Vocal Coach Reacts to G.E.M 鄧紫棋 - Amazing Grace + Gloria｜LIVE on Tatler! XFEST HK vs Inter Miami CF

Рет қаралды 492,631

CZ Media

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 851

@李哲宇-x7u 9 ай бұрын

我很喜歡老師的點評每一首都是用讚美角度去欣賞歌曲給的評論都很有風度

@k778895 8 ай бұрын

這老師好厲害，還能直接把細節複製出來唱給你聽，我相信他要是想當一個嚴格的評審老師絕對很稱職，不會像一些音樂人只會說你不好，但又說不出個所以然

@TCHSIEH323 8 ай бұрын

沒感情😉

@davie0629 8 ай бұрын

不許你臭我們家花花

@cargeek3946 8 ай бұрын

听专业的点评，真是一件很幸运的事😁

@aboutschmidt0414 7 ай бұрын

專業的講評比中國好聲音那些導師好太多這才是一個導師老師的態度和精神為何現在老師的尊嚴漸漸被小屁孩無視，老師本身其實也需要負很大的責任

@mangomilkshakelol 7 ай бұрын

这个老师好屌爱了。爱了

@Steve_0618 9 ай бұрын

Amazing live performance!🎉

@stevenchen8526 8 ай бұрын

藝術就是終於自我，但也要理解他人，這位老師做到了讚

@cheercnrtangel 8 ай бұрын

忠於自我

@5464654135756 9 ай бұрын

Amazing analysis!!!

@joedythurston1551 9 ай бұрын

I'm so glad that you'll be reviewing this performance!! It probably wasn't due to my recommendation in the comments, but I am going to pretend that it is! Haha! Thank you!

@benjaminchiu2995 8 ай бұрын

每位歌手都會有其特色, 長處與短處, 曾經有專欄作家在報章上這樣寫：GEM 低音沒有蔡琴的純厚韻味, 高音沒有鄧麗君的清晰甜美溫婉, 音色沒有王菲的清晰吐字, 但有沒有一位歌手有齊以上三種特色的呢？鼻控共鳴及帶哭腔是GEM的特色, 喜歡的不覺問題, 不喜的是短處, 她能跑到今天獨特的樂壇地位, 很多路人不明白, 她靠的不止是歌唱能力, 還有廣闊的歌風（搖滾, 朋克, 說唱, 西班牙語等）, 曲詞創作, 專注音樂, 再加近年的編曲及監制, 音樂會的統籌, 可說是一位真正的音樂人, 不能簡單的說是一位歌手, 正如我們不能簡單地去評論 Jay Chou, Mayday, Beyond 等一樣；最後喜歡某位歌手, 我們會欣賞他她的優點, 不喜歡會挑剔他她的缺點, 這和做人處事一樣, 並無分別.

@judywho1210 9 ай бұрын

我懂了，Gem因為她獨特的鼻音和偶爾出現的哭腔，顯得整首歌很有感情尤其在這場災難性的足球賽之後，她的聲音很有撫慰性

@007assassins2 8 ай бұрын

她是太常用鼻音，她的技巧來來去去都那幾招，非常需要去找老師學習歌唱。

@caster18230 8 ай бұрын

並不是太常用鼻音而是她本身身體上的缺陷@@007assassins2

@purpleching2836 8 ай бұрын

@@007assassins2 你這麼厲害你來唱

@LinChihHsuanHater 8 ай бұрын

@@purpleching2836 閉嘴啦你什麼咖

@Reginald-n2e 8 ай бұрын

这首歌唱的好听的版本太多了，她这绝算不上好听的版本…

@The452135 8 ай бұрын

以前覺得gem有特色但我說不上來這老師把這個特色解釋出來了原來我是愛聽哭腔的人😂

@tom7377 9 ай бұрын

老師的分析很強，Gem剛出道就有說她偶像是Christina

@阿羅娜 8 ай бұрын

這位老師只是客觀的分析鄧的發音方式跟習慣是「刻意」而為的，怎麼一堆人跑出來一副要替鄧爆不平的感覺？影片中不只一次強調，她是用「聲樂」的理論去分析這是不合理的聲音轉換，但考慮到「藝術價值」的話對某些人來講是加分的

@hengchianli3833 8 ай бұрын

看了這麼多發現有些人如果稍微講到她們喜愛的歌手的缺點就喔開始崩潰，真的好可怕😂

@QNEd-to5yi 8 ай бұрын

明顯高低音轉化也很利害, 聽下去就知道了

@Melissatan2004 8 ай бұрын

不是没实力不是不厉害不是不好听，但真的就... 唱法一直让我觉得很「刻意」(fake) ，not my preference 我听不下去.... 🤣

@laifamily7804 Ай бұрын

老師沒有說是不合理, 她說的是她就是慣性喜歡這樣明顯的真假轉換...沒有說好還是不好, 但當然GEM要厚聲要BELT的時候就會用混聲, 只是柔聲的時候就普遍喜歡唱這樣明顯的真假轉換

@陳靜玲-f9q 9 ай бұрын

第二首歌是紫棋原創中文專集其中一首，後來整張專集又翻成西班牙語。

@Tom-ot8nk 7 ай бұрын

看到後面在找有沒有解答的回覆果然有一定要來留言感謝一下

@rho-2023 9 ай бұрын

每個歌手有自己唱歌preference, 我相信GEM已經用最好最真摯方式去表演，作為觀眾我好enjoy.

@dodoyamaha 8 ай бұрын

不要自圓其滿

@rho-2023 8 ай бұрын

@@dodoyamaha 乜嘢自圓其滿，每個歌手唱歌冇自己preference, 一定要好公式. 或者你聽開嗰啲係囉

@carmenpooh3867 7 ай бұрын

音樂是好主觀，喜歡就喜歡，討厭就討厭

@Bobozzznana 3 ай бұрын

GEM的唱歌技巧是無可奈何的，她的顎骨在發育期12歲時已經停止生長，所以舌頭為了咬字清晰不能放鬆，喉嚨的肌肉都在注意音準上，縱使身體上出現特殊情況，她不以此為藉口，愛音樂的她一直很努力的唱歌。

@謝琦琦-y3l 8 ай бұрын

我對老師的點評著迷不已啊，除了超級強大的專業做支撐還有個人魅力讓我欲罷不能❤

@NaMi-n1b 8 ай бұрын

憑藉《我是歌手》一夜爆紅的鄧紫棋因口音問題曾被誤認為是海外歌手。據悉，她之所以有如此獨特的口音是因為左邊顎骨萎縮，令上下顎牙齒不能咬合，導致說話時會漏風，但鄧紫棋並沒有要做手術的準備。每日頭條

@Sky-pi3mr 8 ай бұрын

原來是這樣啊！害我一直以為她講話時會有點大舌頭的感覺但沒那麼嚴重原來原因是牙齒不能咬合～

@silentboomber 8 ай бұрын

不说唱歌，这么一个可爱的女生说话大得陡，感觉只会更可爱

@yanzhu8741 7 ай бұрын

哦我还以为是大鞋头😅

@pwt136 7 ай бұрын

當年剛出道一直有說這個原因而影響音色說話(in香港) 而且當年她就說當特色就算了😂😂😂😂

@Alessia-x4d 5 ай бұрын

黐脷筋吧，the word “to” find it, haha, no one tells her

@yokj9081 9 ай бұрын

推薦我是歌手的歌如果沒有你，存在，你把我灌醉，存在，你不是真正的快樂

@Christyfu0126 8 ай бұрын

無法完整聽完她唱一整首歌。聽完老師分析我才恍然大悟爲什麼無法喜歡那種唱法～～😂😅

@mankitlo8235 8 ай бұрын

我也是和你一樣的感覺也很討厭 …

@耀耀-c2x 8 ай бұрын

我也不是很喜歡她那種共鳴方式

@raspberrypenny8355 8 ай бұрын

我也是, 她的歌听久了感觉很內伤, 魔音 😂

@g237210 8 ай бұрын

原來如此！我也無法聽她唱完就想轉開～並不是她唱得不好，聽到中斷會開始阿扎

@苒-s2t 8 ай бұрын

我也不喜歡他的唱歌風格，但之前一直說不上來，特地進來看老師講評才懂

@公孫月娘 8 ай бұрын

這老師很棒都是解說歌手用的技巧而不是貶低來堆疊自己專業

@是在哈囉-d4x 8 ай бұрын

她說話時的口音，是因為左邊顎骨萎縮，令上下顎牙齒不能咬合，導致說話漏風，而不是先天性舌繫帶過短症（俗稱「黐脷筋」）。醫生建議其要待21歲身體停止發育後，才適合施行手術矯正[10][138]。然而她表示，由於手術風險較大，加上21歲後，情況沒有惡化，決定暫時不會接受手術[139]。她也承認會刻意改變嘴形，讓發音更準確

@abbitr-h7g 8 ай бұрын

跟这个没有关系，她的鼻音重是自己刻意塑造的声线。如果想要咬字变的清晰，肯定是把舌头放下来，鼻音不重咬字自然就清晰了。作为流行歌手塑造非自然声线很正常，杨丞琳也是一直夹子音，张宇刻意压低喉位，华晨宇哭丧。就像海来阿木如果不采用卡痰唱法，观众也记不住。但是放松舌头和下颌一点关系都没有….一直拿这个强行解释也是有点…..还有吴青峰啥鼻中隔…..反正不得病就不能唱歌就是了…..

@alysha3861 8 ай бұрын

@@abbitr-h7g 完全沒有說過跟他的鼻音有甚麼關係，樓主在講他說話的口音，建議眼睛張大一點不要沒看清楚還要散發口臭酸別人

@abbitr-h7g 8 ай бұрын

@@alysha3861 首先不管是说话还是唱歌都是一样的，说话的口音也不会是因为所谓的下颌出问题，因为在这个语境下，所谓的口音都是在指鼻音，而鼻音只跟舌头摆放的位置有关，舌头平放在下面就不会有鼻音，舌头卷起来就会有鼻音。其次，邓紫棋粉丝出口成脏到是蛮符合刻板印象的。

@jeffreyli7993 9 ай бұрын

真誠地向團隊及老師表達謝意。常看老師的reaction video可以受益良多。真心向團隊及老師推薦So Hyang 的Bridge over troubled water/You raise me up/Oh Holy night. She’s one of the best female vocalists of our time in my humble opinion.

@cookie7362 8 ай бұрын

我也想看老師解析So Hyang的Bridge over troubled water跟Orirang!!!

@hsuan-vlog 8 ай бұрын

很棒的分析❤ 聽到amazing grace的長音那段，大家都在等哭腔還是穩定收尾，覺得很有趣😂

@maverik0615 6 ай бұрын

I became a fan of GEM's (deng ziqi, Gloria) years ago.. and have researched a lot.. and well she is basically number one star in asia and more. While it interesting to see these videos, its funny some of the things i have heard you say, such as in a previous video, you thought her team and her song writer did a great service to her.. but she is her team essentially.. she wrote, composed performed her own music. Plays many instruments from the drums, guitar, piano and more..She is an icon there. At that soccer game, there were many people there to see her as much as the game, easily. Plus she herself is a fan. Oh i wish i could tell you more, and hey write me if you want to know more.. cause she is really amazing. Yes she puts emotions into her songs because they are her. Have you heard her song, Mama?

@阿峰-c7q 8 ай бұрын

老師真的好強隨便就能描述出歌者的表達方式和能力並馬上示範演唱！老師好棒👍

@ericlo6370 9 ай бұрын

This is absolutely HER choice for sure!

@tamowen3391 5 ай бұрын

這老師的評論真的超級好 , 她從不會說不好 , 會說個人特色有人喜歡這樣等等 .....這也沒錯每個人或老師也不同不會每個人也同樣的聲線技巧去唱同一首歌 , 然後便如果是我我會這樣唱

@王世聰-j6g 9 ай бұрын

老師超棒欸非常精彩的解析

@kimfokyap1414 10 ай бұрын

期待中

@jingfei7282 10 ай бұрын

期待期待！！希望日期能挪前~

@redz9731 9 ай бұрын

Nice performance 👏 GEM ❤

@NoobCuber-si4hw 10 ай бұрын

Can't wait 🔥🔥 I am hoping and waiting for this before you announce and now you really did!!!

@chupika3421 8 ай бұрын

超愛這集，透過多次聆聽，聆聽者居然可以這麼深刻的理解歌手的藝術和詮釋。

@lilychan3383 27 күн бұрын

感覺好聽❤

@mingtsongkoh2739 9 ай бұрын

Pink is LA Galaxy team jersey colours, and David Beckham is the owner of

@FunGwoSiuMai 9 ай бұрын

She learned Spanish and released a Spanish album last year .. guess she said a prayer and thanked god at the end coz the football fans didn't boo her 😝... She came on right after the game ended, and everyone was still pissed, shouting 'refund' before she started singing

@wendycheng2337 9 ай бұрын

She did the great job for sure. 👍👍👍

@djdad2482 4 ай бұрын

GEM is a tiny powerhouse! She can blast out some tunes! So much power!

@thisyy 8 ай бұрын

amazing, love to hear your detail analysis.

@小陽光 6 ай бұрын

這集好多發音的細節分析，過癮😍

@Ciiiii-ii 8 ай бұрын

11:15 😂😂原本想看完才留言😂 實在是給這老師的形容解釋解透示範得太具體佩服到要留言👍🏻🫶🏻

@maverik0615 6 ай бұрын

what you were asking about the next song she sang at the soccer match is this.. her latest album, revelations was made in chinese (it did have some english words but primarily chinese).. and then she did it again as revelacions as a new album that was in chinese, spanish and english. Look for a live version of one more nite to see what i mean. so what you heard there was the spanish version.

@davidchoi5 9 ай бұрын

Very professional comment . Two thumbs up

@viviland620 8 ай бұрын

她獨特的唱法成就了鄧紫棋的專屬唱法，如果每個人都唱一樣任何音都要修飾圓滑就無法經營個人品牌，如韋禮安、張學友一樣，擁有辨識度高的音色對歌手來說很重要很重要，就像愛黛兒唱歌用很多嘶吼音、喉音、菸嗓音，可是這就是愛黛兒。

@maverik0615 6 ай бұрын

and that last song was Gloria.. which is her name, given to her by her grandfather, and there is more meaning for that song, and her newest tour. it has to do with her struggles from her old recording company, how they controlled her and trying to keep her stage name. to answer your question.. pink is the color of he soccer team.

@Naminator09 9 ай бұрын

G.E.M.'s songs from Chapter 1 - Gloria to Chapter 12 - The Sky she did them first in chinese and then in spanish all 12 Chapters

@tonywoo1379 5 ай бұрын

厉害，点赞梅西!

@lau0200 10 ай бұрын

我在嗶哩嗶哩也有推介這場LIVE表演，再次期待老師的真實評價👍🏻

@immortalp9p9p9 23 күн бұрын

超專業

@晏真婷 10 ай бұрын

不妨讓老師聽聽gem的rap風格的歌讓老師欣賞她的創作能力推薦幾首：句號、透明、依然睡公主、孤獨🙏

@lolahsu5677 10 ай бұрын

這比較難吧，他們主要看的是唱功，不太看詞而這幾首蠻重詞的(像上次的摩天我覺得老師不了解詞的含義就很可惜)

@changyewwong 9 ай бұрын

给老师听听受难曲

@maverik0615 6 ай бұрын

in this video you said she probably did the spanish version for this.. but now, this was created a good eight months before the soccer match.. she was inspired by god to do a spanish version of her album

@Fabio-y8s 8 ай бұрын

her nasal sound and the crying sound bother a lot of Chinese listeners, believe me!

@Peachu_n_Goma_Home 8 ай бұрын

I learned her songs but i couldnt put my finger on her singing yet when i try to learn to sing a-mei or alin i dont hv confusion. Thank you teacher for finally explaining. When i try to sing like GEM i find it very anti-flow cuz she not singing full mixed voice

@Sagepeh 8 ай бұрын

我的确是不喜欢邓紫棋的鼻音，装出来的哭腔，太多技巧的造作很油腻

@wuuu.ye520 9 ай бұрын

Please, react to her album Revelation and also Revelacíon (Spanish Version)!

@sunsun2718 7 ай бұрын

謝謝老師分析紫祺！她在短時間學會了西班牙語把她的最新創作專輯錄了一個西班牙語版本，第二首歌就是從裡面出來的❤

@itrytobehappy 8 ай бұрын

老師的講解讓我們更清楚知道歌曲唱法唱腔的特色❤希望老師之後可以點評張韶涵的舞台..

@tiffanyovo6042 8 ай бұрын

我這個唱歌負分的人第一次聽懂了什麼叫混聲😂老師教得真好

@小白-w5s 9 ай бұрын

想看老師點評一下鄧紫棋在時光音樂會這個節目唱的唯一，或者11，強推！！！希望老師能看到這條評論🥺

@olivierhe6994 5 ай бұрын

真是内行看门道，太喜欢她的点评了

@garylee840 9 ай бұрын

David Beckham’s wife is the member of Spice Girls (Victoria)

@dichow9141 9 ай бұрын

老师太强了不像国内的只是会批评就不会指出什么发音的地方~~~

@peacefulangel5124 8 ай бұрын

这是他们很好的教材

@TheMinchinist 7 ай бұрын

Very professional reaction. Love it.

@hungcat0123 8 ай бұрын

我一直都沒有很愛鄧的唱腔，原來是這樣😂

@Melissatan2004 7 ай бұрын

无意中听过她正常唱腔唱某首歌其实是有惊艳到的，可惜...在娱乐圈要红就要有特色，每次电台播她的歌我就得转台了😂

@kimfokyap1414 6 ай бұрын

你不喜欢.好多人喜欢

@jennychan3863 6 ай бұрын

我也不喜歡。

@kimfokyap1414 6 ай бұрын

@@jennychan3863 她开一场.演唱会.你们做一世.也赚不到-吊

@babylife3370 8 ай бұрын

這就是我不太喜歡鄧唱歌的原因，用太多哭腔聽的很膩，因為尾音要收細膩肌肉橫隔膜都要細微hold住，她每次都用哭腔摩擦切掉結束，這我個人喜好問題，還有我也是音樂人所以希望不要酸民來酸酸😂

@聽鄧紫棋的歌 7 ай бұрын

This is one of her performance, make me wanna cry. It is because that day, a lot of HK people were so angry, felt like being a fool, especially the people seating there. And Gem happened, she used her voice, her song, her performance to comfort people, comfort us. I literally getting heal because of her. She not just song on that day, she shaked hand, signed autograph, took photo with the people who were very upset on that day because of paying the moeny to see a guy who no showed eventually. And i like her so much and always be proud of being her fans.❤

@kld2399 8 ай бұрын

問貝克漢是誰的時候超好笑😂😂因為很認真的不認識😂😂

@Qie629 9 ай бұрын

希望老師可以看到這則留言，紫棋是因為信仰特地學西班牙語的唷❤她發音真的很標準！！

@kimfokyap1414 9 ай бұрын

十1

@Christine-si4py 9 ай бұрын

她不是基督徒，她是 ……

@christianj0726 9 ай бұрын

请问阁下是否讲西班牙语（西班牙）？我只能够听出她的西班牙语发音是西班牙发音，但是因为我不讲西班牙语所以无法判断是否标准…..个人猜测应该不会很标准，但是已经很好了（在不讲西班牙语的前提下）。我没有任何恶意，只是想确认一下阁下是否是一个European Spainsh speaker？我非常欣赏GEM的表演，是当下我最喜欢的华语歌手。

@christianj0726 9 ай бұрын

@@Christine-si4py据我所知她似乎是新教徒（Protestant)，如果有误请纠正，并且有兴趣了解一下她的信仰是什么。

@yinhei7185 8 ай бұрын

@@christianj0726 基督教

@MartinLin-d4j 8 ай бұрын

這老師真的很棒！！

@何曖 7 ай бұрын

老師真的超專業！！！

@djdad2482 4 ай бұрын

If BRUCE LEE was alive today, he would be on you tube doing this exact thing with peoples martial arts moves 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@hello-mf1hc 7 ай бұрын

超喜歡紫棋❤

@cpth1905 8 ай бұрын

鄧會唱但我卻沒有很喜歡她的聲音. 因為特殊的鼻音音色與哭腔,..對的是因為這樣

@wendy_____du 8 ай бұрын

呀！哭腔真的是特色，只是很吃受眾😅

@antoniaking2653 8 ай бұрын

我也是

@ccyang4705 8 ай бұрын

我也是

@HaHaLam126 8 ай бұрын

我喜歡她剛出道的歌和聲音，但不喜歡她後期歌用太多的特殊鼻音和哭腔。

@naruto2781 8 ай бұрын

哭到都不知道歌詞在唱什麼了😂

@喵喵-e4d 7 ай бұрын

你好能出gem的你不是真正的快乐（我是歌手第二季）吗，这首在我心目中最好的现场之一了

@RC-uw9wf 9 ай бұрын

[Gloria]MV可看性極高❤ kzbin.info/www/bejne/qaWqhqODlttkqcU si=fHB1Y8-ZuP_eAMg_

@Alessia-x4d 5 ай бұрын

Yes memorial she got it

@bilibili6910 9 ай бұрын

老師超厲害~~給讚

@gracesu6440 8 ай бұрын

这位老师太棒了。

@bythewei1245 7 ай бұрын

鄧紫棋真的好正喔>\\\\\

@音樂留聲機 8 ай бұрын

nice performance！

@TSENG666 9 ай бұрын

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

@chenzewu4671 9 ай бұрын

老師示範的是希望學唱的人學習的方式鄧紫棋那樣唱不是不好而是很難控制好要像鄧紫棋那樣唱要有非常深厚的功力所以老師一直都是在稱讚他的只是同時也要讓學唱歌的人有正確觀念

@dwmobusa 9 ай бұрын

只是每个人技术选择不一样吧，老师说出自己的教学理念也挺好，这样想唱成邓那样的人就知道理念不同，不会去跟她学了，省了一个互相折磨

@Peachu_n_Goma_Home 8 ай бұрын

你有看影片吗老师说全混声才是控制好强混打开嘴巴面罩共鸣就是会鼻音你听老师唱歌不会卡鼻音是舒服的如果你说你就是喜欢挤卡声ok但是不要黑白讲

@bao4755 10 ай бұрын

點評這場前應該先了解Gem 承受多少壓力來唱這首歌因為美斯沒有在這場表演賽出場所有觀眾都大喊退錢退票就是gem 的歌聲來安撫他們的情緒

@dwmobusa 9 ай бұрын

re的过程中有解释，更何况她唱歌选择用何种技术跟这个并没有什么关系

@peggy4374 9 ай бұрын

不用特別去了解吧點評唱歌技巧我覺得直接聽最真實有時前置太多反而會先入為主

@julie18237 9 ай бұрын

这是粉丝自己的事情。

@bao4755 9 ай бұрын

對不起因為我在這re 開播前留言的🙏 只是覺得壓力會影響發揮而已謝謝各位利申：不是粉絲

@fusaikeung 8 ай бұрын

點評之前說了怎樣點評？說了之後第二首歌都沒什麼評語了難道老師沒感情的嗎你到底有沒有看一整段片

@meilunyu 10 ай бұрын

感谢老师💜！！感谢杰凯💜！！感谢你们的团队😊

@Ka-vh9tm 7 ай бұрын

Amazing music teacher

@fiona104 8 ай бұрын

老師音感很強，一直覺得鄧紫棋個子小肺活量很強，但鼻音很重的部分，有種擠壓感，我比較難欣賞，但這就是她的特色，可能也是其他能欣賞的人喜歡的部分；不可否認她很有歌唱實力，也長得可愛。

@龜龜毛毛的 8 ай бұрын

同意你

@陳有賀 8 ай бұрын

很棒的老師，很棒的講解

@卡普-g6v 7 ай бұрын

這位音樂界的包青天😂

@lorenzoxiong2611 9 ай бұрын

音樂本就可以是很主觀的東西，我就更喜歡GEM這種，倒是對JJ無感--無論他出道還是現如今。就像我也不喜歡這位老師的一貫唱法，但不代表老師不好或不對。😛

@jeffw2672 9 ай бұрын

其實我也想的一樣。我覺得R這位老師雖然很會唱，但很難感動我，感覺就是匠氣很重。

@dwmobusa 9 ай бұрын

就是听个技术分析而已呀，喜欢是很个人的东西，只要不因为喜欢的点不一样而互相攻击就行了

@fragrantsnow1495 9 ай бұрын

GEM唱歌技巧很差，哭腔跟鼻腔泛濫，除了巨肺和可以飆高音，她真的還好，感情投入的話一堆歌手完爆她

@lorenzoxiong2611 9 ай бұрын

@@fragrantsnow1495 好不好市場決定，正因為她這種技巧單一反而顯得不太矯揉造作，符合現代modern審美。現代人沒有那麼多耐心去靜下來聆聽一個歌者的內心世界，他們更傾向於聆聽節奏與動律，以適配和緩解城市給人的高度緊張感。GEM的這些單一的唱法唱腔其實聯動起來就像固定的節拍器在洗腦。這也是為何像這位老師說的，遠在大城市紐約的老師就會教她的學生像GEM那樣唱歌，而她是不認同的。

@magic32v7182 9 ай бұрын

老師的唱功實力比鄧更好！我喜歡這位老師的唱腔！

@cwchan3911 9 ай бұрын

All the hk people inside the Hong Kong Stadium enjoy the performance of G.E.M.

@hgalactic5185 8 ай бұрын

her spanish version sounds good - G.E.M. - Gloria (Official Video) | Revelación

@Annasssw 9 ай бұрын

Gem created a Spanish version of her album ‘Revelation’ which has a slight difference compare to the Chinese version but not much.

@maverik0615 6 ай бұрын

it was not half time.. that was before the game and then she watched the game.

@5468621 8 ай бұрын

😂她很有人氣很紅可是我偏偏就是聽不了她的歌總覺得...很刻意然後很想表現然後不在乎聲音到底好不好聽跟順不順耳就像台灣曾經很紅的煎熬他喵的我聽了真的很煎熬...

@Peachu_n_Goma_Home 8 ай бұрын

你说的很对可是华语很少游走A4-D5的歌除了GEm比较新不然就是唱Amei所以我练混声会唱她的歌一直有一种奇怪感感谢老师分析😊

@leemichael736 8 ай бұрын

是的, 除了vocal power 的能力, 其實聲音的質地voice texture更為重要。後者是否足夠好很多時候看歌手在唱低音就能大概判斷出來。一首好歌的起承轉合過程中需要用到不太用力至用力的部份, 其中用力部份需要恰到好處才算出色。以上纯個人看法和感受。

@somichan7963 8 ай бұрын

你一定喜歡自然的❤❤不刻意做出來的比較喜歡😃😃

@Christyfu0126 8 ай бұрын

同感😂 我也無法完整聽完她唱一整首歌。聽完老師分析我才晃然大誤爲什麼無法喜歡那種唱法～～

@relaxchilloutwithmusicsoun6182 8 ай бұрын

事實是香港冇咩人鐘意聽她。香港人工作忙壓力大，不會聽她這種充滿壓迫感的演釋，也不喜歡聽唱腔“好嘈”的歌手。

@benita56 9 ай бұрын

想讓老師聽一下李宗盛山丘

@lk1872 9 ай бұрын

點解唔俾Mirror表演果段俾老師睇🤣

@leungkimman4580 9 ай бұрын

因為怕醜出香港

@alysa1220 9 ай бұрын

可以給老師看看啓示錄音樂連續劇

@danfans 10 ай бұрын

Thanks❤

@cooloud77 9 ай бұрын

Gem的發音特色應該源自於天生生理缺陷發展而來的

@rho-2023 9 ай бұрын

什麼缺陷，GEM唱歌音準完全冇問題，很好聽，有辨識度，每個歌手都有其特點，否則就唔會紅，就好似老師教人唱歌，都應該要知道！

@gyfyy52 8 ай бұрын

@@rho-2023 她說話時的口音，是因為左邊顎骨萎縮，令上下顎牙齒不能咬合，導致說話漏風，而不是先天性舌繫帶過短症（俗稱「黐脷筋」）。醫生建議其要待21歲身體停止發育後，才適合施行手術矯正[10][138]。然而她表示，由於手術風險較大，加上21歲後，情況沒有惡化，決定暫時不會接受手術[139]。她也承認會刻意改變嘴形，讓發音更準確，没人说GEM唱不好，但作为粉丝这应该知道吧？说生理问题没毛病，是事实啊

@rho-2023 8 ай бұрын

@@gyfyy52 這個我也是知道，我只是不認同這會影響她唱歌，我知道你好意，想跟人講GEM有呢個缺陷，但我覺得不是這樣，他發音特色係自己練習出來！

@inspectorw5795 7 ай бұрын

@cooloud77 你算把啦！你听一下她16岁时比赛的錄音好吗？那时可没这么难听！

@rho-2023 7 ай бұрын

@@inspectorw5795 現在比當時好很多，高低音都好好聽