Why Brazil's business elite soured on former president Bolsonaro

This video was originally published on Jan 20, 2022.
The pro-market stance of Brazil’s former president, Jair Bolsonaro, helped him win the support of the country's business elite - and eventually the presidency in 2018. So why do some experts say his policies have held back the country's economic potential?
-
At the turn of the century, Brazil was touted for its huge economic potential.
The South American country was named alongside Russia, India and China as the emerging markets with the ability to eclipse the world's biggest economies.
"But then from 2011 to 2014, you had a slowdown in the Brazilian economy. This was due both to changes in the external sector, but also what I consider some mistakes in the economic policy framework," said Laura Carvalho, a Brazilian economist and best-selling author.
The deep economic recession that followed, coupled with political turmoil, fueled the rise of an unlikely winner in the 2018 general election: Jair Bolsonaro.
Among his supporters were Brazil's business elite, who were optimistic that Bolsonaro could turn around the Latin American country's fortunes.
That belief appeared supported by Bolsonaro's appointment of businessman and free-market advocate Paulo Guedes as economy minister, as well as by the Brazilian leader's pro-business speech at the World Economic Forum's Annual Meeting in Davos in 2019.
"We will work to lower the tax burden, streamline rules and make life easier for those who wish to produce and do business," Bolsonaro said then.
Brazil's economic comeback, however, has not happened. Economists like Carvalho point to several policies that are holding the country back.
"Even the people who were supporting him for that reason are very disappointed," she said, "because he did not carry out the structural reforms and the type of economic policies that have been promised in his campaign."
What went wrong? Watch the video above to learn more.
-----
Subscribe: cnb.cx/2wuoARM
CNBC International TV: cnb.cx/2NGytpz
Facebook:
/ cnbcinternational
Instagram:
/ cnbcinternational
Twitter:
/ cnbci
#CNBC #Brazil #Bolsonaro #Brasil

[@nadoio]

Why videos about Brazil always has the Amazon in the thumbnail? It looks like we live in the middle of the jungle 😂

[@vladimirputout2461]

Pq tu come cocô

[@fabiojr15]

É metade do Brasil!!

[@gabrielcarvalho9368]

Claro que nós vivemos na floresta pô, eu mesmo acabei de pegar três linhas diferentes de cipós pra chegar no trabalho kkkkkkkkkkk

[@andarilho_31]

Because that's the stereotypical way foreigners view us

[@lordmaur180]

Cara, fica quieto senão eu vou subir na tua árvore e te acertar com um galho 🤣🤣🤣

[@rusitoexplorador]

The Mercosur part seemed weird. As an Argentinian, although both our governments have very different views, there were no big conflicts or economic disputes. Also I wouldnt say that there is "a very bad relationship" as described in this video.

[@ViniciusVieira13]

Bolsonaro has publicly said many times that Mercosur has no purpose for Brazil and that Brazil should seek other partners

[@MrZekinhaluiz]

From a Brazil perspective. The military fucking hates Argentina or anyone who is foreign. It's weird. It's foolish. There is literally no reason our people shouldn't be friends and brothers. Partners in fighting poverty and building bridges.

[@LuccaSouzaXGAMER]

Economia da Argentina é uma piada por conta do socialismo.

[@MrZekinhaluiz]

@@LuccaSouzaXGAMER vey, vai fazer seu dever de casa. Você não deveria estar na escola? Lugar de criança é na escola.

[@LuccaSouzaXGAMER]

@@MrZekinhaluiz pq choras ? Não pode falar mal do socialismo.

[@GBA811]

5:16 No. The Car Wash investigation started at an office of Gas Station that ironicaly hadn't a Car Wash.

[@TeamEternalEmpire]

@@harryh.r.9082 it's not every at all

[@enzosantos70]

@@harryh.r.9082 wtf

[@joaofrancisco1760]

@@harryh.r.9082 no they don't

[@petergohan]

Brazil is a great country and suffers from being the eternal country of the future (that never comes), mostly because of our elite, not in recent years but actually at least from the start of the republican era. Every single time that a political wave or even a single politician talks about modernazing the country, making it have a strong and diverse industry there comes a crisis that put a stop to it forcing the country to stay only a supply of natural resources. There are strong people in power that think that selling oil to buy gasoline is good, it's because of stupid people like that we are so behind and there's always an economic crisis when the commodities prices drop.

[@lucaslovesnumber5]

Same happens with Argentina or any other Latin American country for that matter, it’s a continent that it’s flawed since conception and people can’t do nothing about it.

[@anacruzcompositora]

Sure. Its an elite colision. Not only in Brazil, everywhere. Wealth its unbalanced and education is a weapon that those goverments avoid to provide.

[@rodrigomendonca4172]

@@anacruzcompositora And let's not forget The Empire's actions to create destabilization and promote coups.

[@anacruzcompositora]

Sure. 1% has 90% of the power in the world. And they want to keep it that way... and the rest of us are blinded or busy with many other things.

[@felipecatto9049]

É o extremo oposto, quando está tudo bem é aí que o governo se prevalece, oferecendo benesses e auxílio qualquer coisa para todo, criam taxas e regulações que atrasam ou impede ou prejudicam o crescimento de empresas... E nenhuma reforma econômica relevante acontece, isso não significa que também o governo faz o oposto quando está crise, mais dado o históricos de países ricos pelo mundo, eles só ficaram ricos depois de implementados reformas econômicas em tempo de crise mais só por que o país entra em crise quer dizer que ele vá implementar reformas

[@andregomes4033]

"It's not that the corruption itself caused the economic crisis " Then, was what?

[@marcelomenezes8488]

Cara, nenhuma crise econômica tem uma causa só. Essa crise teve várias causas: queda no preço das commodities e política econômica desastrosa do governo Dilma são duas das mais importantes.

Because we are a great country. So the tax income is humungous, and the corruption can't drain it all. But economic decisions had a really great impact on our crisis. Some national resource negotiations also had (and still have) impact in this scenario, too. Pre-Sal oil negotiations wasn't performed well by our government, and that should have helped to lower some economic problems. We can expand that to some agro-business key decisions, too. I work at the government (at city level) and the biggest issue, sometimes, it's the lack of decisions at all. Things keeps running (bad) because some key people don't have enough guts to decide. That also leads to corruption. And that also leads to money sinkholes.

[@Caveirazul]

É uma visão bastante limitada achar que corrupção é a causa de tudo, na verdade é só uma consequência de vários outros problemas estruturais do Brasil, como a falta de educação, falta de justiça e impunidade, falta de infraestrutura, alta burocracia, cultura problemática onde os brasileiros não se importam com o próximo, enfim... Corrupção é um sintoma dessa fossa civilizatória chamada Brasil.

[@Fred-sg8fn]

In case of PT it was corruption...you cannot have a healthy economy when you send 400 billion dollars of brazilian tax money to leftists dictatorships in Latin America and Africa...

[@tarciofarias5166]

Má administração econômica. Como o carinha falou, não é só uma causa, nem é simples de explicar.

[@Avinash-xz7yn]

Brasil is such a wonderful country! Brasil must concentrate more on manufacturing sectors, the prices of electronics and automobiles is ridiculous. Education is out of reach for many, forget Masters, Graduation is ridiculously expensive. Tax rate is one of the highest in the world, it's sad that the country that is blessed with enormous amount of natural wealth and people has become a victim of it's own corruption and crime.

[@marcosilva9260]

Victims of a elite that wants to keep it that way..

[@dariodecastrobr]

Actually we have a bunch of cheap graduations here

[@leopardo9430]

The high taxes are one of the main reasons why we don't pay for education (healthcare too) in Brasil, only if you went to a private school

[@Pedro-ms3nt]

Be more careful with the sites about Brazil's quality of life you're accessing.

[@carlosandino821]

I agree! They could very well have taken advantage of the fall in the value of the real against the dollar to strengthen national industry and remove the difficulties in exporting manufactured and highly complex goods (medicines and complex chemical products), but we have an old colonial elite that has not yet left the "Hereditary Captaincies" and they still think of Brazil as an immense agro-exporting farm, and to make the situation even worse we have entered an immense paradox of being one of the largest food producing countries, but the country has returned to the sad Map of Hunger and Malnutrition, setting back all the country's development efforts by decades!

[@maurotavares1664]

Just heard one side of the coin . two left supporters journalists.

[@tonholis]

14:37 “formidable political adversary Lui Lula da Silva” This video is so biased and full of opinions mixed with a bit of facts that we see in so many “documentaries” nowadays when it comes to politics. It’s been hard to get genuine news these days. Watch out people, do your own research and build your own opinion.

[@indiemickey]

I believe they mean formidable compared to Bolsonaro, which everyone is, you could say the same thing about PSDB too for example

[@tonholis]

@@BocaoZ your nickname says a lot about you.

[@phillipvillani9061]

@@tonholis ficou nervosinho?

[@eduardobarbieridealencar4838]

@@tonholis 41% de intenção de votos contra 28-30%, então sim para o Bolsonaro o lula e um adversário formidável, mas se nem portugues vc consegue interpretar quem dirá o inglês ne?

[@wesley-yh1dv]

@netunof 💀

[@luizfernandes1046]

Nice vídeo but there is a mistake. It’s BricS ( South Africa participate too)

[@marcussoares3209]

But not at the beginning, which was the point.

[@yukinagato1573]

They were founded as BRIC. South Africa joined later

[@wesley4604]

No começo, o o grupo chamava-se apenas BRIC. A África do Sul teve um ingresso tardio.

[@polentusmax6100]

Africa do sul eh o afeganistao 2.0, e a china e a russia sao a nova urss na geopolitica mundial. A unica q se assemelha ao Brasil eh a Índia.

[@haydenbrown3817]

South Africa is Afghanistan what a pathetic thing to say at Ed you one of those 40% Brazilian thinks Brazil belongs to them not anymore 60% population have African ancestry deal with that

[@marceloalmeida93]

I wonder if cnbc ever talked about deforestation in the US or in Europe, it’s so easy to use resources from Brazil and at the same time criticize it, that’s so hypocritical in my opinion...we preserve a lot of our forests percentage wise compared to countries in Europe and the US, maybe you could show some data on that as well because not all Brazilians fall for the mainstream media narrative anymore

[@davibnovaes]

if you have a terrain in brasil, 80% of the vegetation must be originaly preserve by the law in brasil. deforestation exist in brasil, but not the way of most people out of brasil say

[@keepwalkingdude]

Bozomion detectado. Eles sempre vao falar de outros problemas para nao terem que debater o problema que esta sendo abordado, por isso esse tipo de gente nao trabalha em minha empresa, sao experts em dar desculpas e incapazes de darem uma solucao. A melhor coisa sobre esse Bozo é que ele tornou mais facil identificar os idiotas que pensam igual a ele.

[@andremacedo8463]

@@davibnovaes como se o desmatamento na Amazônia fosse legal e respeitasse esses limites né kkkkkkkkk cada uma

[@CarlonHardt]

These are a classic Bolsonaro argument and his followers repeat without thinking. Brazil is one of the biggest deforastation countries in the world. We are litteraly burning our biggest asset just to make profit for a few already millionaire cattle raisers. It is very sad. Deforastation has only increased in Bolsonaro administration. He is a enviroment criminal.

[@marceloalmeida93]

@@CarlonHardt do you have any data that proves that he’s the one that caused fires? And why don’t you also talk about countries in general instead of just slamming Brazil on this topic? I’m pretty sure we have a lot more preservation than the US and Europe ever had, I mean proportionately...it’s easy to label people instead of actually talking about the issue at hand on a global scale

[@nathandossantos2514]

Eu vendo um vídeo internacional falando do Brasil porém não tem legendas em português 🤡

[@denisedias9193]

Na tela do vídeo tem um quadrado embaixo que é ativado para legenda. Ao lado tem uma bolinha tipo roldana, clica nela e aparecerá legenda em inglês. Clique em cima dessa legenda e aparecerá qual língua vc quer a tradução. Vai aparecer português em ordem alfabética.

[@ThiagoMoreiraMatos]

Não tem a opção de legenda legenda português, camarada

[@ThiagoVksy]

O vídeo é falando do Brasil, mas não para brasileiros.

[@GibaGouvea]

Vídeo internacional = língua internacional = Inglês

[@___alessandro.337]

Têm opção de legenda em português sim !!!

[@visaoholistica7253]

🇧🇷➡Língua portuguesa, a melhor língua de comunicação do mundo!

[@vladimirputout2461]

Porra nenhuma

[@tehsantana]

verdade

[@ThiagoMoreiraMatos]

Eu gostaria de falar inglês e nao português. Ou espanhol ou francês. Português é uma língua extremamente complexa e difícil

[@Leohots]

Português é muito zuado...

[@obolsopetista5710]

Claro, por isso que o brasileiro fala " vou di a pé", "na onde", "poblema"... excelente língua até para nós! Kkk

[@titus_philemon]

You can tell how they even see Brazil by the shots chosen to this bad video (Favelas, Indians and the Amazon)... Nothing inside the big cities, factories, farms & stores which is where Brazilians are, work and make the economy turn.

[@rtrramon]

Yes, its turning to end of well

[@andarilho_31]

Exactly. Over 80% of Brazillians live in urbanized cities, I don't get why foreigners have such a dumb vision of us.

[@Alexandre.10]

Rum pois é muitos estrangeiros vem aqui e ficam até de bobeira pois eles só veem o Brasil pelas lentes da mídia

[@lovebooks4803]

não intessa, favelas nem deveriam existir, se existem é pq o país falhou até em dar moradia digna

[@lovebooks4803]

@@andarilho_31 se existe favela o país é subdesenvolvido

[@Eduardo-bg7sp]

Brazil with the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) has a much better future than with Europe, I have no doubt about it.

[@gffg387]

Não.

[@lucasryan4181]

The problem of BRICS is lack of democracy, authoritarianism present on both Russia and China are definitely a deal breaker.

[@C4lmaria]

*SO LONG AS WE DON'T THROW IT AWAY*

[@arpankumardas4221]

how ? , brazil does anything with china or russia , US will get angry about it

[@user-rv9um5xc3r]

@@arpankumardas4221 Isn't China our largest trading partner?

[@thiagovalmelo]

The problem with this article is that it only shows one side of the facts. There is no such thing as impartial journalism.

[@matheusrega7046]

impressive how americans dont even try to pronounce brazilian names

[@CarlonHardt]

luí ignacio loola da sillllva

[@Gadavillers-Panoir]

Yeah it’s pronounced Jive Ballsinair

[@cfwin1776]

Bolsonaro is the Brazilian version of Donald Trump. This should explain everything.

[@JohnnyJonathan]

He is not the Brazilian version of Trump. Americans makes that analogy just because they do not have any other analogy to make sense of him.

[@danyo6317]

You mean the economy is getting better and there is more job growth?

[@wumaobot]

@@danyo6317 economy getting better LOL

[@jcavs9847]

he's worse

[@lucasmagalhaes1718]

100% right

[@lucsplayer8966]

Liberalism didn't work. Put more liberalism. 10/10 solution.

[@morderus0033]

Me mostra o liberalismo, que eu te mostro o caminho do hospício.

[@b3ygghsas]

What liberalism? What kind of liberalism increases taxes, creates state owned companies and increases spending?

[@EverYuri]

liberalism in Brasil? are you sure about that?

[@ilviandante2040]

@@b3ygghsas he’s just parroting some politicians slogan

[@coolandy23]

The acronym is actually brics. It’s unfortunate that you felt the need to remove South Africa 🇿🇦

[@henriconfucius5559]

South Africa was incorporated much later on

[@azirmandias4191]

they were talking of the beggining of Brics in early 00'

[@wesley4604]

South Africa is a later partner of the group.

[@RodrigoSilva-dv9xo]

The group was formed in 2006, composed by the four members: Brazil, China, Russia and India. Later on, in 2010, South Africa became a member as well.

[@caven7056]

SA is more of a paper tiger when compared to its BRICs counter parts. In all honesty it shouldn't even be there.

[@luigiranieridrums1630]

3:37 - “Bolsonaro's promise to tackle corruption…” If you wish to move to Brazil... Number one rule for you. Never believe a promise from a Brazilian politicians.

[@kakaquintiliano]

3 year without executive corruption scandal hehehe

[@mt34578]

Could you point me any case of corruption in his government over the past 3 years?

[@gabrielc.2177]

@@kakaquintiliano Rachadinha and Queiroz said hello

[@kakaquintiliano]

@@gabrielc.2177 o pt roubou 1 trilhão de reais brother kkkk

[@gabrielc.2177]

@@kakaquintiliano E eu falei que não roubou? Tá errado também Kkkkk mania de cobrir um erro com outro erro em parceiro, vê se cresce

[@diogo082]

Laura Carvalho... an economy advisor for the Socialist party(PSOL). Totaly biased video.

[@SERGIO-cr6uy]

Is that so, Bolsotario? How convenient for you, ain't it?

[@CB0408]

You know what is biased? Ad hominem comments.

[@Akephalos204]

TLDR a total clusterfuck

[@WICTORHUGO01]

The graphs of GDP changes shown in 01:00 are completely wrong.

[@Sanscripter]

Source?

[@egosirius]

Source: PT (Workers Party)

[@Inglescomgus]

Do you have better data than OECD?

[@ConstantinoMRL]

This entire video is just straight bullcrap.

[@lucasmate1582]

Laura Carvalho is a well known left wing economist, She supported all Dilma's economics policies the same policies that led us to 13% unemployment and 2 years of recession.

[@victorluiz9834]

She may be from the Left, and whats the problem? She recognize some error, Will the Right and Paulo Guedes do the same? They did some disastrous things too

[@lucasmate1582]

@@victorluiz9834 She didnt recognize nothing stop lying. She blames everybody and did want to spend even more. Guedes has blaming for what? Pandemics? Shut up

[@lucasmate1582]

@@victorluiz9834 Blames the presidente about the disastrous handling of COVID, not the minister of economics.

[@MrVitorao]

Talvez criar uma crise fiscal, furar o teto de gastos e mudar a lei de precatórios pra fazer encaixar um auxilio populista e desesperado para se reeleger não seja bom pra economia

[@lucasmate1582]

@@MrVitorao Criar uma crise fiscal? Pela primeira vez um governo vai sair com um gasto público menor do que entrou. A dívida que ia bater 100% do pib vai terminar em 80% do pib. Os precatórios são decisões judiciais, está além dos poderes de um ministro da economia. Um aumento inesperado de 64% em ano eleitoral ainda mais não e pra qualquer um. O teto foi reajustado, uma vez que precatório não tem previsibilidade e depende apenas do judiciário.

[@monarch3724]

GDP Per capita 12000$ in 2012 , 6000$ in 2022

[@henriquelaydner4080]

Just putting out numbers without context says absolutely nothing. US$ 2012 = R$2.07, PC GDP = R$24.840 US$ 2022 = R$5,27 PC GDP = R$31.620

[@VictorSilva-qf2tu]

E o dólar aumentou quanto ? Faça a proporção

[@georgesousa7006]

@@henriquelaydner4080 Bandidonaro, the Biggest Bandit that ever roamed the Earth, is destroying Brazil 🤦🏻 Tchupa 🐮 👉👉

[@georgesousa7006]

@@VictorSilva-qf2tu passador de pano passa mal 😂 🐮 👉👉

[@VictorSilva-qf2tu]

@@georgesousa7006 e o burro ri

[@Arthur-im8ct]

Middle income trap. Also, historically corrupt and inefficient institutions (given to us by the Portuguese colonization and never really burned down and rebuilt).

[@gleitsonSalles]

Oh yeah, we should have being colonized by the British. We would be like Kenia now

[@Joleyn-Joy]

@@gleitsonSalles Kenya GDP growth by percentage was bigger than Brazil in 2021, reaching 5,9%.

[@RodrigoSilva-dv9xo]

I agree with Gleitson. The colonizer's flag wouldn't have changed the current outcome. Actually, who said this was the historian Boris Fausto. The problems that led to the crisis are modern and were caused by the stepping down of public investments in the economy.

[@goncalomeneses5611]

Grande desculpa esfarrapada mas que explica bem o teu estado.

[@heatherfeather9951]

"In many areas in Brazil there is no pond for this said man to fish." That's a very accurate analogy.

[@miriammartinez4891]

You know nothing about Brasil....invite you to come and SEE the reality! Dont trust in everything you see in the tendencious media

[@mysteriousv4751]

@@miriammartinez4891 Sim, ele vai sair do conforto norte-americano/europeu dele pra vir ver a realidade que já foi mostrada no vídeo, me poupe.

[@JoaoPedro-wb5hk]

@@miriammartinez4891 Seriously? What kind of media is reliable? Oh, I get it. WhatsApp groups! Come on! All the information provided in this video is not only reliable but data-based.

[@benderthegreat4728]

@@JoaoPedro-wb5hk Thats what you thinking. CNBC/CNN/CSBC is owned by the same company which is ran by Democrats. You can verify it yourself. Both interviewers are leftist. So this interview was pretty bias.

[@marquesherminio5589]

Well, Brazil have a amazing potential in the future I think, because now we have a politics war between left and right. In my opinion this is the must wrong of Brazil's polulation.

[@Samuel-fo4gv]

Eu já desisti, sem esperança..

[@EDMDarkstyle]

@@Samuel-fo4gv Entao tem que mudar de pais ué kkk

[@Samuel-fo4gv]

@@EDMDarkstyle kkkkk se fosse fácil, mas é um sonho.

[@SimSimi.]

*Que? Isso é bom de mais! tem que ter essa divisão entre vermes bandidos esquerdista e seres humanos sim.* *A esquerda brasileira é o maior responsável pelo o atraso do Brasil. Com suas ideias estúpidas, inúteis e utópicas.*

[@Julc6783]

@@Samuel-fo4gv O ponto de vista é algo muito interessante, o Brasil em relação ao mundo todo é um dos melhores países tirando alguns países da Europa Ocidental e EUA, Canadá e Austrália, mas em relação aos mais de 200 países o Brasil é um bom país, a questão é que o brasileiro foi influenciado ao longo da vida pela indústria cultural a odiar a sua própria existência, e assim não ter amor próprio e não ter uma sensação de pertencimento ao seu povo a sua gente. A pergunta que nós deveríamos fazer é: O que nós podemos fazer pelo nosso país? e não o que o país pode fazer por nós. Houve um estudo de um instituto de pesquisa Japonês que chegou a conclusão de que neste século os mega países vão dominar a economia mundial naturalmente, entenda-se mega países aqueles com maior território, maior população e maior projeção de crescimento, o mas quais são esses países? Eles definiram Rússia, China, EUA, Índia e Brasil, ou seja, somente 5 países terão o controle político, econômico e militar no globo.

[@jocelioferreira2679]

I'm Brazilian and I I thought the material quite realistic. In my opinion Brazil needs two plans, a short term plan and a long term plan! And people need to understand that not everything will work tomorrow! As for the Amazon, the Brazilian government would earn a lot of money from conservation, perhaps a management plan for scientific research.

[@LanceMoraes]

Porra mano, sobre a Amazônia, eles não tem moral nenhuma em fazer qualquer tipo de crítica. É como um morto de HIV criticar quem faz sexo com camisinha kkk ou uma grávida querer dar lição de como não engravidar

[@Gustangela]

@@LanceMoraes o que acontece é que a consciência da preservação ambiental é recente, apenas dos anos 80 pra frente. O Brasil demorou pra se desenvolver, diferente das outras nações. No mais, é uma vantagem ter grandes florestas, sem elas nosso regime de chuvas seria pior, e um deserto é muito menos valioso do que uma floresta. É só saber desenvolver a região sem precisar derrubar tudo.

[@LanceMoraes]

@@Gustangela Eles derrubaram tudo, o Brasil está longe de fazer isso, além de que não existe nada pior para a preservação que pobreza absurda que existe lá na região amazônica. E ao mesmo tempo, não precisa desmatar para ter melhorar economicamente, a China poderia servir de exemplo, mas seria caso a caso, em vários casos eles desmatam tudo

[@Gustangela]

​@@LanceMoraes eles NÃO derrubaram tudo. Existem extensas regiões florestais na América do Norte e Europa. A diferença é que a riqueza biológica/ambiental deles é muito baixa, pois são regiões temperadas.

[@jocelioferreira2679]

@@Gustangela kkkkkkkkk... Seus comentários são muito bons, realista e engraçado! Eu acho que eles não têm moral mesmo, mas eles se arrependem, pelo menos nos EUA. Eu já assisti palestra nos EUA dos caras dizendo que um grande problema na biodiversidade deles é que eles contaram as florestas deles com estradas, linha férrea e etc... O que destruiu muito a biodiversidade num efeito em cadeia.

[@andre22460]

Gustavo Ribeiro said in the video that Bolsonaro's approach to the high murderers rate in Brazil was wrong. But he failed to say that in the first year of President Bolsonaro, the rate of murderers dropped 20% yearly. Journalists should report facts, not opinions.

[@andre22460]

Brazil used to have a high rate of people invading productive farmlands, destroying crops and expelling the owners of the land. After Bolsonaro became the president, those invasions stopped happening.

[@brunomazetti]

Not only that, but he gave out opinions as if they were facts when describing his take on solving systemic crime. It is not real journalism it's really just left wing bullshit.

[@andre22460]

@@brunomazetti it is to easy to be a journalist these days. You just have to throw out your own opinions as if they were facts and hide the actual facts

[@MrZekinhaluiz]

The guys in this comment tree are all neo nazis. Just so you don't fall for them. Xoxo.

[@andre22460]

What guys?

[@marcelo1689]

Only Chile and Mexico started vaccination in 2020 in Latin America. 38.000 doses in total. By the end of January 2021 Brazil had already surpassed both in vaccination PER CAPITA.

[@luizlapa2245]

fora que logo após o começo da vacinação o brasil já estava de igual para igual com outros países da américa latina, mas a mídia negacionista não percebe isso/ não quer que as pessoas saibam disso.

[@IsabellaCoelho]

@@luizlapa2245 isso pq o Brasil tem a "cultura da vacina" criada pelo Zé Gotinha na década de 80 (se não me engano). E por isso, houve demanda da população pela vacina, se fosse depender do presidente.... enfim, basta olhar a última declaração dele, onde ele publicamente afirmou que as vacinas não eram seguras e que a clroquina era eficiente.

[@olooeez]

@@IsabellaCoelho Exatamente.

[@pakku..4326]

of course Brazil has more population than this these two countries added together

[@SuperBe2011]

This economist is a joke in Brazil !!!!

[@SERGIO-cr6uy]

And so are you... Mr Bolsotario!

[@Pirata_Vermelho]

This is our little dark age

[@angelinapaula6687]

Kkkkkkkkkkkk Dark Ages of Journalism. so i would agree

[@diegojustino598]

Hahahahahahahha

[@daniloaugustodacruz162]

Hahahahahahaha

[@paulosergiodasilva3996]

How dare you NBC ! Respect the Volters ……

[@r4qu3l50]

But…you need to remember that he had to deal with the pandemic crisis, he picked up all the dirt that was left behind from previous governments and completed a few things.

[@icaropereira3218]

He helped his friends, protected outdated business and anyone who lobbies enough. Which hurt the poorer and left our country without technology development, all science research has been slashed.

[@anaodetoca5698]

Oque ferrou os pobres foi a esquerda, desde 89 nosso indice de produçao cresceu só 0,4%... bolsa na epoca lula andava de lado... não temos nem montadoras brasileiras, tudo é importado

[@smartroom613]

Anao, pega no meu com as duas “mão”

[@joaodebarroart]

@@pedroaadutra vc falou: pare de deitar

[@CB0408]

If Brazil blindly integrates itself to the world economy following free trade and neoliberalism, it will be a supplier of raw material, which is not enough to develop a country a 200m+. Brazil, however, has the state resources to drive its development in a more sovereign fashion.

[@RichardEricThompson]

Ridiculous.

[@ARCANODESINE]

you basically described brazil's situation rn

[@marechaltukhachevsky2909]

@@RichardEricThompson South Korea and China are ridiculous according to you, wake up liberal.

[@user-rv9um5xc3r]

@@marechaltukhachevsky2909 Dude, you wouldn't survive a week as a chinese average worker.

[@user-rv9um5xc3r]

You really need to learn about comparative advantage, mate.

[@pedroaragaodefreitas1758]

It's sad to see that this analysis focuses so much on public policy and so little on actual economic activity. I'm a huge fan of CNBC's video essays, but the ones on the main channel tend to present much deeper and broader insights. Brasil, much like the USA, is a very regionalized country, with each region offering different possibilities in terms of resources, labor and overall industry potential. And even on the topic of public policy as a driver of economic growth, local governments have a lot to play here. For example, several US states have made themselves hubs for specific industries, among other things by huge tax incentives, and it's been a long while since this kind of thing was being discussed in Brasil. Most states are fiscally broke, and so politically divided that nothing gets done for fear of losing the next election by upsetting one of the 'sides'.

[@walkwithdeath]

Obrigado! Tava procurando esse comentario! One of the main reasons as to why Brazil fails to recover (time and time again!) is our low productivity and inefficiency - we use a tremendous amount of resources (labour, energy, etc.) but the output is disappointing. Anyone who has ever washed their car in Brazil knows what I am talking about!

[@luisamaria3068]

@@walkwithdeath brazil need economic liberty and free market

[@brunomazetti]

@@walkwithdeath and yet those points haven't even been mentioned in the video, as I said before, they are so focused on their agenda that it derails them from the real criticism to be made.

[@lisboaluk]

@Fabricio Costa o melhor programa social é emprego, cara.

[@lisboaluk]

@Fabricio Costa depois q resolver este , vêm os outros. Se fizer o contrário, só dá problema.

[@juliomac2007]

“Then the government ran out of money “ ? That didn’t happen!

[@joaquimjunior7892]

I couldn't even finish to watch. That "reporter" and academic lied in all words they've said!

[@greggieo]

Bolsonaro is the leader of the free world. ❤️ 🇧🇷

[@DANILOLAURINDOARAUJO]

Muder rate dropped from 60k homicides to 22k in 2021, almost 64%.

[@angelinapaula6687]

Esse número entre outros não são bons para a narrativa dos “”jornalistas””

[@gustavoandrade58]

Qual foi a política adotada que fez esse número cair? Já que existem outras explicações como pessoas ficando mais em casa por causa da pandemia. Mas, se você tem um exemplo de causalidade de algo que o governo fez, nos demonstre por favor.

[@ruamcarlos6767]

Fonte: Comic sans Fonte: Meus status do zapzap Fonte: dos desejos Fonte: Vozes na minha cabeça

[@Jubvarela]

CNBC, if your intention is to have an impartial reporting, please interview also specialists not aligned with the oposition Labour's Party.

[@henriqueg374]

In Brazil, the judges of STF create a norm/law that the Police cant go into the favelas (Rio de Janeiro). So If a worker who delivery pizzas (motoboy) has his motorcycle stolen and go to the officers with GPS Tracker and say "My motorcycle is there, u can get It back?", The officers dont have permission to engage and try to get It back. This is a Shame for ALL of us. The judge was indicate by Lula/Dilma.

[@Blckk89]

"What's holding back Brazil's economic recovery?" The answer is in the thumbnail

[@joaopedrobittencourt9524]

"Proto-Fascist Joke", that's how i put his disastrous legacy, if you can call one. And just to point one thing: It wasn't his ideia nor interest to create the $110 monthly help, it came from the left-wing opposition.

[@luanel2036]

Is it just me or this video title has some kind of grammar error? Or at the very least something strange abt "Brazil's Bolsonaro"

[@LucianCanad]

It means "Bolsonaro from Brazil". He might be a household name for us (unfortunately), but there's a reasonable chance a foreigner who reads the name will go "Who?". You might be imagining the sentence should read as "Bolsonaro's Brazil", as in, Brazil how he, gods willing, will leave it next year.

[@ConstantinoMRL]

This entire video is an error

[@luanel2036]

@@ConstantinoMRL você é o erro, vai defende bandido em outro lugar

[@bethdealmeida6789]

I pray Brazilians are recognizing that they deserve a president that looks after the poor, working class, marginalized, every day Brazilian which, ironically, is the MAJORITY! The pandemic, natural disasters and environmental issues, weakened economy, inflation, increased homelessness, are all triggers and CHANCES for a president to rise, defend his/her people and show some empathy...at least! This guy... Brazilians stay alert!

[@helenavicentini8383]

That’s why is Bolsonaro in 2022 again!

[@mtulio6422]

In 2020 there was a thing called covid, so...

[@Jemz35]

Leftists always manipulate facts to suit their agenda.

[@Charvak-Atheist]

@@Jemz35 yes

[@mtulio6422]

@Thiago Andrade os dados mostram que você está errado. Mas eu te entendo, o ódio é mais importante que a realidade

[@Artwr]

Literalmente tirando o brazil e outras rebpublicas de banana, o mundo todo ta em crescimento economico.

[@mtulio6422]

@@Artwr Literalmente? Analfabeto kkkkk

[@Felipe-lh3ph]

Se você é brasileiro e está assistindo isso, parabéns. São poucos os que têm privilégio de entender inglês ;)

[@lgustavopalmieri]

O privilégio de gastar alguns minutos para perceber um panfleto político anti-Brasil.

[@anaodetoca5698]

@@lgustavopalmieri panfleto anti brasil é o lula dizendo que vai interferir na economia

[@georgesousa7006]

@@anaodetoca5698 panfleto antibrasil é Bandidonaro e Paulo Jegues destruindo a economia 🤦🏻 O resto é estatística. Contra fatos não há argumentos 🐮 👉👉

[@BlackSunRX2008]

Fodaci?

[@henriqueb8538]

E isso é motivo de parabéns por que? Estranho demais. Meu inglês é fruto de estudo e privilégio, e por suposto eu teria que saber de qualquer forma.

[@danielmessi1092]

Yes.

[@Jonathan-zi7kh]

I'm Brazilian, that's not real journalism.

[@raez9424]

7:19 when those companies take your anti government stuff down, you know It's true😂

[@rikkaku6358]

Brasil

[@cafurin2857]

We Brazilians hate politicians but love the state

[@hjkl44132]

Teach a man to fish and he’ll still vote for the person who gave him a fish

[@gbic100]

It's funny seeing Laura explaining that the 2014 crisis was only caused by the decrease in the prices of our products, something that should be foreseen in a commodity based economy, and not put in the factor the extremely increasing public expandings of the Lula and Dilma governments and focus on thew companies that were later discovered to be involved on corruption. Also Bolsonaro who initially thought that making a more liberal economy while jn the elections would be his way to power, soon got in the Brazilian game of populism and power juggling with the political elite, the things he criticized in his campaign. Brazil unfortunately is out of options of politicians that can work in the long term for the nation's economy.

[@marcelino6043]

Amigo, li e concordo em absolutamente tudo que disse. Bozo e Lula são dois populistas, mas a população ao menos sabe o que significa essa palavra...

[@iampsico]

The colombian sondtrack at the background is the best.

[@themarcel508]

Brazil has the lowest inflation in G20, its GDP growth is greater than China. Our unemployment rate is the lowest in years! It’s not just about Government social support, the private sector is investing more than ever. Brazil still have to make a great structure reforms, but we did reforms in reail secto, cabotage, sanitation, startups and etc. There’s a greet legacy of liberalism on this administration.

[@breno.luvewigg]

please foreigners Do you want to know if the current government is moving towards the process? Wait for the results of this year's elections, which will be held in Brazil.

[@user-ls4cs1wd2w]

Bolsonaro vai perder 🙏

[@bpspoa]

@@user-ls4cs1wd2w claro, a prova disso é o que acontece quando Lula sai na rua.

[@user-ls4cs1wd2w]

@@bpspoa o fato dos apoiadores do Bolsonaro serem psicóticos não muda o fato dele ser o candidato mais popular até agora e de Bolsonaro perder para todos no segundo turno

[@stewcoil2481]

55 to 60,000 is a pretty wide spread.

[@jalexanderevans]

Haha

[@RichardEricThompson]

They forget to say that these numbers have come down significantly since Bolsonaro was elected. Funny that, as in the video they say his ideas wouldn't improve anything. Wrong! They have! Two consecutive years of fall in the homicide rate, something never seen since redemocratization. These people can have facts thrown in their faces, and still deny it.

[@munniz8032]

They put government opponents to give their version of the economic legacy. Very biased. Brazil will unfortunately hardly change, as this would imply sacrificing the interests of public officials (including the opponents of this video), in addition to favored businessmen.

[@joselevicanasenjo2171]

🤔 esse documentário é interessante mas está bitolado. Gostaria de entender melhor com fatos os pontos negativos do governo. Menciona alguns, mas outros ficam em aberto.

[@alexandrenascimento7212]

situation in Brazil is complicated. leftist government has 19 people convicted of curruption talking on ministries.

[@32620890]

Brazil stock market has a lot of monopoly companies with cash to buy others and showing good earnings report. Althoulgh all the problems, Brazil has few enterprise in stock market, but big part of that, surpass the country problems. One of the biggest problem in Brazil is in the public sector, that are too big and too much expensive for the citizens.

[@MrZekinhaluiz]

Tell me you don't know anything about the economy and the state without telling me so. Me conte que você não entende nada de economia e estado sem me falar que não entende.

[@32620890]

@@MrZekinhaluiz what's wrong about it: One of the biggest problem in Brazil is in the public sector, that are too big and too much expensive for the citizens. If you prove me the brazilian people are rich enough to pay the bill, I admit I don't know anything about the state.

[@MrZekinhaluiz]

@@32620890 fala em português, anta, só tem brasileiro aqui.

[@juniodilon]

I’m Brazilian citizen. I’m no longer living there. But I know how the things works there. This documentary seems something more political than a real information about Brazil situation right now. Brazil (and Brazilians) has only one problem, just one! Poor Education! So then, the corrupt country behavior, isn’t a politician privilege, but, unfortunately, a Brazilian way of life for the most part of the people. When the people begin to realize that they are the source of their own problems, a new way will start to be build. An educated and good behaved people will not agree with an mismanaged country as it’s since 1500 (year of the European colonization beginning… running until present day, by different ways, of course). There are great people with the skills and the knowledge to change the country, but fight against the ”system” might cost a high price. So, that one’s use to choice move to a Brazil State where the life will work better or decide to move abroad. Sometimes, move ourselves out of the “system” (or place) is easier then try to change the “system” (the place where you live).

[@ricardooliveira9830]

Cara, vc eh so um idiota que quer culpar as vitimas, o povo. O povo nao eh corrupto, mas sim roubado pelos corruptos.

[@ericreed4535]

Corruption and impunity are the enemies of the poor. Brasil is a little better than middle of the pack on the corruption index. It's frustrating as Brazil's potential always seems just out of reach. There are many things to like and respect about Brazil.

[@biscoito1r]

@@ricardooliveira9830 O povo apenas continua elegendo os mesmo políticos corruptos pq não receberam uma boa educação dada por esses mesmos políticos corruptos. Percebeu um padrão ?

[@marcelobitaraes2372]

@@ricardooliveira9830 Os políticos representam o povo. O povo é corrupto.

[@galdutro]

Sorry, but poor education only doesn’t cause the problem! You have countries like Argentina and Uruguay who have a much more educated population, but only that doesn’t cause economic growth! What Brazil has to focus is long term social programs, more focus on true low level technological development (infrastructure which upon other higher level technology can develop upon), and better international relations!

[@purew.a.s.p6369]

typical talking heads talking in circles

[@cumintercomercial5156]

BANDO DE TENDENCIOSOS E EU VENDO O BRASIL GRANDE.. CHORA COM A DESPIORA

[@carlosdiniz5480]

The background music translates well the stereotype of the Brazilian as a capoeira fighter, samba dancer and football fan, three things that, as a Brazilian, cause me aversion!

[@HOTLAPP]

shallow it ignored the main cause: current needed reforms being blocked. On a vicious institutional padlock! Current minority opposition, tied with long term corrupt politics, frequently appeal and judicialize any action and lost votes on legislative houses, all assure of the partially from the supreme court, that ends by rewriting executive administrative acts and legislation (even against recent jurisprudence) all support from broke mass media groups (who lost their main advertiser). Doing that legislative opposition breaks the institutional balance by submitting both legislative and executive to the high courts composed by 9 of 11 judges named by the last presidential group who lead all the corruption featuring “car wash”. Brazil faces a kind of judiciary dictatorship!

[@fabinho909090]

Well said my friend.

[@virgiliochagasresende6166]

your words are not true and you know it.

[@Lucas-vz4hk]

Bullshit

[@HOTLAPP]

@@fabinho909090 thx. Than I read curses in absence of arguments! hurled by defenders of love and peace! Before analyzing economics and social context, these people need to read and understand the meaning of words written in dictionaries.

[@HOTLAPP]

@@virgiliochagasresende6166 9 out 11 in STF, 26 in 33 on STJ, 16 years of left corruption, over 1890 politicians on “car wash”, 2 people killed (Celso Daniel and campinas Mayer) and around usd1 trillion lost in fines, bribes and fraudulent loans….. do you really know the meaning of the words you said!?

[@chethanshajan9047]

Brazil needs to ween itself off from ranching and commercial agriculture and industrialize ASAP...thats a major way of ending deforestation of the amazon.

[@Gabriel-Tomaz]

I think that Americans should worry about theirs Democracy and leave Brazil's problems to Brazilians. USA is responsible for many disasters in the world because they like to put his hands where no one is asking for.

[@ThiagoVksy]

International politics is relevant to everyone. How else would you know about u.s. disasters?

[@sulamy1955]

This is very biased. No one neutral or pro bolsonaro was interviewed

[@frankfernandes5]

Funny how we feel the need to talk about our political problems in English as if the first world countries would give a fuck 🤣. They do care a little about the Amazon Forest and products like Açaí ( which they can't even pronounce properly and keep annoyingly calling it AKAI ).

[@psikeyhackr6914]

What is the difference between GDP & NDP? What happens to the depreciation of durable consumer goods like cars, air conditioners and televisions? Economists treat air conditioners like bananas

[@stlouisix3]

They gave Bolsonaro no chance and now they're going to elect Lulu again and kick out Jair Bolsonaro.

[@luizcarlosquerido2943]

May the Gods listen you

[@dubsar]

It's called "terra arrasada".

[@loydi123]

Teve alguns erros grotescos na reportagem, nao falaram do principal problema do pais uma justiça que nao funciona e fica fazendo politica, que varias empresas saíram do pais devido a legislação trabalhista macabra e atrasada que impede o trabalhador de receber mais e o empresario de investir mais.

[@MrDarthsirius]

Só que não. Os números do emprego após duas reformas em 3 anos mostram o óbvio. Emprego não cresce nem diminui em função de diruitos. São investimentos e demanda em uma economia aquecida que geram postos de trabalho, com ou sem direitos. Nenhuma empresa saiu do Brasil por causa de direitos traabalhstas. Saíram porque o mercado consumidor não as suportou. Ford e Uber Eats são exemplos disso. Empresas que já vinham perdendo mercado para competidores melhores.

[@loydi123]

@@MrDarthsirius 2 Reforma onde, acho que nao estamos falando do mesmo pais. Os cara fantasia algo na mente e passa a acreditar que é real, eu prefiro viver no mundo real mesmo ele sendo cruel, macabro e triste.

[@Lucas-vz4hk]

Balela. Vcs não trocam a fita viu, meu Deus

[@shyamalchandradas3157]

It's really nicely ored

[@ryushogun9890]

A big state one..

[@AadhityaSrinivasaPanduRanganV]

When you gave power to right man the country also go in right direction

[@jcavs9847]

wrong power should be separated, divided and checked so that no man can abuse it

[@2pedroandrade]

Bolsonaro lead us so far right that we didn't realize he was taking us down a abyss

[@marcelleza]

A complete wasteland! Next question.

[@LeandrodeSouzaSilva10]

These economic "experts" presented in this video don't understand anything, today we have greater security and a reduction in violence, these people in the video are the typical "security and capitalism for me" "violence, socialism and egalitarian poverty" for you, more ridiculous that the traditional media itself and even after almost 4 years they didn't realize how much they are ashamed with their empty words thinking that the Brazilian swallows this, only those who somehow are part of some cartel or money scheme buy this idea, or do you want fat checks from the federal government like Lula and Dilma used to give to these so-called journalists whose diploma isn't even good for wiping their ass!

[@simoleon1781]

Vai dormir gado

[@simoleon1781]

Falou mal do seu amado e se doeu todo

[@RichardEricThompson]

You should get your facts straight. Consult some serious people instead of these politically biased people.

[@bluegas]

Even when Brazil surpassed UK’s economy one must think UK has 67 million people and Brazil 210 million. Per capita Brazil is more than triple pooer than UK 😔🙈

[@ravenin9353]

Even being the poorest triple per capita, it passed. The Brazilian potential is to be richer than all of Europe.

[@goodhunter1878]

@@ravenin9353 I don't see that potential. We are culturally obsessed with 'natural resources' and hate acutal productive work. Aiming to have profit is seen as shameful and evil. We as the rest of Latin America are destined to an unending stream of radical left "Great Leader" central planners. Lulas and Castros and Maduros and Kirchners are our "potential"

[@fabiojr15]

Mito 😎👉👉

[@maryanjustynski8788]

Ele no !!!!

[@lucaslouzada44]

Far from being a Bolsonaro supporter, I see clearly how deeply politically biased this analysis is. Economic problems were inevitable as the rate of expenditure didn’t cease to grow much after the end of the commodity boom in China - which was the real reason for the huge growth in the beginning of this century - became evident in 2012. Bolsonaro is a terrible president, but, truth to be told, his administration is indisputably better designed and run than Dilma’s - not to mention the corruption scandals that were much more numerous, of an incomparably larger financial magnitude and absolutely far more preposterous at the level of its legal and moral conception. Unfortunately the foreign media gets drawn into the mainstream brazilian media’s discourse - which is deservedly highly critical of Bolsonaro, by the way - and then allow those who wish to fortget the long list of crimes and very many episodes of sheer political incompetence and public money mismanagement that occurred during the Workers’ Party rule. Just another eloquent example of the partisan journalism that has become commonplace nowadays in this Country, using the sitting presindent as a representative of his administration to hide its obvious silver linings and trying to alienate the former left presidents’ disastrous administrations from their public persona, as if they were some sort of powerless monarchs in a fatalist world-stage and not the ones responsible for such a shameful predicament. Looks like electoral campaigns started much earlier this time, as the truth is ready to be tramped upon in such a pathetic fashion…

[@natanbq]

Aqui vemos um exemplo de quem gosta de pagar 7 reais na gasolina, gosta de perder direitos e de "negociar" com o patrão.

[@natanbq]

@@babaw é e o PT inventou a corrupção, antes não existia e depois o Temer e o Bozo não roubaram nada não né?

[@lucaslouzada44]

@@natanbq Eis aqui um exemplo de petista que não entende nada de economia e acredita que os preços explicam o sucesso ou o fracasso de um governante. Mas você tem razão, o melhor seria ter um governante do PT marretando os preços dos combustíveis pra se reeleger - ou eleger sua sucessora - com o prejuízo gigantesco da Petrobras em função do câmbio e dos preços internacionais do petróleo. Gente como você mostra bem qual o futuro inevitável desse país…

[@t.k3650]

@@lucaslouzada44 E que também nunca estudou história para saber o resultado de congelamento de preços kkkkk

[@crystianvasconcelos1951]

@@t.k3650 e quando dá merda os idiota s de esquerda ficam surpresos com o resultado não é como tiveram inúmeros exemplos disso acontecimentos anteriormente

[@joaopadua7134]

E O PT HEIN? E O LULA?

[@luizlapa2245]

E O BOLSONARO? E O MITO?

[@lutti9437]

@@luizlapa2245 BOLSONARO AINDA COM TODOS DEFEITOS DA DE 10 X 0 NO COMUNISTA CORRUPTO...

[@warthk]

None. Next question !

[@maiscosmeticos6274]

Brazil is being censored, help! 🇧🇷🙏

[@Tiraca9]

Weak sources and common stereotypes. What a 15 min waste of my time.

[@francechou]

We need more investment in education and science. Poverty is increasing and ALL the social gains in the last 25 years are Lost. The country is on the verge of uncontrolable inflation again. Thousands os miles of deforastation for cattle and more crops. Rivers in the Amazon are contaminated with Mercury and mud (an ecological diasaster) Because government officials allowed the exploration of Gold and other minerals.

[@seadkolasinac7220]

@Rafael S Macron was right, and the whole world agrees with him. It's just moron Bolsominions who think it's okay to destroy the Amazon

[@MrDarthsirius]

​@Rafael S Romanticizing the gold diggers much? The working masses are far from the forest, toiling in the cities, or in the small family fields, making just enough to pay their bills. The powerful agro bosses and the banks need not your passionate defense. So wake up, work enough, study hard, spend time with your loved ones. Peace.

[@pedronardes-]

@@seadkolasinac7220 Exactly. It's wild how our right wingers are ok with destroying our own country because "we can do whatever we want in our land", while most brazilians will suffer even more because of that.

[@felipesanders4038]

Can't believe how much lies ...

[@falexandre7554]

Alguém traduz pfv; tão falando bem ou mal do Brasil?

[@flanelinhayoutuber9297]

Mal

[@jnsmaffini]

Assistindo esse vídeo até eu fiquei com medo de morar no Brasil, imagina os estrangeiros vendo isso. Por isso ninguém vem pra cá e o gringo que se arrisca vir, nunca mais quer ir embora. Brasil é o melhor país do mundo. Realmente tem seus problemas como qualquer outro, mas nós mesmos só focamos nisso e não no que temos de bom.

[@obolsopetista5710]

Kkkkk melhor país do mundo!? Caramba, imagina o resto..

[@jnsmaffini]

@@obolsopetista5710 já morei em 5 países inclusive EUA e posso afirmar isso.

[@obolsopetista5710]

@@jnsmaffini o planeta terra é formado por aproximadamente 195 paises, ou seja, você ja morou em menos 3% do mundo. Pergunta para um suíço se ele acha a mesma coisa ou um americano, canadense...

[@jnsmaffini]

@@obolsopetista5710 já perguntei, inclusive como te falei morava lá, os americanos reclamam muito dos EUA, dos benefícios dados aos que não trabalham, da segurança, dos índios e seus direitos, dos preços dos combustíveis.... Ou seja, não importa pra onde se vai irão ter problemas e as vezes achamos até injusto, pois comparados aos nossos e são tão pequenos. Por isso digo que aqui é muito bom, não tem neve onde fiquei 5meses só vendo branco, não tem terremoto, furacão, tornado, o povo é muito receptivo, a agricultura provém de tudo. Nos países que vc mencionou desde uma banana é importada. Mas com certeza tua vivência é bem superior a minha, essa é só minha experiência por isso falo que aqui é o melhor país do mundo.

[@Heechan.]

I traveled to Brazil from the end of last year to January of this year. There were many homeless people on the street, and the stench was difficult to bear. I was surprised to see the ridiculously expensive prices compared to the local people's salaries, and it was difficult to even comfortably shoot with a camera because of the bad security. This is by no means the best country.

[@jonathanteixeira7748]

The true is Brazil is still a colony , the elite know that and keep that way , midia try to give other explanations but is pretty clear it’s colony

[@mauriciodls]

Mijair Bolsoshower

[@hitalosiqueira]

Death, hunger and hate

[@rhustoxfordinner]

The vaccination campaign in Brazil has been a complete success and it started about 2021 Jan/Fev just like most of the world So what the economics teacher said about this is simply not true

[@silverknightgundam1196]

Yeah right what about the emails of vaccine manufacturers who were ignored, the disinformation, the little flu, the denial and other actions?

It started DESPITE Bolsonaro best effort to sabotage it. He went so far as to replace leadership on ANVISA to prevent the agency from authorizing vaccines. Not to mention the scandal in trying to collect a bribe from Pfizer and subsequently refusing to buy from them when we needed the most! His efforts were only thwarted by a massive backlash from the public opinion. What you are repeating here, Rafael, is just another misinformation campaign fabricated by the Bolsonaros.

[@pakku..4326]

bolsonaro denies vaccine until today, he sabotaged the vaccination campaign since the beggining