Cooperating with Deviants & Oppressors || NBF 295 || Dr Shadee Elmasry

0:00 Snow!
3:50 When do we work with innovators?
17:00 Defending your own image vs defending the deen
29:46 Dr Shadees live phone call with MBS
35:45 Wednesday Dua
47:37 Shirk to put up lights for Mawlid?
48:20 Intrusive parents?
51:50 Ayah 104 Surah Ali Imran
59:39 Conditions of commanding the good & forbidding wrong
1:01:56 Normalizing with Israel
1:03:39 Reciting salat al-Tunjina for marriage
1:03:48 Combining prayers when sick
1:04:28 Online tafsir
1:04:56 Ba 'alawi Misbah
1:05:04 Darul Fath!
1:05:25 Stuck between Salafism & Ash'ari aqidah
1:06:39 Muhammad Hashim Kamali
1:08:59 Islamic wife searching or dating?
1:10:40 Is there shirk in the Burdah?
1:12:35 Types of taghut in Islam
1:15:40 Evil eye from online
1:16:01 Obeying the ruler
1:18:19 Praying for deceased relatives after maghrib
1:19:31 Fasting during Rajab
1:20:12 Reading Ibn 'Arabi
1:21:40 My pronouns are sidi
1:22:23 What if someone says Ashari/Maturidi is wrong
1:28:49 Etymology of Jerusalem

[@ahmedislamerican8351]

innovators are those who reject God's decision regarding who should be the leader of the people after the death of the prophet

[@mmd2156]

The Messenger of Allah (S) said: "I am leaving for you two precious and weighty Symbols that if you adhere to BOTH of them you shall not go astray after me. They are, the Book of Allah, and my progeny, that is my Ahlul-Bayt.

[@amadeusakreveusmusic3356]

No matter whichever hadeeth you show them about having the people of the Prophet's house be our role models after him PBUH, they'll reject it as their ideological forefathers rejected the wilayah to Ali ibn abi Talib. Inshallah they'll be guided.

[@assamazam5151]

​@@amadeusakreveusmusic3356 we also have many Hadith about the Sahabah Radhya Allahu Anhum being examples and most of the Hadith are narrated by the Sahabah Radhya Allahu Anhum. No matter how many time we tell you, we don't differentiate between the Ahle Bayt and Sahaba Radhya Allahu Anhum within the context of respect and obedience, despite the difference in virtue, you still don't listen.

[@mmd2156]

@@amadeusakreveusmusic3356 I guess your right!

[@kingmosesix432]

And his ahlul bayt was upon his sunnah… Not whtever u rafidahs hv cooked up

[@numairkhan3632]

what does this hadith mean? i am sunni and i always woundered what does this mean? this hadith you have quoted?

[@inconvenient-truth99]

Jazaakumullaahu khairan Sheikh! Very good points. We don't buy over-priced Apple products to save $$

[@josephbarnabas3568]

Tolerance means you believe others are wrong or deviant but still accept them as friends or neighbors, not enemy. In the shia sunni differences, Tolerance is better than bigotry or hatred. It is normal we will claim we are in the right path and others are deviants. But only Allah is the judge. It is still a possibility that we would be surprised in the day of judgement because we are actually the deviants. So better tolerate others belief and be not acting as enemy. Leave to Allah to settle our differences.

[@jj-yi1ne]

u are a chrisian

[@abdladigun6436]

Sounds like something a super deviant would say💀

[@mohammadmostafa4885]

Very deviant mind. Worshipping Allah with doubt? Doubt is the absence of Iman.

[@Hamza7308]

@@mohammadmostafa4885 The brother is just calling for more unity among the various muslim sects.

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

​@@Hamza7308 you can't speak to wahabbis. They are brain dead.

[@Somebody294]

Jazakum Allah khair

[@faridahmad2013]

The theory of Imamat they invented is the greatest bidah... They exaggerate their imams to the extent they seem superior to prophets.. Moreover their imam is everywhere hazir nazir n kashif e soo ! What else is Shirkiya belief?

[@sabilahmed5314]

Where can we donate to get that tap going for dr Shadee? 🤔

[@tashifjilani1732]

jazakallah khair TeamSafinaSociety :)

[@Rocky313Pal]

Key issue here around @34:00. This argumebt has now become matter of sectarianism whereas its more of a political issue where sectarianism is wraponised. The syrian issue is entrenched with issue of Wahhabis, arab control, arab spring and US invasion. On the other hand the Iranians have supported sunni Bosnians, supported Palestinians as well as yemenis. Its easy to sit and say "its shia vs sunni" but thats the storyline media wants to tell us.

[@magnusmunch6372]

There seems to be a consistently positive correlation between "deviance" and willingness to provide practical support for the Palestinians.

[@youngman7600]

Yea as a non Muslim (currently studying Islam) this is throwing me off quite a bit. If Sunni claim to be following the true religion of Allah than why are very wealthy Sunni majority nations doing nothing to help Palestine and struggling Shia militant groups with way less resources fighting against the yahood???

[@abdul-basitraza786]

A question for Dr Shadee Elmasry, can you please ellaborate on why one should not read ibn Arabi's books? Jazakallah khairun

[@alextrebek5237]

@1:02:20 what about China oppressing the Hui and Uighyr muslims?

[@dmdm7690]

China doesn't oppress the Hui but they are oppressing the Uyghur

[@ShoaibKhanZ]

I argue that moon sighting is the only way, is because the word used by Allah is when you WITNESS then you start your fast. How can a calculation be witnessed. Or am I completely off here?

[@besim3916]

46:25: The 3 illnesses that prevent progress in learning.

[@aq7705]

what about joining those who perform "good" innovations?

[@ts7371]

Lol@ MBS’ chainsaw

[@Islamis4all]

A question for Dr Shadee Elmasry You read a Du’a yesterday in your livestream which has following text in Arabic تحصنت بالله وبأسماء الله وبآيات الله وملائكته ورسله وعباد الله الصالحين I have been told by a Scholar not to read this part of the Du’a. Can you please explain what this part of Du’a means according to you? جزآكم الله خيراً

[@SafinaSociety]

All of these are asbab or means of protection and we are told to seek out asbab.

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

​@@SafinaSociety it is "borderline miracle" that TRUTH IN TASAWWUF is coming back to the forefront with channels like yours, akhi. JazakAllah khayr

[@ahmedislamerican8351]

Leadership Rights Private companies are not public companies whose shares are owned by the public with different percentages, nor are they cooperatives whose policies are determined by the majority of member votes. The workers (who are not owners) in a private company do not have the right to determine company policy. It is true that they are stake holders but they are not share holders. All they have are rights and obligations, in this case wages and work. There is no right for them, either personally, collectively or initiated by a handful of working class activists to determine WHO will replace the LEADERSHIP after the official owner of the private company resigns / quits / dies. Only a visionary owner of a private company knows very well about future planning and to whom the baton of the company is passed on. So for those who may feel they own and then initiate an idea, understand who you are? Know yourself, realize your position, limit yourself to your status and role that has been determined by the company owner. He knows better about the future of the company. Don't act like you're smarter than him to come up with ideas about succession. this is not a public company!

[@yassiral31]

what makes shia ahlul bida for example? The Sheikh asserted they're ahlul bida but for eg what are the deviant bida they hold? Also dont we have bida hasana or am i mistaken?

[@Mehmet_Fateh]

Belief in infallible imams

[@fromdarkness2lght587]

​@@Mehmet_Fateh You deny that the Imams of AhlulBayt (A) not infallible & can or have committed mistakes or sin, it's you job and every sunni school & sunni Muslim to prove that. Show me one hadith or historical event where a companion of the Prophet(S) or Tabi'i after the companions mentions or accuses Imam Ali, Fatima the other Imams of committing sin or making a mistake anywhere which is an authentic/narration , show me i'll wait.

[@Mehmet_Fateh]

@@fromdarkness2lght587 Actually, it's your job to provide a nass to prove your position.

[@rambebsi]

@@fromdarkness2lght587 Have you ever seen me commit a sin? Because you've never seen me commit a sin, it doesn't make me infallible. It's the concept of a human not making mistakes which is kufri. Not "We haven't seen them do such a thing".

[@1taParastan]

What a silly notion! The onus is on you to prove that they are infallible! They never claimed to be infallible; you Shias just superimpose those beliefs on the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them). You probably didn't even read Nahj al-Balagha; even in that book, Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) mentions many times how he and his sons are bound to make mistakes! They are not prophets or angels after all! In his Khutbah recorded in Nahj-Al Balaghah # 216, Ali RA Said: فلا تكفوا عن مقالة بحق ، أو بعدل مشورة ، فإني لست في نفسي بفوق أن أخطىء ، ولا آمن ذلك من فعلي "Do not cease from expressing the truth or offering just advice, for I am NOT in myself above making mistakes, and I do NOT consider myself immune from ERRORS in my actions. I rely on Allah to safeguard me from what I may possess within myself. Indeed, I am, like YOU, a servant bound to a Master, and there is no Lord besides Him." Source: Translation: Nahj al-Balagha, vol. 2, pg. 201 You Shias must stop this extremism. Greetings from an Iranian Sunni.

[@tashifjilani1732]

52:32

[@mohammedraheef1415]

You people are the end of us.

[@manoymanok8563]

As a Muslim whoes loves Allah and his Messenger, i do not believe in any Medival Ages Attitudes. I do not believe when i make friends to the Shia, Ahmadiyyah etch i do commit Sin. and reject Allah and Messenger as well. etch. I do not see any Logic? i believe that we there a person is a Sunni, regardless if Ashary, Maturidhi, Athariyyah, Salafis or it is Sufi, Shia, Ahmadiyyah they are the same human beings me like with have a different set of beliefs, interpretation of the Quran, Sunnah, History etch. I do not see any wrong to make friends theme... let us not go back backwards attitude of the Past.. that is a very cleared a Outgroup Biases.

[@ahmedislamerican8351]

SUNNI = di-suni-ty , disarray,

[@brenda726]

what amazing detail. What amazing memories we must have to play Chinese whispers for centuries and have stories so precise!! Stories that have caused endless division, schools of thought and sects, rather than everyone merging under one banner which is the Quran. You are all fools and just dont see it. The Quran talks about Hadiths in a negative aspect in the Quran except GOD'S Hadith, yet here we are fabricating lies.

[@fromdarkness2lght587]

Where did the Qur'an speak negative of hadith ? 😂