COACH ELIZA VS TILLY TOP HANDLE SATCHEL| WHICH ONE SHOULD I KEEP?

[@SimplyDee9301]

Great Comparison! Both bags are so Beautiful! This is Hard Sis! I believe there's enough difference to keep them both.🤦🏾‍♀️🤷🏾‍♀️

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you!

[@galegibbs5946]

Agreed.

[@sofyameytus710]

Love Eliza the most! I myself battling between beige and chalk colors😊❤

[@Drelovesbags]

They are both so pretty it’s hard to decide

[@sofyameytus710]

@@Drelovesbagsthey are so rich and classy looking!!!!❤❤❤

[@Drelovesbags]

I know right!

[@kimilahenry2955]

I prefer the Eliza, I ordered her this week..awaiting her arrival. I bought her as a Dressy bag to wear for special occasions such as date night, church, weddings etc.. I also have a few pair of dressy shoes to pair with her ❤ both bags are beautiful… I would carry the quilted bags as a everyday bag and Eliza for special occasions 🥰

[@Drelovesbags]

I think I prefer the Eliza as well! And I agree she’s perfect for special occasions. What color did you get ? Thank you so much for watching!

[@kimilahenry2955]

I bought the tan color

[@Drelovesbags]

@kimilahenry2955 do you like it?

[@kimilahenry2955]

@@Drelovesbags yes I do… I haven’t carried her yet but I love the color and shape…also the leather doesn’t feel like an outlet bag reminds me of a boutique Coach bag.

[@Drelovesbags]

@kimilahenry2955 I keep telling people it’s retail quality.

[@sloftin]

The hardware on the turn lock looks better, IMO.

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank for watching! A lot of people prefer the more subtle branding on the turnlock

[@tangiessubtleluxuries]

I would keep both handbags. The reason being bc the difference in the hardware. They are both beautiful handbags. ❤❤❤

[@Drelovesbags]

I think I will! Thx for watching

[@DianaStewart-cu7fj]

I would keep both❤

[@Drelovesbags]

I think I am

[@SuzWhat]

They are both beautiful and versatile. A. I always go with keeping both if you don’t feel overwhelmed by having both. B. That being said, if you think you will reach for one over the other consistently, you may end up getting rid of one anyway. C. I’m not much help. D. They both look AWESOME on you. E. I think you are leaning toward the Eliza based on your observations. 💭 Thanks for sharing! Peace and love..Suz What ☮️💛

[@Drelovesbags]

Suz we think so much alike which is why I needed help in the first place 😂. Thx for watching

[@Jploveslv]

Lol @ C 😅

[@Drelovesbags]

@@Jploveslv IKR😂

[@stephaniecraft9827]

Eliza simple and beautiful

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you. I think so too

[@julievenus3670]

Ohhhh my! I didn't even know there was a Tilly!!! We both love our Eliza's!! I have the green, black/gold, and i just got the S/V Redwood ( it's beautiful, darker brown than redwood in RL). Girl, I'm with the Eliza. BTW...YOU ARE SO GORGEOUS ❤. I love your videos 🙏❤️

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you for the kind words 🥰. And thx for watching!

[@myPursesuitOfHappiness]

Both are beautiful. I think they are different enough with the different color hardware and the quilting. However If I had to choose I would go with Eliza. I think the silver hardware is fresh and modern looking. TFS and looking forward to seeing your choice. 🥰🌸☀️

[@Drelovesbags]

I think so too! Thx for watching and commenting 🥰

[@Jploveslv]

When you first asked if you should keep both, I was thinking....ummm yes mamm! They are both different enough. Especially because of the quilting. I love them 😊

[@Drelovesbags]

😂😂😂. I think I will actually. Thx for watching!

[@Jploveslv]

@@Drelovesbags 🤓

[@cherie351000]

I would keep both bags same color but one is quilted leather. One is wider

[@Drelovesbags]

I still have both 😂. Thx for watching

[@ebatle9021]

I would agree they are versatile, this is a hard one

[@Drelovesbags]

IKR! I think I’m keeping both. Thx for watching

[@TenaHales]

I have the Eliza in black, chalk, and green and I am absolutely in love with these bags! To me they are do beautiful and can be worn dressy and casual. I also love the other bag you showed us, so I would keep both because of the different color hardware. But if you decide that they are too much alike, I would keep the Eliza. But you have 2 beautiful bags, so this is a tough choice. 🤔

[@Drelovesbags]

I wanted the green sooo bad and missed out 😩. The Eliza may be one of the best outlet bags ever. I just can’t get over how nice it is. Thx for watching!

[@pattywilliams788]

I’m not going to be much help because I just got my Eliza day before yesterday and I am totally in love with her, Dre. I feel as you do that the Tilly is more casual than the Eliza. I think it’s because the flap on the front is more like a messenger style flap and is a more relaxed silhouette. The woven leather is on trend for 2024, but the smooth leather and the hardware on the Eliza is as well. Like you pointed out, you would have an easier time of choosing if they were different colors. I look forward to knowing what you decide to do. Great comparison.

[@Drelovesbags]

It’s a hard one lol. Thx for watching

[@joeltwo21]

Hi Dre, they are both beautiful. It comes down to the hardware. I love silver or pewter and tend to purchase according to that. Although I do have my fair share of brass or gold-toned hardware handbags. Come back and let us know which one you decided to keep and what helped you decide. tfs😁

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@turquoisepurple7sky151]

I have the Eliza it arrived yesterday I agree the Eliza looks more sophisticated and the Tilly looks less dressier. I love both. I hated I missed out on the Tilly, but I am glad I habe the Eliza. I would DEFINITELY KEEP BOTH.

[@Drelovesbags]

That’s the consensus 😂. What color did you get ?

[@turquoisepurple7sky151]

​@@DrelovesbagsThe white color and I just ordered tge Rowan satchel in the light blue .

[@Drelovesbags]

They had the soft green on the site a couple hours ago. There were 3 left

[@womanhabits84]

I like both 😊

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you! Thx for watching

[@Divinenubian]

Ok, they both have that divider! I really dislike that part. Guess I'll look at the mini dooney satchel instead

[@Drelovesbags]

I don’t care for the divider either. But it’s not a deal breaker for me. It’s just an extra compartment I never use lol

[@ladyb7588]

Ask yourself the question ? Which one has your heart more.......then, that will be your answer.

[@Drelovesbags]

Thank you!

[@PSAPublicShoppingAddict]

Dang this is a hard one Dre! I usually buy two colors when I can decide which color to get LOL. If I hada hada hada, the Eliza would be the one by a hair! That's it, that's all I got for you LOL :) hugs.

[@Drelovesbags]

That’s enough! Thx for watching 😂

[@mushroomngrass.]

The Eliza is giving me H Kelly vibes. I love her.i like the silver hardware better than THe gold it really fresh. I love the quilting on the other bag, but like you said the elizavisvdressier to me. Both are great. This is a hard choice but I’m picking the Eliza love her matching wallet!so cute anew see the wallets layout please and wha leather is hthe Eliza?if it’s cross grain ughanwhich has more weight? Heavier one has to go😊

[@Drelovesbags]

The leather is smooth on the Eliza, not a cross grain. Not gonna lie it reminds me of the leather on the bandit. Thanks for watching!

[@Divinenubian]

The tilly quitted is, my pick top handle is not my favorite, but I like that because it is not a coach. 😊

[@Drelovesbags]

Actually they’re both Coach bags

[@Divinenubian]

@@Drelovesbags oh wow ! How did I miss that part? Now I want one 😩

[@Drelovesbags]

@Divinenubian 😂😂😂

[@Divinenubian]

@@Drelovesbags I see them on poshmark! Are you selling one?

[@Drelovesbags]

@Divinenubian no. Thats not me

[@jenniferhusted48]

Based on how the Eliza looks stuffed, the clasp, and how nicely it sits cross body I pick Eliza! The Tilly is so pretty but the clasp would annoy me lol

[@Drelovesbags]

Yes she’s perfect! Coach really showed out with this one. Thx for watching!

[@brendalawson1935]

keep both

[@Drelovesbags]

I think I will. Thx for watching!

[@jsmith2747]

Keep the Eliza.

[@Drelovesbags]

I did 😂

[@imashygyrl65]

💌💌💌

[@SuzWhat]

When you said “2000” I was like “sounds legit” then you annotated “2020” and I was like…I knew Dre meant 4 years ago not 20. 😂😂😂

[@Drelovesbags]

When you’re real grown like me it’s pretty much the same anyway. What’s 20 years lol