Desh Deshantar - CAA को समझिये | Understanding Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019

आज देश देशांतर में चर्चा का विषय है सीएए को समझिए...इस खास विषय पर चर्चा करने की वजह है प्रधानमंत्री नरेंद्र मोदी का नागरिकता संशोधन एक्ट के समर्थन में ट्विटर पर शुरू किया गया कैंपेन #IndiaSupportsCAA....प्रधानमंत्री ने #IndiaSupportsCAA ट्वीट करते हुए लिखा कि CAA प्रताड़ित शरणार्थियों को नागरिकता देता है और ये किसी की नागरिकता छीनता नहीं है। उन्होने इस हैशटेग के जरिये सीएए को लेकर अपना समर्थन देने का आहवान भी किया। आप जानते है कि CAA का कांग्रेस, टीएमसी समेत लगभग सभी विपक्षी दल विरोध कर रहे हैं। राजधानी दिल्ली, यूपी, पश्चिम बंगाल, बिहार, असम में इस एक्ट के विरोध में जोरदार प्रदर्शन भी हुए थे। यूपी में तो इन प्रदर्शनों में कई लोग मारे भी गए थे। विपक्षी दल सरकार से इस एक्ट को वापस लेने की मांग कर रहे हैं। वही रविवार को कार्यक्रम मन की बात में नागरिकता संशोधन कानून, उसके विरोध और इन सबके बीच युवाओं को लेकर भी प्रधानमंत्री ने बात की। उन्होने कहा कि हमारे देश के युवाओं को अराजकता से नफरत है,..वे भेदभाव को पसंद नहीं करते हैं। प्रधानमंत्री ने कहा कि हम सभी जानते हैं कि युवा पीढ़ी बहुत प्रतिभाशाली है। यह सोशल मीडिया का युग है। लोग सिस्टम को फॉलो करते है और अगर वह सही काम नहीं कर रहा हो तो बेचैन भी होते हैं। तो आज ट्विटर पर शुरू किये गये प्रधानमंत्री के इस कैंपेन और इसके असर को जानने की कोशिश करेंगे और साथ ही ये भी जानेंगे की कि आखिर CAA को लेकर ग़लतफहमी दूर क्यों नहीं हो पा रही है.
Anchor: Ghanshyam Upadhyay
Producer: Sagheer Ahmad
Guest Name: Chakshu Roy, Head of Outreach, PRS Legislative Research
Syed Ghayorul Hasan Rizvi, Chairman, National Commission for Minorities
P. K. Malhotra, Former Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice, GoI
Prafulla Ketkar, Editor, ORGANISER

[@sanjana329]

Proudly say that # I SUPPORT CAA & NRC #

[@ashwanikumartiwari9446]

When as govt UPA passed executive order for giving citizenship to illegal migrants coming from Pakistan then Where the Congress way of opposition? Nice Discussion and thanks sir

[@dilipbunty23]

कम से कम आप ( RSTV) तो निष्पक्ष रूप से,तार्किक ढंग से विश्लेषण करते।खुद को उदासीन रखते हुए सभी सैद्धांतिक तथ्य बताते। फिर व्यवहार में आने वाली चुनौतियों और संभावनाओं पर चर्चा करते । CAA की तकनीकी जानकारी और सम्बंधित तथ्यों को जानने के लिए मैंने ये वीडियो प्ले किया लेकिन बहुत निराशा अनुभव कर रहा हूँ कि इसमें लग रहा है जैसे मनचाहे तरीके से,जबर्दस्ती किसी एक बात को सही साबित करने की कोशिश की जा रही है । तथ्यों और संभावनाओं की क्रोनोलाॅजी ही नहीं है ।😒

[@pppyyypo]

Sir aap bahot achha bolte h🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@vandanaliterature4603]

घनश्याम गुरु जी ... विनम्र निवेदन है कि आप अतिथियों को उनकी बात पूरी करने का पूर्ण अवसर दें ... उनकी बात को पूरा होने दें फिर आप अपनी बात शुरू करे , बात को काटना अशिष्टता का संकेत है ।

[@madhurishah8774]

Missing Old Rajyasabha TV Days.. No Biased Data and Pure Journalism Days.

[@imaman_415]

Today I know clearly what is CAA Thnx rstv

[@GauravSingh-in9fp]

Jay.hind.bharat.mata.ki.jay.vandematram.

[@brijeshpatel9473]

Agar baccha fail ho jaye to sarkar ki galti hai Agar pass ho jaye to baccha hoshiyar hai

[@vedsinghjbp]

CAA के माध्यम से राजनीतिक पार्टियां अपनी वोट बैंक की रोटियां सेक रहे हैं लेकिन ये देश हित मे नहीं हैं लोग अफ़वाहों पर ज़्यादा विश्वास किया जा रहा हैं।

[@ImTheMan007]

This is not healthy discussion, which is not expected from RSTV. Kavindra Sir should be there for this discussion...

[@GauravSingh-in9fp]

Jay.ho.modi.ji.

[@youththefutureofindia.6875]

कवीन्द्र सचान सर कहाँ है??

[@jayshelke5096]

Kya Pata Kavindra Kaha Gayab Ho Gaya 😁😁😁😁😁

[@aditravelss]

Kavindra sir is best because he is like Non-aligned movement 😁

[@mohanmaffick-3530]

Sahi farmaya sir aapne, bin jan bhramka afwah desh ke liye khatra ko ghanti

[@chetankumawat7152]

Thank you sir Experts panel

[@user-ni3tc7wl9b]

Yess i am full support caa Sobi hondhu ok ko asei nagaritho pana chaiye

[@kelvingupta37]

In these kind of discussion critics should be included so that both perspective can be understand by the viewers. Overall this discussion is much better than other news channels debates in which speakers literally fights with each other and session ends with no conclusion.

[@shrikant8417]

Critics Should be also included in Panelists. RSTV Only Brings pro Government panelists. It is not Healthy debate. I expect more healthy discussion from RSTV.

[@Manisha....]

right 👍

[@shrawanmeena3720]

Sb ke sb chumche ki trh bol rhe hai, some points are good, but it should be critical also

[@pranaligore3205]

Right

[@Abhishek.sharma.1994]

Rstv don't focus on pro vs anti. It's about logic. That's why they neither call bjp spokesperson nor congress

[@sanjana329]

@@Abhishek.sharma.1994 ABSOLUTELY TRUE...

[@babasahabias1246]

Thanks friends, ye Deshdeshantar ho ya vishesh,, sarajanha ye sabhi only aam logo tak seemit nahi hai balki ye ek UPSC student ke liye Rambaan ka kam kar raha hai

[@Dream4pcs]

Thank you Rajyasabha 📺...

[@user-ir6fg5pd5z]

जय भारत जय बिहार

[@bheemkumar8909]

Very nice conversation. Every people should understand that what the actual issues about CAA and then those should support and reject. Right information helps take right decision and that is all.

[@kunwarkavirajcharan1341]

Bahut Bahut Aabhar Team Rajya Sabha Tv

[@prityparihar6664]

Thank you for that km se km kuchh pde likhe logo ka samuday jo brantiya fela rha tha. Unhe bhi smj aya hoga

[@satyamshivamsundaramsss3057]

Thanks rstv

[@himanshunautiyal530]

Thnku rstv

[@powerofeee7786]

it is the big responsibility of media to protect the truth.

[@SandeepKumar-xl5jw]

Right

[@kundan-mv8kw]

Many people says that it violates the article 14 15 and 21. But i think that they are misguided by some illiterate person. I support CAA.

[@brijeshpandey8031]

Thank you sir, best debate

[@puneetmaurya2882]

Sandar explaination

[@mRsk1344]

Today I clearly understand that benefit of CAA, otherwise I confuse that if Muslim religion want to be citizenship of india, they have right or not after this CAA act. Thank you so much, Rajya Sabha TV. I regularly viewer of this channel on my Mobile

[@vikasthakur4790]

You understand nothing bhaiii

[@niharikakandhol7051]

Thanks

[@aviral_flanker]

Is there can be a debate on upcoming jet deal of IAF

[@life-Unscripted-with-UPSC]

We all these student want this type of debate Not all those channel type debate

[@kumaranil3558]

Thanks rs.

[@Deepak-hq8uc]

🇮🇳🇮🇳JAI HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@ManishKumar-mo3go]

Pm ka bahut hi swagatyogya kadam hai jise algawadiyo.ko jawab milega

[@kumaramit4309]

# I Support CAA

[@Kgfert65]

Ghanshyam Sar aap acchi anchoring kar rahe hai

[@harshitapandey7629]

Thank u sir

[@chaudharysangram2523]

🇮🇳🇮🇳 JAY HIND 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@ShivaniRajput-rz1gc]

I support CAA

[@gyanendrajayswal4837]

जय हिंद 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@shivrajsingh2097]

CAA jald lagu hona chahiye

[@ganeshthombre848]

CAA 17th Loksabha ka ab tak ka Bhartiyon ke liye pas kiya hua sabse kam important Amendment Act hai, Isliye ise Sabse jyada Virodh sirf India men he ho sakta hai!

[@DevenderSingh-nd6he]

Upadhyay ji Bangladesh kase ajad hua espe video banaye please

[@BPSCHINDI]

Very good

[@yashraajchaurasia8610]

It's ok this act

[@subi-infinity]

India support caa

[@AnkitKumar-cw3lw]

सही नहीं है

[@vijaykumar-nw7nz]

Modi ji u are real herro

[@UK-ro9lb]

Jai hind sir plz provide much more awareness to us because there are so many pro pakistani here

[@manosahoo8489]

Russ mey mausom kesa hey putin ji

[@nandansinghbisht2496]

बहुत अच्छा कार्यक्रम था।

[@neeta027]

Maximum protestors ko CAB,CAA,NRC ,NPR and Detention Centre ka mtlb bhi pta nhi hai..

[@khadimmehdi5338]

Sir aap Ka program bhut Accha hota hai lekin sir aap cross Questions kyu Nahi karte hai

[@upscaspirants8640]

Modi g

[@brijeshpatel9473]

1.) Dange wo kar rahe jo free baithe hain 2.) agar government chahti hai ki public property ki recovery ho to hona chahiye Kyonki aap bataiye agar apke ghar me kuch tut jata hai to kya sarkar banati hai Mujhe lagta jo owner hai ghar ka wahi banata hai Phir sarkar galat kya kar rhi, apne toda to aap bharo... Hamare desh ke nagrik bolte hain desh pragati nhi kar Rha, Ye batao agar 99cr ki railway property damage hui protest ke karan Sarkar paise kahan se layegi, sarkar kuch naya kare ki jo dange me damage usko banaye

[@rajeevkulhari4691]

congress ne bhut bda game khel liya h student , Muslim & left valo ko sath leke ## I support CAA

[@AB-lb4ci]

Assam will never accept illegal migrants.. assam case is different than other parts of India,, it's about who is native and who is outsider.. not about hindu muslim..

[@pankajpraful1368]

Illegal immigrant kaise tay hoga npr se ya nrc se .

[@mesoncompetitionclasses8266]

Support CAA

[@alamkhangs2956]

I OPPOSE CAA NRC NPR ISME 💯 PRESENT MUSALMANO KO TARGET KIA GYA HAI OR Art 14 K OPPOSE HAI BJP OR RSS KI AAGE KI TARGET SBKO PTA HAI YE AAGE KIA CHAHTE HAI ISKE KHILAF EDUCATED LOG ROAD PR HAI AS LIKE RAM CHANDR GUHA IRFAN HABIB SWRA BHASKAR YOGENDR YADOV KNHIYA KUMAR EX IPS IAS EX SC JUDGE YE SB KIA JAHIL LOG HAI YE LOG TO KISI PARTY SE BHI TO NHI HAI

[@alamkhangs2956]

@Rawdy Indian UPR WALE NE POWER DIA H PAPULATATION BDAHANE K LIYE TUM LOG BHI APNI POWER BDAHO NAMARD LOG

[@pk1257]

Miss Sachan sir

[@munavarshaikh5224]

Kya Jo inclusion horaha hai o religion ke basis par karsakte hai, According to constitution?

[@UK-ro9lb]

According to constitutiona ilelgal migrants ko anha rkhne or na rkhna depands upon present situation of country

[@sandeshsingh9670]

Yes ofcourse

[@powerofeee7786]

in yesterdays indian express paper our ex chief justice of delhi also pointed out this point and this bill is an immoral as ipc 377.

[@AbdulMajid-kt7bx]

Sir some people are confusing that relegious persecution muslim ka bhi ho rha h Rohingya mei....ahmdya and shiya in Pakistan also....

[@ajeetsarkar2435]

Sir, how govt will know who faced religion persecution?

[@manojprabhakar825]

Malhoatra sahb CAA Act me dharmik utpiran likha h kaya

[@jayshelke5096]

♨️😁Ghanshyam Thanks Aa.....Jay Maharashtra😄♨️

[@MaraMasaiAnimals]

narrow thinking, only jay hind

[@vishalmeena4277]

Sir hamare pm lakho me nhi krodo me ek he lekin ye sb nhi samjenge us bat ko

[@Startv.234]

# India support caa .

[@prashantbanker1040]

माननिय मोदीजी द्वारा लिया गया यह निर्णय वाकिया काबिले तारिफ है देश मे कुछ लोग उ. प्र. रैप केस के आरोपियों के इनकाउंटर को लेकर मानव अधिकार की बात कर रहे है वे जिसे मानव अधिकार समझ रहे है वह दानव अधिकार है उन्हे पाकिस्तान मे प्रताड़ित लोगो के मानव अधिकार क्यू नही नजर आते क्यू कोई उनकी बात भी नही करता

[@tolstoyeducation]

NPR kun census act me nahi ata hai ??

[@tolstoyeducation]

Kia CAA se assam me reh gaye hao unhe nagrikta mil jayegi ???

[@manishkumarIAS]

Yes, expect Muslims. They are not included in CAA. They have to follow long route of naturalisation.

[@sanjibbera9194]

@@manishkumarIASLet me correct you... 'except illegal immigrants Muslims not all Muslims'.

[@inderkumarnishad6114]

1947me Pakistan me hindu 23%thhe jabki 2011me 3.4%hi he Baki Hindu caha gay agar Hindustan ki bat kijay 1951 Muslim 9.8% thhe jabki 2011 14.2% a sab artcal 14/21/25 ke anukul he kuchh rajnitik party bholi bhali janta ko bhadhka Rahi he

[@UK-ro9lb]

Inder kumar Nishad abhi non muslim 3 percent h hindu 1.8 percent

[@RahulSingh-pk9zz]

# I support CAA

[@learnandenjoyy]

I support caa

[@atulvikram7003]

Citizenship is given on the name of religion that is major issue of concern..JPC recommendation of citizenship should be given to prosecuted minority is not taken into bill..now central government telling lie outside

[@brijeshpatel9473]

Sab bol rahe job nhi hai Are mujhe ye batao, ghar banane me saalon lag jate hain Aur public kehti hai sarkar kam nhi kar rhi

[@yudhishthirakumar5856]

Apne positive view diya jo negative hai bo bhi to btao

[@amitkumar-we7mo]

chachhu sir ji ne bahut achhi bat khi ki bilkul saral sabdo me kisi bhi kanun ki vyakhyaya honi chahiye aur gram star par prachar prasar karna chahiye dusri aham bat jo mere man me bhi chal rhi thi wo ye ki ye sabhi kam itne lagatar ho rhe hai logo ke najar me jisse danga ya bhranti failane walo ko ek achha mauka bhi mil gya khair is CAB citizenship amendment bill- iski suruaat 2015 me ho chuki thi CAA citizenship amendment act- uper likha bill ab president ke sign se ab kanun ban gya NPR national population register - ye bharat me rah rhe nagriko tatha gair nagriko ke liye NRC national register of citizen ye keval ASAM ke liye aur yah SC ka aadesh hai na ki GOV KA CENSUS desh ke andar bhartiya nagriko ki sankhya - aur ye to har 10 sal par hona hi hai magar mujhe to ye lag rha hai ki anpadh jogi sab ispar bhi bawal kar denge ki yah bhi nagrikta chhinne ke liye hi hai jai hind

[@Foodyykitchen]

Thanku rstv and pk sir 1914 nhi 2014

[@targetbpsc3099]

Shi pkre....

[@Rudr273]

Full saport citizenship amendment act "CAA"

[@sachin8408]

So they think that only these 6 religions are being persecuted ? what about the Ahamadiya and Shia muslims?

[@TheGogula]

Sir is charcha me dono paksh rehe hote to jyada achha hota.. Positive and negative dono ki bat sunna chahiye.

[@tolstoyeducation]

App NPR par debate karo

[@krishnachoudhary5177]

31 dec1914 nhi h 2014 h

[@pankajpraful1368]

आप पहले N R C को बताए , जब सरकार ही कन्फ़्यूज हैं तो लोग क्यों नहीं ।

[@anilmathpal9198]

Ghanshyan g .apki anchoring wakai kaniletareef hai.

[@anilmathpal9198]

Kabiletareef

[@rkveer6092]

Agar jhooth ko bhi tukdo m dekhe to wo bhi Satya hi najar aata hai..

[@nick-dr5tu]

why anchor and organizer... words in English as it is it should be in हिंदी translated. It's not proper way.

[@thakurtsp3935]

Jald se jald caa lagu ho 25 sal se nagrikta ka intezar kar rahe hai

[@swatisachan574]

Mr.p.k.malhotra ji vasudhaiv kutumbkam me dharm to nhi bataya gaya h to sbko citizenship deni chahiye.

[@GauravSingh-so1sc]

But u have. To bring protestor too ...virdohi bhi humare desh ke hai

[@naumershaikh5313]

इस कानून को समझनेके लिए पहले अमित शाह के क्रोनोलॉजी समझना पड़ेगा, जो लोग विरोध कररहे है ओ क्रोनोलॉजी को अच्छी तरह से समझ गये है,

[@raymundvincentreyes6972]

Before 2019 ends, I still support CAA. JAI HIND🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@niftybazaar9368]

Ramlila maidan ki rally ko to jhuth bolne ke liye novel price milna chahiye

[@alamkhangs2956]

Right 😂😀😀

[@IAS_Vinay_Kumar]

Rstv bhi biased media banne ki aur agrasar hai😓😓

[@vikasthakur4790]

Jab documents hi ni hai to kese check pta chalegA ki kon kaha se Aaya hi ,kis dharm ka hi.....etc. bakwas band kre aur sidha sa jawab de

[@yudhishthirakumar5856]

Log protest kyo kr rhe hai Ye bhi btao detail me

[@jibanchakma123]

I think that's they Ideology and try to promote their culture. They want to live only but don't want to let others to live.

[@sameer1038]

One sided debate hai.. articles 14,15 ki bat q nhi Kar rhe..