Desh Deshantar: सीबीआई का दायरा और राज्य

[@the_shevak]

Shekhar Ayyar anr DeshRatna Nigam sir you nailed it!!

[@venkataratnamnaiduavula9087]

I have been seeing so many debates on this issue in different news channels since morning but this debate in rstv gave me a clear picture thankyou rstv

[@hiteshkumardeshmukh9889]

सीबीआई की नियुक्ति सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जजों की collegium के व्दारा होना चाहिए ।

[@VikasYadav-mi5yq]

कविन्द्र सचान जी मैं आपको धन्यवाद देता हूं इस डिबेट के लिए,अतः हम कह सकते हैं कि सीबीआई चुनौतियों से गुजर रही है और सीबीआई निदेशक को साबित करना पड़ेगा कि वो सीबीआई संस्था को राजनीतिकरण नही होने देंगे।

[@korangalalita1229]

Thanku so much sir and RStv

[@mohammaddanish3968]

Anil Chaudhry .. hats off. Seasoned bureaucrat..

[@Nikkubhai12.]

बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद कविंद्र सर।।। and rstv

[@Shiv_5500]

Shekhar Ayyar nailed it

[@studymaterial2620]

Shekhar Ayyer & Nigam ji nailed it good job 👍👍

[@riteshkumar.592]

Thank you sir. ..

[@rp4262]

Without discussing political angle, debat is not complete. Kudos to Mr Shekhar Ayyar.

[@GauravSingh-ix2vt]

Ratan Nigam sir well said

[@Souravupadhyay1234]

Thank you so much rstv

[@RJ21_RAS]

Cbi के निदेशक की नियुक्ति के लिए pm, लोक सभा अध्यक्ष और लोक सभा में विपक्ष के नेता की समिति होनी चाहिए

[@kanoon5491]

Best Sir

[@MohdIrfan-iv5vu]

Very informative. Thanks RSTv

[@anifeedroom8472]

राज्यसभा टीवी से अनुरोध है कि जिस तरह आज का डिबेट इफेक्टिव और जिस पर और चर्चा हो सकती है तो वो उसके लिए थोड़ा समय ज्यादा दे, डिबेट कोई समाधान पे पहुंचे तो बात बने||

[@preetisagar1497]

I am agree with you

[@deveshkumar5602]

poora favour lekar Anil chaudhary sahab bol rahe hain mein kisi ka favour nahi lerha .Waah re Gentleman

[@rkveer7867]

Dhanyawad team rstv nd kavindra sir

[@anandpatel5332]

👍👍👍👌👌

[@sidharthpatel6gkumar693]

Nice discussion Sir ,thakur so much

[@beautykori3461]

CBI ki power aur organigation pr dobara vichar krne ki jrurat hai jisse CBI GORNMENT KI TOTA NA BNI RAHE AUR JANTAk viswas kayam rhe CBI PR..

[@slemwe1234]

Nice job rstv team

[@geographywithalokcivilserv975]

Important for UPSC

[@iBabalooDevamofficial]

CBI को चाहिए कि वह राज्य सरकार के साथ तकरार न होने दे। उसे पहले नोटिस देने चाहिए कि आप हमे पूछताछ करने दे वरना हमे आपको हिरासत में लेकर पूछताछ करना होगा। CBI को ये समझना चाहिए था कि ये चुनावी दौर है इस समय ऐसी निर्णय राजनीतिक पार्टियों के लाभ हानि की स्तिथि बना सकती है। निष्पक्षता के साथ CBI को देश के लिए जिम्मेदारी समझनी चाहिए थी।

[@rajnishraz8234]

Thanks rstv for understanding this topic...

[@pkstudy-pb6nf]

Very good debate

[@vijaykumaryadav6284]

As per Anil Chaudhary who has done graduation in computer science is honest or competence Wow! What a logic.

[@jayshelke5096]

.....Thanks RS TV..... .....🌋jay Maharashtra🌋.....

[@MrAnilkiran]

Sad to see downfall in nature of debates in rajya sabha

[@Sadhan1666]

सीधे तौर पर देखा जाए तो cbi vs commissioner इस मामले को अभी sc तक जाना ही नहीं चाहिए था, इसमें शारदा चिटफंड और उससे संबंधित एक और मामले जो लोग शिकार हुए हैं उसमें जिन गरीबों का पैसा डूबा है उस पर ध्यान देने की जरूरत है । इसमें राज्य सरकार ने क्यों दखल दिया, यह समझ के बाहर।

[@arjunkumarsabdokafaker2595]

election ke pass aati he......2007 ka mayavati case open,akhilesh yadav ka case open,lalu to pehle he jail me hai,Congress to pehle hi fasi hai,arvind kejiriwal to 102 case chal rahe hai,mamta ji ka aab no. lag gya hai,bache chander babu naidu,sarad yadav,sita ram yuchiri,....par ye kam 4.5 sal me kyu Nahi huaa...desh hit kaha hai...ye pehle hi karte to lgta

[@prabhakarranjan6971]

I agree in talk to this matter

[@AjayKumar-gy5cl]

गौर करें, शेखर अय्यर की लेंग्वेज - मोदी जी ने सहयोग किया /और ममता क्यों परेशान हो रही है।

[@hiteshsahu535]

पश्चिम बंगाल सरकार जिस तरह का संवैधानिक संस्था के साथ व्यवहार कर रही वो निदनीय हैं और देश को इस संवेदनशील मुद्दे पर चुप नहीं रहना चाहिए

[@ArjunJangidHere]

Mjhe lgta h ki Ramnath sir ko State emergency laga deni chaiye Wb me... Or fir Cbi ko Free hand dena chaiye Investigation k liye 😊 catch the currupts and Save nation

[@upsccsatwithme6317]

Anil chaudhary favouring trinmul congress

[@lalankumarguptalkg3938]

CBI का राजनीतिकरण हो रहा है।।ये सीधा मोदी VS ममता बन चूका है।।।

[@gauravrai9685]

Thanku Rstv

[@sonika2695]

A balance debate this time. Thanks to Anil Chaudhary sir. Otherwise at times it looks as if pro government people are only invited

[@RahulSingh-pk9zz]

एक IPS ऑफिसर के बचाव में CM साहिब धरने पर है !! ये ही अपने आप मे अनुठा है। ये महागठबंधन बना रही है सभी सामान विचार वालो ( चोरो ) को लेकर।

[@jigneshpatel729]

Raffael ki JPC kyo nahi hoti.

[@arunchauhan23456]

Jpc ने कितने लोगों को जेल भेज आज तक

[@jigneshpatel729]

@@arunchauhan23456 BJP aur BJP gadhbandhan walo ke waha CBI RAID kyo nahi hoti?

[@arunchauhan23456]

Modi ko too 10 saal lagatar target kiya gya upa govt ke samay

[@arunchauhan23456]

और ये तो लोगो के पैसों से जुड़ा घोटाला है शारदा

[@priyankagautam4008]

हांलाकि ममता बनर्जी द्वारा उठाया गया कदम उचित नजर नहीं आता पर सीबीआई के द्वारा उठाया गया कदम उचित प्रदर्शित नहीं होता है अर्थात दोनों संस्थाओ ने अपने -अपने दायरों को लांगा है।

[@TarunKumar-cn4rl]

Rstv thanks

[@gautamsachdev7216]

👌👌

[@gyankasagarwithkittu3678]

राज्यसभा वालो कभी तो आरएसएस के लोगो के बिना debate kar लिया करो इस देश मै और भी अच्छे विद्वान है

[@StudyPoint1]

Thanks rstv

[@asmitaprajapati807]

पश्चिम बंगाल के घटना से ऐसा लगता है कि हमारा संविधान सिर्फ नाम भर के लिए ही रह गया है क्योंकी उसके नुसार कोई भी कार्य नहीं दीख रहा है.... अगर ऐसा ही होता रहा तो हमारे देश की छबी के साथ - साथ संविधान की भी छबी कहीं ना कहीं खराब होगी...

[@gauravtripathi9179]

सुप्रीम कोर्ट के आदेशानुसार सीबीआई ने अपनी कार्रवाही करी लेकिन राज्य सरकार द्वारा किया गया बर्ताव सुप्रीम कोर्ट के आदेश की अवहेलना और साथ ही भारत के संघीय ढांचे पर प्रतिघात है! न्यायिक प्रक्रिया का राजनीतीकरण एक स्वस्थ लोकतंत्र के लिए घातक है!

[@golukalam1322]

Io

[@golukalam1322]

Right

[@jigneshpatel729]

BJP aur BJP gadhbandhan walo ke Ghar pe CBI RAID kyo nahi hoti??

[@pallaviarya3399]

हाल ही में जिस तरह का विवाद कोलकाता में देखने को मिला यह भारतीय संविधान की भावनाओं के खिलाफ है एवं लोगों का विश्वास इन पर बना रहा इसके लिए दोनों को आपस में संतुलन बनाकर कार्य करने की आवश्यकता है साथ ही सीबीआई की स्वायत्तता में इस तरह से राज्यों के द्वारा हस्तक्षेप करना सही प्रतीत नहीं होता।

[@Ramansingh-dx5pf]

Good morning arya kafi dino bad much likha

[@pallaviarya3399]

@dd fauzdar right

[@abinashchanda2148]

yeh constitution ke khilaf he or WB cm ko aage ana nhi chaiye agor IPS officer sochha he dor ne ka kya he unko CBI ke sath corporate korna he or Anil sir bol raha he CBI election dek ke case ko ulja raha he yeh kya ho raha he

[@ramsaranyadav9125]

good

[@sanjaikumar1093]

CBI looses its character in conflict of Mr alok Verma and Mr asthana in few days ago

[@vishnubatham1797]

TQ rstv All. Doubts r Clea

[@laxmikantchaurasia3048]

#CBI और #kolkatta Police का विवाद कही न कही सीबीआई पर ढेरों सवाल उठा रहे हैं. वही ममता का धरना पर बैठना एक कमजोर मुख्यमंत्री को दर्शाता है. राजनीतिक लाभ के कारण पाट्री लडकर लोकतंत्र को कमजोर कर रही है.इसे परिणाम राष्ट्रहित के लिए ठीक नहीं है.

[@genknow4u]

Now we must think over how much relevance today IPS service, these guy now become political worker.

[@VJeducation999]

Two CBI directors... Asthana and Verma were alleging each other of corruption.... surprisingly no body take actions.....where is law, constitution....what is pm doing?

[@divyanshisingh796]

thanks

[@jayshelke5096]

बायको : कशी दिसतेय मी आज नवरा : छान दिसत आहेस बायको : असं नाही, एक शेर म्हणा ना माझ्यासाठी नवरा : ये जो लग रही हो तुम इतनी प्यारी … इस मे पगार लग जाती है मेरी सारी.!!!!

[@K.M.jaiswal8125]

हम अपने प्रतिनिधियों का चयन ओछी राजनीति आरोप-प्रत्यारोप एवं भ्रष्टाचार पर पर्दा डालने हेतु नहीं करते केंद्रीय एवं राज्य जांच एजेंसियां केंद्र एवं राज्य सरकार अपने अपने उत्तरदायित्व को समझें ताकि जनता में सरकार एवं सरकारी एजेंसियों पर विश्वास बना रहे जिससे राष्ट्र की एकता अखंडता पर किसी प्रकार का आंच ना आने पाए

[@bipinmishra8427]

Whatever bt this present dispute btw state n acentral authority is really the matter of shame. It must be solved by supreme court by its own fare decision so that such disputes can never arise again. It can also give the roadmap to the government to make the law on this issue as by the consent of 50percent states . thanks !

[@don007rp5]

Shekhar iyer is omnipresent 😂

[@Shiv_5500]

Kavindra ji unecessarily gave more time to Anil Chaoudhary when he is unclear on facts and his own views

[@vinayghuge8786]

Anil chowdhari.....is awesome...observations...

[@BhatnerIAS]

IAS Prelims की तैयारी में CSAT को लेकर परेशान हैं तो हमारा चैनल Bhatner IAS देखें...CSAT का कोर्स हिन्दी माध्यम में जारी है, Polity व History के लिए भी अच्छी सामग्री मिलेगी...धन्यवाद RSTV Please Cooperate

[@samratanandfutureias7689]

Sir aapka video dekh rhe h Sir aapse ek request h ki si csat 2013 ke bad agar aap yr by yr discuss kr de to sir Hmlog aapke bhut aabhari rahenge

[@The_voice_360]

Gaandu jholachaap channel bana lete hai

[@Engineer113]

It is not good for our democracy to arrest the CBI officers. West Bengal me Akhilesh Yadav aa sakte hai . Arvind Kejriwal aa sakte hai . Sarad Pawar aa sakte hai Lekin yogi aditynath Ko rally Ko kyo roka ja raha hai . Shame on you Mamta didi

[@bajwabajwa4911]

Main accuse is mukul roy who is in BJP right now.after he joined bjp there was no CBI raid on him.

[@sir_navadiya9428]

#JAIHIND pehli baat to ye hai ki constitutional power sab ko di gai hai, state ho ya center. Jab jab state or center ka problem hota hai Matlab constitution ke samne ungli ho rhi hai.aur constitution ka dhyan rakhne k liye hamri SUPREME COURT hai...ek bar sc ne order de Diya hai to CBI bilkul apni taraf se investigation Kar sakti hai lekin baat yaha pe MORALITY OR ETHICALLY ki hai...political party apna dekhegi..lekin state force aur CBI ko desh ka dekhna hai....voh kisi party ko support karenge to law and order ki samsya vajbi hai, aur ye ARTICLE 33 k hisab se UNCONSTITUTIONAL STEP hai...iske liye police ho ya state sarkar dono ko SC me khada karna chahiye..... Thank you. KEEP ENVIRO NMENT SAFE #JAIHIND🙏

[@UttamKumar-cf5jy]

Anil Choudhary की भी मीली भगत है, भाई ये तो साफ साफ पता चलता हैं ।

[@nickthenaturelover8968]

What a political Drama! Shame on those dirty politicians who are the representative faces of our country

[@mohammaddanish3968]

Shekhar Iyer appearing as bjp spokesperson

[@upsccsatwithme6317]

Chit fund regulation, cbi, sebi, ponzy scheme (important for prelims)

[@shashikumar2331]

Sir eska 2nd part me v discussion Kare .

[@mahikdm]

Bhai ji.....Political angle bhi toh discuss karo....Otherwise it's fine

[@AshrafKhan-sm9mj]

Neutral channel should not invite Nigam a non neutral person.

[@AshrafKhan-sm9mj]

Ek BJP ke log hi doodh ke dhule hain, baki sab corrupt hain, wah re chutiya Nigam.

[@vikram8639]

इस प्रकार की घटनाये हमारे संघीय ढांचे की कार्यप्रणाली में सेंध लगाती प्रतीत होती हे जो की गंभीर समस्या है , किसी संवैधानिक निकाय कार्यो में बाधा उत्त्पन्न करना हमारे संघीय व्यवस्था, हमारे संविधान की अवहेलना करने जैसा प्रतीत होता है जो की उचित नहीं है।

[@MrutyunjayJoshi]

I think In future will have to apply for visa in bengal

[@maheshkumararya2092]

Yar cbi investigation kar sakti h kabhi bhi lekin present time me jo intention h wo cause of concern h

[@ruchitabhalerao3617]

Modi ka example dena chahiye.... 😂😂😂😂😆😆😆😆😆😆

[@VJeducation999]

CBI is misused only

[@vikrantkumar3837]

If you don't know fact then why do you come here to debate.I m talking about Anil chaudhary,he said "maine suna h ki wo bahut achhe officer hai COMPUTER SCIENCE me graduate hai".What is he saying.it means those officer who have very impressive educational background is not corrupt.C.B.I has summoned him thrice but he has not respond a single time.what kind of honesty is this.if he has not something to hide then why is he not cooperating with CBI.it means Daal me kuchh kaala h.

[@openmind2681]

SARDA chit fund scam took 300 life and millions of investers their life became hell,even my mother looses 50 thousand...shame on mamta and Kolkata police

[@jigneshpatel729]

What about mukul Roy and subhodh Sen and central minister You know him.

[@pravindukare8633]

Political drama in west Bengal for CBI vs Police is not good our country, CBI is national investigation agency working on corruptions cases. It's good for eradicate corruptions and to create ditrance against corruption or any other criminal entity So,mamta gov. don't oppose the investigation against DGP

[@prabhakarranjan6971]

Mamta is wrong

[@jigneshpatel729]

Mukul Roy kaha hai.

[@chandramanisingh7842]

Bachapan me ek kahani pdi thi ek dacait ne apahiz bankr ek sadhu se uska horse liya tha, tab sadhu ne daku se Kaha ki Kisi se kahna mat ki tumne es tarah se ghoda liya barna log apahizo pr visbas nhi krege, bahi kam Modi ji ne Kiya tha tb Congress ne unke liye CBI bheji thi 8-8 hours puchtash ki jati thi lekin unhone to CBI ke liye kuchh nhi Kaha tha ki aam logo Ka CBI se visbas na uth jaye, aaj to CBI SC ke kahne pr gyi thi to vipaksha ko sahyog krna Chahiye yaha ki janta aaj bhi ajagruk Mamta Rahul Akhilesh Maya .....ityadi neta unhe bevkoof bna kr apna Ghar rupro se bharte rahte h

[@chandrikaprasad6930]

Sir aap longo se jyada jaankari CBI ke baare me tao nahi hai , lekin Mujhe ye nahi samajh me nahi aata ki manta ko kya huaa hai CBI ki baat chhode wo tao -BJP leaders ko raili ke liye bhi rok rahi hai Jo ki behad dukhad hai kul Mila kar ye dekha jaye ki election ki wajah se Opposite party baukhala gayi hai Sirf ek naam Narendra Modi jinke khilaf sab hai usi me constitutional institution ko bhi ghasita jaa raha hai sawal ye nahi ki janta sab samjhati hai sawal ye hai ki janta par eska prabhaw kaise padega .......Jai hind jai Bharat

[@abhinavyaduvansi7519]

Kiu ki o nhi chahiti unke state m apsi bhadka ho aur BJP k sare neta apsi bhadva ka mahol bnate hain aur jb mamta ji se permission nhi diya to CBI jach lga kr vaha uthl puth mchaa rhe hain

[@adityagupta294]

@@abhinavyaduvansi7519 have u seen on aaj tak the sting operation on west bengaal police, they themselves has that they were compelled to prepare a fake report to prevent the bjp leaders rallies

[@saddamalam9420]

Shayad mamta banarji shamil hai

[@Bankerspage]

It's a shamefull for our country and presenting a wrong message to the world for a democratic country. I am agree with Mr anil that both should work under the provision and should co-ordinate to each others to solve the issues.

[@student.affairs]

Interrogation k liye 40/45 CBI officer lagta hay???????? #strange

[@joshi517020]

Its all politics at the end...rest law and order and constitutional mechanisms are mute spectators as of now...keep the cases pending for right time to strike for personal gains

[@AshishSharma23]

How can we trust the CBI when its two top-most guns pulled the triggers against each other, and that too, recently.

[@monishgattu4009]

Anil choudhary chamcha giri bandh karo. Koi award nahi milega

[@michaelscott3190]

Kha se chamcha ? Usne dono ko galat btaya hain, aur aisa hai bhi.

[@jigneshpatel729]

Simple question, BJP aur BJP gadhbandhan walo ke Waha CBI RAID Kyo nahi hoti???

[@vikrantkumar3837]

He said "maine suna h ki wo bahut achhe officer hai COMPUTER SCIENCE me graduate hai".What is he saying.it means those officer who have very impressive educational background is not corrupt.C.B.I has summoned him thrice but he has not respond a single time.what kind of honesty is this.if he has not something to hide then why is he not cooperating with CBI.it means Daal me kuchh kaala h.

[@ShahrukhKhan-wm8jo]

See these types of channels to improve your analysis power.

[@mridulshepherd]

Shekhar Taiyyar reduced it to the level of off the mill Aaj Tak debate... Discussion in RSTV is minimal politics and maximal erudite knowledge.

[@hemantpatil7035]

Mr.Anil Chaudhary says he doesn't know the facts about this issue... And still repeats that both sides are making mistakes..

[@un-human]

Hawa me baat kr rhe hai wo

[@abinashchanda2148]

itna sab hone k bad abhi v facts nhi pata he unko

[@nightmare_122]

Sabse bada chor to bjp join kr liya hai mukul rai

[@jigneshpatel729]

Raffael pe JPC Kyo nahi hoti? BJP aur BJP ke gadhbandhan walo ke waha CBI RAID kyo nahi hoti?

[@DeepakKumar-mw2xl]

Aplog kuchh nispaksh logo ko laeye debate k lie

[@cricketkedewane8362]

Mamta Didi khud corrupt Hai lekin Didi ek baat bhool rhi Hai ki law se upar koi nhi Hai aur State emergency BHI Hoti hai Kuch didi

[@aditidixit4356]

ममता जी ये सब कर के वोट बैंक बढ़ाना चाह रहीं हैं (फ़्यूज बल्बों वाली झालर 16 राज्यों के 21 दल )

[@cricketkedewane8362]

+Aditi Dixit Sahi Kaha Aapne lekin ek Baat jarror Hai log yeh bhi Dekh rahe Hai ki sirf Modi ji ko harane ko ek ho rahe Hai yeh Sab na inka koi agenda Hai for development na koi pm face janta kaafi samajdar Hai aur sbko Accha jawab degi in elections

[@ankeshsh9211]

Mukul Roy ko bhul Gaye😂😂😂

[@PraveshKumar-ns1fv]

RS TV is also godi.

[@Vishal-ft8me]

Anil ji should have been brave enough to take a stand...you just played diplomatically...and do come with facts next time...

[@openmind2681]

Still here one pannelist are not aware of sarda chit fund scame...first to know about this case then speek

[@randheerathiya6779]

Shekhar ji jayada hosyari mat maro....

[@kapilparwal3729]

Kyu tmhari kyu jal rhi h

[@kumudakuanr30]

There was no need to take part ANIL CHOUDHARY in this debate...LOL.....he is saying like a beneficiary of this scam