Creative value of sin: Iqbal on idea of sin | گناہ کی تخلیقی اہمیت

Today's video is about " Creative value of sin: Iqbal on idea of sin | گناہ کی تخلیقی اہمیت "
Welcome to our KZbin channel dedicated to the profound wisdom of Allama Iqbal, philosophy, and books! Prepare to embark on an intellectual journey that delves deep into the life, thoughts, and works of one of the greatest philosophers and poets in history.
If you yearn for intellectual stimulation, philosophical enlightenment, and a deeper understanding of Allama Iqbal's invaluable contributions, then this KZbin channel is the perfect destination for you. Subscribe now and embark on a journey of intellectual discovery that will broaden your horizons and leave an indelible impact on your mind and soul.
__________________________________
Connect With Mr Khurram Ellahi:
Facebook: / khurram.ellahi
Email: [e-mail]
__________________________________
Buy My Book:
gufhtugu.com/product/managers...
#Iqbal #Philosophy #poetry #sin

[@educatedfool4871]

"Out beyond the Ideas of right and wrong, there is a field. I will meet you there" Rumi

[@irfanmehmud63]

"Some rise by sin, and some by virtue fall." - William Shakespeare

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wah

[@ahmadamin9015]

کمال است ❤بہت خوبصورتی سے گناہ کی تعریف بتای اج تک ایسی سینس مین گناہ کو سمجھا ہی نہین تھا

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@WomanAndLeadership]

This is so intriguing and disturbing at the same time, wow

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed , ideas of Iqbal first shock us and later they please us

[@shehzadaziz2706]

بہت اعلیٰ آپ نے پہلے کہا کہ گناہ میںcreativity ہے۔ اور آخر میں کہا کہ گناہ چھوڑنا سب سے بڑی فتح ھے کیا یہ تضاد نہیں ہے

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

دردِ دل ہوسِ گناہ و بر لب توبہ در صحت مے خوری و در تب توبہ

[@Sania-p9x]

کبھی گناہ کو اس انداز سے نہیں دیکھا😢😢،حیرت ہوئی بہت۔ بہت مزہ آیا سن کر۔ جزاک اللہ!!

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@tasawarmajeed3082]

شاید مجھ جیسے انسان نے گناہ پر غور ہی نہیں ۔۔۔۔۔شکریہ سر

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@inayatullah4339]

This video is so so great brother. Keep making such learn full videos.❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@qamarafrozshaikh6870]

Bahot khob samjhaya aap ne.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@zulfiqarahmed5156]

Mashallah very nice explanation...

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@sahilhussain270]

Dear khurram, this is the first video I've ever commented on in youtube, allamas thought and your interpretation of it have forced me to do so, what a great philosopher allama was. It's our bad luck we explored western philosophers soo much but forgot our own thinkers. Never be disappointed for the view count, if people ever start searching meaning for thier meaningless lives they will search for these topics. I know you dont live for attention. Bdw you've nice book collection ❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Honored. And thank you for kind words. I am actually indebted that you took out time and wrote this And yeah, my Library is my place where I practice madness, where I try to leave back mediocrity and go for higher thought.

[@hasnainabbas3442]

Would love to see a high res pic of your library. Want to read the titles. ​@@khurramellahiofficial

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Will give a tour of it someday

[@fayyazahmedramay6287]

یار کمال۔۔۔حیرت

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@mehar_e_Meer]

گناہ کی طاقت نیکی کو للکار دینے کا اہم حصہ ہے تو جب تک یہ رہے گا تو ہی دنیا میں تخلیقی دوڑ لگی رہے گی

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Rightly said

[@ayeshaakhtar5371]

بہت معنی خیز پیغام دیا ہے۔

[@TheEntertainmentEmpire-wz2ul]

❤

[@hussnainhaider7327]

❤❤

[@intellectualislam-py9ih]

Mind blowing 😮......

[@imranbasit8276]

Wah! ❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@EhsanSahu80]

Ma sha Allah sir ❤️

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@asadabbasi484]

Mashallah ❤Bhai jan

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@faranrockstar]

Thought provoking indeed

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@skyriser901]

Mashaallah behtareen Allah ap ko jaza day ameen

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Ameen

[@magrayfayaz1478]

Great video dear ..

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@Chocholato15]

Never think about sin in this way . Eye opening talk

[@sialkoplus6712]

علم جن کو گمراہ کرتا ھے وہ ایسے ہی ہوتے ہیں۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Brother I am happy that you are on the right path. May Allah keep you on right path

[@ahtishamulhaq4597]

Sir incredible thought

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed a different thought from Iqbal

[@humairmuhammad3984]

How beautiful these thoughts are

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you so much

[@hasnainabbas3442]

Wow..such unorthodox orthogonal stray thoughts and yet so beautiful

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@jamilkiani8836]

Ma sha Allah sir you have given a new perspective towards Sin. Is sy pehly kabhi aisi bhtain nahi suni. Hats off to you.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Let's thank Iqbal for introducing these ideas to our frozen community

[@sabirghulamkk4263]

We are lucky that we are living in the contemporary of such brains. Like him. Like Javed Ahmad. Technilogically AI is the highest of creations of science while Sir Khuram is the 'AI' of Sir Javed Ahmad.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Loved your words. Thank you

[@Chocholato15]

Plz make another video on this topic

[@trivziatrivzia7897]

Dear Sir bohat zabardast Kia ham ap ki is baat ko asy ley skty hain k jesy " Success will teach u only 1 lesson, but Failure will teach u 100 leassons " To ap ki baat k mutabiq Kia Guanh k liye bhi same socha ja sakta hai k " Piety will teach u only 1 lesson, but Sin wiol teach u 100 lesson" Or jesa Wasif Ali Wasi saab ny farmaya tha k " Wo gunah jo tujhy aajiz bana dey us naiki sey bohat behtar hai jo tery andr takabur or gharoor paida kr dey " Ap ki rahnumai ka bohat shukria JazakAllah

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you so much

[@Drabbaskhan526]

What is sin please answer this question is a troubling me since my childhood what is your opinion and what is sin in its essence are good people vulnerable to continuing it throughout our lives what are the opinions on this topic among various religions and what are the views of philosophers is sin a trademark of greatness or perversion please explain would love to have your views about this very basic and taboo subject

[@ateeqwasil9683]

کمال۔ مزی اندر جہانے کور ذوقی کل ہی ایک غزل لکھی۔ مطلع اسی موضوع پر تھا: آدمی ہوں، پئے میراثِ پِدَر جاتا ہوں سنگ ابلیس کے، میں سوئے شجَر جاتا ہوں 🖋️عتیق واصلؔ

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wah

[@wakilkhan9418]

ویڈیو ایک کہانی کی طرح تھی جو اٹھنا شروع ہوئی لیکن آخری 3 منٹ تک یہ عروج پر پہنچ گئی جب کہ یہ صرف اعلیٰ صلاحیت، درست الفاظ، صحیح وقت اور اس اہمیت کے موضوع پر تھا۔ پہلے نصف کے لیے آپ فلسفی لگتے ہیں اور اس کے بعد آخر تک آپ "درویش" بن جاتے ہیں... آپ کی گہری اور دور اندیش گفتگو کا شکریہ۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Kind words. Honored. You just showed me a new mirror.

[@kashirkahani09]

Biwi aur gf mai b yehi farak hai....biwi ik roz marah ki exercise hai ..jab ki..gf har pal ik naya takhayul hai...

[@mudassirrizwan2473]

sir, you are doing a great great service to our youth. It is a pity that your channel does not have many subscribers. But it is their loss than it is your loss. So, Please never ever stop doing what you are doing. Well done

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Kind words, thank you. My job is to create the image, can never force humans to open eyes. So doing my humble job of creating the images. And someday I get surprise testimonial like this. Shukriya

[@lifenutrition9704]

Study Allama Ghulam Ahmed parwez

[@MuhammadAhmad-zb5zq]

Sir please please please please ek video Imam Al juwaini aur Imam al Baqillani par tafseeli ♥️Khuda apko ajar de

[@TheEntertainmentEmpire-wz2ul]

کسے خبر کے ھزاروں مقام رکھتا ہے وھ فقر جس میں فقر ھے روح قرآنی

[@sabirghulamkk4263]

Sir, I commented on your video once before, this is my second comment on the same issue. Sir it will be more beneficial for us if u use to pick a topic and then dive a little more deep into it, making your video at least 15 to 25 mints. This video is better as compared to others which are very short.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you for suggesting that. Just wait until we touch the mark of 200 videos. Later I will try to have longer sessions on topics.

[@sabirghulamkk4263]

@@khurramellahiofficial thank you for consideration❤️

[@pakistanzindabad9257]

خالص گناہ۔۔۔۔ اکثر معرفت الہی کی پہلی سیڑھی بن جایا کرتی ہے

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wah

[@uchanel8205]

مقالات حکمت میں لکھا یے گنہگار ہی حقیقت کا عرف ہوتا۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔ ہے ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔!!!

[@user-yn2rl5xk4t]

سر بہت شکریہ ! ❤️ سر ! کس ترتیب کے ساتھ حقیقی علم حاصل کیا جا سکتا ہے ؟ مہربانی کر کے اس بارے میں ایک فہرست بنائیں ۔

[@manaummahadafraz9028]

اس قدر پیار ہے انساں کی خطاؤں سے مجھے کہ فرشتہ مرا معیار نہیں ہو سکتا

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Khoob

[@user-zv4ru3ni8d]

This world according to me is correspondence to just a bolly wood film in which some one will be hero and some villin by the will of allah.

[@Curiositylab55]

Sir ma Kaisa ISS tarah Apne AAP Ku bana skta hu study krna philosophy like yours sir but Kaise batayee

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Start the journey. It will not happen overnight You need to walk this path.

[@abdullahmirza8899]

Assalamualikum Khurram Bhai..I hope you’re fine and doing well. Bhai mane pichhle kuchh arsay se ALLAMA saahab ko sunna shuru kiya hua hai…Please make more videos about his Philosophy and visions.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you. If you can go to playlist of our channel. You will find two playlists, one on stray Reflections and other on Iqbal, both are about his work

[@abdullahmirza8899]

@@khurramellahiofficial Alright Bhai Thank You So Much. More Respect for you. Take Care

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Welcome

[@basitali415]

Sir i want to get in contacts with you...a big big fan from kashmir

[@khurramellahiofficial]

[e-mail]

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

اور اِسی کے بعد پھر اِنسان یہ کہتا ہے کہ حیاتِ چند روزہ بھی حیاتِ جاوداں نکلی

[@sirajqureshi6537]

Sir apne kya Bola "fahz kuruni..." Ispe par kuch btao

[@MARTIN-101]

read surah baqrah ayat 152. waha apko yeh alfaz milenge. iska matlab hai. "mujhe yaad karo me tumhe yaad karonga"

[@voicenoteguy]

Khurram sir mera recently philosophy mai interest paida huva hai aur Alama Iqbal ra ki ideology aur un ki poetry mai khaas kr k . lakin mujhe samj nahi aaraha ki mai kaha se aur kese shuru karu alama iqba ra ko parhna. apki guidance ki boht zaroarat hai so please toh guide kr den.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

This playlist might make it easy for you. kzbin.info/aero/PLsQazMNuEFkyRzaIPeqU5k89IUljzRCgO&si=XSxTVRvyLRlE4kCh

[@bilalfareedi7035]

ایک ہی طرح کے سجدے کرنا یہ عبادت ہے تو عادت کیا ہے

[@intellectualislam-py9ih]

مولانا رومی کی نظم کا نام بتا دیں ❤

[@shawalkhan4109]

Sir how to comprehend such lines of Stray Reflection on our own?

[@khurramellahiofficial]

By reading diversified subjects. You get new insights on same phenomenon

[@shawalkhan4109]

Sir please start teaching Philoophy sequentially.

[@a.jwrestling9940]

Sir you Should Interduce you Self to Japanese Art Like Manga or may be Anime

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Yes I am planning to. Thank you for recommending

[@a.jwrestling9940]

May be Watch or read beserk, death note, Attack on titan

[@Sufyan-er5ni]

@@khurramellahiofficial+ jjk (philosophy of curse spirits)

[@a.jwrestling9940]

@@Sufyan-er5ni yes that Would be great

[@a.jwrestling9940]

@@khurramellahiofficial If this you ( not moderator) you made my Day sir

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

سر ایک ولی سے کسی نے سوال کیا کہ اگر ہم سے گناہ شیطان کرواتا ہے تو اس میں ہمارا کیا قصور ہے آپ اِس بارے میں کیا کہتے ہیں

[@arifv.s.8640]

کائنات میں پہلا گناہ مذہبی کے سر جاتا ہے عاجزی اور احترام سے انکار انا پرستی مذہبی شخصیات کا خاصہ ہوتا ہے

[@khurramellahiofficial]

In these times, here I agree.

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

Please Sir reply zaroor ki Jai ga

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Sure. I will try to make another video to address your question and thank you for watching

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

JazakALLAH Sir, and I am waiting your video!

[@nayabrung]

آخری جملے ❤ 'پوری نیکیوں کا دیس آباد کردیں اور گناہ کی ایک گلی چھوڑ کے دیکھیں، تو وہ گلی چھوڑنا بڑی فتح لگے گی '' ❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Kuch ese he ha

[@hmbilalmustafa5481]

مگر گناہ کے بعد پھر اس سے پیدا ہوئی "مایوسی و ندامت" کو کیسے tackle کیا جائے پھر ؟ دامن کا میلا ہو چکنے کے عذاب ِ ندامت سے پھر کیسے معاملہ کیا جائے گا ؟ اس بارے بھی کچھ بتائیں

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Please watch the video of Faust on our channel.

[@wowshakeel]

Sir 'disco' aadmi kisay kehty hain? 😅

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Certainly a disco-man can only tell. So need to ask the right person

[@sialkoplus6712]

بغیر استاد کے بندے کا یہی حال ہوتا ھے جو اس وقت آپ کا ھے۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Now that was a judgemental statement

[@omarzaidiomar3152]

یہ دنیا کشاکشِ نفس کی جگہ ہے، امتحان ہے۔ گناہ کی لذت وقتی ہوتی ہے مگر اس کی روحانی اذیت اور تکلیف بہت زیادہ ہوتی ہے ۔ گناہ سے حقیقی فائدہ بھی وہی اٹھا سکتا ہے جو گناہ کو گناہ سمجھے، گناہ کرکے اسے شرمندگی ہو ، اس کی یہ شرمندگی اسے توبہ تک لےکر جائے ۔ جس بندہ کو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ نے گناہ سے دور رکھا ہوا ہے اس کے لیے گناہ گار کی حالت سے سبق لینا کافی ہے اسے شکر کرنا چاہیے کہ اسے گناہ کی اذیت سے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ نے بچایا ہوا ہے ۔ شیطان نے تو گناہ کو گناہ ہی نہیں سمجھا وہ تو خود کو حق پہ سمجھتا رہا ، اسی لیے وہ توبہ سے محروم رہا، شیطان کی باطل خودی کتنی بڑی تھی جو کہ اسے گمراہی کی طرف لے گئی۔ لہذا ہمیں اپنے اندر حقیقی خودی تو یقیناً بڑی پیدا کرنی چاہیے ، جو ہمیں نفس کی سازشوں سے بچاکر رب العالمین کی محبت اور عبادت میں مشغول رکھے۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wonderful words. Thank you for detailed comment.

[@user-nf7fc8tz2b]

سر سلام عرض ہے۔۔۔۔اگر آ پ کی بات کو سچ مان لیا جائے کہ فری ول گناہ کی طرف زیادہ مائل ہے تو فطرت سلیم ۔۔۔۔۔؟؟

[@sialkoplus6712]

آپ کے خیالات سے اگر کچھ علمی و فنی نوعیت کا اختلاف ہو تو ۔۔۔۔ اختلاف مٹانے کے لئے کیا کیا جائے۔ 🤔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

One should mention the conflict. Or write an article or send me a good reply points while having points of conflict. I will welcome those

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

اور سر یہ بھی کہتے ہیں کہ اکثر گناہ ہی اِنسان کو نیکی کی طرف راغب کرتے ہیں اور اِس کے بعد جو لزت اِنسان کو اچھا کام کرنے میں ملتی شاید وہ اُسے کھبی نہ مل سکتی

[@nayabrung]

کمال بات۔

[@Sufyan-er5ni]

لیکن وہ لذت کچھ عرصہ بعد ختم ہوجاتی ہے

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

Nahi aasi bat nahi ha maulan Tariq Jameel farmata Hain k jab main سیدھے راستے ki tarf ragib hua tu main na aik sawal ka jawab manga tha khud sa

[@user-ix6co5od8l]

K agr aj kaymat aa jay to ap ka Kaya خیال ha k ap جنت main Jain ga ya دوزخ main to mere Dil sa awaz aai k dozakh main bas wahi wakat that k Tariq Jameel sa Maulana Tariq Jameel ban gay

[@sayyedmouhtashimgelani6576]

Dear Mr Khurram, i feel that such statements are when made infront of the masses,they are seldom not able to digest it.Each man has his own size of cup. Such things are better to be kept confidential otherwise you have to fall in the situation of Mansoor Hallaj. Anyway,i know you from a long time when i once came across your show on Ptv (Nukta) .I liked it. Moreover,may i know what city are you from?

[@khurramellahiofficial]

You are very right here, hence our society is consuming mediocre stuff I am from Islamabad

[@sayyedmouhtashimgelani6576]

@@khurramellahiofficial I would like to propose you to go through the work of a man who is from Lahore. His name is Raza Kazim,a relative of Juggan Kazim,and the grand father of Noori(Pakistani pop singers). He is 93 ,a retired lawyer,and now resides in his institute,Sanjan Nagar institute of Philosophy and Arts. He set the foundations of a new discipline,named Evolutionary Mentology in 1970.Unfortuantely his work couldn't get much recognition. Other than that he invented a musical instrument "Sagar Veena" and set up a school named sanjan nagar trust.I felt a need to make you aware of this personality, because i feel right now he is one of the only few alive men who have spent their lives on pondering on the Nature that Almighty has created but he is not much recognised. I believe that as you go through every other discipline and knowledge in history,i would make you aware of this new one as well incase you are not aware of it. I would send its website where there is a summary of his work on your email if you say. I would like you to review or critique his work. Thankyou

[@khurramellahiofficial]

You just came as a light, I am truly honored that I will be introduced to his work. Word evolutionary methology has triggered me please send details on [e-mail] If you can also add you WhatsApp number in the email.

[@idreeskhan2360]

Socrates and Aristotle hv given the theory of virtue ....Eudomania if I hv correctly spelled. Virtue and sin are relative terms though. Iqbal borrowed thoughts from many ...from khushal khattak to Sartre to Goethe. I dnt consider him an original thinker as evident from his literary journey. Virtue does not mean religious only it rather includes courage etc. regards

[@khurramellahiofficial]

I will address this question soon and if you can find my podcast on KZbin on specific topic , there I have addressed this question in detail. He wasn't only original thinker but amazing reader also. He brought so many scenes from western and other parts of the world and similarly for the rest of the world, he portrayed the eastern perspective. I am not writing this message to convince you but to put forward my opinion.

[@idreeskhan2360]

@@khurramellahiofficial i respect your valued views,yet allow me to pen down that entire literary and off course political journey of Dr Iqbal , one gets a unambiguous impression that Dr sb was prey to contradictions. Starting with his Pan Hindustan stance , Iqbal Sb took to mystic thought processes in line with Rumi and portrayed himself as a Sufi. Towards the end, he then switched to khudi after his stay in west , apparently under the influence of Self , esteem,khudi of Sartre, Dante and Goethe. In fact all this stance of mine struck me when I listened to his esteemed son Javed Sb. I am not negating his stature as a great poet ,though there too he has copied many poems of khushal khattak ( pl read both if not so far), and record shows that Dr sb asked Khadeeja madam to complete ph.D on khushal khattak which she did too.anyway I hope we must do scholarly dispositions rather than emotional one that by and large we all do. Regards

[@khurramellahiofficial]

I wish we could sit someday, this isn't even partial reality. I hope you stay with us in this journey and we can introduce such thoughts to each other. Iqbal has been quoting all these people that how he reached them, where he differentiates etc. But I like the way you disagree. Honored by that

[@idreeskhan2360]

@@khurramellahiofficial my profound regards

[@academia3602]

ایرک فرام نے اسے disobidience کہا ہے۔۔۔ ان کے بقول انسانی تاریخ ہی اس نافرمانی اور انحراف سے شروع ہوتی ہے، انسان اصل معنوں میں انسان بنتا ہی اسی دن ہے جب وہ انحراف کرتا اور جنت سے نکالا جاتا ہے۔۔۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Beautiful. Enlightening comment

[@mutahirshah6352]

Ek Saal SE soft porn Dekh Raha tha.. aaj aap ke kehne par animal porn dekha

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Kash apko video samajh aati

[@ixmix]

you're glamorizing Milton's Satan

[@fayyazahmedramay6287]

اچھا نیک لوگوں کو اس معاملے میں تو میں نے احمق پایا ہے کہ ان کو لوگ پڑھنا نہیں آتے۔ان کو پتا تک نہیں ہوتا لوگ کس حد تک گر سکتے ہیں۔وہ سب کو اپنے جیسا سمجھتے ہیں کبھی کسی نیک بندے سے کسی کے متعلق مشورہ بھی نا لیں یہ عیب چھپا جائیں گے۔ کسی چھپری سے ہوچھیں وہ آپ کو سب سچ بتائے گا

[@khurramellahiofficial]

You just opened a new window for me

[@aimalhayatswati2619]

کسی غلط سی خطا کی نہ رکھ امید کہ ہم بڑا منجھا ہوا ذوق گناہ رکھتے ہیں عدم. ابوالکلام آزاد صاحب کا نقط نظر اس حوالے سے مسحور کن ہے۔۔!

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wah