COMMUNISM VS SOCIALISM| Explained in TAMIL| Manjari

#economics #communism #socialism #tamil
We have been using these terms quite common in our conversation. But what is the actual difference between both?
Watch the video fully to understand the meaning of both in an economic context.
NOTE: The ideas talked about is not related to the communist political party
Do check our latest video on marxism and communism : • Marxism என்றால் என்ன? ...
Editing Credits: Abhishek Sahu
Thumbnail Credits: Abinesh
Econfinity is an initiative to break down complex ideas in economics, finance, and public policy in simple terms for the Tamil audience.
Follow and support our initiative by subscribing and sharing with your network.
Do comment on topics that you would like me to cover in the upcoming videos.
Stay in touch on Social Media
Website: www.econfinity.in
Facebook Page: / manjaribalu
Instagram: / manjari_balu
For queries mail [e-mail]

[@TamilScreenshot]

இந்தியாவில் அதிக பட்சம் நம் வாழ்நாள் முழுவதும் அடிப்படை தேவைக்காக தான் உழைத்துக் கொண்டிருக்கிறோம்! Socialism என்பது அடிப்படைத் தேவைகள் அனைவருக்கும் கிடைத்த பிறகு வர வேண்டிய ஒன்று, அதாவது Communism-ன் அடுத்த படி என்று சொல்லலாம், நாம் ஒரு படி மேலே சென்று விட்டோம் என நினைத்து வாழ முடியாமல் தடுமாறிக் கொண்டிருக்கிறோம்!

[@Ejamaan_3s0]

வார்த்தை உச்சரிப்பு அசத்தலாக உள்ளது...👏🤗 மேன்மேலும் வளர்க 👍

[@prabakaran6348]

எது காம்யூனிஸ்ட்னு சொல்ரதா

[@blueplanetmadras9158]

Na nenachan neenga sollitinga 😂​@@prabakaran6348

[@தமிழ்வளவன்]

சிறப்பான பதிவு வாழ்த்துக்கள் தோழர்

[@johnvedhamuthu6866]

ஆயிரம் ஆயிரம் வாழ்த்துக்கள்*

[@apratheep9140]

பண ஆசை எல்லா தீமைக்கும் ஆணிவேர்.

[@PsychologyinTamil]

Really good initiative, havent seen your channel in these many years.

[@pravinap9004]

Easy to understand these concepts, thank you

[@arula2741]

Please make a detailed video about - M O N E Y -

[@linganathan1896]

அருமையான விளக்கம் நன்றிங்க

[@parvathyponniah4591]

Ur content is v good .

[@haseebdxb6444]

Sister some time communism nu solluringa ..illana caammunism nu solluringa

[@ArvindKumar-hk6le]

Unaku purinja podo pa, velakamm tevaillae

[@rpsudhan_]

voice sync illa... happening only for me?

[@apratheep9140]

எல்லாமே இதில் வரும்...!!!

[@santhoshk6695]

Thanks for such a clarity😊

[@mohann1906]

Nantry tholare

[@கார்த்தீமோகன்தமிழன்]

மயக்கும் குறள்🥳🥳

[@AadhiJay]

Nice explanation. Can we say socialism is a softer version of communism?

[@Idlinomics]

Yes. To some extent. In terms of ownership it's softer version

[@abilashraghavan786]

The ultimate goal of socialism is communism.

[@AadhiJay]

@@Idlinomics Please make a video about how our soviet style five year planning helped or hindered our economic prospects.

[@dhejonithandondj]

Pls make a video on thinkers like Karl Marx as a series or playlist

[@Idlinomics]

Sure. Stay tuned for the next video on Marxism

[@thamaraiannadurai6160]

I understand this concept in your video only, apt explanation... please post more videos...

[@vinithkumart4635]

Please explain about cold war sister

[@vigneshwaranravi4263]

Libertarian socialist.. Anarchist... Liberal.. Who is liberatrian... Indha term la onnume purila... Do explain video bout it

[@gowtham002]

_உலக வங்கி மற்றும் சர்வதேச நீதி ஆணையம் எப்படி செயல்படுகிறது என்று கூறுங்கள் அக்கா_

[@Idlinomics]

Will make one sure. 🙂

[@CuriousAdil]

Clearly Explained with good Examples...👌 Crisp and to the point.

[@newday1393]

Purinchu😍

[@friedrichengels1364]

Ma'am I just wanted to say that sweeden is not a socialist country.....it's a monarchy

[@pretty948]

Monarchy is not a economic structure it's a form of government

[@basedtsar9440]

Its is a capitalist country and its is a constitutional monarchy.

[@marimuthuazhagusundaram]

Good evening, I wanna know about share market from basics....so can you please put a video abt it...or if you have already done please give me link. Thank you

[@nilavazhaganc3918]

Excellent.. well explained... expecting more videos sister...

[@dineshchandra4619]

Thank you sister....

[@amongdoomers9464]

Quality content 👌

[@vivekraju5109]

Kaar mark capital .can stand nowadays. Can upto stand the nation ...come under socialism and dmolise indiviualism

[@Raj-gq3ki]

Mam Please refer some Communism books in tamil

[@nivethaselvam9318]

Very nice explanation

[@mohgangovindasamy8443]

What's apps இந்த காண்னொளியை பதிர இயலுமா?

[@aravindsamson6184]

Aravakadu

[@jayanthipandiyan6639]

Loved it.❤️

[@velmuruganbalakrishnan4564]

Good sister .

[@kaushiksampath3071]

Manjari ma'am, may you please offer your critique of Reaganomics, Thatcherism & the concept of neo-liberalism. Has liberalisation of the economy through free markets helped the middle class of the world to improve their standard of living? What is your take on LPG reforms in India since 1991. Hasn't Free Markets brought more positive changes to the world? Pls share your opinions on the above & kindly ask Economist Jayaranjan sir to give a detailed exposition on why he asserts that India's pre-LPG era was better for India?

[@Idlinomics]

I can't talk for economist Jeyeranjan. I will make a video on neoliberalism the pros and cons very soon.

[@kv7670]

Different between Marxism, communism, socialism?

[@Idlinomics]

Please follow the channel. There will be a video on Marxism very soon.

[@omcarhari]

interesting ...

[@yuvarajkosalram6955]

Information is simple and clear, then is UK a socialist country? they do have good free education and hospital.

[@kaleeswarank9798]

Super akka

[@manjunathang1566]

Hammer 🔨 is used in communism not a cross symbol please change the thumbnail sister

[@hockeyprasanth8844]

👍 but pasi ponnathuku aporam sapudura oru idly aduthavan oodathu nalla dialogue tha ana aaravwaykaadu nu solleta 😂

[@Idlinomics]

But that's not what communism is

[@mspriyan123]

Sister very super

[@abu2688]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@kasadarainainthukarpom6655]

👌👌

[@KirubanithiSLakshmi]

👏👏👍

[@a_living_creature]

🔥 🔥 🔥

[@engg14]

தமிழ் தேசியம் பற்றி பேசுங்க

[@senthilkumar5]

Communism is utopia concept.. so far we never achieved

[@basedtsar9440]

Utopia is impossible for human beings it only can achieved by tribes and animals

[@KarlMarxist]

sorry to say u told wrong information abt communism and socialism. Socialism is when the key industries sectors of a country economy are controlled by the government like telecommunication transportation financial sectors and heavy industries and resources and mineral mining industries and even crude oil sectors the government take the profits from these sectors to give free education health care facilities and constriction of houses for homeless ppl and other social welfare schemes and even some times they are used to give cheaper interest rate loans to co operative society that are controlled by workers or the public ppl like us and the rest of the economy like light industry and consumer industries are owned by workers co operatives and collectively owned by public or consumer ppl and this is called socialism and communism is the last stage after the completion of socialist economic model in communism the government will no longer exist instead every companies both key and light industries will owned co operatively or collectively owned there will be no single ownership or government ownership instead ppl share their income from the produce equally among themselves for the greater benefits of the society there wouldn't be no income inequality and no private companies and exploitation no one percent community owning 99% of the wealth of the world thus there will equitable distribution of resources for betterment of the public is called communism . Ussr is not communist or socialist it is a state capitalist and China also state capitalistic

[@withtheflow...wtf...4667]

Simple and liked it👍 but communism has dark side only history quoting us isnt it?if there is no success what is the meaning of still holding it?👍

[@ajazasharaf7865]

Nothing is permanent brother.. marx himself said history is cyclic.. even though communism is not completely successful its a hope.. hope for all the suppressed and poor.. hope for a better future.. hope for a egalitarian society.. so don't loose hope!

[@withtheflow...wtf...4667]

There are 7 billions of DNA's...every DNA is difference...so...

[@martinmadrazo1781]

The Darkest side of Capitalism is two world wars. Communism doesn't has anything dark to equal that.

[@user-zj5et2bo3q]

Rendumay thandamay

[@basedtsar9440]

Based

[@Joker-rw1wr]

😀😁

[@ashokagri736]

உங்களோட முழு விளக்கமே தவறா இருக்கு தோழி

[@theanonymous2532]

Ena thavaru?

[@raviprasad3024]

Both are waste, not one country in this worlds history has benefited from either philosophies

[@murugavelrayar3202]

பாப்பா படி.....படி

[@manjaribalu6462]

Edha?

[@faizurrahman597]

இரண்டு மாடுகள் வைத்திருப்பவனிடமிருந்து அரசாங்கம் ஒன்றை வாங்கி மாடு இல்லாதவனிடம் கொடுத்தால் அது சோசலிசம் அதே இரண்டு மாடுகள் வைத்திருப்பவன் இரண்டையும் அரசாங்கத்திடம் ஒப்படைத்துவிட்டு தேவையான பாலை மட்டும் (இலவசமாக) வாங்கிக்கொண்டால் அது கம்யூனிசம் உரிமையாளனிடமிருந்து மாட்டைப் பிடுங்கிக்கொண்டு அதன் பாலை அவனுக்கே விற்றால் அது பாசிசம் எங்கோ படித்தது!

[@krishnamoorthyrkm8560]

இது பாவேந்தர் பாரதிதாசனின் விளக்கம்

[@karunaharanv6617]

Actually china is capitalist but the govenment is strict.

[@invincibleman1258]

Communism pudici oombu

[@saikeerthana8906]

You deserve more! Very simple explanation with clear content.. please continue your videos. U will reach heights! Waiting for more videos..

[@Idlinomics]

Thank you for your encouragement and support.☺

[@ashokagri736]

@@Idlinomics உங்க விளக்கமே தவறு

[@KarlMarxist]

​@@Idlinomics sorry to say u told wrong information abt communism and socialism. Socialism is when the key industries sectors of a country economy are controlled by the government like telecommunication transportation financial sectors and heavy industries and resources and mineral mining industries and even crude oil sectors the government take the profits from these sectors to give free education health care facilities and constriction of houses for homeless ppl and other social welfare schemes and even some times they are used to give cheaper interest rate loans to co operative society that are controlled by workers or the public ppl like us and the rest of the economy like light industry and consumer industries are owned by workers co operatives and collectively owned by public or consumer ppl and this is called socialism and communism is the last stage after the completion of socialist economic model in communism the government will no longer exist instead every companies both key and light industries will owned co operatively or collectively owned there will be no single ownership or government ownership instead ppl share their income from the produce equally among themselves for the greater benefits of the society there wouldn't be no income inequality and no private companies and exploitation no one percent community owning 99% of the wealth of the world thus there will equitable distribution of resources for betterment of the public is called communism . Ussr is not communist or socialist it is a state capitalist and China also state capitalistic

[@ipejohn8252]

👌👌👌

[@gokulg3521]

Communism showing socialism,lol.

[@naaperiyasami4803]

எளிமையான விளக்கம். படங்களுடன் இணைத்துக் காட்டியது அருமை. வாழ்த்துக்கள்.

[@manimozhiyanl5004]

கம்யூனிசம் மற்றும் சோசலிசம் குறித்து நீங்கள் பேசியிருப்பது அடிப்படையிலேயே தவறானதாகும். தயவு செய்து எங்கள்ஸ் எழுதிய கம்யூனிச கோட்பாடுகள் என்ற புத்தகத்தைப் படிக்கவும்.

[@Idlinomics]

நன்றி. ஒரு கோட்பாடு அரசியல் மற்றும் பொருளாதார வெளிப்பாடுகளில் உருவெடுத்து வரும். What Engels spoke was majorly on the political lens. And let me remind you that Marx spoke of labour value theory that advanced from the initial ideas. As we look back at history what was developed in these books did not happen the same way. This video is trying to explain the trajectory. And it is not wise to believe things will happen the way it was written in a book. There are other factors and things that influenced such things. If I just have to tell what Engels said in that book that means I'm romanticizing communism. I'm basically putting an economics lens and trying to be as practical as possible. Thanks.

[@Idlinomics]

I have read communist Manifesto and Das Kapital. And let me say there are multiple problems in the translation. This is a common problem flagged by many.

[@apratheep9140]

எதுவும் நிரந்தரம் இல்லை.

[@karthikrv1984]

1)இடது முன்னனி 2)இடது ஜனநாயக முன்னனி 3)சோசலிசம் 4)கம்யூனிசம்

[@மயில்ராவணன்]

Love u akka😘😘😘😘😘😘

[@tamil_rebel]

Lal salam saghave

[@karthikkarthik453]

Hail dravidanadu support from telangana state 💪🔥

[@preparingminds-silamsharif1957]

Socialism is not followed by Scandinavian countries ...Basic principal is communism equal education ,Healthcare and rights ..and independent rights apart from basic needs are democracy....

[@mallikr2900]

you can always be a communist in a free country but you can never been free in the communist country

[@manjaribalu6462]

True

[@sivaa7580]

Wonderful, Simple and clear. Keep doing this great work!!! Appreciated. Kalakkal!!!

[@shivanaturallife9056]

சோ சொலிசத்தில் இருந்து Captalismத்திற்கு மாறுகிறார்களே

[@pavipavithran3896]

Comrade better learn more about socialism and communism.😃 Most information you provided are false.

[@Idlinomics]

Feel free to add your comments and cite your sources. Thank you!

[@sanbumanimani5426]

உலகத்தில் எங்குமே கம்யூனிஸம் இல்லை.சோவியத்யூனியன் உள்பட முந்தைய கிழக்கு ஐரோப்பிய நாடுகளில் இருந்தவை எல்லாம் சோசலிசமே.கம்யூனிசத்தின் முதல் கட்டம் சோசலிசம் இரண்டாவது கட்டம் கம்யூனிசம்.உழைப்புக்கேற்ற ஊதியம் சோசலிசம்.தேவைக்கேற்ற ஊதியம் கம்யூனிசம்.அரசு முதலான அடக்குமுறை கருவிகள் இல்லாத ஒரு அற்புதமான சமுதாயம்.ஒவாவொருவரும் தன் திறமைக்கேற்ற உழைப்பை நல்குவர்.தன் தேவைக்கேற்றதை எடுத்துக்கொள்வர். சுரண்டலற்ற ஒரு சொர்க்கபுரி அதுதான் கம்யூனிசம்.

[@pavipavithran3896]

@@sanbumanimani5426 exactly comrade.✊

[@letsplay4332]

@@sanbumanimani5426 exactly

[@tdeepak1991]

Perfect bro

[@Sharu1888]

Why are you not uploading any videos in recent times manjari ?

[@manjaribalu6462]

Will start v soon

[@apratheep9140]

தவறுவது மனித இயல்பு ஆகும்; மன்னிக்க, தெய்வீக.

[@mmuthuvel6829]

சம உடைமை என்ற சொல்லே கிடையாது. தவறான விளக்கமாக நான் பார்க்கிறேன்.

[@pkgaming750]

Mam Unga speech super I intrested to be learn about communism socialism pls suggest books for me to I intersted to read books plsz give suggest

[@svk2548]

Super sister

[@apratheep9140]

அதிகாரம் கெடுக்கிறது; முழுமையான சக்தி முற்றிலும் சிதைக்கிறது.

[@vishnubharathip]

Communist pronounce crt aha pannu ma

[@sanbumanimani5426]

கம்யூனிசம் பற்றிய அடிப்படை அறிவு சிறிதும் அற்ற விளக்கம்.சகோதரி படிக்கவேண்டிய புத்தகம் லெனின் எழுதிய 'அரசும் புரட்சியும்' ஆங்கிலத்தில் State and Revolution

[@tamilworldpowers6953]

Correct தான் நீங்க போய் படிங்க

[@sakthieaswaran3037]

நீங்களும் படிக்க வேண்டியது அதிகம் உள்ளது நண்பா கம்யூனிசத்தின் கடவுளாக இன்றும் 135 கோடி தொழிலாளர்களால் போற்றப்படும் மார்க்ஸின் சிறுதுளியையேனும் கற்றுத்தேருங்கள்

[@Krishna_rationalist]

நல்ல பகுப்பாய்வு... தொடர்ந்து பேசுங்கள் தோழி...👍

[@LocalstarMohan777]

Socialsm irunthale pothum...

[@rajarathnamprasannavinayag3204]

Sister there is no communist country in the world (USSR was not a communist country). The countries you list are run by their communists party. They are all socialist. Communism is what they are trying to achieve. It is a classless stateless moneyless society. A society of abundance. A utopia. Socialism is the intermediate stage between capitalism and Communism. A socialists government takes very means necessary to achieve Communism while maintain some level of equality and equity. Hope this helps.

[@viveikcsekaran1992]

Romb romba nandri 🙏🙏🙏romba arumaiyana explanation...enaku theliva purinjadhu...

[@gokulramr.s293]

Viva comrade 💪

[@vijaysangakkarasri5073]

Super

[@sakthiramasamy96]

அருமையான விளக்கம்

[@snehakannan4111]

Amazing work!!! Can you make a seperate video completely about India, Which would help out many people to understand about our country more ☺

[@sakthivels7582]

Perfect...🚩🚩🚩

[@sanjaymuthulakshmi9867]

Sister your explanation is good .But people like me who knows the two word communisum and socialism from this video can't able to understand clearly sorry but you said it is vast subject right so explain individual so engineering's like me can understand about this important subjects little bit and explain it's merits and demirets . AND I HAVE A QUESTION WHICH YOU WILL PREFER FOR OUR HOME NATION.

[@mabi2kr]

VOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW. EXTRAORDINARY TALENT. BEAUTIFULL EXPLANATION

[@sivasankar1484]

'Democracy is a form of the state, it represents, on the one hand, the organized, systematic use of force against persons; but, on the other hand, it signifies the formal recognition of equality of citizens, the equal right of all to determine the structure of, and to administer, the state. This, in turn, results in the fact that, at a certain stage in the development of democracy, it first welds together the class that wages a revolutionary struggle against capitalism--the proletariat, and enables it to crush, smash to atoms, wipe off the face of the earth the bourgeois, even the republican-bourgeois, state machine, the standing army, the police and the bureaucracy and to substitute for them a more democratic state machine, but a state machine nevertheless, in the shape of armed workers who proceed to form a militia involving the entire population. Here "quantity turns into quality": such a degree of democracy implies overstepping the boundaries of bourgeois society and beginning its socialist reorganization. If really all take part in the administration of the state, capitalism cannot retain its hold. The development of capitalism, in turn, creates the preconditions that enable really “all” to take part in the administration of the state. Some of these preconditions are: universal literacy, which has already been achieved in a number of the most advanced capitalist countries, then the "training and disciplining" of millions of workers by the huge, complex, socialized apparatus of the postal service, railways, big factories, large-scale commerce, banking, etc., etc. Given these economic preconditions, it is quite possible, after the overthrow of the capitalists and the bureaucrats, to proceed immediately, overnight, to replace them in the control over production and distribution, in the work of keeping account of labor and products, by the armed workers, by the whole of the armed population. (The question of control and accounting should not be confused with the question of the scientifically trained staff of engineers, agronomists, and so on. These gentlemen are working today in obedience to the wishes of the capitalists and will work even better tomorrow in obedience to the wishes of the armed workers.) Accounting and control--that is mainly what is needed for the "smooth working", for the proper functioning, of the first phase of communist society. All citizens are transformed into hired employees of the state, which consists of the armed workers. All citizens becomes employees and workers of a single countrywide state “syndicate”. All that is required is that they should work equally, do their proper share of work, and get equal pay; the accounting and control necessary for this have been simplified by capitalism to the utmost and reduced to the extraordinarily simple operations--which any literate person can perform--of supervising and recording, knowledge of the four rules of arithmetic, and issuing appropriate receipts.[1] When the majority of the people begin independently and everywhere to keep such accounts and exercise such control over the capitalists (now converted into employees) and over the intellectual gentry who preserve their capitalist habits, this control will really become universal, general, and popular; and there will be no getting away from it, there will be "nowhere to go". The whole of society will have become a single office and a single factory, with equality of labor and pay. But this “factory” discipline, which the proletariat, after defeating the capitalists, after overthrowing the exploiters, will extend to the whole of society, is by no means our ideal, or our ultimate goal. It is only a necessary step for thoroughly cleansing society of all the infamies and abominations of capitalist exploitation, and for further progress. From the moment all members of society, or at least the vast majority, have learned to administer the state themselves, have taken this work into their own hands, have organized control over the insignificant capitalist minority, over the gentry who wish to preserve their capitalist habits and over the workers who have been thoroughly corrupted by capitalism--from this moment the need for government of any kind begins to disappear altogether. The more complete the democracy, the nearer the moment when it becomes unnecessary. The more democratic the “state” which consists of the armed workers, and which is "no longer a state in the proper sense of the word", the more rapidly every form of state begins to wither away. For when all have learned to administer and actually to independently administer social production, independently keep accounts and exercise control over the parasites, the sons of the wealthy, the swindlers and other "guardians of capitalist traditions", the escape from this popular accounting and control will inevitably become so incredibly difficult, such a rare exception, and will probably be accompanied by such swift and severe punishment (for the armed workers are practical men and not sentimental intellectuals, and they scarcely allow anyone to trifle with them), that the necessity of observing the simple, fundamental rules of the community will very soon become a habit. Then the door will be thrown wide open for the transition from the first phase of communist society to its higher phase, and with it to the complete withering away of the state.' - Lenin www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1917/staterev/ch05.htm#s4

[@Muthukavi18]

தெளிவா சொல்லிருக்கிங்க❤️

[@sakthivelm3422]

Madam india?

[@recreationalraj2972]

Tell about Ilyich ulyonov

[@honest61997]

communism pathi innum depth ah pesuna nalla irrukum

[@pretty948]

Theory padeenga boss

[@dance00002]

I heard the 1st sentence and hit the like and subscribe button✊