Why Do Starlings Flock in Murmurations?

[@Mario-yo6or]

this is crazy thing, thanks for the wonderful video, do we have any other examples for this ??

[@earlaweese]

*You literally just said that something causes them to move and they in turn bump into each other. That’s not what’s happening. My eyes aren’t lying to me. They’ll murmur just for the sake of murmuring in random cities without any predators being around. Quit bothering me.*

[@carolinearick3082]

I agree. I’ve read that scientists are not certain why starlings do this. The Most common reasoning is that murmurations form for protection, to make it more difficult for a predator to pluck a starling from the group. Others argue that that is a weak and simplistic theory. Why, then, is the murmuration performed at about the same time every evening, and always before settling down for the night? Why not simply land when it’s ‘bedtime’ and avoid the risk of a big ol’ display of flesh and feathers. Why advertise like a darting, live billboard the nearest eatery? “Exit 47, chick-fowl-A!” I prefer the theory that the airborne ballet is a ritual that inspires awe by accident, without makeup or dress rehearsals. Without the ego of a leading man. A dance the starlings can’t help but do. That they can’t see their beauty makes it even more powerful. Murmurations are literally breathtaking to me. Sometimes I don’t realize that tears (of joy? Of yearning?) are streaming down my face. I watch and rewatch these videos when I feel out of place in my skin, in my family. When I’m lost, alone. I return to the whoosh of millions of wings like it’s home. I rise with urgency, with relief, and breathe again.

[@ipfreely9245]

This will explain around 10% of ufo 🛸sightings, wow! Beautiful patterns

[@roshnibhatt2801]

wonderful information, we are always seeing but not know what reason birds is cause the murmuration, thank you.

[@adhamhamed7080]

It’s the what if guy!!

[@kristinazickiene4209]

Ikr

[@jahjahpascual]

This is his other channel

[@saftheartist6137]

Thank you

[@AthenaStanley24]

These birds have been violently exterminated because they are deemed invasive species. The last murmeration I saw was around 2016. They kill lawn pests, sing nice songs & remind us the power of congregation. However they chase woodpeckers out of hollows to steal the nests.

[@rampauhzeliang2523]

Subscribed!!

[@SofianAmir-l1x]

Thank you Good 🙏🏻….. we see 🫶🏻 in everything you made 🙏🏻❤️

[@Bromeliadsss]

Great video

[@IronmanCoop]

That is crazy, whoever watched should give this man support

[@robertmyers6865]

you didn't answer anything!

[@Lantern7100]

Cool!

[@paulturner1535]

Any video of the "Wren" murmuration?

[@CYBERemnant]

People who deny the existence of a Creator miss out on so much. The greatest natural high for me is contemplating His wonders.

[@ppietras97]

So you have to believe in a magical man on the sky in order to be in awe of nature? You quack

[@CYBERemnant]

@@ppietras97 I don’t believe in a “magical man on the sky” to use your exact words. There’s no such thing. You contemplate the wonders of evolution (a false theory). I contemplate the wonders of CREATION, the works of the omniscient imagination and omnipotence of Almighty God. It makes a HUGE difference.

[@ppietras97]

@@CYBERemnant the greatest serial killer in history

[@CYBERemnant]

@@ppietras97 Who? You didn’t say whom you are speaking of. If you’re referring to the Roman Church of medieval times, I would agree with you. Research the Inquisition. That’s what happens when church and state unite. Persecution “in the name of God” is always the result. Biggest problem is it fuels criticisms from atheists. But God wasn’t responsible. Christianity was hijacked while basically still in its infancy. Nevertheless the critics have their field day with it and attribute to God what man is responsible for. Like war . . . Genocide . . . man-made viruses . . .

[@dogviperyt7304]

its the what if guy

[@christakpan]

What does flock in Murmurations mean?

[@tahanlaoboy]

The were making the rains the Starling Murmuration was created static electricity in the atmosphere to form the water droplets the locust and honeybee also induced static electricity in the atmosphere sometimes the mass numbers of Starlings got killed in mass numbers, because of the lighting from the static electricity that they were created the movement of the birds were perfect of generated the static electricity to charged the particles

[@ultimateclutch7938]

Make more videos!

[@markyanh6630]

GREAT

[@purple8774]

Woah! remember me when your 𝒻𝒶𝓂ℴ𝓊𝓈

[@emilyjoe326]

Birds glorify God.. They know their creator

[@caroleanderson4020]

This totally does not answer the question!!!

[@guletgulet3389]

every things that Humans know we learned from the Animals,the Ants,the smalest of the insects we learned some thing from them.

[@davidj-nv1sm]

You sound like that what if guy

[@aserelaser2232]

It is the what if guy he confirmed it

[@nonwolf5015]

@@aserelaser2232 also the “ How to survive” person. This is their 3rd channel

[@drwsopro8471]

It looks like when you’re extinct

[@pepper419]

Why couldn't you just show it without interfering.

[@lemondemon4740]

Lol this is insane lol

[@Goofy_youtuber]

Bruh why so bad video and it's top on my list???

[@DanielHHurt]

Starlings do this to take down Passenger planes. Boston airport, 1960, plane crash caused by flock of Starlings. 62 people died. true story, Daniel

[@RetroMill]

Rember me

[@splitfacemedia8519]

2:40 leftists and old rich people: "REEEEEEEE!!!"

[@Aloneagainofcourse]

Bird brains like the proud boys. Where we go one we go all.

[@random_weirdo._.8094]

6th comment😃

[@jimmim3000]

But... but they don't "bump into each other." Sounds like you didn't do your research. Disappointing.

[@ei1368]

..?

[@crgaillee]

You are trying to scientifically describe something that goes far beyond science. THAT harmony is the power of the Holy Spirit. Baptism includes water, the link between them mimics water. If you understand how water flows and pools, then you get a glimpse of how the Holy spirit flows.

[@lemondemon4740]

Community guidelines

[@earlaweese]

*”It’s not any communication between the birds”. Oh, so birds aren’t communicating with each other when they’re literally flying next to each other. Alright. Thanks for clearing that out. You’re annoying!!!!!*

[@earlaweese]

*That is blatant telepathy and nothing else.*

[@Bubblyhiccups]

I used to shoot these with my pellet gun as a kid. I had piles of them in my backyard. stray cats would come and pick them up.