COOKIE OF THE YEAR 2024 is Here! WHO IS THE BEST COOKIE?!

[@Nebbuwu]

i really wished that they did COTY with how ovenbreak's doing theirs, with separating legendaries and epics. the highest epic in the polls is milky way, and even then she's in 20th place :(

[@HyRoolLegend]

@@Nebbuwu that would be interesting!

[@bigturtle6377]

didn't dreamweaver cookie grief the votes for legendaries

[@Nebbuwu]

@@bigturtle6377 true since they were the most recently released legendary in COTY

[@Cat-astronaut-u2m]

all i need is astronaut recognition

[@Cinna3193]

It’s now peach blossom cookie at 19th place

[@drakerbrohd9727]

This is truly based on the fandom's opinion and they are looking for cookies that are either cute, attractive, handsome, or beautiful. There is barely any emphasis on viability and obviously the Legendary and higher rarity cookies are gonna be on the top of their detail; also Cream Ferret on top 20 proves that the cuteness factor is still there.

[@oosha2000]

At least, I'm not that type of biased player no matter.

[@rexlapis4726]

the top 10 cookies are basiclly some of the most used arena cookies and you still barely any emphasis on viability

[@solarprogeny6736]

​@@oosha2000 How is it biased to pick the cookie of the year based on how good it looks? The question asked by the game is open-ended. You can judge based on whatever criteria you prefer, be it appearance or gameplay, but both are biased - in the literal sense of the term.

[@oosha2000]

@solarprogeny6736 There are people who choose cookies according to either appearance or metability hence the bias. Meanwhile, it doesn't matter to me which cookie is the most appealing and which one is meta since I love them all but it's a tough choice to make sense.

[@Tangeraineee]

Black pearl: I will win The beasts: Not today

[@HermioneBigBrain]

lol black pearl used to win every time rip

[@hi6575]

Golden cheese was first last time I checked

[@jimmydeguzman7168]

Crazy how it's been years since Milkyway's release yet she's always the top epic in COTY

[@TJ_266]

Wonder what a legendary costume looks like for Mystic flower lol

[@SahabuddinAhmed-kj4ln]

*flour*

[@TJ_266]

@SahabuddinAhmed-kj4ln so what I made a little spelling mistake I always do it so no need to correct me

[@mori_san8206]

If a costumes comes for the Beasts I'm willing to save for a whole year just for it.

[@SahabuddinAhmed-kj4ln]

@TJ_266 sorry

[@Him_eko]

@TJ_266ur acting like he was gonna put u in jail for correcting u, its not that deep

[@MysticxFlourCookie]

MYSTIC FLOUR COOKIE FOR THE WIN

[@Jarvy2007]

Finally, much different cookies that made the top three

[@isz576]

Mystic flour got the attention she long for

[@veebot75]

I love both cookies, but you’ve got me giving you massive side eyes for picking Cream Ferret Cookie over Parfait Cookie.

[@FrFrost-q9b]

8:08 they’re having an alpha off

[@6lu3b3rry]

Imagine black pearl winning again

[@Jarvy2007]

Nah, not happening anymore, this is time its the era of Beasts and Ancients

[@kachosuffer7]

​@@Jarvy2007 So basically, nothing's changed at all?

[@mori_san8206]

I'm happy that Mystic is first but bro WHY IS WIND ARCHER SO LOW ??? He's even lower than Black Pearl what a joke lmao

[@Jarvy2007]

​@@kachosuffer7there is change, it's the fact that the people have finally come to their senses, and are giving other cookies a chance this time

[@Ben-v6z3s]

Hell nah

[@Asarani]

Hollyberry was the first cookie I maxed, so she always has a #1 spot for me ♥️ I hope she gets some lovin' during her Beast Yeast chapter!!

[@DoughnutGigaChad]

I hate the fact that they ignored giving black pearl something, Because she won last year, and the fact that they used the well animation strategy for ancients, and beasts makes it vert very unfair for all cookies to participate. At least make cookie of the year but for a separate rarity, because this is not fair!

[@hexx9065]

they need to do what ovenbreak did and seperate the epics from the legendaries beasts etc

[@DoughnutGigaChad]

​@@hexx9065 yep, that's what I meant, I can't believe they took the players opinion in OvenBreak but still made the same mistake in kingdom.

[@rexlapis4726]

@@DoughnutGigaChad i vote to have a micmac for the crk side of things because i feel like he is the onlyone that interacts withplayers

[@DoughnutGigaChad]

@@rexlapis4726 Very true indeed.

[@starsthecasual1670]

4th last year should have gotten something, since BP won already. It probably would have been a good move all around… GC was 2nd last year, she probably also needs a costume, but her awakening was huge and costume-quality at least. Stardust (4th last year) got shafted fr

[@RHoysterCRK]

I love the fact people don't tell people to vote for frost queen anymore

[@HyRoolLegend]

That phase is over haha

[@rexlapis4726]

she got her costume so war is over

[@wubtastical]

7:00 is an actual crime dawg 😭🙏🏽

[@keitaronagame3432]

A costume for mystic flour would be so gooood

[@Deeyoik]

8:32 during video, get that guy In chat banned from the internet

[@HyRoolLegend]

@@Deeyoik noted

[@camelnotllama]

gotta love when the first thing you see clicking on the video is 'sex' in chat

[@Goobis365]

My queen golden cheese is waiting for her costume still.

[@anika5599]

Hasn’t she already gotten one?

[@Goobis365]

@anika5599 no her cookie of year 2023 costume is still mia.

[@anika5599]

@@Goobis365 Mia? What does Mia mean?

[@Goobis365]

@@anika5599 Missing in action

[@anika5599]

@@Goobis365 oh Larry

[@Lunchbox15]

I really want both the beasts to win so baddddd

[@elijahrodriguez0509]

Hyrool I think you didn't see my comment but, when I was watching your live last night I did a 1 pull and got Mystic Flour

[@HyRoolLegend]

@@elijahrodriguez0509 sheeeshh awesome! Congrats!

[@elijahrodriguez0509]

@HyRoolLegend late reply, but the extra stats on toppings are giving me *ATTACK* when I need Cooldown. Btw can you make a vid on the new towers? And tips to beat them? Because tray 130 in strawberry cake tower is so hard, mystic just kills you instantly

[@nathangaming4936]

At least a good thing is That sea fairy and moonlight aren't in the top 3 freaking Finally people aren't dumb this time BUT I HATE THAT MYSTIC FLOUR is 1ST PLACE SHE A IRL WAR CRIMINAL

[@anika5599]

YEAH FR

[@Kolie376]

Apathy for the win

[@nathangaming4936]

@Kolie376 No are you crazy If mystic flour were a real person in real life , she'd be the definition of world war two , if there were more nukes Involved I don't know if you noticed but she was trying to commit world genocide inside of the game.She does not deserve the number one spot

[@anika5599]

@@Kolie376 apathy not for the win!!

[@Him_eko]

She maybe is a bad person but who cares 😀she does not exist and u need to admit that « return to flour » is ✨iconic✨

[@jessquiatchon2204]

Skins for the beasts would need 3 forms for each phase change

[@Ajgamer6930]

9:58 my fav epic vs the most broken cookie Chooses broken cookie without saying he likes her, Something tells me he probably didn't know this is basically who ya like more kinda event

[@Tegarcs142]

5:36 If OJ saw this he always choose muscle cookie lol

[@mas0deX]

Sadly I missed the livestream but I’m excited for more in the future! Cookie of the year is so fun ❤❤❤

[@suhpernova]

black pearl in top 10 again 😭😭

[@oosha2000]

At least not top 3

[@zacrysyap]

theres a chance we get a legendary costumes(virtue/heroic forms) for the beast early on since mystic flour ranks really high at the poll .. possibly another beast might take place the coty for 2025 .. just dont pissyfy mystic flour .. that will be madness

[@elijahkao8848]

Cries in dragon cookie, hopefully it wins so it can get a skin. It's been more than a year now.

[@Yukiiya0]

Guys what if we all voted milky way

[@leja6275]

Did no one else hear him say that white Lily was a legendary 11:07

[@Biggesthumbugfan]

One day pitaya dragon cookie....one day you'll win 💔

[@catbunny4785]

VOTE GINGERBRAVE LET THEM KNOW THAT EVEN A COMMON COULD WIN

[@Maskit4life]

Still waiting for zaddy margarizz cookie to get more attention/screen time..

[@yorotheporo934]

The only choice i had trouble with was wildberry vs redvelvet. All the other choises where like beet vs frostqueen. And ninja vs wind archer. Like gurl that aint much of a choice

[@oosha2000]

Good jelly, black pearl cookie isn't in top 3 but if only devs split the above epic and below cookies according to their own brackets like ovenbreak, it'd make more sense and be more fair. I didn't choose bp but come on, we need epic cookies on top 10 for once. Also, where are the costumes for caramel arrow cookie and red velvet cookie ?

[@flob4400]

I love how many decided to just choose whoever was paired with Black pearl so she doesn't wins and she's still like way up there top 10 or 15 idk Voted a while ago, Golden Cheese first and I can't remember second but I think Awakened Dark Cacao is still third I voted Pitaya though, really wished they could finally get a constume :(

[@albertogaming7364]

I voted Herb and Caramel Choux over Snapdragon and Cream Ferret. I’m very curious how this coty top 3 will be

[@stancinatti8198]

Based on usefulness wither crème or wind archer

[@Ben-v6z3s]

Wind Archer is just the best aesthetic wise and meta wise

[@-nik._]

every coty is just the same blatant annual event now, just legendary+ cookies win now

[@ilovesaintlucia]

11:08 Ah, yes, White Lily Cookie the legendary

[@The_Cookie_Player]

I mean there is no real difference between ancients and legendaries. Besides which shops you can buy their soul stones.

[@linhhuynh9042]

⁠@The_Cookie_Player bro it is still defined as a ancient bruh

[@ariflewar789]

Mystic Flour on top of vote and our greed Queen on second, at moment i write this.

[@JefimijaStosic]

The awakened ancients look legendary as it is...most people don't use their other costumes....Given that, I hope COTY2025 win Shadow Milk, Pure Vanilla and Holyberry!

[@ilovesaintlucia]

4:08 This is a warcrime. Choosing Icicle Yeti over Cocoa, come on

[@ferringsylveon219]

More like the Cookie Awards!!!!

[@stantwice8937]

Mystic Flour🗣️🗣️🗣️

[@Ben-v6z3s]

Top 3 so far: 1. Mystic Flour 2.Golden Cheese 3.Dark Cacao

[@ujjwalkumar2199]

Treasure tier list!!!

[@Moose6557]

Istg if black pearl cookie wins again

[@oosha2000]

Only top 3 cookies will get the costumes

[@lostintheclxud]

awakened cookies/beasts would most likely pass onto black pearl so she most wont likely win

[@5umo_70g7]

I’m really hoping mystic flour overtakes golden cheese!!!!

[@Hosib666]

cherry cookie best cookie

[@DavinTheCRKFan]

I made a castkecrashers mod of cream soda cookie

[@Reppyi]

i hope white lily wins

[@Ben-v6z3s]

*Wind Archer* that’s all 😌

[@Kolie376]

Apathy for the win

[@stancinatti8198]

I swear if red velvet wins

[@Goobis365]

Black pearl in 7th the world is healing

[@lucas-b7p6d]

CREAM PUFF OVER UNI??

[@mariadefatimatrindadediasb8019]

Royal margarine is the best

[@hexx9065]

Yall i say we all vote ONLY cookies who dont have costumes OR cookies with a low amount of costumes

[@wubtastical]

CANDY DIVER OVER ORINCESS?

[@wubtastical]

star coral over kouign diva cookie.. That’s it ! No more mr. nice guy..! 😈👍👍👍

[@triplebluethreat6823]

You do realize you just missed out on Moonlight Cookie's little speech while she was in her latest legendary costume. Sure, it was a few sentences. But, still just wanted to let you know. Also, you called White Lily Cookie legendary by mistake

[@waerlee9944]

bruh please no more black pearl

[@rexlapis4726]

its definitely rigged to the epic+ and specials favours no epic cookie stands a chance let alone a rare or a common i am literally choosing epic cookies or lower just for pure hatred how rigged the coty is

[@thegreatkevington]

strawberry crepe ftw!!!!!!!!!!

[@helert9052]

GINGERBRAVE IS THE BEST🎉🎉🎉

[@yuzhongluoyisson9420]

Bro called White Lily a Legendary

[@lucas-b7p6d]

OMG NOO CREAM UNII

[@OmikoOmika]

Mother flour

[@woahitsfranco5286]

voting against sea fairy and moonlight and black pearl no matter what atp sorry i dont want them winning again

[@oosha2000]

As much as I favor Moonlight cookie, I had to choose cocoa cookie over her for starters.

[@niikirby]

never vote again

[@W4fflu]

why did you call white lily a legendary 😭😭

[@SirenVivian]

🧀🧀🧀🧀✨✨✨✨✨

[@kirbydude667]

I’m unsubscribing because you voted for candy d*ver.

[@tea_eston]

am I first?

[@jedidahstewart3990]

yes

[@tonycoaja1034]

review my acc plss

[@jedidahstewart3990]

second