Holbein Colored Pencil Review | Why I Regret Buying Them (But You Might Not)

Please remember this is my opinion ONLY. Take into consideration that mine doesn't match everyone else's, but that's because no two people experience or use pencils exactly the same.
Okay, so this is a nerve-wracking review to put up for me. If you have watched me long enough, you know that I'm not a fan of Holbeins. But hey, we're all different and we all experience pencils differently. That said, I feel I should share my experiences with Holbein, my gripes, and why I truly regret buying them. Does that mean they won't work for you?
Absolutely not! We are all different, but at least you have another perspective to consider when you think about whether or not this is the right investment, especially with the price tag.
QUICK UPDATE It looks like they do come in and out of availability still on Amazon Japan - so you might be able to snag them there cheaper. However, as I said in my review, I still wouldn't pay that because they just aren't for me, but you might have a chance to find them cheaper than Blick!
ITEMS MENTIONED IN THIS REVIEW:
Recommended:
12 Basic Holbein Colored Pencils: shrsl.com/32zk3
12 Pastel Holbein Colored Pencils: shrsl.com/32zjr
50 Pastel Holbein Colored Pencils: shrsl.com/32zjo
Holbein Soft White: shrsl.com/32zjy
If You're Ready to Go All In:
Holbein 150 Colored Pencils: shrsl.com/32zjt
Holbein Meltz (blending solution): shrsl.com/32zjn
#adultcoloring #holbein #coloredpencil reviews #holbeinreviews
-----------------------
SUPPORTING MY CHANNEL
The best way is to “like” my videos and share my content, comment and participate, and just enjoy the coloring community with me!
However, coloring can get expensive, so if you do wish to add a little extra to your contribution, you can do some of the following (but please keep in mind none of these are necessary!):
Amazon Wishlist: amzn.to/3ltjLyY
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/colorfullyoptimistic
-----------------------
SOCIAL MEDIA
Instagram: / colorfullyoptimistic
Join My Facebook Group: / 801975026969467
-----------------------
In some of my video descriptions, I may include affiliate links for coloring books and mediums I use. Using those links is no extra cost for you and there is no obligation to use them, but I do receive a small percent in return which just helps go toward funding my coloring habit so I can continually share it with you all!
Until next time, stay Colorfully Optimistic!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Quick update, you MAY be able to snag these on Amazon Japan still (they seem to go in and out). However, as I said in my review, I still wouldn't buy them for that, because the pencil itself (regardless of price) isn't for me. That said, you might be able to snag them cheaper via Amazon Japan if you want!

[@tammygeorge1638]

I love your honest opinion on them. I've got the white pencil. And it was a gift! I'm curious if all the pencils like the soft white! ? Because I know there's 2 different whites they have. Blick set for the 150, 429,00 a set. Nope! I wouldn't buy ether! Have you thought about selling them? I do color all different ways! If you're interested in selling, let me know! I want the Derwent luminous light fast pencils! The 100 set of them are only 280! I really want them bad! 😂 😂! . That's my wish pencils! 😊 ❤.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@tammygeorge1638 I love love the Derwent Lightfast. The soft white to me is not like the rest. A lot smoother, less sticky

[@rebeccaterry9428]

@@tammygeorge1638 if it is the soft white Holbein than No that pencil is softer than the rest of the pencils,that being said the lamp black is also softer IMO. I use pencils on photographs so I absolutely love the Holbeins

[@tammygeorge1638]

@@rebeccaterry9428 awesome! Thank you for the info. ❤👍

[@221b-Maker-Street]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Another vote for the Derwent Lightfast here! I live in the UK, and buying the full set in a wooden box last year was one of the rare occasions that something is cheaper here than in the US - they are absolutely _beautiful_ pencils.

[@jaimiec2404]

What i appreciate the most about this review, and something I wish everyone would do with all pencils they review, is that you described the coloring style and paper requirements to be successful with these pencils!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes, not all pencils love all paper. I mean even my Prismas, which I adore, I rarely use in Hanna K books because they require layers on that paper - and well, we've established I don't enjoy layers.

[@jaimiec2404]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic i don't enjoy a lot of layers either and I start out light handed but ALWAYS end heavy handed lol

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@jaimiec2404 Like I said, I've yielded to the skin gods because skin just needs layers and you can't escape it, but everything else nope.

[@ArtistJane]

I actually just released a video with an official statement from Holbein about the lightfast testing methods they use, and they are actually lightfast (I called the company up and they sent me that info - and it’s not a plug. I’m just commenting here because you may want to know that to clear up any confusion) That being said, colored pencils preferences are entirely personal. Just because you didn’t end up liking them doesn’t make your opinion invalid, and I’m sorry there were so many nasty comments from people. Especially the comment of you’re “just a colorist”. That’s just elitist and patronizing. Your opinion is valid, and it doesn’t have to be the majority. As your fellow KZbinr, I understand when people say nasty things, they can be very dehumanizing. It takes thick skin but we’re not all bulletproof. Just remember it’s more about the person being nasty than it it’ll ever be about you! ♥️🙌

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes! I saw that just a minute ago. I had some questions on that letter, actually. So, that was from Holbein Japan, right? For some reason, Holbein US says they don't use ASTM and use in-house, they've actually told multiple people this, which is making it rather confusing regarding their lightfast ratings, especially if their US reps are telling us they don't use ASTM LOL. I do appreciate your comment though Jane! Pencil choices are most definitely personal. I know you love your Holbeins, but I appreciate your kind words for sure, especially because you understand that a pencil doesn't work 100% across the board for us all and that's what's important. You are too sweet. I have actually watched you work with your Holbeins and thought gosh I wish I liked these things so I could do that haha.

[@ArtistJane]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Hey I’m sorry I didn’t see this until now! The letter I was received was from the US Holbein division and they collaborated with Holbein in Japan to come up with that official statement. I’m not sure who from Holbein was saying that, but I could see why that would be confusing. That’s why I wanted it from the horse’s mouth, so that there wasn’t any misunderstandings hopefully. Thank you for your kinds words! I do love my Holbeins and from what I see, you do amazing work with other pencils you love! I think it’s an all encompassing experience when it comes to art supplies, and what works for one person may not work for the next. I just can’t believe people actually bullied you over your opinion on pencils, of all things! Bullying is never ok, but when you think about it, it’s kinda crazy! People can have differing opinions even if something is well loved! KZbin can be a strange land and there’s usually more love shown than hate or ugliness, but there will always be some jerks out there. Hold your chin high because you’re doing amazing and you are awesome! ♥️🙌🎨👍✏️

[@mzebony]

@@ArtistJane hi Jane, I think it’s the year of cancel culture on the art supply companies. It started out with Arteza this year, now Holbein. Prismacolor is sitting in the corner sipping tea because it’s been in the cancel culture pool for years. We’ll see who is next, Derwent I’m looking at you lol.

[@sushifiggy]

Unfortunately, bullies are everywhere. Sometimes I think that these haters actually troll for people to bully. A sick hobby. Hang in there kid, don’t listen to the haters because they’re just going to hate anytime that they get a chance. It’s okay to agree to disagree, but in a respectful way; like grownups.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@sushifiggy Awe thank you Julie. And, I agree. No one should be penalized for not sharing popular opinion, but sadly, most don't see it that way lol

[@jaimiec2404]

Thank you for being brave enough to give your honest opinion and explain why you feel that way!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you very much Jaimie.

[@aliciabushman7806]

I appreciate this review. One thing I have come to accept is that there is no such thing as a perfect pencil. We have preferences based on how we color and the look we prefer. I have many sets of pencils and adjust for each set. I enjoy the differences because of their different palettes and overall look. I think that the holbeins would be really good for me. But I would expect to use them differently and let them guide me in their use. I think that we have the tendency to expect money to equal coming closer to perfection. We have to change that expectation. I think that you might still come to like these pencils. The palette has much to offer you. But that is my take. Do what makes you feel happy.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I do agree they have beautiful colors. I'm just not the layering type. Lots and lots of layers don't make me happy and I like to be in my happy place when coloring and creating art LOL. So if a pencil requires lots of layers, I'm just meh haha.

[@pennypop408]

Whats wrong with being a colorist Many of our great artists have been called that aka Van Gogh ect

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@pennypop408 it was not being called that but the way it was used. The person was telling me since I do my art in coloring books in not an artist and my opinion doesn't matter

[@pennypop408]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Well I think your opinion matters otherwise I would not bother to reply. But I know what you mean I"ve been in art shops and had the odd put down myself. Its nothing to me its their problem I don't intend to take it to heart. They just need a little more time to grow up:) Enjoy your art in whatever way you like, its your art after all.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@pennypop408 awe ty Penny!

[@ChristinaTodd1970]

Wow! I can’t believe another “artist” said a “colorist” isn’t an artist or coloring isn’t art! I’m so sorry. I got started on my art journey by coloring in coloring books and although watercolor is my jam now and I don’t color in books anymore I still could never match some of the colored pencil art created by “colorists.” Not only that but I think colorists definitely know their stuff when it comes to colored pencil. Art can be a snobby community and I hate that the community puts down colorists. Because, damn! You guys produce some stunning art.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe you are too sweet. I agree coloring is an art and the work some people create is like wow!

[@leesanchez8432]

I have seen some awesome coloring in books. That said, a person coloring in books is not an artist, because they are adding color to someone else's original drawing. To be a work of art it must be 100% original to you. That is why you cannot sell your original drawing and coloring in,of another person's photograph, because that breaks copyright law. So there is no reason for shame because you are a colorist, but if you do not create your own 100% original art you are not actually an artist. To those who might care, hope this is helpful.

[@ChristinaTodd1970]

@@leesanchez8432 I disagree. That sounds like a definition for a *professional* artist. Colorists can and do create art. They are filling in a silhouette or contour line drawing, that's it. The color palette, shading, etc are all decisions they make, not the original artist who designed the line drawing.

[@rebekah1362]

@@leesanchez8432 Hi Lee, this is actually not true. There are professional colorist, particularly for comic illustrators. They create the drawing, send it to an inkist (ink artist) and then on to a colorist. ;-)

[@mariamorjane]

@@ChristinaTodd1970 I agree with you, anyone that's drawing, painting, doing anything with a pencil or a brush is an artist! It doesn't matter if a person is coloring some design that wasn't produced by them, you are still an artist! Someone may ask... why am I here lol I saw someone did a bad review on Holbein's product, I was in shock since I can't imagine Holbein would have a bad product, so I had to check it out 😉

[@Elmcolors]

Great review, Kori!! When pencils are as expensive as these, you need to know what you’re getting into. Both the positive and negative sides of the pencil. Really appreciate this ☺️

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

So true! I mean even if I could get them at the Amazon Japan price, I still would have the same opinion on these. They just don't work for my style - but that doesn't mean they won't work for everyone.

[@princesslaika6606]

I really appreciate your honest experience/opinion with these pencils. That’s why your one of my favourite people to listen and watch. Thanks again.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you Laika, I really appreciate that.

[@prettybrwnwoman]

Thank you for this review. I am a beginning colorist (I don’t blend or layer anything) and watching lots of videos and seeing all the books, pencils and supplies it makes you want to get everything. You really reinforced for me considering my style and budget before buying new supplies.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Glad it was helpful! I do still always say eventually try them for yourself, even a few open stock, because they may end up being your thing :)

[@sweetart3299]

The most gorgeous pencils I have ever used and I have loads of colored pencil sets in a variety of price ranges to compare. I have found my Holbeins are top of the list as being far the most enjoyable. Could care less about light fastness. I don’t sell my art and are not sure of how many people watching this review actually do. If I did you can always sell numbered prints. So lightfastness is of no issue at all except for originals. All sets are pretty easily available now as well as open stock. I have a variety of quality papers and have used them on most with great results. Everyone has different budgets they may want to spend on their art but I can sure think of other hobbies and creative occupations that are much, much, more expensive then Holbein pencils. I have no issue at all with the price for such a great pencil. Would highly recommend these pencils to anyone who wants a silky soft gorgeous colored pencil with no wax residue or sharpening issues. A pleasure to use and worth every penny.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I'm glad you enjoy them! They didn't work for me, but a lot of people really do love them.

[@inezspeight9092]

Wonderful! Take courage in your self. Be well, stay strong. You are doing a great job informing the community.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you so much!

[@sherried2114]

I appreciate your honest opinion on these pencils. I think it is a great idea about buying open stock to try a few before jumping in and purchasing the entire set.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes! Open stock is definitely the safest way to try these first.

[@gemmacalimeri886]

Excellent review! Wish I had seen something like this before I bought them several years ago. I’ve only used them once but will try again. Thanks so much!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I mean no harm in trying if you already own them right? That's kind of my feelings about them.

[@JustNatasha93]

Life is too short to force yourself to use colored pencils that you don't like. Especially when there are plenty that you love. Sell the Holbeins on eBay/Facebook, etc. and use what you love instead.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha very true. But I also have the collector's addiction side of coloring and can't let go of what I've purchased. However, yes, life is definitely too short to use a pencil you don't like.

[@VeehattInspired]

Girl, I thank you and I’m sure my husband thanks you for this review. I’m a heavy-handed Primacolor Premier and Caran D’Ache Luminance “colorist” and I’ve been on the edge of buying these. You just saved me hundreds of dollars and years of buyer’s remorse/frustration if I had followed my full-set-syndrome and gotta have it all take on my art supplies. Keep up the great work with your honest review because there are a lot of us that tend to color in the same fashion you do. TFS!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha, FSS is a pain, especially when there are some sets out there that cost sooooo much money.

[@cowcollectr]

I appreciate your honest opinion in this review. As someone who wants to make educated decisions regarding pencil purchases it's important for there to be a variety of viewpoints out there so that I can spend my hard earned money wisely. It helps a lot to know what style of coloring/art these pencils are used for prior to buying them. Thank you for putting yourself out there!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe any time Jennifer. Hope it helped. I never want to discourage. Everyone should try at least a pencil whether its a few open stock or a small set, but I definitely don't want anyone diving in without knowing.

[@poetspicecolorwrite]

Yes! Thank you for this! All the hype about blending, etc. made we want to try them (of course I’m not paying that price). I don’t like having to use a ton of layers. I don’t mind some layers but taking forever to color is annoying. Again agreed about the shaming. I HATE Prismas but the world seems to husband shame if you don’t.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

LOL it's okay if you don't like Prismas. Not every pencil works for everyone. I don't get why people shame anyone for not liking a colored pencil. I mean...I didn't make the pencil so I really don't care if someone likes them or not, but not everyone takes that approach!

[@leonnehaaijman4709]

Woohoo, I’m not the only Prisma hater!! 😆 Gorgeous colour palette but I can’t get those pencils to work, on any type of paper.

[@suekrieg2033]

I agree with you. I'm just not that crazy about these pencils. I like some of my budget pencils better than these!

[@Cascada200]

Paper is more important than pencils. High quality paper will make cheap CP work look great, but The best CP on cheap paper will look awful.

[@mchobbit2951]

Not liking layering and also not liking Primas is a difficult combination, because Prismas are the go to pencils if you don't like to layer.

[@jillwiswall5386]

Thank you so much for taking the time to articulate exactly why these pencils don’t work well for your style, as well as which papers and styles they might work for!!!!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

No problem at all. Like I said, everyone should try a pencil and decide for themselves, but I still wanted to share my experience nonetheless.

[@debbien.3315]

Thanks for review. It's always good to see both sides of any set. I think you were very fair.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I agree, better to see both sides, whether positive or negative.

[@tcconnection]

Thanks for your review. I love when there are differing experiences, and so opinions, among artists. Viewers can have a variety of experiences and this can make them feel less alone. Thanks for your honesty, as there is no one right way or tool for everyone.🌻

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you for your sweet words. I'm glad this was helpful

[@kpixiewings_Kelley]

I know this comment is over a year after your posting, but I just want to thank you for explaining what you desire in a pencil and who may not love these. I am sorry that you had felt such pressure and feared the negativity that would come your way by speaking your honest opinion about a pencil. I plan to buy a couple of open stock to try but I will not jump in like I usually do with any new endeavor I take on. Major props to you for your bravery, I appreciate it immensely. I think I'll grab a couple Luminance to try too. (I hope your fears did not come to pass.)

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you for being so kind. Yes, the Holbeins weren't for me, but there are others that really like them and do AMAZING things with them, so definitely try some open stock and see how you feel about them :)

[@keves11]

Thank you so much for such an honest review and truly wish this was out when I bought mine from Japan in 2020 and paid $300 as well. I have experienced everything that you have and was so disappointed. Thank you for being so brave and posting this video you did a fine job!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe I'm sorry you have buyer's remorse with these. Truly. There's nothing worse than spending that money only to then realize they aren't for you.

[@realmencolor5912]

I very much appreciate your honest and fair review. Different colonists ha e different preferences. Its not personal. People shouldn't take it that way. Great job Kori.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Well thank you Brian. Yes, I agree, we all are so different. I honestly still think everyone should try a Holbein to see for themselves, just don't buy the 150 set if you're unsure lol.

[@grittykitty50]

Agreed: I thought this review was systematic and through. You t stated your pros and cons and supported those opinions which is what a review is.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@grittykitty50 Awe thank you very much.

[@Wisea60]

Thank you for your review! I bought the Holbein's basic set last week. However, I didn't know how much layering was involved and on top of that I used smooth paper! But thank you for letting us know how to use them!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Ah yeah, you want to avoid super smooth cardstock with these pencils if you can. They need lots and lots of light layers.

[@nanschifris8734]

Thanks for your honest opinions! Colored pencil preferences are very personal & unique to individuals. I respect that you give clear information on why you like/dislike products. That allows me to decide for myself if the pencils might be right for me to try.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes, pencils are highly personal, and it is definitely okay to like/dislike a pencil.

[@nanschifris8734]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Yes! The main thing for me is that you give very specific information in your review. Sometimes people just say! “They’re great!” or “They stink!” I want to know if they’re hard or soft, smooshy or not, break easily, are crumbly, pigmented or not so much, and so on. That’s what makes a meaningful review. Thank you again for taking so much time on this review!

[@Septembergirl70]

I've only heard someone say negative things about Holbeins a couple of times and it always shocks me. I absolutely LOVE my Holbeins. I got mine on Amazon US (yes they sold them for quite awhile) for about $300 and I never had any regrets. Now I hardly ever use them because I am scared to use them up. The Blick price shocked me, so ridiculous! But of course everyone is entitled to their opinion. I love your channel btw. I just received my copy of Summer Scenes to follow your Inktense tutorial. I have had mine for years and have never used them because they terrified me, but you finally made me brave enough to follow your tutorial!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Amazon US? Wow I've never seen them there, but $300 is not bad - esp considering how much it would cost you now lol. Yeah the Blick price had me sit there starring at the screen like soooo did they add something magical here? I mean there are a lot of people that love Holbeins, and that's totally okay. We are all so different in how we use our pencils and that's what makes it great there are soooo many out there to choose from. Oh I hope the tutorial helps you. Inktense are annoying, sometimes scary at first, but once you get it down they are so much fun! I plan to do another next month as well.

[@india1422]

Use them and use them up. Don’t waste them sitting on a shelf

[@KitKatToeBeans]

Individual pencils cost less than luminance. I bought mine from Amazon Japan and it’s significantly cheaper than what blick overcharges. I love mine.

[@cherylo8237]

I too got my Holbeins on Amazon US; paid about $200-250, which was a lot back then. Ended up really liking them so much, I bought a back up set, since individual pencils were not available. At one point there was an ebay seller with individual pencils for sale. He had them in color groups, which made it perfect for replacing pencils. I know I may get hit by lightning, but I get good coverage in my coloring books, not to mention shading. They're one of my favorite "go to" options, even though others may be shocked using them in "coloring books" For me, making art is my goal, and even though I can't draw, especially detailed work, I enjoy the pleasure I get creating just for me!!! Art is an outlet, and after all, isn't that what it's all about?

[@peculiarArt]

Why care what others think...Your the bomb chick! You are blessed with talents. I watch your tutorials and drool LOL

[@craftingemily]

I would love a future video on how you use polys in your coloring style. I like like the polys but I’m not in love with them as a beginner and a heavy handed person. I do appreciate this review. I learned early on that I was heavy handy and that is why I was so happy when I found a color along with the square bruts and you said that was your style. Sorry, but I was hooking my car to your wagon to learn once I saw that! I have found how to work with my black widows, and Windsor and Newton. I am almost there with my prismas I still need to work with them but I am in love so I don’t mind working with them. Oh and my 20 lumis! I am in love with those with just playing around, I need to actually do a page with them! I am leaving for Wisconsin tomorrow and I can’t choose what pencils to bring!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I think my color along votes have Polys winning for next month, so I will likely be coloring with them :).

[@GwyllionFaye]

Than you so very much for your honest review! Such a big help. Really great to see someone e who e plains their coloring style etc and why a pencil may work for some but not others. I am also just love to smush and burnish so this review was a huge help 💜

[@Danadane314]

Omg! You just saved me, my money…and possibly a fight with my honey. I was just about to purchase the 150 set on EBay for $302.00, very expensive for me. But I thought I’d wait and sleep on it. I’m like you, I want instant gratification, so I smush quickly. Thank you so much! This review is invaluable! ❤️

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

$302 on Ebay isn't a bad price compared to Blick's price lol. That said, I recommend buying maybe three open stock from Blick, seeing if you like them, then take the plunge. That way fewer regrets.

[@anli604]

I love your honesty. I’ve tried many different pencils that influencers have given rave reviews for and have been disappointed way to many times. Different pencils are going to work for different people, for sure. Sometimes I wonder if influencers reviews are clouded because they are given products and then feel like they have to give it a good review. Or maybe they give better reviews when they see so many others giving certain pencils good reviews so they do as well, who knows. But either way it’s hard to find influencers who give honest reviews and arent afraid to go against the crowd when they really don’t like something. Thank you for your honesty.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

No problem at all - and thank you for watching. I know some of the positive reviews were done by people who bought the pencils themselves. I think it is all just preference at the end of the day. Your style of using a colored pencil, and even paper preferences play a role in whether these pencils are right for you and sometimes, a pencil just isn't a good fit.

[@jendedios707]

So love your candid review on the holbeins!! BTW, I ended up buying the pastels to try holbeins… and to get my own perspective… well. I don’t like them either…. I have the same coloring style as you and wondered why it was so sticky and felt like the layers were not performing as expected!! haha. Thank you for saying exactly how I feel about these pencils. I applaud you for saying like it is. :) I will stick to my prismacolors, derwent lightfast, polys and lumis. I also love my fellisimo tokyo seeds too! 💜

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Oh I do like the Tokyo Seeds too. In the process of my subscription with those actually. Yeah, sticky is the only way I can describe Holbeins. It is odd. But, that said, some people can make them work and do absolutely amazing things.

[@KitKatToeBeans]

I do even, thin layers and get absolutely no stickyness.

[@annavanderwal6408]

Great review! I bought these a while ago and tried using them but couldn't work out why I didn't 'love' them. Now I understand why....so thank you for that. 🙂 I'm like you and don't really like to layer. I bought the 50 set which included the whites and some pastels as well as some normal colours. I will use them again and see how I go layering but I'm not patient by any means 🙂 I think you were pretty fair in your review

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe ty. Good thing you started with a smaller set first to get a feel!

[@melinda4815]

First off, I don' use coloring pencils for use with a coloring book, so I don't know about " tooth, smooshing, or burnishing. I use my Prisma's for Bible journaling and coloring stamped images. That being said, I love to watch the creativity that you have with your coloring. I watch others also and am amazed at the pictures you all produce. I also appreciate the information that you give. Although I never heard of Holbein pencils, i knew I would get a lot from your review. I did, in fact, learn a lot! Thank you so much for taking the time to do this for us, even for those of us that are new to the "coloring world". I don't know what other folks mean by "colorist", but I think that a "colorist" is definitely an artist. A rose is still a rose, and you are certainly a very talented artist. Thank you for your review, time and sharing your talent!!!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Colorist is just what people call those who color in coloring books, but yes, they are artists (however, there are some artists that tend to forget that lol). Thank you so much for your kind words Melinda!

[@majesticmythicalsart7563]

So glad to see an honest review, I was going to buy these pencils because of all the good reviews,then I got some in a palettful packs box and hated them. I ended up getting polychromos and love those. So glad I didn’t waste my money on Holbein even though some of those colors are so pretty

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

The colors are so pretty 😍 but the pencils just aren't for me

[@nancybarney2330]

Thank YOU!! For your objective opinion! It is Valuable!!! 💖 Yes I have them.. bought them from Amazon Japan earlier this year(because I had the extra money to work with), but haven't used them very much! Mostly thinking "Oh they are Gold" I should wait until I'm a better colorist! I may NOT have purchased them after seeing your review though!? Like you found everyone raving about them! I will get them out Now and work with them! Thanks Again for Sharing!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe well I never want to talk anyone out of anything. I think everyone should try a pencil to make their own opinion, BUT I definitely want to save people from buying 150 pencils if it might not work well for them. I mean I will still use mine, because I can't handle something sitting there unused when it cost so much, but if they were something I bought on Amazon US I could have just returned them after swatching lol.

[@mkboyd6880]

This is a great review. I purchased several of these pencils open stock from Blick to try them. So far I am not sufficiently impressed to buy a full or partial set. I'll take Derwent over these any day. Thanks for the comprehensive review.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

That's great you bought open stock first to save money!

[@sketchshinaver2137]

I got mine on line 315$ US. They took some getting use to. I was so use to prisma. Then I got my poly set I finally figured out how to use them. They are a lil different to use they don’t blend the same way as prisma. To me they seem to layer more so than blend. Artist Jane Bush just did a video on Holbein lightfast. Which made my day because I have come to love my Holbein set. I don’t use them on everything I do. When I do use them, I use only them. I use them on special pieces mostly stuff I do for me! Just because the expense of the pencils. I think your review is fare and honest. I’m a huge fan of Holbein

[@thecolouringzone172]

This is a long one ❤️… Good on you Kori! I really appreciate your honesty. I also own Holbeins 150 set… I love them but haven’t used them a great deal and I think it’s probably due to the price tag. I know there are now available open stock so hopefully will get more use of them. I’m very fortunate to own many sets of pencils. I’m sorry to hear that you’ve had rude and harsh comments. My 10 year old nephew actually checks all my comments on here. It’s very sweet but at the same time quite sad that even a 10 year old knows how mean people can be. Thanks again for sharing. Very much appreciated ☺️💖

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe your nephew is too sweet. I never understood the passion to bring others down. If I disagree, I can tell someone, but there's a nice way to even disagree. No need to be nasty. Yeah, like I said, others might not regret their Holbeins - I just do haha.

[@janicehammock121]

A

[@janicehammock121]

I didn’t mean to post that A. I like your review on the Holbein pencils. I’m a heavy-handed colorist, also. I have the pastels and they do require layering. They have beautiful colors though.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@janicehammock121 Yes, they are definitely pretty colors. Just don't suit my style :)

[@HHCbhc]

Thank you for your opinion! I truly appreciate it. Love it when an artist is honest and balanced in their assessment of a particular tool they have used. AND yes, you can be "eh" about anything you use to make art!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you! 😊 appreciate your kind words

[@ellyfranken6137]

First i like to say "you are not just a colorist", to be a good colorist you need to learn techniques, practice over and over. It's nice if you have talent, some do and some don't. But it sure requires patience. So don't let that person bring you down. Second i like your video's, honoust reviews. I only have one Holbein pencil, tried it, but it doesn't feel any better then prismas, polychromos or luminance. I hear so many say that i need them. Well no i don't. I think they are ridiculous pricey. Ive seen masterpieces done with budget pencils. Thank you for this video. And colorists are artist to in my opinion :).

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you Elly. I agree, colorists are artists. The Holbeins were just not for me, and no, no one NEEDS any pencil. It's about what you like, your coloring style, and it's okay to not love every pencil you own - that's the point of trying them (in my opinion lol).

[@ellyfranken6137]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic i totally agree, but ive seen people really believe that the more expensive the better you color. I prefer my prismas, like my polys in other books. You need to feel a pencil before you buy a whole set. I buy on stock when it's possible, just to try if it's my kind of pencil.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@ellyfranken6137 I'm actually a big prisma fan (if you have seen my office tour, uh...you see my devotion lol). But, even my prismas don't work well in all books. In fact, in Hanna Karlzon, I prefer to use my polys.

[@ellyfranken6137]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic i've seen many video's from you. I think in Klara Markova books polychromos are better, but i simply love my prismas.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@ellyfranken6137 With Klara's both work well for me in there since there is a tiny tiny bit of tooth, but nothing that kills the Prisma smoosh haha.

[@loricatwhy2k2000]

thank you so much for your honesty. I think its important to have different options.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Always! Thank you so much for watching. I agree, I think we should all be able to have different opinions, and share them without any worry of negativity.

[@positronixartandlife4545]

I just want to say thank you for this. I started with Polychromos and much prefer the layering method and slowly building up colour (even if it does take forever) so the Holbein pastels went well for me (especially the light peaches for skintones and other really light colours). Personally, I'm going to have a lot of learning to do with the Caran D'Ache Luminous because I am so not used to pencils that lay down a heavy thick layer even with the lightest pressure :D I will also agree that the lightfast is definitely an issue - I don't know if it's a cultural thing but other Japanese brands seem to be similarly vague on how they tested for appropriate/accurate lightfast values so...I am still learning (yes, despite the mass amount I've spent!) and so I use colouring books/colouring pages to build up my skill, nothing that will be displayed let alone sold. If I did get to that point, I'd definitely do my own lightfast testing to verify it for myself. I still love the soft white though - Prismacolour are difficult to get here in the UK, open stock even more so. Even when I can find the Prismacolor white, it's about the same price as the Holbein soft white anyway, so I just loaded up on holbein instead.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes the Lumis are very opaque so if you do light layers, even light layers come down heavier with those lol. You'll get there! Ah didn't know Prismas are hard to get in the UK (even Cult Pens and Jackson's?). Don't get me wrong, the Holbein soft white is stellar, but to buy it open stock here in the US for over $3 USD a pencil...I'd rather just buy prismacolor's white because I get almost 3 for the price of a single Soft White.

[@positronixartandlife4545]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Nope, unfortunately neither Cult Pens nor Jackson's Art stocks Prismacolor, not even a set. Searching for them generally gives me an Amazon listing of 12 for £22 (plus £10 delivery) from a US seller, or an ebay seller for £3.33 each (going down to £2.66 when buying 3 or more. Holbein on Jackson's art is £3 open stock, so for us in the UK, if we're willing to search around we can get Prismacolor a little bit cheaper, but Holbein is more accessible for us - at least for the time being.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@positronixartandlife4545 That is very interesting! I figured Prisma would be readily available out there. That's a bummer.

[@bethmegansmith4642]

Thank you for being honest, this is a good review thank you Happy new year

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Happy new year! Thank you so much for watching.

[@izza_ISFP]

Thanks for your review. I think it's a good think to hear why someone didn't liked the Holbeins, all the reviews are just I'm so loving these... And I'm gonna share an unpopular opinion too ( so maybe the haters will take their hate on me instead of you lol ) I don't like Johanna Basford books, I have 4 of them and I colored 1 image in them. It's just not for me ;)

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

LOL it's okay you don't like Johanna's books. I didn't like her first ones, but her newer ones I'm okay with but she's not my favorite. But hey, not every book or every pencil out there works for everyone - and that's okay! :)

[@leonnehaaijman4709]

Izzy, I agree on the Bashford books. I think she’s overhyped.

[@1Letter23Numbers.]

When I color I want to turn off my mind and color by instinct and not have to concentrate on keeping a pattern. This is why I'm not a big fan of complicated mandalas. I own one Johanna book, Worlds of Wonder, because it's not super detailed/chaotic to my senses. I've attempted to buy her earlier books but when I flip through them and imagine coloring in them they make me anxious because there is so much going on in the details.

[@AlexisCassandraArt]

Props for you being honest about these. The best thing to do is try out pencils open stock before buying a set BUT these pencils were really really hard to find and weren’t available open stock in the US until recently. So that’s a really tough one. You could maybe resell them to someone else at a better price than Blick and make most of your money back. I’ve tried a few of these open stock and the feel of them is odd, definitely different to most pencils I’ve tried. Apparently they use fat or something in the formulation (especially the soft white) but it’s not completely clear. I bought the soft white separately and I love it because it’s soooo bright. Regardless I’m not going to buy these anytime soon- if anything I’m interested in the pastel range and that’s the only set I could see being a unique addition to my collection. It’s not that the pencils don’t match my style because I very much love layering and polychromos are my favorite pencil, however, the holbeins are just soooo expensive. If I’m going to spend a chunk of change I think I’ll try a set of derwent lightfasts instead :) again thanks for your honest thoughts on your review!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yeah back when I got these, open stock wasn't an option sadly. I don't want to resell them, just because I do want to keep working with them. But, they may be something I get rid of down the road if I just cannot figure it out. The pastel range is a lot softer and more tolerable than the other pencils for sure. Regardless, these are going to require loads of layers haha.

[@ingelagoransson3560]

it´s been a year since you done this video. I´m in the process of choosing pencils so I watch lots of videos to find pencils to try. This video and the review of Holbeins is GOOD and well based on your experiences. Please don´t let "ugly" comments get to you!! I like the way you describe your way of coloring. Heavy handed, like to smosh color down, and not gently layering layer upon layer. I don´t like layering!! I get this. I´m not the biggest fan of Prisma colors though, beaucause they cost a fortune here in Sweden were I live. But I´ve got Brutfuner Square and I LOVE them. Now I need a harder pencil to make thin strokes with. thanks for sharing your knowledge!! 😊😘

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Ah yes, Prismacolor are quite expensive out of the U.S. I really enjoy Polys, Pablos and Derwet Procolour for thinner strokes.

[@rainrobin4505]

Your opinion is valued. They are like bellybuttons, everyone has one 😊

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha thank you Robin.

[@recoveringsoul755]

I'll have to remember the belly button, better than the term most people use (and I know of someone who was born without one of those) but we all have belly buttons

[@Discofoxx1]

Great review, and I think that you set the gold standard 🏆for colored pencil reviews! Very thorough. Thanks and you get a lot of 💖💝💕💓💗❤ from me for that! Sad that you got the negativity. That’s why I thought lemme say something cuz I do appreciate your efforts and think you deserve flowers for that 💐

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you. That is so very kind of you to say.

[@andrewmandywilsontatham49]

Thank you! Awesome review and really good to hear someone giving an absolutely honest opinion that these "suck the kumara" for you. And everyone is different, and has different styles and needs. I am in NZ, where colouring pencils cost a fortune anyway. I have a similar attitude to yours with colouring, I just don't have time to do endless layers. Price is out of this world for something that won't work for me. Because cost down under generally is such an issue, I really don't like looking at US videos saying Prismas are cheap. They're not here. Polychromos today are $43.50/12, $473.50/120. Prismacolor are $39.99/12, $499/150. Luminance $7.60 per pencil. So I generally look but don't even try to hit that buy button on Holbeins...I could buy 12 for $79.95 from Ali Express. But that's more than I paid for my Nyoni 120 which I love, so I would obviously go for a second set of those first. Or even Marco Tributes/Renoir.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

So happy it helped. While I still believe a person should always try a pencil and make up their own decisions, it is a very expensive pencil that someone can't just dive into that's for sure. Thank you so much for watching!

[@ana.perezrico]

Thank you so much for your review. You explained really clearly why you disliked these pencils and it is super valid. I am also a colour pencil artist and I have been very curious about the hype of these pencils especially the lack of bad reviews, so I was really happy to find your review. Just as you mentioned, everyone who uses coloured pencils has a preferred way of using them and they are all different. I like to work in layers, from light colours to dark ones, blend and spend my time on smaller sections (which sounds like something you would not enjoy) so my taste in brands might be different than yours. Even if we used our pencils in a similar way, we may still not like the same brands, and that is also ok. I love that there are different brands for different tastes and different techniques. I wish there had been more information and reviews back when you bought made this big purchase, but then again, your review would not exist and I think you did a great job with it. I may be inclined to get just the pastel set, when the time is right (ie, when a get some money saved up). Thank you for your hard work.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you so much for your comment. Yes, you are exactly right! Even if we colored/used pencils the same, the same pencil might not be our favorite. Everyone is so different.

[@leonnehaaijman4709]

Thank you soooo much for this honest review. I'm extremely light-handed and always use layers, working from light to dark, so they are right up my street. On my part, I struggle with Primsas, total war and carnage 😂 New sub here, by the way. You're funny!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Lol well I'm glad they work for you! Yea if you layer these will be excellent

[@addie7043]

Thank you for your review. Funny enough I followed the hype about Luminance the same way you got into these and I must say I don’t like Luminance. They are scratchy, very uneven and sometimes stop giving any pigment until I sharpen more to get to the better part of a pencil. BTW Luminance have now 100 colours :). I don’t have Holbein’s (just yet :) but as far as I know they are not just mixture of oil and wax - they also have fat in them, according to Holbein Japan website. Anyway thanks again for your point of view!!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes, wax, fats and oils. I just kinda picture fats and oils as one. Though it makes me curious what fats they're using lol. It might attribute to the sticky feeling. Yes I do know lumis have 100 pencils (I own them). Unfortunately you can't buy the 100 in a single set which is why I was comparing the box of 76. To get all 100 you have to buy 4 open stock, the portrait and the original 76 in the US. If they came in a single 100 box set I'd compare that pricing but the fluctuations between costs for multiple components was too hard to calculate and would still just show lumis cost more in the end any way 🤣.

[@RebeccaMarrion]

I’m glad you did this review as i have been having issues myself. I first bought the set of 12 pastels and i loved them so i got the 50 set of pastels and was happy so i thought I’d by singles of the other colours and think i got another 50 pencils in the other colours and then tried a page using those and i was not happy. I agree with you they are really sticky that’s exactly what i thought about them too and i didnt get it as i loved the pastel ones. But I haven’t continued buying the rest of the other 50 and i wish i had just stayed with the pastel set as i too dont like the other pencils in the set and was so disappointed as they are soooo much money and i was super excited about having them cause of all the hype and then didnt like the other colours. I do like the pastel ones and will continue using them but really not keen on the other ones so i thank you for this review as i dont feel alone in my thoughts with this and its good to know someone else has had a similar experience so thank you.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes! Sticky. I dunno how else to describe it, but on a smooth cardstock they were just sticky. They left this funky crumble that stuck to the page too, and I was like what on earth is this?? The pastels are a lot softer and less sticky/crumbly/dusty. However, that's likely because there is less pigment, which allows them to stay softer, while the darker, deeper tones need more pigment and become a lot harder to use.

[@RebeccaMarrion]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic yes that makes complete sense to me and is my experiences too. You could even hear like a tacky sound as you put them on and off the paper if that makes sense. Ah yeah that’s a very good point and makes it much easier to figure out why the coloured ones are much worse then the pastel ones. Thanks so much kori ☺️

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@RebeccaMarrion Oh yes, tacky is a good way to describe it! No problem at all. Sorry your experiences weren't so hot either :(

[@InfiniteTranscendence]

Thanks for the detailed review. I have a question. I have Polychromos, Luminos, and I just got the Derwent Lightfast. I looked at these as I like to mix and match colors, and that's how I use mine as they all have pros and cons at the end of the day. How do you find they mix and match with other colors? I see some say they blend well with themselves but are greasy and don't play well with others. Did you have any problems blending them with your other brands? Your advice would be most appreciated!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Unfortunately, I don't use my Holbeins a ton, but I have found they play nicely with my polychromos.

[@InfiniteTranscendence]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Thanks for the reply. Another thing you mentioned was residue. I like to do detail based art or even people with a lot of small details (like a person in a large background). Because of this I would hate for crumbs and residue to get in other areas and stick. Did you find these pencils messy? Did the extra gunk make a mess on your drawing? A splendid thanks. 🙏

[@ArtJourneyUK]

I love your honesty, I like hearing the true opinions of people who have used a product. I think some people rave about these pencils because they are like the kings new clothes, they’re expensive and exclusive... but are they really that good?

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I mean I've seen people do great work with these, but for me, they definitely don't work out well. Everyone is so different with how they use pencils, so it's really important to always try one and see if it works for you, but just don't go buy the whole set until you're sure lol

[@KitKatToeBeans]

Yes. They are.

[@caseyanne967]

Thanks for your review. I was thinking about getting a small set of Holbeins, but not anymore. I don't want to do a ton of layering, and they don't sound like they're worth the price. I mostly use Prismas, and I'm very happy with them.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I love my prismas and I too don't enjoy the layers

[@AdoraClyoniaDesigns]

I have put these in my buy box the store has them on hold for me. Until I decide. Our creator of creation made sure I see your channel first. I’m so grateful for you being brave to share your input with us all. Will call shop tomorrow and cancel my order. Thank You, you help convince me these are not with their hype. Hugs❤

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I just suggest trying open stock first and see what you think before paying so much for the entire set

[@Kristenaann]

I like Holbein but I thought your review was super informative. Also your nails are so pretty!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you Tena! It's totally okay if someone likes Holbein. They weren't for me, but that never applies to everyone. Trust me, I wish I liked them so they got used more lol.

[@Kristenaann]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic I definitely understand. I actually really appreciate hearing different point of view because that's how we learn things and challenge our own ideas. For example, i learned so much from your talk and stopped to ask myself: Why do i like these pencils? What is my coloring style? Were these worth it for me? These types of considerations are important, and help me learn about myself as an artist. :-) I'm loving your channel and the information you share on art.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@Kristenaann Awe thank you. I too like to stay open minded and hear all of the different sides (bad and good) so I can hopefully decide for myself. Doesn't always work, but sometimes I make good purchasing decisions.

[@kelleerens1]

I haven’t really seen a lot of your stuff, but I did only .buy the Holbein because of the hype, I did buy them 2019 I think, but didn’t get them and I was just learning.. there is so much that you don’t know about yourself especially when you don’t no what your doing.. but my prismas fell apart always.. I think your my new hero!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you.

[@Colourmestressfree]

Kori your review was just spot on. I have to agree too I regret buying such a big set I wish I bought the smaller set first but in saying that I’m not just using colouring books I’m using nicer paper and trying to try different art so I’m glad I do have them but just spending that money was arghh!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe I'm sorry you feel that way. Nothing is worse than buyers remorse, and not like you can return these pencils, which makes it really rough. I have tried these on a variety of paper outside of coloring books, including some of my own sketches (and ruined a few lol). They just need tooth and lots of light layers, which is just not my style whether in a coloring book or a sketch book. Hopefully you're able to make them work for you!

[@catiejane5287]

Thank you for a honest review. These pencils are very expensive and I needed both sides of the argument before spending that amount of money. Thanks to your honesty I will tried a smaller set.

[@julieholt2864]

Thank you for your honest review!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

No problem, and thank you for watching.

[@tonyaguerrero2279]

I think you are wonderful! Don’t let anyone call you ‘just a colorist’ !

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thanks Tonya.

[@colourpalettesbymichelle]

As a colorist AND artist, I just want to say what a waste of emotional energy it is for any human being to get upset about any other human beings opinion. There is no ‘good’ or ‘bad’ pencil. Just like there is no food or bad FOOD. It’s all relative to the person using the pencil or eating the food. What’s great to one person is garbage to another, in any given scenario under the sun. While I appreciate artists like yourself taking the time to create these reviews and put your opinion out into the universe, any artist who has been coloring for more than a week knows that the most due diligence any of us can do before investing our hard earned money into our craft is do your research, consider your sources, and while listening to OR READING any review on any product, be careful to weed through the authors “personal opinion” and actual FACTS. If ten different human beings say they hate a product or love a product, I will listen to their reasons why, and if more of them than not say similar feedback about a product, I will put a pin on that *fact* in my mind while assembling all the information that I deem necessary to have before making a purchase. I personally don’t take any reviewers “facts” about a pencil as truth with a capital T. Someone says “X brand pencils do not blend well”. Could that be true? Possibly. Could it also be true that the same KZbin reviewer sucks at blending techniques? Yep: At the end of the day, thanks for your opinions on the Holbeins, I take it with a grain of salt because to be honest, I’m not going to sit here for an hour and listen to you tell me all your “feelings” about this pencil. I’m certainly not going to take anything you say about them personally. And any fools who get on here and want to dispute your opinion because it’s different than theirs? Well, lady, those people are why the world is at war with one another. Lack of respect for their fellow human being. But that’s a whole other conversation. 😄 To that end; I LOVE LOVE LOVE my Holbeins, what I consider their faults and all weighed in the balance against the other 17 sets I own; my Holbeins are my go-to babies; and they rock my world and changed my entire coloring experience. And I’m totally okay if it was a different pencil that brings YOU joy. Just keep coloring and creating peace and joy and spreading it..: the world needs it now more than ever, especially the internet trolls. 😂 Xoxo 🦋Michelle Berens🦋 ColorDreams by Michelle.Facebook.com ✌🏻

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I'm glad to hear you enjoy your Holbeins - I do state throughout my review why they aren't right for me, because like you said, it is an opinion. Really, there are only so many "facts" a person can put out there in a review, such as what its made out of, price, etc. The way it reacts on paper is still 100% opinion, because we are all different in how we use a pencil on the same type of paper, even down to pressure. So, in reality, most reviews will always be mostly opinion :)

[@sweetmarheart5862]

I also didn't know there's apparently a right way to use a colored pencil. :(( Like sorry I don't use it the same way you do. I see this same thing unfortunately in many other areas in life. Please pardon me as I'm commenting using a backup account!

[@sassybanjo3586]

Congratulations on paying off your car. I paid off my 2019 Mazda last month. Feels so good! Maybe I should buy the full set of Polychromos. I would have more than half a car payment amount left over. 😊

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha it was vindicating having a paid off car for a bit there. Of course, I just recently purchased a new one, so I'm back to car payments.

[@realmencolor5912]

Hey so I just watched this video again and am wondering if you have used the Holbeins much (any?) since making this video? Has your opinion changed any? I also want to thank you for this video. I held out on buying these, not only because of the cost, but because I know I have similar coloring style to you and value your opinion. Even still, curiosity recently got the best of me and I bought just the small 12 pc set of design tones and had exactly the same experience that you had in this review. I had all of the same issues and was really frustrated with my inability to get them to do what I wanted them to do, they way I wanted to do it. They're gorgeous and well made....no doubt. But definitely not for me. So once again...thank you for saving me a decent chunk of money.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I have! March was all Holbein madness, and I still feel the same. Just couldn't work with them like I wanted to, and put them back in their case to sit there haha

[@surroundedbycolors5931]

I wish I would have known this before I purchased them lol. I color a lot like you do and have had very similar results with my Holbeins. While I also love the colors I get frustrated with them every time I attempt to color with them. So thanks for your honesty, you are not alone in your assessment of them. They are beautiful to look at though lol

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha well glad I'm not alone. I'm sorry though that you had to experience the buyer regrets. I still keep trying to use them though. I'm freaking determined to get miles on them because I paid for them LOL

[@surroundedbycolors5931]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic yes I hate that I have such an expensive set of pencils just sitting on my shelf. I am generally a very frugal person and so since I spent my hard earned money on these pencils you better belive I am going to use them one way or another lol

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

@@surroundedbycolors5931 Same my friend. Same. LOL

[@corineantonis]

I got sucked into these too, luckily I only bought 10 pencils. Luminance are where it's at for me! Thanks for the review!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe at least it was only 10 haha. I do like the Lumis!

[@darlastitz6767]

Really great review, thank you

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thanks for watching!

[@rebekah1362]

You demonstrated the necessity (and power) of knowing your style and preference for methods and materials. Every artist is not the same and no two artists approach a project in the same way. It's absolutely imperative for peace of mind, and efficiency as well, to know what method you prefer to use, and what mediums and materials best suite you AND help you achieve your desired results. It's never a good thing to jump on trends/bandwagons just for the sake of it. 1) it's expensive and 2) you set yourself up for disappointment. But if you're like me, and are an art supply fiend (ROFL) it can take a lot of self control to put that into action. I'm really glad you did this video. I'm always suspicious of nothing but positive reviews because some of them are regurgitating other opinions. I want the good, the bad, and the ugly of a product before I invest a large amount of money into it. Typically on Amazon, I look for the negative reviews first, then the customer images, and only then will I read the good reviews. I want the whole picture. It's saved me a ton of money, time and frustration over the years. On a side note, many people don't realize there are professional colorists in the illustration industry. Artists often have a lot of deadlines to meet and don't have time to color every piece or to put lines to it. So, they send their sketch to a line artist, and from there to a professional colorist. Again, not all artists are the same. We love different aspects of the art process, not necessarily every step. I don't particularly enjoy ideation, sketching and plotting frames. I don't get excited about a piece until it's time to lay down lines and especially add in the color. Procreate makes ideation easier, thank the good Lord but it's still not something I overly enjoy. God bless the artists who love the entire process! ROFL Keep up the good work! And btw - I don't like Holbein either (except the white OP501 and OP500 - it's stellar for highlights and masking color strays). It's over priced. I'm not only an artist, I'm also a business grad and project manager - believe me, a lot of the price is marketing, supply chain pay and import/export tax bloat.😉

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes, the way you use an art supply, or your technique/style, can greatly influence how much you enjoy a product. Not all products were created to apply to everyone 100% of the time, and Holbeins are definitely one of those (for me). It was a good learning experience for sure.

[@cubancachita70]

I appreciate your review. I bought 12 open stock when Blick fist came out with them and found the same thing you did. They do not fit my style. I'm also heavy handed and do not like multiple layers since it hurts my hand. I follow light, medium, dark and I want it to be done. So thank you for being honest and not follow the crowd. We're entitled to our own opinion just like we are entitled to our own styles.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Oh ty! So glad you bought the smaller set first to save money!

[@suewilkinson910]

I got the 12 pastels from Amazon Japan to U.K. to see what they are like. I do layer, it’s my style. But I am not wowed by them. They are blotchy on so many papers and the pastels in the 12 set are mostly a bit dull because of the amount of white they have in them. I’m glad I got them to see. But I’m not tempted to buy more. I am busy using the 12 though. They mix in with other brands. It’s good to have a review that doesn’t just gush. I think this is a very well pitched and fair review.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you Sue! Yeah it is great you started with a small set to get a feel whether or not you liked them. I always say do open stock or the smallest set they have and see if it is something you like before diving into a 150 set lol

[@shawnawilliams5909]

I am using my for the first time! I totally agree with your review, I was expecting a totally different result. Hope I will eventually like them, since I spent $300 on them.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

They do have a learning curve so try them a few more times and hopefully you end up loving them and not hating them like I did lol

[@joycegandy1495]

Thank you for this and it is very helpful.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

You're very welcome!💜

[@catzkc5488]

Thank you for your honest and justified review! I don't trust those KZbinrs who love everything they try - comes across to me as they're just trying to sell one more thing to me, rather than being honest!

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

No problem at all! I try my best to always be as honest as I can.

[@margaretbusby6992]

Oh goodness. I feel exactly the same way about the caran d'ache luminance. As soon as I swatched them, I knew they weren't for me. I know that people love them and that they are lightfast. But, I totally don't like them. For me, they are way overpriced. Tu chey...

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

and there is nothing wrong with that! No pencil is for everyone. I will admit when I swatched Lumis I didn't like them haha. Took a few uses to get used to them. It's like Prismacolor. I really like prismas, but a lot of people don't and that's OKAY. I don't judge or get angry (not like I have stock investments in Prisma here and didn't make the darn things so I don't take it personal). Everyone needs to find what works best for them.

[@nancymensch1087]

Thank you for doing this review… I wish I would have seen this before I bought mine. I didn’t get the entire 150, but bought a 36 set and about that many in pastels. To be honest, I am having not the best time coloring with these. I find them not playing well with other pencils and I don’t like that. I plan on using them as like you, I don’t want them to sit in the closet. I bought some Holbein Meltz to see if that made it any better. I do think I need to watch a few videos to see how best to color with them. Having said all of this, I really like their soft white pencil. It is fantastic! I’m curious though, if I am remembering correctly, you weren’t a fan of the Pablos. Could you manipulate those to your coloring style or do you find them similiar to the Holbeins?

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

So Pablos, yes, I could get those to work with my coloring style. I just found them scratchy, so I'm going to give them another go and see if the next batch is softer. That said, when I swatched them, I could definitely work with those. The Holbeins, when using my style, get sticky, crumbly, dusty. It's like really weird lol.

[@nancymensch1087]

I get you with the hype with colored pencils… I feel that is happening even with the budget friendly ones. I feel I have enough of them (although I will be getting Lori Green’s collab with Star Joy at Color my World) and am no longer planning on anymore of them. I’m still trying to see what my style is. I find the Holbein’s a bit sticky too. I bought an 18 set of Pablos and am trying to decide if I want to get more of them. I like pencils that I can get open stock. I bought a few Lumi’s and I find them to be scratchy and crumbly, besides being overly expensive, but I need to see if its more me than the pencils. I like the Pablos points andthey aren’t crumbly. Oh the decisions!

[@beuvelain]

I'm like you. I have a heavy-handed style of drawing. I kind of use my color pencils like I'm painting with them. I have the pastel set of Holbeins and I realize that once you burnish them it's hard to layer/smudge other colors on top (which is still possible to do with Prismacolors). Although I do like how they kind of create this solid, streak-free, almost glossy area of color - Like you mentioned: they work for a cartoonish style. My question to you is: Do the darker colors work the same way? Or are they harder/streakier than the pastels/lighter tones? Thank you for a great and honest review! PS. I don't understand why you receive hate for having your own opinion on something! I want more critical reviews. I hate how most reviewers in the art community here on KZbin are so hesitant to point out flaws of products or just say that this or that pencil doesn't work for their unique style. If I want to use a colorbook and I follow a colorist that I find inspiring, I want to hear their opinion of how it works for THEM. As long as you're making clear that it might have or even is intended for other uses.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

So the darker ones for me were dustier. Honestly, I found the pastels the most tolerable. The darker colors and heavier pigments (since there is a lot of white in the pastels) are not as creamy and got a lot harder to use.

[@beuvelain]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Thank you! That is what I needed to know. I probably don't need them. I have all the prismas, Luminance, Derwent lightfast and Polychromos already haha.

[@alli_went_bonkers]

Wow! Grateful for the honesty! Sorry to hear that you’re “just a colorist,” as I’m coming to count on your videos to make my days more entertaining and informative in my current hobby-of-choice. What the heck does that make those of us who color, but don’t teach our methods/techniques?? I think you’re a brave, honest, hard-working person who doesn’t feel those of us with the curiosity, but not “the means,” don’t over-extend ourselves and then be forced to live with regret, so THANK YOU (for not “drinking the koolaid” and giving us the cult-following opinion of the masses).

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Thank you. Hopefully the review was helpful for you :). Most people took this review very maturely, which was awesome.

[@alli_went_bonkers]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Very helpful as I no longer feel like a colorist "from another planet" just because I don't agree with the masses! 😉

[@askialuna7717]

I tested a few of my colored pencils next to each other on the same paper and noticed that this sticking happened to several types. I got stuck with some of my Derwent Drawings, Colorsoft and Lightfast. I don't like it because I automatically use more strength to move the pencil again and then often move it too far and would paint over it using line arts and accidentally end up in a different color. That was also always the case with the colored pencils that felt a little too much wax in the binding agent and were more like wax crayons. Strangely enough, I didn't get stuck with the Prismacolor, probably because they have a softer wax. With my Pablo's it looked a bit like crayons, but I didn't get stuck with them. The Pablo's got the price for the worst black from the artist-quality colored pencils. It didn't want to be darker than a dark gray, it is even lighter than that of the Faber Castell Classics colored pencils. I don't have enough colors of the Luminance and the Procolor to be able to compare them with the others. I try to have at least a 12 color set for the tests.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Oh how odd the Lightfast were sticky. I'd say yes on Coloursoft but my Lightfast haven't - but it also depends on the paper.

[@synergyscrap]

THANK YOU! I color in the same manner you do and I had purchased some open stock. I am horribly disappointed in the amount of dust and crumbling they create. And colorists are artists 😘

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Sadly, they do crumble and get incredibly dusty if you go in heavy. I swatched like 4 and was like "well crap this isn't going to go well" lol

[@KitKatToeBeans]

It’s not the pencils. It’s how you’re using them. Mine have never been dusty or crumbly.

[@tammycolorstoo]

I'm so glad you did this. I could tell from your voice in the video you were kinda dreading it. And I think you don't want to be disappointed in such an expensive pencil, but you are. And thank you so much for being honest about that. I'm an honest person and that's the way I roll. We are all entitled to our opinion and to feel the way we want. As long as we are respectful to others opinions and we don't disparage other for liking or hating something, it's all good. I'll never understand those who are mean to others for not feeling the same way about something as they do. I don't have Hollbein pencils. I have lots of pencil sets: Polychromos, Prisma, Art-N-Fly, Star Joy, Black Widow, and many others. I love pencils. I am not sure I was really thinking about getting the Holbein's myself as, well, I have lots of pencils I enjoy using already. I do want Derwent Lightfast and Luminence pencils. I'm like you, I don't do a ton of layers. And not all pencils work well on all paper. Love your channel, love your pictures. You are so much fun! Thanks for being true to yourself and honest with us. I know it's not easy sometimes. Hopefully you feel better now that it's out there. :)

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha well I was dreading it slightly just because of the feedback I've received in the past, but do feel better finally publishing a video on it. I do like the Lightfast and Lumis, I'll be honest, and they work really really well with one another so if you ever buy them you can combine them (funny since one is oil, other wax, but hey it works).

[@pennypop408]

You said it. They are not ment for smooth coloring book papers. You have taken a ferrari and driven it off road so to speak. Use these on artist quality paper with some tooth, layer them and blend with blender. Best to use these as an accent pencil with polys or another hard pencil for the detail work. Do not buy them for coloring books. Light fast ratings are shown on the lid of the new box. They use the astm scale please see the really interesting video that Jane Bush has done on her channel as well as read the leaflet that comes in the new style box. Still in doubt then do your own test on them and please share your results.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes, I haven't gotten the box here in the U.S. yet. Soooo, I don't know if you intended the comment to come off that way, but I wouldn't downgrade adult coloring. There are some books out there on artist-quality paper. Very nice, expensive paper. That said, no, if you are only going to color, they aren't worth it. I did mention in my video I had tried them in my own art on a toothier paper and that was what they needed, but still, didn't like them even after doing that. I'm glad they have added it to the box, but I wish their representatives would get their facts straight. To this day, they still say they don't use ASTM. So perhaps I'll go get a small set at Blick and send them a picture of it on the box and ask why.

[@pennypop408]

@@ColorfullyOptimistic Sorry if my comment caused concern. I mean no disrespect to any artist. What I mean is you have to use the right product with the right product to get max results. Might be nice if you could share another art work on the good paper books with blender for those that love to use coloring books. Expensive or not try water color paper 300gsm acid free with cold press/ not tooth and give it another go and pop in some of the blender to smoosh it. You have lovely pencils here shame not to give them another go. You are right we all need to find our own fit with art materials. Light fast ratings are with the new box design to see an unboxing look out for pamelas passion for pencils its her My dream pencil video with leaflet giving astm ratings of the pencils. I wish you the best with all your art pieces we as artists all need to share the love. I watch your channel often and enjoy your content best. :)

[@carolberres5528]

I bought a set of 12 pastels when they first surfaced. I liked them and bought the full set later off of Amazon US. I don’t use them as much as I should, due to the amount of sets I own. I agree with your assessment for the most part. I can get them to work for me. I love the Romantic Country coloring books but I struggle with most pencils on that paper. I will replace these when I need to, now that they are available on Blick. Thanks for sharing.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

You got yours on Amazon US? I have yet to find them there myself sadly 😥

[@cherieberry9823]

Just seeing your review and truely appreciate your honest opinion. I wish people would lighten up. It's sad that you can't critique a product without being bashed and insulted on your opinion. In watching swatching or opinions on products from other content creators, I sometimes feel like they sugar-coat their opinion. With these pencils, I heard its a learning curve but you gave it a honest try and determined they are not your cup of tea. I'm not heavy handed but also don't like adding lots of layers either. I was curious and bought a few pencils and expected more from them too but in full disclosure, I haven't given them a chance. Once again, thank you for your honest critique on these pencils.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Hi there friend! Thank you. I agree, no one should be bashed for sharing an opinion, but sadly, it happens. Sigh. I do plan to use these a bunch next month *eeek*, but that’s because it is part of my alphabet challenge. Maybe I will feel different after. Or not, haha

[@blessednhm]

I'm a heavy-handed colorist as well and I also color from dark to light so I'm gonna trust you on this one. In fact as you were giving your review I notice a lot of the things you pointed out before you actually mentioned them. There's also the fact that I can't justify spending $300 on colored pencils lol😁

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

If you are curious, you can always buy a few open stock for yourself and just see if you like them.

[@gwensimmons_gigi1629]

Here, here for Luminance!! 🤩👍🏾 Thank you for this honest opinion. 🥰💕🤘🏾 This is how I felt about the Irojitens, overhyped and very disappointing to color with!! BTW, whose ‘skin’?? 🥺😔

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Ah I did not enjoy Irojiten either. Bought one dictionary and was over it sadly. What do you mean skin? LOL

[@paule5896]

Thank you for your review and opinion on these pencils. I tried, I really tried to like these pencils. In my opinion, the pastels are very hard to blend, seem a bit to chalky. The colors are beautiful, but I could not love them, and for the price I should. They are a bit too soft, wear down very easily. However, the Soft White is the best white I have ever used. In the end, I sold them on eBay. Just not my cup of tea.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I hear you. For the price, you just really really want to love them and they are BEAUTIFUL pencils. But, in the end, they didn't work for me. I do agree about the soft white though. That thing is amazing.

[@Lenyxx3]

What a bunch of jerks. I’m so sorry. You absolutely have a right to your opinion. It’s not a big deal if you don’t like a colored pencil. Each person colors differently. Don’t let them get you down. You seem like a kind and genuine person.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Awe thank you. Appreciate it. I do agree that sometimes people should be able to just share an opinion and not be attacked. I mean it's a pencil for pete's sake lol.

[@tamarascoloringcoven718]

TY TY TY for you VERY honest review on these pencils. I myself only wanted the pastels, but since Pastlowe came out I bought those (& I do love those). BUT like you love the prismas, I HATE prisma's & too have been told off even pmed & told off for hating them, & "quote don't know what to use them right! I went through so many sharpeners, & bought 2 of those tggal's & in less then a week of having each the blades bent! People were telling me to stick them out in the sun, nope didnt trust people in our neighbor hood, or put them in the microwave..NOPE the metallic on the pencil will flare up & blow out your microwave, was told to put a heating pad around them, nope doesn't work, then was told a hair dryer...come on really a hair dryer, you know how long it would take to get a hair dryer to melt a darn wax pencil??? Then was told use a heat gun, yeah right, the whole pencil would be melted in no time. The breakage was just too much for me, I was even told I was holding the pencil wrong. I ended up selling mine. I spent more time sharping them then using them, nor should I have to stand on my head to get a darn pencil to work. That being said my fav pencil to use with each other are Derwent coloursofts, Derwent Chromaflows, Sargent Arts Supreme's. My Other are Faber Castell Poly's with my Dick Blick's studio pencils. And then the Amazon basics which I swear are the crazy arts just different colors as they feel like each other, so I use my Amazon basics & crazy arts with each other. But mostly, I'm a Derwent girl.

[@tamarascoloringcoven718]

also like you said hun, everyone has their own preference to what they like. Just because 1 person loves Prisma's or say Polys, but the other doesn't its ok, but don't tell someone off for not liking what another likes

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

So, these have a lot of oil in them, so heating them would not necessarily repair a broken core and could actually cause further issues depending on the formation (which no one knows because no manufacturer says the percentage of oil, wax, etc. Also, Holbeins have fats, and not sure how well that'd fare heated up anyway lol. I totally understand the negativity you get while expressing a dislike for a pencil, and sad that someone feels they cannot share their opinion over a frigging pencil.

[@iwantmy10dollars]

I’m glad for your review. It sounds like they may be more of a specialty pencil. Maybe a better match with Brush and Pencil products. That being said they better get that lightfast fiasco straightened out. Most artist I watch who sell their work prob won’t buy these. Also, I can’t remember who, but someone on KZbin said that in order to sell them in the US they had the change the formula. So the US formula is different than the Japan formula. I thought about buying some of these.. but I think I’ll get the Derwent lightfast instead.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Supposedly they have finally fixed their lightfast rating, but the price of them from Blick is OUTRAGEOUS. I still can't believe they charge that much.

[@sassybanjo3586]

I ordered my pastel 50 set of Holbeins from Amazon Japan after they became available from Dick Blick because they were $98.00 (included shipping). I purchased the 12 set first from Dick Blick, to make sure I liked them. They are still available from Amazon Japan. Perhaps the 150 set is not.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

They go in and out of stock on Amazon Japan for US availability - it seems. When I recorded this there were none. Even said, I wouldn't pay the $240-$270 from Amazon Japan for them. It's not just the price, it's the pencil style - just not for me. Doesn't mean it's not for everyone though.

[@MunchiesMusicMadness]

Great review you let me now every thing I needed to know about these pencils . Based on your review it's a hard pass for me I use a smooth Bristol board. Polychromos may be the most expensive pencil ill use However I use caran d ache white and blender sticks . Thanks for a great review

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Polys are still a great pencil with great lightfastness

[@gwynethglas-brown9171]

Thank you for your honesty. I am tempted but they are on the pricey side. ( i not an artist. I just love doing adult coloring books Done coloring in from off very young age ) So agree every colour pencil set is a huge different story for everyone ,you either like them or you don’t . 🥰 Sorry for the 2 nd answer i kicked to fast before i was finished .

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Very true!

[@NatalieBramasole]

Thank you so so much for your review.....it is sooooooo much money. I have your style and i bought Brutfuner macaron pastel pencils to have such pastel and I think you will like them too,they are better than from Castle arts pastels.........again,thank you so so much

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

I did buy those bad boys actually! Also just got the new Arteza pastels. So there are a good deal of options.

[@pennypop408]

Forgot to say thanks for your honest opinion btw. I am a painter in oils and watercolor also graphite and colored pencils.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

You are so welcome! Oooh I really want to learn oil paints. It's on my list of things to try/learn.

[@yazosoyo]

Very nice review, I also don’t want to layer for days, why don’t you just sell them? I’m sure a lot of people would grab them off you hands and then you can buy another set or another art supply you REALLY want and like! 🥰

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Haha because I also like to collect! but I might part with them one day

[@askialuna7717]

It could also be possible that there were defects that were not noticed by the quality control. I once exchanged a set of Polychromos because many were a bit harder and the pigments were not well mixed with the binding agent that looked very gritty on the paper. The second set hardly had a problem with it, only the ultramarine light colored pencil was always hard and gritty. I tried them all in one store, and they weren't all good.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

That is true which is a reason I will retry pablos

[@CherryBlossomHill]

If you check out Animal Art by Law (colored pencil society), she’ll talk about hardness vs softness of pencils, what she teaches based on her experience is that normally softer pencils will require a lighter pressure to avoid filling up the tooth of the paper before getting all the desired layers to achieve the look that you want. harder pencils like the Polychromos or Pablo’s are more forgiving because you can layer more easily, especially if you color with a heavier hand, without filling up the tooth as quickly when you do want to layer. If these pencils are on the softer side, in theory they should be able to lay down a lot of color quickly so I’m wondering if the problem is more related to what sounds like a very different binder used vs the other brands. Everything she discusses is based on the assumption that hardness of pencil is related to paper with some tooth is being used like cold press watercolor paper. Since most coloring books don’t have a lot of tooth, harder pencils would be better in theory. I’m really sorry you went through all of this. Holbein is known as a student art brand, at least that is what I was told at a Blick store, the high cost may have more to do with the yen-dollar exchange rate rather than the quality. If you haven’t tried the Caran d’Ache Pablo’s, they are on the harder side and are easy to use on smooth paper, their color palette includes more earth tones (fewer brighter tones) compared to the Polychromos.

[@ColorfullyOptimistic]

Yes! These do have fats in them which is one reason they may be softer but don't layer the same