Controversial Moments

[@Carlols88]

You can rename this video: 'The terrible referees of England' .

[@nkululekondhlovu4020]

This is basically a Michael Oliver comp with others

[@andrazpecan9393]

We can all se that Oliver is the problem, 90% of moments

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

Arsenal fans are 90% Oliver is the other 10%

[@bighas96]

​@@lifeofvirtue1833 your dad 90% your mom 10% for giving you birth

[@Mr_Goose6000]

City’s 90%and Oliver is the 10%

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@@Mr_Goose6000 sounds like you are salty that yall are just bottle jobs

[@FBTENN]

No just Oliver premier league Refs are bad

[@ernestomaggiobello7669]

In Italy we constantly complaint about our referee's decisions, I think the PL has the worst referees

[@bugrabal1836]

Watch Turkish League Talk Later Bro an example pyro thown at pitch a defensive player holding it in his hand in the penalty area and yelling refree to stop the match refree lets it contiue and oppositon team scores goal given that was the only match that team lost that season and that team was at the second place at the end of the season by 2 points (total 99 points) Welcome to Türkiye

[@erickjuma7643]

No contest

[@乃乇卂爪]

you must watch Indonesia vs Bahrain at World Cup Qualifying 3rd round, the referee was so controversial and worst

[@x-drive6586]

Yep, 90 + 6 = 99 was trending topic.... It should have been a historic win for Indonesia but was robbed by the referee... 6 minutes of added time but the referee blew the whistle in the 99th minute only to wait until Bahrain scored a goal to level the score to 2 - 2

[@jitroglennwcmandagi]

@@x-drive6586 Math: 90 + 6 = 96 Bahrain vs Indonesia's Referee: 90 + 6 = 99

[@Akunfa-y9i]

Alay lu

[@dimashomarov5357]

12:50 this is a clear yellow card, but the referee called the player several times to show him a yellow card, but the player didn't want to, and received a well-deserved red card for it

[@alexperlinger]

13:00 The player was down while Inter was attacking before they lost possession and got counter attacked, commentator even mentioned it.

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

Inter also did a similar thing earlier that game but didn’t score

[@Bapa_nada]

I remember watching that game and man was down while Inter was in possesion and i was wondering why they dont stop, then when they lost the ball they started complaing there is their player laying down. How ironic they lost a goal XD

[@Matt-z4q]

According to Gianluiggi Buffon, Referee Mike Oliver is an animal

[@jaxsonbateman]

Had to stop watching after the Japan / Spain one. The fact that you omitted the crucial bird's eye view that shows part of the edge of the ball was over the line (and thus the ball was in), and instead only showed the ambiguous clips to make it seem more controversial, is just deceptive.

[@markball406]

The whole ball must be over the whole line

[@jaxsonbateman]

@@markball406 Exactly! There's the graphic that shows the ball was veeery slightly over the line, meaning it didn't go out. Don't get me wrong; it absolutely looks out if you don't have that birds eye view, but when you see it you know it's not controversial at all (now, you could argue the rule itself is controversial - I don't, but I could imagine some people would say "if the ball isn't touching the line it should be out" - but with the rules as they are combined with the evidence, there's no controversy).

[@islahartel9304]

⁠​⁠ the video is about controversial moments. The video isn’t providing an answer to the moments just the moment and why it was controversial. At the moment, all we had were the views shown. It wasn’t until later we found out they had goal line technology and VAR confirmed that it was still inbounds. This was still absolutely controversial. There’s nothing deceptive about calling this a controversial moment.

[@jaxsonbateman]

@@islahartel9304 I'd argue it wasn't controversial. It's only controversial if you don't show the birds-eye clip - which the channel conveniently didn't do. If you show that clip, you see that the ball isn't entirely out. Ball not being out = still in, so the call of it being in isn't controversial at all.

[@EdisonCheng]

It is controversial if only the ref made the wrong decision. And the ref did the right one and has given the goal to Japan. Nothing is controversial there

[@mrproprgamr9824]

4:37 you can physically hear Haaland shout 'fuck off'

[@OAFB]

Haaland throwing the ball makes me laugh every fucking time 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mrproprgamr9824]

@@OAFB yea i know right?

[@Kalah_]

Yeah he was lucky not to be sent off, actually. Throwing the ball on someone counts for the same as a punch, if you want to be really anal about the rules.

[@dimashomarov5357]

9:45 Actually the ball wasn't completely crossed the line, that was right decision

[@allandavis8201]

Are you as blind as the referee, @ 9:47 the photograph shows the ball was clearly out. Putting aside the fact that the assistant referee and referee might not have seen it because of it being a split second to decide, we have hindsight and multiple still images to see the ball was clearly out.

[@dimashomarov5357]

@@allandavis8201 you have to look from above to make sure whether the ball crossed the line or not, the official version showed the ball from above, and the ball did not cross the line

[@pratosaurusrex1128]

@@allandavis8201seems like you’re blind to the rules. ALL of the ball needs to be over ALL of the line to be out.

[@allandavis8201]

@ okay, I DO know the rules, and in MY OPINION the whole of the ball WAS over the line, and if, in YOUR OPINION, it wasn’t then that is your opinion, but then again it doesn’t matter what I think because you made up your mind I was wrong and you were right, so we will have to agree to disagree, it isn’t 1966 or important in the slightest.

[@Morion001]

@@allandavis8201 I mean, the VAR checked it with all the technology they have available to them, and it was shown the ball did not completely cross the line. This is a verifiable fact, which the VAR did check, so opinions don't really matter here. You can have the opinion facts are wrong, but that just makes you sound obtuse

[@thegreenend.]

They dont have to put the ball out when a player is injured unless it was a head injury. Yes its unsportsmanlike but its not a MUST

[@islahartel9304]

Why didn’t VAR just tell the ref to review haaland throwing the ball at arsenals players head?

[@ano9161]

Doku kicked the ball where the ref was pointing.

[@FootballN7Studio]

This is a great video and your work is very good 😃😃

[@Heathen.Deity.]

Just because you can see grass between the line and where the ball is on the turf, doesn’t mean the ball is completely past the line.

[@tuomasvalinen3084]

😂😂

[@RuthNodjitanOfficial]

The Germany vs Spain was outrageous, the ball clearly touched Cucurella's arm

[@barcaelvis9586]

FOR REAL

[@WSG-2]

But why people blame him, blame the ref instead tho! And i think it was offside before

[@타룽이]

CU-CU-CU-CU-RE-LLA!

[@NabhithShetty]

His hand was in a natural position 😂😂

[@cmfkingmusic]

@@WSG-2 people like you

[@jespermortensen-sj5fl]

God video og god weekend og fedt content

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

The ball going out before de bruynes goal doesn’t matter because city lost possession of it before they scored. If they hadn’t lost possession then it would have mattered

[@MariaTovar-g4e]

Jajajaja you’re one of the most stupidest persons alive, of course it matters, if they had mark the out of bounds they would of never regained control of the ball, in other words it does ,Ayer and Madrid got robbed

[@mamamaumamam]

28:58 Bosingwa with the no nonsense "This is Sparta".

[@AY_912]

brexit means brexit

[@SMILERSBACK]

Michael oliver is a Manchester city fan..simple

[@UknoWmannz782]

The robot has gone berserk

[@JudeMcdonald-i6f]

Brilliant video

[@alvifadhollah]

Even with all the technology, referee still making stupid mistake. And yet, people still think VAR is the reason why football is suck now.

[@SimBir08]

Var was bought in to help bad referee's make better desicions, but it's just highlighted how bad referee's are because even with the tech they still make bad decisions.

[@Walshy94]

Nothing wrong with that first one. Walker had plenty of time to run and get back into position, but decided to slowly jog back instead. Also the Suarez handball wasn't controversial. He got sent off for it. Not his fault that Gyan missed the penalty

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

Because he was still speaking to the ref

[@Walshy94]

​​@@lifeofvirtue1833no he wasn't. He had a good 4 or 5 seconds, maybe even longer after talking to the ref to get back. But he decided to jog and got caught out

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@@Walshy94 if you look, as he is going back he is talking to the ref telling him the ball was too far forward

[@islahartel9304]

He definitely gets into position to defend in time. They are just looking for something else to blame it on. I’m pretty sure the point of quick restarts is to catch the team out of position…

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@@islahartel9304 that wasn’t a quick restart. The whistle was blown twice.

[@denisestevam2368]

Jesus the Premier League is terrible mistakes... Michael Oliver and Anthony Taylor, they are the worst of the worst... A disgrace

[@IbnuRahmat-u2f]

City always takes advantage from the controversial

[@p.j.723]

that awful techno music in the background tho...

[@hanoman78]

The "best" of Michael Oliver 🤭😜

[@franekdolas7559]

0:17 i dont see any problem in here referee used whistle goal 100% legit

[@BennyHarveyBigMan]

0:55 Doku is literally looking at the referee pointing back to where the kick is to be taken from. Why do I get the feeling an Arsenal fan has made this compilation. 5:40 defending team retook possession of the ball then lost it to a poor pass, new APP - can't bring it back for that.

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

Finally someone who has ball knowledge

[@Aryan_184]

Yeah I was thinking the sme

[@Uncle.everything]

Exactly people don't wanna see that ... and complain about doku not getting a card. 0 knowledge football fans .

[@FootballLatestOfficial]

yeah people just hate city so find any excuse to say that they cheat

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@@FootballLatestOfficial exactly. It’s annoying

[@tanzolo4487]

Not an Arsenal fan at all, but that decision at 2:40 was just unbelievable. Really I was screaming at the television as if I was a fan. Crazy that one.

[@AryaPatelYT]

bro the speed one was most controversial

[@tanzolo4487]

3:50 Vandyk has the face of a man who knows this is a lose-lose situation. Pure disbelief. He wants to scream but it’s Messi.

[@mamamaumamam]

Most of them are English and EPL referees. They have grown way too overconfident and even arrogant because the EPL always back their poor judgements and they always get away with them.

[@islahartel9304]

Try to look at it from their side. They are 1 ref on a field trying to watch 22 grown men. If you compare it to another sport with similar number of players like American football who has 7 refs and 2 in the booth for 22 players. This has 3 refs and 1 VAR ref for 22 players. Shit is gonna be missed. Sure fifa could add more refs but no one wants that. I don’t think they are trying to be egotistical but they are only human. Every call they make is gonna make someone unhappy. 90+ minutes of verbal abuse from every side. Add in that now people slow down and measure every millimeter to prove their point…give them a break

[@mamamaumamam]

@@islahartel9304 I guess you miss my point. Yes, refering is hard but how come other referess from other leagues don't make mistakes as much as the EPL referee? And they have VAR to consult which they often don't.

[@AaronCrane-l2w]

14:00 there is no angle where you can say the ball 100% went out of play, therefore the decision on the field stands

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

There is one from the corner flag but I remember watching this game and they were on var for 5-10 minutes

[@twainnn8592]

9:37 the ball is round bro not like a square, the side on the ball was on the line

[@VitoKimberly]

I like this video❤😊

[@allandavis8201]

What really gets up my nose is when referees or assistant referees make a mistake, that is quite obviously the wrong decision, they usually get away with it, yes they might get a slapped wrist or something else that is not really a punishment, and yet when the players get angry and upset because of the referees mistake and challenge the referee or line runner, they can be booked or sent off, and if the FA decide to have a disciplinary hearing they can be fined or suspended, okay the money is nothing for the players in the highest level of the leagues but in the lower tiers it could make a huge difference to the player/club, but if a player gets a suspension then that hurts their reputation and pride, something that they do not like at all, it just seems extremely unfair and one sided,

[@FOOTBALINO21]

If the margin is less, the person will enjoy more

[@strawberryman47]

So frustrating watching this as a Bayern/Germany fan 😅

[@erickjuma7643]

How Michael Oliver is still officiating matches leaves me wondering he does the crapiest job

[@nadeemislamlaskar4653]

Oliver should be stripped of his status as a referee.

[@erickjuma7643]

Is he even human, looks like an😊 individual who doesn't have a life outside being a referee

[@pauljohnson577]

When football is blatantly corrupt

[@khyrovancho3319]

When the officials look at the replays, does they see what we see? Cause these are just some crazy calls and crazy

[@dronesclubhighjinks]

For more controversial moments, look at COPA America, 2024! Especially the matches featuring South American teams versus USA or versus Canada. The most lopsided biased refereeing I have ever seen! The play is much more umm physical than we see in the World Cup, or in the champions league. Really enjoyed this video, thanks!

[@deniszlatevski9269]

3:30 I still don't understand how is that not a penalty it's littlery handball

[@BraisFernandez-z9c]

I still dont understand how Kroos didnt get any card after what he did to Pedri

[@Rizki_Gunawan23]

Yes Is HandBall For Players Manchester City For Semi-Finals Fa Cup Last Season Against Chelsea

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

It’s on his sleeve by his shoulder and according to a new rule the season prior, that isn’t a hand ball

[@zuanradzeem8290]

Fifa would be checking on that referee.. So much misconduct..

[@AaronCrane-l2w]

9:24 you don’t show the correct angle from the side, so you cannot tell if the ball is in or out.

[@rafael_lana]

There's a reason every news outlet ran with that angle too, it looks absurd with just one perspective. To this day some people think it was out and don't wanna be convinced otherwise.

[@clipdump15618]

Even with these angles you can very clearly see the ball did not go out

[@SouthsideWanderlust-wh6th]

Premier League referees are very unpredictable

[@mrboogie1704]

what kind of fake is this 20:18??????? You can cleary see in 20:15 that the ball is not completly in wtf

[@daniellageorgiou-norman2244]

final comment i promise but at 9:39 the edge of the ball was still on the line

[@EmilioPérez-j3m]

In 3:28 there was a previous offside, that's the reason why it was not a penalty. Put things in context

[@gunnergunnarsson3534]

And rival fans say that Arsenal fans cry too much when we get robbed a lot.

[@mjhg.arsenal]

it's true, but football is depend on Man City owner and England government decision.

[@smithofsmiths1872]

28:58 Notice how the linesman is stood right in front of that and yet he flags the other way! Bizarre.

[@ShofiulEmam]

Michael Oliver everywhere 😂😂😂😂

[@TimothySmith-jg4le]

No, Oliver just gets lumped with humdingers. Cause he's actually one of the best. The extra controversy this brings doesn't help his reputation unless you understand what's what. With great competence comes greater responsibility. 🕸

[@erickjuma7643]

You are calling Oliver competent? You must have very low standards then

[@TimothySmith-jg4le]

​@@erickjuma7643 And your standards are what? Try it yourself and see what happens.

[@hXxshXx]

Even Arsenal Haters kno that Rice red card was harsh n wrong.. but they will never admit it.. just imagine d same scenario happening to a player of a team they support..

[@MelvinPeter-zt9xo]

Odegaard slipped and was trying to find balance that why it was not blown

[@erickjuma7643]

He disrupted the direction of the ball and put himself at an advantage

[@bradrockl8330]

Haaland thinks too much of himself

[@erickjuma7643]

He has talent but hasn't matured mentally.

[@SimBir08]

Nobody really knows what the handball rule is, they've changed it so many times it's just confusing to everybody now. A player doing a jesus in the wall isn't hand ball but a player with his arm down and it bounces off his knee and hits his hand is.

[@dylanocampogomez5573]

The Japan vs Spain one in WC was so bs dude it was very clear the ball went out 😤

[@marksneddon6325]

It's a complete myth that Michael Oliver is a good referee. As a Newcastle United fan I'm delighted that he's not allowed to referee our matches.

[@erickjuma7643]

Based on what I wish they didn't allow him to officiate Arsenal games too. He brings a lot of tension in the field

[@tanzolo4487]

Keep in mind that most of these decisions were made AFTER they introduced VAR

[@fitsaiG]

You added a lot Bs & forget Kovacic's 2 red card fouls at the Emirates with that like 40 percent of this decisions are against Arsenal compared to only that one Odegaard mishap (ps that wasn't the offside in the Brentford game but the later one)

[@Solomonッ]

I knew as soon as I clicked on this video Arsenal was gonna be 90% of the video

[@clipdump15618]

Most of the decisions against them were correct though, channel owner is just a whiny arsenal fan

[@suckersyt250]

13:16 the INTER played even when their teammate was down injured but they lost the ball and Lazio scored as they were a goal down i think or level. Its Fair

[@AaronCrane-l2w]

10:01 the players arm is away from his body, it doesn’t matter wether or not it was natural

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

Because it was off his chest it can be called a non-handball in some situations including if it hits your upper arm in a running motion

[@AaronCrane-l2w]

@@lifeofvirtue1833 they changed the rules, the current ones say that the defender takes the risk of where they have their arms

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@@AaronCrane-l2w what

[@AaronCrane-l2w]

@@lifeofvirtue1833it means that a hand ball can be called if there is a deflection of the body

[@islahartel9304]

I think the rule is that your hand needs to be by your side in its natural position. Not natural position based on the action. So even if you’re running and you naturally run with your arms up, it would still be a handball. The only exception is if you put your arms out to brace a fall, it’s not a handball. They’re always changing it so I might be wrong.

[@apa5749]

The quality of English referees summed up in one video.

[@Jonathanlenthang]

The usual suspects: oliver and tyler😂😂

[@UgoCornillon]

is it normal that the majority of the "controversial" decisions are against arsenal ?

[@paidactoriam]

Show this video to Pep, H.Web and of course, M. Goldbridge so he can put some content on that. PL CLOWN League!!!

[@JimmyEatsFood]

The Rodri handball was dodgy as hell.

[@festimlimani5309]

Oliver again and again and again

[@MXMBrothers]

To be honest, the ref gave a foul because Grealish was offside, so he just gave a foul. 4:19

[@9livesLexaPrianik]

7:40 футболеры конечно клоуны, нападающий в момент когда пролетает мимо вратаря САМ выставляет ногу в сторону вратаря а мяч то под другой ногой🤔🙈

[@bully3628]

Saka throws his leg out at the goalkeeper and then cries to the referee they it’s a penalty. Good call by the referee to not award a penalty for that.

[@tsourlinicious]

Oliver is the biggest rubbish in history of refereeing

[@bugrabal1836]

2.46 Correct decision yellow player tried to play fast red one should give him space but he kicked the ball right before yellow so desicion was correct

[@mrkipling2201]

4:48 they probably told Haaland to get a haircut.....

[@mrkipling2201]

Oliver is a terrible referee...

[@SM1-1048]

There’s no card for Messi handball vs Netherlands but the ref gave a free kick only bc there was promising attack in the middle of the field. Using google since it’s free helps. Admin of the account won’t know the rules tho.

[@mattjcwig]

Not a pen on Saka, was past him already and stuck his leg out and went down, great refereeing

[@thibaultmangon3676]

30:34 madueke and jackson are to blame here. The penalty are strike by palmer, decision of the coach, they dont have to react like that. And Cold palmer never missed a penalty with chelsea so the coach was right.

[@nandinhocunha440]

Japan goal, the ball wasn't out, this creater missed the part where it was reviewed by others and the tech and it said the ball wasn't out

[@islahartel9304]

It was still controversial…

[@nandinhocunha440]

@islahartel9304 it was still in, it wasnt 100% out

[@FarshidAyaz]

3:51 . Come on how can that be wrong decision. Basically, it's his game, he gets whatever he wants. One day, we see Argentina get penalty for committing foul in Argentine box. After the world cup, nothing of these feel unjust.

[@darrenduffy6036]

Not an arsenal fan but the red card for rice was ridiculous

[@gedhoughton9523]

The standard of refereeing in UK is embarrassing. Bet they just change their mind every other week on every same decision. Notice how Man City always seem to benefit from referees but then lose their rag when something doesn't go their way...

[@changelive4075]

tell me your arsenal fan without telling me your arsenal fan🤣

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

You can’t technically give a card for foul for something that happens after the play is blown dead

[@islahartel9304]

Yes you can. You can actually give a card even after the game ends and at half time. The only time a ref can’t give a card is before the game or before the ref enters the field.

[@lifeofvirtue1833]

@ true but it needs intent

[@2Kinetic]

Bro Japan wasnt controversial

[@olliethetrucker417]

I find refs are so quick to get the cards out with very little or no explanation

[@dimashomarov5357]

22:03 what a poor sportsmanship by Ederson, player was apologizing for his action, and he hit him from behind like a rat

[@oladipupoalade4114]

That Michael Oliver and refs like him. Shouldn't go unpunished for this disgrace acts and decisions

[@NetDijk]

This video could've easily have been all games of Argentina at the 2022 World cup. They were made kings by most of the organisation and many refs didn't dare to stand up to this plan.

[@Odadian]

As a Liverpool fan both Anthony and Fernandes needs to go they are a shame for Man U

[@toondarkrabbit8238]

3:27 el momento en que españa juega con 2 porteros😂😂

[@rakkowakko4921]

Basically Michael Oliver in ManCity matches compilation and a few others

[@patrikandersson7199]

30.02 vini jr "i just wanna play football"