Crime and Punishment | Fyodor Dostoevsky

[@Eternalised]

Enjoy these type of videos? Please give it a like Support this channel: www.patreon.com/eternalised KZbin Member Perks: kzbin.info/door/qos1tl0RntucGGtPXNxkkAjoin Donate a Coffee: ko-fi.com/eternalised PayPal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/eternalisedofficial Official Merch: eternalised.creator-spring.com

[@satnamo]

I like it!

[@chrysostomusc.5645]

Fantastic video. I finished the book yesterday and I am totally fascinated of this novel, the dark ambiance and the overall melancholic feeling, but my favorite moment is when he is on the way to confess and sees that Sonya was following him and now realizes that she will follow him forever.

[@Eternalised]

Thank you very much! It is definitely one of the highlights of the novel. I enjoyed it very much as well :)

[@CidolofasOrlandu]

Why do you think Raskolnikov leaves the station upon hearing that Svidri killed himself? It’s only when he sees Sonya again that he walks back inside.

[@deb1847]

@@CidolofasOrlandu I think he was again considering Suicide upon hearing the news.but the appearance of Sonya forced him to return and finally confess

[@titustius6759]

which translation

[@maxwellelymas3880]

Hey... really appreciate the spoiler alert. That's really cool of you to give away what seems like one the more important parts of the novel. Incredibly selfish, uncourteous, and just down right robbery to those who have not read it. If you even realize just what little you shared could just really "take away" to some of those really appreciate works of literature and just literature as a whole. That was such a jerk move and I don't care what you say about me voicing my opinion about your childish spoiler alert. Have some God damn respect for those who have not read such a brilliant novel! I mean really, who does that on application/site where people can read tainted posts such as yours potentially ruining a legendary tale such as Fodor's "Crime and Punishment". Refrain from your ignorant and foolish posts for people who have not had the honor due to their busy lives. I hate spoiler alerts and individuals such as yourself should consider such outcomes of your reckless post

[@MrOreo2010]

Something that struck me was how Raskolnikov, whenever he recounted the murder, completely left out murdering the sister. At least to me, it's clear that he cannot find any reason whatsoever that would even remotely justify his action. Meaning that conscience still is a force active inside him and/or that as much as he is a materialist/nihilist he nevertheless needs a justification, feeble as it may be, for killing He cannot justify killing the sister to himself and so he attempts to forget the fact because he cannot but be moral

[@animula6908]

That’s interesting. I haven’t read the ending of the book yet, but if you hadn’t said that I think I’d have interpreted it the opposite way.

[@KevinSantifort]

Damn, I completely missed this.

[@johnsun11]

Some skeptics might say it is an apologetic story about russian atrocities and their lack of morality. If not the grotesque happy ending of the story I would disagree. But they might be right.

[@Sindrsus]

So killing without reason is immoral, but killing with a justifiable reason is not immoral? Is morality only about being rational, then?

[@Boz196]

@@Sindrsusneither is moral, there is no ‘superior man’ and there is no murder for the ‘greater good’. History has proven this.

[@catanaschilote]

A really awesome book... The redemption of Svidrigailov through suicide left me speechless...

[@happygucci5094]

Echoes Judas… I think

[@demotsit1290]

Достоевски е жертвал себе си, за да каже, да ни предупреди за нашите грешки или грехове. Това е, като метафора за висш пилотаж. Респект!

[@davidwalker5054]

This is the novel that started my love of the classics I have read some outstanding novels. But none have made such an imprint on my mind as this masterpiece. Dostoevsky is a master

[@lygrow5450]

Great video. I just finished reading this book. it's amazing how profoundly Dostoevsky is able to convey the guilt/psychological effects Raskolnikov experiences as a result of his crimes.

[@Eternalised]

Thanks! An incredible psychologist as well! Interesting how Nietzsche called him "the only psychologist from whom I had something to learn"

[@IamJsb]

Keep up the work. Please don't stop uploading ❤️

[@Eternalised]

Thank you! ❤️

[@NegationOfNegation]

You are serious doing a profound job! The images, the editing, the references, the narration all on point. What I sensed from your content is that you are exploring the big questions and which are very religious & metaphysical in some sense. I love the content you're creating on Jung, Dostoevsky, Nietzsche, Kierkegaard, Peterson (the existentialists) and in the future, I hope you would create some content on Greek Philosophy, Eastern Philosophy (Daoism, Buddha, Hindu mythology) and would really love to see you cover some Biblical stories associated with the Old Testament and Christ as a symbol of the self. Excellent work and good wishes to you!

[@Eternalised]

Thanks a lot! That means a lot to me. I'll surely explore Greek philosophy and more Eastern philosophy/Christianity in the future.

[@NegationOfNegation]

@@Eternalised I'm very much looking forward to it and what you're doing with your channel is excellent - which is compressing these complex works of art into 10 minutes. I feel when people are preyed with inattention and abundance of empty choices, you are adding something really valuable and even further by making this not only an auditory but a visual process with other arts. What I mean to say is people would be interested in reading such works but neither they have the time nor the attention and tried to be brainwashed constantly with ideological pieces, instead of something valuable and aimed at improvement.

[@Eternalised]

@@NegationOfNegation Thanks so much! This is one of my main goals with the channel, to spread other kinds of thinking, which deals really with existence and the human spirit - also to possibly inspire others to eventually read the original book by themselves, which is ultimately, the best source. :)

[@raskolnikovman936]

Have been waiting for this one for a long time! Thank you!

[@Eternalised]

Hope you like it! Thanks for the support.

[@Gandalf914]

The fact that Dostoevsky accurately predicted the horrors of the 20th Century makes him all the more profound. He was a man who was truly touched by God.

[@rodycaz8984]

There is no "god." Come on, you should know better by now.

[@uncleusuh]

@@rodycaz8984 What do you know about? You mere mortal?

[@nbeutler1134]

@@rodycaz8984 you will literally never be able to prove that there isn't lmao (nor that there is).

[@dipeshduwal3234]

Nice. Please never stop uploading. The growth of the channel might be slow, but you will get there.

[@Eternalised]

Thanks a lot Dipesh!

[@Davlavi]

This channel deserves way more likes. Keep up the great videos.

[@popystellat.7495]

Just finished this book. I love your channel! Not only do you always make a great analysis, but also use captivating art in your videos. So happy I found your work 🖤

[@T_Civ]

I love your videos! You summarize great works of philosophy and literature very well. It was great to revisit this amazing novel by Dostoyevsky through your elegant production on this video! Keep up the good work!

[@Eternalised]

Thanks so much Tomás! Appreciate the kind words!

[@PhilosophyToons]

Dope video! Razumikhin is the real bro

[@Eternalised]

Yep! Thanks friend!

[@InspirationFromThePast]

Excellent info, I did enjoyed this video a lot Dostoevsky is one of my favorite writers and needless to say Crime and Punishment is one of the best books I ever red.

[@Eternalised]

Thank you! One of my all-time favourite novels as well. The Russians have some amazing writers and thinkers.

[@InspirationFromThePast]

@@Eternalised They certainly are.

[@khemiri2663]

This channel deserves so many more subscribers. Keep it up man !

[@Eternalised]

Thank you very much!

[@joshuastevens6734]

It's a great novel and the detail of the human psyche is the greatest depiction of what it means to be human. Dostoevski analyzed what makes humans human. It a very simple analogy but that's the only way I can put this character study into words

[@gvancakupreishvili7220]

💙 This voice, clip and explanation are heartfelt. Thank you! and keep going!

[@Eternalised]

Thank you so much Gvanca!

[@AmicusNoctis]

your videos are amazing! keep it up :)

[@Eternalised]

Thanks a lot Ruben!

[@erezshahrur544]

Absolutely terrific video. Extreamly articulated

[@ANGEL-eh6pd]

I love this channel! Thank you.

[@ananyahernote7019]

I have subscribed cuz i know this channel will boom

[@matrixsena]

Your content is nothing but pure art.

[@AnhPham-kb7by]

Thanks so much for the video! Please consider a 10-minute video on Brothers Karamazov.

[@Eternalised]

You're welcome Anh! I'd love to read that book when I get the time :)

[@theproclaimer588]

Thank you.

[@Eternalised]

You're welcome!

[@klara7326]

Keep up the great work!

[@Eternalised]

Thanks Klara!

[@QueenCityFilmsComm]

Nice overview. Keep up the great work!

[@nithin1729s]

Love your content 🤗

[@renvicious]

i just finished this book and... i'm not okay

[@danielnidhiry5796]

why?

[@Dacademeca]

Great job! Gotta read this book..

[@Eternalised]

Thanks! Definitely a must read :)

[@pronateceepadm7852]

Summed it up well. In fact Fyodor Dostoyevisk wanted to show that socialist nihilism is not as powerful and strong as he thinks it is. There is a metaphor here, with Rodka as the man who seeks to be the superman, above ordinary mortals. At first, extremely materialistic, he commits murder for money and as his punishment unfolds, his conscience appears, which torments him and leads him to the true treasure, Sophia, a name whose meaning is wisdom. So he started it all in materialistic nihilism and ended it in the wisdom of faith, which brought him peace and comfort and actually indicated that he was not a superman.

[@bojackinaround8860]

I think there could be a philosophy essay that proposes the book as the thought experiment and the epilogue can be the whole analysis. PArticularly the consequence of every individual thinking and acting as Raskolnikov did at the time of the murder. I think that this "consequentialist" (?) view is what Kant proposed?

[@Sciviias]

Subscribed.

[@melodicseaweed387]

What is the title of the picture at 0:52 and who painted it? Thank you

[@Eternalised]

It's the book cover of Nolen Gertz's Nihilism and Technology, I'm not sure if he's the original author or if there's another one behind it though.

[@melodicseaweed387]

@@Eternalised Thank you very much. I've seen this picture so many times. The book sounds interesting, too, though :)

[@CidolofasOrlandu]

I totally did not think that Dmitri knew that Raskol committed the murders. Where did you find that?

[@Eternalised]

I suppose you mean Svidrigailov? He had been listening to Raskolnikov's confessions to Sonya behind doors.

[@CidolofasOrlandu]

@@Eternalised at 6:50 you say that Razumikhin realizes without a word being spoken, that Raskolnikov is guilty of the murders.

[@Eternalised]

@@CidolofasOrlandu Ah yes, that's how some interpret it. Even though there are no words being spoken. You can check out Plot Overview in Sparknotes.

[@TopLobster11]

Fun fact: Marmeladov is actually based on Dostoevsky. He was also an alcoholic and gambling addict. His daughter who died in infancy was named Sonya. And the characteristics between Marmeladov’s wife and FD’s wife are same. To know more, listen to Episode 20 of MartyrMade Podcast (it’s 5hrs long btw). It’s based on FD and Nietzsche.

Dostoyevski wasn't an alcoholic.

[@JadeHonor-n1p]

The Best THE BEST THE GREATEST THE BEST The Best

[@ajay.sehrawat]

That Pulcheria video is gonna give me nightmares.

[@tranvictor8860]

After finishing "Crime And Punishment", I wished I had a girlfriend like Sonya 😅

[@Dexter-vj2lr]

Will this be a Netflix series?🤔

[@JadeHonor-n1p]

Best The Best The Best The Best

[@gen-x-zeke8446]

I argue that philosophy does not require an education, but an awakening to the fact that it's not about what we want to know, but how to accept what we lose. *Philosophy of Brain-Loss.

[@kainlives7958]

Good story

[@YoYo-mp2tn]

Really good video. I really want to know some of your views in life

[@Eternalised]

Thanks! My views mostly tie in with "finding meaning in the pursuit of meaning". As well as exploring different kinds of philosophies: existentialism, eastern philosophy, stoicism..and psychology as well.

[@gvancakupreishvili7220]

What do U think about eastern phylosophy? A lot of people belive, that phylosophy was first introduced in Athen, so Indian and Chinese phylosophies are only beautiful myts, compared to them. 🤔🙄 Greek phylosopers were arguing, discussing, searching, thinking, but in the east existed other style and different phylosopical structure and here wasn't a place for dialectic. 😀💙

[@Eternalised]

​@@gvancakupreishvili7220 Eastern philosophy is fascinating. I believe a mix of both Western and Eastern can give us a more holistic approach to human thought. Such as Lao Tzu (Taoism), the Buddha (Buddhism) and Hinduism. I wouldn't say one is superior to the other. Although, Nietzsche famously said: “I imagine future thinkers in whom European-American indefatigability is combined with the hundredfold-inherited contemplativeness of the Asians: such a combination will bring the riddle of the world to a solution.” ​

[@gvancakupreishvili7220]

I can't don't agree with your opinion. I know, that Schopenhauer loved old indian and chinese phylosophy, Especially the Vedas, the Upanishads. Lao Tzu also was very interesting person and i think, that he was closed to Plato 😊 Thank you for shearing your personal views 😊

[@YoYo-mp2tn]

@@Eternalised how do you find meaning in the pursuit of meaning? I just turned 16 years old this year, and I really don’t like that I’m turning into a nihilist. Is there anything you can help me with? Thanks!

[@FR-yr2lo]

2:24 : the painting shows Louis XVI of France

[@justinakers3196]

3:54 thought that was a younger Ben Stiller

[@titustius6759]

is constance garret translation good

[@rustcohle733]

Spanish subtitles?

[@Eternalised]

You're right! I didn't upload them. I'll be uploading Spanish subs briefly.

[@rustcohle733]

@@Eternalised Thank you! I would appreciate it very much. My English is not very good

[@Eternalised]

@@rustcohle733 He añadido los subtítulos :)

[@rustcohle733]

@@Eternalised ¡Muchas gracias!

[@ashutoshsinghparmar8181]

Which translation is the best to read?

[@Eternalised]

The one from Michael R. Katz is fantastic (you can find a link in the description)

[@bobascalera5094]

Constance Garnett

[@johnsun11]

Some skeptics might say it is an apologetic story about russian atrocities and their lack of morality. If not the grotesque happy ending of the story I would disagree.

[@truestory2990]

Some might say you’re a moron, no one would disagree

[@erwingunther2569]

Alyona is not that evil because she looks after her sister even though she is useless just like my uncle is more then just his tyranny and violence. He is very generous and he loves his family.

[@hernehill6282]

Was Dostoyevsky also making a political statement regarding western nations (or another colonizer currently in the news)? Like Raskolnikov they rationalized elimination and theft of the 'less worthy' and anyone else that got in the way. Would Dostoyevsky see redemption of the west as impossible, given the its lack of guilt and love -- like a Jack Torrance (The Shining) character, possessed by the ghosts of the past and the banal 'obligation to fulfill his duties'?

[@Anna-jr8gu]

😍💯

[@markmcflounder15]

I gotta say that Svidrigaïlov was based on a real person. Of all the inmates he came across he found the intellectuals most disturbing. I think in his notes the real name of of Svidrigaïlov started with an A (something like Azizov). I don't have my book with me

[@jarrodyuki7081]

cao cao i would rather betray the world than have the world betray me.

[@GRZNGT]

What?! He killed that person not because of some moral dilemma, but because he owed her money. Gee, what kind of translation did you read?!

[@kristizeqo199]

Kinda but not really thats the whole point of it.

[@דוריתקפלן-כ3ת]

תרתי משמע.דורית גרץ

[@kaseybrown7664]

Aside from this novel being just horribly written (it seriously has 3 solid hours of nothing but adjectives and descriptions), there's nothing even slightly thought-provoking. What exactly is so brilliant here? . The man had a point. Some people might be better off dead. He could have killed the old woman who was only causing misery, take her money, and do a world of good with it. The *ONLY* reason this doesn't work out is that he feels guilty afterwards. What point is this making? That he could definitely have done alright if only he hadn't felt guilty? . Then he gets the hots for a chick and that "brings him back from alienation". Clearly this guy didn't have Tinder back in the day, he could have any old chick he wants if he had the right kind of game. . I simply do not understand why people think this novel is good. There's nothing philosophical here -- the only reason he failed was he felt guilty. There's nothing intellectual or poetic here either. It's an extremely simple story with an extremely simple point that's stretched unbearably long.

[@danidan2174]

It's because of nihilism, he didn't have anything to affirm himself that he did a good thing, I also has the same problem my whole life, the message here is to believe in something having something to stand on and not trying to be a nihilist, rational materialistic that only cares about value,

[@truestory2990]

Ok psycho

[@lifeisabadjoke5750]

Fr I couldn’t even finish the audio book the story is boring af. Basically is all about human perception on morality if there is no God. What it good or bad. The rest of the story is so boring. Life back in the 1800s was very dull and full of suffering everyone.

[@ninasimoan]

it is very clear and repeated again n again that rodia gave the money to the widow and not sofya yet u say the otherway. and dunyas employer was not in love but made advances on her which made her lose her job. why show lenins picture when saying dangerous ideas as if he didnt lift russian society from hellish poverty to liviable and secure state

[@ArzybgVideeoo-ng9oc]

'ischm-schism' 😑

[@ohnoes423]

napoleon

[@jarrodyuki7081]

man CAN rise above god.

[@ReiXMinako23]

Other than sliding in your own political opinion apropos of nothing, these videos are great.

A great book, a good movie, a bad video.