Comparison Between Different Bosch Wet/Dry Extractor Bags

[@julesjay1634]

bro i've got so much respect for you ! you made my day better, you prove that the human spirit is really incredible and that if there is a will there is a way, i can't even begin to imagine what life must be like for you without your eyes and yet you make it look so easy ! thank you !

[@youtrades]

Fantastic in depth review mate! Thanks! (High fiber porridge 🤣)

[@bcy0]

Thanks for that vid! Answered my questions :)

[@manissahdaud1150]

Thank you so much for the demo very very informative 👍👍👍

[@VisionlessDesigns]

Glad you found it useful.

[@blahdiblah2169]

Hi Damien, coming in from your other vid, thanks for another informative one. More I think about the problem of dust extraction in smaller workshops, the more I think it's impossible to solve elegantly without both an extractor and a shop vac. Main limitation here is space and convenience. Given the fact that the paper bags are useless and the plastic bag just makes removal slightly easier, the fleece bag is the one to go for. That's a fantastic solution for construction work or general cleaning. For woodworking it's ideal for sanding tasks. Cost per bag must be considered too. I believe you could almost justify such a high price in bag if all you're using it for is sanding. It would surely take a decent amount of sanding to full a 35l gross volume bag. From my experience though, planers generate much larger shavings which shouldn't clog a filter with fine dust, so in this case the plastic bag and filter would be fine, and the limitation is how much volume of shavings planers can produce (a mountain in a small time). So the solution would be to do a manual clean first and then a tidy up using the plastic bag. Table saw is another machine that generates a decent amount of dust, but unlike the planer, it generates a wider range of dust, ranging from shavings or spikes, medium size dust and to a lesser extent fine dust. Still the medium sized dust a table saw produces will clog a filter. So in this case the fleece bag is a must, but that will full up a bag fairly quickly, now the main limitation is cost. However it could be possible to use an aftermarket dust separator. Better yet fully fledged dust extractor with an aftermarket separator. Miter saw. another machine that produces a great deal of medium size dust, obviously less dust though than a table saw since you're doing cross cuts and not rip cuts. But kerf widths here are for the most part almost comparable in my setup. So in this case the miter saw needs a separator too. Again dust extractor far more suitable for this. If you're still with me, you can see how ideas evolve as do workshops. So now since you're needing 2 separators (or a separator per tool) or a mobile separator, you might as well have one larger one, centrally installed and piping, to do this though you need to factor in additional hose lengths, gates and a stronger extractor to cope. Those budget ones most likely won't cut it anymore. Finding an m class extractor at a reasonable price, never going to happen, so you end up with something not even L class, that too has consumable bags and a filter to replace. And after all of this you will still need your shop vac for cleaning up the fine dust, and ideally a workshop blower for occasional blowouts. When I factor in all of this, I am back to square one. My current solution uses a DIY dust collection cart, a fairly crappy shop vac and a Triton dust bucket. No point in even attempting to connect this to certain power tools, but worthwhile to keep some movement on the table saw and handheld tools. Most of the filtering happens in the Triton lid, there's a fine dust filter there that appears to be L class, but it's most likely unrated. All of this is fine, except the Triton bucket started collapsing in on itself recently. I was considering building a better bucket for it out of metal, but this wouldn't be that easy to still keep the integrated filter, which got me thinking why not just buy something more suitable. Reality is dust collection is expensive if you want to do it right, and even if you rush out and buy a product like this Bosch vac (or any other decent vac) it still isn't going to be idea for some machines or just too expensive on the consumables to feel right. I think I'll stick with my homemade solution and try and reinforce the Triton bucket. Would be great if someone came out with a metal dust deputy style product with a filter.

[@VisionlessDesigns]

Dust extraction wise, you can’t use one tool for every job realistically. Large dust extractors are no good for small power tools as the more you shrink their piping down, the less suction they have; whereas small wet/dry extractors have great suction in small piping but can’t handle larger pipes. I learnt this when playing about with my 3HP Fine Dust Extractor. Regarding your Triton Dust Separator, have you had a look at Rutlands dust separators? If I recall, they used to have some really good ones. Yes, the plastic bags would be fine for planings as they would not clog the filter. Also, my daughter thanks you for your decent grammar lol 😆

[@bartholomewgreatpants3425]

The solution is festool. Sorry about it.

[@matiasvirsu6925]

Thank you for the video, very informative. I just bougth the same dust extractor and I was contemplating what dust bags I should order. I think I will order a set of fleece bags and add a cyclone dust separator to it.

[@VisionlessDesigns]

Thanks for the comment. I'm glad you found it helpful.

[@CRAZYCR1T1C]

Great info thanks. I always wondered the point of the plastic bags.

[@VisionlessDesigns]

Glad you found it helpfull.

[@noamlabounty7797]

Hay man, thanks for the video. I really would recommend buying or making a cyclone separator for the dry stuff. It will save you both fuss and money. Cheers

[@VisionlessDesigns]

Thanks for the comment. I have been considering getting the Rutlands dust separator for the workshop.

[@mr.kenslifeshop4034]

Which vacuum and model number is this is this the 14 gallon dust extractor?

[@ngkp4481]

Is there any other option brand of dust bag can be fitted in to this vacuum machine?

[@chillkebab]

Hi Is it supose to make that sound when u turn it off , min also does this an gas 35 H clas

[@gstyles-qf2tu]

yeah hey, great vid, can i just say so we are all on the same page,, its is a dust extractor and not a hoover and is designed to remove hazardous materials. Each bag is designed to be used with different material types and in different applications and then removed sealed and disposed of. If the materials are not a hazard you can bypass the use of a bag and go straight into the bucket, this will be fine for non toxic shavings from a joiner or thicknesser spindle molder and even leaves and small children and most important all your non toxic liquids.

[@POLPO_WOOD]

You got the M but aren't the L and the M the same? they have the same filters, same motor, the L only doesn't have an alarm when the pressure slightly drops

[@eclipseflooringdaz1656]

What’s putting me off is the fleece bags. I would be using lots of bags each day when grinding concrete.

[@Buddy-po4hv]

You are certainly big on sound effects 😅

[@krystian401]

THX

[@jameslooker4791]

You don't need the AFC with a filter bag.

[@stemack1975]

on the 12 25 bosch vacum the open bag is used but a gasket like cover is also supplied which seals the filter from the bag and why dont you make your own bags with zip at the end