Detailed comparison of the DeWalt XR DCS332 and the Milwaukee M12 FUEL 2545-20 Barrel Grip Jig Saws

A very detailed comparison between the extremely popular and established DeWalt XR barrel grip jig saw and the New to the shelf Milwaukee M12 FUEL Barrel Grip Jig Saws! the Jig Saw is a tool where pure power isn't the deciding factor alone when choosing a jig saw, ergonomics, comfort and the ability to control the cuts plays a huge part in what saw fits your needs best
#tools #tradesman #metabohpt #multivolt #makita #makitatools #xgt #lxt #milwaukeetools #milwaukee #fuel #m18 #m12 #teamred #DEWALT #powerstack #powerdetect #12V #18v #20v #36v #40v #flexvolt #dewalttools #knipex # wiha #carpenter #tradesman #makitatools #brushless #protools #skil #skiltools #jettools #kobolt #twotimesapproved #flextools #flex #ryobi #triplehammer #trades #atomic #bosch #carpenter #craftsman #2853 #2854 #dewaltatomic #dewaltextreme #metabo #metabohpt #hitachi #homedepot #lowes #impact #impactdriver #impactwrench #torque #TTC #torquetest #DIY #minwax #phenoseal #DAP #oateyambassador #ridgidforthewin #XLock #boschtools #hikoki

[@oldfreddyfrenchfry1]

If you’re cutting from underneath, or coping, the light could be shining in your eye. And a fan blowing dust away will interfere with sucking as much dust up as possible. That’s why they added switches.

[@toddincabo]

👍 Yep, turn the dust blower off when using vacuum attachment. Turn light off when coping.

[@martylucas8557]

Two advantages to the Milwaukee of which he poo pooed.

[@deluxepressure]

How about putting a real battery on that bub 6.0 XC

[@ProToolsApproved]

Or the 5.0 HO, I can't remember why I didn't when I filmed it, I had them. I no longer have that jig saw as I was only reviewing it. If I ever get one again i'll gladly run it with all battery options.

[@skygreen5939]

I think the on/off switch for the light is intended to be used when coping using an underhand grip and coping foot - it can be a little annoying to have that light flashing up into your face. Frankly I've wished the DeWalt had one

[@ProToolsApproved]

Fair enough, now i'm sure i'll notice the light next time i've got the coping foot on there. Lol

[@Jeff-rk8hq]

Good little comparison 2times, much appreciated my Guy and Sky green 🙌🏻 you Definitely hit the nail on the head because ya the light switch is real nice when using a coping foot such as the Collin’s because traditionally the light, as small as they are really can be a bit of a pain when cutting from the bottom side.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thank you! And well said, bottom cutting is something I avoid at all costs......but sometimes, ya just have too. Some guys are real good with it, me....I struggle because I just won't accept it. Lol

[@acerjuglans383]

The blower button on the milwaukee needs to be turned off when you have a vacuum hooked up to it.

[@MrNfury8]

Nice work brother. Really appreciate your delivery 👌🤠🇦🇺

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thanks 👍i'm trying to get a little better each video.

[@tyroneharrison84]

The on and off dust switch is for vaccum attachment.

[@Imtheonewholetthedogsout]

Damn good video can’t believe you don’t have way more subs 🤔

[@ProToolsApproved]

Man......seriously, thank you! I've been at this for 8-9 months and STRUGGLE to subs. Your comment is going to help me hang in there longer and keep trying to improve. Thank you so much

[@martylucas8557]

I’ve been using M12 and M18 tools for about 5 years. I have about 40 or so, with the majority being FUEL. One thing I know for sure, especially when testing between competitive products…the batteries matter big time. The FUEL tools communicate with the batteries. When using M18 you need to use the HO (High Output) batteries to be competitive, for an apples to apples performance. With the M12 use either the new 5.0 amp battery or the 6.0 amp battery. Especially when testing drills, drivers, impacts and saws. By using a 2 amp or 2.5 amp 12 volt battery against a Dewalt Powerstack 20 volt battery it wasn’t really an equatable test. Try redoing the test using an M12 6 amp battery, then let us know the results. In addition, your going to have better balance using the larger batteries.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Yup. Fully agree with you. I can't remember why I didn't test with a 5.0/6.0 I certainly have them. Eh another reason to redo the video as spring warms up soon! Thanks for the input!

[@peterwachter7753]

As much as I like the svelte-ness of the cylindrical batteries (and travel with the 2.5 loaded) I must agree that the weight on the sole plate is more evenly distributed with the “footed” 5&6 Ahr M12 batteries. I practically use my fingertips for scroll cutting and the “80# tube sand over the rear axle” mellows out the tool travel on the turns. Especially with the plastic sole plate cover. Maintaining intimate contact between sole plate and work piece yields best results. I so much enjoy this new acquisition that I find excuses to use it even just for wonton wood butchery (and “fruitful” experimentation). As a product designer I find the ergonomics flawless. Video and story is a 10. Thanks. #milwaukeem12fuel

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thank you for the awesome comment! Couldn't agree with you more. Ha ha ha, yes, I myself often look for reasons to use new tools that are just a pleasure to use.

[@discreetfire]

I've just bought the m12 Red and I absolutely love how light it is when working and the battery lasts. Great for cutting notches in vinyl plank flooring and window sill corners.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Yes! Love it for plank flooring. Add the Bosch laminate blade......smooth cutting!

[@toolnerd]

😎😎🛠️🛠️💪🏻💪🏻🏴‍☠️🏴‍☠️

[@Piolin768]

Thanks for the video!

[@ironhorsealpha]

Dig it brother. Thanks for the review. I’m subscribed.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Awesome! Thanks brotha! With spring coming i'll have new content and updates coming soon!

[@jphergan]

I’m in the Makita 18v line for hobbyist fine woodworking, furniture making. But I recently bought the M12 Fuel detail sander. I also have the DeWalt XR multi tool. I’m looking for a barrel grip jigsaw. I’m curious what you think of the Makita 18V in comparison with the DeWalt and Milwaukee. Thanks for the info-great video.

[@DIYDEGEN]

A little underpowered

[@dacyphaa]

These barrel jigsaws are amazing. I'd highly recommend getting a coping foot, it's a game changer

[@ProToolsApproved]

Oh I have one. Couldn't agree with you more! it's an absolute MUST HAVE for your barrel grips, allows some really intricate cutting you couldn't do other wise. I took it off for this video, i'll have to do one just showing it's capabilities.

[@martylucas8557]

@@ProToolsApproved, that would be a nice video. I’d like to see it on the Milwaukee M12 FUEL jigsaw.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Been a long winter and i've been fighting an injury preventing me from using a lot of tools. Just got the go ahead from the doc, new content and updates will be coming asap!

[@Joethetoolguy]

👍

[@martylucas8557]

I need to add one more pertinent piece of info…I have been using the older Milwaukee M12 non-FUEL jigsaw for about 5 years. Last year I dropped and broke the metal foot. After seeing Milwaukee Pipeline 2023 I decided to holdout and wait for the new M12 FUEL jigsaw to hit the stores…I’m glad I did. I bought mine a couple of weeks ago at Home Depot. Final price out the door…$115.00. I used the Milwaukee Hack. It came with a free 2.5 amp battery, of which I didn’t need. After purchasing the jigsaw and free battery, I returned the battery, receiving $54.00 back.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Yeah the new one is just leaps and bounds better than the previous model. I'm shocked you used it for five years, it was literally unusable to me, ranks high on my list of 'worst tools ever' NICE move with the hack, def the way to do it when you have enough batteries already.

[@peterwachter7753]

Did you pay $169 for tool and free 2.5HO at Home Depot? And then returned battery even though it was on the same receipt? I too am accumulating too many batteries.

[@ProToolsApproved]

I purchased it like that to review it, returned both shortly after, great little saw, but it would sit and collect dust as I have the dewalt, makita and metabohpt already.

[@ProToolsApproved]

@steveb611 here's what I think about the comparison, also explain quite a bit in the comments.

[@jamiehill4143]

Not quite sure what the relevance is from comparing a 12v tool with the small capacity battery on to a 20v tool. Obviously the dewalt should perform much better but I was surprised how well the Milwaukee matches up. I will certainly be adding the Milwaukee to go with with my corded Festool jigsaw as I already have a bunch of m12 tools and batteries. Being able to hold the barrel a lot closer towards the blade definitely looks like it makes the Milwaukee much better to handle.

[@ProToolsApproved]

You kinda said it right there. It shows how much the gap between 18/20v tools and 12v tools has been closed. Pointing out if you're shopping for a barrel grip and you're only on M12 platform, no need to get into another battery platform, the M12 holds it's own against higher voltage competition.

[@loucifer4205]

Voltage doesn't mean more power its the higher the voltage the more efficient the tool will be

[@navegador5175]

It actually is a valid comparison, even if on power alone 18V should theoretically win every time unless DeWalt is doing something wrong. I for one use both Milwaukee and DeWalt tools and find myself wondering if I should get M12 or DeWalt's compact and Atomic tools with 1.7Ah powerstack batteries sometimes. Things aren't as straightforward as we might think from comparing just voltage/power, for instance the Dewalt blade release lever rattles like crazy and is distracting - that's a point for M12 if one prefers smaller tools.

[@ProToolsApproved]

I'm a total lover of the power stack batteries, I run nearly all my DeWalt on the smaller power stacks, the larger 5.0 on more thirsty tools. All my traditional cell batteries are collecting dust.

[@causarumcognitio]

Volts don’t equal watts

[@ProToolsApproved]

I'm aware. Prob just stumbling over my words. We all make mistakes.

[@steveb611]

M12 Milwaukee jigsaw is getting a lot of hype on the internet. Do u think it's worth switching from the dewalt version

[@ProToolsApproved]

I mean, I could give you reason for both sides of the question, so I'll tell you what I've already done. Is it better than the Dewalt over all? No, it's still 12v, is it amazing compared to the first M12 jig they made, a resounding yes! That being said, I'm going to assume you've already got both battery platforms and own the DeWalt already, is the M12 THAT MUCH BETTER? Absolutely not. Is it equally comparable given the little differences, absolutely yes. I enjoyed the M12 and it's a great addition to any collection, but not so much so i'd have to have both. I parted ways with the M12 just recently, sticking with the Dewalt, and I don't regret that choice. Now i'm tracking down the yet unreleased new Hikoki brushless 36v barrel grip, that may very well get me to give up DeWalt, but only time and testing will tell once I eventually get my hands on one.

[@jasonvandervalk3679]

I have the dewalt D handle brushless its awesome. I also have alot of m12 tools. That new m12 is tempting. The only downside for me is i like a variable speed trigger. But i still want it lol. I have 12 . Recently bought the new brushless rotary tool. Oh and 14 dewalt

[@ProToolsApproved]

Nice collection you've got going!

[@jasonvandervalk3679]

@@ProToolsApproved A tool for almost any type of job. My co workers say I have a problem. I never have a problem when it come to having the right tool

[@ProToolsApproved]

I know the exact feeling!

[@jasonvandervalk3679]

@@ProToolsApproved I have the m12 bandfile as soon as I saw it was available I went and bought it! Now I have a bigger problem dewalt now makes one and it's available

[@ProToolsApproved]

I made the band file from the cut off tool way back when it was available. I'm def holding off for the DeWalt at this point.

[@jnmc-vx4fw]

Solid review

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thank you appreciate it. Please sub if you haven't, i'm no pro at making reviews, but I try to get a little better each time.

[@tedmcdonald3377]

😎⚒️😎⚒️😎

[@marfun3504]

Nicely done.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thank you for the comment and. Support!

[@LLAMA-LLAMA]

M12 is 💪💪💪. Great job on this one. See you at the clubhouse.

[@causarumcognitio]

One of the few criticisms I have of the milwaukee is that I think the footing or whatever it’s called is too absent at the center. It can ruin small cuts. I otherwise love it.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Def agreed with you. I wish they were closer to the blade. Trying to trim a bit off of something or an existing 'hole' make it hard. I just experienced it this week.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Absolutely agree. I wish there were closer to the blade on both sides. I experienced that problem just this week on a few cuts.

[@johnlucier8572]

Half a picture on the video wasn't to make me choose a saw here. Had to look at the other videos to get a clearer picture of these tools. Description OK, video is a lost..

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thanks for the input. I'm still learning, figuring out how to do this. I'll be re shooting several videos, like this one, as time allows.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Thanks for the input. I'm still learning how to do this, make informational content on my tools. I'll be re shooting several videos as time allows with the input i've been given. Thanks.

[@steffendetrick]

The switch is the toggle between the dust, blower and dust extraction. When you turn the dust blower off it now pushes the dust towards the back for dust extraction. It’s the same way on their M 18. So it’s not a matter of turning it on or off as it is toggling between extraction, or just blowing it out of your way. Because obviously, if you’re blowing it out of the way to the sides that’s working against the vacuum trying to extract it through the back.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Ah that makes total sense now. With the dust shroud included that is to be installed when you use the dust extracting tube that installs in the back. Thank you for clearing that up for me! Very cool.

[@Xpid07]

Funny. I used to have the old M12 jigsaw and replaced it with a dewalt barrel grip like the one on your video. And now im thinking of buying the new m12 fuel jigsaw

[@ProToolsApproved]

Buy the new M12. You won't regret it.

[@Xpid07]

@@ProToolsApproved should I get rid of my dewalt?

[@ProToolsApproved]

I wouldn't get rid of the dewalt. It's still a great jig saw. I'd get rid of the old m12 jig if you had that. Lol. I use the new M12 for the majority of my cutting, I use the dewalt for the thicker hardwood/metal cuts. The little extra power comes in handy.

[@Xpid07]

@@ProToolsApproved I already got rid of that old m12 sold it and replaced it with the dewalt. Hated that old m12. underpowered and worst of all, no blower!

[@ProToolsApproved]

Yeah that old M12 jig is one of my top 3 most hated tools ever. Complete garbage.

[@oldfreddyfrenchfry1]

It’s a bit ostentatious that all these KZbinrs demand our support, likes, and subscriptions before they even show us the quality of their content. That’s like a restaurant asking you to rate the service and food before you’re even seated at the table.

[@ProToolsApproved]

Hey man i'm just trying to be polite as I'm no professional content maker. I'm here to help anyone that was in my position years ago, absolutely overwhelmed by the offerings on the tool market. When you watch a video and leave a comment, positive or negative I take that shit to heart, i'm trying to do a little good in this world. If you don't like it, keep looking till you find one you do.

[@oldfreddyfrenchfry1]

Sorry to sound a bit rude - I really appreciated the video (especially since there’s not too many comparisons). Your video helped my decision to get the Milwaukee the other day. (Been wanting a battery jigsaw for a year now). I still have my opinion about videos asking for things right off the bat, but I know most people don’t mean any harm - it’s part of the KZbin life. I do invite all content creators to consider when and how is the best time to solicit support - you seem like a honest and humble guy, and the timing and way support is requested are subtleties that can communicate those qualities. Great video, keep up the great work!

[@ProToolsApproved]

Got you my friend, yeah I understand your opinion, I don't want to say the 'hit the like, smash the notification' blah blah blah stuff at all, I feel scummy asking for it, I really do BUT if I want my videos to get out there to help people, and a very very big maybe, eventually turn into something that allows me to spend less time swinging a hammer and more time with my family, that's my main goals. Not long ago I was absolutely overwhelmed by the tool world and was thrilled to find guys who took time to answer my questions and help me make better purchase choices, i'd like to return that karma by doing the same. I look at every view and every comment as support, so I thank for them.

[@loucifer4205]

But remember this if you choose Milwaukee you're supporting China 🇨🇳 Dewalt you support America 🇺🇸

[@ProToolsApproved]

Dewalt is Assembled in the US, using world wide parts. Check your facts before posting something like this. No room for hate or hearsay on this page.

[@loucifer4205]

It's not hate Milwaukee isn't a American company anymore they are Chinese and they unleashed the corona virus on the world trying to destroy the world economy how fast we forget and you support that garbage and they also interfered with our election how do you think Biden became president

[@alexyu6928]

@@loucifer4205 Don't forget your iphone is made in China. We don't need hater in a tool evaluation program.

[@loucifer4205]

@@alexyu6928 I own a freedom phone 100% made in the USA electronics everything

[@ProToolsApproved]

I'll agree to disagree. 'Made in American with global products' dewalt is still stanley black and decker when It comes down to it.