DECLUTTERING MY MAKEUP COLLECTION: Cream Eyeshadow, Eyeliner, Lashes & Brows

[@paigejohnson9201]

I gasped when you brought out the So Mermaizing palette! lol!

[@CaseyDreyfuss]

you do such an awesome job at maintaining a reasonable collection, I respect you so much. ❤

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you so much!

[@snehamishra2702]

Just by looking at the swatch on your hand, seems like the elf wildflower and dannesa myricks flakes would make a beautiful eye look👀👀

[@darbysiler1329]

I love the got2b glued hair gel applied to my brows with a spoolie for a laminated look. I’ve been using it for a couple of years now. Just don’t apply too much or it will flake also

[@anadelwrites2144]

Do get the inglot duraline as it’s a wonder for recovering dried out products or turning powder shadows into liquid liners.

[@jennifershay8980]

Inglot isn't cruelty-free unfortunately

[@coastlines]

Lethal Cosmetics' Elixir is a good CF option, too! I actually used that to repress my So Mermaizing shimmers when they got all crumbly, and it worked like a charm.

[@jacksonlevy5464]

got2b glued hair gel does the exact same thing as any of the best strong hold brow gels and is super cheap especially per ounce. an Elmer's glue stick would also do a good job

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Thank you for the recommendation!

[@catrice1296]

@@SarahRoseBeautyit gets white and flakes tho.

[@cheyreimer7770]

​@@catrice1296I agree! It holds really well but can be so finicky so I ultimately pulled it from my makeup kit. I LOVE the nudestix brow gell though

[@flawedfabulous]

You're so good at decluttering 💚

[@angiesmith6782]

I have the same shades in the Hard Candy and ELF shadows sticks😂Our taste of makeup is so similar it’s funny! Alsoooo, I picked up a matte hard candy liquid eyeshadow at my Walmart in the shade CAKE, I think you would love the shade and they wear really well…I want to pick up another shade now that I’ve tried this one, once set, they do not budge all day! Love cream shadows and shadow sticks, I think they’re actually my fav😊

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I didn’t know hard candy made matte liquid eyeshadows now!! I need to look for that!

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

I love Magnetic Pull from Elf, and Stoned and Pony from Hard Candy! Lazy liner is my fav. I also only keep one mascara open at a time. I'm about to finish up Elf Lash XTNDR (which I love!) and have Flower Beauty Dream Warrior on deck.

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I can’t wait to try the elf lash xtndr! It’s next on my list to buy!

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

@@SarahRoseBeauty I'm about finished with soft black and I bought brown to use this fall!

[@brendaleyvaa.4970]

That kaja shadow stick that you kept reminds me somewhat to the colourpop stix in cocktail party. I have and love that one.

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I will have to check out the colourpop one!! Thank you!

[@purplerain4]

Angelica Nyqvist recommended the Physicians Formula brow gel (green one) as a really good holding brow glue. Haven't tried it yet but it looks promising :)

[@tintinr]

I would recommend the physicians formula brow lift brow gel!

[@niamhcaitriona]

You must have tried Benefit 24hr brow setter Sarah?! I find it the best ❤

[@juliakrigbaum3742]

I have heard a lot of people rave about the maybelline super lock brow gel!

[@lunalee1320]

I was wondering if you've tried the elf eye primer? And if so, how it compares to the Milani one. As for brow gels, have you tried rare beauty. A lot of people are raving about it

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

I tried the original elf eye primer years ago (I think it’s called shadow lock now) and didn’t find it very effective, but I haven’t tried the newer one in the black tube yet!

[@julieann19]

I used Milani eyeshadow primer for years and I recently got the new elf one and I love it! It makes my shadows pop way more than the Milani one. Of course everyone’s eye lids are different but it’s a new go to for me 😀

[@kellya8267]

The new Elf one is really good! I had a bad reaction to the milani when they changed it, but the elf one doesn't cause any issues for me, and it works great!

[@UnpurrfectRobyn]

I have the new Elf Lock It Down Eyeshadow Primer and it's really good!

[@britbc4461]

I'm surprised the color fix didn't work well for you. I don't use mine often since they are messier but once I get them on they stay put and I always end up LOVING the look. I don't use them at all on my lips though.

[@maggiebranch9296]

Hey Sarah

[@maiki167]

I really enjoy the Armani Liquid eye tints. They are a bit more expensive but all the shades are so easy to apply, stay put and last😊

[@Itsstuff7328]

I had the ciate london mascara. It was awful! Fine for the first two weeks, then it started flaking EVERYWHERE

[@SarahRoseBeauty]

Oh nooo 😩

[@BelleStreetBoyz]

💙💜💚