Creta vs Scorpio N vs Thar Roxx | Price Vs Features Which Is The Best Buy | 4K

[@SuperAjnag]

No one beats the Scorpio N! The presence, the smooth engine, the power, the value for money aspect ❤

[@sidpatankar]

As you must have seen in the video I echo your sentiment largely

[@APAPictures]

Remember, Scorpio N is only D segment Real SUV in comparison. Its class apart.

[@KKJi001]

Yeah👍🏻

[@sidpatankar]

Fair point - but we never said we are doing a within segment or like comparison

[@Vantageview]

You said creta is more comfortable than scorpion . Seriously?

[@sunnymurthy4624]

I will choose only the THAR ROXX…. ROXXY IS HERE TO RULE, from a proud XUV 700 owner… 😊

[@16green]

Rule what ? only 10 percent of Indian roads ?

[@abhidesign]

Bodyroll

[@Godshand87]

Says a scooty rider 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jitendrajain5769]

Thar Rox & Scorpio N look wise , character & ability wise are proper SUVs ..Its an insult to have compared with creta tbh

[@sidpatankar]

Am only respecting a buyer query I have recd in. many nos... Its about what some ppl compare, not a technical comparison

[@Ni3iN_D28]

🌟 Previously ScorpioN Was Nice Balance Between 3 Door Thar & XUV 700 But 5 Door Thar Changed Whole Game, That Roxx Offers More Than Everything Which So Called Sophisticated Segment Leader Offers With Unmatched Off-road Capabilities & Road Presence & I Think Roxx Gets Huge Advantage Ovet Its Competitors.......Roxx For All👍

[@_M_D_M_]

Roxx is amazing to drive. But in the flesh it lacks road presence like that of ScorpioN. Roxx looks pretty boring. I would go with N than Roxx.

[@mrpublic7921]

You already booked scorpio or what😅

[@jitendrajain5769]

Thar Roxx Road presence is next level...Have seen it in person jn kochi...Scorpio N looks great as well but scorpio needs huge update now like adas , panaromic sunroof , 360 camera etc

[@micheal903]

@@jitendrajain5769Scorpio n looks bigger in person than the thar roxx

[@Renthlei_Pa]

Of course I will go for Thar ROXX... Scorpio N looks like Big wagon R

[@lemedico]

Auto journalists must not skip the narration of the safety stars and crash worthiness

[@sidpatankar]

Agree. It’s an assumption since the Creta in new form and Thar Roxx haven’t been crash tested as yet. But your point is valid. And I take the feedback to heart

[@lemedico]

​@@sidpatankarthank you, Mr Patankar. Another question... You haven't aged a day since your ndtv days. Help a brother out

[@sidpatankar]

@@lemedicohaha at least you didn’t call me a vampire. Truth tho I have aged indeed. It escapes no one 😢

[@drgurpreetayurveda4564]

Thar rox can never beat creta in sales due to mileage gap of atleast 4-5 kml difference, Creta’s reliable engines and electronics, ride and handling is way ahead of ladder frame suvs and more importantly creta perfect size

[@sidpatankar]

Yup it becomes the no-brainer as I said. But if someone wants something butch and least the 5-door is a more practical choice than how the 3-door was simply not.

[@garudagaming2019]

No sense ​@@sidpatankar

[@KKJi001]

Creta tatti

[@lalhriatpuiaralte2454]

cosmetic car uakkkk

[@mrpublic7921]

Its all 10kmpl As of creta gives 16 or 18 in the city

[@PremKumar-gs3ym]

I will choose Thar ROXX off course.😊

[@jsvigneshwaran]

My choice will be either Roxx or the ScorpioN

[@Mrkclean]

These three beast...stands on its own class 💪👍... love all

[@niravmehta3854]

Hi svp its was so good to actually see u in one of the videos from so long , great to see u bro , i would hv chosed Creta as my mom is 82 and she will not be able to easily get inside the thar so personally would have bought the creta.

[@sidpatankar]

Thanks for your support! Agree Creta more comfy for her for sure

[@jitendrajain5769]

Thar Roxx anytime over scorpio N..Its looks great SUV from angles..

[@nitinmodi6675]

Good to see you back Siddarth Vinayak ji❤👍

[@k.c.perumalchinnasamy9705]

❤ THE 2.2 M-HAWK DIESEL DESPERATELY NEED 8 SPEED AT

[@desertracer278]

Let me bring in another perspective, of honesty and ethics. Here Mahindra trumps the Korean twins. The Korean twins are dishonest in that they sell cars loaded with features to entice customer, but with the safety of a paper cup, in India. Coz they know they can milk the market with big screens without a care for the basics Mahindra wants to give the best to the customer, they are honest in this endeavor, albeit falling short on quality control and after sales service experience.

[@sidpatankar]

That is indeed an interesting perspective. It has been great to see how M&M has gone so sincerely after safety and now design too. Best yet to come I reckon

[@desertracer278]

@@sidpatankarI always loved your reviews. Please keep them coming..

[@MrNikrulesu]

Between scorpio n and thar roxx, which one has better ride quality? And by how much.

[@sidpatankar]

Scorpio N overall as the Roxx is a bit bouncier, but its seats are more comfy

[@shravansrimushnam1268]

@@sidpatankar isnt Roxx built on new frame and it should be much better ride ? also due it lower height than N

[@MotoBeast25]

​@@shravansrimushnam1268I have the same doubt, Roxx has newer platform and suspension hence I expect it to be better than Scorpio N, I am yet to test drive Roxx.

[@micheal903]

@@shravansrimushnam1268thar roxx is around 100 kgs lighter than the top spec Scorpio n which is why there’s less body roll and better ride

[@shravansrimushnam1268]

@@micheal903 yes, but in video it's mentioned differently

[@vishalbhosale353]

Paid review by Hyundai?? My Scorpio N has Apple car play. Please don't give false information.

[@lemedico]

11:50 is a DRL blown, or not captured due to the frame rate of the camera?

[@sidpatankar]

Great observation. Yes the latter. It works fine :)

[@narendersharma72]

Was waiting for Thar 5 door for more than a year. C-pillar is dampener. I don’t like Roxx naming but will never buy Korean cars. Enjoyed 10+ years of Nissan Terrano which is great mid-SUV.

[@sidpatankar]

Yup I don't like both those also. But look at the bloody bookings!!

[@colorsoflife8942]

Sid...my favourite car reviewer.😊👍

[@sidpatankar]

😀🙏

[@vagabondwanderers]

Rox & Scorpio are closely priced… they both need to compared in detailed

[@viveksood401]

Am buying the Creta! Very impressed with the Roxx, but it still does not tick the 'primary car' box. Lags behind in the ride quality as well as feel & comfort. But as your second car, it's a good option. The Thar 3 door was only a Third Car choice but with the Roxx, Mahindra has moved a step up!

[@shobhitjadli6566]

Hi Sid, It's good to see you back... Where did you vanish for such a long time ???

[@sidpatankar]

I have always been around doing my reviews online now for some years! Now that you found me do subscribe!

[@shobhitjadli6566]

@@sidpatankar Already did !

[@munishthakur3437]

ScorpioN is the best...... looks muscular, decent ride quality, great sitting position..... THE BIG DADDY !!!

[@vishnushankar4404]

Thar Roxx.. Thar Roxx.. Thar Roxx.. always, anytime..

[@sidpatankar]

:)

[@HemanthVlogs]

Scorpio n vs hycross vs Gloster which is better ?

[@sidpatankar]

not really comparable in direct terms. But what is your priority?

[@saras2365]

Bro I remember you… Siddarth ….kar 🤔 if I’m not wrong… I used to watch your videos of car reviews in news channel…

[@aayushbhingare2279]

Beautiful review, happy to see you are now with acko drive. Grown up watching your car and Bike show with my dad. Scorpio N great car has some serious shortcomings like the third row is unusable. Over all the car is great and ironing out pot holes. I personally found it better to drive than xuv700, Scorpio n was always at ease everywhere road or no-roads.

[@sidpatankar]

thanks so much - for your thoughts and you and your dad's viewership! :)

[@doitmyway4415]

My budget is 16 lakh on road , should I buy base model of thar roxx or Scorpio N, or should I go for creta or seltos, or Verna , I don’t like compact SUV , either it is full size suv or a sedan.. plz suggest I m confused

[@micheal903]

16 lakh on road you’ll only get the 2 wheel drive 3 door thar that too probably on petrol variant if you want a large suv but it won’t be practical for family

[@VidushiLohia-do5vd]

Comparing two 5 star rated cars (yup roxx will get 5 star for sure, since its a mahindra pedigree, and even 3 door was good 4 star) WITH POOR 3 STAR TIN CAN WITH “UNSTABLE STRUCTURE” 😂😂😂 everyone curse maruti for built quality, imagine Hyundai providing very poor built quality at 22 lac price 😂😂😂 giving wagon r build quality at 22 lac is criminal, indians should understand this and should not fall for larger screen than longer life !

[@sudhirshinde0901]

Bought Creta auto top spec last year.. now nothing to think about.. let Roxx to go in second gen with change in chapri alloy wheels n interior change with more refinement then can consider..

[@salesalpha3832]

Things you cannot afford, tag it as chapri 😂.... So convenient 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@rohinanand540]

yeah FE is his concern

[@cannotthinkofoneatth]

agree on the wheel design...who gave a flower like design to a car as macho as Thar Roxx..

[@Hars.Sharma123]

​@@salesalpha3832top spec auto creta goes 22-23 lakh you kido even thar top and scorpion are placed at same price the difference is that creta is like I phone and Mahindra micromax making big cars but poor quality

[@sudhirshinde0901]

@@salesalpha3832 in this way all luxury cars will be chapri for you..

[@HashsirHaroon1]

Thar Roxx is more Handsome

[@piyushporwal1307]

If you buy creta instead of xuv700, thar, thar roxx, harrier or scorpio n then either you are a blind or a fool

[@kahihihihihihi]

Welcome Sidharth We are very happy to saw in acko Drive I am very confused between Rox and Sco.N

[@ackodrive]

Hope this video helped?

[@sidpatankar]

So what do u now think after watching this?

[@MrVishalsingh]

You should have compared xuv 700, Scorpio n and That roxx.

[@prokashchetia2599]

Roxx and creta❤

[@Reddylion]

I will go will Hyundai creta EV.

[@sidpatankar]

Yup it becomes the no-brainer

[@spydy8707]

Scorpio win

[@sunnyjain2451]

Nice comparison

[@sidpatankar]

Thanks very much!

[@404_Not_Found_1]

Scorpio N is beast will choose over any other SUV. And Sir, Scorpio N has good image and lot of Sophistication way more than Thar brother. And everybody knows Chapri car of India. So bhai please do your research

[@sohail1127]

Comparing Creta With Two Giants.. whats the logic???? ...you should Compare Creta with his own Relatives Not with Hulks

[@sidpatankar]

Am only respecting a buyer query I have recd in. many nos... Its about what some ppl compare, not a technical comparison or. segment shootout. Your views are valid, but understand why I did that story. Its not apples to apples.

[@Mo34565]

Creta is more expensive than Thar Rox

[@sohail1127]

@@Mo34565 Cheaper and Costlier is not the concern Sir , Concern is Segment Creta is not a Rare Wheel Drive Full fledge Suv .. Creta doesn't Come in 4x4 Varient etc etc

[@salesalpha3832]

Roxx all the way!

[@kipaama298]

Any day scorpio n at z8L 4wd....still will my favorite.....roxx has been gud upgraded because this is new model of 2024 no doubt gud changes but i will pick scorpio n ..so ,i think when scorpio n will get facelift version this roxx thar will feel again old in specifications, tech wise, driving etc 🫠🙃...because scorpio n is above n up segment thn thar roxx...segment is D segment, and i don't like white interior of thar roxx no sense will get easily dirt....instead of white black old thar interior colour was oky for me

[@sidpatankar]

Agree on that

[@shalinmodi6748]

Stop over rating creta..... It's neither 7seater nor with 2ltr engine...... It seems that Hyundai is paying auto reviewers hefty..... In the past also some compared creta with Harrier and xuv700.... Doesn't make sense.

[@ramus6188]

Thar ROXX

[@Carsamachar1111]

Have Hyundai given you some sort of bribe because if you really wanted to compare then you must have compared Creta to XUV 700 both front wheel drive & more aerodynamic shapes of both than these two pure SUV’s

[@sidpatankar]

Am only respecting a buyer query I have recd in. many nos... Its about what some ppl compare, not a technical comparison - and besides the Roxx comes off positively in the end. So you think what you will... but don't assume and attack someone's integrity just for a lark

[@Carsamachar1111]

​@@sidpatankar then why you didn't included XUV 700 in the comparison? Because then these silly point on which you have shown that Creta is better would also had been vanished in front of XUV 700. So no comparison of pseudo SUV Creta to a real Macho ladder on frame Scorpio or Thar.

[@IbrahimAli-i2u]

Creta is best for city and highway 😊I am satisfied with it ☺️

[@RajSingh-hv5tj]

😃

[@singhsamyak]

Mahindra would be a nice vehicle but not if looking at comfort and family car

[@sidpatankar]

Agree

[@Legend_aviation]

Not agreed

[@singhsamyak]

That Roxx I have seen all the reviews and if anyone has any knowledge of ladder on frame and what creta and other vehicles are made in the ride comfort is miles away from Roxx, so if you want a rugged SUV then it’s perfectly good.

[@Legend_aviation]

@@singhsamyak bro Xuv 700

[@shankarpandi9177]

Don't fool us. Creta is not an SUV. It's a cross-over

[@chandangowda4471]

What about build quality!

[@sidpatankar]

Of?

[@tulsibhattarai6010]

Roxx without a second thought…

[@sidpatankar]

What do u think of its crazy bookings?

[@chandangowda4471]

Roxx can't be compared with cosmetic cars...

[@airdbreck]

Scorpio

[@manasmanu1456]

Could have added bit more premium ness to Roxx

[@kipaama298]

Y, i think that's enough to have that's all features in thar....thar is usually meant for hardcore offroad car...not for premium....what will happens to these 2 cars xuv700 and scorpio n which is a above segment car than thar roxx...

[@sidpatankar]

What would u have liked to see?

[@jayanthmakam4547]

This comparison would have been better, if you had compared only scorpio n and thar, or including any other ladder frame chassis vehicle. It makes zero sense comparing creata with scorpio and thar.

[@lemedico]

"segment leader" for some reason

[@sidpatankar]

I agree with you both as an automobile enthusiast. But average buyers don’t always compare apples to oranges. So I hope you get where I’m coming from and why this was necessary. Though you may still continue to disagree of course

[@pradeepsolanke7711]

@@sidpatankar better salesman instead of a critic dont you think

[@abhidesign]

Drive Thar Roxx then you must drive Jeep Compass.

[@jsvigneshwaran]

Compass is nothing infront of these 3 SUVs brother.

[@sidpatankar]

Also price point mismatch - hence can't go there. I get your point though...!

[@abhidesign]

@@sidpatankar you must check once both dealers.

[@abhidesign]

@@jsvigneshwaran body roll.

[@chinmayjoshi8750]

Whats the point in comparing creta with these 2? They are of totally different segments.

[@sidpatankar]

Did u watch the whole thing? I explained the point in vivid detail. You need not agree with my perspective. But I did for buyers who DO have this dilemma

[@piyushporwal1307]

In the price range of 15-20 lakh, most important thing is road presence and creta is not even in this race. You are getting scorpion, 700, roxx in the price of seltos or creta. Creta and seltos is not in the competition. Creta and seltos are comparable to brezza, kushaq, taigun.

[@sairoadways4365]

hmm, creta now seems over-priced, but i think its selling coz of mileage and compact size (not big and not small).

[@sidpatankar]

Am only respecting a buyer query I have recd in. many nos... Its about what some ppl compare, not a technical comparison

[@Tomboy_xthetics]

❤

[@cradle652]

Thar Roxx is a classic identity crisis product.

[@ugparmar1568]

Scorpio N

[@ravisingla6422]

Scorpio n

[@hirakbhaumik1996]

Creta always king

[@Sting699]

Dnt be so foolish creta is not even close to thar or scropio. Creta is for nexon.brezza . GV. kia. Honda elevate. MG.

[@avinashrallapati1413]

Half of the video telling stories, kindly do comparison

[@sidpatankar]

Your perspective, and mine... need not match - no? Idea was to answer the dilemma a certain set of buyers have. This video is not designed as a generic comparo anyway

[@JaskaranSingh-dt4bz]

What creta is doing here goo home

[@abhinavbaruah]

Scorpio N WILL STING OTHERs

[@YDallDay]

Roxx is ugly, like chinese version of RR evoque copy fail