuqi n vava didn’t respect han hong when she was talking…? but the stage was okay overall, keep going yuqi n vava!
@hannahevens11313 жыл бұрын
It's ok humans makes mistakes I support u yuqi don't worry fighting! Also tomorrow I am going hostel so I will be not able to support yuqi for the next months because I also need to focus on my studies I am gonna miss gidle 😭😭😭 also I gonna work hard just like yuqi, love you all keep supporting Yuqi bye bye👋😭💜❤
I feel like the performance is good but not the best if u compare it to the others...this is a competition she can't get first everytime...there will be good n tough in a competition
@최주영-o-13 жыл бұрын
우기야....언니가 이제 봤다ㅜㅜㅜ 한국 댓글이 없네,,, 그래도 언니가 많이 사랑한다😭😭 울지 말어 우리 강아지ㅜㅜㅜ 힘들 때 그래도 가족이랑 같이 있을 수 있어서 좋을 것 같구나 응원한다 송우기!!!
@lalililihe58393 жыл бұрын
You can see that yuqi has now experience in Survival show in China, She has never competed alone, in queendom it was in a group and Soyeon was the leader, we know that Yuqi's personality is very spontaneous and this can cause misunderstandings with strangers that's why I'm glad she's here, she can learn to manage her feelings and attitudes, she's good yes but we always need to improve
@booplamon58833 жыл бұрын
@David Richards that’s because China isn’t even interested in the international scene though. And the pinky/kyulkung/feiqong girl was actually in a Korean produce survival group and became part of I.O.I. Just because yuqi was criticised by them doesn’t mean that the show is total garbage, even your favs can make mistakes and you just have to accept it.
@PotatoUwU3 жыл бұрын
@David Richards China doesn’t need a global scene because they already have a huge music industry in their own country. Kpop needs the international attention because korea is small and if they don’t expand globally, their music industry will never grow.
@pangkouxiong12443 жыл бұрын
Wow, they freaking used her and dragged her thru the mud! China survival show my ass. Nothing is more brutal than the Korean idol industry! This is a sham.
@pangkouxiong12443 жыл бұрын
@@PotatoUwU rofl sure, sure. 😂
@tonychen33683 жыл бұрын
@David Richards Su RuiQi, Have you ever heard of her name before? She is the same age as Yuqi and she's overseas competing in the Survival show GP999 and the bad news is, the Koreans want the Chinese out of their survival shows. In reality, China is not really kissing anybody's behind. Yuqi is young, but she'll grow, she only had one best performance of "Giant" that brought the best out of herself, if you think that my Motherland China is competing with anybody you're dead wrong my friend.
@luvluv65443 жыл бұрын
I'm always loving yuqi, however I have to say that their performance wasn't as good as I expected. Overall concept dance, rap and singing is great, however because yuqi is an idol korean group so I seem to have more expectations. As professional idol having earphone is a basic thing, i can see that she singing out off tone and they also mess up with the dance. I understand that they want to hype up each other but they shouldn't be reckless. They made mistakes during performance and judges should tell them and not lifting all the pink flags. Yuqi shouldn't be playful when the judges make comments, it's ok the be playful but has to be in a right time.
i think yuqi need to practice for vocal technique more bcs i often hear her voice cracked. also i hope she can learn through this show about her attitude, she should aware where the place she can or not being playful. go yuqi!
@jackkey19343 жыл бұрын
Wait wht u just talk about her bad attitude and then you said go yuqi😂 wtf fake people...shut the fuck up...
@pangkouxiong12443 жыл бұрын
You can mention the voice crack but don't you dare go for her personality. That's just her personality. She takes this just as serious as the other girls of not more since she initially got big in s korea first. If you want to blame anything, you should blame the structure for this stupid show. 🙄 everything's all over the place and unreasonable. Smh
@jackkey19343 жыл бұрын
@Getaway Minnie that's. Fact girl🔥
@tonychen33683 жыл бұрын
@@jackkey1934 There was no bad attitude, when you make an mistake at anything you pay the price, having Mrs. Hang to scold her for being too happy about something is an life lesson, Vava and Yuqi both passed, I don't really know if its the Judges having acceptance for their performance, I truly don't know, Yuqi has so much to learn, and she'll grow.
@jackkey19343 жыл бұрын
@@tonychen3368 u mean yuqi act like a child's when their mom scold them, haha i know wht u mean. But the fact is! She's is a clever girl in high schools, so she know it, she understands what they said, but this is a variety show, she also a entertainer others than being a idol...so she try boost up the moods, that how it works on TV, she hurt, and she knows it, but she act like she okay, somehow she was not okey...so compared than that fat bij hong, she try to put yuqi underground baby!!! So shut the fuck up...u don't know her, u just said wht u try to said, without understands yuqi...she is the busier idols, in china, magazines, also others variety show like keep running and other...so pls use your brain, no matter how hard she thru, she keeps trying boost up mood, as a entertainer...so fuck off bij haters🔥🔥🔪
@GADS_053 жыл бұрын
Yuqi and vava is like a kid getting scold
@ohyouarenana52283 жыл бұрын
This is reality no need to sugarcoat.
@breadstrips81683 жыл бұрын
is yuqi a guest in this show?
@cherylmyg44193 жыл бұрын
Nope
@breadstrips81683 жыл бұрын
@@cherylmyg4419 then?
@M4tchazz3 жыл бұрын
@@breadstrips8168 she's one of the competitors
@pangkouxiong12443 жыл бұрын
Singing is off but I enjoyed their stage. No matter how good a voice is, if they can't deliver the feel of the song, you won't keep an audience for long. Yuqi and Vava fighting! 💓
the judges raised the signs and they will not perform on that big stage. I know that they sing out of pitch but why they raised the signs? And then they will perform at XXXL stage
Whatever they say, the result was unfair because they were not taken to the small stage because of what they say here but because Han Hong did not want Shan Yichun to be on a small stage again. I think this is disrespectful to Yuqi Vava, Yammy and Shan Yichun herself.
@apinksonnaeun54163 жыл бұрын
很喜欢yuqi 可是这次yuqi真的有点不尊重韩红老师 还是永远支持yuqi💜💜
@poon6773 жыл бұрын
金武林?是當初評張韶涵,陶喆唱歌給0分的那個評審嗎?
@elchen42033 жыл бұрын
對,就是那個人渣⋯⋯
@黃新-b2z Жыл бұрын
雨琦也是舒華才知道她的她很可愛很有才華.越來越喜歡她了她和小舒超搞笑的關係真好妳們加油喔⋯⋯
@annej45803 жыл бұрын
i seriously think this is all a ploy by the show to get us all riled up for the next episodes.
Why the mentors not give them the reason why they can’t perform on boom stage? The 2 male mentors keep saying it’s hard to say. 🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
@kanazza723 жыл бұрын
@@chocostrawberry13 lol
@tonychen33683 жыл бұрын
I don't know the reason either, they just seem to let them pass without any explanation or is it just for the heck of it, I don't know. But I want Yuqi to grow from her mistakes, and she'll understand this.
@kanazza723 жыл бұрын
@@tonychen3368 I just watch the latest episode and found out that even 3 other mentors don’t agree, XXXL Mentor insist that San Yichun should perform on Stageboom because she missed it last time. Her logic is terrible. It’s so injustice.