Commander but I Can Play Everyone’s Decks | With

[@s4ad0wpi]

I'm a little sad that my video about Tree discussion was interrupted by a Magic game, but maybe next time!

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

i support cardmarket magic's tree-discussion expansion.

[@BruderSeth]

I wonder what two videos about tree discussions would be called.. A twodeo? A videtwo?

[@Reach_W]

​@@BruderSethA Viduo.

[@blueplayer6197]

I am considering unsubscribing, this channel used to have the best naming object groups with various count and tree discussion videos out there, now it's just some sort of card game channel or something.

[@sh41]

A Grovid?

[@violaknapp7904]

You have heard of Chekov's Gun, now get ready for Chekov's Chronatog

[@AdorableHamster32]

This was *so insane*. Like. It's incredible xd

[@ConManAU]

And also Chekov’s Fling. That last turn felt like the scene in a movie where it flashes back to every insignificant event that was actually a key part of the master plan.

[@StarshadowMelody]

Everyone got fucking _Atog'd._

[@nicolasmendez8286]

Gotta love the 2 minute tree grove discussion and its lasting effects on the gameplay

[@ddp77]

Karl has an inherent concept of Chekov's Rifle built in.

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

i really enjoyed the tree discussion as well. easily could've gone on for 10 minutes and i'd still be very happy with their content!

[@M0NK3Y42]

@@lastnamefirstname8655 Next video is Carl just talking about the different names of things depending on how many trees are involved.

[@JimFaindel]

Thoralf: "Guys, the Communist Brit is back in town, any ideas for a video?" Carl: "Hold OUR beer, comrade!"

[@MoonPatch]

This was genuinely the most earned win I've seen since the legendary 0/5 Fact or Fiction split And honestly, even more epic because of the amazing foreshadowing and twists involved

[@willjust7099]

What video was that? Must have missed it?

[@ryast]

@@willjust7099 Their video on Fires vs Nether-Go, Frank Karsten vs Thoralf

[@peanootor8718]

@@willjust7099 It was a 1v1 video with Thoralf and Frank Karsten, I think Thoralf was on Psychatog and Karsten was on Fires but I'm not sure

[@MoonPatch]

@@peanootor8718 fires vs nether-go, yeah

[@GG-dt5hh]

I could not be more proud of the Chronatog kill. Eater of Days is one of my favourite cards, so the spite turn skip (even if it didn't end up mattering) was a beautiful way to end it.

[@danielmacdonald131]

Me "Oh hey spice is back again its nice they are getting more time on this channel" Spicy "Help I can't leave" Me "I hope they are at least feeding Spicy this time."

[@natben6099]

dunno, he lookis kinda thin

[@GaybrohamStinkton]

He had to barter his penis for an sandwich

[@pigtumor6059]

@@natben6099 *they

[@firby7341]

there was one moment when i thought the last card in Carl's hand that he didnt discard was a Fog because...yaknow he loves Fogs. but then he asked what spice's life total was and i just remembered that one fateful card he mustve kept xD awesome win! ATOG ATOG ATOG!

[@techfour4921]

"Gove of the Burnwillows has 3 trees" All the trees in the back "I guess we just don't mean anything to you"

[@mellowyellow5427]

My absolutely favorite Spice8rack quote is now "When does trees become woods? 🤔"

[@BenziTrain]

That was an AMAZING ending. Couldn't have scripted it better.

[@sigurdviskum978]

Took Spice 1 minute 17 seconds to get existensialist - that's the good stuff we're all here for!

[@The_PokeNerd]

Having a whole video where they all debate random stuff like at the start of this would be a perfect and hilarious April Fools video or something. Anayway, great video!

[@Mthegathering]

Lots of fun, lots of mistakes. The true essence of a Commander game. Amazing show ❤

[@PeterButchens]

I knew something brilliant would happen when hall of the mountain king started playing. But I was still not prepared. Glad I could see Spice mirroring my reaction to all of THAT.

[@ublabaah3908]

Fele. You don't always get a reaction on the table with your jokes (it might be just the editing) but I must say that your humour tickles me greatly.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Fele is the Jamin of the group. He has a niche sense of humor but boy does he serve that niche well :D

[@Rasgat]

That was an absolutely perfect ending to a hilarious game

[@mellowyellow5427]

Holy fuck Carl absolutely stole this game! Absolutely Chad. Also Fele absolutely got targeted for no reason. He had the least threatening board state yet got taken out first. Lol.

[@sulevjaaniste5394]

The fate of a combo player lol, at our lgs we had a Emry player who mostly just drew cards during his turns and minimally developed his board besides that. Still got targeted the moment he showed up, most of the time he died without really doing anything XD

[@AdorableHamster32]

God... the ending

[@gamptrak]

"It don't mean a thing, if it ain't got that fling" - Some old guy in a country that scares me

[@x_chaos_x]

Treefact : trees improve water quality! Tune in next time for more tree facts.

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's a great tree fact! :D

[@GreenMonkeySam]

SUBSCRIBE

[@mrpinguimninja]

Spice's only mode the whole game is "violence isn't the answer, violence is a question, and the answer is always yes".

[@JusteazyGames]

53:50 - The Wilhelm Scream against the intense crescendo of Hall of the Mountain King as Carl secures a rare memeatog victory is just 🤌🤌🤌

[@michel0dy]

If I had a nickel for every video this week in which Spice plays commander with a special rule that lets them use the opponent's cards, I'd have two nickels. Two nickels is good, three would be a crowd.

[@madelyneation]

I thought there was a grove?

[@madelyneation]

I thought there was a grove?

[@RealityMasterRogue]

that ending was anime worthy, actually wild

[@jacobisbell9388]

I feel like Thoralf might not have known the format before he chose his commander, not casting permanent spells is a pretty big downside when you can cast your opponents spells. Okay i watched more of the video and nevermind i get the point now.

[@CristichiEX]

Common galaxy brain Thoralf move

[@AaronThePerson]

True

[@BruderSeth]

Never underestimate the pro :D

[@lucasrodriguesdefreitas3387]

you could have played with upside down decks and prevent all that flipping.

[@xolotltolox7626]

Convulsion of Nature gameplay

[@CardmarketMagic]

Isn't the flipping just more fun? :)

[@yamamotokun80]

I like the idea that if not Thoralf is the first casualty, it’s Fele. Hehehe…. Excellent game!

[@hadinossanosam4459]

Hot damn, Spice was out for blood during filming... 27:49 "This is *our* friendship, and you need to back off" 29:44 the quiet "Do we need to step outside?" 34:00 "I seek carnage" (what a line) 42:05 impromptu villain dialogue 47:39 "Atraxa's gotta get off the board somehow and I don't have targeted removal" 49:53 "Are you still here?"

[@masterseaturtle6913]

I really liked the music in this episode, especially at the end when it kept getting faster

[@Whothefisalice]

I am just on my own fully cheering for that ending when i realised what card had been left.... I think my dog is concerned. Great video.

[@CraftyCreeper64]

you know when spice made the joke about the two towers, carl 100% thought he was going somewhere else

[@darkora_]

My god, what a GLORIOUS game, I was not prepared for that last turn 🤣

[@qjc1142pigs]

Man souls herder putting the counter on what it blinks instead would be interesting. Was fun to see what that would be like even if it was a mistake

[@ddp77]

Got my first laugh at about 8 seconds in, and literally clapped for the ending. Brilliant and fun throughout.

[@pdb189]

That ending was unbelievable. I love this channel

[@zoleriibaenre8365]

5:12 I really thought that joke was going in a different direction

[@josuelservin]

That win was a thing of beauty! What a game, I hope the format returns it's a blast to watch.

[@obeseninja4]

Spice: Dear God please help!! Thoralf: :D

[@Necroskull388]

In Japanese, the kanji for “tree” is 木 and the kanji for “forest” is 森 which is just three trees. So Japan has decided, you need three trees to make a forest.

[@catgirlQueer]

but two trees make a grove / small group of trees! it's 木, 林, 森

[@Genshboy]

Just that the Japanese didn't decide that because it was an import from China. It's the same in Chinese where the Kanji or rather Hanzi have originated.

[@Necroskull388]

@@Genshboy "Kanji" in Japanese is spelled with the characters for "Chinese" and "Character", so I'm well aware of that. When I say this in the context of Japanese, I'm not saying that because I think it's unique to Japan, but because I learned Japanese, not Mandarin or Cantonese.

[@Genshboy]

@@Necroskull388 Sorry, I maybe just came of as a little passive aggressive but I was just refering to Japan deciding, which I think didn´t really happen but rather it was adapted as is.

[@rajamicitrenti1374]

@32:50 Spice stops to explain how Coat of Arms works, but explains it wrong. Coat of Arms effectively gives each creature +1/+1 for each other creature that shares at least 1 type with it. 2 Goblin Wizards would each only give each other +1/+1, but a Goblin Wizard, a Goblin Rogue, and a Human Wizard would give +2/+2 to the Goblin Wizard and +1/+1 to each of the Goblin Rogue and the Human Wizard.

[@SwiftVines]

Megatog eating the nevinyrral's disk was awesome. I can only imagine what that would actually look like.

[@kharkarus]

I'm here to support Fele in his quest for being heard.

[@GreenMonkeySam]

This was TOP DRAWER entertainment. Absolute cinema.This might be a top 3 episode.

[@bryanbailey-v3y]

Watching you guys play is so entertaining! I absolutely love the banter and can’t get enough of it. 😂 Please keep putting out this enormously funny content. Thank you for your hard work. May you continue for as long as you want to.

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm really happy you enjoy our bafooneries :) we'll be sure to keep bafooning

[@FrequencySpectre-y1b]

Fun fact: In Chinese, 木=wood/tree, 林=woods, 森=full of trees, 森林=forest

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's just multiplying the character for tree! I love it :D

[@Tryptic214]

Can you imagine if Soulherder actually did put the +1/+1 counter on the creature it flickered, instead of putting the counter on itself? o.O

[@nataliem7719]

Omg that ending! The music was perfect too haha. Super fun video from start to finish!

[@wraith.ferron]

There's an arborist that's either very happy, or extremely angry right now

[@CardmarketMagic]

According to what I've found on Google, the arborist would have mixed feelings :P

[@Moetastic]

I completely forgot about fling, Carl RKO'd the board. 😂

[@omegavulture8379]

The BobRossTron taps for two of each type of mana.

[@Mindscape6]

Happy little trees, er grove.

[@vincentxu8217]

So disappointed that Carl didn't dress up as Karl who is right there in the thumbnail, 0/10 J/K, awesome video guys

[@CardmarketMagic]

Check out the deck lists here: bit.ly/3Za5FXO

[@shadestrademark8738]

Always love to see the deck lists; can help see if there are any cards I could add to my own decks!

[@hughmungas4724]

Been loving the content you guys have been putting out, some of the best magic content on this platform. Would love to see the return of feature matches at some point too with people like Arne, Gabriel, or Andrea going head-to-head against you guys!

[@CardmarketMagic]

We finished out Best Deck Ever just last month :) which was two months of regular feature matches. We'll be launching the next one early next year

[@tonythepokemonguy751]

I expected the whole video to be about groves and forests with the video ending with a giant white board and Thoralf and Spice covered in marker

[@whammaster]

Why did no one see maskwood nexus as a massive threat and have fele cast it.

[@usof75756]

They all talked about how big of a threat it was. Spice did nicely ask them to not mess with it though.

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

truly, the ending to this game of commander is so beautiful and perfect.

[@Sparkleonitsthursdayinnit]

Im drowning in pure bliss at three back to back spice 8 rack commander videos. Omfg

[@TheDarkElder]

Aaaahmazing ending for a fun game. Well played, all of you! Funny how it all played in one player's favour in the end. Even the wild creature counting did it. 😀

[@DefinitelyNotReal627]

Fele is a menace and i'm here for it lol.

[@jaggedtoothgrin]

This is one of, possibly the, best game of commander I've ever seen

[@DragoSmash]

i had to rewatch that ending several times because i cannot yet believe how things lined up for Carl, it was an epic ending for an epic game

[@JanderStrahd]

Very interesting and high-brow discussion about the terms of venery for trees. Playing with the top card always revealed. No one realizes they can just play with their decks face-up. 🧐

[@CardmarketMagic]

Flipping the card is more fun :)

[@Starcrash6984]

What an epic ending! I loved that so much. It's worth watching to the end, for certain.

[@ScorpioneOrzion]

Codie is actually exile until you hit a instant/sorcery that cost less, you may play that card this turn without paying its mana cost. So you can cast it later as well.

[@monikaswife2434]

52:28 this is CINEMA the looks on their faces are everything,, truly one of the endings of all time

[@WolfPage-f8w]

Every episode with spice... well... Has some spice!

[@Cheems59]

This is just every commander game for me. *Laughs in big red dinosaur*

[@bishop5116]

You can choose not to search / shuffle off of Path to Exile. Great game btw! Awesome ending.

[@doim1676]

That was an amazing last turn! Such an awesome victory!

[@JusteazyGames]

7:45 - I'm calling it now, Spice is playing a Maskwood Nexus deck.

[@HeroErix]

That ending was beautiful

[@Arathai_]

Music choice at the end was on point!

[@DEATHMETALRUST]

WHAT A WIN!!!! That was great. 😂😂😂

[@AdorableHamster32]

So that's why Spice hasn't been answering my emails!

[@AstoranSolaire]

There are clearly seven trees in the art of Grove of the Burnwillows.

[@phillipmeade7640]

OMFG that was an amazing video with the best ending of a magic game I have seen in soo long.

[@Carteboy]

When Spice said "We have the two towers!" I freaked out

[@SuperF16-h4r]

Wouldn’t it be Spice trapping people normally 😮

[@Casi_Here]

Doing this with decks with identical sleeves is diabolical

[@lastnamefirstname8655]

this is so much fun! thanks cardmarket magic! it's fun to steal cards from other players in mtg. i have a brawl deck in mtga that aims to steal the opponents' cards as much as possible, even though it's not good at all.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Sometimes it's about having fun more than winning :)

[@Rocknoob49]

7:50 there's some (hopefully not too over the line) joke about an enby playing kindred kindred in there.

[@dmonki6585]

its like your reading my mind. i was exactly wondering how 3 of these commanders would play out! :O

[@yuriemmettippi4503]

I've seen it and I AM SPEECHLESS! ASTONISHING! BEAUTIFUL! WONDERFUL! I stood up and applauded! The entire game was pure Chaos, and Carl that was an absolute BOMB! Chronatog kill! I bow to the master!

[@CardmarketMagic]

🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳 I'm happy you enjoyed it!

[@STS-qi1qy]

Nice. More Spice! Love to see it!

[@LarsEckert_Molimo]

2:22 At least we can agree that hobbits are not orcs

[@ozzie_paladin]

ok this makes me want to build 4 decks just so i can play this with some friends! I am inspired now 😂

[@JakkHorwikk]

I am truly so deeply impressed with how this game went down. Love Spices tribal tribal deck.

[@SargeantPacman]

I'm sure other people said this already, but I googled it and at least in the US a "forest" is a space of an acre with at least 10% of the land covered by the tree canopy. So in theory, if you had two REALLY BIG trees it would be a forest lol

[@Stevetr0n]

That is one of the qualifiers, but according to the USFS no land considered a forest can have any activities preventing tree regeneration or succession. So even mowing that acre would disqualify it.

[@kyledawson8336]

Thank you for another amazing video Cardmarket team! I love all the videos you all make, but i especially love the ones with whacky and fun rules :D currently building a sharpie cube too introduce my children to magic, keep up the amazing work.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Ooooh enjoy the Sharpie cube! They are super dun :D I'm happy you enjoyed the video!

[@FraggleRockss]

That ending was incredible

[@shyammilanshah9949]

I need the decklist for that Morophon Deck! A friend wants to build a Kindred Lords deck, it would be fun to show that to them :)

[@Buchaus]

It's posted in the comments! Also on their website

[@Einherjar212]

This is the best commander video I've yet seen.

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm happy you enjoyed it :)

[@scissorthief5119]

The second I saw "Our Deck" in the thumbnail I knew Spice was here lol

[@sebastiankortmann4689]

By the way: Fele forgot his first counter on the Soulherder, when he exiled Atraxa.

[@MoonPatch]

Carl usually gets stomped and punished for being the agent of chaos and fun silly times he is, so it's vindicating to see him win, doubly so because his win ended up being just as chaotic and silly as all his plays

[@ultimategamer8622]

Spice rocking the kufiya in every video is a joy

[@EffinChat]

If I had a dollar for every time Spice appeared in a video where it played a commander variant involving playing other people's decks this month, I'd have 2 dollars. Which isn't much but it is weird that it happened twice

[@jaimeluisdossantos6535]

a Blim, Comedic Genius deck in this game would be crazy

[@abefaerber7994]

I think a group of two trees would be called a stand.