WHAT IF: Doggy Never Died...?

in this roblox piggy animation I will show you my theory on what would happen if doggy never dies in the chapter forest.

[@llethum]

“What if DOGGY never DIED?” Doggy : *dies*

[@ViciousBee_Return6969]

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO TRUE

[@khrisjoe3946]

Literally

[@quinteriaethridge5463]

I was about to say that.

[@Ablissy]

Yup so trueee

[@andytoonanime]

Hey, you copied my comment

[@Linxyc]

Imagine this as a serie.

[@mixsnoof]

We need that like for real

[@1G1NE_haha]

Antflix better be making a "What if?".

[@piggeh4057]

2:09 Doggy: I will hold them off while u guys run. Foxy: *causally holding a knife in the background.*

[@geometrydashmhaeztheprogam7379]

He looks like hes baout to stab player

[@prozaifr]

LMAO

[@Justbored8783]

Mr P has plasma shooter...

[@ElGoblino331]

‏‪2:40‬‏

[@vulcanx8769]

Doggy still died so it should be "If Doggy was not infected in the forest?" That sounds better

[@emmamcsomething9595]

Also, why is a police officer fighting the military!?

[@GreatRamilYT]

@@emmamcsomething9595 they have different interests, zombie apocalypse after all

[@jaxdagamer7594]

This truly shows how easy it would be to end the infection with Doggy around. Loved the animation btw. Edit:wow 35 likes ? Tysm everyone!

[@Mister_F]

Bruh so we forgot about Bunny?

[@tomatosoup1589]

@@Mister_F yup pretty much. Because doggy survived.

[@LimitWIS]

This wouldnt even happen lol its too unrealistic, but still cool

[@nanyombiteddy8837]

It wouldn't end like this

[@nanyombiteddy8837]

@@Mister_F bunny got too much attention

[@Zach12663]

love how players just keeping hold of that gun

[@farofonalegal6388]

E o doggy gastar imunição para morre pro rato

[@daymare6703]

2:38 DANCE FOR ME, DOGGY!!!

[@miserablenoob7689]

The mouse:*shot doggy and keep shotting for no reason*

[@thethreehomies4430]

It’s mary

[@Mosylla]

@@thethreehomies4430 It’s not.

[@julzronin4773]

@@thethreehomies4430 the mouse with Monroe isn’t Mary, Mary got infected as seen in the camp map

[@thethreehomies4430]

@@julzronin4773 oh yeah I forgot😂

[@CheeserMeo]

@@julzronin4773 It's pretty much nameless for us, so we will just call it a "Mouse". Cause Minitoon haven't said anything yet lol.

[@Navernous]

Is anybody gonna talk about how with Doggy you can speed run Book 1 And skip like 8 chapters….

[@vonnygowin8972]

Is nobody gonna talk why bunny is not there

[@CleetusMcDingus]

@@vonnygowin8972 shes trapped at school forever

[@bullyman5895]

@@CleetusMcDingus bunny: how could this happened to me i have made a mistake

[@tridianaambarwati1881]

I think theres another teacher that help her (i Will name it Mr.Duolingo lol )

[@MRBKcool20]

My idea is what if Bunny never die

[@spinorexrawr]

This would be great if that happened, Doggy is awesome! Your animations are the best :DD The end tho :(

[@Nakicky]

I hope he adds the other part but this is my theory: Everyone goes to find Doggy and saw he got shot. Mr.P takes him to the hospital and helps Doggy and he is alive

[@user-kg8fr3pk7e]

What if someone actually make piggy the alternate universe where there are some universe like if doggy did not die or george infected or not met pony and zizzy if the player was infected

[@ImpossibleKrahs]

Sgt Monroe: Come out, we know you have the cure. Doggy: Make us! Sgt Monroe: I have a water gun and I dont wanna use it!

[@lubbyaguilar9815]

The fact that the insolence didn't even rise when doggy didn't die.

[@user-mc4oz8th7k]

It wouldn't dare lol

[@Haroonsfunlife]

Alternative title: if we never met bunny and pony was never a good character

[@shadooooooostayss]

@@millowtoon9030 Firstly, willow forced pony to give the potion to DOGGY and PLAYER because THEY ruined HER life. AND BUNNY DID NOTHING.

[@millowtoon9030]

@@shadooooooostayss Ik

[@being10158]

AYO, PONY DEAD

[@millowtoon9030]

@@being10158 sus

[@TheAlwaysSillyOne]

What you doing here harpoonsbaddead

[@TotallyNormalHandle]

“ woah .” caught me deadass laughing

[@significancedry6627]

Idea: What if Mr. Stitchy was a good guy? This would basically be following the Book 1 timeline, and will actually have TIO corrupting Mr. P and start the Infection. Since Mr Stitchy first appeared in the Forest Map for the Halloween event, we can possibly assume the player meets Mr. Stitchy right after escaping the Forest, helping the player out by taking out and infected or any possible threats to the player like T.S.P or any other threat that TIO might throw at us. Edit: Mr. Stitchy COULD already possibly be a good guy to do the end of the Distraction Chapter Escape cutscene, but what I'm trying to say is what if Mr. Stitchy DIDN'T start the infection and appeared earlier in the timeline that we expect

[@el_Capitan_Dorado]

Mr Stitchy IS a good guy.

[@ForgedSteel2562]

@@el_Capitan_Dorado he was just controlled by too. Edit: darn autocorrect I meant Tio

[@aidan_metallix72]

Mr. Stitchy isn't canon

[@significancedry6627]

@@aidan_metallix72 Mr Stitchy is mostly likely canon, due to the Distraction Chapter revealing that TIO had a friend, and around the Book 1 maps, it says on secret notes that Mr. Stitchy had a friend that gave him a face, and it only would've made sense that Mr. Stitchy and TIO were friends before, making Mr. Stitchy canon. This means TIO gave Mr. Stitchy a face. Also, the secret notes I'm talking about are STILL inside the Book 1 maps, even after 1 one year of them being added in for the Halloween event.

[@kai_v248]

I always have an animation in my head about the hidden ending, in there, Mr Stitchy is in inside your body helping you. (It will look like there is insolence on your right like a half insolence half normal.)

[@elpapachicho5992]

2:08 Foxy is like: hello, hello hello, i want to be famous with davebb

[@PiggyMasterY]

Or he is just a psychopath

[@theapparentlymark6734]

Legend says the mouse is shooting his gun still to this day

[@spookyidk3438]

lol

[@billcipher817]

1:36 fun fact: i made an skin for me in piggy intercity, and its the doggy in that scene when doggy is in the lab.

[@ziyanggan3381]

Everyone: *holds a actual M16* Monroe: W A T E R G U N

[@ImpossibleKrahs]

the power of water is truly inevitable

[@ziyanggan3381]

@@ImpossibleKrahs indeed

[@ViciousBee_Return6969]

Damn I Could Drink Up

[@c0smic2189]

Water knocked out willow or tigry in lab

[@aaronmmch]

Actually it would have been perfect if they went to mall at some point, that way you two could have completed the investigation in wich all started and georgie could have seen penny

[@henrytoycollector7115]

Yeah that would’ve been an interesting scene. Although Georgie is still with them you can see him in the plant scene.

[@aaronmmch]

Oh right i didnt even notice him

[@lenjen11]

Marker.

[@lenjen11]

@the gravity loomian its Georgie now not 'George'

[@flaming_mc]

technically, doggy didn't die. he got infected, and if we were to give him the cure, he would be back. edit: wtf 41 likes edit again: what is this 100 likes

[@nitroblaze6696]

Well technically they are like zombies

[@Zeil250]

Technically the infected are not zombies, they are puppets of the infection, the infected are aware that they are doing it but they cannot stop because the virus does not allow them conclusion: the virus controls its hosts

[@DoggyDNPATI]

What if the player shot him in the forest?

[@carpz4724]

True

[@carpz4724]

@Alif Arman Ziauddin No mr tio made you see ghost bunny and doggy cause hhow would you see ghost?

[@nokiagamer7744]

2:28 When went to mine a cave in minecraft:

[@Zyxl-]

The fact the soldier kept shooting even after he died. Tbh that ending would be way sad than Pony getting infected, as Pony can still be saved and we prefer Doggy. (Actually the storyline we live in is good, because we can save both Pony and Doggy when the cure gets reworked)

[@someminecraftwardenfan1526]

I am sure she is shooting the ceiling of the helicopter

[@Thesecondspy]

I think he was scared and kept shotting cause he was scared

[@FINGIEMAN]

How? They have no boat. Budgey probably left them and willow and tigry took the boat back to alleys so they can’t get the others that are across the sea.

[@stary-w-8925]

@@Thesecondspy He? That soilder is called Mary and she eis comfirmed to be a female soldeir from piggy Wiki

[@Prismgameduo]

@@stary-w-8925 no it isnt mary mary is infected

[@d_akanneriukku130]

Doggy is our faithful friend, he is our faithful friend. And if one day you find yourself far, far, from your beautiful home. Close your eyes and remember that he is your faithful friend :D I realize that he is very intelligent and thus many disasters could have been avoided :0 And Bunny? They abandoned her xd

[@yst_3MK]

و doggy صديق و في و مخلص ايضن

[@-gitchy-2672]

Yeah

[@fourbfb9358]

Right but bunny is still our friend

[@-gitchy-2672]

Yep

[@yst_3MK]

@@fourbfb9358 ادري بسسسسسس ما احس فادتنا اكثر من Doggy

[@Heres_CHUCKY.4.22]

Amazing alternate universe I really like the part whene the player gets willows gun and shots pony 🔫😂

[@light_37m]

Yes I am happy we got someone that use play piggy now watch chucky s that’s why I do

[@miroslavsamek2816]

Can we give respect to Pony?

[@light_37m]

@@miroslavsamek2816 nah he not real so no

[@miroslavsamek2816]

@@light_37m Rude, i give respect atleat for Pony.

[@light_37m]

@@miroslavsamek2816 I don’t he not real and I am not rude

[@isaiahruiz4176]

I actually wish minitoon made a second piggy game and this is the whole story and we still have doggy alive and foxy on our side. That would be amazing

[@jammingteller5482]

*book 2…*

[@marionwatkins8329]

FAN GAME MAKERS WHERE ARE YOU

[@FredyPlayz]

Piggy Intercity, maybe we will foxy and doggy roaming around, and when we get the cure we can save them both

[@1G1NE_haha]

@@marionwatkins8329 HERE I've made fan piggy game Piggy: the lost chapters

[@nanyombiteddy8837]

@@FredyPlayz nah we saved zizzy and foxy nah he's not even a side character we don't care about him doggy hmm he may have a chance

[@retwgyiopppop5670]

Hey Dave, you should make a full on piggy movie or even a fan made game with this animation style, that would get you a bunch of likes and views ;) also keep up the good work!

[@Imcoolandepic]

Yeah like the lore but it’s actually a movie

[@dipsydarbuckle3458]

To be honest if this happened I would be shocked, in order for him to stay alive you don't give him any bones to fight the infected Edit: 20 Likes?! Thanks for the support guys

[@Blocles]

Amazing work as always!

[@theendlessone3460]

Dude I love all of your animations but this was one of the best

[@AhYesItsMada]

It would be amazing if someone made this as a game!

[@jaundoce]

I love how the Player has an actual gun but SGT. Monroe has a squirt gun.

[@darksunday3012]

I think there should've been a little bit when willow and doggy met up as in convincing but other than that it was really good

[@crisbellquitting6395]

THIS IS A WORK OF ART!!!

[@alievahmat5730]

Dude the animation...You improved so much!

[@rainbgalax1307]

Doggy:*Doesn't get infected* TIO:oh well *disappears*

[@JennieKimzx]

Cool video Bro Love the animations Very unique love how doggy is different so is zizzy

[@helioigoralbuquerquefilho1493]

Doggy is my favorite character, so this timeline would be awesome

[@corvettemf]

I Love This Dave! This is amazing animation so great for me to watch! :)

[@silverbronzeee]

I thought of this yesterday and now theres a video about it. And your version is much better and i cant breathe. Like

[@no_one6495]

At the last one the mouse soldier shooting up but its still get doggy me : WHAT AIMBOT?

[@no_one6495]

@@Allasko101 Hmm maybe

[@no_one6495]

@@Allasko101 lol

[@wizaslol]

The end of doggy. The best character. It’s too late to save him.. R.I.P Doggy 2009-2020

[@progamerYTbes]

He tragically died by a final blow to his head by a superior hardened gun. not the bullet, the gun.

[@SharkManTheAngryShark]

f

[@Wwilliamrandm]

How do u know he’s was 11 when he what he’s young

[@nevrmore.suspicous]

Omg well done that was epic man!!

[@ayanaziz2919]

Zizzy really forgot about pony💀💀💀

[@adoringlyxaay8862]

this animation is amazing. I rate it a 10/10. but can u do if bunny never died? Add doggy in the story too. tbh if doggy didn’t die, we wouldn’t have to go in this entire mission.

[@vonnygowin8972]

Best alternate ending: dont let doggy die by saying "wake up" Edit: wheres bunny

[@andyesquivia7965]

Piggy Unstable Reality: cool! Time to add this in my game :)

[@ItzVelocityy]

Do WHAT IF: Pony never left TSP

[@valentin73474]

Title: What if Doggy never died The end: *doggy dies*

[@thaMonkeKing]

What If Idea :- What if.... Daisy Never Left Willow.

[@DummyTestPlayz]

Lol i love how that guy shot in a up wall lol

[@Humi405]

DANG THIS ANIMATION IS SMOOTH!

[@snoopybear0101]

2:39？？？？

[@maruaechegaray282]

Doggy:*doges* Mary:looks up* Hmmmmm Doggy:jumps* Doggy:OH SHOO- *dies* Mary: that was easy also why am I shooting the air

[@jennifersantillan7419]

Dang, he improved so much! It's so smooth now!

[@PIGGY4EVS]

I love the fact pony got shot in the head at the beggining but later on he was back and alive lol

[@zundermoon3750]

I will never forget his words in the ending of Gallery . . .

[@MaxGamerFun]

How is foxy still not infected? Willow locked him up in a cage because he was infected.

[@ElCloverfachero]

nope,remember the sewers?,willow found foxy in the sewers,so as a sentence she lock him in the carnival

[@Aang_the_avatar]

This guy shows us marvel what if.. but in piggy. Man I love this guy

[@ingridjitzabeth]

these animations are so amazing and Masterpiece and if Doggy was alive so I guess is the different story

[@hankgato-.-6694]

0:55 el hacker

[@RealSnuuy]

0:10 Noooooo!!!!! Pony!!!! Anyways

[@PowerupGamer4]

This was more of funny then serious lol but this was great.

[@Phase2act]

Georgie and Bunny: wait who are we in this alternate timeline

[@swher8333]

1:50 Hold up… the code is an L…

[@_pemula.]

I'm just saw Monroe slap mary with his gun 😂😂😂

[@kacklin74]

Legend has it that Mary is still firing the gun

[@ChillzPlaysThis]

U did a good work on this video and I loved when doggy was holding an axe and willows gun and he killed SGT And saved penny

[@edgylearner9249]

Davey, you know that hoods aren't attached to people's heads, right? Why did Foxy's hood move along with his head instead of his torso?

[@CheeserMeo]

no idea, it's just an animation dud. Why needs to be that detailed when you need to post animations a lot bruh.

[@edgylearner9249]

@@CheeserMeo Because it's hard not to see.

[@elpapachicho5992]

0:40 Spider-Wolf Spider-Wolf

[@nokiagamer7744]

2:03 I like how sgt monroe have toy gun

[@knightrider7349]

seeing doggy running towards the helicopter shooting is sad but the music is even sadder man this guy makes better sad stuff than minitoon

[@Meme-gn2md]

I love this video but I still kinda have a few questions on it like why would Mr.P leave the hospital if the player was not there to make him think The Player and Bunny are infected?

[@Meme-gn2md]

Another question is would the group meet up with Kona? And where was Sheepy when they were at the forest think she would have heard the gun shot

[@NAUFALPR]

Is alt so that mean mr p just leave bunny and bunny infected in metro just like piggy story but bunny never meet player

[@Meme-gn2md]

@@NAUFALPR But if that was true then how did Bunny get out of the school the player was the one who freed her

[@NAUFALPR]

@@Meme-gn2md maybe mr p save him or she escape but we dont know how bunny get out maybe kick door or mr p help us or bunny never stuck in school but she stuck in hospital but doggy and player dont see bunny

[@Meme-gn2md]

@@NAUFALPR No we do know how Bunny got out the Player used a book to open her door and she escaped but in this we never met her in that universe

[@shinhayu11037]

To be honest, this should have been what happened, since Doggy was a character that had huge potential, but all he got was 3 chapters and appearances in the endings. Also i don't like Bunny

[@angelthefunnyguy1yt]

I don’t like bunny either lol

[@Mister_F]

He only had two ending cutscences

[@izaclee6497]

we dont like bunny because we are not like stupid simps

[@angelthefunnyguy1yt]

@@izaclee6497 actually for me, it’s because she almost does nothing and she’s almost completely useless in the story.

[@Rytisroblox]

I like the new attires that you gives doggy and the others

[@deepikasoni5475]

I love the sound in 0:01 it's funny it's like a high pitch pew. Lol

[@Badwifiman8887]

Two forgotten characters for doggy and player to find bunny and George why would you leave the child tho :(

[@F1ndyyllkz]

Georgie was actually with them at the plant if u didn't notice

[@maruaechegaray282]

@@F1ndyyllkz yea I saw the bean

[@geometrydashmhaeztheprogam7379]

@@F1ndyyllkz but theres 1 is missing

[@Mister_F]

I don't think a military guard would easily take Doggy down

[@UniqueNarwhaI]

He was unarmed after throwing his axe at the bear, and the mouse had a gun and he managed to shoot doggy before he got the mouse, doubt he can survive multiple bullets in his head and chest.

[@Mister_F]

@@UniqueNarwhaI I know he was unarmed but he could of literary dodged the Mouse guard by using some of his moves.

[@UniqueNarwhaI]

@@Mister_F thing is, a bullet can go extremely fast, there’s barley anyone who can dodge one, which is the same case as doggy

[@BIGFUNNYMAN1]

Plz more piggy what if videos i don,t care how long it takes I just hope this can become a full series

[@damianpoplolly5004]

The end is so funny 😂 and the way Mari just shoots then continues shooting

[@brubthegrub5219]

0:40 be like: *Willow the glitcher!*

[@javiscarson]

1:20 tsp:ima just squat down with one knee because I can

[@Nicolas_Silva]

Bro this animations is sick

[@srilaasya3935]

I love the way doggy says 'potato we need ur help'

[@sus_king3899]

I love it can you do TIO’s story

[@TheNecrozmatic_Reborn]

666 likes sheesh also this is such a good animation keep the work up - Earned sub -

[@kennythegamer7662]

Hello can you make part 2 its such a nice movie dude!

[@JunkPlaysgamer]

LOL! I LAUGHED SO HARD WHEN SEEN SGT. Monroe BRING A WATER GUN

[@ethanalfonso2291]

I love your videos so much its so cool and merry christmas 🎁🎄❤️ Edit: and the last part mary killed doggy 😢😭

[@deshaunpatton5444]

LOL I just remembered rat what if show, this reminds me off it.

[@im_aceBD]

Insane animations!

[@nikilo876]

I really like this view point from what would be happend with doggy alive, no what one can think it, i was a really diferent story with much emotions including the happy one, and the sadly one, a really worked animation, but the final was very confused and sad, but really coolllll!!!!

[@republica_doyago-2023]

The mouse: *shots doggy and Keeps Shoootin' for no reason* Doggy: I'm down here, idiot

[@--PhamThieuNam]

Doggy: *Speedrun Chapter 6 -8 - 11* *Bunny, Teacher, Beary, Mousy and Robby: WhY We StiLl HeRe... JUst AnotHEr SuFfeR...*

[@Ironmanmax18]

Fun fact doggy was our first friend we experienced in piggy

[@manusia8368]

You should make more what if content dude 👍

[@josuemartinez9643]

The mouse soldier kept shooting upwards lol and Sargent Monroe had a water gun.

[@disruptive_artist]

Doggy and player: ruins willows life Willow:prepare to unalive Doggy we need your guns and stuff we r going north Willow:north? Also willow: NICE. MODE. ACTIVATE

[@maruaechegaray282]

Can you also make what if rash never went to Leo washer room?

[@Danskio]

Amazing animation! For real