Comparing American Girl Tiana to Claudie / Disney Dolls

As much as I love Tiana x AG, I wanted to do a comparison video of her next to Claudie as well as Tiana dolls by Disney.
#americangirl #agtube #doll #disney #disneyprincess

[@amber0290]

I would love to see the eye and wig swap because I completely agree with the differences you’re seeing!

[@DisBlaine]

I’ve ordered a Claudie and a Tiana to swap. They’ll probably arrive in a couple days. Wish me luck lol

[@Kari-G]

Lol I’m right there with ya. Every Tiana vid I’ve seen doesn’t talk about the yellow or “how beautiful the tone is” and I’m sitting there like but she’s….yellow? 😂. I also feel like they could have done so much more for the head piece to look A bit more intricate and high quality. It’s literally what your eye is drawn to first and completely cheapens the entire look of her IMO. Anyway nice content- you’ve got a new sub 😊

[@DisBlaine]

You see the yellow filter too?? I’m in the process of doing a sort of Frankenstein Tiana (swapping her wig and eyes with Claudie and making a nicer version of the dress and tiara), so I’m excited to see her look less yellow lol

[@Monay-p7l]

Thank you for the insight. I love Princess Tiana. I bought my daughter everything Princess Tiana when she was little, she just turned 18. Now I’m somewhat taking over her AGD collection.

[@DisBlaine]

No way!! A Tiana AND American Girl fan??? That’s so exciting! My Tiana collection makes my AG collection look like a mere toy box. I have so much I’ve gotten embarrassed showing it on my Tiana based instagram. I wonder how many cool things you have if you started in 2009!! 💚💚

[@CherishedDollFriends]

I really love the custom Tiana dress on Claudie. It is very sweet. I am not a fan of the papery/plastic texture of the meet dresses on the new Disney dolls. Cinderella is my favourite.💕

[@DisBlaine]

I decided to proceed with making a sort of hybrid doll, so I’ll post a video once I make the eye and wig swap. Fingers crossed!

[@Flanuora]

I really appreciated hearing your perspective as a Tiana collector.

[@DisBlaine]

I’ll try to make another video now that my other Tiana dolls have arrived

[@rach496]

They definitely made Jasmine too dark and Tiana too light. But I have to say I love the Tiana doll very much because her skin tone and my skin tone are very similar. I guess I have yellow undertones lol

[@DisBlaine]

Welllll I obviously love Tiana and her yellow undertones considering I bought 6 😅 I hope you get one if you haven’t yet! She doesn’t look very yellow in other outifts. And she’s very unique!

[@Grandma_HoneyVA]

I love this comparison! I’m partial to the Tiana skin tone because it’s more caramel like my husband. ❤😂 but in all seriousness, I think she’s lighter when she’s in her work outfit in the movie, and darker at night in the moonlight in the blue dress. I love her either way!!!!!❤

[@DisBlaine]

@@Grandma_HoneyVA when I look at Tiana in the AG world, I absolutely love her skin tone. I’ve also adjusted to it-and appreciate that I have a Claudie / Tiana hybrid that makes her perfect 😁

[@AGbcn_0629]

What a great video! I have not purchased anything related to Tiana or Claudie. I'm way behind on my wish list these two are not even close to being bought during 2025 hehe.. Thanks for sharing your nice collection 🤩🤩

[@DisBlaine]

@@AGbcn_0629 well I’m the opposite lol! I have everything Claudie and Tiana… x10 🤣

[@AGbcn_0629]

@@DisBlaine I guess if I could get them easier I would be in your shoes lol 🤩🤩

[@kimberlyzuluaga]

I looveee the Claudie mold and didn't know whether to get Tiana or Claudie. I think I like og Claudie a little more she is just so cute. Thank you for the video!

[@DisBlaine]

They both have unique features and qualities. I have trouble choosing… so I won’t 😅

[@PatriciaDesmet-d5g]

Thank you for the honest review. Tiana still a lovely AG doll with even with the lighter skin tone.

[@DisBlaine]

Yes! And I hope my review didn’t sound negative. Just the resemblance is off. I love the doll enough that I’ve ordered 5 of her … so far…

[@keenyatodd7054]

Your review is spot on. I purchased Tiana at AG yesterday. I was actually contemplating getting a different doll until I realized the green dress wasn’t sold separately.

[@DisBlaine]

Oh! Thank you! It can be daunting to share an opinion… because they may vary lol

[@fatimaazam6108]

Thankyou 4 sharing. Lisa

[@DisBlaine]

❤

[@fatimaazam6108]

Thanx 💗

[@DisBlaine]

@@fatimaazam6108 I didn’t have my notification a couple months ago, so I was had at replying then 😬

[@fatimaazam6108]

@@DisBlaine 😉💓

[@SuperButterfly217]

Thank you for this review.

[@DisBlaine]

💚💚

[@AishaAnnDolls]

Please could you do a Tiana collection video x

[@DisBlaine]

Most DEFINITELY! I’m doing a room tour video in 3 weeks (it’ll be 6 months before her 15 year anniversary) and then I’ll do a few videos showcasing my favourite Tiana pieces after that

[@AishaAnnDolls]

@@DisBlaine yayyy can’t wait

[@MissyJ-216]

I really want that celebration outfit for my Kavi. How do you like it? I heard that it stains the dolls.

[@DisBlaine]

I think ag corrected the staining issues. I don’t know how long it takes to stain, but any dolls who’ve worn it in my collection are fine so far.

[@nailahvenable7989]

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this doll.

[@DisBlaine]

And thank you for listening to me ramble about her lol

[@Joolieannie]

I wouldn’t say jasmine is fair skinned by any means at all, and truthfully Tiana is much deeper than jasmine doll wise there’s actually in my opinion much less depth difference shade wise between Tiana and Claudine than there is jasmine and Tiana , jasmine and Tiana are just much closer tone wise

[@DisBlaine]

Hmmm, if Tiana and Claudie look more similar than Tiana and Jasmine do, it might be the quality of my video. On the AG skin tone color chart, Tiana and Jasmine are next to each other, but there are 3 tones between Tiana and Claudie, as in Tiana is 1 shade darker than Jasmine, and Claudie is 4 tones (maybe 3.5) darker than Tiana.

[@JoanneSag]

Tiana looks color tone wise like many of my patients we saw in our pediatric office. If you search on U tube you will find someone who purchased her and shows an unboxing and you will see their skin tone matches. It is quite realistic. Now does she match the frog princess in Disney movie'? I don't know as I grew up with her as a light toned person shown in the story. I actually bought Tiana to be Claude as the Claude dolls did not look right to me at least the ones in the store, even the display model looked off. I am going back and maybe the new batch will be better. Thank you. Love them both. I am buying dress forms for the other dresses unless I dress one of my other dolls to be "inspired by". I just don't have room for more than one or two of the same dolls.

[@DisBlaine]

Yes her skin tone is really beautiful-I ended up buying 6 of her in the end, and I think I only stopped there because she sold out 😆 I also managed to make my ultimate Tiana by combining her with Claudie. And once I got her out of the outift, her tone didn’t look quite as yellow. It was more so how she came together. My regret about this video is I felt like I sounded very negative despite how excited about and in love with the doll I was. Her color choices aren’t bad on their own, they just don’t exemplify Tiana. But I understand why they might’ve made the choices. No matter, I love love LOVE her.

[@JoanneSag]

@@DisBlaine I was going to buy the doll with the purple hair # 91 on Amazon on sale for a donation auction but I just could not get over her coloring. Then I saw her in colors that complemented her coloring and wow! I went back and purchased her for donation and thought to make her a dress/outfits more complementary to her coloring. Makes a difference and you have that art.