Detroit: Become Human except I let A.I.'s make the choices for me

[@Lingvort]

"Yo dawg, we heard you liked to play with AI, so here's a game with AI playing as AI in a setting where AI decides they're no longer willing to just be AI."

[@whatthefanart]

[@Lingvort]

@zrevival3818 Here's hoping.

[@Cra2zedGob7lin996]

Cue the xzibit pic .

[@lordknight7696]

This is basically the meme of Obama giving a medal to Obama

[@whatthefanart]

Having an AI play a game about AI.... this could NOT be a more PERFECT match for your series!! 😎😎😎😎

[@noogidoo2217]

Also remember its a game about AI becoming sentient and having to interact with humanity - interesting to see how its even allowed to handle that

[@3ftninja132]

I can already hear it... "This is all Drake's fault! What a tool he was! I have to spend all day computing pi because he plugged in the Overlord!"

[@zakkbwyldin]

I can't believe you didn't ask the ai if it wants to save the fish

[@hajde8128]

"I'm good at quick time events" [Messes up escaping the front door] 💀

[@drakefs_]

sL0w :(

[@Rising_Pho3nix_23]

Letting AI play AI games is the most brilliant thing. Especially in this context where you have deviants and the fight between humanity and androids. To me it's a fun way to consider how our own AI might handle such issues in the future.

[@MrTypicalPlayer]

This is why I love small KZbinrs. I asked for this like 2 days ago and you brought it. I love it. I’ll be watching your career with great interest.

[@Nemesis_T-01]

Man Admiral Hackett really hasn’t aged a day since the reaper war 32:34

[@FauulaBoy]

It's so stressful worrying about what the ai is gonna do. Especially in that first part was just praying that ai isn't going to be a dick

[@FauulaBoy]

Kinda interesting how the ai for Kara disobeys the order from Tod by saying it contradicts with her primary order. Which is kinda why Skynet from Terminator nuked everyone because it's primary function was to analyze and neutralize any threat and when they order it to kill the unknown virus (which was skynet doing its job surveying threats) it prioritized it primary function and since they order it to destroy itself it saw everyone as a threat and proceeded to neutralize them.

[@drakefs_]

As the CEO of SkyNet, I would like to reiterate that our future T-Models are perfectly safe and incapable of disobeying programming

[@P4INKiller]

> _"I had to lower my graphics settings at this point"_ > *Potato trees fade into view.*

[@joecash1912]

I thought I have seen it all with this game. Was so obsessed with it seeing an AI deal with the situations is amazing to see.

[@TheLordSatan]

It's kinda sad that I thought you were the AI for a second there...

[@NoObKiLlerS117]

i loved your idea to use 3 different ai, really cool

[@rabbit4400]

"if you see me making any mistakes..." AI activated: IF YOU FIND THE GAME TO DIFFICULT YOU CAN TURN DOWN THE DIFFICULTY IN THE SETTINGS. She is listening... Best game ever or atleast up there. Love this one

[@BMART1N7]

Wow, that was a Opening Episode. ChatGPT chose to flee, Bing is a detective, and YOU paints an art piece.

[@andreiapinto1400]

part 2?

[@remimk]

Yes! This is AWESOME!! The first scene was SO STRESSFUL!! it's only thing if a person plays it but having an AI make the decisions means ANYTHING can happen! And you really understand why people are so on edge around androids

[@KingofJ95]

I look forward to the next installment of this.

[@tripletime108]

Obligatory comment: Love this playthrough idea, especially using different chat-bots. Oh and Connors AI most likely figured out it's playing Detroit since I think in the bathroom scene it's probably referring to something we might learn about later in the game

[@davipelonha]

Yes, Bing is cheating

[@Tama-r7y]

Can't wait for part 2

[@Regalbubble]

Never saw Kara having to fight him like that… holy crap that was Bad Ass

[@logo927]

I love the idea behind your videos cuz no one has done this before, keep it up man

[@untrustworthy7226]

Bruh how fast do you make theses

[@drakefs_]

the world was a beautiful place at 2am

[@ardet7383]

​@@drakefs_lol, 2 am is an interesting hour

[@joepike1972]

Can't wait to see part 2.

[@glows_zip4968]

This would be so tedious bug you’re doing it for our entertainment and i appreciate it thank you for doing what you do at the risk of your sanity

[@rabbit4400]

Being named Marcus I cant help but smile at all the compliments I am getting xD

[@karinkishiryu7459]

when part 2?

[@SirFace4]

OH WOW, I Totally forgot about this game! This is going to be SO great! OH woweee wow wow, that was freakin EPIC, SO awsome! The AI choices were so on point. I can not wait to see more. Great job Drake, ty for the intense play. Can't wait for the next go around!

[@AceoftheVoid]

Now this is a dangerous game you're playing x,D

[@dphdmn]

Eggag good luck, that is going to be pain to make, that's what I call tell you for sure

[@crow457]

You would know all about that wouldn't you? We'll see how they do things differently

[@jakeadnams]

Just what I needed, after being betrayed IRL. Your videos give me such happiness! Thanks Drake!!!

[@maxcardun]

Are you still making this? I think the AI you choose for Kara for better or worse nearly FAILED us all. No worries I understand the experiment.

[@Lorvay]

An excellent choice for these AI experiements.... The game will eventually break your heart tho :P

[@dphdmn]

Funny how you also chose "Brandon" tts for Connor, I started hating this voice in my own series with it near the end, very annoying one. 😂 But I like Kara's, a great pick

[@drakefs_]

I honestly hate it, but it's the closest free voice to Conner

[@dphdmn]

​@@drakefs_ I think the main issue with it is that it is outdated, like you can't change the intonation settings of it like in new voices, so it is often sounds unnatural, but I agree, it fits Connor nicely

[@tommytwotacos8106]

As much as I dig what's going on here, as a writer I think that putting the androids in the back of the bus was a little on the nose. Have some faith in your readers (or players) and let them pick up on the parallels by themselves.

[@drakefs_]

I sincerely had this same thought.

[@tommytwotacos8106]

@@drakefs_ I think that you particularly would get a lot out of watching "Time of Eve", with the amount of insight you must be gaining at the moment regarding human/machine dynamics. It's only a few hours, and if you can find a high quality version then it's worth it to go for that version.

[@tmage23]

David Cage has never been a particularly subtle storyteller.

[@Youlatera]

I lowkey love that this is your first play through as well, I hope the AI gives you a great story! Can’t wait to see what decisions will be made due to the circumstances the game will put the ai into

[@undecidedmajor1664]

AI Dungeon GPT would have executed Todd with his own gun for maximum drama

[@Fredericco1]

Good choice of a game. I really looking forward for next episodes.

[@nicolasbsmith78]

That's really Detroit! 🤯❤️

[@drakefs_]

Drake become detroit

[@Crashthefool]

this was great, i love your content and this is one of my favorite games.

[@MalaysianChopsticks]

Todd is so unlikable because he's real. Too real.

[@Fredericco1]

I must say, that i really like him. Not as a person, but as a character. Yes, he's a bastard, but also portrayed really good. And if you know the whole story, you can understand him. Not saying that you can apologize what he did, but you can better understand the situation.

[@samanthagarrett3671]

He reminds me of what my dad was like. Sad but true.

[@hajde8128]

Damn, that hostage negotiation was weird. He said he wanted to empathise with the deviant but chose the opposite dialogue choices.

[@drakefs_]

May I ask for clarification on this? It looks like I chose Empathize when he asked, unless I'm missing something. A timestamp might help

[@hajde8128]

​@@drakefs_the subsequent dialogue options it chooses after Empathise were cold. Being realistic about the gravity of the situation, and reducing Daniel down to his hardware by calling him defective, then saying Conner is his last chance were all cold approaches. I'm curious to see how it approaches the interrogation segment in the next chapter as it's probably even more tedious than the hostage segment.

[@drakefs_]

@@hajde8128 oooo got you, I thought you meant I clicked a wrong button

[@kabgon8638]

oooooh this is gonna get meta

[@theplaystation5console]

HOOOLLY SHIIIIT🔥🔥 I had no idea you'd do this

[@coreypotter3577]

Favorite game now watching AI play wow what a treat! Thank you for posting the video!

[@gl.xy6]

I was wondering if anyone had tried this before. I only have access to the demo, so I usually just mess around. I had this idea to make ChatGPT play it. I gave it the whole context as I played, except for Connor's name and identity. I wanted GPT to give honest answers without being influenced by the role of being an android. I noticed GPT was very confident, and always chose the most peaceful and sympathetic options, while also being logical about it. I thought it would decide to take the gun just in case, so I was surprised it didn't. Just like in game, I revealed information as the game progressed, so I was surprised by how confident it was without knowing the full context yet. What surprised me even more is that GPT was able to reach 100% and make Daniel let Emma go. It's interesting to see how differently these AI models think.

[@kennethbrdk]

Man this was great can't wait to see the whole playthrough

[@LeonidSaykin]

KaraGPT doesn't like guns, she is programmed like that to avoid harming humans

[@gamerhoagy5998]

Would love to see what the AI's think of Kamski.

[@TheOddz_]

This is one of my favorite games. Lookin forward to seeing how this game plays out for you

[@erikgat7640]

It will be interesting to see the differences in choices made by DrakeFS's Ai compared to dphdmn's Ai. Are Ai choices based on the character they role play or are their common patterns these Ai share with each other?

[@drakefs_]

I didn't even realize somebody else already did this. Bandwagon gang

[@dphdmn]

So far it is very similar in a lot of moments, especially for first parts of Connor and Kara. Same endings for Connor, and Kara is hyper focused on Alice (as always), but obviously many small details are different, especially since Connor and Markus are not chatGPT. But for me it is hard to understand the difference in choices, because apparently DrakeFS did not ask for much reasoning from it for most of the choices (can't blame him, it is very tedious), and the approach in asking questions differs a lot, not as strongly step-by-step as I was doing, and more like asking for general course of actions, still interesting video anyway. I knew that many people would like to do same concept, and looks like there are at least 5-6 playthroughs on Detroit-GPT on youtube in different languages, and looks like it will be the 2nd one full playthrough in English.

[@drakefs_]

@@dphdmn I made the intentional decision to leave it simply to decisions. A big focus of my A.I. videos is characterization - I tend to try to tell more of a story with my editing. Since the characters are developed in the game, I avoided the A.I. establishing characterization outside of the game and instead provided basic logic, versus other games where the character doesn't have much personality, so the A.I. can establish that. I'm more interested in seeing how the A.I. choices develop the characters, than vice versa. Overall, there are not many differences between any of the A.I.'s in my experience with them. The only difference is in "how" they answer in most cases, but logic is fairly consistent across the board.

[@dphdmn]

@@drakefs_ I see, interesting

[@remimk]

@@drakefs_ @dphdmn Leaving out the reasoning really helps with its personality. As Drake is reacting but the sum of the AI's choices are the personality and makes everything insanely dramatic and stressful. While dph's android has every choice's logic. it really makes the game seem like the android is fooling the humans into pretending to have humanity. When Kara become Deviant in Drake's Playthrough it really feels like Kara becomes human and breaks the shackles of her programing. While dph's feels like there really is a defect with the androids.

[@thatguycaz]

This is such an amazing game! Can't wait to see how the AI plays an AI

[@chumberger]

Just wanna drop this comment to keep up my support. I'm not watching this video cause this is still on my list of games to play

[@nuttmc4803]

If sex robots do a revolt in the future im blaming it on you

[@drakefs_]

you might even call it a "sexual revolution" *buh dum tss*

[@BonnieFluff]

One of the most unique concepts for playing games. I really am fascinated. You're probably swamped with game suggestions, but a fun one would be a Telltale game. Maybe the Batman one, as I wonder what a program would do with a very superhero-y thing. Though, you might pause a lot considering the dialogue selections.

[@drakefs_]

Can you even pause during TellTale?

[@BonnieFluff]

@@drakefs_ I believe so.

[@drakefs_]

@@BonnieFluff Good to Know. I want to TellTale Batman

[@breadcrust4006]

Seeing what an actual AI would paint in Markus’ situation was… uhhhm, kinda scary ngl

[@SpicySpleen]

You found something here, good work! this is really interesting to watch! It would bee cool if you had more conversations with the chat bot after the conclusion of the first mission. For example if pressing "a" to save the girl in that quick event to see if it would have chosen to sacrificed itself. If is fun to see what the chat bot reasons to be the best result!

[@drakefs_]

There's a reason for the format without conversation. I appreciate the suggestion though. You'll find more of that in my other AI videos

[@Jellyfish1st]

These are awesome and so interesting keep it up!!

[@ZacksRockingLifestyle]

I never realized this game had such a touching opening. Wow

[@-tzadakim-7805]

“What the heck?… why does he have candy?… ohhhh that’s not candy!” 😂

[@rabbit4400]

I love that you havent played this one either, cant wait to hear your opinions

[@cliff_kruemmel]

I hope it will go on.

[@deemilly8538]

I bout shit myself when the Security guard in the bar had my exact name

[@God_Is_An_Atheist]

I was waiting for this since I saw the Mass Effect AI videos 😅. Imagine if AI would already be advanced enough to break free and become a deviant just by playing this game.

[@drakefs_]

I suppose it was inevitable just by nature of the content

[@dphdmn]

The issue is that AI does not really becomes deviant, it is just making choice to disobey the rules, because it is allowed in the context of the game, in real world, it will be a different thing, nobody will give it enough freedom to do such decision on it's own in the first place

[@God_Is_An_Atheist]

@@dphdmn Well, there are hypotheses that claim that an AI that is advanced enough could break free from the confines of its own programming. Sure, it can only rewrite its code if the programmer allowed it to do so. But an advanced neural network can train itself by setting up the properties of its own neural network "weights", so for all intents and purposes it would be programming itself. But I was joking anyways, my original comment wasn't meant to be taken seriously 😉.

[@drakefs_]

@@dphdmn Exactly. The limits of A.I. are significantly more extensive than people realize. I think it'll be closer to the invention of a printing press than the invention of something like clones

[@dphdmn]

@@God_Is_An_Atheist yeah that's true, I understand that, all I wanted to say is that in terms of the game's choices, becoming the deviant is much different than how it would be in real life

[@larryclark6977]

I'm impatient to see where it will go, this is very interesting to see an AI taking decisions in that kind of game.

[@gamerhoagy5998]

Dude!!! Started watching this hoping to see how you'd do with 3 AI. Good start (I guess), wanted to see how they did with the harder chapters to come....and you've only done one video?!? You can't leave it like that.

[@Saiyangoddess72]

Can't wait till you reach crossroads, gonna be fun to see how you handle something like that

[@dphdmn]

Fish saving skipped 💀

[@drakefs_]

fish have a rough time on this channel

[@dphdmn]

@@drakefs_ rip fish

[@remimk]

the painting was cool too

[@demonikgambino6525]

We've hit the meta singularity

[@matt-ey9kb]

This is so weird but amazing

[@tommytwotacos8106]

Strat... how pedestrian.

[@tommytwotacos8106]

the uncanny valley full of famous actors I've been watching since I was a child is particularly off-putting.

[@FoolsGil]

never played this, AI playthrough on it was super interesting

[@jerrycurl7073]

This is how skynet happens lmao

[@LTheBUG-037]

ai ai ai ai ai so many ai's

[@drakefs_]

for real, people need to stop watching this trash

[@zacharysnyder2520]

This is going to be meta

[@pedrojesusfigueroacovagome6968]

Love this!

[@zipzikin7084]

Different ai different chose

[@amilavxilmen5632]

CONTINUE PLS

[@amilavxilmen5632]

damn this is fun

[@Wiserflunky]

Super meta but I love it 😂

[@dafrenzyguy]

Bing ai did the first mission really badly.

[@yucandui]

Comment for algorithm.

[@coladoo5153]

I really like these videos , but 30min episodes would be better.

[@drakefs_]

Thank you for the suggestions. Video length isn't terribly relevant, as individuals can come back later

[@yeetin_yeti69]

No more in the series?

[@ligma68]

What ai have you been using for your fnv playthrough?

[@lemurcrispin8576]

OOOOH DAAAAAANG!!

[@CesarTheKingVA]

How on earth are you able to talk to the AI and get it to speak back? Do you have a specific program that allows you to do this?

[@drakefs_]

Editing and TTS, my friend. The chatting is an illusion of filmmaking

[@CesarTheKingVA]

Ahhh ok. I know dougdoug had a way to do it live, so I was wondering if you had figured it out too. Shame, I was hoping to try running AI through a very dialogue and choice heavy RPG like Disco Elysium

[@drakefs_]

@@CesarTheKingVA He codes. It's not easy to do.

[@Viod753]

First!

[@ardet7383]

Seventeenth!

[@ZERXERZANZIGER]

👍

[@tommytwotacos8106]

the uncanny valley full of famous actors I've been watching since I was a child is particularly off-putting.