Game Composer Reacts to GEHRMAN THE FIRST HUNTER - Bloodborne

[@DaviVasc]

Well, turns out that last build up was not a fake after all. That is what I get for thinking I had the music all figured out haha By the way, make sure the check out the videos I did on Dark Souls music if you haven't already: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lXKum4Cnnapgo6s

[@satitlertritsumpun8930]

A great but sad thing I've seen perple described this song is "two people, who care for one another, try to mercy kill each other. One, Gehrman, don't want you to meet the same fate as he is. Another, you, want to release your mentor from the torment he has endured for far too long.

[@Lulu-ex7fc]

When you have a chance, could you check out King of the Shingai, or Requiem (English version) from Code Vein?

[@albinogingerblackman7739]

The Latin choir in the theme becomes even more sad if you translate what they say. Its a plea for freedom from Gehrman's perspective, he's quite literally begging someone to free him but he would rather suffer alone forever than subject your hunter to his fate

[@hermitcard4494]

Do Lady Maria's theme. Next Cleric Beast FIRST and then Lawrence.

[@MisterK-YT]

Can you make a video about how similar this song is (or isn’t) to this kzbin.info/www/bejne/roCuYZqoiJ2ffas

[@Frazer2]

To Gehrman this is a literal death wish, the final fight. He doesn't want to kill you, but He doesn't want you to suffer the same fate He is suffering. Yet He definitely wants to die, It's all conflicted. He doesn't know what He wants.

[@Frazer2]

He's scared, that's all I'm feeling.

[@damobeck1]

Death is freedom and he wants you to be free.

[@pedroscoponi4905]

But he also definitely, on some level, wants to die and be free from the Nightmare... even if that means some other poor fool needs to suffer in his stead.

[@theshoe17]

I've always felt he wants to be free from the dream but his willingness to save you is stronger so he fights true until there is nothing left from him

[@MikeHesk742]

The player-character may or may not be aware at this point, but from Gehrman's point of view this is a fight to see who'll be enslaved by the Moon Presence. He's giving it all he's got to save you from that fate, even though he wants to be free himself.

[@theclown5763]

Wow, it's so incredible to see people who have never played Soulsborne describe the music of the boss and they're basically describing the lore of this Boss.

[@KaminariHouse]

Shows how masterfully the Soulsborne music is composed.

[@river7874]

This video is proof of why Bloodborne is considered a masterpiece.

[@latiaos11]

THATS WHY BLOODBORNE SHOULD HAVE WON OST OF THE YEAR AND THEY WERE R O B B E D

[@khalidpapa6299]

@@latiaos11 who cares about awards? What game Won that award even? I don't know and I don't care. but fromsoftware games will be remembered for I long time believe me.

[@proudfirebrand3946]

@@khalidpapa6299 Aye, what was it? the accolade of the crowds? or the tears of those whove picked up the controller? Doesn`t matter.... It will always be the pain that cuts deep that will leave scars to be remembered, a reminder for all through time..

[@eaterofchickens5438]

"Oh, Laurence... Master Willem... Somebody help me... Unshackle me please, anybody... I’ve had enough of this dream... The night blocks all sight... Oh, somebody, please" - A victim of the Eldritch Truth

[@KalaamNozalys]

To me, that song has 2 components: -Gherman's leitmotif, the lonely melancholic one. Looping over and over it is his eternal loneliness, trapped as the overseer of the Hunt. Having lost all those he cared about, slowly going mad and apathetic. The counterpoint also echoes at how old this whole charade is by now, how long ago it started for him. -The repetitive motif that comes back several time. This is the Hunt, the Dream that always come back like a looming, foreboding cycle. Those build ups might be periods where another hunter challenged Gherman, being a note of hope for him to be released from his duty, only to be extinguished by his own blade. That last one that does turn out to not be a fake out though, I think this might be all the Hunters' voices, or at least the ones who marked our Hunter's journey. That final ray of hope that pierce through the nightmare when Gherman is close to being vanquished, and by that: woken up from the dream.

[@williamfreeman8624]

Goddamn this was a great write-up. Thanks for sharing, dude.

[@KalaamNozalys]

@@williamfreeman8624 Thank you.

[@everforward5561]

Even the final chorus stanza reflects this. "Hunter, who hold in awe the abyss But you are never supposed to be a scapegoat I would swing this scythe once again, to offer an end to your nightmare But please, give me an end to my role."

[@KalaamNozalys]

@@everforward5561 Thanks for the transcription :)

[@DaviVasc]

This was great. Thank you for sharing your interpretation.

[@MightyMyna]

Almost like someone being put to rest, finally at peace, after so much suffering.

[@HEROm7]

Exactly

[@LiloDemon]

The song is a Requiem, so it fits well not only by the faight, but also the scenario helps to put it.

[@chereborn2525]

When I hear this theme I keep visualizing when Skull Knight from Berserk will finally rest after years and years of hunting down apostles and godhands alone and now with Guts and crew.. As Skull Knight looks at Guts his last word will be "Fare thee well struggler" RIP Kentaro Miura 1966-2021.

[@Funnyguyfive]

Put these foolish ambitions to rest - Margit

[@sharonwong5688]

Out of all the 'final' bosses from FromSoft, this is the saddest for me. Even when you aren't clear on the backstory or lore there's an undeniable tone in the presentation alone which makes you question 'why am I feeling sad?' And then you find out more about Gehrman and it just makes it even more tragic.

[@redlfclegend24]

I love this one, it’s my favorite soulsborne boss, however I felt more sadness with Gwyn as a final boss. The music was so surprisingly simple and different from the Rest, still perfectly defined Gwyn in his hollowed state and let you question your whole journey up to this point.

[@iruga7379]

Not gonna lie...i tear up a bit with the song...i was like...''why am i crying ?''

[@professorgrimm4602]

FromSoft often does the "now kill this old guy" for the final boss, but it was something different in Bloodborne. The final boss fight in Bloodborne is not about the fate of the world, it's just two hunters wanting to free each other.

[@whyareyouhere6274]

@@professorgrimm4602 Is bloodborne friendly to beginners early on? My only souls game was elden ring, so i don't exactly know what other games are like

[@OldHunterLight]

@@whyareyouhere6274 yes, it is fairly friendly, it is still my fav soulsborne game, the only issue for newer players is farming a few things here and there but most can be purchased and chalice dungeons reward you with a few other things, I'm avoiding spoiling it to you.

[@river7874]

Gherman wants to be free from the Hunter's Dream and an endless night. He doesn't want to kill you, but he must because of the being that has enslaved him. Everyone he knows is long dead, and their spirits/souls are stuck in an endless blood filled nightmare. You, as the Good Hunter, just want answers as to what's going on and to be free of the Hunt. When you die in the Hunter's Dream, you wake up and forget everything. And you never dream again. By killing Gherman, you free him from an endless nightmare, and finally allow him to rest. I'm really glad that you covered this one, the music really portrays the emotions and lore behind the fight perfectly. One very old hunter who has gone insane from loneliness and death, who is trapped in an endless nightmare. One fresh hunter, curious for knowledge and answers, half-cut with blood and in their prime. It's a fight to free the Original Hunter from his shackles versus a fight to stop a young hunter from the same fate as the Original Hunter. Bloodborne is a masterpiece. Can't wait to see if Elden Ring is going to have the same amazing score.

[@dawson3776]

The Menu Theme already sets up a tone.

[@Xalocin]

Judging by what we’ve heard in the latest network tests, yes. Elden Ring is gonna sound just as good

[@immortaldragon935]

I mean if you told him you have eyes on the inside he might’ve not fought but only if you went for that ending and the MP might have forced him anyway.Gherman also might not know what it means I suppose.

[@hermitcard4494]

But even slaved by the Moon Presence, he KNOWS he has a duty as a hunter to hunt beasts... Supposedly any sane person would suffer in the Bloodborne nightmare, and that's why he offers the player the mercy he is denied. The character instead has "enjoyed" the nightmare and wants to continue to shred blood, and this is the beginning of becoming like Gascoigne. Gherman realizes this and proceeds to hunt you and free you from the Hunter's Dream(or nightmare), but he fails.

[@immortaldragon935]

@@hermitcard4494 “””spoilers”””””you right but what I mean is if he knows you have used three third umbilical cords considering he has gone through many hunts and was the first hunter he might know what they do and realise that you can kill the moon presence

[@gaijinhunter]

I am so happy you did this one as it's one of my favorite songs from the game and seeing your musical interpretation match with the narrative one just shows how well it was composed. Thank you for doing this one!

[@safijivvaboi5081]

Gaijin hunter in the wild

[@Harhaharha]

Please promote this man, his stuff is all so good

[@AlejandroRodriguez-lw2pj]

You play Bloodborne too? you’re quite the cultured gamer

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you for your support, Gaijin. It means a lot!

[@YoastnToastn]

@@safijivvaboi5081 Safi’jivva Boi in the wild

[@nomad6628]

You seemed interested in learning a bit more about the context of this song, so I'll summarize it as best as I can with regards to someone who's not familiar with Bloodborne's lore. (It's a bit long, but I just wanted to follow through with my train of thought. Don't feel like you have to read this.) "Gherman, The First Hunter" is the final boss theme of Bloodborne (connecting to how you related it to "Gwyn, Lord of Cinder" from Dark Souls 1, who was the final boss of that game), belonging to the character of the same name. The events in Bloodborne take place during the "night of the hunt", where monsters flood the streets, men turn into beasts, and specialized warriors referred to as "Hunters" are tasked with dispatching these creatures while trying not to fall prey to their own bloodlust and turn into beasts as well. Your player character is one of these hunters, and finds refuge within a space called the "Hunter's Dream", a realm that preserves one's consciousness while their body traverses the real world. Essentially, it's how your character can die and come back to life multiple times. The Dream was created when the first of the Hunters, Gherman, made a pact with an otherworldly being called the "Moon Presence" . Gherman would serve as the dream's host, and other hunters that were bound to it could traverse the real world without fear of death. Once the hunters had fulfilled their purpose, Gherman would sever them from the dream so that they could wake up once morning came and live out the rest of their lives. It's a cycle that Gherman has repeated many times, and it is the same cycle that the player finds themselves in. The player's hunter is bound to the dream until the night is brought to an end. Gherman, introducing himself as a friend, aids you on this journey as much as he can, offering you free use of whatever tools that you can find. However, Gherman himself can never leave the dream, as he is bound to it as its host. While he may be a hunter, he himself cannot fulfill his own purpose. He can never know rest, never be free, he is trapped within the dream, forced to repeat the same cycle over and over, bringing about the end of one hunt only to have to wait for the next to begin again. From the dialogue that the player can hear from him in-game, it's clear that he resents this life. Skipping ahead to the end of the game, Gherman offers the player a choice, the same choice he had offered all the hunters that had passed through the dream before. By submitting their life to Gherman in the dream, the player's hunter will awake underneath the morning sun with no memory of the night's events, freed from the dream. However, if the player refuses, then Gherman will try to force you out by fighting you. But the player, perhaps realizing Gherman's suffering at this point, might elect to refuse and fight him in an effort to free him from his curse. This is the final battle of Bloodborne, not a epic clash between the hunter and a beast, but rather, two people fighting each other out of a desperate, piteous attempt to *save* one another. It's the theme of Gherman, trying to spare you from becoming the dream's next host and living like him. It's the theme of your hunter, perhaps trying to spare Gherman from the fate that he's currently trapped in. It's the theme of the hunt, of your first and Gherman's last, giving him one final hurrah before his dream finally comes to an end. Perhaps that's why it's composed the way you mentioned, with intermingling elements of hope and sorrow. Perhaps your hunter might find the strength to resist the Moon Presence, and prevent the cycle from repeating any longer, finally granting Gherman peace. Perhaps not. Who knows? _"The night, and the dream, were long..."_

[@sergmanprime]

Brilliant comment, you should write more 💯❤️

[@nomad6628]

@@sergmanprime Why, thank you! I'm actually an aspiring author myself, with a few concepts for books that I've been steadily developing for several years now, so I really appreciate your compliment! Any bit of encouragement helps to make me motivated to write more

[@sergmanprime]

@@nomad6628 Good to know, with people like you around, I have no doubt in my mind that literature has a future. Keep it up, and if possible, keep me updated on your books 👍👍👍

[@nomad6628]

@The Sentinel Of Abyss thank you! And I like your profile pic, I only just finally got around to watching that art competition video this week!

[@firelordiroh3951]

What a spectacular and well-written comment. Splendid job.

[@SingingInferno]

Gehrman is such a tragic character. A man abandoned by his comrades, alone to wallow in his self hatred for his horrible actions. He's seen hunters come and go so many times, and as you refuse to die, he sadly gets up from his chair, adamant in his resolve to save you from his fate. Thank you, Gehrman, First of the Hunters. Thank you, and rest. You've earned it.

[@robertm0499]

Orphan of Kos is another theme that's also sad but then gets pretty terrifying

[@DaviVasc]

That sounds cool. Thank you for the suggestion.

[@abrahamcoronelbeltran6033]

I beated the dlc more than 5 times and all I remember is the orphan screaming "yeaaaaaoooow"

[@theamazingspiderwuss4236]

@@abrahamcoronelbeltran6033 “I am malenia, blade of miquella” is the new “YAAAIAOUIIWWWW”

[@DanS044]

@@theamazingspiderwuss4236 both happen shortly before, and after, death.

[@KeizerSosebee]

@@DanS044 unlike malenia, krphan is actually fun to fight

[@ikophi7093]

this is a true "where man cried" moment, it's a fight between 2 friends trying to save the other, he's trying to save you from the burden he's willingly carrying from what seems to be an eternity, sacrificing himself so you, and every hunter that came before you can live a peaceful life outside of the hunter's dream, you're trying to deliver him from the hunter's dream shackels as an act of recognition and sympathy for what he endured, putting an end to his misery, unending tourment and lonelyness so he can finally rest in peace, inevitably dooming yourself with his burden, only one can be saved, but none wants to be for the sake of the other, it's so beautiful i'm literally crying right now

[@iruga7379]

You're not alone...i cryed listening and understanding this music for the first time.

[@professorgrimm4602]

I actually cried during my first fight with Gehrman. The track hit really hard.

[@PenguinsAreColdish]

the hunter and gehrman aren't friends by any stretch of the imagination

[@hiarus8850]

@@PenguinsAreColdish perhaps not, but there's certainly at least a little sense of camaraderie there Gehrman doesn't want you to become another hunter bound to the dream, he wants to kick you out because he doesn't want another person suffering the same fate as him when he really doesn't need to care; he could easily accept that the hunter isn't going to leave and maybe even ask the hunter to kill him knowing well that there's a possibility the moon presence is gonna do to them what it did to him just to finally be free The motivations of the hunter are up to the player to decide, maybe they have finally gone insane, maybe they want to free Gehrman, maybe it's looking to slay the moon presence and sees the old hunter as an obstacle etc etc It a tragic dual regardless of the players intentions because of Gehrman's character and his actions

[@tadfibonacci4926]

Gherman was fighting you to save you from the dream. He's been dreaming and suffering so he knows the pain of being trapped. The happy chords maybe represented his complex emotions since if you defeat him, you're freeing him from the night and the dream, so maybe he felt a bit hopeful and happy from that.

[@DaviVasc]

I see. Thank you for the context.

[@Q-Vu]

10:05 "See? It's fake build-up again" The music 4 sec later: "SIKE!" I love seeing his surprise reaction

[@Kortegard0341]

Of course Gehrmans theme is lonely, everything else is dead.

[@thecartofvideos4766]

Everything is dead. His legacy... his best friends.... his love. Forever trapped in the Hunters Dream....

[@Xandralas]

Not dead but realesed out of the nightmare, so yea for him he is all alone.

[@TheHarrisontemple]

@@thecartofvideos4766 And finally the nightmare itself

[@Kortegard0341]

@@thecartofvideos4766 I mean, I meant like, all the bosses, but yours makes much more sense

[@hermitcard4494]

He can only exist in a graveyard, to remember everyone has gone and he's alone.

[@Bazelboy11]

You can feel sad for gehrman couse he is trying to save you for the nightmare leaving his humanity and his soul. I love this track so much

[@MattR8605]

A perfect theme for such a tragic battle. The classic mentor vs student. Each is trying to save the other from a terrible fate. The lyrics (roughly) translate to Gherman begging the hunter to let him free them from the nightmare of the hunt and to leave him to his fate as the host of the dream. The Hunter (You), is trying to release him from his shackles and grant him rest, even if that means wearing those same shackles yourself. Incredible fight on all accounts.

[@DaviVasc]

Awesome. Thank you for the context.

[@DeusExProcella]

"Lonely, sad, and intimate" My favorite comment about Soulsborne music was replacing Dark Souls with "Fighting Old Men to Sad Music" Great analysis as always!

[@DaviVasc]

Thanks Kevin!

[@exodosthesoulbanish]

Fingers crossed for Abyss Watchers breakdown!

[@LorisNoKami]

Oh hell yes

[@matthewlugo2417]

I remember when i first fought the abyss watchers, the cutscenes and music flowed so beautiful together my jaw hit the floor, every single person ive seen fight them havent recreated that moment, it was like perfectly timed like the nier soundtrack. I remember the momemt very vividly, when the boss hits the floor dead silent then the music builds as essence or soul of the other watchers leaves their body, the music crescendos and the choir kicks in timing it self with each soul coming into the boss watcher

[@DaviVasc]

I'll do it!

[@trilo_boy]

@@DaviVasc ma man 😎

[@ComicAcolyte]

@@DaviVasc LEGEND IM SUBSCRIBING

[@ForeverDansky]

Hey Davi, loving these Soulsborne music breakdown videos, especially seeing you play and explain certain elements!

[@DaviVasc]

Glad you like them, Dansky! Thanks :)

[@calvinbowman3289]

Makes me remember when you find Gehrman crying in his sleep begging for the dream to end. This is the most human track in Bloodborne, hell maybe almost in all of music

[@DS_DoggerX]

It's not the same without Gherman going "KHAA HAA HAEP HAA GHHAAAAARG"

[@drag0n_f1re]

I was waiting for this one. One of the most emotional osts I've ever heard

[@DaviVasc]

Absolutely. Thank you for watching my friend

[@Zero_Cool8760]

As someone who knows nothing about music theory, I appreciate the way you're able to explain some of the logic behind music. It's eye opening and forces me to listen to music with a more nuanced view; so thanks for that😄 Also if you're interested in more bloodborne, I recommend "Orphan of Kos" or maybe "Lady Maria of the Astral Clocktower"

[@DaviVasc]

Glad this is making you listen to music in a deeper way, I feel honored. And thank you for the suggestion!

[@valus2455]

This near perfect (possibly even straight up perfect) masterpeice, is so incredibly emotional and leaves me speechless with tears in my eyes, my favorite soulsborne peice by a longshot. Everything about this peice speaks to my soul, the fight, the theme and the setting just absolutely unmatched by any other boss i have fought, such an incredibly amazing peice. Thank you for breaking down this masterpeice. BTW, the lyrics during the climax are talking about the mercy that gherman desires and how he was decieved by the moon presence.

[@tomwow01]

Also to keep in mind for Bloodborne Boss themes, when the boss hits 50% HP they always transition into phase 2, which is always accompanied by the theme exploding or getting more intense. They always try to make that transition dynamic, because each player will always take a different amount of time to get the boss to the next phase, so a theme like Gherman's having this many "opportunities" to explode into something more intense gives them also multiple neat means of transition into his P2 theme. So either it's intentional for it's effect like you described, or just a means for a better and more smooth transition... or of course, it's both! A practical solution that also serves a thematic purpose and artistic expression and aids the musical story telling.

[@bangbangchan7665]

It’s amazing because the fakes build up seemed like a rejection to fight from a character then when the chords come up it seems like the same character finally accepts the fight. Perhaps our character or the boss? It’s so sad and I think Bloodborne just got my heart and attention!

[@tyronegaming818]

The reason I like this theme isn’t just because of how the song actually sounds, but because how well it fits the emotion of the fight, 2 men fighting to the death to prevent the other from a horrible fate

[@Nerazmus]

That's why Miyazaki is a genius. He knows what he wants and his team is able to execute the vision masterfully. I mean, plin plin plon is one of the most iconic gaming music pieces, even to people who never played DS1.

[@drake565]

Gehrman's theme almost sounds like he's expressing his feelings about the whole situation, the buildup representing his growing hope that your character will accept the freedom from the hunters dream when he offers it only for the melancholy part afterword to represent his shattered hopes when you reject his offer. The bits with the vocals feel like a mix of him begging you to free him from his current fate while simultaneously begging you to just let him free you, to not shackle yourself the the same fate he's suffered for who knows how long.

[@ygorschuma3059]

Out of Bloodborne OST, you could react next to Laurence the First Vicar, basically Ludwig, except it's not a dance, just straight up chaotic church music, and DS3's Slave Knight Gael aswell, they're really different and more emotional than the other boss musics in the series; Really sad that Yuka Kitamura didn't win any awards in both Bloodborne or Dark Souls, let's hope she does with Elden Ring. Also i've just discovered your channel and learned you're brazillian too, mostly from your accent, abraço :D

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you for the suggestions and welcome!

[@slendydie1267]

I'm always so impressed by Davi when he perfectly describes a character through the music. It speaks volumes to both his knowledge and understanding and the skill of the composer and musicians. Every time he points something out, i'm like "oh I hear it perfectly now it should've been obvious."

[@lumina6123]

I just have to suggest Darkeater Midir. That theme is absolutely amazing. It matches the ferocity supposed to be felt in a battle with a true descendant of the ArchDragons. Especially phase 2. That’s when Midir begins to realize “oh shit, I could actually die here”. The vocals kick in even more, the strings begin to rise. So beautiful and imposing. The vocals at the beginning almost give the feeling that this beast is completely otherworldly, the introduction like a choir of angels presenting their warrior.

[@DaviVasc]

Sounds interesting. Thank you for the suggestion!

[@Tutorial7a]

You have done what ATLAS never will, and held the dream, the dread. Feel pride in that, Hercules.

[@pravum3150]

People wanted ATLAS to listen to it so much it became a meme on his channel. Every sneak peak for a reaction there's always a "It's Gehrmans theme" in the comments lol

[@queenvictoriann]

@@pravum3150 I hate to say it, but I helped start that meme and created a monster that won’t die until Altas gives us what we want…please help….the night and the wait…are long….I’m going insane…

[@miguelcabreracastro6968]

when the choir start, thats when this theme hurts emotionally, it literally makes cry sometimes, It hurts a lot all of the sudden. I only have a bit of knowledge of Bloodborne, cuz I havent seen a full gameplay or lore video explaining, but the music gives me the information I need.

[@kingxbuu]

When this guy says “…so beautiful…” We all felt that. Right in our feely feels.

[@cosmic2750]

I love how much lore is in the music, that composers analyzing the music almost figure out accurately the lore of the boss! Would love to see how you interpret Laurence The First Vicar... I kinda wanna put in some lore for Gehrman, trying to do so without too many spoilers lol (not something worry about in Soulsborne though, cause the story is not handed to you on a platter so): Gerhman is basically the first Hunter after the Hunters split from the Healing Church. He was the one who founded the Abandoned Workshop (which is basically the Hunter's Dream in the real world), and he was the one who made the Doll to keep him company as he grew old. He played a crucial role in the main story, and the events that led up to it, mainly the incident at Fishing Hamlet. Gehrman, Maria, Laurence. Maria lies in the Astral Clocktower now, drifting in the realm of Nightmare. Gehrman is trapped in the Hunter's Dream, with no means of escape since well, Laurence isn't coming back to rescue him. (this you may consider spoilers...so if you don't want to, don't read further if you wanna actually play Bloodborne sometime in the future) One of the best things about Gehrman is that, unlike Gwyn, you are not fighting a kind of antagonist, no no, he's the hero of the story. You are fighting because he wants to save you (since the only way to escape the wretched nightmare is death), and you want to save him. Its not a epic heroic piece where "good" is fighting "evil". Its a fight between two equals, between two..."old friends", fighting each other to save the other from an eternity of suffering.

[@andyzhang7890]

Everything hurts my heart like a truck here, be it the tragic score, the tragic story, that choir beat drop, or Gehrman’s fist…

[@StandardBuster]

Entire song basically describes how Gehrman is as a character in the story, trapped in a dream, a dream with supposedly no end.

[@LorisNoKami]

So glad you're getting to appreciate the masterpiece that is the Bloodborne soundtrack. Listen to this and then remember this games soundtrack was completely snubbed by the game awards. Unforgivable.

[@DaviVasc]

Awards don't mean anything

[@redseagaming7832]

@@DaviVasc correct Awards don't mean anything it's the opinion of the Observer or The Listener in your case

[@FFTM155]

Bloodborne is the best game i have ever played. This game is one of the kind. Nothing is good as this game. Absolutley perfect. Waiting for next gen patch to play this masterpiece again. Music is one of the best in games.

[@leothelion634]

So much beautiful art in one game

[@jackwellington9863]

Gherman's theme sort of displays his entrapment in the hunter's dream since he desperately wants to leave as we can hear him beg for help from Lawrence and we as the player can lore-wise free him from this "nightmare" of his, a common theme of bloodborne, which is overcoming your nightmares in manner of speaking. That explains the hopeful tunes that come and go just as the others like Djura and Eileen came and left the hunter"s dream as Gherman waited for someone strong enough to overpower and kill him. Also for more info just read the "Paleblood hunt" by red grave or one of Vaati's videos hope this explains some stuff even though everyone who's played the game probably knows this.

[@GeigermSv]

What I'm glad for is the fact this game was such a masterpiece we're still talk about it almost 6 years after its release.

[@25BDominique2021]

You explain the music well 10:48 and in doing so nailed Gehrman's tragedy. Gehrman was trapped there waiting for Lawrence to return there to free him there was always a build-up and then disappointment for him (Just like in the music). Just as Gehrman loses hope and offers to release your character you refuse and offer instead too end his suffering and free him. It's bitter-sweet because you want to release him but know you are dooming your character to be trapped for eternity and he doesn't want you to have to make that sacrifice therefore he MUST defeat you. The music captures this conflict and sadness so well. It isn't until he is on the verge of death that the choir comes in with the epic climax as he realizes that this is the moment he's about to be free AND THEN HE FIGHTS HARDER so that you don't have to suffer in his place!!!!

[@professionalidiot7208]

It never ceases to amaze me how he always describes the lore to a T while describing the tones of the music, as a massive music and bloodborne fan alike I must say Great job!

[@Dxm28D]

Probably one of the best breakdowns I’ve heard. Definitely nailed this one, and I hope you keep doing more soulsborne music!

[@masquerader101]

I relate to Gehrman more than I can even express. Over the past several years, I've allowed myself to become almost nothing. All in an attempt to extinguish my inherent ego, destructive nature, and preconceptions. To this day there's this ripping tearing feeling accompanied by a feeling of being utterly trapped in myself. I know theres so many more out there suffering in these ways that most cannot even begin to understand. And I hope we all find our way. In the end maybe we can even be our true selves

[@grenenjaex5342]

“Solo violin,very lonely “ Fffff that hits hard… The whole breakdown is amazing and on point tho The lyrics btw Hunter. Ah, I have hunted. I did it all to cleanse my soul from evil. An insidious hunt. The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") This way I knew eternal mercy (or "eternal misery"). My Hunter Let the evil be hidden (from you) My life devoted to sustaining the Dream The insidious Moon The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") Great One, look upon me and grant eternal mercy (or "Great One has looked upon me and grant this eternal misery"). Take my sickly vein My soul hurts, free me, rightly The insidious Moon The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") Great One, look upon me and grant eternal mercy (or "Great One has looked upon me and grant this eternal misery"). Hunter, who hold in awe the abyss But you are never supposed to be a scapegoat I would swing this scythe once again, to offer an end to your nightmare But please, give me an end to my role. Edit: holy heal,hearing now about the two voices hits even harder

[@DaviVasc]

This is awesome. Thank you for the lyrics!

[@daviid4567]

at 9:30 when he says "so lonely" it makes me think how lonely Gehrman was.

[@babo5005]

I love the fact that you listened to half of the song and you nailed the story behind it. As it does refer to a lonely man ready and accepting of his death

[@DaviVasc]

Goes to show that the piece is really well composed

[@babo5005]

@@DaviVasc true, it is excellent but you're clearly super talented as well. Being able to no the notes from just listening to the song for example

[@caitfitz8029]

I'm so glad the algorithm threw your channel my way. Beautiful descriptions of the two lone voices of violin duel

[@lordcobra6355]

This song is very special for me. A very sad song about master and student, two close partners that refuse to leave the other face eternal sorrow. The first hunter is trying to save us from his own destiny. That's why the lyrics say something like: "Oh hunter... i know the hunt myself, everything i did was to purge evil from my soul..." He is trying to warn us about the horrible destiny that awaits the winner of this duel. My favorite comments about this song would be: "Two hunters, fighting to save the other" and "The first hunter vs the last"

[@louieberg2942]

I really like how you basically touch on the fact that Gerhman is finally done. The peacefulness.

[@slendydie1267]

This is probably the best music reaction channel.

[@arthuroliveira4630]

Nunca pensei que veria um compositor brasileiro reagir a OST do Gehrman! Principalmente vc falando do sentimento da música q relembra um pouco da vida do Gehrman! Se for continuar nessa pegada de reacts de Soulsborne, recomendo as Ost de Laurence do Bloodborne, e a Ost do Gael de Dark souls 3! Mas de qualquer maneira continue com seus vídeos, são excelentes! Um abraço!

[@wyzen9542]

A noite... e o sonho... eram longos.

[@optie5]

3:30 "Kinda has a repetitiveness to it. Whenever in music I hear something that is repetitve and insistent like this, it gives to me a theme of madness and insanity to repeat something over and over again." This description couldn't be more accurate.

[@dxcSOUL]

So happy I discovered this channel! Soulsborne music is a treasure trove for music nerds!

[@DaviVasc]

Haha absolutely. I haven't even played most of the games and I can't get enough of the music.

[@ItsPronouncedShawna]

I absolutely love this analysis! I'd like to get into creating music, so videos like these are highly uplifting. The biggest thing that strikes me about this song is that for me at least, it it sounds almost like a lullaby. And when the choir kicks in, it's like the song itself, while limping through the buildups and falls, is trying to usher or urge the listener to sleep as though it's swinging/rocking to and from the positive-sounding chord in there. Combined with the melody starting in at around 5:16 it gives off the feel of somebody who is tired, and someone who is soothing a person to rest, then several someones later on doing the same. It's one of the most emotional songs in a game I've ever heard, and was enough to, despite me never having played Bloodborne, make me have to wipe my eyes.

[@EinNettesHotDog]

2:15 For me these chords feel like Walking over a field of Sunflowers at Dawn. Kind of poetic because Maria (The Person Gherman was in Love with) resides behind a Garden of Sunflower-Type-Flowers. The theme puts everything that this character went through and is destined to do in such a great perspective and Emotion its actually crazy. Bloodborne will be my forever favourite Game, and the music played a big Part in that.

[@harpyeagle5107]

Would love to hear what your thoughts are on the 'Living Failures' boss theme. It's one of my favourites in Bloodborne it's unlike any other. Also the track Queen of the Vilebloods is incredible

[@DaviVasc]

I'll do Living Failures. It's one of the most requested ones.

[@ElSueno97]

Nothing compares to fighting Gehrman and hearing that opera come on in the back. Knowing the lore and hearing that while fighting him will make you shed some tears

[@androblade3009]

Gehrman is probably my favorite boss in bloodborne. His fight is intense and fun. The lore is sad and can be felt here in the fight and, of course the music is amazing!

[@DaviVasc]

I can't wait to experience this fight myself soon.

[@columbo7056]

man i fucking love the fact that even voice that sing in latin actually sing about the lore ( almost had me crying of how well done is this game )

[@pravum3150]

Oh my God! Finally! Someone actually reacted to it. I've been waiting for someone for years - years, to react to this! Thank you Davi! Will rewatch again.

[@DaviVasc]

Wait, no one reacted to this yet? That is crazy.

[@pravum3150]

@@DaviVasc Yep, i've been searching on and off for a few years and NO ONE has done it.

[@lordalatreon]

Gerhman the First Hunter! A beautiful track that I absolutely adore from Bloodborne. I'm kind of sad that I didn't love the gameplay of Bloodborne, but I will never not enjoy the soundtrack, setting, and characters. The First Hunter is a very sad and somber song for a very sad and somber fight. A fight between the First and Last Hunter. It's quite a poetic end, and quite a beautiful song.

[@Someone-lg6di]

My sadness was never getting to play the game due to exclusivity

[@darkluxgames2347]

From what I understand, it's pretty sad for a theme because Gehrman is old and worn out from sustaining the Dream for the Moon Presence. I think he's hopeful that you will turn around and just wake up like he told you to, or that if you don't that you'll kill him and spare him this horrible travesty of being basically under the control of a lovecraftian god as he watches innocents become insane and previous hunters also succumb to the the insanity. The lyrics in Latin at the end has a few different interpretations because of not being officially released with lyrics on a soundtrack. It roughly translates to him telling you how he's been desperately trying to hide the truth from you, but you found out. In some translations it mentions 'The Insidious Moon' which is about the Moon Presence (a title for Nyarlathotep (I think I spelt it right) a lovecraftian god that indulges in chaos.) and how it's the cause behind it all. Fucking love this theme so much. I'd recommend next for Bloodborne music: Moon Presence, and Lady Maria of the Astral Clock Tower.

[@crampedcasket3887]

And don't forget Laurence or Gascoigne, or really all of them.

[@crampedcasket3887]

(Specifying): for the recommendation part at the end

[@crampedcasket3887]

And oh, there are so many different interpretations for *this* one's Latin, probably more than any of the others, so many of them make a lot of sense for it too. (oh god, I've left *3* replies to *one* comment...)

[@wasteman9548]

The song gives me goosebumps from the start, then the choir kicks in and i get goosebumps on my goosebumps

[@leonnguyen7433]

this is the first video i’ve seen by you, and you are a genius!!!

[@ivansvalker7025]

This is the music you hear when you fight you childhood hommie to the death

[@moonlightfinger]

I can't help it, the music makes me cry. Even though I haven't played Bloodborne for once, it was so sad and I was gonna cry at the beginning even, but thankfully you cut and speak and I had some time to build myself up LOL. But at the ending... Even you've stopped speaking, and I, literally fell into tears. What a beautiful and sad song OMG

[@wander_boi69]

I absolutely adore this song, but I feel like I learned so much about /why/ I love it watching this. And it was beautiful watching your journey through hearing it for the first time, seeing you react so strongly to many of the same bits that also provoked emotion from me, and having you explain why it has that effect. This video earned a sub from me, I'm late to the party but thanks for this.

[@DARKEYE654]

The live orchestra for this is so good. It’s so amazing!

[@CaeliaMillenart]

I recently got interested in games such as Bloodborne so I guess I'll get to listen to even more of your analysis! :D The fight against this man is so elegant, though. Reminds me of some iconic boss battle in gaming such as this boss from Metal Gear Solid 3 or even in Sekiro... And that music! At first, I was laughing at how much they denied the theme's acceleration... But when they finally did... Here goes the resolve. Is death really the thing Gehrman is looking for? I think that's no longer the case. Still, the fight shall end, and I could feel tears rising! A really beautiful, poetic song!

[@beef6958]

Gerhman was always a tough boss for me, mostly because it's hard for me to see my TV through all my tears from the music and what the fight means lmao

[@ducasse8473]

10:02 "oh see another fake build up" FromSoft: that's where you're wrong kiddo 👉😎👉.

[@Seelensocke]

My god, this song. Every single time that final buildup comes up I catch myself having to breathe away the wave of emotion that just kind of swallows me whole. And that choir right after is a real tear jerker.

[@annegilbert4786]

Oi Davi. What a moving piece of music, it made me quite emotional. Thank you for your reaction video - very insightful, as always :)

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you, Anne :)

[@remygallardo7364]

I think you described it perfectly as melancholic hope. Gehrman's been waiting for the nightmare to end, enslaved by the moon presence to be the host for so long but at the same time he fears the end because he summoned the moon presence to answer his prayers. Like a classic monkey's paw he had a desire, he went to extreme lengths to acquire it, he suffered because of it, and now lives in perpetual torment. If you submit to him his story continues on, still the host, still suffering. You can at times catch him asleep crying, begging to be freed from his fate. By challenging him you deliver him from his enslavement, either at the cost of you becoming the new host or having to fight and kill the moon presence and ascending yourself. Unlike Gwyn who had sacrificed everything and long since been a husk of himself Gehrman is still very capable, but trapped in his fate. As with most things in Bloodborne it is tinged with depression. And I love every note.

[@Revelation40000]

The Lyrics at the end. Rough translation. Instance 1: Latin lyrics: Venator Ah mi supra venata Anima tor feci si vre re mal Venare insidiosus Mira tenebrarum Hic sic scitis miserere aeterna (or "miseriae aeterna") English translation: Hunter. Ah, I have hunted. I did it all to cleanse my soul from evil. An insidious hunt. The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") This way I knew eternal mercy (or "eternal misery"). Instance 2: Latin lyrics: Venator Ah mi sumo vela mala Anima do res mihi somne restas Luna insidiosa Mira tenebrarum Di vises mi miserere aeterna (or "miseriae aeterna") English translation: My Hunter Let the evil be hidden (from you) My life devoted to sustaining the Dream The insidious Moon The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") Great One, look upon me and grant eternal mercy (or "Great One has looked upon me and grant this eternal misery"). Instance 3: Latin Venator A mi sumo vena mala Anima doles mihi solve recta Luna insidiosa Mira tenebrarum Di vises mi miserere aeterna (or "miseriae aeterna") English translation: Hunter Take my sickly vein My soul hurts, free me, rightly The insidious Moon The wonderful darkness (or "These mysterious nights") Great One, look upon me and grant eternal mercy (or "Great One has looked upon me and grant this eternal misery"). Instance 4: Latin lyrics: Venātor abyssum venārator Tū nōlī at esse supplētūrum Supprēmum sic falcem quatiam semel modo Mē parti si finem praebētō English translation: Hunter, who hold in awe the abyss But you are never supposed to be a scapegoat I would swing this scythe once again, to offer an end to your nightmare But please, give me an end to my role. I am very curious what you would make of the Moon Presence.

[@hypersleeper8252]

11:49 yo Gehrman youre not supposed to be up there. Also i love how with these types of videos each composer picks different things to say about the song. Goes to show how subjective music is.

[@levvsann3753]

thanks to you I knew how to perceive better and love this Ost very much. personally I listen to phase one on a loop. compared to your video it corresponds to the build up at 5:20 until the addition of voices at 10:10 . this long part is really exceptional you feel calm, a kind of peace half present and feeling of tranquility that hides a quiet force that can kneel any opponent without forgetting the note you mentioned at 9:10 which is superb.

[@HazeMakerMusic]

Bloodborne's OST is one of the best in video game history, the DLC soundtrack being the best in my opinion. Nioh 2 has incredibly well orchestrated music as well you should react to, like "Tokichiro's theme" or Nobunaga's theme or "The Interim."

[@matheusfantinel7970]

I love how much it seems that the violin is Gehrman's voice, and the counterpoint is the Moon Presence, always looming there, guiding and in a way keeping the melody stuck in that endless loop. Only when the choir comes does the violin finally break free of the Moon Presence's influence.

[@Aya_Albion]

Great video as always! This is the memorable fight for me. Fluttering petals were beautiful and sad. Gehrman is so exhausted from the eternal dream. His sleep-talking is so painful. I love this beautiful piece since expressed Gehrman’s solitude, suffering and conflict beautifully, it sounds like a lullaby or a requiem for Gehrman and all the hunters. Giving that Gehrman was released, it’s no wonder this piece sounds hopeful. Thank you for this amazing video, Davi!

[@DaviVasc]

I always love your descritptions of music, Aya. A lullaby or a requiem is a great way to put it.

[@zaxbitterzen2178]

To me this song almost sounds like an epic funeral score to play over an elaborate ceremony. It is so full of melancholy, and loneliness, yet there almost feels like peace in any outcome despite how frustrating he is to fight. If he defeats you by your own choice (at least with story decisions) you truly awaken in the real world as yourself and not tethered to the dream. If you kill him finally he almost welcomes it since he has been alone and isolated for so long.

[@DragonHornet]

I know i'm late but check out living failures and lady maria's themes too. so glad you're covering music from my favourite games and picking them apart so well. This is also my excuse to listen to the music more lol

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you for watching and thank you for the suggestions my friend

[@a_tarasevich]

I don't know much about Bloodborne and this boss, but this theme feels like it's in pace with the fight itself, slowly gaining intensity

[@proudlarry8225]

If you sneak up on Gehrman while he's sleeping in the garden, he begins wimpering and sobbing and begging for Laurence, Willem, anybody to help him, to unshackle him from the dream which blocks all sight.

[@Dudewithnoface1]

It's simply incredible how music can move you to tears. It taps into the innermost confines of your heart and bypasses all the barriers that have been built up over a lifetime. Bravo 👏🏻

[@MightyMyna]

Seeing you get lost in the music is so relatable, just so...I have no words for what is like it's just wow

[@DaviVasc]

It feels good to know that you are able to relate to it. Thanks :)

[@soulsmith5935]

That last high pitch before the main chorus always gets me, such a beautiful build up

[@piggnut18]

Very impressive, detailed & accurate analysis of Gehrman's theme! You are amazing. More Bloodborne OSTs please!

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you! There will be more Bloodborne videos for sure.

[@cn2490]

Wonderful breakdown man. I'm learning and revisiting.

[@DaviVasc]

Awesome, thank you!

[@TikaMaranga]

"It's very lonely and sad". This breaks my heart considering that Gehrman is locked, alone in this neverending dream waiting for a good hunter to unshakle him...

[@hairypencilman8890]

I love that you really help your audience visualize what you’re thinking and how effectively you translate that, for example, this demonstration 6:24 was bizarre because of how quickly I understood it, haha

[@DaviVasc]

That is really cool feedback, thanks!

[@rieJW]

The cello at 8:36 always gave off a very strong victorian baroque feel that I absolutely adored with his theme

[@abigailfiltness4635]

Wow, there is just so much sadness and tragedy in this theme. It's really refreshing that it isnt all big sounds and fast paced music, it really gives feeling and emotion to the character. Never played bloodborne but I would love to know the story. Bet it would make a great animated show. Much like the Castlevania anime.

[@dankneo69]

It legit shows how amazing these games are. The fact that this dude who's never seen or played the game can describe the boss's lore and themes by just the music that comes with shows how much thought the creators of these masterpieces put into them. Now I appreciate this art even more.

[@becksel7167]

Can't help but love your video's, it's so pleasant to hear those theme once more with someone describing, trying to figure out the meaning of them

[@DaviVasc]

Thank you for saying that :)

[@purelucknoskill5158]

thx for reminding me why and how good this games soundtrack is!